the odyssey homer- humanities

PENGUIN BOOKS

Published by the Penguin Group:

Penguin Books Ltd, 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England

Penguin Putnam Inc., 375 Hudson Street, New York, New York 10014, USA

Penguin Books Australia Ltd, Ringwood, Victoria, Australia

Penguin Books Canada Ltd, 10 Alcorn Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4V 3B2

Penguin Books India (P) Ltd, 11 Community Centre, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi – 110 017, India

Penguin Books (NZ) Ltd, Cnr Rosedale and Airborne Roads, Albany, Auckland, New Zealand

Penguin Books (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd, 5 Watkins Street, Denver Ext 4, Johannesburg 2094, South Africa

Penguin Books Ltd, Registered Offices: 80 Strand, WC2R 0RL

First published 1996

Published as electronic edition 2002

Copyright © Robert Fagles, 2002

All rights reserved

The moral right of the author(s) has been asserted

Making or distributing electronic copies of this book constitutes copyright infringement and could subject the infringer to civil and/or criminal liability, where applicable. No part of this book may be reproduced by any means without the prior written permission of the publisher.

All rights reserved.

US:

ISBN 0786504528 in MS Reader format

ISBN 0786509139 in Adobe eReader format

PENGUIN BOOKS

HOMER

The

Odyssey

TRANSLATED BY

Robert Fagles

INTRODUCTION AND

NOTES BY

BERNARD KNOX

For Lynne

su gar m’ebiôsao, kourê

INTRODUCTION

INTRODUCTION

THE ODYSSEY

“O
dyssey” is a familiar English word, meaning, according to Webster, “a series of adventurous journeys usually marked by many changes of fortune.” The Greek word Odusseia, the form from which the English word is derived, means simply “the story of Odysseus,” a Greek hero of the Trojan War who took ten years to find his way back from Troy to his home on the island of Ithaca, off the western coast of mainland Greece. Homer’s Odyssey does indeed present us with “adventurous journeys” and “changes of fortune,” but it is also an epic tale of a hero’s return, to find at home a situation more dangerous than anything he faced on the plains of Troy or in his wanderings over uncharted seas.

The Greek philosopher Aristotle, writing in the fourth century
B.C
., gives us, in his treatise known as the Poetics, what he considers the essence of the plot. “A certain man has been abroad many years; he is alone, and the god Poseidon keeps a hostile eye on him. At home the situation is that suitors for his wife’s hand are draining his resources and plotting to kill his son. Then, after suffering storm and shipwreck, he comes home, makes himself known, attacks the suitors: he survives and they are destroyed.” This terse summary is the armature of an epic poem that consists of 12,109 lines of hexameter verse composed, probably, late in the eighth century
B.C
. or early in the seventh, by a poet known to later ages as Homer, for whose life and activities no trustworthy information has come down to us. The poem, in other words, is some 2,700 years old. How, the reader may well ask, did it survive through such an expanse of time? By whom, for whom, and how and in what circumstances was it composed? Perhaps the best way to proceed to an exploration of these questions (no one can promise a complete and certain answer) is backward—from the text of this book.

It is a translation, by Robert Fagles, of the Greek text edited by David Monro and Thomas Allen, first published in 1908 by the Oxford University Press. This two-volume edition is printed in a Greek type, complete with lower- and uppercase letters, breathings and accents, that is based on the elegant handwriting of Richard Porson, an early-nineteenth-century scholar of great brilliance, who was also an incurable alcoholic as well as a caustic wit. This was of course not the first font of Greek type; in fact, the first printed edition of Homer, issued in Florence in 1488, was composed in type that imitated contemporary Greek handwriting, with all its complicated ligatures and abbreviations. Early printers tried to make their books look like handwritten manuscripts because in scholarly circles printed books were regarded as vulgar and inferior products— cheap paperbacks, so to speak.

Back to 1488, then, there is a continuous history of the printed text of Homer, differing a little from one editor to another but essentially fixed. Before that, Homer existed only as a handwritten book. Such handwritten copies had been in circulation in Italy for a hundred years or so before the first printed edition. Petrarch had tried to learn Greek but gave up; Boccaccio succeeded and also, in 1360, had a chair of Greek founded in Florence. But before Petrarch, Dante, though he put Homer in his limbo of non-Christian poets, had never read him, and could not have read him even if he had seen a text. For the best part of a thousand years, since the end of the Roman Empire, the knowledge of Greek had been almost lost in Western Europe. In the fourteenth century it was reintroduced into Italy from Byzantium, where a Greek-speaking Christian empire had maintained itself ever since Constantine made the city the capital of the eastern half of the Roman Empire.

The knowledge of Greek and the manuscripts of the Greek classics, Homer included, came to Italy just in time; in May 1453 Byzantium fell to the Ottoman Turks, and the Greek empire of the East came to the end of its thousand-year career. During its long life it had carefully preserved, copied and recopied a select number of the Greek masterpieces of pre-Christian times, Homer prominent among them. The immediate predecessors of the printed edition of Florence were bound manuscript books written on vellum or on paper in a cursive minuscule script complete with accents and breathings. These books were the final phase of the process of copying by hand that went all the way back to the ancient world. The new minuscule handwriting had been adopted in the ninth century; since it separated words, it was easier to read than its predecessor, a hand consisting of freestanding capital letters without word division—the standard writing of the ancient world. In the second to fifth centuries
A.D
., the form and material of the books had changed: parchment, with its longer life, had replaced papyrus, and the codex form, our book form—folded quires of paper sewn at the back—had replaced the roll. In the ancient world, the Iliad consisted of a number of papyrus rolls, the text written in columns on the inside surface. The rolls could not be too big (or they would break when opened for reading); a long poem like the Odyssey might require as many as twenty-four—in fact, it is possible that the so-called books of our text represent an original division into papyrus rolls.

In this form the poem was known to the scholars who edited and wrote commentaries on it in Alexandria, the city founded by Alexander before he set out on his epic march to India in the late fourth century
B.C
. And it was in this form—though, before the Alexandrian scholars made a standard edition, with many variations from one text to another—that copies were to be found all over the Greek world of the fourth and fifth centuries
B.C
. There must have been texts in circulation in the sixth century too, for we hear of official recitations at Athens and find echoes of Homer in sixth-century poets. By the seventh century
B.C.
, we are moving back into the dark. In the poets of this century (whose work survives only in fragments) there are epithets, phrases and even half-lines that are also common in Homer. Though these poets—Tyrtaeus, Callinus, Alcman and Archilochus—may be using tags common to a general epic tradition, it seems more likely that these echoes betray acquaintance with the work we know as Homer’s. There is also a vase, discovered on the island of Ischia, off the coast of Naples, and dated to before 700
B.C
., which has an inscription that seems to refer to the famous cup of Nestor described in the Iliad (11.745–53).* And echoes in art are also found in the early seventh century—illustrations of scenes from the Odyssey, for example, on vases dated in the 670s.

But back beyond about 700
B.C
. we cannot go. Evidence for this period is rare; in fact, we know very little about Greece in the eighth century, still less, if possible, about Greece in the ninth. We have only the archaeological record—geometric pots, graves, some weapons. It is the era of Greek history known, because of our almost total ignorance about it, as the Dark Age.

All we have is the tradition, what the Greeks of historical times believed they knew about Homer. Herodotus thought that he lived four hundred years, not more, before his own time; that would put him in the ninth century. The great Homeric scholar Aristarchus of Alexandria believed that he lived about one hundred forty years after the Trojan War; since the Trojan War was generally dated (in our terms) around 1200
B.C
., Aristarchus’ Homer was much earlier than the Homer of Herodotus. Men might disagree about his date, but everyone believed that he was blind, and though some thought he came from Chios (a so-called Homeric hymn mentions a blind singer from Chios), others traced his origin to Smyrna. It was also generally assumed that Homer, though he speaks of singing and probably did sing in performance, was a poet using the same means of composition as his fifth-century successors— that is, writing. Even those who thought that his poems were not combined into their present shape until long after his death (that, for example, the last part of the Odyssey is a later addition), even those who believed that different poets wrote the Iliad and the Odyssey, the so-called Separatists—all assumed that Homer was a poet who composed as all poets since have done: with the aid of writing. And so did all succeeding centuries down to the eighteenth. Pope, whose translation of the Iliad is the finest ever made, speaks of Homer as if he were a poet like Milton or Shakespeare or himself. “HOMER”—so begins his Preface—“is universally allow’d to have had the greatest Invention of any Writer whatever.” Homer, it is taken for granted, wrote.

There had been one skeptic in the ancient world who thought differently. He was not a Greek but a Jew, Joseph ben Matthias. He wrote in Greek (for which, as he admits, he had a little help) a history of the Jewish rebellion against Roman rule in the first century
A.D.
and its savage repression by the emperor Titus—events in which he had played a prominent role. But he also wrote a pamphlet, countering the claim of a Greek writer, Apion, that the Jews had no history to speak of, since they were hardly mentioned in the works of Greek historians. Besides defending the historicity of the Old Testament chronicles, Josephus (to give him his Greek name) counterattacked by pointing out that the Greeks did not learn to write until very late in their history. The heroes of the Trojan War were “ignorant of the present-day mode of writing,” he said, and even Homer “did not leave his poems in writing”; his separate songs were “transmitted by memory” and “not unified until much later.”

It is true that (with one remarkable exception, which is discussed later) no one in the Iliad or the Odyssey knows how to read or write. The Mycenaean scribes had used the complicated Linear B syllabary— eighty-seven signs for different combinations of consonant and vowel. It was a system only professional scribes could handle; in any case, all memory of it was lost with the destruction of the Mycenaean centers in the twelfth century
B.C.
The Greeks did not learn to write again until much later. This time, they took over an alphabet of fewer than twenty-five letters from the Phoenicians, a Semitic people whose merchant ships, sailing from their cities Tyre and Sidon on the Palestinian coast, reached every island and harbor of the Mediterranean Sea. The Phoenician alphabet consisted of signs for consonants only. The Greeks appropriated their symbols (alpha and beta are meaningless words in Greek, but their Phoenician equivalents, aleph and beth, mean “ox” and “house”), but by assigning some of the letters to the vowels, they created the first efficient alphabet, a letter system that provided one, and only one, sign for each sound in the language.

Just when this creative adaptation took place is a subject of scholarly disagreement. Some of the letter shapes of the earliest Greek inscriptions look as if they had been copied from Phoenician scripts that date from as far back as the twelfth century. On the other hand, the earliest examples of Greek alphabetic writing, scratched or painted on broken pottery and found all over the Greek world from Rhodes in the east to Ischia, off the coast of Naples, in the west, are dated, by their archaeological contexts, to the last half of the eighth century
B.C.

But it was not until the eighteenth century that the possibility of Homeric illiteracy was once again proposed. The English traveler Robert Wood, in his Essay on the Original Genius of Homer (1769), suggested that Homer had been as illiterate as his own Achilles and Odysseus. The German scholar F. A. Wolf elaborated the theory in a learned discourse entitled Prolegomena ad Homerum, and the Homeric Question was launched on its long and complicated career. For if Homer was illiterate, Wolf declared, he could not possibly have composed poems as long as the Iliad and the Odyssey; he must have left behind him shorter, ballad-like poems, which, preserved by memory, were later (much later, in Wolf’s opinion) put together in something like the form we now possess. Wolf’s thesis was almost universally accepted as soon as published. It came at the right time. Almost a century before this, the Neapolitan philosopher Giambattista Vico had claimed that the Homeric poems were the creation not of one man but of the whole Greek people. The spirit of the age now sought to find works of untutored genius, songs and ballads, the expression of a people’s communal imagination—a contrast to the artificial culture and literature of the Age of Reason. The Romantic rebellion was at hand. Everywhere in Europe, scholars began to collect, record and edit popular song, ballad, epic—the German Nibelungenlied, the Finnish Kalevala, Percy’s Reliques of Ancient English Poetry. And this was the age that saw the popularity, especially in Germany and France, of a fake collective bardic epic: the story of Ossian, a Gaelic hero, translated from the original Gaelic and collected in the Highlands by James Macpherson. In spite of the fact that Macpherson was never able to produce the originals, “Ossian” was admired by Goethe and Schiller; it was the favorite book of Napoleon Bonaparte. They should have listened to Samuel Johnson, who called the book “as gross an imposition as ever the world was troubled with.”

In such an atmosphere of enthusiasm for folk poetry, the discovery of a primitive Homer was more than welcome. And scholars, convinced that the Iliad and the Odyssey consisted of ancient shorter poems that had been sewn together by later compilers and editors, now addressed with gusto the task of deconstruction, of picking out the stitches and isolating the original “lays” or “ballads” in their primitive, pure beauty. The exercise continued throughout the whole of the nineteenth and into the twentieth century.

It continued because of course no two scholars could agree about how to take the poems apart. This was understandable, since the criteria they were using—inconsistency of character, imbalance of structure, irrelevance of theme or incident, clumsiness of transition—are notoriously subjective. At first the affair was a free-for-all; it seemed almost as if there were a competition to see who could find the greatest number of separate ballads. Karl Lachmann, in the mid-nineteenth century, after claiming that the newly discovered Nibelungenlied was a mosaic of short ballads (a theory now believed by no one), went on to divide the Iliad into eighteen original heroic songs. A similar theory of the origin of the Chanson de Roland was popular at about the same time. The idea was not as impossible as it now sounds; in fact, a contemporary of Lachmann, the Finnish scholar and poet Lönnrot, collected Finnish ballads on his travels as a country doctor in the most backward parts of the country and put them together to form the great Finnish epic, the Kalevala, a poem that has ever since been the foundation of the Finnish national consciousness. But Lachmann’s analytical methods produced no agreement, only scholarly squabbles, conducted with the customary venom, about how long the pieces should be and exactly where to use the knife.

The Iliad, in which the action is confined to Troy and the Trojan plain and lasts for no more than a few weeks, lent itself less easily to such surgical operations than the Odyssey, which ranges over ten years and vast spaces. It was easy for eager analysts to detect originally separate epics and short ballads. There was a Telemacheia (Books 1–4), the tale of a diffident young prince’s growth to full stature as a man and warrior. It contained what had originally been three separate ballads of the type known as Nostoi (Returns)—the voyages and homecomings of Nestor, Menelaus and Agamemnon. There was a long tale of a hero’s voyage through far-off fabulous seas, like the saga of Jason’s ship, the Argo, a song actually mentioned in the Odyssey (ref). Embedded in this travel tale was a short but brilliant song about a sex scandal on Olympus—Ares and Aphrodite caught in flagrante delicto by her irate husband, Hephaestus. It is one of the songs of the blind bard Demodocus, who at the Phaeacian court tells also the tale of the quarrel between Achilles and Odysseus and another of Odysseus and the wooden horse that brought about the fall of Troy. There was also a full-scale Nostos, the return home of Odysseus, the welcome he received, and his vengeance on the suitors.

The precise dimensions of these presumably once separate components and the stages of the process that led to their amalgamation were (and in the writings of many eminent critics still are) matters for speculation and dispute. Were there three main poets—one who composed the core of the epic (the wanderings and return of Odysseus), another who sang of the coming of age and travels of Telemachus, and a third who combined the two and forged the links that bind them? Or were there only two—the poet of the voyages and homecoming, and the other who added the Telemacheia and Book 24 (which many scholars consider a later addition in any case)?

One obvious weakness of this line of argument is that the story of Telemachus is no fit subject for heroic song; there is nothing heroic about it until Telemachus takes his place, spear in hand, by his father’s side in the palace at Ithaca. As a separate epic poem, the material of Books 1–4 is something hard to imagine in the historical context—a Bildungsroman, the story of a young man from a poor and backward island who asserts himself at home and visits the sophisticated courts of two rich and powerful kingdoms, to return home a grown man. Such a theme is worlds apart from the songs offered by bards in the Odyssey and the Iliad. Demodocus at the Phaeacian court tells the tale of the quarrel between Odysseus and Achilles, and later, at Odysseus’ request, of the wooden horse that brought about Troy’s fall. Phemius in the palace at Ithaca sings of the return of the Achaeans from Troy and the disasters inflicted on them by Athena, and when Penelope asks him to choose some other theme, she speaks of his knowledge of the “works of the gods and men that singers celebrate” (ref). And in the Iliad, when the ambassadors from Agamemnon come to plead with Achilles to rejoin them on the battle line, they find him playing the lyre, “singing the famous deeds of fighting heroes” (9.228). A song celebrating the travels of Telemachus is not easy to imagine in the context of a male audience accustomed to tales of adventure and feats of arms. How would the bard begin? “Sing to me, Muse, of the coming of age of Telemachus…”? It seems much more likely that the Telemacheia was a creation of the poet who decided to combine a tale of adventures in fabulous seas—a western voyage modeled on the saga of the Argo’s voyage to the east—with a Nostos, the return home of a hero from Troy, in this case to face a situation as dangerous as that awaiting Agamemnon. For that decision forced on him a radical departure from the traditional narrative procedure of heroic song and confronted him with a problem for which the Telemacheia was a masterly solution.

Epic narrative characteristically announces the point in the story at which it begins and then proceeds in chronological order to its end. The Iliad opens with the poet’s request to the Muse: “Rage—Goddess, sing the rage of Peleus’ son Achilles”; he then tells her where to start: “Begin, Muse, when the two first broke and clashed, / Agamemnon lord of men and brilliant Achilles” (1.1–8). She does, and the story is told in strict chronological order until its end: “And so the Trojans buried Hector breaker of horses” (24.944). In the Odyssey, when Odysseus asks the Phaeacian bard Demodocus to “Sing of the wooden horse / Epeus built with Athena’s help,” the bard “launched out / in a fine blaze of song, starting at just the point / where the main Achaean force, setting their camps afire…” (ref), and carries the story on until Troy falls. But the prologue to the Odyssey abandons this traditional request to the Muse or the singer to begin at a certain point. It begins, like the Iliad, with a request to the Muse to sound a theme—the wrath of Achilles, the wanderings of Odysseus—but instead of telling her where to start—“Begin, Muse, when the two first broke and clashed”—it leaves the choice to her. “Launch out on his story, Muse, daughter of Zeus, / start from where you will” (ref). And she does. She begins, not with Odysseus’ departure from Troy (which is where he begins when he tells his story to the Phaeacians), but in the twentieth year of his absence from home, as Athena starts Telemachus on his journey to Pylos and Sparta and arranges Odysseus’ escape from his seven-year captivity on Calypso’s island.

The reason for this startling departure from tradition is not far to seek. If the poet had begun at the beginning and observed a strict chronology, he would have been forced to interrupt the flow of his narrative as soon as he got his hero back to Ithaca, in order to explain the extremely complicated situation he would have to deal with in his home. The Telemacheia enables him to set the stage for the hero’s return and to introduce the main participants in the final scenes—Athena, Telemachus, Penelope, Eurycleia, Antinous, Eurymachus—as well as a group of minor players: Medon, the servant who helped rear Telemachus; Dolius, the servant of Laertes; Halitherses and Mentor, two old Ithacans who disapprove of the suitors; the suitor Leocritus; and Phemius, the Ithacan bard. And the accounts of Telemachus’ voyages do more than chart his progress, under Athena’s guidance, from provincial diffidence to princely self-confidence in his dealings with kings; they also offer us two ideal visions of the hero’s return, so different from what awaits Odysseus—Nestor among his sons, Menelaus with his wife and daughter, both of them presiding over rich kingdoms and loyal subjects.

Division into separate songs by different poets was not the only approach to dissecting the body of the Odyssey. The nineteenth century was the age that saw the birth of the scientific historical spirit. And also of the history of language—the discipline of linguistics. All this had a bearing on the problem. If in fact some sections of the Odyssey were older than others, they should contain linguistic features characteristic of an earlier stage of the language than that to be found in the more recent additions. Similarly, the later parts of the poem should contain allusions to customs, laws, objects and ideas belonging to the later historical period, and vice versa. Toward the end of the century a fresh criterion emerged for gauging the antiquity of different sections of the poem—the archaeological criterion. For with Heinrich Schliemann’s excavations at Troy and Mycenae, and those of Sir Arthur Evans at Cnossos, a previously unknown civilization was revealed. If there was any historicity to Homer’s account of the Achaean world that organized the attack on Troy, it must be a reference to this world—a world of gold masks, bronze weapons, palaces and fortifications—not to the archaeologically poverty-stricken Greece of the Dark Age. Now, by finding in Homer descriptions of objects that corresponded to something excavated from a Bronze Age site, the scholar could date a passage, because it was clear that with the destruction of the Mycenaean and Minoan palaces, all memory of that age had disappeared in Greece. Schliemann and Evans had discovered things Herodotus and Thucydides had no idea of.

Of these three approaches, the linguistic seemed the most promising, the most likely to yield objective criteria. Studies of the origins of Greek in the Indo-European family of languages had progressed along generally agreed and scientific lines: the history of the Greek language and the Greek dialects had become an exact discipline. Surely the linguistic analysis of the text would confirm or refute theories of earlier and later strata in the poems.

THE LANGUAGE OF HOMER

T
he language of Homer is of course a problem in itself. One thing is certain: it is not a language that anyone ever spoke. It is an artificial, poetic language—as the German scholar Witte puts it, “The language of the Homeric poems is a creation of epic verse.” It was also a difficult language. For the Greeks of the great age, that fifth century we inevitably think of when we say “the Greeks,” the idiom of Homer was far from limpid (they had to learn the meaning of long lists of obscure words at school), and it was brimful of archaisms—in vocabulary, syntax and grammar—and of incongruities: words and forms drawn from different dialects and different stages of the growth of the language. In fact, the language of Homer was one nobody, except epic bards, oracular priests or literary parodists would dream of using.

This does not mean that Homer was a poet known only to scholars and schoolboys; on the contrary, the Homeric epics were familiar as household words in the mouths of ordinary Greeks. They maintained their hold on the tongues and imaginations of the Greeks by their superb literary quality—the simplicity, speed and directness of the narrative technique, the brilliance and excitement of the action, the greatness and imposing humanity of the characters—and by the fact that they presented the Greek people, in memorable form, with the images of their gods and the ethical, political and practical wisdom of their cultural tradition. Homer was thus at once contemporary in content and antique in form. The texture of Homeric epic was for the classic age of Greece like that of the Elgin Marbles for us—weathered by time but speaking to us directly: august, authoritative, inimitable, a vision of life fixed forever in forms that seem to have been molded by gods rather than men.

The language of Homer is the “creation of epic verse” in a strict sense too: it is created, adapted and shaped to fit the epic meter, the hexameter. This is a line, as its name indicates, of six metrical units, which may, to put it crudely, be either dactyls (a long plus two shorts) or spondees (two longs) in the first four places but must be dactyl and spondee in that order in the last two (rarely spondee and spondee, never spondee followed by dactyl). The syllables are literally long and short; the meter is based on pronunciation time, not, as in our language, on stress. But unlike most English verse, the meter does not allow departures from the basic norms—such phenomena as the Shakespearean variations on the basic blank verse line, still less the subtleties of Eliot’s prosody in The Waste Land.

Yet though it is always metrically regular, it never becomes monotonous; its internal variety guarantees that. This regularity imposed on variety is Homer’s great metrical secret, the strongest weapon in his poetic arsenal. The long line, which no matter how it varies in the opening and middle always ends in the same way, builds up its hypnotic effect in book after book, imposing on things and men and gods the same pattern, presenting in a rhythmic microcosm the wandering course to a fixed end which is the pattern of the rage of Achilles and the travels of Odysseus, of all natural phenomena and all human destinies.

The meter itself demands a special vocabulary, for many combinations of long and short syllables that are common in the spoken language cannot be admitted to the line—any word with three consecutive short syllables, for example, any word with one short syllable between two longs. This difficulty was met by choosing freely among the many variations of pronunciation and prosody afforded by Greek dialectal differences; the epic language is a mixture of dialects. Under a light patina of Attic forms (easily removable and clearly due to the preeminence of Athens as a literary center and then of the book trade), there is an indissoluble mixture of two different dialects, Aeolic and Ionic. But the attempts of the linguists to use this criterion for early (Aeolic) and late (Ionic) ran into the dilemma that Aeolic and Ionic forms sometimes appear inextricably tangled in the same line or half-line.

The attempts to dissect the Odyssey along historical lines were no more satisfactory (except of course to their authors). There are indeed passages that seem to imply different historical backgrounds, but they are not passages that are identifiable as early or late by the criteria of linguistic difference or structural analysis. All through the poem, weapons and armor are made of bronze—spearheads, arrow tips, swords, helmets and breastplates; men are killed by “pitiless bronze.” In superior palaces, like those of the gods or King Alcinous of the Phaeacians, bathtubs and cauldrons and even the threshold of the building are made of bronze. On the other hand, iron is used for axes and adzes; it is so familiar an item that it is constantly in use in metaphor and simile—“heart of iron,” for example. But there is no way to separate Bronze Age from Iron Age layers; the two metals lie cheek by jowl, and even the distinction between bronze for weapons and iron for tools is often ignored—“Iron has powers to draw a man to ruin” is a proverbial phrase twice quoted by Odysseus (ref, ref), and a man who is dipping red-hot iron in water is called a chalkeus, a bronze or copper worker. Early in the poem, Athena, disguised as Mentes, says that she is sailing for Temese with a cargo of iron, which she intends to trade for bronze.

But archaeological ages are not the only matter to be handled by the Muse with careless abandon. There seem to be two different marriage systems in the world of the Odyssey: in some passages the bride’s family settles a dowry on the bride, but in others the suitor makes valuable gifts to the bride’s family. “It is most probable,” says a recent commentator on the Odyssey (West, Commentary, I, p. 111), “that Homeric marriage-customs represent an amalgam of practices from different historical periods and different places, further complicated, perhaps, by misconception.” They are obviously not much use for dating the passages in which they appear.

It is not surprising, in view of such frustrating results, that by the beginning of the twentieth century, opinion had begun to swing away from analysis and to concentrate on the qualities of the poem itself, to stress the unity of the main action rather than the digressions and inconsistencies, above all to explore the elaborate correspondences of structure that often link scene to scene. The architecture of the poem is magnificent, and it strongly suggests the hand of one composer, but it is true that there is a certain roughness in the details of the execution. The poem does contain, in an indissoluble amalgam, material that seems linguistically and historically to span many centuries. And it does contain long digressions, and some disconcerting inconsistencies, some weaknesses of construction. What sort of poet composed it, and how did he work?

The answer was supplied by an American scholar, whose name was Milman Parry. Parry, who came from California and was an assistant professor at Harvard when he was killed in a gun accident at an early age, did his most significant work in Paris; in fact, he wrote it in French and published it in Paris in 1928. It did not appear in English until 1971, when, translated by his son, Adam Parry, it formed part of a collection of all his Homeric studies. His work was not appreciated or even fully understood until long after his death, in 1935, but once understood, it completely changed the terms of the problem.

Parry’s achievement was to prove that Homer was a master of and heir to a tradition of oral epic poetry that reached back over many generations, perhaps even centuries. Parry drew attention to the so-called ornamental epithets, those long, high-sounding labels that accompany every appearance of a hero, a place, or even a familiar object. Odysseus, for example, is “much-enduring,” “a man of many schemes,” “godlike” and “great-hearted”; the island of Ithaca is “rocky,” “seagirt” and “clear-skied”; ships are “hollow,” “swift” and “well-benched,” to list only some of the often polysyllabic epithets attached to them. These recurring epithets had of course been noticed before Parry, and their usefulness understood. They offer, for each god, hero or object, a choice of epithets, each one with a different metrical shape. In other words, the particular epithet chosen by the poet may have nothing to do with, for example, whether Achilles is “brilliant” or “swift-footed” at this particular point in the poem—the choice depends on which epithet fits the meter.

Parry pursued this insight of the German analytical scholars to its logical end and demonstrated that in fact there was an intricate system of metrical alternatives for the recurring names of heroes, gods and objects. It was a system that was economical—hardly any unnecessary alternatives were used—but had great scope: there was a way to fit the names into the line in any of the usual grammatical forms they would assume. Parry demonstrated that the system was more extensive and highly organized than anyone had dreamed, and he also realized what it meant. It meant that this system had been developed by and for the use of oral poets who improvised. In Paris he met scholars who had studied such improvising illiterate bards still performing in Yugoslavia. He went there to study their operations himself.

The Homeric epithets were created to meet the demands of the meter of Greek heroic poetry, the dactylic hexameter. They offer the improvising bard different ways of fitting the name of his god, hero, or object into whatever section of the line is left after he has, so to speak, filled up the first half (that, too, quite possibly, with another formulaic phrase). Odysseus, for example, is often described as “much-enduring, brilliant Odysseus”—pŏlūtlās dīŏs Ŏdūssēus—a line ending. In Book 5 Calypso, who has had Odysseus to herself on her island for seven years, is ordered by the gods to release him and tells him he can go. But he suspects a trap, and shudders. “So she spoke,” says Homer, “and he shuddered”—hōs phătŏ rīgēsēn dĕ—and he ends with the formula “much-enduring, brilliant Odysseus”—pŏlūtlās dīŏs Ŏdūssēus—to form a hexameter line. A little later Calypso asks Odysseus how he can prefer his wife at home to her immortal charms, and his diplomatic answer is introduced by the formula: “and in answer he addressed her”—tēn d’ ăpŏmēibŏmĕnōs prŏsĕphē. But the line cannot be completed with “much-enduring, brilliant Odysseus”; that formula is too long for this position. So Odysseus ceases for the moment to be “much-enduring” and “brilliant” and becomes something that conforms to the metrical pattern: “a man of many schemes”—pŏlŭmētĭs Ŏdūssēus. The hero’s name is especially adaptable; Homer uses two different spellings—Odusseus and Oduseus—which give the hero two different metrical identities. Often, however, the poet has to use the name in a different grammatical case from the nominative— the genitive Ŏdŭsēŏs, for example—and when that happens the hero becomes “blameless”—Ŏdŭsēŏs ămūmŏnŏs—or, with the longer spelling of his name, “great-hearted”—Ŏdūssēōs mĕgălētŏrŏs. In the dative case he becomes “godlike”—āntĭthĕō Ŏdūsēĭ—or “quick-minded”—Ŏdŭsēĭ dăīphrŏnĭ. The choice of epithet is dictated by the meter. So also the island of Ithaca is “rocky,” “seagirt,” “clear-skied” or “lying under Mount Neriton,” depending on its grammatical case and position in the line; and under the same imperatives the Phaeacians appear as “great-hearted,” “famous for ships” or “lords of the sea.” As for the ships, objects as essential to the story of Odysseus as spears and swords are to that of Achilles, they are “hollow,” “swift,” “black,” “well-benched,” “well-oared,” “well-worked,” “scooped-out,” “fast-moving,” “scarlet-cheeked” and “black-prowed,” to name only the principal epithets that enable the poet to use them in any grammatical case and metrical position.

This system, obviously the product of invention, refinement and elimination of superfluities over generations, could only be the work of oral bards, and in fact similar phenomena, though infinitely less sophisticated, are found in oral poetry, living and dead, in other languages. There was more to it, of course, than handy epithets. Whole lines, once honed to perfection by the bards of the tradition, became part of the repertoire; they are especially noticeable in recurring passages like descriptions of sacrifice, of communal eating and drinking. Such passages give the oral singer time to concentrate on what is coming next and, if he is a creative oral poet, to elaborate his own phrases mentally as he recites the formulas that he can sing without effort. He is helped, too, by the formulaic nature of whole themes, great type-scenes—the arming of the warrior for battle, the launching and beaching of ships. These are traditional patterns that the audience expects and the bard may vary but not radically change.

There is one aspect of Parry’s discovery, however, that changed the whole problem of the nature of our Homeric text. The oral bard who uses such formulaic language is not, as scholars in the nineteenth century who struggled with the problem of illiterate bards all assumed, a poet reciting from memory a fixed text. He is improvising, along known lines, relying on a huge stock of formulaic phrases, lines and even whole scenes; but he is improvising. And every time he sings the poem, he may do it differently. The outline remains the same, but the text, the oral text, is flexible. The poem is new every time it is performed.

If Homer’s poetry is the culmination of a long tradition of such oral composition, many of the problems that bedeviled the Analysts are solved. Over the course of generations of trial and error, formulas are introduced and rejected or retained for their usefulness in improvisation, without regard to linguistic consistency or historical accuracy. The language of the poets becomes a repository of all the combinations that have proved useful. Small wonder that Aeolic and Ionic forms appear in the same line, that a Mycenaean boar-tusk helmet can turn up in a passage in the Iliad, full of late linguistic forms, that people in the Odyssey sometimes give dowries and sometimes demand payment for their daughter’s hand, that cremation and inhumation are practiced side by side. As each new generation of singers re-creates the song, new formulas may be invented, new themes and scenes introduced; reflections of contemporary reality creep into descriptions of the fighting, especially into the similes. But the dedication of epic poetry to the past and the continuing usefulness of so much traditional phraseology will slow the process of modernization and produce the unhistorical amalgam of customs, objects and linguistic forms that we find in our Homeric text.

It is the fate of most new and valuable insights to be enthusiastically developed beyond the limits of certainty, or even of probability, and Parry’s demonstration that Homeric poetry had an oral base has not escaped that fate. Phrases, even whole lines, that are repeated often enough to qualify as formulaic are indeed characteristic of the poet’s diction, but they do not account for more than a part of it—about one third of the whole. In an attempt to raise the formulaic element to a higher level, Parry counted as formulas expressions whose metrical pattern and position in the line were identical and that contained one word in common: for example, tēuchĕ ĕthēkĕ; ālgĕ’ ĕthēkĕ; kūdŏs ĕthēkĕ—he “put” the arms, the sorrows, the glory on. Not content with this, Parry went on to suggest, hesitantly, the inclusion in the system of similar expressions that, however, did not contain one word in common: dōkĕn hĕtāirŏ, for example, and tēuchĕ kŭnēssĭn—“he gave to his comrade,” “he made [him prey] for the dogs.” Some of Parry’s followers have been less hesitant, and by this and other extensions of the meaning of “formula” have boosted the inherited content of Homer’s verse to ninety percent. This of course leaves very little room for Homer as an individual creative poet. It seems in fact to be a return to the idea of Giambattista Vico: the poems are the creation of a people, of a tradition, of generations of nameless bards.

But the argument for full formularity has feet of clay. A poet composing in a strict, demanding meter is bound to repeat syntactical combinations in identical positions, and the stricter the meter, the higher the incidence of such repeated patterns. English has no meters as precisely demanding as Homer’s, but Alexander Pope, to take an example, is rich in lines that by rigid Parryite standards would qualify him as an illiterate bard:

The Smiles of Harlots, and the Tears of Heirs

The Fate of Louis and the Fall of Rome

Proclaim their Motions, and provoke the War

Maintain thy Honours, and enlarge thy Fame

The shining Helmet, and the pointed Spears

The silver Token, and the circled Green

Weak was his Pace, but dauntless was his Heart

Lame are their Feet, and wrinkled is their Face

Samuel Johnson, in fact, wrote a description of Pope’s technique that has more than a little resemblance to Parry’s conception of the oral poet. “By perpetual practice, language had in his mind a systematical arrangement; having always the same use for words, he had words so selected and combined as to be ready at his call.”

Extravagant claims for the predominance of formula in Homeric poetry have now been generally discounted, and even Parry’s basic theses have been shown to need modification in the light of later examination. There are many cases, for example, where a truly formulaic epithet does in fact seem to be poetically functional in its context. There are cases where verbal repetition is so poetically effective that it must be the result of poetic design rather than the working of a quasi-mechanical system. Careful investigation of the type-scenes—the ceremony of sacrifice, the arming of the warrior, and so on—has revealed that although sometimes whole verses are repeated from one scene to another, no two scenes are exactly similar. “Each occurrence,” to quote a recent evaluation (Edwards, p. 72), “is unique, and often specifically adapted to its context.” Even the basic concept of economy, the strict limitation of the epithets for one god or hero to those needed in different cases and positions, has been questioned: a recent study shows that in his analysis of the epithets for Achilles, Parry considered only the phrases containing the hero’s name, ignoring other ways of identifying Achilles, such as “Peleus’ son” (Shive, passim). All this, together with the monumental scale and magnificent architecture of the Iliad, the complex structure of the Odyssey, makes the image of Homer as an illiterate bard, totally dependent on ready-made formulas and stock scenes for improvised performance, hard to accept.

There is nevertheless fairly general agreement that Parry was right in one thing: Homer’s unique style does show clearly that he was heir to a long tradition of oral poetry. There is, however, one problem that Parry raised but did not solve: Homer may or may not have been as illiterate as his forerunners, but at some time the Iliad and the Odyssey were written down. When, by whom, for what purpose and in what circumstances was this done?

The most likely date for the composition of the Iliad is the fifty years running from 725 to 675
B.C
.; for the Odyssey, somewhat later in the period. That is also the time to which the earliest examples of Greek alphabetic writing can be dated. Did Homer take advantage of the new technique to record for future singers the huge poems he had composed without the aid of writing? Did writing perhaps play a role in its composition? To both these questions Parry’s collaborator and successor, Albert Lord, gave an emphatically negative answer. “The two techniques are… mutually exclusive… It is conceivable that a man might be an oral poet in his younger years and a written poet later in life, but it is not possible that he be both an oral and a written poet at any given time in his career” (p. 129). Lord based this assertion on his experience with Yugoslav oral poets who, when they came in contact with literate urban societies, lost their gift for improvised recitation. He envisaged a Homer, an oral bard at the height of his powers, who dictated his poem to a scribe, one who had mastered the new art of writing. This was of course how the songs of illiterate Yugoslav bards had been written down (sometimes with the aid of recording equipment, sophisticated for its time) by Parry and Lord.

This scenario did not satisfy everyone. The analogy with modern Yugoslavia, for example, was flawed. When the bards there learned to read and write, they were immediately exposed to the corrupting influence of newspapers, magazines and cheap fiction, but if Homer learned to write in the late eighth century, there was little or nothing for him to read. Lord’s generalization about the incompatibility of the two techniques has been questioned by students of oral poetry; in other parts of the world (particularly in Africa), they find no such dichotomy. “The basic point… is the continuity of oral and written literature. There is no deep gulf between the two: they shade into each other both in the present and over many centuries of historical development, and there are innumerable cases of poetry which has both ‘oral’ and ‘written’ elements” (Finnegan, p. 24). Furthermore, the extant specimens of alphabetic writing of the eighth and early seventh centuries
B.C
. make it hard to believe in a scribe of the period who could take dictation at or, for that matter, anywhere near performance speed: the letters are freestanding capitals, crudely and laboriously formed, written from right to left, or from right to left and left to right on alternate lines. One critic, in fact, irreverently conjured up a picture of Homer dictating the first line (or rather the first half-line) of the Iliad: “Mênin aeide thea… You got that?”

A different scenario for the transition from oral performance to written text was developed by Geoffrey Kirk. The epics were the work of an oral “monumental composer,” whose version imposed itself on bards and audiences as the definitive version. They “then passed through at least a couple of generations of transmission by decadent and quasi-literate singers and rhapsodes” (Kirk, The Iliad: A Commentary, I, p. xxv)— that is, performers who were not themselves poets. Lord’s objection to this, that memorization plays no part in the living oral tradition, was based on Yugoslav experience, but elsewhere—in Somalia, for example—very long poems are recited from memory by professional reciters who are themselves, in many cases, poets.

What neither of these theories explains, however, is the immense length of the poem. Why should an oral, illiterate poet, whose poetry exists only in its performance before an audience, create a poem so long that it would take several days to perform? For that matter, if his poetry existed only in performance, how could he create a poem of such length? If, on the other hand, he delivered different sections of it at different times and places, how could he have elaborated the variations on theme and formula and the inner structural correspondences that distinguish the Homeric epics so sharply from the Yugoslav texts collected by Parry and Lord?

It is not surprising that many recent scholars in the field have come to the conclusion that writing did indeed play a role in the creation of these extraordinary poems, that the phenomena characteristic of oral epic demonstrated by Parry and Lord are balanced by qualities peculiar to literary composition. They envisage a highly creative oral poet, master of the repertoire of inherited material and technique, who used the new instrument of writing to build, probably over the course of a lifetime, an epic poem on a scale beyond the imagination of his predecessors.

The last half of the eighth century was the time in which writing was coming into use all over the Greek world. Homer must have known of its existence, but the traditional nature of his material naturally forbade its appearance in the relentlessly archaic world of his heroes, who belonged to the time when men were stronger, braver and greater than men are now, a world in which men and gods spoke face-to-face. Even so, Homer does show, in one particular instance, that he was conscious of the new technique. In Book 6 of the Iliad Glaucus tells the story of his grandfather Bellerophon, whom Proetus, king of Argos, sent off with a message to the king of Lycia, Proetus’ father-in-law; it instructed the king to kill the bearer: “[He] gave him tokens, / murderous signs, scratched in a folded tablet” (6.198–99). There has been much discussion about the nature of these signs, but the word Homer uses—grapsas, literally “scratching”—is later the normal word used for “writing,” and pinax—“tablet”—is the word used by later Greeks to describe the wooden boards coated with wax that were used for short notes.

If Homer could write, what did he write on? Obviously, “tablets” would not be adequate. We do not know when papyrus, the paper of the ancient world, was first available in Greece, though we do know that it came at first not from its almost exclusive source, Egypt—which was not opened to Greek merchants until the sixth century
B.C
.—but from the Phoenician port the Greeks called Byblos (the Greek word for book was biblion—our “Bible”). Archaeological evidence for Phoenician imports into Greece dates from the ninth century
B.C
., and Phoenician traders are mentioned in the Iliad (23.828) and their operations described with a wealth of detail in the Odyssey. But even if papyrus was not available in quantity, there were other materials, such as animal skins. Herodotus, writing in the fifth century
B.C
., says that in his time the Ionian Greeks still used the word diphthera—“skin”—when they meant “book.”

The crudity of the script in the eighth century meant that writing was a laborious business. If Homer did use writing in the composition of the poem, it is likely that the process extended over many years. Episodes from the Odyssean voyages (the one-eyed giant) or from the return of Odysseus (the slaughter in the hall) would be brought to near perfection in oral performance, perhaps combined with other episodes to form longer units for special occasions (Odysseus among the Phaeacians, the beggar in the palace) and eventually committed to writing. Gradually a complete text would be assembled, to be refined in detail and extended by insertions, the longer sections welded into unity by connecting links. It was inevitable in such a process, with writing a newly acquired skill and writing materials, papyrus or leather, not convenient for cross-reference, that the final version should contain inconsistencies. No one has ever, in spite of repeated and ingenious efforts, been able to produce a totally convincing ground plan of the palace of Odysseus; people enter and emerge from rooms that seem to shift position from one episode to the next. There are also inconsistencies in the location of the characters. In Book 15, for example, when Telemachus and Theoclymenus, the fugitive he has taken under his wing, arrive at Ithaca, they go ashore and Theoclymenus sees a hawk carry off a dove, a bird sign that he interprets as a prophecy of victory for Telemachus. But later, when he refers to this incident, he says that he saw the hawk as he “sat on the benched ship” (ref).

These are inconsistencies typical of poetry improvised in dramatic presentation; the wonder is that there are not many more of them in so long and complex a poem. Though pointed out in scholarly commentaries, they rarely disturb the ordinary reader today, and of course Homer’s original audiences, even if they had been critically disposed, would have been hard put to cite chapter and verse for their objections. But in fact the poet’s listeners were not in a critical frame of mind. The word Homer uses to describe audience reaction to the longest epic recital in the Odyssey—the hero’s tale of his wandering course from Troy to the court of the Phaeacian king, where he now sits at the banquet table—is kêlêthmos, “enchantment.” “His story [held] them spellbound down the shadowed halls” (ref). Many centuries later, in Plato’s dialogue Ion, a rhapsode, a professional reciter of the Homeric epics, echoes Homer’s words as he describes the audience’s reaction to his performance. “I look down on them weeping, gazing at me with an awe-struck look, joining me in my astonishment at the words I am speaking.”

The surprising thing is that the inconsistencies stayed in the text. If Homer, as in Lord’s model, had dictated his poem, the scribe could hardly have failed to notice and correct them. In fact, Lord records such corrections in the course of dictation in Yugoslavia. And it seems hard to imagine the lines going uncorrected in Kirk’s scenario of a monumental poem preserved by recitation for a generation or two before being written down. Any rhapsode (and in the earlier generation he would have been an oral poet himself) could have corrected the lines without effort and would have seen no reason not to do so. There seems to be only one possible explanation of their survival in the text: that the text was regarded as authentic, the exact words of Homer himself. And that can only mean that there was a written copy.

This is of course pure speculation, but so are all other attempts to explain the origin of the text that has come down to us. We shall never be able to answer the questions it raises with any certainty and must rest content with the fact that a great poet marshaled the resources of an age-old traditional art to create something new—the tales of the wrath of Achilles and the wanderings of Odysseus that have been models for epic poetry ever since.

THE
ODYSSEY
AND THE
ILIAD

I
t has always been assumed that the Odyssey was composed later than the Iliad. One ancient critic, the author of the treatise On the Sublime, thought that the Odyssey was the product of Homer’s old age, of “a mind in decline; it was a work that could be compared to the setting sun—the size remained, without the force.” He did, however, temper the harshness of that judgment by adding: “I am speaking of old age—but it is the old age of Homer.” What prompted his comment “without the force” is clearly his preference for the sustained heroic level of the Iliad over what he terms the Odyssey’s presentation of “the fabulous and incredible” as well as the realistic description of life in the farms and palace of Odysseus’ domain, which, he says, “forms a kind of comedy of manners.” His judgment is of course determined by the conception of the “sublime” which is the focus of his book, one that did not welcome scenes like those offered by Book 18 of the Odyssey—a fistfight between two ragged beggars, for example, or the award of a sizzling-hot goat’s-blood sausage full of fat to the winner.

On the Sublime was written sometime in the first century
A.D.
, but a different scenario for the relation of the Iliad to the Odyssey had already been proposed in the second century
B.C
. A number of scholars, known as chorizontes—“separators”—recognized that the Odyssey was composed later than the Iliad but suggested that it had a different author. This is the position taken also by many modern scholars, who find significant differences between the two poems not only in vocabulary and grammatical usage but also in what they consider development from the Iliad to the Odyssey in moral and religious ideas and attitudes. Estimates of the validity of such evidence vary, however, and there are those who find it hard to accept the idea of the emergence of two major epic poets in such a short span of time.

That the Odyssey was composed later than the Iliad can hardly be doubted. For one thing, though it takes for granted the audience’s knowledge not just of the Trojan War saga but of the particular form it has been given in the Iliad, it carefully avoids duplicating its material. Incidents from the tale of Troy are frequently recalled, sometimes in detail and at length, but they all fall outside the time frame of the Iliad, occurring either before or after the period of forty-one days that began with the wrath of Achilles and ended with the burial of Hector. Demodocus at the Phaeacian court sings of the quarrel between Odysseus and Achilles (an incident not mentioned in the Iliad or, for that matter, anywhere else in extant Greek literature) and later of the wooden horse that brought the siege to an end. In the palace at Ithaca, the theme of the minstrel Phemius is the sufferings of the heroes on their way home from the war. Nestor at Pylos tells Telemachus how Agamemnon and Menelaus quarreled after the fall of Troy and took separate routes home. Helen and Menelaus at Sparta tell stories about Odysseus at Troy, neither of them familiar from the Iliad. Even when Odysseus meets the shades of his comrades Agamemnon and Achilles in Hades, Iliadic material is avoided: Agamemnon tells the story of his death at the hands of his wife and her lover, Odysseus tells Achilles about the heroic feats of arms of his son Neoptolemus and later talks to Ajax about the award of the arms of Achilles.

That the poet of the Odyssey knew the Iliad in its contemporary form is strongly suggested also by the continuity of character delineation from one poem to the other. In the Odyssey they are all older, those of them who are still alive, but they are recognizably the same men. Nestor is still regal, punctilious and long-winded. Menelaus’ generous reaction to Telemachus’ tactful refusal of his gift of chariot and horses recalls his princely response to young Antilochus’ apology for his unsportsmanlike maneuver in the chariot race at the funeral games for Patroclus. Helen is still, at Sparta as she was at Troy, the poised mistress of a difficult situation. And Odysseus is still the spellbinding speaker Antenor remembered in Book 3 of the Iliad, whose “words came piling on like a driving winter blizzard” (3.267); he is still “the man of twists and turns” Helen identified for Priam in the same passage (3.244). And he is still the man “who says one thing but hides another in his heart” (9.379)—Achilles’ description of the kind of man he hates (he is addressing Odysseus, who has come as Agamemnon’s ambassador). Odysseus is still the quick-thinking and resourceful leader who by prompt action stemmed the rush for the ships caused by Agamemnon’s foolish decision to test the morale of the troops by suggesting that they go home.

But in the Odyssey he is no longer one of many heroes fighting between the beached ships and the walls of Troy. He is on his own, first as admiral of a small fleet, then as captain of an isolated ship, and finally as a shipwrecked sailor clinging to a piece of wreckage. The scenes of his action and suffering widen to include not only the coasts and islands of the Aegean Sea and continental Greece but also, in the false travel tales he spins in his disguise as a beggar, Crete, Cyprus, Phoenicia and Sicily, and, in the stories he tells the Phaeacians at their feast, the unknown world of the western seas, full of marvels and monsters. Those ships that in the Iliad lie beached behind a palisade and, with Achilles out of the fighting, face the fury of Hector’s assault, return in the Odyssey to their natural element, the wine-dark sea.

THE WESTERN SEAS

M
any centuries after Homer, the Florentine Dante Alighieri, who had not read Homer and whose information about Ulysses (the Latin form of Odysseus’ name) came from Virgil and Ovid, saw in the Greek hero a vision of the restless explorer, the man who, discontented with the mundane life of that home he had longed for, set off again in search of new worlds. “Neither the pleasure I took in my son,” he says in the Inferno, “nor reverence for my aged father, nor the love I owed Penelope that should have made her joyful, could prevail against the passion I felt to win experience of the world, of human vice and worth.” He sets sail for Gibraltar and launches out into the Atlantic, following the sun “to the world where no one lives.” This theme was taken up in Tennyson’s “Ulysses,” where the hero announces his purpose “to sail beyond the sunset, and the baths / Of all the western stars…”

But these visions of Odysseus as the restless explorer, hungry for new worlds, have little to do with Homer’s Odysseus, who wants above all things to find his way home and stay there. It is true that, as Homer tells us in the prologue, he saw “many cities of men… and learned their minds” (ref); once afloat in uncharted seas, he has a thoroughly Greek curiosity about the inhabitants of the landfalls he makes, but the voyage was none of his choosing. He was “driven time and again off course, once he had plundered / the hallowed heights of Troy” (ref), and far from seeking “experience of the world,” he was “fighting to save his life and bring his comrades home” (ref).

Odysseus’ wanderings in the west have inspired many attempts to plot his course and identify his ports of call. This wild-goose chase had begun already in the ancient world, as we know from the brusque dismissal of such identifications by the great Alexandrian geographer Eratosthenes, who said that you would be able to chart the course of Odysseus’ wanderings when you found the cobbler who sewed the bag in which Aeolus confined the winds. This of course has not deterred modern scholars and amateurs from trying; their guesses run from the possible—Charybdis as a mythical personification of whirlpools in the straits between Sicily and the toe of the Italian boot—to the fantastic: Calypso’s island as Iceland. According to one investigator of the subject, “There have been some seventy theories proposed since Homer wrote the Odyssey, with locations bounded only by the North and South Poles and ranging within the inhabited world from Norway to South Africa and from the Canary Islands to the Sea of Azov” (Clarke, p. 251).

But even identifications that are not obviously ridiculous seem implausible in the light of Homer’s confused geographical notions of areas much nearer home. He knows the Asia Minor coast and the Aegean islands: Nestor on the alternative routes from Troy across the Aegean sounds like an expert seaman. But Homer’s notion of Egypt, where Menelaus was delayed by contrary winds and where Odysseus in his lying tales often lands, is, to put it mildly, vague. Menelaus describes the island of Pharos, which is one mile off the coast, as distant as far as a ship runs in a whole day with the wind behind her. And when Homer’s characters move to mainland Greece and its western offshore islands, confusion reigns. His description of Ithaca is so full of contradictions that many modern scholars have proposed Leucas or Cephallenia as the real home of Odysseus rather than the island that now bears the name. Homer also displays total ignorance of the geography of mainland Greece: his Telemachus and Pisistratus go from Pylos on the west coast to Sparta in a horse-drawn chariot over a formidable mountain barrier that had no through road in ancient times.

But Homer’s hazy notions of any area outside the Aegean is only one of the objections to the idea of assigning western locations to Circe’s island and the land of the Lotus-eaters. A great many of the incidents in Odysseus’ wanderings are obviously based on a different voyage, the voyage of the Argo, which, with a crew of heroes captained by Jason, sailed not the western but the eastern seas. The Laestrygonians who attack Odysseus’ ships with rocks have their counterparts in the Argonauts’ saga; Circe is the sister of Aeetes, keeper of the golden fleece, and Homer himself locates her island not in the west but in the east—where the sun rises. The Clashing Rocks are also a feature of Jason’s voyage, and the poem that celebrates it is specifically mentioned by Homer at this point. And the Sirens appear in Apollonius’ poem the Argonautica, which, though written in the second century
B.C
., certainly drew on the earlier poem to which Homer refers. What Homer has done is to transfer episodes from a mythical epic journey in eastern waters to the western seas.

It was of course a geographical imperative that if Odysseus was to be blown off course on his way home, the wind would take him west. But that imperative must have been eagerly welcomed by Homer and his audience, for the early years of the eighth century
B.C.
saw the beginnings of what was to become a large-scale movement of Greek traders and, later, colonists into the western Mediterranean. Odysseus, when he declines the invitation of a young Phaeacian to compete in an athletic contest, is contemptuously dismissed as no athlete but

“some skipper of profiteers,

roving the high seas in his scudding craft,

reckoning up his freight with a keen eye out

for home-cargo, grabbing the gold he can!”

(ref)

The traders were soon followed by the colonists. The first settlement seems to have been Pithecusae, on the island of Ischia in the Bay of Naples; it was not a city but a trading station and is dated by archaeological evidence not later than 775
B.C
. By 700 there were Greek cities in Italy: Cumae, on the mainland opposite Ischia; Rhegium (Reggio Calabria), on the toe of the Italian boot; and the proverbially wealthy city of Sybaris, on the instep, as well as Taras (Taranto) in the same area. On the neighboring island of Sicily, Syracuse and Zancle (Messina) were founded around 725. Still later were to come settlements on the southern coast of France: Massilia (Marseilles), Antipas (Antibes) and Nicaea (Nice), as well as Cyrene on the coast of what is now Libya.

Long before the first colonists set out, there must have been many voyages of trader-explorers, who no doubt brought back tales of wonders and dangers that improved in the telling. Charybdis, for example, may possibly be a fantastic version of the currents and whirlpools that are sometimes encountered in the straits between Sicily and the mainland. And though the Cyclops’ gigantic size and one eye mark him as mythical, his pastoral economy and ferocity toward strangers may be a memory of the indigenous populations who opposed the intruders landing on their shores—a demonized vision of the native, like Shakespeare’s Caliban. The Tempest was written in a similar age of exploration, and though Prospero and Ariel have powers that are not of this world, there can be no doubt that the wonders of the play are an imaginative reworking of the tall tales of the sailors and pirates who for half a century had sailed the Central American seas in search of land to settle, Spanish ships to board, Spanish towns to sack, or Spanish buyers for their cargoes of African slaves. We know, in fact, that Shakespeare must have read some of the accounts of the shipwreck of the Sea-Venture, the flagship of a fleet on its way to the Virginia colony, in a “dreadful and hideous storm” off the island of Bermuda, and the company’s survival and eventual arrival at the colony—a series of events that one of the accounts calls “a tragical comedy.”

And there is one passage in the Odyssey that is a clear reminiscence of Greek voyages of exploration in the west. When Odysseus comes to the land of the Cyclops, he sees a small island offshore, which is fertile and well stocked with wild goats, but uninhabited. The Cyclops, he explains to his Phaeacian audience,

“have no ships with crimson prows,

no shipwrights there to build them good trim craft…

Such artisans would have made this island too

a decent place to live in… No mean spot,

it could bear you any crop you like in season.

The water-meadows along the low foaming shore

run soft and moist, and your vines would never flag.

The land’s clear for plowing. Harvest on harvest,

a man could reap a healthy stand of grain—

the subsoil’s dark and rich.”

(ref)

It is the authentic voice of the explorer evaluating a site for settlement.

VOYAGER

O
dysseus’ voyage to the fabulous western seas begins in the everyday world, as he leaves the ruins of Troy homeward bound, his ships loaded with booty from the sack of the city. As if that booty were not enough for him, he attacks the first settlement he comes to on his way, the town of Ismarus on the Thracian coast opposite Troy:

“… I sacked the city,

killed the men, but as for the wives and plunder,

that rich haul we dragged away from the place—

we shared it round…”

(ref)

It is sheer piracy—Ismarus was not a Trojan ally—but it is obviously an action not unusual in its time and place; one of Odysseus’ epithets is in fact ptoliporthos, “sacker of cities.” Nestor at Pylos politely asks Telemachus and Pisistratus if they are

“Out on a trading spree or roving the waves like pirates,

sea-wolves raiding at will, who risk their lives

to plunder other men?”

(ref)

And Polyphemus asks Odysseus the same question (ref). Thucydides, writing in the fifth century
B.C
., was probably thinking of passages like these when, speaking of the measures taken by Minos to suppress piracy in the Aegean, he pointed out that in ancient times “this occupation was held to be honorable rather than disgraceful. This is proved… by the testimony of ancient poets, in whose verses newly arrived visitors are always asked whether they are pirates, a question that implies no disapproval of such an occupation on the part of either those who answer with a disclaimer or those who ask for the information.” Piracy was endemic in the Aegean—a sea of islands large and small, of jagged coastlines full of hidden harbors—whenever there was no central sea power strong enough to suppress it. Long after Minos, in the fifth century, an Athenian fleet under the command of Cimon cleared out a nest of pirates on the island of Scyros. Many centuries later the young Julius Caesar was captured by pirates near the small island of Pharmacusa off the Ionian coast and held for ransom. The seas became so unsafe that in 67
B.C
. Cnaeus Pompeius was given the overriding authority to deal with the problem and did so by manning 270 warships and mobilizing 100,000 troops. Whenever there was a power vacuum in the Aegean, piracy reappeared; as late as the 1820s Arab corsairs carried off the inhabitants of the Greek island of Cythera to sell in the slave market at Algiers.

Cythera is the island off Cape Malea past which Odysseus, trying to turn north toward Ithaca, was blown west for nine days, off the map, into a world of wonders and terrors, of giants and witches, goddesses and cannibals, of dangers and temptations. The tales of his landfalls and the welcomes he received differ widely in content and scope, but they are connected by a common theme, on which they are all variations. It is a theme fundamental for the Odyssey as a whole, pervasive not only in the wandering voyage of the hero but also in the opening books, which deal with Telemachus at home and abroad, and in the last half of the poem, which presents us with Odysseus, disguised as a ragged beggar, home at last in his own house. This theme is, briefly stated, the relation between host and guest, particularly the moral obligation to welcome and protect the stranger, an obligation imposed on civilized mankind by Zeus, one of whose many titles is xeinios, “protector of strangers.” “Zeus of the Strangers,” says Odysseus to the one-eyed giant in his cave, “guards all guests and suppliants” (ref).

Zeus is invoked as the divine patron and enforcer of a code of conduct that helps to make travel possible in a world of piracy at sea, cattle raiding and local war by land, of anarchic competition between rival families—a world with no firm central authority to impose law and order. In such a world, a man who leaves his home depends on the kindness of strangers. Without a universally recognized code of hospitality, no man would dare travel abroad; its observance is therefore a matter of self-interest. One of its almost ritual components is the parting gift offered by the host. So when Athena, in the shape of Mentes, takes leave of Telemachus, he tells her to go back to her ship “delighted with a gift,… something rare and fine… The kind of gift / a host will give a stranger, friend to friend” (ref). Athena does not wish to be burdened with the gift now; she asks him to save it for her so that she can take it on her way back. “Choose something rare and fine, and a good reward / that gift is going to bring you” (ref). The reward is not a cash payment; it is the reciprocal hospitality and gift Telemachus will receive when he goes to visit Mentes. So Odysseus, in his false tale to Laertes at the end of the poem, pretends to be a man who entertained Odysseus once on his travels and loaded him with gifts. He has stopped at Ithaca now to visit Odysseus. The old man tells him Odysseus has never returned and must be dead.

“But if you’d found him alive, here in Ithaca,

he would have replied in kind, with gift for gift,

and entertained you warmly…

That’s the old custom, when one has led the way.”

(ref)

The host’s gift is so fixed a feature of the relationship that the guest can even ask for something else, if the proffered gift is not suitable. So Telemachus, offered a splendid chariot and team of horses by Menelaus, declines the offer. “Those horses I really cannot take to Ithaca,” where there is “No running-room for mares… no meadows.” His island is “Goat, not stallion, land” (ref). Menelaus, far from being taken aback, recognizes his frankness as the mark of aristocratic birth and breeding—“Good blood runs in you, dear boy”—and offers him instead “a mixing-bowl, forged to perfection— / it’s solid silver finished off with a lip of gold” (ref). The bowl, he goes on to explain, was itself a gift from a host, Phaedimus, king of the Phoenician city of Sidon, with whom he stayed on his wandering course home from Troy.

Throughout his voyage, Odysseus will be dependent on the kindness of strangers, their generosity as hosts. Some of them, like the Phaeacians and Aeolus, king of the winds, will be perfect hosts, entertaining him lavishly and sending him on his way with precious gifts. Others will be savages, threatening his life and taking the lives of his crew. Still others will be importunate hosts, delaying the guest’s departure—an infraction of the code. “I’d never detain you here too long,” Menelaus says to Telemachus. “I’d find fault with another host… too warm to his guests.” And taking a leaf from Pope’s translation, he formulates the golden rule: “‘Welcome the coming, speed the parting guest!’” (ref, see note ref). Many of Odysseus’ hosts seem to have heard only the first half of that injunction. Circe is a charming hostess, but she charms her guests out of human shape and keeps them forever. Calypso too would have kept Odysseus forever, but in his own shape, perpetually young. The Sirens would have kept him forever also, but dead. Calypso and Circe, however, when the time comes to speed the parting guest, provide the requisite gifts. Calypso sends a fair wind to send his raft on its way, and Circe gives him precious instructions—how to deal with the Sirens, the warning not to kill the cattle of the Sun. Telemachus also has to deal with an importunate host. On his way back from Sparta to Pylos, he manages to evade what he fears will be an intolerable delay if he goes to Nestor’s palace. “Your father’s old,” he says to his companion Pisistratus,

“… in love with his hospitality;

I fear he’ll hold me, chafing in his palace—

I must hurry home!”

(ref)

Telemachus will return to a house where the suitors of Penelope represent an unusual infraction of the code: they are uninvited guests who abuse and waste their reluctant host’s possessions. Showing their utter contempt for the idea that wanderers, beggars and suppliants are under the special protection of Zeus, they offer insults and physical violence to Odysseus, the ragged beggar who, as they will eventually find out to their cost, is their unwilling host.

Odysseus’ first landfall after passing Cape Malea is the country of the Lotus-eaters, who offer three of his men food that would have kept them as permanent guests—

“[they] lost all desire to send a message back, much less return,

… all memory of the journey home

dissolved forever.”

(ref)

—if Odysseus had not dragged them, weeping, back to the ships. The Lotus-eaters, as he reports, “had no notion of killing my companions” (ref), but his next host, the Cyclops, not only kills but also eats six of them. Odysseus’ invocation of Zeus as protector of strangers is met with scorn—“We Cyclops never blink at Zeus… or any other blessed god” (ref)—and Odysseus’ request for a guest-gift is met with the concession that Odysseus will be eaten last, after all his crew. Odysseus makes his escape only because of the resourcefulness for which he is famous, but in order to trick the Cyclops he has to suppress his identity and give his name as Nobody.

Deceit is indispensable if he and his crew are to escape, but though he is master of all the arts of deceit, this particular subterfuge is one his whole nature rebels against. It is for his name and all that it means to him and his peers that he struggles to go on living and return to the world where it is known and honored. When, later, at the court of King Alcinous, he reveals his identity, he tells the banqueters, and us, not only his name but also the renown it carries. “I am Odysseus, son of Laertes, known to the world / for every kind of craft—my fame has reached the skies” (ref). He speaks of his fame in an utterly objective manner, as if it were something apart from himself; his words are not a boast but a statement of the reputation, the qualities and achievements, to which he must be true. Once free of the Cyclops’ cave, he insists, at great risk to himself and his ship, on telling the Cyclops who has blinded him: “Odysseus, / raider of cities, he gouged out your eye, / Laertes’ son who makes his home in Ithaca!” (ref). And this enables Polyphemus to invoke the wrath of his father, the sea god Poseidon, and ensure that Odysseus will “come home late / and come a broken man—all shipmates lost, / alone in a stranger’s ship,” to “find a world of pain at home” (ref).

With Odysseus’ next port of call, however, it begins to look as if Polyphemus’ prayer will remain unanswered. Aeolus, the keeper of the winds, is a generous host and sends his guest on a magical ride—the West Wind blowing steadily toward Ithaca and all the other winds imprisoned in a bag aboard his ship. In sight of home—“we could see men tending fires” (ref)—Odysseus, who has been at the helm for the entire voyage, finally relaxes. But the deep sleep he falls into allows the crew, suspecting that the bag contains treasure, to open it and let loose the winds. As his ships are blown back into the unknown, Odysseus faces the first of his temptations—“should I leap over the side and drown at once?” (ref)—but resolves to stay alive, even though the hurricane winds are hurrying his ships back to Aeolus, where his plea for further aid is indignantly rejected. His next encounter is with the gigantic cannibals, the Laestrygonians, from whom he makes a narrow escape, but with the loss of all his other ships and crews. Circe’s island confronts him with another danger, from which he escapes with the help of the god Hermes, but then she turns into a temptation. Circe, after she has renounced her plan to change him and his crew into swine, becomes a perfect hostess, entertaining Odysseus in her bed and his crew at the banquet table. Odysseus, if not bewitched, is certainly charmed, for at the end of a whole year of dalliance he has to be reminded by his crew of his duty: “Captain, this is madness! / High time you thought of your own home at last” (ref). Circe, unlike Calypso, is willing to release him, but tells him that he must first go down to the land of the dead to consult the ghost of the blind prophet Tiresias.

Homer’s picture of the lower world is of course the model for all later Western geographies of Hell, through Virgil’s sixth book of the Aeneid to that greatest of all visions of the life to come, the Divina Commedia of Dante. Quite apart from the consultation with Tiresias, the visit has a special significance for Odysseus. All through the trials of his voyage home, the temptation to find release in death has always been at hand— by suicide, as in his despair off Ithaca, or, more subtly, at any moment of tension, by simply relaxing momentarily the constant vigilance, the quick suspicion, the inexhaustible resilience and determination, that keep him alive. Anyone who has been under a continual strain in action and especially in command knows the weariness that can tempt a man to neglect precautions, take the shortcut, let things go for once; it is a mood in which the death that may result seems for the moment almost preferable to the unending bodily fatigue and mental strain. But when Odysseus sees for himself what it means to be dead, he loses any illusions he may have had that death is better than a life of unbroken tension and hardship. Homer’s world of the dead is dark and comfortless; it is no place of rest and oblivion. The shades crowd round the sacrificed animals, yearning for a draft of the blood that will for a moment bring them back to life, restore memory and the power of speech. Achilles reads the lesson to Odysseus, who had congratulated him on reigning like a king over the dead:

“No winning words about death to me, shining Odysseus!

By god, I’d rather slave on earth for another man—

some dirt-poor tenant farmer who scrapes to keep alive—

than rule down here over all the breathless dead.”

(ref)

The land of the dead has been hospitable, but perhaps Odysseus has overstayed his welcome, for as he waits to see still more shades of famous heroes,

“… the dead came surging round me,

hordes of them, thousands raising unearthly cries,

and blanching terror gripped me…”

(ref)

He heads for his ship and returns to Circe, who proceeds to plot them “a course and chart each seamark” (ref) for their voyage home.

They have yet to face the Sirens, make a choice between Scylla and Charybdis, and land, against Circe’s advice and Odysseus’ opposition, on Thrinacia, the island where the crew will slaughter the cattle of the Sun and so seal their own fate. The Sirens are another temptation for Odysseus, perhaps the most powerful of all, for if he had not been bound to the mast, he would have gone to join the heaps of corpses that surround them. “Come closer, famous Odysseus,” they sing. “We know all the pains that the Greeks and Trojans once endured / on the spreading plain of Troy” (ref). Odysseus is a veteran of a ten-year war; he is on his way back to a society in which a new generation has grown up in peace. There will be no one to understand him if he talks about the war— it is significant that once home and recognized, he does not mention it to Telemachus or Penelope. Only those who shared its excitement and horrors with him can talk about it. That is perhaps why Menelaus says he would have given Odysseus an estate in his own lands if he had come home: “how often,” he says, “we’d have mingled side-by-side! / Nothing could have parted us” (ref). The bonds forged by fellowship in dangerous action and suffering are very strong. And that is the strength of the Sirens’ appeal: “we know all the pains that Achaeans and Trojans once endured / on the spreading plain of Troy.” He orders his sailors to untie him, let him go. But of course the Sirens’ song is an invitation to live in the past, and that is a kind of death; the Sirens’ island is piled with the bones of dead men. It was in the land of the dead that he could relive the saga of Troy, with his fellow-veterans Achilles and Agamemnon. Those days are over, and he must look forward to the future, not backward to the past.

The choice between Scylla and Charybdis is still to be made, but Odysseus will have to face both—Scylla as a ship’s captain on his way to Thrinacia, and Charybdis as a lone shipwrecked sailor clinging to a piece of wreckage on the way back. Rescued by the goddess Calypso (whose name is formed from the Greek word that means “cover,” “hide”), Odysseus spends seven years a virtual prisoner on her island, “unwilling lover alongside lover all too willing” (ref). He rejects her offer to make him immortal and ageless, her husband forever. Ordered by Hermes to let him go, she reminds him of the offer and foretells the trials and tribulations that still await him on the voyage home:

“… if you only knew, down deep, what pains

are fated to fill your cup before you reach that shore,

you’d stay right here, preside in our house with me

and be immortal.”

(ref)

But he refuses.

Calypso’s offer and Odysseus’ refusal are an exchange unique in Greek literature and mythology. Immortality was a divine prerogative, grudgingly conferred. Heracles had to die a fiery, agonizing death to win it, and when the Dawn goddess obtained it for her mortal lover Tithonus, she forgot to ask also that he should never grow old. Now as she sets out on her route every morning, she leaves him behind in bed, where he lies inert, shriveled with age. But Calypso has offered to make Odysseus “immortal, ageless, all his days” (ref) and invited him to live with her in a paradisal environment so enchanting that

… even a deathless god

who came upon that place would gaze in wonder,

heart entranced with pleasure

(ref)

—a place before which Hermes, messenger of Zeus, “stood… spellbound” (ref). All this Odysseus rejects, though he knows that the alternative is to entrust himself again, this time alone and on a makeshift craft, to that sea about which he has no illusions. “And if a god will wreck me yet again on the wine-dark sea,” he says,

“Much have I suffered, labored long and hard by now

in the waves and wars. Add this to the total—

bring the trial on!”

(ref)

One more offer to forget his home and his identity is made and refused before he reaches Ithaca. In the land of the Phaeacians, where he is welcomed and honored, he is offered the hand in marriage of a young and charming princess and a life of ease and enjoyment in a utopian society. The offer is made not only by the king her father—

“… if only—

seeing the man you are, seeing we think as one—

you could wed my daughter and be my son-in-law

and stay right here with us”

(ref)

—but also, earlier, by the girl herself, in the subtle hints contained in her instructions to him about his approach to the city. She makes a final appeal to him as he goes to the banquet hall for the feast at which he will later identify himself and tell his story. She reminds him how much he owes her:

“Farewell, my friend! And when you are at home,

home in your own land, remember me at times.

Mainly to me you owe the gift of life.”

(ref)

This is not quite the resigned farewell it sounds like. The word she uses for what Odysseus owes her—zôagria—is an Iliadic word: “the price of a life.” Hephaestus uses it when Thetis comes to ask him to make new armor for Achilles; he will do anything for her, since she saved his life once—he owes her zôagria. Three times in the Iliad, Trojan warriors, disarmed and at the mercy of the victor, use the verb from which this noun is formed to offer rich ransom in exchange for their lives. Nausicaa is pressing Odysseus hard, with a word he fully understands; he had heard his captive Dolon use it to him in an appeal for his life, which was refused (Iliad 10.442–43). But now, reminded of how much he owes her, he tactfully evades the issue by taking her request literally; when he reaches home, he will pray to her as a deathless goddess all his days.

Loaded with treasure greater than all he had won at Troy and lost at sea, Odysseus, in a deep sleep, is transported in the magical Phaeacian ship to the real world and landed, still asleep, on the shore of Ithaca. When he wakes up, he does not recognize his own country, for Athena has cloaked the shore in a mist. Afraid that the Phaeacians have betrayed him, he repeats the agonized questions he has asked himself on so many strange shores—

“… whose land have I lit on now?

What are they here—violent, savage, lawless?—

or friendly to strangers, god-fearing men?”

(ref)

He has in fact reached the most dangerous of all his landfalls. To survive this last trial, he will have to call on all the qualities that mark him as a hero—the courage and martial skill of the warrior he was at Troy, but also the caution, cunning, duplicity and patience that have brought him safe to Ithaca.

HERO

“I
hate that man like the very Gates of Death / who says one thing but hides another in his heart.” These are the words of Achilles, the hero of the Iliad (9.378–79), the chevalier sans peur et sans reproche of the Greek aristocratic tradition. He addressed them to Odysseus, who had come as leader of a delegation charged by Agamemnon and the Achaean chieftains to persuade Achilles to rejoin them in the attack on Troy. These are strange words with which to open an answer to what seems like a generous offer of compensation for harsh words uttered in anger, but Achilles knows his man. Odysseus has told no lie, but he has concealed the truth. He has repeated verbatim the bulk of Agamemnon’s message—the long list of splendid gifts, the offer of the hand of a daughter in marriage—but he has suppressed Agamemnon’s reiterated claim to superiority, his relegation of Achilles to inferior rank. “Let him bow down to me! I am the greater king, /… the greater man” (9.192–93).

For Achilles a lie is something utterly abhorrent. But for Odysseus it is second nature, a point of pride. “I am Odysseus,” he tells the Phaeacians when the time comes to reveal his identity, “known to the world / for every kind of craft” (ref). The Greek word here translated “craft” is dolos. It is a word that can be used in praise as well as abuse. Athena uses the word when, in the guise of a handsome young shepherd, she compliments Odysseus on the complicated lie he has just told her about his identity and his past, and it is with this word that Odysseus describes the wooden horse he contrived to bring Troy down in flames. On the other hand, Athena, Menelaus and Odysseus use it of the trap Clytemnestra set for Agamemnon when he returned home, and it serves Homer as a description of the suitors’ plan to ambush and kill Telemachus on his way back from Pylos. But whether complimentary or accusing, it always implies the presence of what Achilles so vehemently rejects—the intention to deceive.

Odysseus has the talent necessary for the deceiver: he is a persuasive speaker. In the Iliad the Trojan prince Antenor, who had listened to Odysseus when he came with an embassy to Troy, remembered the contrast between his unimpressive appearance and the powerful magic of his speech. “When he let loose that great voice from his chest /… then no man alive could rival Odysseus!” (3.266–68). And in the Odyssey, in the palace of Alcinous, he holds his host spellbound with the story of his adventures. When he breaks off, pleading the lateness of the hour, Alcinous begs him to go on: “what grace you give your words, and what good sense within! / You have told your story with all a singer’s skill” (ref). In his travels on the way to Phaeacia, Odysseus has not had much occasion to give rein to his eloquent persuasion; his skill in deception will be needed and fully revealed only when at last he reaches the shore of Ithaca, where in order to survive he has to play the role of a penniless, ragged beggar. The tales he tells, to Athena, Eumaeus, Antinous, Penelope and Laertes are brilliant fictions, tales of war, piracy, murder, blood-feuds and peril on the high seas, with a cast of rogue Phoenician captains, Cretan adventurers and Egyptian Pharaohs. They are, as Homer says, “lies like truth,” thoroughly convincing, true, unlike the tale he told in Phaeacia, to the realities of life and death in the Aegean world, but nonetheless lies from beginning to end. And Homer reminds us of the contrast between Odysseus and Achilles by making Odysseus, just before he launches out on a splendidly mendacious account of his background and misfortunes, repeat the famous words Achilles addressed to him at Troy. “I hate that man like the very Gates of Death who /… stoops to peddling lies” (ref).

The repetition of that memorable phrase makes the contrast between the two heroes explicit, but Odysseus is still, as he was in the Iliad, a warrior faithful to the martial ideal. He will gladly employ deceit to win victory, but if necessary he will confront mortal danger alone and unafraid. On Circe’s island, when Eurylochus returns to report the disappearance of his companions inside the witch’s palace and implores Odysseus not to go to their rescue but to set sail at once, he is met with a scornful refusal:

“Eurylochus, stay right here,

eating, drinking, safe by the black ship.

I must be off. Necessity drives me on.”

(ref)

This necessity is his fidelity to that reputation, that fame among men, for which Achilles accepted an early death. This is the Odysseus of the Iliad, who, finding himself alone and outnumbered in a desperate struggle with the Trojans, rules out the thought of flight:

“Cowards, I know, would quit the fighting now

but the man who wants to make his mark in war

must stand his ground…”

(11.483–85)

Odysseus shares with Achilles another characteristic of the heroic mentality: a prickly sensitivity to what he regards as a lack of respect on the part of others, an irrepressible rage against any insult to his standing as a hero. This was the motive of his near-fatal insistence on revealing his real name to Polyphemus: he could not bear the thought that the blinded giant would never know the identity or the fame of his conqueror. More cautious among the Phaeacians, he carefully remains anonymous but comes close to revealing the truth when, scorned by a young Phaeacian for his lack of athletic prowess, he hurls the discus a prodigious distance and then challenges them all—at boxing, wrestling, racing and archery. “Well I know,” he tells them,

“how to handle a fine polished bow…

Philoctetes alone outshot me there at Troy

when ranks of Achaean archers bent their bows.”

(ref)

The most painful insult to his honor is of course the conduct of the suitors; their three-year-long occupation of his house is an intolerable affront, compounded by their brutal treatment of him as he plays the role of Nobody once again. And their sublime confidence that even if he did return he would meet a humiliating death fighting against their superior numbers stirs in him an Achillean wrath. When he finally kills Antinous, the most violent of the suitors, and identifies himself at last—“You dogs! you never imagined I’d return from Troy” (ref)— Eurymachus, the most deceitful of the suitors, offers full compensation and more for the damage they have done. Odysseus fiercely rejects it:

“No, Eurymachus! Not if you paid me all your father’s wealth—

all you possess now, and all that could pour in from the world’s end—

no, not even then would I stay my hands from slaughter

till all you suitors had paid for all your crimes!”

(ref)

We have heard this note sounded before, in the voice of Achilles in the Iliad rejecting Agamemnon’s peace offering:

“Not if he gave me ten times as much, twenty times over, all

he possesses now, and all that could pour in from the world’s end—

… no, not even then could Agamemnon

bring my fighting spirit round until he pays me back,

pays full measure for all his heartbreaking outrage!”

(9.464–73)

In the event, Achilles exacts full measure not from Agamemnon but from Hector, who has killed his friend Patroclus and now wears Achilles’ armor. One after another he cuts down Trojan warriors, drives them into the river to drown or die under his merciless sword, until he meets and kills Hector, whose corpse he drags back to his camp, to lie there unburied while he sacrifices captured Trojans to appease the spirit of Patroclus dead. Odysseus’ vindication of his honor is no less bloody and merciless. Backed by his son and two loyal servants, he kills all the one hundred and eight young aristocrats who have besieged his wife; his servants savagely mutilate and kill the faithless shepherd Melanthius, who had insulted Odysseus; and Telemachus, ordered to dispatch the disloyal maids with his sword, chooses to deny them this “clean death” (ref) and hangs them. All scores are paid. With interest.

Achilles’ revenge ends with a compassionate gesture, the return of Hector’s body to his father, Priam, but at the end of the Odyssey more blood is spilled. Eupithes, Antinous’ father, leads the suitors’ relatives against Odysseus and his men, but is killed by Laertes when the battle is joined. “They would have killed them all,” says Homer (ref), if Athena had not ordered Odysseus back and allowed the Ithacans to run for their lives. The description of the final battle is phrased throughout in Iliadic phrase and formula, and as Odysseus encourages his son and receives assurance that Telemachus will not disgrace his lineage, old Laertes sounds the authentic heroic note: “What a day for me, dear gods! What joy— / my son and my grandson vying over courage!” (ref).

This aspect of the Odyssey has often been overlooked or underemphasized. Much, perhaps too much, has been made of Achilles’ bitter rejection of Odysseus’ attempt to comfort him in the world of the dead: “I’d rather slave on earth for another man— /… than rule down here over all the breathless dead” (ref). His words have been interpreted as a rejection of the heroic code of which in the Iliad he was the great exemplar. But it is not so much a rejection of the everlasting glory for which he consciously and deliberately traded his life as it is an angry reproach to Odysseus for contrasting his own “endless trouble” (ref) with Achilles’ great power among the dead. Achilles knew what he was giving up when he chose an early death with glory over long life, and it is understandable that Odysseus’ specious words of comfort should provoke an angry response. In any case, he goes on to ask for news of his son Neoptolemus: “Did he make his way to the wars, / did the boy become a champion—yes or no?” (ref). When Achilles hears Odysseus’ answer—“scores of men he killed in bloody combat. / How could I list them all…?” (ref)—and hears the tale of his aggressive courage in the wooden horse and his safe return home, Achilles goes off

“loping with long strides across the fields of asphodel,

triumphant in all I had told him of his son,

his gallant, glorious son.”

(ref)

GODS

U
nlike the Iliad, the Odyssey is an epic with a thoroughly domestic base. Except in the wanderings—and sometimes even there—we are down to earth, whether in the full and frequent meals in the palace (Fielding called the Odyssey the “eatingest epic”) or in the rural domesticity of Eumaeus’ hut. Yet the poem is firmly set in what might be called “heroic time,” a time when men were stronger, braver and more eloquent than they are now, women more beautiful, powerful and intelligent than they have been ever since, and gods so close to human life and so involved with individual human beings, in affection or in anger, that they intervened in their lives and even appeared to them in person. The inclination of modern critics to emphasize the unique aspect of Odyssean heroism at the expense and often to the exclusion of the recognizably Achillean aspects of the heroic vengeance that concludes the epic is paralleled by a tendency to find new developments on Olympus, in the nature and action of the gods, especially of Zeus. What has happened—according to Alfred Heubeck in his thoughtful and valuable introduction to the Oxford Commentary on the Odyssey—is nothing less than an “ethical transformation”: “With perceptiveness and wisdom Zeus now directs the fate of the world according to moral principles, which alone create and preserve order. The father of the gods has only a little way to go to become the just ruler of the world” (I, p. 23).

Quite apart from the fact that it may be doubted whether Zeus ever went that little way (even in the Oresteia his justice is problematic), it is hard to find in the Odyssey evidence for this ethical transformation. In the meeting on Olympus with which the poem opens, Zeus discusses the case of Aegisthus, who, disregarding a warning delivered by Hermes, has seduced Clytemnestra and, with her help, murdered Agamemnon. “Ah how shameless,” says Zeus,

“the way these mortals blame the gods.

From us alone, they say, come all their miseries, yes,

but they themselves, with their own reckless ways,

compound their pains beyond their proper share.”

(ref)

There is, as Heubeck himself points out, “nothing new in this moralizing.” Zeus admits that much of humanity’s suffering is the responsibility of the gods; what he is complaining about is that they compound it by reckless initiatives of their own.

This council on Olympus presents us with a situation all too familiar from the Iliad: gods bitterly opposed to each other over the fate of mortals. In the Iliad Hera and Athena are ferociously bent on Troy’s destruction because of an insult to their pride and preeminence—the Judgment of Paris, the Trojan prince, which awarded the prize for beauty to Aphrodite. Poseidon, brother of Zeus, is equally intent on Troy’s destruction, because the Trojan king Laomedon cheated him of payment for building the walls of Troy. Apollo, whose temple stands on the citadel of Troy, is the city’s champion, and Zeus, the supreme arbiter, is partial to Troy because of the devotion of its inhabitants to his worship. The fate of the city and its women and children, as well as the lives and deaths of the warriors on both sides, are determined by the give-and-take of these divine wills in opposition, by the pattern of alliance, conflict, deceit and compromise that form their relationships.

The conflicts rarely take violent shape; on the few occasions when they do, the divine opponents are not equally matched. Athena fights Ares and Aphrodite, and easily defeats both, while Hera spanks Artemis as if she were a little girl. But among the major powers—Zeus, Hera, Athena, Poseidon, Apollo—the struggle takes different forms: retreat, deceit, compromise. When, in the climactic battles that lead up to the death of Hector, Apollo is challenged to fight by Poseidon, he declines:

“God of the earthquake—you’d think me hardly sane

if I fought with you for the sake of wretched mortals…

like leaves, no sooner flourishing, full of the sun’s fire,

feeding on earth’s gifts, than they waste away and die.”

(21.527–30)

Gods may favor a hero or a city, but if that favor threatens to create a rupture between major powers, one of them may withdraw. Or they may bargain, as Zeus does with Hera when he reluctantly consents to let Troy fall. He consents, but with a proviso:

“One more thing…

Whenever I am bent on tearing down some city

filled with men you love—to please myself—

never attempt to thwart my fury…”

(4.46–49)

And Hera accepts; in fact, she offers him three cities instead of one:

“… The three cities that I love best of all

are Argos and Sparta, Mycenae with streets as broad as Troy’s.

Raze them… I will never rise in their defense…”

(4.60–63)

Gods may also get their way by deceit, as Hera does when she seduces Zeus and puts him to sleep so that she and Poseidon can rally the Achaeans against Hector’s assault.

All three of these modes of Olympian diplomacy reappear in the Odyssey. Odysseus, by blinding Polyphemus, Poseidon’s son, has incurred the vengeful wrath of the god who rules the waves. When the hero meets Athena on the shore of Ithaca he asks her rather brusquely why she had abandoned him during the course of his wanderings:

“… I never saw you,

never glimpsed you striding along my decks

to ward off some disaster.”

(ref)

Her reply, short, obviously embarrassed, and sandwiched between fulsome compliments and the lifting of the mist to show Odysseus that he really is home, is an avowal of concession made to superior force. “I could not bring myself,” she says, “to fight my Father’s brother, / Poseidon” (ref). And even this apology is evasive: she makes no attempt to explain why she did not help Odysseus before he incurred Poseidon’s wrath. Not until she secures the agreement of Zeus does she take the steps that lead to Odysseus’ return home. She proposes to Zeus that Odysseus be released from his seven-year confinement on Calypso’s island, and she does this at a meeting on Olympus from which Poseidon is absent; he is far away, at the ends of the earth, enjoying the homage of the Ethiopians. Poseidon is, in effect, deceived; when he returns and sees Odysseus on his raft approaching the Phaeacian shore he is furious. “Outrageous! Look how the gods have changed their minds / about Odysseus—while I was off with my Ethiopians” (ref). Athena would not challenge him openly; she acts behind his back.

Poseidon knows that once Odysseus reaches Phaeacia he is “fated to escape his noose of pain” (ref), and in the event, the Phaeacians send him home on a supernaturally fast ship, loaded down with treasure greater than all he had acquired at Troy and lost at sea. Poseidon’s power has been defied, his honor slighted, and someone must pay. Odysseus is now beyond his reach, but the Phaeacians are another matter. “I will lose all my honor now / among the immortals,” he complains to Zeus,

“now there are mortal men

who show me no respect—Phaeacians, too,

born of my own loins!”

(ref)

Zeus assures him that there is no loss of respect for him on Olympus, and as for mortal men—

“If any man, so lost in his strength

and prowess, pays you no respect—just pay him back…

Do what you like. Whatever warms your heart.”

(ref)

Poseidon explains his purpose: to sink the Phaeacian ship that took Odysseus home as it sails into the harbor and to “pile a huge mountain round about their port” so that “They will learn at last / to cease and desist from escorting every man alive” (ref). Zeus approves, and suggests a refinement: to change the ship and, incidentally, its crew of fifty-two young men—“the best in town” (ref)—into a rock as the Phaeacians watch it approach the harbor. Poseidon swiftly does so, and at that sight King Alcinous recognizes the fulfillment of a prophecy, which also predicted that the city would be surrounded by a great mountain. He leads his people in sacrifice and prayer to Poseidon, hoping for mercy and promising that the Phaeacians will never again give sea passage to men who come to their city.

This is the end of the great Phaeacian tradition of hospitality and help for the stranger and wayfarer. This action of Zeus casts a disturbing light on the relation between human ideals and divine conduct. If there is one stable moral criterion in the world of the Odyssey, it is the care taken by the powerful and well-to-do of strangers, wanderers and beggars. This code of hospitality is the one universally recognized morality. And its divine enforcer, so all mortals believe, is Zeus himself, Zeus xeinios, protector of stranger and suppliant. His name and title are invoked time after time, by Odysseus and also by Nausicaa, Echeneus the Phaeacian elder, Alcinous and Eumaeus.

Of all the many hosts measured by this moral standard, the Phaeacians stand out as the most generous, not only in their regal entertainment of Odysseus but also in their speedy conveyance of the hero to his own home, a service they provide for all wayfarers who reach their shore. And now they are punished by the gods for precisely this reason, since their magnanimity has made Poseidon feel that his honor—the touchy sensitivity to public opinion that in Achilles brought ten thousand woes on the Achaeans, and drove Ajax to suicide and fueled his sullenness in the underworld—has been dealt an intolerable blow. The offenders must be punished, even if their punishment displays utter indifference to the only code of moral conduct that obtains in the insecure world of the Odyssey. Faced with Poseidon’s rage against the Phaeacians, Zeus the protector of strangers enthusiastically joins his powerful brother in his denunciation. Not only does he suggest the refinement of turning the ship to stone; he also approves of Poseidon’s intention to cut the Phaeacians off from the sea forever by piling a huge mountain around the city.

This has shocked some modern translators and editors, who have accordingly followed the lead of the ancient editor Aristophanes of Byzantium. By changing three letters in the Greek, he made Zeus end his speech with the words “but do not pile a mountain round the city.” The suggested petrification of the ship is a sop to gratify Poseidon and compensate him for a concession—the Phaeacians will not be cut off from the sea. Zeus xeinios lives up to his title; he is a Zeus who has undergone an ethical transformation.

We have no record of the reasons Aristophanes gave for his reading; though they must have been spelled out in his commentaries on the poem, our manuscript tradition preserves only the fact that he proposed it. But it does give us one more important piece of information. “Aristarchus,” we are told in the same note that recorded Aristophanes’ emendation, “argues against him in his dissertations.” Aristarchus was the pupil of Aristophanes and was regarded as the most critical and correct of the Alexandrian editors—readers of Pope’s Dunciad will remember that his target Richard Bentley was portrayed as “that awful Aristarch.” So the suggestion was already contested in antiquity by Homer’s most respected editor. And though we are told nothing about Aristophanes’ reasons for suggesting the change, we may guess at them by comparing other examples of his textual criticism. He was much concerned, for example, with decorum and suspected the authenticity of lines in which royal characters fell below the level of etiquette maintained at the court of the Ptolemies. In Book 6, where Homer has Nausicaa bring her washing out of the house—“the princess brought her finery from the room / and piled it into the wagon’s polished cradle” (ref)—Aristophanes, with a slight alteration, produced: “Meanwhile the maids brought the finery from the room…” Princesses do not carry their own laundry.

He shows a similar concern for propriety when dealing with the conduct of the gods. In Book 11, when Odysseus sees the shade of Ariadne, he identifies her as

“daughter of Minos, that harsh king. One day Theseus tried

to spirit her off from Crete to Athens’ sacred heights,

but he got no joy from her. Artemis killed her first

on wave-washed Dia’s shores…”

(ref)

For ekta, “killed,” Aristophanes adopted eschen, “detained,” thus unburdening Artemis of a killing for which no reason is given. So in that dialogue between Zeus and Poseidon, by introducing a negative, Aristophanes made Zeus, the greater god, more merciful than Poseidon.

But there is no warrant for this alteration. There is indeed a very good reason—quite apart from the fact that Aristophanes’ motive is obvious—to reject it out of hand. If Homer’s Zeus had really urged such a radical revision of Poseidon’s plan, some sort of reply on Poseidon’s part—acceptance, rejection or at least acknowledgment—would be indispensable. But he says not a word. Furthermore, if the Phaeacian city was never to be cut off by a mountain, we are left with something unprecedented in Homer, an unfulfilled prophecy—Alcinous twice mentions the prophecy of his father that one day Poseidon would ring their city with a mountain. Homer does not tell us what happened: when we see the Phaeacians for the last time, they are about to engage in sacrifice and prayer to Poseidon, hoping that he will spare them. But one thing is clear: they are done with generous hospitality and conveying strangers to their destinations. A god has forced this decision; his vindictive punishment has been fully approved by Zeus. Zeus may sometimes act as the protector of suppliants, beggars and wanderers, but human concerns and conceptions of justice fade into insignificance when the maintenance of a powerful god’s prestige is the issue. Odysseus meanwhile, left asleep on the Ithacan shore with all his treasure laid out beside him, wakes to find a landscape he does not recognize—Athena has covered it in mist. He jumps to the conclusion that the Phaeacian crew has dumped him on some foreign shore. “They never kept their word,” he cries,

“Zeus of the Suppliants

pay them back—he keeps an eye on the world of men

and punishes all transgressors!”

(ref)

He does not realize it, but Zeus of the suppliants has already paid them back. Not for breaking their word, but for keeping it.

Poseidon and Zeus are not the only Olympians to display indifference to human codes of conduct and sense of justice. Later in the poem Athena joins them. There is among the suitors one decent man, Amphinomus, who “pleased Penelope the most, / thanks to his timely words and good clear sense” (ref). It is he who persuades the suitors to reject Antinous’ proposal to waylay and murder Telemachus on Ithaca, now that he has evaded the ship waiting for him in ambush and returned safe home. And it is Amphinomus who, after Odysseus’ victory over Irus in the boxing match, drinks his health in a golden cup and says,

“Cheers, old friend, old father,

saddled now as you are with so much trouble—

here’s to your luck, great days from this day on!”

(ref)

Odysseus tries to save him from the imminent slaughter. He warns him solemnly that Odysseus will soon return, is now very near home, and that blood will be shed. This is dangerous ground. He calls Amphinomus by name; how could this ragged beggar who has just arrived know it? He goes even further. “You seem like a man of good sense to me,” he tells him. “Just like your father.” It is a slip he tries to cover at once, adding quickly, “at least I’ve heard his praises” (ref). Homer has made it clear what a great risk Odysseus is running in his attempt to save Amphinomus’ life, and he emphasizes his sincerity by having him pray for divine intervention on the suitor’s behalf:

“… may some power save you,

spirit you home before you meet him face-to-face

the moment he returns to native ground!”

(ref)

Far from spiriting him home, a divine power has already passed sentence on him: “Even then Athena had bound him fast to death / at the hands of Prince Telemachus and his spear” (ref). Amphinomus is the third of the suitors to die, immediately after the two principal villains, Antinous and Eurymachus.

When they are not deciding the fate of mortals, the gods live a life of their own, on Olympus, where, they say,

… the gods’ eternal mansion stands unmoved,

never rocked by galewinds, never drenched by rains,

nor do the drifting snows assail it, no, the clear air

stretches away without a cloud, and a great radiance

plays across that world where the blithe gods

live all their days in bliss.

(ref)

We are given a sample of their life of pleasure in one of the tales told by the minstrel Demodocus in the great hall of the Phaeacian palace—the entrapment of the adulterous pair Ares and Aphrodite in the golden net fashioned by the wronged husband Hephaestus, and their exposure to the prurient gaze and “uncontrollable laughter” (ref) of the gods whom Hephaestus has summoned to witness his wife’s perfidy. (The goddesses, we are told, stayed modestly at home.) Hephaestus himself, when he summons the gods, refers to the spectacle he offers them as “a sight to make you laugh” (ref), and the comic aspect of the tale is made plain when Apollo asks Hermes if he would like to change places with Ares and receives the reply:

“Oh Apollo, if only!…

… bind me down with triple those endless chains!

Let all you gods look on, and all you goddesses too—

how I’d love to bed that golden Aphrodite!”

(ref)

This glimpse of the private lives of the Olympians has a parallel in the Iliad: the episode (14.187–421) in which Hera, armed with all the charms and magic of Aphrodite, seduces Zeus, who is watching the battle from a mountaintop, so that she can put him to sleep and then, with Poseidon, rally the Achaean fighters against Hector’s victorious assault. Zeus is overcome with desire for his wife; his lust, he tells her, is greater than anything he has felt in his mating with mortal women, whom he proceeds to list in a long speech that has been aptly named the “Leporello catalogue,” after the famous aria in Mozart’s Don Giovanni.

In both epics the gods enjoy their pleasures and pursue their intrigues on Olympus, while on earth they decide the fate of mortals and their cities with scant regard for human conceptions of divine justice, whenever what is at stake is the interest or prestige of a major god. Human beings may indeed, like the suitors and Odysseus’ crew, bring disaster on themselves “beyond their proper share” (ref), but disaster may still come to those who, like the Phaeacians and Amphinomus, are by human standards admirable, and in each case it is a god who serves them their “proper share.”

WOMEN AND MEN

T
he two Homeric epics are alike in their vision of the Olympian gods and their affirmation of the heroic code, but there is one striking difference between them. The Iliad celebrates the action and suffering of men at war; it is only in the poem’s similes and on the shield of Achilles that we are given occasional glimpses of a world at peace. The few women who make an appearance—Briseis, Andromache, Hecuba, Helen—are secondary figures, who play no significant part in the main action. But the Odyssey, though its climax is a scene of furious combat and mass slaughter, presents us with a world at peace: a secure and settled peace at Pylos and Sparta, a troubled and threatened peace on Ithaca, and, in the dangers and temptations of Odysseus’ voyage, intervals of peace— temptingly restful with Circe, oppressive with Calypso, and beneficent on Scheria. And almost everywhere in this peaceful world, women, human and divine, have important roles.

In Odysseus’ wanderings they help, tempt or delay him. Calypso offers him immortality and keeps him for seven years but sends a favoring wind when he departs; Circe tries to keep him forever in her pigpen, does keep him for a year as her lover, but finally helps him on his way; the Sirens are his most dangerous temptation, but the sea-nymph Ino helps him land on Scheria, where Arete and Nausicaa smooth his path. There are female presences even among the monsters he has to face: Scylla, Charybdis and the gigantic wife—“huge as a mountain crag” (ref)—of the Laestrygonian cannibal king. On the Egyptian island of Pharos, Menelaus is rescued by the minor goddess Eidothea, daughter of the Old Man of the Sea, and at Sparta, Helen gives a dazzling performance. On Ithaca, Penelope, enigmatic to the last, is the object of the suitors’ desires and her son’s suspicions, and it is she who precipitates the final crisis by offering to marry whichever of the suitors can string the bow of Odysseus and shoot an arrow through the axes. Eurycleia too is never far from the limelight and gets full exposure when she washes her master’s feet and recognizes the scar he carries on his thigh. Meanwhile the goddess Athena encourages and supports Telemachus on his journey, and from Scheria onward she is Odysseus’ helper and then fellow-conspirator in deceit and ally in battle. Besides these principal players there is a plentiful cast of female extras: the Sicilian woman who looks after old Laertes; the Phoenician nursemaid who kidnaps the young prince Eumaeus to sell him as a slave; Eurynome, Penelope’s housekeeper; Melantho, the disloyal maid, lover of Antinous; Iphthime, Penelope’s sister, who appears to her in a dream; and the long list of famous women Odysseus sees among the dead—Tyro, Antiope, Alcmena, Epicaste, Chloris, Leda, Iphimedeia, Phaedra, Procris, Eriphyle. It is a vision that has echoed down the centuries, that lies behind Propertius’ magical line sunt apud infernos tot milia formosarum—“so many thousands of lovely women among the dead”—and Campion’s “shades of underground… White Iope, blithe Helen, and the rest.”

Only when the Odyssey turns Iliadic, as Odysseus and his son and two loyal servants face the suitors in the hall, are women offstage, and even there Athena is at hand, sustaining the morale of the hero and his party, diverting the suitors’ spears from the target. Elsewhere in the poem women’s voices are heard at frequent intervals and sometimes at length. Hostile critics might well be tempted to cite the defense of his tragedies Aristophanes put in the mouth of “Euripides” in the Frogs: “They all stepped up to speak their piece, the mistress spoke, the slave spoke too, / the master spoke, the daughter spoke, and grandma spoke.” In the Iliad, scenes that present men in contact with women, though memorable, are rare—Helen and Paris, Hector and Andromache, Hecuba and Priam—but in the Odyssey, the rare exception is the scene from which women are excluded—the battle in the hall, the Cyclops in the cave. What historical reality, if any, lies behind this imagined world, so far removed from the peasant misogyny of Hesiod’s near-contemporary Works and Days, we shall never know; perhaps it reflects an aristocratic Ionian culture like that which, a century later, saw the birth of Sappho on Lesbos.

The Odyssey owes much of its power to enchant so many generations of readers to its elegant exploitation of something that war temporarily suppresses or corrupts—the infinite variety of the emotional traffic between male and female. In his treatment of these relationships Homer displays an understanding of human psychology that many critics, especially those who believe in multiple authorship, but even some of those who accept a sole author yet deny him literacy, have been reluctant to recognize. A case in point is the first encounter between human beings of the opposite sex in the poem, the exchange between Telemachus and Penelope in Book 1. She has just told the bard Phemius, who is entertaining the suitors with a song about the return of the Achaeans from Troy, to change his tune, since this one pains her to the heart. Telemachus intervenes, to remind her that Phemius is not to blame for her sorrow; it is Zeus who allots to mortals whatever destiny he pleases. But he concludes with some words that have rightly been characterized as “harsh”:

“… mother,

go back to your quarters. Tend to your own tasks,

the distaff and the loom, and keep the women

working hard as well. As for giving orders,

men will see to that…”

(ref)

These same words, with “bow” replacing “giving orders” (muthos), recur much later in the poem, in Book 21 (389–93), where Penelope insists, in opposition to Antinous, that Eumaeus should give the bow to Odysseus; and of course they are an echo of Hector’s words to Andromache in their last interview in the Iliad—“As for the fighting, / men will see to that” (6.587–88). In Book 21 Telemachus’ words are obviously essential, for Penelope has to be removed from the hall before the fighting starts, as it will do as soon as Odysseus strings the bow. But critics have thought them out of place in Book 1; in fact, Aristarchus condemned them as an interpolation. Some modern translators (Fitzgerald, for example) have omitted them, and a recent commentator has expressed uneasiness about Telemachus’ “callousness” and “adolescent rudeness.” The lines have often been defended as the first manifestation of the new fighting spirit that Athena’s visit has instilled in Telemachus, and though this is true, the fact is that his harshness here is consistent with the tone of nearly all the other remarks Telemachus addresses to his mother throughout the poem and of much of what he says about her to other people.

His first reference to her is, at the very least, ambiguous. Asked by Athena if he is the son of Odysseus, he replies: “Mother has always told me I’m his son, it’s true, / but I am not so certain” (ref). Commentators have tried to explain his remark away as “curious but perhaps conventional” and “an idea that must already have been a commonplace,” but they produce little or no evidence for such a case. Telemachus is not, of course, suggesting that his mother is an adulteress but merely expressing a doubt that he is a worthy son of his great father. But he could have done so without mentioning his mother; there is a resentful tone in his voice, which sounds again when he describes for Athena the situation he faces in Ithaca:

“she neither rejects a marriage she despises

nor can she bear to bring the courting to an end—

while they continue to bleed my household white.”

(ref)

Telemachus has grown to manhood without the correction and support of a father, an absence poignantly evoked in the words he addresses to Athena when, in the person of Mentes, she urges him to call an assembly, defy the suitors and take ship in search of news of his father. “You’ve counseled me with so much kindness now, / like a father to a son” (ref). He has been raised by women, Eurycleia and Penelope, and it was almost inevitable that his normal adolescent rebellion would be against his mother. The first result of Athena’s move to rouse Odysseus’ son “to a braver pitch, inspire his heart with courage” (ref) is this stern dismissal of his mother as he asserts his mastery in the house. Penelope has given orders to Phemius: to “break off this song” (ref) and choose some other theme. “As for giving orders” (muthos), says Telemachus, “men will see to that.” And as soon as she leaves, he announces that he will call an assembly where he will give his “orders” (muthos) to the suitors: “You must leave my palace! See to your feasting elsewhere” (ref).

Much later, at Sparta, Athena comes to hasten his return to Ithaca; she does so by suggesting that Penelope may decide to marry, and take some treasure with her:

“You know how the heart of a woman always works:

she likes to build the wealth of her new groom—

of the sons she bore, of her dear, departed husband,

not a memory of the dead, no questions asked.”

(ref)

Athena is not a dream, for Telemachus is awake; she is not in disguise, as she was on Ithaca. But Telemachus makes no reply to the goddess, no acknowledgment of her presence—it is as if he had never seen or heard her. This unusual treatment of a divine epiphany may have been Homer’s attempt to suggest that Athena was only enhancing in Telemachus’ mind the fears and suspicions that were already there. He had, as Homer tells us, been sleepless all night, “tossing with anxious thoughts about his father” (ref). And when he gets back to Ithaca the first thing he says to Eumaeus shows how deeply rooted are his suspicions of his mother’s intentions. “I’ve come,” he says,

“… [to] learn the news—

whether mother still holds out in the halls

or some other man has married her at last,

and Odysseus’ bed, I suppose, is lying empty,

blanketed now with filthy cobwebs.”

(ref)

At his meeting with Penelope, who weeps as she speaks of her fears that he would never return alive—she knew about the ship the suitors had sent out to waylay him—he is brusquely ungracious; he does not even answer her questions about news of Odysseus but tells her not to stir up his emotions and sends her off to her room to bathe and pray; he has business to attend to, men’s business. She has to ask him later, and hesitantly, before he tells her what he learned at Sparta about her husband.

But she is not always so submissive. When she comes into the great hall after Odysseus has won his fight with Irus, she rebukes her son for exposing a stranger-guest to the risk of bodily harm. In her speech we can hear the tone of maternal reproof that Telemachus must often have heard and resented in his boyhood and adolescence:

“Telemachus,

your sense of balance is not what it used to be.

When you were a boy you had much better judgment.

Now that you’ve grown and reached your young prime…

now your sense of fairness seems to fail you.”

(ref)

Telemachus’ reply is, for once, conciliatory, even apologetic. He no longer feels the need to assert himself against her; his father is home, and he has been assigned a principal role in the final reckoning with the suitors. But he can still speak unflatteringly of her behind her back, as he does to Eurycleia after the nightlong interview between husband and wife:

“Dear nurse, how did you treat the stranger in our house?

With bed and board? Or leave him to lie untended?

That would be mother’s way—sensible as she is—

all impulse, doting over some worthless stranger,

turning a good man out to face the worst.”

(ref)

And he rebukes her to her face when she stubbornly refuses to recognize the bloodstained ragged beggar sitting opposite her as Odysseus. “Oh mother,” he says,

“cruel mother, you with your hard heart!

Why do you spurn my father so—why don’t you

sit beside him, engage him, ask him questions?

What other wife could have a spirit so unbending?…

your heart was always harder than a rock!”

(ref)

Penelope answers him gently but firmly; she denies him any competence in the matter at hand: “… if he is truly / Odysseus… we two will know each other… we two have secret signs” (ref). And Odysseus, with a smile, sends Telemachus away.

Penelope’s attitude to both the suitors and her disguised husband has given rise to much controversy and diverse interpretation. That she is faithful to Odysseus we are assured several times, as Odysseus is assured by Anticleia and Agamemnon in the world of the dead and by Eumaeus in the land of the living. On this score even Telemachus can have no doubt. It is also clear that she has done everything she can to avoid the marriage the suitors are trying to force on her. In his indictment of her before the Ithacan assembly, Antinous pays reluctant tribute to the subtlety of her delaying tactics—the shroud for old Laertes that for three years she wove at her great loom by day and unraveled by torchlight at night. Yet though her resolve to avoid marriage is firm, she would not be human if she did not feel flattered by the suitors’ infatuation with her; a woman whose husband has been away for twenty years, and for whose return she has almost given up hope, could hardly remain indifferent to the ardent courtship of so many young princes. When, in Book 18, Athena inspires her with a longing “to display herself to her suitors, fan their hearts, / inflame them more” (ref), she is prompting impulses that lurk dormant below the surface of Penelope’s conscious mind, just as she played on Telemachus’ deep suspicions of his mother’s intentions in Book 15. That same hidden layer of Penelope’s emotions is revealed in the dream about the pet geese slaughtered by the eagle, which she describes for Odysseus. In the dream the eagle identifies himself as Odysseus and the geese as the suitors, but not before Penelope has spoken of her delight in watching the geese and her unbridled sorrow at their destruction. In these few lines Homer shows more understanding of how dreams work than is to be found anywhere in the four books of the Interpretation of Dreams written by Artemidorus of Daldis in the second century of the Christian era.

None of these feelings affects Penelope’s refusal to choose a husband from among the suitors, but during her long interview with Odysseus she suddenly tells him that she has decided to do so: she will marry the suitor who can string the great bow of Odysseus and shoot an arrow through the twelve axes lined up in a row. There are good reasons for yielding to the suitors’ pressure at this point, and she states them clearly. After the betrayal of her delaying tactics with the shroud, she can think, she says, of no further expedient. Her parents are pressing her to remarry, and her son broods impatiently as the suitors devour his inheritance; he too, she says, beseeches her to leave. She has previously told Eurymachus what Odysseus had said to her when he left for Troy:

“‘… once you see the beard on the boy’s cheek,

you wed the man you like, and leave your house behind.’

So my husband advised me then. Now it all comes true…”

(ref)

For the plot of the Odyssey, of course, her decision is the turning point, the move that makes possible the long-predicted triumph of the returning hero. But why, critics have asked, does she make up her mind to do it now, when her dream clearly announces the return of Odysseus and the slaughter of the suitors, when the disguised Odysseus has convinced her that he saw Odysseus in person long ago on Crete and assured her that Odysseus had lately been seen in nearby Thesprotia and was now on his way home; when, even earlier, the prophet Theoclymenus had assured her that Odysseus was actually in Ithaca, planning destruction for the suitors? Many critics have found her decision utterly implausible. “The poet,” writes one learned and influential scholar (Page, p. 123), “could not possibly have chosen a worse moment for Penelope’s surrender.” For those who suspect multiple authorship of the poem a simple explanation lies ready to hand: Penelope’s decision comes from an alternate story line, in which husband and wife join in conspiracy to entrap the suitors. They find support for the theory in Book 24, where the shade of the suitor Amphimedon tells Agamemnon that it was Odysseus, “the soul of cunning,” who “told his wife to set / the great bow and the gleaming iron axes out” (ref). But it was only natural that the suitors should think so, since Penelope, at a critical moment, had argued strongly against Antinous that Odysseus should be allowed to try his hand at stringing the bow.

One modern critic (Harsh) has developed a subtly argued theory that she does in fact recognize her husband in the course of their long night interview and, while forwarding his purpose, withholds from him her realization of his identity. This reading, however, runs into an immovable obstacle in Book 23, where, to Telemachus’ disgust and Odysseus’ frustration, she refuses to recognize him as her husband and tests his knowledge of those “secret signs” she had mentioned before, signs “known to us both but hidden from the world” (ref). Other critics have suggested that without recognizing the stranger’s identity, she has been profoundly impressed by him and deeply moved by his proof that, unlike so many others who have come to her with sightings of Odysseus, he really has seen her husband. The disguised Odysseus, in the words of a recent sensitive interpreter (Russo, Commentary, III, pp. 11–12), “has come to mean much more to Penelope than would normally be possible in a relationship between a famous queen and a wandering stranger… an unusual and almost improper intimacy.” When they go off to their separate beds, each dreams of the other. “Homer is showing us that Penelope has some kind of intuitive awareness of her husband’s presence but… it is active on a less than conscious level.” All this prompts her “to take a risk, to commit herself to life and to life’s chances after years of defensive, calculated maneuvering.”

This is a brilliant and attractive reading, but like many other interpretations, it does not take full account of the fact that Penelope does not have a choice in the matter. She has eloquently stated the reasons why she must decide now—pressure from her parents and her son, compounded by the threat to her son’s life, demand a decision at this point. But what she proposes is not a “surrender.” What the suitors have been demanding is that Penelope, or her father, choose one of them for her husband, “the best man in Achaea,” the one “who offers her the most [gifts]” (ref). But she faces them with something quite different: a challenge, a test in which each of them must measure himself against Odysseus by stringing his bow and shooting an arrow through the twelve axes. She is, of course, running a risk. As she tells Odysseus of her decision, she speaks as if the outcome will be the marriage she has so long avoided, and later, in her bed, she prays for death to save her from having to “warm the heart of a weaker man” (ref). Yet she must have foreseen the possibility that none of these inferior men, youths who spend their days and nights feasting, playing board games, dancing, hurling javelin and discus, would have the strength to string the bow of Odysseus and the skill to shoot an arrow through the line of twelve axes. Antinous, in fact, though he secretly hopes to succeed, expresses a fear that they may all fail to pass the test Penelope has imposed on them:

“No easy game, I wager, to string his polished bow.

Not a soul in the crowd can match Odysseus—

what a man he was…”

(ref)

Failure on the part of all the suitors might free her from their attentions; both Leodes and Eurymachus, the two suitors who try their hand and fail, speak of wooing other women elsewhere. In any case, failure would, as Eurymachus says, demonstrate their inferiority to Odysseus—“A disgrace to ring in the ears of men to come” (ref). It would be a fatal blow to the suitors’ prestige and might well turn opinion in Ithaca against them. Penelope’s surprising move looks more like a counteroffensive than a surrender. She told Odysseus that after her work on Laertes’ shroud was exposed as a fraud, she could not think of another “deft way out” (ref). The word so translated is mêtis; it is the word that characterizes Odysseus—he is polumêtis, a man of many twists and turns. Penelope is from the same mold as her husband, a worthy partner—and adversary. As she demonstrates by the mêtis she deploys against him before she will accept him fully as her husband.

Even when he has bathed, exchanged the filthy rags of the beggar for splendid raiment, and been given the grace and beauty of an immortal by Athena, she still sits apart from him, silent. He reproaches her for her coldness, using words that recall what Telemachus said to her earlier: “She has a heart of iron in her breast” (ref). He orders Eurycleia to prepare a bed for him, apart and alone. Penelope’s response shows that she is almost convinced: “You look—how well I know—” she says, “the way he looked, / setting sail from Ithaca” (ref), but nonetheless she insists on testing his knowledge of those “secret signs” she mentioned when she answered Telemachus’ angry outburst. She orders Eurycleia to move Odysseus’ bed out of the room. For the first and only time in the poem, Odysseus is taken aback. Up to this point he has always been the calculator, the manipulator, the dissembler, who played on the emotions of others, whether to win sympathy or to provoke hostility, but now Penelope has usurped that role. In a furious emotional outburst—“Woman—your words, they cut me to the core!” (ref)—he tells the story of the bed’s construction, and even though he realizes that he has given her the sign that she was seeking, he ends nevertheless with an accusing speculation:

“Does the bed, my lady, still stand planted firm?—

I don’t know—or has someone chopped away

that olive-trunk and hauled our bedstead off?”

(ref)

Penelope is convinced at last; in tears of joy she embraces him as she explains her hesitation. “In my heart of hearts I always cringed with fear / some fraud might come, beguile me with his talk” (ref). Homer and his audience had not heard of Martin Guerre, but they knew the story of Alcmena and Amphitryon (both mentioned in the Odyssey)— how Zeus assumed the appearance and personality of Amphitryon, who was away at the wars, to lie with Alcmena and beget Heracles. In the lower world, Odysseus hears a similar story from Tyro, deceived by Poseidon, who took the form of her lover, the river Enipeus. Penelope, in fact, when Eurycleia brought her the news that the stranger was Odysseus and that he had killed all the suitors, had replied, “the story can’t be true, not as you tell it, / no, it must be a god who’s killed our brazen friends.” (ref).

Even among those who believe that the Odyssey is the work of one poet there may be those who doubt that an oral poet, using writing to construct, over the course of many years, a poem on the scale of the Odyssey, could deploy so effectively so subtle an understanding of the emotions that drive men and women together and apart. But this same sympathetic understanding of the human, especially the female, heart is at work not just in the scenes set in Ithaca but everywhere throughout the poem. Calypso, for example, when she starts Odysseus on his journey home, does not tell him that she does so under duress, on orders from Zeus, but takes credit for the action herself. And even when it is clear that he is determined to go, she cannot refrain from asking him how he can possibly prefer Penelope to her own divine person. Nausicaa on Scheria manages, with exquisite tact but in unmistakable terms, to offer her hand in marriage to Odysseus without committing herself. And at Sparta, behind the splendid facade of marital harmony in the royal palace lies the reality of subdued but barely repressed embarrassment and resentment. The embarrassment is revealed obliquely in the self-exculpatory story Helen tells of her encounter with Odysseus during the war that was fought for her sake. He came into Troy, she says, disguised as a beggar; she recognized him but helped and protected him:

“… my heart had changed by now—

I yearned

to sail back home again! I grieved too late for the madness

Aphrodite sent me…”

(ref)

The resentment is clear in Menelaus’ story of Odysseus at Troy; Odysseus was the one who saved their lives in the wooden horse by holding them back when Helen, imitating the voices of their wives, called on them by name to come out. What is more, she was accompanied by Deiphobus, the second Trojan prince she had married, after the death of Paris.

There are two remarks which Alexander Pope made about Homer that readers of the Odyssey should bear in mind. The first is that “Homer is frequently eloquent in his very Silence.” And the second: “Homer has taken in all the inward Passions and Affections of Mankind to furnish his Characters.”

THE END OF THE
ODYSSEY

A
t the Greek line 296 of Book 23 of the Odyssey, husband and wife go joyfully to bed, the bed that served Penelope as the test of Odysseus’ identity. We know Aristophanes and Aristarchus said that this was the “end” of the poem. We do not have their own statements, and our sources cite two different Greek words for “end.” One of them, peras, means something like “limit” or “boundary,” and the other, telos, besides meaning “end” in the temporal or spatial sense can often mean something more like “fulfillment,” “consummation”—“end” in the Aristotelian sense. Some modern scholars have taken the words literally and pronounced the remainder of Book 23 and all of Book 24 a later addition composed by a different, and inferior, poet. They cannot, however, claim Aristarchus as their authority, for we know that he excluded the Greek lines 310–43 of Book 23 (in which Odysseus tells Penelope the tale of his travels) and lines 1–204 of Book 24 (the arrival of the shades of the suitors in the lower world). There would have been no point in doing so if he had already decided that the original poem ended at the line which put Odysseus and Penelope to bed.

In any case the poem cannot end there; too many loose ends remain to be tied up, like the consequences of the slaughter of the suitors; too many scenes have been carefully prepared for, like the meeting between Odysseus and Laertes. The first of these themes was introduced as far back as Book 20, when Odysseus discussed with Athena the plan to kill the suitors. He was appalled by the odds, one man against so many, but that is not all. “There’s another worry,” he tells her,

“that haunts me even more.

What if I kill them—thanks to you and Zeus—

how do I run from under their avengers?”

(ref)

It is with this in mind that later, in Books 22 and 23, with the corpses of the suitors cluttering the hall, he tells Telemachus to have it cleared and to organize music and dance so that passersby will guess that Penelope has at last chosen a new husband. No rumor of the truth will get out before Odysseus and his followers leave for his father’s farm in the country—where Homer will stage the last of a series of recognition scenes. It is a scene for which audience expectation has been expertly aroused: in the opening book Athena-Mentes describes Laertes mourning for his son in isolation in the country, a theme taken up later by Anticleia in the world of the dead and by Eumaeus in his hut. The poem cannot end without a meeting between father and son; their reunion is in fact one of the three large units of which the final book consists.

The first, the descent of the suitors to the lower world, where they meet Agamemnon and Achilles, was condemned by Aristarchus as an interpolation. For once, we have some information about an Alexandrian editor’s reason for such an opinion: the scholia, comments written on the margins of the medieval manuscripts, give us a selection. Some of them seem trivial; the fact that elsewhere in the poem Hermes is not called Cyllenian, for example, or the claim that a White Rock is not an appropriate landscape feature for the world of the dead. Others are more serious, such as his assertion that elsewhere in Homer the shades of the unburied are not allowed to cross the river into Hades, and the suitors’ bodies are still in the hall of Odysseus’ palace. It is true that in the Iliad the ghost of Patroclus, appearing to Achilles in a dream, tells him he cannot cross the river until Achilles gives him burial. But in the Odyssey, Elpenor begs Odysseus to bury his body, which has been left behind on Circe’s island, and he is in Hades and makes no mention of a river. The laws and the terrain of Hades are obviously not strictly defined; they remain somewhat vague even in Virgil—it was Dante who gave Hell strict logic and a fixed geography.

Quite apart from such considerations, the descent of the suitors’ ghosts to the lower world has already been foreseen in the terrifying vision that comes to Theoclymenus in the great hall in Book 20: “Ghosts, look, thronging the entrance, thronging the court, / go trooping down to the world of death and darkness!” (ref). And Plato, who lived long before Aristarchus, quoted the Greek lines 6–9 of Book 24 in the Republic:

[and the ghosts trailed after with high thin cries]

as bats cry in the depths of a dark haunted cavern,

shrilling, flittering, wild when one drops from the chain—

slipped from the rock face, while the rest cling tight…

So with their high thin cries the ghosts flocked now…

(ref)

Like Aristarchus, he proposes to suppress them, but not because he thinks Homer did not write them—on the contrary. It is one of a list of passages Plato objects to because they will sap the morale of young men training for battle. “We shall ask Homer… to forgive us if we delete all passages of this kind. It is not because they are bad poetry… in fact the better they are as poetry… the less suitable they are for an audience of boys and men on whom freedom places the obligation to fear slavery more than death.”

The long scene in which Odysseus reveals his identity to his father has been roundly condemned by many modern critics. The last of his autobiographical fictions, the skillfully crafted tale he tells Laertes has been described as a “bizarre plan,” as “pointless cruelty” and as a product of Odysseus’ “habit of distrust.” There is of course no question of real distrust; he has nothing to fear from Laertes, as he might have suspected he had from Penelope. But all these judgments should be assessed in the light not only of the difficult psychological situation Odysseus is faced with but also of Homer’s imperatives as a narrative poet.

The last half of the Odyssey is a drama of identity disguised and revealed, a series of artful variations on the recognition scene. The first, and in some ways the strangest, of these scenes occurs in the first half of the poem, when Odysseus, waiting for the prophet Tiresias to appear, sees the ghost of his mother, Anticleia, who had still been alive when he left for Troy. He bursts into tears, but following Circe’s instructions to the letter, he will not allow her to drink the sacrificial blood that would give her a semblance of life until he has heard from Tiresias. During the prophet’s long speech the ghost of Anticleia sits there in silence, making no sound, showing no emotion. But once she is allowed to drink the blood, memory returns. “She knew me at once,” says Odysseus, “and wailed out in grief” (ref). Back on Ithaca, he reveals his identity to his son, but since this involves his transformation by Athena from a ragged beggar to a magnificently dressed and handsome man, Telemachus at first (like Penelope later) is reluctant to accept him as Odysseus and thinks that he must be a god. The next recognition is one Odysseus had not planned on and that might have aroused suspicions, but his old dog Argos, recognizing his master after twenty years, is too feeble to approach him and can do no more than let his ears droop and wag his tail and then die. The next recognition, Eurycleia’s discovery of the scar, might have disrupted his plans, but he forces her to keep silent. Just before the climactic moment when he gets his hands on the bow, he reveals his identity to Eumaeus and the shepherd Philoetius, enlisting them on his side, and the next revelation is also his initiative: after killing Antinous, he tells the suitors who he is and what will happen to them. “You dogs! you never imagined I’d return from Troy— /… your doom is sealed!” (ref). Penelope, in her turn, is unable to accept the revelation of his identity, but after he passes her test she clasps him joyfully in her arms. Only the recognition by Laertes remains.

It comes as no surprise. Not only does Odysseus tell Penelope of his intention to confront his father, but Laertes’ overwhelming grief for his missing son and his withdrawal from society have been described in harrowing detail by Athena-Mentes, Anticleia and Eumaeus. The theme has been building to a climax, and something more than a simple declaration and joyful acceptance is required by the laws of storytelling. The poet’s dilemma is in fact reflected in the text, put in the mouth of Odysseus. Catching sight of his father, “a man worn down with years, his heart racked with sorrow” (ref), Odysseus

halted under a branching pear-tree, paused and wept.

Debating, head and heart, what should he do now?

Kiss and embrace his father, pour out the long tale—…

or probe him first and test him every way?

(ref)

Like his hero, Homer decides on the second alternative.

But the choice makes sense also in terms of the persons involved. Laertes is a man to whose burden of old age has been added the loss of his only son—missing in action, no word of when, where, how or even if he died. Laertes has become a hermit, never coming into town, Athena-Mentes says in the opening book of the poem, suffering as he drags himself along the slope of his vineyard. Anticleia, his dead wife, rounds out the picture of his renunciation of civilized life: he sleeps with slaves in the ashes by the fire in winter and on fallen leaves in the summer, nursing his overwhelming grief. Eumaeus tells Odysseus that the old man prays for death as he grieves for his son and his wife, and that his reaction to the news that Telemachus has sailed off to Pylos is to refuse food and drink.

Clearly this is a case that calls for careful handling if Laertes is to be extracted from the prison of grief and self-humiliation in which he has closed himself off from the world. What Odysseus does is to bring him back to consciousness of his own dignity as a man and a king before making any mention of his son. The first part of his long, adroitly structured speech consists of what Homer calls “reproachful words.” The adjective kertomiois is usually translated as “bantering” or “mocking,” and it does often carry that meaning, but from what follows here it clearly in this case means “reproachful,” as its cognate noun does in the first book of the Iliad (line 539 in the Greek), where it describes Hera’s angry accusation that Zeus is, as usual, conspiring against her.

Odysseus’ reproaches are far from gentle. He takes note of Laertes’ patched and miserable garments, his fieldhand’s leather shin guards and gloves, his goatskin cap. Though he starts by commending him on his work, and pays him the compliment of detecting the lineaments of royalty under his sordid appearance, he ends the first part of his speech with a question deliberately phrased for its shock effect: “whose slave are you? whose orchard are you tending?” (ref). Nothing could more swiftly bring Laertes to a realization of the degraded condition into which he has allowed himself to fall, and Odysseus now asks another question— whether he is indeed in Ithaca. For he once befriended and helped a man from Ithaca, the son of Laertes. “By posing questions, awaking memories, and stirring long-repressed feelings,” Heubeck writes in his masterly commentary on Book 24 (III, p. 390), “Odysseus forces his father not only to answer the questions put, but to ask questions in return, and so, step by step, to emerge from his self-inflicted isolation and apathy.” Finally, told that the man he is talking to is Odysseus in person, he asks for a sign and is given not only the scar that Eurycleia recognized but Odysseus’ enumeration of the trees his father had given him when he was a little boy—“thirteen pear, ten apple trees / and forty figs” (ref). Laertes flings his arms around his long-lost son and the two of them go off to the farmhouse to join Telemachus.

There is little more to be told. The fathers of some of the dead suitors—in spite of Medon’s caution that he had seen a god helping Odysseus in the fighting and old Halitherses’ reminder that they were themselves to blame for not restraining their sons—arm and set out, led by Eupithes, Antinous’ father, to exact vengeance from Odysseus and his party. Only one man is killed: Eupithes, at the hand of a Laertes rejuvenated by Athena. The goddess puts an end to the fighting and then, in the shape of Mentor, administers oaths to both sides as a guarantee of reconciliation and peace.

The poem ends here, but like the Iliad, it has already charted the future of its hero. Achilles has been told by his mother, Thetis, that his death will come soon after Hector’s, but he will not renounce his passionate resolve to avenge Patroclus’ death. As he prepares to take Lycaon’s life, he foresees the end of his own—“There will come a dawn or sunset or high noon / when a man will take my life in battle too” (21.125–6). In the Odyssey the hero’s death is foretold by Tiresias in the underworld. After he has killed the suitors, Tiresias tells him, he must make his peace with the god Poseidon by traveling inland, carrying an oar on his shoulder, until he reaches a people utterly ignorant of the sea and ships. When one of them asks him why he is carrying a winnowing fan on his shoulder, he is to fix the oar in the ground and make an extraordinary sacrifice—a bull, a ram and a boar—to Poseidon. Once returned home, he is to sacrifice to all the Olympian gods in turn. “And at last your own death,” says Tiresias,

“will steal upon you…

a gentle, painless death, far from the sea it comes

to take you down, borne down with the years in ripe old age

with all your people there in blessed peace around you.”

(ref)

THE SPELLING AND PRONUNCIATION OF HOMERIC NAMES

T
hough the English spelling of ancient Greek names faces modern poet-translators with some difficult problems, it was not a problem at all for Shakespeare, Milton, Pope and Tennyson. Except in the case of names that had through constant use been fully Anglicized—Hector, Helen, Troy—the poets used Latin equivalents of the Greek names, which they found in the poems of Virgil and Ovid that they read in school. These are the forms we also are familiar with, from our reading of English poets through the centuries: Circe, Scylla, Sirens.

Recent poet-translators have tried to get closer to the original Greek and have transliterated the Greek names directly, not through the medium of their Latin adaptations. One translator, for example, presents his readers with Kirkê, Skylla and the Seirênês. Another shares several of these spellings but will strike a compromise at times—Circe, Skylla. All translators compromise when it comes to such fully naturalized forms as Helen, Trojans and Argives (Helenê, Trôes and Argeioi in the Greek), and they also retreat from strict transliteration in cases like Odysseus (Odusseus), Priam (Priamos) and Thrace (Thrêikê).

This is an area in which no one can claim perfect consistency: we too offer a compromise. Its basis, however, is a return to the traditional practice of generations of English poets—the use of Latinate spellings except for those names that have become, in their purely English forms, familiar in our mouths as household words.

Rigid adherence to this rule would of course make unacceptable demands: it would impose, for instance, Minerva instead of Athena, Ulysses for Odysseus, Jupiter or Jove for Zeus. We have preferred the Greek names, but transliterated them on Latin principles: Hêrê, for example, is Hera in this translation; Athênê is Athena. Elsewhere we have replaced the letter k with c and substituted the ending us for the Greek os in the names of persons (Patroklos becomes Patroclus). When, however, a personal name ends in ros preceded by a consonant, we have used the Latin ending er: Pisander for Peisandros. The Greek diphthongs ai and oi are represented by the Latin diphthongs ae and oe (Achaean for Akhaian, Euboea for Euboia).

This conventional Latinate spelling of the names has a traditional pronunciation system, one that corresponds with neither the Greek nor the Latin sounds. Perhaps “system” is not the best word for it, since it is full of inconsistencies. But it is the pronunciation English poets have used for centuries, the sounds they heard mentally as they composed and that they confidently expected their readers to hear in their turn. Since there seems to be no similar convention for the English pronunciation of modern transliterated Greek—is the h sounded in Akhilleus? is Diomedes pronounced dee-oh-may’-days or dee-oh-mee’-deez?—we have thought it best to work with pronunciation that Keats and Shelley would have recognized.

As in Achilles (a-kil’-eez), ch is pronounced like k throughout. The consonants c and g are hard (as in “cake” and “gun”) before a—Acastus (a-kas’-tus), Agamemnon (a-ga-mem’-non); before o—Leucothea ( lew-ko’-the-a), Gorgon (gor’-gon); before u—Autolycus (aw-to’-li-kus); and before other consonants—Patroclus (pa-tro’-klus), Cauconians (kaw-kho’-ni-unz). They are soft (as in “cinder” and “George”) before e—Circe (sir’-see), Geraestus (je-ree’-stus); before i—Cicones (si-koh’-neez), and before y— Cyclops (seye’-klops), Gyrae (jeye’-ree). The final combinations cia and gia produce sha—Phaeacia (fee-ay’-sha)—and ja—Ortygia (or-ti’-ja)— respectively. There are, however, cases in which the pronunciation of the consonants does not conform to these rules. One of the names of the Greeks, for instance—Argives—is pronounced with a hard g (ar’-geyevz, not ar’-jeyevz), by analogy with the town of Argos.

The vowels vary in pronunciation, sometimes but not always according to the length of the Latin (or Greek) syllable, and the reader will have to find guidance in the rhythm of the English line or consult the Pronouncing Glossary at the back of the volume. Final e is always sounded long: Hebe (hee’-bee); final es is pronounced eez, as in Achilles. In other positions, the letter e may represent the sound heard in sneeze or that heard in pet. The letter i may sound as in “bit” or “bite”: Antinous ( an-ti’-no-us) or Atrides (a-treye’-deez). The two sounds are also found for y— Cythera (si-thee’-ra) or Cyprus (seye’-prus)—while o is pronounced as in Olympus (o-lim’-pus) or Dodona (doh-doh’-na). In this spelling system, u except in the ending us and in combination with other vowels (see below) is always long, since it represents the Greek diphthong ou. But it may be pronounced either you as in “dew”—Dulichion (dew-li’-ki-on)—or oo as in “glue”—Arethusa (a-re-thoo’-sa).

The diphthongs oe and ae are both pronounced ee—Achaeans ( a-kee’-unz), Oenops (ee’-nops). The combination aer does not produce a diphthong: Laertes (lay-ur’-teez); in cases where these letters are sounded separately, a dieresis is used: Phaëthusa (fay-e-thoo’-sa). The diphthong
au is pronounced aw—Nausicaa (naw-si’-kay-a)—but in name endings, Menelaus, for example, it is not a diphthong, and the vowels are pronounced separately (me-ne-lay’-us). Since his name is familiar to the English reader, we have thought it unnecessary to use the dieresis in such cases. The ending ous is similar: Pirithous (peye-ri’-tho-us). The ending eus is sounded like yoos—Odysseus (o-dis’-yoos), except in the case of the name of one river—Alpheus (al-fee’-us)—and one Phaeacian elder, Echeneus (e-ken-ee’-us).

All other vowel combinations are pronounced not as diphthongs but as separate vowels. Double o is pronounced o-oh: Thoosa (tho-oh’-sa). Similarly, oi is treated not as a diphthong but as two separate sounds— Oicles (oh-ik’-leez). The sequence ei, however, is pronounced eye, as in the feminine name ending eia: Anticleia (an-ti-kleye’-a), Eurycleia ( yoo-ri-kleye’-a) and other names as well; the constellation called the Pleiades (pleye’-a-deez) and the sea-nymph Eidothea (eye-do’-the-a); but Deiphobus (dee-i’-fo-bus) is an exception.

Obviously we cannot claim complete consistency even within the limits we have imposed on the system. Where no Latin form exists, as in the case of Poseidon, we have used the transliterated Greek, traditionally pronounced po-seye’-don (not po-see’-i-don). But we can claim to have reduced the unsightly dieresis to a minor factor and to have given the reader who comes to Homer for the first time a guide to pronunciation that will stand him or her in good stead when reading other poets who mention Greek names. We have also provided a Pronouncing Glossary of all the proper names in the text, which indicates stress and English vowel length.

HOMER:

THE

ODYSSEY

BOOK ONE

Athena Inspires the Prince

1

S
ing to me of the man, Muse, the man of twists and turns

2driven time and again off course, once he had plundered

3the hallowed heights of Troy.

4Many cities of men he saw and learned their minds,

many pains he suffered, heartsick on the open sea,

6fighting to save his life and bring his comrades home.

But he could not save them from disaster, hard as he strove—

the recklessness of their own ways destroyed them all,

the blind fools, they devoured the cattle of the Sun

10and the Sungod wiped from sight the day of their return.

11Launch out on his story, Muse, daughter of Zeus,

start from where you will—sing for our time too.

By now,

all the survivors, all who avoided headlong death

were safe at home, escaped the wars and waves.

But one man alone…

16his heart set on his wife and his return—Calypso,

the bewitching nymph, the lustrous goddess, held him back,

deep in her arching caverns, craving him for a husband.

But then, when the wheeling seasons brought the year around,

20that year spun out by the gods when he should reach his home,

21Ithaca—though not even there would he be free of trials,

even among his loved ones—then every god took pity,

23all except Poseidon. He raged on, seething against

24the great Odysseus till he reached his native land.

But now

25Poseidon had gone to visit the Ethiopians worlds away,

Ethiopians off at the farthest limits of mankind,

a people split in two, one part where the Sungod sets

and part where the Sungod rises. There Poseidon went

to receive an offering, bulls and rams by the hundred—

30far away at the feast the Sea-lord sat and took his pleasure.

But the other gods, at home in Olympian Zeus’s halls,

met for full assembly there, and among them now

the father of men and gods was first to speak,

34sorely troubled, remembering handsome Aegisthus,

35the man Agamemnon’s son, renowned Orestes, killed.

Recalling Aegisthus, Zeus harangued the immortal powers:

37“Ah how shameless—the way these mortals blame the gods.

From us alone, they say, come all their miseries, yes,

but they themselves, with their own reckless ways,

40compound their pains beyond their proper share.

Look at Aegisthus now…

42above and beyond his share he stole Atrides’ wife,

he murdered the warlord coming home from Troy

though he knew it meant his own total ruin.

Far in advance we told him so ourselves,

46dispatching the guide, the giant-killer Hermes.

‘Don’t murder the man,’ he said, ‘don’t court his wife.

Beware, revenge will come from Orestes, Agamemnon’s son,

that day he comes of age and longs for his native land.’

50So Hermes warned, with all the good will in the world,

but would Aegisthus’ hardened heart give way?

Now he pays the price—all at a single stroke.”

53And sparkling-eyed Athena drove the matter home:

54“Father, son of Cronus, our high and mighty king,

surely he goes down to a death he earned in full!

Let them all die so, all who do such things.

But my heart breaks for Odysseus,

that seasoned veteran cursed by fate so long—

far from his loved ones still, he suffers torments

60off on a wave-washed island rising at the center of the seas.

A dark wooded island, and there a goddess makes her home,

62a daughter of Atlas, wicked Titan who sounds the deep

in all its depths, whose shoulders lift on high

the colossal pillars thrusting earth and sky apart.

Atlas’ daughter it is who holds Odysseus captive,

luckless man—despite his tears, forever trying

to spellbind his heart with suave, seductive words

and wipe all thought of Ithaca from his mind.

But he, straining for no more than a glimpse

70of hearth-smoke drifting up from his own land,

Odysseus longs to die…

Olympian Zeus,

have you no care for him in your lofty heart?

Did he never win your favor with sacrifices

burned beside the ships on the broad plain of Troy?

75Why, Zeus, why so dead set against Odysseus?”

“My child,” Zeus who marshals the thunderheads replied,

“what nonsense you let slip through your teeth. Now,

how on earth could I forget Odysseus? Great Odysseus

who excels all men in wisdom, excels in offerings too

80he gives the immortal gods who rule the vaulting skies?

No, it’s the Earth-Shaker, Poseidon, unappeased,

82forever fuming against him for the Cyclops

83whose giant eye he blinded: godlike Polyphemus,

towering over all the Cyclops’ clans in power.

85The nymph Thoosa bore him, daughter of Phorcys,

lord of the barren salt sea—she met Poseidon

once in his vaulted caves and they made love.

And now for his blinded son the earthquake god—

though he won’t quite kill Odysseus—

90drives him far off course from native land.

But come, all of us here put heads together now,

work out his journey home so Odysseus can return.

Lord Poseidon, I trust, will let his anger go.

How can he stand his ground against the will

of all the gods at once—one god alone?”

Athena, her eyes flashing bright, exulted,

“Father, son of Cronus, our high and mighty king!

If now it really pleases the blissful gods

that wise Odysseus shall return—home at last—

100let us dispatch the guide and giant-killer Hermes

101down to Ogygia Island, down to announce at once

to the nymph with lovely braids our fixed decree:

Odysseus journeys home—the exile must return!

While I myself go down to Ithaca, rouse his son

105to a braver pitch, inspire his heart with courage

106to summon the flowing-haired Achaeans to full assembly,

speak his mind to all those suitors, slaughtering on and on

his droves of sheep and shambling longhorn cattle.

109Next I will send him off to Sparta and sandy Pylos,

110there to learn of his dear father’s journey home.

Perhaps he will hear some news and make his name

throughout the mortal world.”

So Athena vowed

and under her feet she fastened the supple sandals,

ever-glowing gold, that wing her over the waves

and boundless earth with the rush of gusting winds.

She seized the rugged spear tipped with a bronze point—

weighted, heavy, the massive shaft she wields to break the lines

of heroes the mighty Father’s daughter storms against.

119And down she swept from Olympus’ craggy peaks

120and lit on Ithaca, standing tall at Odysseus’ gates,

the threshold of his court. Gripping her bronze spear,

she looked for all the world like a stranger now,

123like Mentes, lord of the Taphians.

There she found the swaggering suitors, just then

amusing themselves with rolling dice before the doors,

lounging on hides of oxen they had killed themselves.

While heralds and brisk attendants bustled round them,

some at the mixing-bowls, mulling wine and water,

others wiping the tables down with sopping sponges,

130setting them out in place, still other servants

jointed and carved the great sides of meat.

132First by far to see her was Prince Telemachus,

sitting among the suitors, heart obsessed with grief.

He could almost see his magnificent father, here…

in the mind’s eye—if only he might drop from the clouds

and drive these suitors all in a rout throughout the halls

and regain his pride of place and rule his own domains!

Daydreaming so as he sat among the suitors,

he glimpsed Athena now

140and straight to the porch he went, mortified

that a guest might still be standing at the doors.

Pausing beside her there, he clasped her right hand

and relieving her at once of her long bronze spear,

met her with winged words: “Greetings, stranger!

Here in our house you’ll find a royal welcome.

Have supper first, then tell us what you need.”

147He led the way and Pallas Athena followed.

Once in the high-roofed hall, he took her lance

and fixed it firm in a burnished rack against

150a sturdy pillar, there where row on row of spears,

embattled Odysseus’ spears, stood stacked and waiting.

Then he escorted her to a high, elaborate chair of honor,

over it draped a cloth, and here he placed his guest

with a stool to rest her feet. But for himself

he drew up a low reclining chair beside her,

richly painted, clear of the press of suitors,

concerned his guest, offended by their uproar,

might shrink from food in the midst of such a mob.

He hoped, what’s more, to ask her about his long-lost father.

160A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

and over a silver basin tipped it out

so they might rinse their hands,

then pulled a gleaming table to their side.

A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve them,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

A carver lifted platters of meat toward them,

meats of every sort, and set beside them golden cups

and time and again a page came round and poured them wine.

But now the suitors trooped in with all their swagger

170and took their seats on low and high-backed chairs.

Heralds poured water over their hands for rinsing,

serving maids brought bread heaped high in trays

and the young men brimmed the mixing-bowls with wine.

They reached out for the good things that lay at hand,

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink

the suitors set their minds on other pleasures,

song and dancing, all that crowns a feast.

178A herald placed an ornate lyre in Phemius’ hands,

the bard who always performed among them there;

they forced the man to sing.

180A rippling prelude—

and no sooner had he struck up his rousing song

than Telemachus, head close to Athena’s sparkling eyes,

spoke low to his guest so no one else could hear:

“Dear stranger, would you be shocked by what I say?

Look at them over there. Not a care in the world,

just lyres and tunes! It’s easy for them, all right,

they feed on another’s goods and go scot-free—

a man whose white bones lie strewn in the rain somewhere,

rotting away on land or rolling down the ocean’s salty swells.

190But that man—if they caught sight of him home in Ithaca,

by god, they’d all pray to be faster on their feet

than richer in bars of gold and heavy robes.

But now, no use, he’s died a wretched death.

No comfort’s left for us… not even if

someone, somewhere, says he’s coming home.

The day of his return will never dawn.

Enough.

Tell me about yourself now, clearly, point by point.

Who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?

What sort of vessel brought you? Why did the sailors

200land you here in Ithaca? Who did they say they are?

I hardly think you came this way on foot!

And tell me this for a fact—I need to know—

is this your first time here? Or are you a friend of father’s,

a guest from the old days? Once, crowds of other men

would come to our house on visits—visitor that he was,

when he walked among the living.”

Her eyes glinting,

goddess Athena answered, “My whole story, of course,

208I’ll tell it point by point. Wise old Anchialus

was my father. My own name is Mentes,

210lord of the Taphian men who love their oars.

And here I’ve come, just now, with ship and crew,

sailing the wine-dark sea to foreign ports of call,

213to Temese, out for bronze—our cargo gleaming iron.

Our ship lies moored off farmlands far from town,

215riding in Rithron Cove, beneath Mount Nion’s woods.

As for the ties between your father and myself,

we’ve been friends forever, I’m proud to say,

and he would bear me out

219if you went and questioned old lord Laertes.

220He, I gather, no longer ventures into town

but lives a life of hardship, all to himself,

off on his farmstead with an aged serving-woman

who tends him well, who gives him food and drink

when weariness has taken hold of his withered limbs

from hauling himself along his vineyard’s steep slopes.

And now I’ve come—and why? I heard that he was back…

your father, that is. But no, the gods thwart his passage.

Yet I tell you great Odysseus is not dead. He’s still alive,

somewhere in this wide world, held captive, out at sea

230on a wave-washed island, and hard men, savages,

somehow hold him back against his will.

Wait,

I’ll make you a prophecy, one the immortal gods

have planted in my mind—it will come true, I think,

though I am hardly a seer or know the flights of birds.

He won’t be gone long from the native land he loves,

not even if iron shackles bind your father down.

He’s plotting a way to journey home at last;

he’s never at a loss.

But come, please,

tell me about yourself now, point by point.

240You’re truly Odysseus’ son? You’ve sprung up so!

Uncanny resemblance… the head, and the fine eyes—

I see him now. How often we used to meet in the old days

243before he embarked for Troy, where other Argive captains,

all the best men, sailed in the long curved ships.

From then to this very day

I’ve not set eyes on Odysseus or he on me.”

And young Telemachus cautiously replied,

“I’ll try, my friend, to give you a frank answer.

249Mother has always told me I’m his son, it’s true,

250but I am not so certain. Who, on his own,

has ever really known who gave him life?

Would to god I’d been the son of a happy man

whom old age overtook in the midst of his possessions!

Now, think of the most unlucky mortal ever born—

since you ask me, yes, they say I am his son.”

“Still,” the clear-eyed goddess reassured him,

“trust me, the gods have not marked out your house

for such an unsung future,

259not if Penelope has borne a son like you.

260But tell me about all this and spare me nothing.

What’s this banqueting, this crowd carousing here?

And what part do you play yourself? Some wedding-feast,

some festival? Hardly a potluck supper, I would say.

How obscenely they lounge and swagger here, look,

gorging in your house. Why, any man of sense

who chanced among them would be outraged,

seeing such behavior.”

Ready Telemachus

took her up at once: “Well, my friend,

seeing you want to probe and press the question,

270once this house was rich, no doubt, beyond reproach

when the man you mentioned still lived here, at home.

Now the gods have reversed our fortunes with a vengeance—

wiped that man from the earth like no one else before.

I would never have grieved so much about his death

if he’d gone down with comrades off in Troy

or died in the arms of loved ones,

once he had wound down the long coil of war.

278Then all united Achaea would have raised his tomb

and he’d have won his son great fame for years to come.

280But now the whirlwinds have ripped him away, no fame for him!

He’s lost and gone now—out of sight, out of mind—and I…

he’s left me tears and grief. Nor do I rack my heart

and grieve for him alone. No longer. Now the gods

have invented other miseries to plague me.

Listen.

All the nobles who rule the islands round about,

286Dulichion, and Same, and wooded Zacynthus too,

and all who lord it in rocky Ithaca as well—

down to the last man they court my mother,

they lay waste my house! And mother…

290she neither rejects a marriage she despises

nor can she bear to bring the courting to an end—

while they continue to bleed my household white.

Soon—you wait—they’ll grind me down as well.”

“Shameful!”—

brimming with indignation, Pallas Athena broke out.

“Oh how much you need Odysseus, gone so long—

how he’d lay hands on all these brazen suitors!

If only he would appear, now,

at his house’s outer gates and take his stand,

armed with his helmet, shield and pair of spears,

300as strong as the man I glimpsed that first time

in our own house, drinking wine and reveling there…

302just come in from Ephyra, visiting Ilus, Mermerus’ son.

Odysseus sailed that way, you see, in his swift trim ship,

hunting deadly poison to smear on his arrows’ bronze heads.

Ilus refused—he feared the wrath of the everlasting gods—

but father, so fond of him, gave him all he wanted.

If only that Odysseus sported with these suitors,

a blood wedding, a quick death would take the lot!

True, but all lies in the lap of the great gods,

310whether or not he’ll come and pay them back,

here, in his own house.

But you, I urge you,

think how to drive these suitors from your halls.

Come now, listen closely. Take my words to heart.

At daybreak summon the island’s lords to full assembly,

give your orders to all and call the gods to witness:

tell the suitors to scatter, each to his own place.

As for your mother, if the spirit moves her to marry,

let her go back to her father’s house, a man of power.

Her kin will arrange the wedding, provide the gifts,

the array that goes with a daughter dearly loved.

320For you,

I have some good advice, if only you will accept it.

Fit out a ship with twenty oars, the best in sight,

sail in quest of news of your long-lost father.

Someone may tell you something

or you may catch a rumor straight from Zeus,

rumor that carries news to men like nothing else.

First go down to Pylos, question old King Nestor,

328then cross over to Sparta, to red-haired Menelaus,

of all the bronze-armored Achaeans the last man back.

330Now, if you hear your father’s alive and heading home,

hard-pressed as you are, brave out one more year.

If you hear he’s dead, no longer among the living,

then back you come to the native land you love,

raise his grave-mound, build his honors high

with the full funeral rites that he deserves—

and give your mother to another husband.

Then,

once you’ve sealed those matters, seen them through,

think hard, reach down deep in your heart and soul

for a way to kill these suitors in your house,

340by stealth or in open combat.

341You must not cling to your boyhood any longer—

it’s time you were a man. Haven’t you heard

what glory Prince Orestes won throughout the world

when he killed that cunning, murderous Aegisthus,

who’d killed his famous father?

And you, my friend—

how tall and handsome I see you now—be brave, you too,

so men to come will sing your praises down the years.

But now I must go back to my swift trim ship

and all my shipmates, chafing there, I’m sure,

350waiting for my return. It all rests with you.

Take my words to heart.”

“Oh stranger,”

heedful Telemachus replied, “indeed I will.

353You’ve counseled me with so much kindness now,

like a father to a son. I won’t forget a word.

But come, stay longer, keen as you are to sail,

so you can bathe and rest and lift your spirits,

357then go back to your ship, delighted with a gift,

a prize of honor, something rare and fine

as a keepsake from myself. The kind of gift

360a host will give a stranger, friend to friend.”

Her eyes glinting, Pallas declined in haste:

“Not now. Don’t hold me here. I long to be on my way.

As for the gift—whatever you’d give in kindness—

save it for my return so I can take it home.

365Choose something rare and fine, and a good reward

that gift is going to bring you.”

With that promise,

off and away Athena the bright-eyed goddess flew

like a bird in soaring flight

but left his spirit filled with nerve and courage,

370charged with his father’s memory more than ever now.

He felt his senses quicken, overwhelmed with wonder—

this was a god, he knew it well and made at once

for the suitors, a man like a god himself.

Amidst them still

the famous bard sang on, and they sat in silence, listening

375as he performed The Achaeans’ Journey Home from Troy:

all the blows Athena doomed them to endure.

And now,

from high above in her room and deep in thought,

she caught his inspired strains…

379Icarius’ daughter Penelope, wary and reserved,

380and down the steep stair from her chamber she descended,

not alone: two of her women followed close behind.

That radiant woman, once she reached her suitors,

drawing her glistening veil across her cheeks,

paused now where a column propped the sturdy roof,

with one of her loyal handmaids stationed either side.

Suddenly, dissolving in tears and bursting through

the bard’s inspired voice, she cried out, “Phemius!

So many other songs you know to hold us spellbound,

389works of the gods and men that singers celebrate.

390Sing one of those as you sit beside them here

and they drink their wine in silence.

391But break off this song—

the unendurable song that always rends the heart inside me…

the unforgettable grief, it wounds me most of all!

How I long for my husband—alive in memory, always,

396that great man whose fame resounds through Hellas

397right to the depths of Argos!”

“Why, mother,”

poised Telemachus put in sharply, “why deny

our devoted bard the chance to entertain us

any way the spirit stirs him on?

400Bards are not to blame—

Zeus is to blame. He deals to each and every

laborer on this earth whatever doom he pleases.

Why fault the bard if he sings the Argives’ harsh fate?

It’s always the latest song, the one that echoes last

in the listeners’ ears, that people praise the most.

Courage, mother. Harden your heart, and listen.

Odysseus was scarcely the only one, you know,

whose journey home was blotted out at Troy.

409Others, so many others, died there too.

So, mother,

410go back to your quarters. Tend to your own tasks,

the distaff and the loom, and keep the women

working hard as well. As for giving orders,

men will see to that, but I most of all:

I hold the reins of power in this house.”

Astonished,

she withdrew to her own room. She took to heart

the clear good sense in what her son had said.

Climbing up to the lofty chamber with her women,

she fell to weeping for Odysseus, her beloved husband,

till watchful Athena sealed her eyes with welcome sleep.

420But the suitors broke into uproar through the shadowed halls,

all of them lifting prayers to lie beside her, share her bed,

until discreet Telemachus took command: “You suitors

who plague my mother, you, you insolent, overweening…

for this evening let us dine and take our pleasure,

no more shouting now. What a fine thing it is

to listen to such a bard as we have here—

the man sings like a god.

But at first light

we all march forth to assembly, take our seats

so I can give my orders and say to you straight out:

430You must leave my palace! See to your feasting elsewhere,

devour your own possessions, house to house by turns.

But if you decide the fare is better, richer here,

destroying one man’s goods and going scot-free,

all right then, carve away!

But I’ll cry out to the everlasting gods in hopes

that Zeus will pay you back with a vengeance—all of you

destroyed in my house while I go scot-free myself!”

So Telemachus declared. And they all bit their lips,

amazed the prince could speak with so much daring.

440Eupithes’ son Antinous broke their silence:

“Well, Telemachus, only the gods could teach you

to sound so high and mighty! Such brave talk.

443I pray that Zeus will never make you king of Ithaca,

though your father’s crown is no doubt yours by birth.”

But cool-headed Telemachus countered firmly:

“Antinous, even though my words may offend you,

447I’d be happy to take the crown if Zeus presents it.

You think that nothing worse could befall a man?

It’s really not so bad to be a king. All at once

450your palace grows in wealth, your honors grow as well.

But there are hosts of other Achaean princes, look—

young and old, crowds of them on our island here—

and any one of the lot might hold the throne,

now great Odysseus is dead…

But I’ll be lord of my own house and servants,

all that King Odysseus won for me by force.”

457And now Eurymachus, Polybus’ son, stepped in:

“Surely this must lie in the gods’ lap, Telemachus—

which Achaean will lord it over seagirt Ithaca.

460Do hold on to your own possessions, rule your house.

God forbid that anyone tear your holdings from your hands

while men still live in Ithaca.

But about your guest,

dear boy, I have some questions. Where does he come from?

Where’s his country, his birth, his father’s old estates?

Did he bring some news of your father, his return?

Or did he come on business of his own?

How he leapt to his feet and off he went!

No waiting around for proper introductions.

And no mean man, not by the looks of him, I’d say.”

470“Eurymachus,” Telemachus answered shrewdly,

“clearly my father’s journey home is lost forever.

I no longer trust in rumors—rumors from the blue—

nor bother with any prophecy, when mother calls

some wizard into the house to ask him questions.

As for the stranger, though,

476the man’s an old family friend, from Taphos,

wise Anchialus’ son. He says his name is Mentes,

lord of the Taphian men who love their oars.”

So he said

but deep in his mind he knew the immortal goddess.

480Now the suitors turned to dance and song,

to the lovely beat and sway,

waiting for dusk to come upon them there…

and the dark night came upon them, lost in pleasure.

Finally, to bed. Each to his own house.

Telemachus,

off to his bedroom built in the fine courtyard—

a commanding, lofty room set well apart—

retired too, his spirit swarming with misgivings.

His devoted nurse attended him, bearing a glowing torch,

489Eurycleia the daughter of Ops, Pisenor’s son.

490Laertes had paid a price for the woman years ago,

still in the bloom of youth. He traded twenty oxen,

honored her on a par with his own loyal wife at home

but fearing the queen’s anger, never shared her bed.

She was his grandson’s escort now and bore a torch,

for she was the one of all the maids who loved

the prince the most—she’d nursed him as a baby.

He spread the doors of his snug, well-made room,

sat down on the bed and pulled his soft shirt off,

tossed it into the old woman’s conscientious hands,

500and after folding it neatly, patting it smooth,

she hung it up on a peg beside his corded bed,

then padded from the bedroom,

drawing the door shut with the silver hook,

sliding the doorbolt home with its rawhide strap.

There all night long, wrapped in a sheep’s warm fleece,

he weighed in his mind the course Athena charted.

BOOK TWO

Telemachus Sets Sail

1

W
hen young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

the true son of Odysseus sprang from bed and dressed,

over his shoulder he slung his well-honed sword,

fastened rawhide sandals under his smooth feet

and stepped from his bedroom, handsome as a god.

At once he ordered heralds to cry out loud and clear

and summon the flowing-haired Achaeans to full assembly.

Their cries rang out. The people filed in quickly.

When they’d grouped, crowding the meeting grounds,

10Telemachus strode in too, a bronze spear in his grip

and not alone: two sleek hounds went trotting at his heels.

And Athena lavished a marvelous splendor on the prince

so the people all gazed in wonder as he came forward,

the elders making way as he took his father’s seat.

15The first to speak was an old lord, Aegyptius,

stooped with age, who knew the world by heart.

For one dear son had sailed with King Odysseus,

bound in the hollow ships to the stallion-land of Troy—

19the spearman Antiphus—but the brutal Cyclops killed him,

20trapped in his vaulted cave, the last man the monster ate.

Three other sons he had: one who mixed with the suitors,

22Eurynomus, and two kept working their father’s farms.

Still, he never forgot the soldier, desolate in his grief.

In tears for the son he lost, he rose and said among them,

“Hear me, men of Ithaca. Hear what I have to say.

Not once have we held assembly, met in session

since King Odysseus sailed away in the hollow ships.

Who has summoned us now—one of the young men,

one of the old-timers? What crisis spurs him on?

30Some news he’s heard of an army on the march,

word he’s caught firsthand so he can warn us now?

Or some other public matter he’ll disclose and argue?

He’s a brave man, I’d say. God be with him, too!

May Zeus speed him on to a happy end,

whatever his heart desires!”

Winning words

with a lucky ring. Odysseus’ son rejoiced;

the boy could sit no longer—fired up to speak,

he took his stand among the gathered men.

39The herald Pisenor, skilled in custom’s ways,

40put the staff in his hand, and then the prince,

addressing old Aegyptius first, led off with, “Sir,

that man is not far off—you’ll soon see for yourself—

I was the one who called us all together.

Something wounds me deeply…

not news I’ve heard of an army on the march,

word I’ve caught firsthand so I can warn you now,

or some other public matter I’ll disclose and argue.

No, the crisis is my own. Trouble has struck my house—

a double blow. First, I have lost my noble father

50who ruled among you years ago, each of you here,

and kindly as a father to his children.

But now this,

a worse disaster that soon will grind my house down,

ruin it all, and all my worldly goods in the bargain.

Suitors plague my mother—against her will—

sons of the very men who are your finest here!

They’d sooner die than approach her father’s house

so Icarius himself might see to his daughter’s bridal,

hand her to whom he likes, whoever meets his fancy.

Not they—they infest our palace day and night,

60they butcher our cattle, our sheep, our fat goats,

feasting themselves sick, swilling our glowing wine

as if there’s no tomorrow—all of it, squandered.

Now we have no man like Odysseus in command

to drive this curse from the house. We ourselves?

We’re hardly the ones to fight them off. All we’d do

is parade our wretched weakness. A boy inept at battle.

Oh I’d swing to attack if I had the power in me.

By god, it’s intolerable, what they do—disgrace,

my house a shambles!

You should be ashamed yourselves,

70mortified in the face of neighbors living round about!

Fear the gods’ wrath—before they wheel in outrage

and make these crimes recoil on your heads.

73I beg you by Olympian Zeus, by Themis too,

who sets assemblies free and calls us into session—

stop, my friends! Leave me alone to pine away in anguish…

Unless, of course, you think my noble father Odysseus

did the Achaean army damage, deliberate harm,

and to pay me back you’d do me harm, deliberately

setting these parasites against me. Better for me

80if you were devouring all my treasure, all my cattle—

if you were the ones, we’d make amends in no time.

We’d approach you for reparations round the town,

demanding our goods till you’d returned the lot.

But now, look, you load my heart with grief—

there’s nothing I can do!”

Filled with anger,

down on the ground he dashed the speaker’s scepter—

bursting into tears. Pity seized the assembly.

All just sat there, silent…

no one had the heart to reply with harshness.

90Only Antinous, who found it in himself to say,

“So high and mighty, Telemachus—such unbridled rage!

Well now, fling your accusations at us?

Think to pin the blame on us? You think again.

It’s not the suitors here who deserve the blame,

it’s your own dear mother, the matchless queen of cunning.

Look here. For three years now, getting on to four,

she’s played it fast and loose with all our hearts,

building each man’s hopes—

dangling promises, dropping hints to each—

100but all the while with something else in mind.

This was her latest masterpiece of guile:

she set up a great loom in the royal halls

and she began to weave, and the weaving finespun,

the yarns endless, and she would lead us on: ‘Young men,

my suitors, now that King Odysseus is no more,

go slowly, keen as you are to marry me, until

I can finish off this web…

so my weaving won’t all fray and come to nothing.

This is a shroud for old lord Laertes, for that day

110when the deadly fate that lays us out at last will take him down.

I dread the shame my countrywomen would heap upon me,

yes, if a man of such wealth should lie in state

without a shroud for cover.’

Her very words,

and despite our pride and passion we believed her.

So by day she’d weave at her great and growing web—

by night, by the light of torches set beside her,

she would unravel all she’d done. Three whole years

she deceived us blind, seduced us with this scheme…

Then, when the wheeling seasons brought the fourth year on,

120one of her women, in on the queen’s secret, told the truth

and we caught her in the act—unweaving her gorgeous web.

So she finished it off. Against her will. We forced her.

Now Telemachus, here is how the suitors answer you—

you burn it in your mind, you and all our people:

send your mother back! Direct her to marry

whomever her father picks, whoever pleases her.

So long as she persists in tormenting us,

quick to exploit the gifts Athena gave her—

a skilled hand for elegant work, a fine mind

130and subtle wiles too—we’ve never heard the like,

not even in old stories sung of all Achaea’s

well-coifed queens who graced the years gone by:

133Mycenae crowned with garlands, Tyro and Alcmena…

Not one could equal Penelope for intrigue

but in this case she intrigued beyond all limits.

So, we will devour your worldly goods and wealth

as long as she holds out, holds to that course

the gods have charted deep inside her heart.

Great renown she wins for herself, no doubt,

140great loss for you in treasure. We’ll not go back

to our old estates or leave for other parts,

not till she weds the Argive man she fancies.”

But with calm good sense Telemachus replied:

“Antinous, how can I drive my mother from our house

against her will, the one who bore me, reared me too?

My father is worlds away, dead or alive, who knows?

Imagine the high price I’d have to pay Icarius

if all on my own I send my mother home.

Oh what I would suffer from her father—

150and some dark god would hurt me even more

when mother, leaving her own house behind,

152calls down her withering Furies on my head,

and our people’s cries of shame would hound my heels.

I will never issue that ultimatum to my mother.

And you, if you have any shame in your own hearts,

you must leave my palace! See to your feasting elsewhere,

devour your own possessions, house to house by turns.

But if you decide the fare is better, richer here,

destroying one man’s goods and going scot-free,

160all right then, carve away!

But I’ll cry out to the everlasting gods in hopes

that Zeus will pay you back with a vengeance—all of you

destroyed in my house while I go scot-free myself!”

And to seal his prayer, farseeing Zeus sent down a sign.

He launched two eagles soaring high from a mountain ridge

and down they glided, borne on the wind’s draft a moment,

wing to wingtip, pinions straining taut till just

above the assembly’s throbbing hum they whirled,

suddenly, wings thrashing, wild onslaught of wings

170and banking down at the crowd’s heads—a glaring, fatal sign—

talons slashing each other, tearing cheeks and throats

172they swooped away on the right through homes and city.

All were dumbstruck, watching the eagles trail from sight,

people brooding, deeply, what might come to pass…

175Until the old warrior Halitherses,

176Mastor’s son, broke the silence for them—

the one who outperformed all men of his time

at reading bird-signs, sounding out the omens,

rose and spoke, distraught for each man there:

180“Hear me, men of Ithaca! Hear what I have to say,

though my revelations strike the suitors first of all—

a great disaster is rolling like a breaker toward their heads.

Clearly Odysseus won’t be far from loved ones any longer—

now, right now, he’s somewhere near, I tell you,

breeding bloody death for all these suitors here,

pains aplenty too for the rest of us who live

in Ithaca’s sunlit air.

Long before that,

we must put heads together, find some way

to stop these men, or let them stop themselves.

190Better for them that way, by far. I myself

am no stranger to prophecy—I can see it now!

Odysseus… all is working out for him, I say,

just as I said it would that day the Argives sailed

for Troy and the mastermind of battle boarded with them.

I said then: after many blows, and all his shipmates lost,

after twenty years had wheeled by, he would come home,

unrecognized by all…

and now, look, it all comes to pass!”

“Stop, old man!”

Eurymachus, Polybus’ son, rose up to take him on.

200“Go home and babble your omens to your children—

save them from some catastrophe coming soon.

I’m a better hand than you at reading portents.

Flocks of birds go fluttering under the sun’s rays,

not all are fraught with meaning. Odysseus?

He’s dead now, far from home—

would to god that you’d died with him too.

We’d have escaped your droning prophecies then

and the way you’ve loosed the dogs of this boy’s anger—

your eyes peeled for a house-gift he might give you.

210Here’s my prophecy, bound to come to pass.

If you, you old codger, wise as the ages,

talk him round, incite the boy to riot,

he’ll be the first to suffer, let me tell you.

And you, old man, we’ll clap some fine on you

you’ll weep to pay, a fine to crush your spirit!

Telemachus?

Here in front of you all, here’s my advice for him.

Let him urge his mother back to her father’s house—

her kin will arrange the wedding, provide the gifts,

the array that goes with a daughter dearly loved.

220Not till then, I’d say, will the island princes quit

their taxing courtship. Who’s there to fear? I ask you.

Surely not Telemachus, with all his tiresome threats.

Nor do we balk, old man, at the prophecies you mouth—

they’ll come to grief, they’ll make us hate you more.

The prince’s wealth will be devoured as always,

mercilessly—no reparations, ever… not

while the queen drags out our hopes to wed her,

waiting, day after day, all of us striving hard

to win one matchless beauty. Never courting others,

230bevies of brides who’d suit each noble here.”

Telemachus answered, firm in his resolve:

“Eurymachus—the rest of you fine, brazen suitors—

I have done with appeals to you about these matters.

I’ll say no more. The gods know how things stand

and so do all the Achaeans. And now all I ask

is a good swift ship and a crew of twenty men

to speed me through my passage out and back.

I’m sailing off to Sparta, sandy Pylos too,

for news of my long-lost father’s journey home.

240Someone may tell me something

or I may catch a rumor straight from Zeus,

rumor that carries news to men like nothing else.

Now, if I hear my father’s alive and heading home,

hard-pressed as I am, I’ll brave out one more year.

If I hear he’s dead, no longer among the living,

then back I’ll come to the native land I love,

raise his grave-mound, build his honors high

with the full funeral rites that he deserves—

and give my mother to another husband.”

A declaration,

250and the prince sat down as Mentor took the floor,

Odysseus’ friend-in-arms to whom the king,

sailing off to Troy, committed his household,

ordering one and all to obey the old man

and he would keep things steadfast and secure.

With deep concern for the realm, he rose and warned,

“Hear me, men of Ithaca. Hear what I have to say.

Never let any sceptered king be kind and gentle now,

not with all his heart, or set his mind on justice—

no, let him be cruel and always practice outrage.

260Think: not one of the people whom he ruled

remembers Odysseus now, that godlike man,

and kindly as a father to his children!

I don’t grudge these arrogant suitors for a moment,

weaving their violent work with all their wicked hearts—

they lay their lives on the line when they consume

Odysseus’ worldly goods, blind in their violence,

telling themselves that he’ll come home no more.

But all the rest of you, how you rouse my fury!

Sitting here in silence…

270never a word put forth to curb these suitors,

paltry few as they are and you so many.”

“Mentor!”

272Euenor’s son Leocritus rounded on him, shouting,

“Rabble-rousing fool, now what’s this talk?

Goading them on to try and hold us back!

It’s uphill work, I warn you,

fighting a force like ours—for just a meal.

Even if Odysseus of Ithaca did arrive in person,

to find us well-bred suitors feasting in his halls,

and the man were hell-bent on routing us from the palace—

280little joy would his wife derive from his return,

for all her yearning. Here on the spot he’d meet

a humiliating end if he fought against such odds.

You’re talking nonsense—idiocy.

No more. Come,

dissolve the assembly. Each man return to his holdings.

Mentor and Halitherses can speed our young prince on,

his father’s doddering friends since time began.

He’ll sit tight a good long while, I trust,

scrabbling for news right here in Ithaca—

he’ll never make that trip.”

290This broke up the assembly, keen to leave.

The people scattered quickly, each to his own house,

while the suitors strolled back to King Odysseus’ palace.

Telemachus, walking the beach now, far from others,

washed his hands in the foaming surf and prayed to Pallas:

“Dear god, hear me! Yesterday you came to my house,

you told me to ship out on the misty sea and learn

if father, gone so long, is ever coming home…

Look how my countrymen—the suitors most of all,

the pernicious bullies—foil each move I make.”

300Athena came to his prayer from close at hand,

for all the world with Mentor’s build and voice,

and she urged him on with winging words: “Telemachus,

you’ll lack neither courage nor sense from this day on,

not if your father’s spirit courses through your veins—

now there was a man, I’d say, in words and action both!

So how can your journey end in shipwreck or defeat?

Only if you were not his stock, Penelope’s too,

then I’d fear your hopes might come to grief.

Few sons are the equals of their fathers;

310most fall short, all too few surpass them.

But you, brave and adept from this day on—

Odysseus’ cunning has hardly given out in you—

there’s every hope that you will reach your goal.

Put them out of your mind, these suitors’ schemes and plots.

They’re madmen. Not a shred of sense or decency in the crowd.

Nor can they glimpse the death and black doom hovering

just at their heads to crush them all in one short day.

But you, the journey that stirs you now is not far off,

not with the likes of me, your father’s friend and yours,

320to rig you a swift ship and be your shipmate too.

Now home you go and mix with the suitors there.

But get your rations ready,

pack them all in vessels, the wine in jars,

and barley-meal—the marrow of men’s bones—

in durable skins, while I make rounds in town

and quickly enlist your crew of volunteers.

Lots of ships in seagirt Ithaca, old and new.

I’ll look them over, choose the best in sight,

we’ll fit her out and launch her into the sea at once!”

330And so Athena, daughter of Zeus, assured him.

No lingering now—he heard the goddess’ voice—

but back he went to his house with aching heart

and there at the palace found the brazen suitors

skinning goats in the courtyard, singeing pigs for roasting.

Antinous, smiling warmly, sauntered up to the prince,

grasped his hand and coaxed him, savoring his name:

“Telemachus, my high and mighty, fierce young friend,

no more nursing those violent words and actions now.

Come, eat and drink with us, just like the old days.

340Whatever you want our people will provide. A ship

and a picked crew to speed you to holy Pylos,

out for the news about your noble father.”

But self-possessed Telemachus drew the line:

“Antinous, now how could I dine with you in peace

and take my pleasure? You ruffians carousing here!

Isn’t it quite enough that you, my mother’s suitors,

have ravaged it all, my very best, these many years,

while I was still a boy? But now that I’m full-grown

and can hear the truth from others, absorb it too—

350now, yes, that the anger seethes inside me…

I’ll stop at nothing to hurl destruction at your heads,

whether I go to Pylos or sit tight here at home.

But the trip I speak of will not end in failure.

Go I will, as a passenger, nothing more,

since I don’t seem to command my own crew.

That, I’m sure, is the way that suits you best.”

With this

he nonchalantly drew his hand from Antinous’ hand

while the suitors, busy feasting in the halls,

mocked and taunted him, flinging insults now.

360“God help us,” one young buck kept shouting,

“he wants to slaughter us all!

He’s off to sandy Pylos to hire cutthroats,

even Sparta perhaps, so hot to have our heads.

Why, he’d rove as far as Ephyra’s dark rich soil

and run back home with lethal poison, slip it

into the bowl and wipe us out with drink!”

“Who knows?” another young blade up and ventured.

“Off in that hollow ship of his, he just might drown,

far from his friends, a drifter like his father.

370What a bore! He’d double our work for us,

371splitting up his goods, parceling out his house

to his mother and the man who weds the queen.”

So they scoffed

but Telemachus headed down to his father’s storeroom,

broad and vaulted, piled high with gold and bronze,

chests packed with clothing, vats of redolent oil.

And there, standing in close ranks against the wall,

were jars of seasoned, mellow wine, holding the drink

unmixed inside them, fit for a god, waiting the day

Odysseus, worn by hardship, might come home again.

380Doors, snugly fitted, doubly hung, were bolted shut

and a housekeeper was in charge by night and day—

her care, her vigilance, guarding all those treasures—

Eurycleia the daughter of Ops, Pisenor’s son.

Telemachus called her into the storeroom: “Come, nurse,

draw me off some wine in smaller traveling jars,

mellow, the finest vintage you’ve been keeping,

next to what you reserve for our unlucky king—

in case Odysseus might drop in from the blue

and cheat the deadly spirits, make it home.

390Fill me an even dozen, seal them tightly.

Pour me barley in well-stitched leather bags,

twenty measures of meal, your stone-ground best.

But no one else must know. These rations now,

put them all together. I’ll pick them up myself,

toward evening, just about the time that mother

climbs to her room and thinks of turning in.

I’m sailing off to Sparta, sandy Pylos too,

for news of my dear father’s journey home.

Perhaps I’ll catch some rumor.”

A wail of grief—

400and his fond old nurse burst out in protest, sobbing:

“Why, dear child, what craziness got into your head?

Why bent on rambling over the face of the earth?—

a darling only son! Your father’s worlds away,

god’s own Odysseus, dead in some strange land.

And these brutes here, just wait, the moment you’re gone

they’ll all be scheming against you. Kill you by guile,

they will, and carve your birthright up in pieces.

No, sit tight here, guard your own things here.

Don’t go roving over the barren salt sea—

no need to suffer so!”

410“Courage, old woman,”

thoughtful Telemachus tried to reassure her,

“there’s a god who made this plan.

But swear you won’t say anything to my mother.

Not till ten or a dozen days have passed

or she misses me herself and learns I’m gone.

She mustn’t mar her lovely face with tears.”

The old one swore a solemn oath to the gods

and vowing she would never breathe a word,

quickly drew off wine in two-eared jars

420and poured barley in well-stitched leather bags.

Telemachus returned to the hall and joined the suitors.

Then bright-eyed Pallas thought of one more step.

Disguised as the prince, the goddess roamed through town,

pausing beside each likely crewman, giving orders:

“Gather beside our ship at nightfall—be there.”

426She asked Noëmon, Phronius’ generous son,

to lend her a swift ship. He gladly volunteered.

The sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark.

Now the goddess hauled the swift ship down to the water,

430stowed in her all the tackle well-rigged vessels carry,

moored her well away at the harbor’s very mouth

and once the crew had gathered, rallying round,

she heartened every man.

Then bright-eyed Pallas thought of one last thing.

Back she went to King Odysseus’ halls and there

she showered sweet oblivion over the suitors,

dazing them as they drank, knocking cups from hands.

No more loitering now, their eyes weighed down with sleep,

they rose and groped through town to find their beds.

440But calling the prince outside his timbered halls,

taking the build and voice of Mentor once again,

flashing-eyed Athena urged him on: “Telemachus,

your comrades-at-arms are ready at the oars,

waiting for your command to launch. So come,

on with our voyage now, we’re wasting time.”

And Pallas Athena sped away in the lead

as he followed in her footsteps, man and goddess.

Once they reached the ship at the water’s edge

they found their long-haired shipmates on the beach.

450The prince, inspired, gave his first commands:

“Come, friends, get the rations aboard!

They’re piled in the palace now.

My mother knows nothing of this. No servants either.

Only one has heard our plan.”

He led them back

and the men fell in and fetched down all the stores

and stowed them briskly, deep in the well-ribbed holds

as Odysseus’ son directed. Telemachus climbed aboard.

Athena led the way, assuming the pilot’s seat

reserved astern, and he sat close beside her.

460Cables cast off, the crew swung to the oarlocks.

Bright-eyed Athena sent them a stiff following wind

rippling out of the west, ruffling over the wine-dark sea

as Telemachus shouted out commands to all his shipmates:

“All lay hands to tackle!” They sprang to orders,

hoisting the pinewood mast, they stepped it firm

in its block amidships, lashed it fast with stays

and with braided rawhide halyards hauled the white sail high.

Suddenly wind hit full and the canvas bellied out

and a dark blue wave, foaming up at the bow,

470sang out loud and strong as the ship made way,

skimming the whitecaps, cutting toward her goal.

All running gear secure in the swift black craft,

they set up bowls and brimmed them high with wine

and poured libations out to the everlasting gods

who never die—to Athena first of all,

the daughter of Zeus with flashing sea-gray eyes—

and the ship went plunging all night long and through the dawn.

BOOK THREE

King Nestor Remembers

A
s the sun sprang up, leaving the brilliant waters in its wake,

climbing the bronze sky to shower light on immortal gods

and mortal men across the plowlands ripe with grain—

4the ship pulled into Pylos, Neleus’ storied citadel,

where the people lined the beaches,

6sacrificing sleek black bulls to Poseidon,

god of the sea-blue mane who shakes the earth.

They sat in nine divisions, each five hundred strong,

each division offering up nine bulls, and while the people

10tasted the innards, burned the thighbones for the god,

the craft and crew came heading straight to shore.

Striking sail, furling it in the balanced ship,

they moored her well and men swung down on land.

Telemachus climbed out last, with Athena far in front

and the bright-eyed goddess urged the prince along:

“Telemachus, no more shyness, this is not the time!

We sailed the seas for this, for news of your father—

where does he lie buried? what fate did he meet?

19So go right up to Nestor, breaker of horses.

20We’ll make him yield the secrets of his heart.

Press him yourself to tell the whole truth:

he’ll never lie—the man is far too wise.”

The prince replied, wise in his own way too,

“How can I greet him, Mentor, even approach the king?

I’m hardly adept at subtle conversation.

Someone my age might feel shy, what’s more,

interrogating an older man.”

“Telemachus,”

the bright-eyed goddess Athena reassured him,

“some of the words you’ll find within yourself,

30the rest some power will inspire you to say.

You least of all—I know—

were born and reared without the gods’ good will.”

And Pallas Athena sped away in the lead

as he followed in her footsteps—man and goddess

35gained the place where the Pylians met and massed.

There sat Nestor among his sons as friends around them

decked the banquet, roasted meats and skewered strips for broiling.

As soon as they saw the strangers, all came crowding down,

waving them on in welcome, urging them to sit.

40Nestor’s son Pisistratus, first to reach them,

grasped their hands and sat them down at the feast

on fleecy throws spread out along the sandbanks,

43flanking his brother Thrasymedes and his father.

He gave them a share of innards, poured some wine

in a golden cup and, lifting it warmly toward Athena,

46daughter of Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder,

greeted the goddess now with an invitation:

“Say a prayer to lord Poseidon, stranger,

his is the feast you’ve found on your arrival.

50But once you’ve made your libation and your prayer—

all according to ancient custom—hand this cup

of hearty, seasoned wine to your comrade here

so he can pour forth too. He too, I think,

should pray to the deathless ones himself.

All men need the gods…

but the man is younger, just about my age.

That’s why I give the gold cup first to you.”

With that

Pisistratus placed in her hand the cup of mellow wine

and Pallas rejoiced at the prince’s sense of tact

60in giving the golden winecup first to her.

At once she prayed intensely to Poseidon:

“Hear me, Sea-lord, you who embrace the earth—

don’t deny our wishes, bring our prayers to pass!

First, then, to Nestor and all his sons grant glory.

Then to all these Pylians, for their splendid rites

grant a reward that warms their gracious hearts.

And last, Poseidon, grant Telemachus and myself

safe passage home, the mission accomplished

that sped us here in our rapid black ship.”

70So she prayed, and brought it all to pass.

She offered the rich two-handled cup to Telemachus,

Odysseus’ son, who echoed back her prayer word for word.

They roasted the prime cuts, pulled them off the spits

and sharing out the portions, fell to the royal feast.

Once they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

old Nestor the noble charioteer began, at last:

“Now’s the time, now they’ve enjoyed their meal,

to probe our guests and find out who they are.

Strangers—friends, who are you?

80Where did you sail from, over the running sea-lanes?

81Out on a trading spree or roving the waves like pirates,

sea-wolves raiding at will, who risk their lives

to plunder other men?”

Poised Telemachus answered,

filled with heart, the heart Athena herself inspired,

to ask for the news about his father, gone so long,

and make his name throughout the mortal world.

“Nestor, son of Neleus, Achaea’s pride and glory—

where are we from, you ask? I will tell you all.

We hail from Ithaca, under the heights of Nion.

90Our mission here is personal, nothing public now.

I am on the trail of my father’s widespread fame,

you see, searching the earth to catch some news

of great-hearted King Odysseus who, they say,

fought with you to demolish Troy some years ago.

95About all the rest who fought the Trojans there,

we know where each one died his wretched death,

but father… even his death—

the son of Cronus shrouds it all in mystery.

No one can say for certain where he died,

100whether he went down on land at enemy hands

101or out on the open sea in Amphitrite’s breakers.

That’s why I’ve come to plead before you now,

if you can tell me about his cruel death:

perhaps you saw him die with your own eyes

or heard the wanderer’s end from someone else.

106More than all other men, that man was born for pain.

Don’t soften a thing, from pity, respect for me—

tell me, clearly, all your eyes have witnessed.

I beg you—if ever my father, lord Odysseus,

110pledged you his word and made it good in action

once on the fields of Troy where you Achaeans suffered,

remember his story now, tell me the truth.”

Nestor the noble charioteer replied at length:

“Ah dear boy, since you call back such memories,

such living hell we endured in distant Troy—

we headstrong fighting forces of Achaea—

so many raids from shipboard down the foggy sea,

118cruising for plunder, wherever Achilles led the way;

119so many battles round King Priam’s walls we fought,

120so many gone, our best and bravest fell.

121There Ajax lies, the great man of war.

There lies Achilles too.

123There Patroclus, skilled as the gods in counsel.

And there my own dear son, both strong and staunch,

125Antilochus—lightning on his feet and every inch a fighter!

But so many other things we suffered, past that count—

what mortal in this wide world could tell it all?

Not if you sat and probed his memory, five, six years,

delving for all the pains our brave Achaeans bore there.

130Your patience would fray, you’d soon head for home…

Nine years we wove a web of disaster for those Trojans,

pressing them hard with every tactic known to man,

and only after we slaved did Zeus award us victory.

And no one there could hope to rival Odysseus,

not for sheer cunning—

at every twist of strategy he excelled us all.

Your father, yes, if you are in fact his son…

I look at you and a sense of wonder takes me.

Your way with words—it’s just like his—I’d swear

140no youngster could ever speak like you, so apt, so telling.

As long as I and great Odysseus soldiered there,

why, never once did we speak out at odds,

neither in open muster nor in royal council:

forever one in mind, in judgment balanced, shrewd,

we mapped our armies’ plans so things might turn out best.

But then, once we’d sacked King Priam’s craggy city,

Zeus contrived in his heart a fatal homeward run

for all the Achaeans who were fools, at least,

dishonest too, so many met a disastrous end,

150thanks to the lethal rage

of the mighty Father’s daughter. Eyes afire,

Athena set them feuding, Atreus’ two sons…

They summoned all the Achaean ranks to muster,

rashly, just at sunset—no hour to rally troops—

and in they straggled, sodden with wine, our heroes.

The brothers harangued them, told them why they’d met:

a crisis—Menelaus urging the men to fix their minds

on the voyage home across the sea’s broad back,

but it brought no joy to Agamemnon, not at all.

160He meant to detain us there and offer victims,

anything to appease Athena’s dreadful wrath—

poor fool, he never dreamed Athena would not comply.

The minds of the everlasting gods don’t change so quickly.

So the two of them stood there, wrangling, back and forth

till the armies sprang up, their armor clashing, ungodly uproar—

the two plans split the ranks. That night we barely slept,

seething with hard feelings against our own comrades,

for Zeus was brooding over us, poised to seal our doom…

At dawn, half of us hauled our vessels down to sea,

170we stowed our plunder, our sashed and lovely women.

But half the men held back, camped on the beach,

waiting it out for Agamemnon’s next commands

while our contingent embarked—

we pushed off and sailed at a fast clip

as a god smoothed out the huge troughing swells.

176We reached Tenedos quickly, sacrificed to the gods,

the crews keen for home, but a quick return was not

in Zeus’s plans, not yet: that cruel power

loosed a cursed feud on us once again.

180Some swung their rolling warships hard about—

Odysseus sailed them back, the flexible, wily king,

veering over to Agamemnon now to shore his fortunes up.

But not I. Massing the ships that came in my flotilla,

I sped away as the god’s mischief kept on brewing,

185dawning on me now. And Tydeus’ fighting son

186Diomedes fled too, rousing all his comrades.

Late in the day the red-haired Menelaus joined us,

188overtook us at Lesbos, debating the long route home:

189whether to head north, over the top of rocky Chios,

190skirting Psyrie, keeping that island off to port

191or run south of Chios, by Mimas’ gusty cape.

We asked the god for a sign. He showed us one,

he urged us to cut out on the middle passage,

194straight to Euboea now,

escape a catastrophe, fast as we could sail!

A shrilling wind came up, stiff, driving us on

and on we raced, over the sea-lanes rife with fish

198and we made Geraestus Point in the dead of night.

Many thighs of bulls we offered Poseidon there—

200thank god we’d crossed that endless reach of sea.

Then on the fourth day out the crews of Diomedes,

breaker of horses, moored their balanced ships

at Argos port, but I held course for Pylos, yes,

and never once did the good strong wind go limp

from the first day the god unleashed its blast.

And so, dear boy, I made it home from Troy,

in total ignorance, knowing nothing of their fates,

the ones who stayed behind:

who escaped with their lives and who went down.

210But still, all I’ve gathered by hearsay, sitting here

in my own house—that you’ll learn, it’s only right,

I’ll hide nothing now.

212They say the Myrmidons,

213those savage spearmen led by the shining son

of lionhearted Achilles, traveled home unharmed.

215Philoctetes the gallant son of Poias, safe as well.

216Idomeneus brought his whole contingent back to Crete,

all who’d escaped the war—the sea snatched none from him.

But Atreus’ son Agamemnon… you yourselves, even

in far-off Ithaca, must have heard how he returned,

220how Aegisthus hatched the king’s horrendous death.

But what a price he paid, in blood, in suffering.

Ah how fine it is, when a man is brought down,

to leave a son behind! Orestes took revenge,

he killed that cunning, murderous Aegisthus,

who’d killed his famous father.

And you, my friend—

how tall and handsome I see you now—be brave, you too,

so men to come will sing your praises down the years.”

Telemachus, weighing the challenge closely, answered,

“Oh Nestor, son of Neleus, Achaea’s pride and glory,

230what a stroke of revenge that was! All Achaeans

will spread Orestes’ fame across the world,

a song for those to come.

If only the gods would arm me in such power

I’d take revenge on the lawless, brazen suitors

riding roughshod over me, plotting reckless outrage.

But for me the gods have spun out no such joy,

for my father or myself. I must bear up,

that’s all.”

And the old charioteer replied,

“Now that you mention it, dear boy, I do recall

240a mob of suitors, they say, besets your mother

there in your own house, against your will,

and plots your ruin. Tell me, though, do you

let yourself be so abused, or do people round about,

stirred up by the prompting of some god, despise you now?

Who knows if he will return someday to take revenge

on all their violence? Single-handed perhaps

or with an Argive army at his back? If only

the bright-eyed goddess chose to love you just

as she lavished care on brave Odysseus, years ago

250in the land of Troy where we Achaeans struggled!

I’ve never seen the immortals show so much affection

as Pallas openly showed him, standing by your father—

if only she’d favor you, tend you with all her heart,

many a suitor then would lose all thought of marriage,

blotted out forever.”

“Never, your majesty,”

Telemachus countered gravely, “that will never

come to pass, I know. What you say dumbfounds me,

staggers imagination! Hope, hope as I will,

that day will never dawn…

not even if the gods should will it so.”

260“Telemachus!”

Pallas Athena broke in sharply, her eyes afire—

“What’s this nonsense slipping through your teeth?

It’s light work for a willing god to save a mortal

even half the world away. Myself, I’d rather

sail through years of trouble and labor home

and see that blessed day, than hurry home

to die at my own hearth like Agamemnon,

killed by Aegisthus’ cunning—by his own wife.

269But the great leveler, Death: not even the gods

270can defend a man, not even one they love, that day

when fate takes hold and lays him out at last.”

“Mentor,”

wise Telemachus said, “distraught as we are for him,

let’s speak of this no more. My father’s return?

It’s inconceivable now. Long ago the undying gods

have sealed his death, his black doom. But now

there’s another question I would put to Nestor:

Nestor excels all men for sense and justice,

his knowledge of the world.

Three generations he has ruled, they say,

280and to my young eyes he seems a deathless god!

Nestor, son of Neleus, tell me the whole story—

how did the great king Agamemnon meet his death?

Where was Menelaus? What fatal trap did he set,

that treacherous Aegisthus, to bring down a man

far stronger than himself? Was Menelaus gone

from Achaean Argos, roving the world somewhere,

so the coward found the nerve to kill the king?”

And old Nestor the noble charioteer replied:

289“Gladly, my boy, I’ll tell you the story first to last…

290Right you are, you guess what would have happened

if red-haired Menelaus, arriving back from Troy,

had found Aegisthus alive in Agamemnon’s palace.

No barrow piled high on the earth for his dead body,

no, the dogs and birds would have feasted on his corpse,

sprawled on the plain outside the city gates, and no one,

no woman in all Achaea, would have wept a moment,

such a monstrous crime the man contrived!

But there we were, camped at Troy, battling out

the long hard campaign while he at his ease at home,

300in the depths of Argos, stallion-country—he lay siege

to the wife of Agamemnon, luring, enticing her with talk.

At first, true, she spurned the idea of such an outrage,

303Clytemnestra the queen, her will was faithful still.

And there was a man, what’s more, a bard close by,

to whom Agamemnon, setting sail for Troy,

gave strict commands to guard his wife. But then,

that day the doom of the gods had bound her to surrender,

Aegisthus shipped the bard away to a desert island,

marooned him there, sweet prize for the birds of prey,

310and swept her off to his own house, lover lusting for lover.

And many thighbones he burned on the gods’ holy altars,

many gifts he hung on the temple walls—gold, brocades—

in thanks for a conquest past his maddest hopes.

Now we,

you see, were sailing home from Troy in the same squadron,

Menelaus and I, comrades-in-arms from years of war.

316But as we rounded holy Sounion, Athens’ headland,

317lord Apollo attacked Atrides’ helmsman, aye,

with his gentle shafts he shot the man to death—

an iron grip on the tiller, the craft scudding fast—

320Phrontis, Onetor’s son, who excelled all men alive

at steering ships when gales bore down in fury.

So Menelaus, straining to sail on, was held back

till he could bury his mate with fitting rites.

But once he’d got off too, plowing the wine-dark sea

325in his ribbed ships, and made a run to Malea’s beetling cape,

farseeing Zeus decided to give the man rough sailing,

poured a hurricane down upon him, shrilling winds,

giant, rearing whitecaps, monstrous, mountains high.

There at a stroke he cut the fleet in half and drove

330one wing to Crete, where Cydonians make their homes

331along the Iardanus River. Now, there’s a sheer cliff

332plunging steep to the surf at the farthest edge of Gortyn,

out on the mist-bound sea, where the South Wind piles breakers,

334huge breakers, left of the headland’s horn, toward Phaestos,

with only a low reef to block the crushing tides.

In they sailed, and barely escaped their death—

the ships’ crews, that is—

the rollers smashed their hulls against the rocks.

But as for the other five with pitch-black prows,

340the wind and current swept them on toward Egypt.

So Menelaus, amassing a hoard of stores and gold,

was off cruising his ships to foreign ports of call

while Aegisthus hatched his vicious work at home.

344Seven years he lorded over Mycenae rich in gold,

once he’d killed Agamemnon—he ground the people down.

346But the eighth year ushered in his ruin, Prince Orestes

home from Athens, yes, he cut him down, that cunning,

murderous Aegisthus, who’d killed his famous father.

Vengeance done, he held a feast for the Argives,

350to bury his hated mother, craven Aegisthus too,

the very day Menelaus arrived, lord of the warcry,

freighted with all the wealth his ships could carry.

So you,

dear boy, take care. Don’t rove from home too long,

too far, leaving your own holdings unprotected—

crowds in your palace so brazen

they’ll carve up all your wealth, devour it all,

and then your journey here will come to nothing.

Still I advise you, urge you to visit Menelaus.

He’s back from abroad at last, from people so removed

360you might abandon hope of ever returning home,

once the winds had driven you that far off course,

into a sea so vast not even cranes could wing their way

in one year’s flight—so vast it is, so awesome…

So, off you go with your ships and shipmates now.

Or if you’d rather go by land, there’s team and chariot,

my sons at your service too, and they’ll escort you

367to sunny Lacedaemon, home of the red-haired king.

Press him yourself to tell the whole truth:

he’ll never lie—the man is far too wise.”

So he closed

370as the sun set and darkness swept across the earth

and the bright-eyed goddess Pallas spoke for all:

“There was a tale, old soldier, so well told.

373Come, cut out the victims’ tongues and mix the wine,

so once we’ve poured libations out to the Sea-lord

and every other god, we’ll think of sleep. High time—

the light’s already sunk in the western shadows.

It’s wrong to linger long at the gods’ feast;

we must be on our way.”

Zeus’s daughter—

they all hung closely on every word she said.

380Heralds sprinkled water over their hands for rinsing,

the young men brimmed the mixing bowls with wine,

they tipped first drops for the god in every cup

then poured full rounds for all. They rose and flung

the victims’ tongues on the fire and poured libations out.

When they’d poured, and drunk to their hearts’ content,

Athena and Prince Telemachus both started up

to head for their ship at once.

But Nestor held them there, objecting strongly:

“Zeus forbid—and the other deathless gods as well—

390that you resort to your ship and put my house behind

like a rank pauper’s without a stitch of clothing,

no piles of rugs, no blankets in his place

for host and guests to slumber soft in comfort.

Why, I’ve plenty of fine rugs and blankets here.

No, by god, the true son of my good friend Odysseus

won’t bed down on a ship’s deck, not while I’m alive

or my sons are left at home to host our guests,

whoever comes to our palace, newfound friends.”

“Dear old man,

you’re right,” Athena exclaimed, her eyes brightening now.

400“Telemachus should oblige you. Much the better way.

Let him follow you now, sleep in your halls,

but I’ll go back to our trim black ship,

hearten the crew and give each man his orders.

I’m the only veteran in their ranks, I tell you.

All the rest, of an age with brave Telemachus,

are younger men who sailed with him as friends.

I’ll bed down there by the dark hull tonight,

408at dawn push off for the proud Cauconians.

Those people owe me a debt long overdue,

410and no mean sum, believe me.

But you, seeing my friend is now your guest,

speed him on his way with a chariot and your son

and give him the finest horses that you have,

bred for stamina, trained to race the wind.”

With that the bright-eyed goddess winged away

in an eagle’s form and flight.

Amazement fell on all the Achaeans there.

The old king, astonished by what he’d seen,

grasped Telemachus’ hand and cried out to the prince,

420“Dear boy—never fear you’ll be a coward or defenseless,

not if at your young age the gods will guard you so.

Of all who dwell on Olympus, this was none but she,

423Zeus’s daughter, the glorious one, his third born,

who prized your gallant father among the Argives.

Now, O Queen, be gracious! Give us high renown,

myself, my children, my loyal wife and queen.

And I will make you a sacrifice, a yearling heifer

broad in the brow, unbroken, never yoked by men.

I’ll offer it up to you—I’ll sheathe its horns in gold.”

430So he prayed, and Pallas Athena heard his prayer.

And Nestor the noble chariot-driver led them on,

his sons and sons-in-law, back to his regal palace.

Once they reached the storied halls of the aged king

they sat on rows of low and high-backed chairs.

As they arrived the old man mixed them all a bowl,

stirring the hearty wine, seasoned eleven years

before a servant broached it, loosed its seal.

Mulling it in the bowl, old Nestor poured

a libation out, praying hard to Pallas Athena,

440daughter of Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder.

Once they had poured their offerings, drunk their fill,

the Pylians went to rest, each in his own house.

But the noble chariot-driver let Telemachus,

King Odysseus’ son, sleep at the palace now,

on a corded bed inside the echoing colonnade,

with Prince Pisistratus close beside him there,

the young spearman, already captain of armies,

though the last son still unwed within the halls.

The king retired to chambers deep in his lofty house

450where the queen his wife arranged and shared their bed.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

old Nestor the noble chariot-driver climbed from bed,

went out and took his seat on the polished stones,

a bench glistening white, rubbed with glossy oil,

placed for the king before his looming doors.

There Neleus held his sessions years ago,

a match for the gods in counsel,

but his fate had long since forced him down to Death.

Now royal Nestor in turn, Achaea’s watch and ward,

460sat there holding the scepter while his sons,

coming out of their chambers, clustered round him,

462hovering near: Echephron, Stratius, Perseus

463and Aretus, Thrasymedes like a god, and sixth,

young lord Pisistratus came to join their ranks.

They escorted Prince Telemachus in to sit beside them.

Nestor, noble charioteer, began the celebration:

“Quickly, my children, carry out my wishes now

so I may please the gods, Athena first of all—

she came to me at Poseidon’s flowing feast,

470Athena in all her glory!

Now someone go to the fields to fetch a heifer,

lead her here at once—a herdsman drive her in.

Someone hurry down to Prince Telemachus’ black ship

and bring up all his crewmen, leave just two behind.

475And another tell our goldsmith, skilled Laerces,

to come and sheathe the heifer’s horns in gold.

The rest stay here together. Tell the maids

inside the hall to prepare a sumptuous feast—

bring seats and firewood, bring pure water too.”

480They all pitched in to carry out his orders.

The heifer came from the fields, the crewmen came

from brave Telemachus’ ship, and the smith came in

with all his gear in hand, the tools of his trade,

the anvil, hammer and well-wrought tongs he used

485for working gold. And Athena came as well

to attend her sacred rites.

The old horseman passed the gold to the smith,

and twining the foil, he sheathed the heifer’s horns

so the goddess’ eyes might dazzle, delighted with the gift.

490Next Stratius and Echephron led the beast by the horns.

Aretus, coming up from the storeroom, brought them

lustral water filling a flower-braided bowl,

in his other hand, the barley in a basket.

Thrasymedes, staunch in combat, stood ready,

whetted ax in his grasp to cut the heifer down,

and Perseus held the basin for the blood.

Now Nestor the old charioteer began the rite.

498Pouring the lustral water, scattering barley-meal,

he lifted up his ardent prayers to Pallas Athena,

500launching the sacrifice, flinging onto the fire

the first tufts of hair from the victim’s head.

Prayers said, the scattering barley strewn,

suddenly Nestor’s son impetuous Thrasymedes

strode up close and struck—the ax chopped

the neck tendons through—

and the blow stunned

the heifer’s strength—

The women shrilled their cry,

Nestor’s daughters, sons’ wives and his own loyal wife

508Eurydice, Clymenus’ eldest daughter. Then, hoisting up

the victim’s head from the trampled earth, they held her fast

510as the captain of men Pisistratus slashed her throat.

Dark blood gushed forth, life ebbed from her limbs—

they quartered her quickly, cut the thighbones out

and all according to custom wrapped them round in fat,

a double fold sliced clean and topped with strips of flesh.

And the old king burned these over dried split wood

and over the fire poured out glistening wine

while young men at his side held five-pronged forks.

Once they’d burned the bones and tasted the organs,

they sliced the rest into pieces, spitted them on skewers

520and raising points to the fire, broiled all the meats.

521During the ritual lovely Polycaste, youngest daughter

of Nestor, Neleus’ son, had bathed Telemachus.

Rinsing him off now, rubbing him down with oil,

she drew a shirt and handsome cape around him.

Out of his bath he stepped, glistening like a god,

strode in and sat by the old commander Nestor.

They roasted the prime cuts, pulled them off the spits

and sat down to the feast while ready stewards saw

to rounds of wine and kept the gold cups flowing.

530When they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Nestor the noble chariot-driver issued orders:

“Hurry, my boys! Bring Telemachus horses,

a good full-maned team—

hitch them to a chariot—he must be off at once.”

They listened closely, snapped to his commands

and hitched a rapid team to a chariot’s yoke in haste.

A housekeeper stowed some bread and wine aboard

and meats too, food fit for the sons of kings.

Telemachus vaulted onto the splendid chariot—

540right beside him Nestor’s son Pisistratus,

captain of armies, boarded, seized the reins,

whipped the team to a run and on the horses flew,

holding nothing back, out into open country,

leaving the heights of Pylos fading in their trail,

shaking the yoke across their shoulders all day long.

The sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark

547as they reached Phera, pulling up to Diocles’ halls,

548the son of Ortilochus, son of the Alpheus River.

He gave them a royal welcome; there they slept the night.

550When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

they yoked their pair again, mounted the blazoned car

and out through the gates and echoing colonnade

they whipped the team to a run and on they flew,

holding nothing back—and the princes reached

the wheatlands, straining now for journey’s end,

so fast those purebred stallions raced them on

as the sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark.

BOOK FOUR

The King and Queen of Sparta

A
t last they gained the ravines of Lacedaemon ringed by hills

and drove up to the halls of Menelaus in his glory.

They found the king inside his palace, celebrating

with throngs of kinsmen a double wedding-feast

for his son and lovely daughter. The princess

6he was sending on to the son of great Achilles,

breaker of armies. Years ago Menelaus vowed,

he nodded assent at Troy and pledged her hand

and now the gods were sealing firm the marriage.

10So he was sending her on her way with team and chariot,

north to the Myrmidons’ famous city governed by her groom.

12From Sparta he brought Alector’s daughter as the bride

13for his own full-grown son, the hardy Megapenthes,

14born to him by a slave. To Helen the gods had granted

no more offspring once she had borne her first child,

16the breathtaking Hermione,

17a luminous beauty gold as Aphrodite.

So now

they feasted within the grand, high-roofed palace,

all the kin and clansmen of Menelaus in his glory,

20reveling warmly here as in their midst

an inspired bard sang out and struck his lyre—

and through them a pair of tumblers dashed and sprang,

whirling in leaping handsprings, leading on the dance.

The travelers, Nestor’s shining son and Prince Telemachus,

had brought themselves and their horses to a standstill

26just outside the court when good lord Eteoneus,

passing through the gates now, saw them there,

and the ready aide-in-arms of Menelaus

took the message through his sovereign’s halls

30and stepping close to his master broke the news:

“Strangers have just arrived, your majesty, Menelaus.

Two men, but they look like kin of mighty Zeus himself.

Tell me, should we unhitch their team for them

or send them to someone free to host them well?”

The red-haired king took great offense at that:

36“Never a fool before, Eteoneus, son of Boëthous,

now I see you’re babbling like a child!

Just think of all the hospitality we enjoyed

at the hands of other men before we made it home,

40and god save us from such hard treks in years to come.

Quick, unhitch their team. And bring them in,

strangers, guests, to share our flowing feast.”

Back through the halls he hurried, calling out

to other brisk attendants to follow quickly.

They loosed the sweating team from under the yoke,

tethered them fast by reins inside the horse-stalls,

tossing feed at their hoofs, white barley mixed with wheat,

and canted the chariot up against the polished walls,

shimmering in the sun, then ushered in their guests,

50into that magnificent place. Both struck by the sight,

they marveled up and down the house of the warlord dear to Zeus—

a radiance strong as the moon or rising sun came flooding

through the high-roofed halls of illustrious Menelaus.

Once they’d feasted their eyes with gazing at it all,

into the burnished tubs they climbed and bathed.

56When women had washed them, rubbed them down with oil

and drawn warm fleece and shirts around their shoulders,

they took up seats of honor next to Atrides Menelaus.

A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

60and over a silver basin tipped it out

so they might rinse their hands,

then pulled a gleaming table to their side.

A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve them,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

As a carver lifted platters of meat toward them,

meats of every sort, and set before them golden cups,

the red-haired king Menelaus greeted both guests warmly:

“Help yourselves to food, and welcome! Once you’ve dined

we’ll ask you who you are. But your parents’ blood

70is hardly lost in you. You must be born of kings,

bred by the gods to wield the royal scepter.

No mean men could sire sons like you.”

With those words

he passed them a fat rich loin with his own hands,

the choicest part, that he’d been served himself.

They reached for the good things that lay outspread

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Telemachus, leaning his head close to Nestor’s son,

spoke low to the prince so no one else could hear:

“Look, Pisistratus—joy of my heart, my friend—

80the sheen of bronze, the blaze of gold and amber,

silver, ivory too, through all this echoing mansion!

Surely Zeus’s court on Olympus must be just like this,

the boundless glory of all this wealth inside!

My eyes dazzle… I am struck with wonder.”

But the red-haired warlord overheard his guest

and cut in quickly with winged words for both:

“No man alive could rival Zeus, dear boys,

with his everlasting palace and possessions.

But among men, I must say, few if any

90could rival me in riches. Believe me,

much I suffered, many a mile I roved to haul

such treasures home in my ships. Eight years out,

93wandering off as far as Cyprus, Phoenicia, even Egypt,

94I reached the Ethiopians, Sidonians, Erembians—Libya too,

where lambs no sooner spring from the womb than they grow horns.

96Three times in the circling year the ewes give birth.

So no one, neither king nor shepherd could want

for cheese or mutton, or sweet milk either,

udders swell for the sucklings round the year.

100But while I roamed those lands, amassing a fortune,

a stranger killed my brother, blind to the danger, duped blind—

thanks to the cunning of his cursed, murderous queen!

So I rule all this wealth with no great joy.

You must have heard my story from your fathers,

whoever they are—what hardships I endured,

106how I lost this handsome palace built for the ages,

filled to its depths with hoards of gorgeous things.

Well, would to god I’d stayed right here in my own house

with a third of all that wealth and they were still alive,

110all who died on the wide plain of Troy those years ago,

far from the stallion-land of Argos.

And still,

much as I weep for all my men, grieving sorely,

time and again, sitting here in the royal halls,

now indulging myself in tears, now brushing tears away—

the grief that numbs the spirit gluts us quickly—

for none of all those comrades, pained as I am,

do I grieve as much for one…

that man who makes sleep hateful, even food,

119as I pore over his memory. No one, no Achaean

120labored hard as Odysseus labored or achieved so much.

And how did his struggles end? In suffering for that man;

for me, in relentless, heartbreaking grief for him,

lost and gone so long now—dead or alive, who knows?

How they must mourn him too, Laertes, the old man,

and self-possessed Penelope. Telemachus as well,

the boy he left a babe in arms at home.”

Such memories

stirred in the young prince a deep desire to grieve

for Odysseus. Tears streamed down his cheeks

and wet the ground when he heard his father’s name,

130both hands clutching his purple robe before his eyes.

Menelaus recognized him at once but pondered

whether to let him state his father’s name

or probe him first and prompt him step by step.

While he debated all this now within himself,

Helen emerged from her scented, lofty chamber—

136striking as Artemis with her golden shafts—

and a train of women followed…

138Adreste drew up her carved reclining-chair,

139Alcippe brought a carpet of soft-piled fleece,

140Phylo carried her silver basket given by Alcandre,

141King Polybus’ wife, who made his home in Egyptian Thebes

where the houses overflow with the greatest troves of treasure.

The king gave Menelaus a pair of bathing-tubs in silver,

144two tripods, ten bars of gold, and apart from these

his wife presented Helen her own precious gifts:

a golden spindle, a basket that ran on casters,

solid silver polished off with rims of gold.

Now Phylo her servant rolled it in beside her,

heaped to the brim with yarn prepared for weaving;

150the spindle swathed in violet wool lay tipped across it.

Helen leaned back in her chair, a stool beneath her feet,

and pressed her husband at once for each detail:

“Do we know, my lord Menelaus, who our visitors

claim to be, our welcome new arrivals?

Right or wrong, what can I say? My heart tells me

to come right out and say I’ve never seen such a likeness,

neither in man nor woman—I’m amazed at the sight.

To the life he’s like the son of great Odysseus,

surely he’s Telemachus! The boy that hero left

160a babe in arms at home when all you Achaeans

fought at Troy, launching your headlong battles

just for my sake, shameless whore that I was.”

“My dear, my dear,” the red-haired king assured her,

“now that you mention it, I see the likeness too…

165Odysseus’ feet were like the boy’s, his hands as well,

his glancing eyes, his head, and the fine shock of hair.

Yes, and just now, as I was talking about Odysseus,

remembering how he struggled, suffered, all for me,

a flood of tears came streaming down his face

170and he clutched his purple robe before his eyes.”

“Right you are”—Pisistratus stepped in quickly—

172“son of Atreus, King Menelaus, captain of armies:

here is the son of that great hero, as you say.

But the man is modest, he would be ashamed

to make a show of himself, his first time here,

and interrupt you. We delight in your voice

as if some god were speaking!

The noble horseman Nestor sent me along

to be his escort. Telemachus yearned to see you,

180so you could give him some advice or urge some action.

When a father’s gone, his son takes much abuse

in a house where no one comes to his defense.

So with Telemachus now. His father’s gone.

No men at home will shield him from the worst.”

“Wonderful!” the red-haired king cried out.

“The son of my dearest friend, here in my own house!

That man who performed a hundred feats of arms for me.

And I swore that when he came I’d give him a hero’s welcome,

him above all my comrades—if only Olympian Zeus,

190farseeing Zeus, had granted us both safe passage

home across the sea in our swift trim ships.

Why, I’d have settled a city in Argos for him,

built him a palace, shipped him over from Ithaca,

him and all his wealth, his son, his people too—

emptied one of the cities nestling round about us,

one I rule myself. Both fellow-countrymen then,

197how often we’d have mingled side-by-side!

Nothing could have parted us,

bound by love for each other, mutual delight…

200till death’s dark cloud came shrouding round us both.

But god himself, jealous of all this, no doubt,

robbed that unlucky man, him and him alone,

of the day of his return.”

So Menelaus mused

and stirred in them all a deep desire to grieve.

Helen of Argos, daughter of Zeus, dissolved in tears,

Telemachus wept too, and so did Atreus’ son Menelaus.

Nor could Nestor’s son Pisistratus stay dry-eyed,

remembering now his gallant brother Antilochus,

209cut down by Memnon, splendid son of the Morning.

210Thinking of him, the young prince broke out:

“Old Nestor always spoke of you, son of Atreus,

as the wisest man of all the men he knew,

whenever we talked about you there at home,

questioning back and forth. So now, please,

if it isn’t out of place, indulge me, won’t you?

Myself, I take no joy in weeping over supper.

Morning will soon bring time enough for that.

Not that I’d grudge a tear

for any man gone down to meet his fate.

220What other tribute can we pay to wretched men

than to cut a lock, let tears roll down our cheeks?

And I have a brother of my own among the dead,

and hardly the poorest soldier in our ranks.

You probably knew him. I never met him, never

saw him myself. But they say he outdid our best,

Antilochus—lightning on his feet and every inch a fighter!”

“Well said, my friend,” the red-haired king replied.

“Not even an older man could speak and do as well.

Your father’s son you are—your words have all his wisdom.

230It’s easy to spot the breed of a man whom Zeus

has marked for joy in birth and marriage both.

Take great King Nestor now:

Zeus has blessed him, all his livelong days,

growing rich and sleek in his old age at home,

his sons expert with spears and full of sense.

Well, so much for the tears that caught us just now;

let’s think again of supper. Come, rinse our hands.

Tomorrow, at dawn, will offer me and Telemachus

time to talk and trade our thoughts in full.”

240Asphalion quickly rinsed their hands with water,

another of King Menelaus’ ready aides-in-arms.

Again they reached for the good things set before them.

Then Zeus’s daughter Helen thought of something else.

Into the mixing-bowl from which they drank their wine

she slipped a drug, heart’s-ease, dissolving anger,

magic to make us all forget our pains…

No one who drank it deeply, mulled in wine,

could let a tear roll down his cheeks that day,

not even if his mother should die, his father die,

250not even if right before his eyes some enemy brought down

a brother or darling son with a sharp bronze blade.

So cunning the drugs that Zeus’s daughter plied,

253potent gifts from Polydamna the wife of Thon,

a woman of Egypt, land where the teeming soil

bears the richest yield of herbs in all the world:

many health itself when mixed in the wine,

and many deadly poison.

Every man is a healer there, more skilled

than any other men on earth—Egyptians born

260of the healing god himself. So now Helen, once

she had drugged the wine and ordered winecups filled,

resuming the conversation, entertained the group:

“My royal king Menelaus—welcome guests here,

sons of the great as well! Zeus can present us

times of joy and times of grief in turn:

all lies within his power.

So come, let’s sit back in the palace now,

dine and warm our hearts with the old stories.

I will tell something perfect for the occasion.

270Surely I can’t describe or even list them all,

the exploits crowding fearless Odysseus’ record,

but what a feat that hero dared and carried off

in the land of Troy where you Achaeans suffered!

Scarring his own body with mortifying strokes,

throwing filthy rags on his back like any slave,

he slipped into the enemy’s city, roamed its streets—

all disguised, a totally different man, a beggar,

hardly the figure he cut among Achaea’s ships.

That’s how Odysseus infiltrated Troy,

280and no one knew him at all…

I alone, I spotted him for the man he was,

kept questioning him—the crafty one kept dodging.

But after I’d bathed him, rubbed him down with oil,

given him clothes to wear and sworn a binding oath

not to reveal him as Odysseus to the Trojans, not

till he was back at his swift ships and shelters,

then at last he revealed to me, step by step,

the whole Achaean strategy. And once he’d cut

a troop of Trojans down with his long bronze sword,

290back he went to his comrades, filled with information.

The rest of the Trojan women shrilled their grief. Not I:

292my heart leapt up—

my heart had changed by now—

I yearned

to sail back home again! I grieved too late for the madness

Aphrodite sent me, luring me there, far from my dear land,

forsaking my own child, my bridal bed, my husband too,

a man who lacked for neither brains nor beauty.”

And the red-haired Menelaus answered Helen:

“There was a tale, my lady. So well told.

Now then, I have studied, in my time,

300the plans and minds of great ones by the score.

And I have traveled over a good part of the world

but never once have I laid eyes on a man like him—

what a heart that fearless Odysseus had inside him!

304What a piece of work the hero dared and carried off

in the wooden horse where all our best encamped,

our champions armed with bloody death for Troy…

when along you came, Helen—roused, no doubt,

by a dark power bent on giving Troy some glory,

309and dashing Prince Deiphobus squired your every step.

310Three times you sauntered round our hollow ambush,

feeling, stroking its flanks,

challenging all our fighters, calling each by name—

yours was the voice of all our long-lost wives!

And Diomedes and I, crouched tight in the midst

with great Odysseus, hearing you singing out,

were both keen to spring up and sally forth

or give you a sudden answer from inside,

but Odysseus damped our ardor, reined us back.

Then all the rest of the troops kept stock-still,

320all but Anticlus. He was hot to salute you now

but Odysseus clamped his great hands on the man’s mouth

and shut it, brutally—yes, he saved us all,

holding on grim-set till Pallas Athena

lured you off at last.”

But clear-sighted Telemachus ventured,

“Son of Atreus, King Menelaus, captain of armies,

so much the worse, for not one bit of that

saved him from grisly death…

not even a heart of iron could have helped.

330But come, send us off to bed. It’s time to rest,

time to enjoy the sweet relief of sleep.”

And Helen briskly told her serving-women

to make beds in the porch’s shelter, lay down

some heavy purple throws for the beds themselves,

and over them spread some blankets, thick woolly robes,

a warm covering laid on top. Torches in hand,

they left the hall and made up beds at once.

The herald led the two guests on and so they slept

outside the palace under the forecourt’s colonnade,

340young Prince Telemachus and Nestor’s shining son.

Menelaus retired to chambers deep in his lofty house

with Helen the pearl of women loosely gowned beside him.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

the lord of the warcry climbed from bed and dressed,

over his shoulder he slung his well-honed sword,

fastened rawhide sandals under his smooth feet,

stepped from his bedroom, handsome as a god,

and sat beside Telemachus, asking, kindly,

“Now, my young prince, tell me what brings you here

350to sunny Lacedaemon, sailing over the sea’s broad back.

A public matter or private? Tell me the truth now.”

And with all the poise he had, Telemachus replied,

“Son of Atreus, King Menelaus, captain of armies,

I came in the hope that you can tell me now

some news about my father.

My house is being devoured, my rich farms destroyed,

my palace crammed with enemies, slaughtering on and on

my droves of sheep and shambling longhorn cattle.

Suitors plague my mother—the insolent, overweening…

360That’s why I’ve come to plead before you now,

if you can tell me about his cruel death:

perhaps you saw him die with your own eyes

or heard the wanderer’s end from someone else.

364More than all other men, that man was born for pain.

Don’t soften a thing, from pity, respect for me—

tell me, clearly, all your eyes have witnessed.

I beg you—if ever my father, lord Odysseus,

pledged you his word and made it good in action

once on the fields of Troy where you Achaeans suffered,

remember his story now, tell me the truth.”

370“How shameful!”

the red-haired king burst out in anger. “That’s the bed

of a brave man of war they’d like to crawl inside,

those spineless, craven cowards!

Weak as the doe that beds down her fawns

in a mighty lion’s den—her newborn sucklings—

then trails off to the mountain spurs and grassy bends

to graze her fill, but back the lion comes to his own lair

and the master deals both fawns a ghastly bloody death,

just what Odysseus will deal that mob—ghastly death.

380Ah if only—Father Zeus, Athena and lord Apollo—

that man who years ago in the games at Lesbos

382rose to Philomelides’ challenge, wrestled him,

pinned him down with one tremendous throw

and the Argives roared with joy…

if only that Odysseus sported with those suitors,

a blood wedding, a quick death would take the lot!

But about the things you’ve asked me, so intently,

I’ll skew and sidestep nothing, not deceive you, ever.

Of all he told me—the Old Man of the Sea who never lies—

390I’ll hide or hold back nothing, not a single word.

It was in Egypt, where the gods still marooned me,

eager as I was to voyage home… I’d failed,

you see, to render them full, flawless victims,

and gods are always keen to see their rules obeyed.

Now, there’s an island out in the ocean’s heavy surge,

396well off the Egyptian coast—they call it Pharos—

far as a deep-sea ship can go in one day’s sail

with a whistling wind astern to drive her on.

There’s a snug harbor there, good landing beach

400where crews pull in, draw water up from the dark wells

then push their vessels off for passage out.

But here the gods becalmed me twenty days…

not a breath of the breezes ruffling out to sea

that speed a ship across the ocean’s broad back.

Now our rations would all have been consumed,

our crews’ stamina too, if one of the gods

had not felt sorry for me, shown me mercy,

408Eidothea, a daughter of Proteus,

that great power, the Old Man of the Sea.

410My troubles must have moved her to the heart

when she met me trudging by myself without my men.

They kept roaming around the beach, day in, day out,

fishing with twisted hooks, their bellies racked by hunger.

Well, she came right up to me, filled with questions:

‘Are you a fool, stranger—soft in the head and lazy too?

Or do you let things slide because you like your pain?

Here you are, cooped up on an island far too long,

with no way out of it, none that you can find,

while all your shipmates’ spirit ebbs away.’

420So she prodded and I replied at once,

‘Let me tell you, goddess—whoever you are—

I’m hardly landlocked here of my own free will.

So I must have angered one of the deathless gods

who rule the skies up there. But you tell me—

you immortals know it all—which one of you

blocks my way here, keeps me from my voyage?

How can I cross the swarming sea and reach home at last?’

And the glistening goddess reassured me warmly,

‘Of course, my friend, I’ll answer all your questions.

430Who haunts these parts? Proteus of Egypt does,

the immortal Old Man of the Sea who never lies,

who sounds the deep in all its depths, Poseidon’s servant.

He’s my father, they say, he gave me life. And he,

if only you ambush him somehow and pin him down,

will tell you the way to go, the stages of your voyage,

how you can cross the swarming sea and reach home at last.

And he can tell you too, if you want to press him—

you are a king, it seems—

all that’s occurred within your palace, good and bad,

440while you’ve been gone your long and painful way.’

‘Then you are the one’—I quickly took her up.

‘Show me the trick to trap this ancient power,

or he’ll see or sense me first and slip away.

It’s hard for a mortal man to force a god.’

‘True, my friend,’ the glistening one agreed,

‘and again I’ll tell you all you need to know.

When the sun stands striding at high noon,

then up from the waves he comes—

the Old Man of the Sea who never lies—

450under a West Wind’s gust that shrouds him round

in shuddering dark swells, and once he’s out on land

he heads for his bed of rest in deep hollow caves

and around him droves of seals—sleek pups bred

454by his lovely ocean-lady—bed down too

in a huddle, flopping up from the gray surf,

giving off the sour reek of the salty ocean depths.

I’ll lead you there myself at the break of day

and couch you all for attack, side-by-side.

Choose three men from your crew, choose well,

460the best you’ve got aboard the good decked hulls.

Now I will tell you all the old wizard’s tricks…

First he will make his rounds and count the seals

and once he’s checked their number, reviewed them all,

down in their midst he’ll lie, like a shepherd with his flock.

That’s your moment. Soon as you see him bedded down,

muster your heart and strength and hold him fast,

wildly as he writhes and fights you to escape.

He’ll try all kinds of escape—twist and turn

into every beast that moves across the earth,

470transforming himself into water, superhuman fire,

but you hold on for dear life, hug him all the harder!

And when, at last, he begins to ask you questions—

back in the shape you saw him sleep at first—

relax your grip and set the old god free

and ask him outright, hero,

which of the gods is up in arms against you?

How can you cross the swarming sea and reach home at last?’

So she urged and under the breaking surf she dove

as I went back to our squadron beached in sand,

480my heart a heaving storm at every step…

Once I reached my ship hauled up on shore

we made our meal and the godsent night came down

and then we slept at the sea’s smooth shelving edge.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

I set out down the coast of the wide-ranging sea,

praying hard to the gods for all their help,

taking with me the three men I trusted most

on every kind of mission.

Eidothea, now,

had slipped beneath the sea’s engulfing folds

490but back from the waves she came with four sealskins,

all freshly stripped, to deceive her father blind.

She scooped out lurking-places deep in the sand

and sat there waiting as we approached her post,

then couching us side-by-side she flung a sealskin

over each man’s back. Now there was an ambush

that would have overpowered us all—overpowering,

true, the awful reek of all those sea-fed brutes!

Who’d dream of bedding down with a monster of the deep?

But the goddess sped to our rescue, found the cure

500with ambrosia, daubing it under each man’s nose—

that lovely scent, it drowned the creatures’ stench.

So all morning we lay there waiting, spirits steeled,

while seals came crowding, jostling out of the sea

and flopped down in rows, basking along the surf.

At high noon the old man emerged from the waves

and found his fat-fed seals and made his rounds,

counting them off, counting us the first four,

but he had no inkling of all the fraud afoot.

Then down he lay and slept, but we with a battle-cry,

510we rushed him, flung our arms around him—he’d lost nothing,

the old rascal, none of his cunning quick techniques!

First he shifted into a great bearded lion

and then a serpent—

a panther—

a ramping wild boar—

a torrent of water—

a tree with soaring branchtops—

but we held on for dear life, braving it out

until, at last, that quick-change artist,

the old wizard, began to weary of all this

and burst out into rapid-fire questions:

‘Which god, Menelaus, conspired with you

520to trap me in ambush? seize me against my will?

What on earth do you want?’

‘You know, old man,’

I countered now. ‘Why put me off with questions?

Here I am, cooped up on an island far too long,

with no way out of it, none that I can find,

while my spirit ebbs away. But you tell me—

you immortals know it all—which one of you

blocks my way here, keeps me from my voyage?

How can I cross the swarming sea and reach home at last?’

‘How wrong you were!’ the seer shot back at once.

530‘You should have offered Zeus and the other gods

a handsome sacrifice, then embarked, if you ever hoped

for a rapid journey home across the wine-dark sea.

It’s not your destiny yet to see your loved ones,

reach your own grand house, your native land at last,

not till you sail back through Egyptian waters—

536the great Nile swelled by the rains of Zeus—

and make a splendid rite to the deathless gods

who rule the vaulting skies. Then, only then

will the gods grant you the voyage you desire.’

540So he urged, and broke the heart inside me,

having to double back on the mist-bound seas,

back to Egypt, that, that long and painful way…

Nevertheless I caught my breath and answered,

‘That I will do, old man, as you command.

But tell me this as well, and leave out nothing:

Did all the Achaeans reach home in the ships unharmed,

all we left behind, Nestor and I, en route from Troy?

Or did any die some cruel death by shipwreck

or die in the arms of loved ones,

550once they’d wound down the long coil of war?’

And he lost no time in saying, ‘Son of Atreus,

why do you ask me that? Why do you need to know?

Why probe my mind? You won’t stay dry-eyed long,

I warn you, once you have heard the whole story.

Many of them were killed, many survived as well,

but only two who captained your bronze-armored units

died on the way home—you know who died in the fighting,

you were there yourself.

And one is still alive,

held captive, somewhere, off in the endless seas…

560Ajax, now, went down with his long-oared fleet.

561First Poseidon drove him onto the cliffs of Gyrae,

looming cliffs, then saved him from the breakers—

he’d have escaped his doom, too, despite Athena’s hate,

if he hadn’t flung that brazen boast, the mad blind fool.

“In the teeth of the gods,” he bragged, “I have escaped

the ocean’s sheer abyss!” Poseidon heard that frantic vaunt

and the god grasped his trident in both his massive hands

and struck the Gyraean headland, hacked the rock in two,

and the giant stump stood fast but the jagged spur

570where Ajax perched at first, the raving madman—

toppling into the sea, it plunged him down, down

in the vast, seething depths. And so he died,

573having drunk his fill of brine.

Your brother?

574He somehow escaped that fate; Agamemnon got away

575in his beaked ships. Queen Hera pulled him through.

But just as he came abreast of Malea’s beetling cape

a hurricane snatched him up and swept him way off course—

groaning, desperate—driving him over the fish-infested sea

579to the wild borderland where Thyestes made his home

580in the days of old and his son Aegisthus lived now.

But even from there a safe return seemed likely,

yes, the immortals swung the wind around to fair

and the victors sailed home. How he rejoiced,

Atrides setting foot on his fatherland once more—

he took that native earth in his hands and kissed it,

hot tears flooding his eyes, so thrilled to see his land!

But a watchman saw him too—from a lookout high above—

a spy that cunning Aegisthus stationed there,

luring the man with two gold bars in payment.

590One whole year he’d watched…

so the great king would not get past unseen,

his fighting power intact for self-defense.

The spy ran the news to his master’s halls

and Aegisthus quickly set his stealthy trap.

Picking the twenty best recruits from town

he packed them in ambush at one end of the house,

at the other he ordered a banquet dressed and spread

and went to welcome the conquering hero, Agamemnon,

went with team and chariot, and a mind aswarm with evil.

600Up from the shore he led the king, he ushered him in—

suspecting nothing of all his doom—he feasted him well

then cut him down as a man cuts down some ox at the trough!

Not one of your brother’s men-at-arms was left alive,

none of Aegisthus’ either. All, killed in the palace.’

So Proteus said, and his story crushed my heart.

I knelt down in the sand and wept. I’d no desire

to go on living and see the rising light of day.

But once I’d had my fill of tears and writhing there,

the Old Man of the Sea who never lies continued,

610‘No more now, Menelaus. How long must you weep?

Withering tears, what good can come of tears?

None I know of. Strive instead to return

to your native country—hurry home at once!

Either you’ll find the murderer still alive

or Orestes will have beaten you to the kill.

You’ll be in time to share the funeral feast.’

So he pressed, and I felt my heart, my old pride,

for all my grieving, glow once more in my chest

and I asked the seer in a rush of winging words,

620‘Those two I know now. Tell me the third man’s name.

Who is still alive, held captive off in the endless seas?

Unless he’s dead by now. I want to know the truth

though it grieves me all the more.’

‘Odysseus’—

the old prophet named the third at once—

‘Laertes’ son, who makes his home in Ithaca…

I saw him once on an island, weeping live warm tears

in the nymph Calypso’s house—she holds him there by force.

He has no way to voyage home to his own native land,

no trim ships in reach, no crew to ply the oars

630and send him scudding over the sea’s broad back.

But about your own destiny, Menelaus,

632dear to Zeus, it’s not for you to die

and meet your fate in the stallion-land of Argos,

no, the deathless ones will sweep you off to the world’s end,

635the Elysian Fields, where gold-haired Rhadamanthys waits,

where life glides on in immortal ease for mortal man;

no snow, no winter onslaught, never a downpour there

638but night and day the Ocean River sends up breezes,

singing winds of the West refreshing all mankind.

640All this because you are Helen’s husband now—

the gods count you the son-in-law of Zeus.’

So he divined and down the breaking surf he dove

as I went back to the ships with my brave men,

my heart a rising tide at every step.

Once I reached my craft hauled up on shore

we made our meal and the godsent night came down

and then we slept at the sea’s smooth shelving edge.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

we hauled the vessels down to the sunlit breakers first

650then stepped the masts amidships, canvas brailed—

the crews swung aboard, they sat to the oars in ranks

and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

Back we went to the Nile swelled by the rains of Zeus,

I moored the ships and sacrificed in a splendid rite,

and once I’d slaked the wrath of the everlasting gods

I raised a mound for Agamemnon, his undying glory.

All this done, I set sail and the gods sent me

a stiff following wind that sped me home,

home to the native land I love.

But come,

660my boy, stay on in my palace now with me,

at least till ten or a dozen days have passed.

Then I’ll give you a princely send-off—shining gifts,

663three stallions and a chariot burnished bright—

and I’ll add a gorgeous cup so you can pour

libations out to the deathless gods on high

and remember Menelaus all your days.”

Telemachus,

summoning up his newfound tact, replied,

“Please, Menelaus, don’t keep me quite so long.

True, I’d gladly sit beside you one whole year

670without a twinge of longing for home or parents.

It’s wonderful how you tell your stories, all you say—

I delight to listen! Yes, but now, I’m afraid,

my comrades must be restless in sacred Pylos,

and here you’d hold me just a little longer.

As for the gift you give me, let it be a keepsake.

676Those horses I really cannot take to Ithaca;

better to leave them here to be your glory.

You rule a wide level plain

where the fields of clover roll and galingale

680and wheat and oats and glistening full-grain barley.

No running-room for mares in Ithaca, though, no meadows.

Goat, not stallion, land, yet it means the world to me.

None of the rugged islands slanting down to sea

is good for pasture or good for bridle paths,

but Ithaca, best of islands, crowns them all!”

So he declared. The lord of the warcry smiled,

patted him with his hand and praised his guest, concluding,

688“Good blood runs in you, dear boy, your words are proof.

Certainly I’ll exchange the gifts. The power’s mine.

690Of all the treasures lying heaped in my palace

you shall have the finest, most esteemed. Why,

I’ll give you a mixing-bowl, forged to perfection—

it’s solid silver finished off with a lip of gold.

694Hephaestus made it himself. And a royal friend,

695Phaedimus, king of Sidon, lavished it on me

when his palace welcomed me on passage home.

How pleased I’d be if you took it as a gift!”

And now as the two confided in each other,

banqueters arrived at the great king’s palace,

700leading their own sheep, bearing their hearty wine,

and their wives in lovely headbands sent along the food.

And so they bustled about the halls preparing dinner…

But all the while the suitors, before Odysseus’ palace,

amused themselves with discus and long throwing spears,

out on the leveled grounds, free and easy as always,

full of swagger. But lord Antinous sat apart,

dashing Eurymachus beside him, ringleaders,

head and shoulders the strongest of the lot.

Phronius’ son Noëmon approached them now,

710quick to press Antinous with a question:

“Antinous, have we any notion or not

when Telemachus will return from sandy Pylos?

He sailed in a ship of mine and now I need her back

714to cross over to Elis Plain where I keep a dozen horses,

brood-mares suckling some heavy-duty mules, unbroken.

I’d like to drive one home and break him in.”

That dumbfounded them both. They never dreamed

the prince had gone to Pylos, Neleus’ city—

certain the boy was still nearby somewhere,

720out on his farm with flocks or with the swineherd.

“Tell me the truth!” Antinous wheeled on Noëmon.

“When did he go? And what young crew went with him?

Ithaca’s best? Or his own slaves and servants?

Surely he has enough to man a ship.

Tell me this—be clear—I’ve got to know:

did he commandeer your ship against your will

or did you volunteer it once he’d won you over?”

“I volunteered it, of course,” Noëmon said.

“What else could anyone do, when such a man,

730a prince weighed down with troubles,

asked a favor? Hard to deny him anything.

And the young crew that formed his escort? Well,

they’re the finest men on the island, next to us.

And Mentor took command—I saw him climb aboard—

or a god who looked like Mentor head to foot,

and that’s what I find strange. I saw good Mentor

yesterday, just at sunup, here. But clearly

738he boarded ship for Pylos days ago.”

With that he headed back to his father’s house,

740leaving the two lords stiff with indignation.

They made the suitors sit down in a group

and stop their games at once. Eupithes’ son

Antinous rose up in their midst to speak,

his dark heart filled with fury,

blazing with anger—eyes like searing fire:

“By god, what a fine piece of work he’s carried off!

Telemachus—what insolence—and we thought his little jaunt

would come to grief. But in spite of us all, look,

the young cub slips away, just like that—

750picks the best crew in the land and off he sails.

And this is just the start of the trouble he can make.

Zeus kill that brazen boy before he hits his prime!

Quick, fetch me a swift ship and twenty men—

I’ll waylay him from ambush, board him coming back

in the straits between Ithaca and rocky Same.

This gallant voyage of his to find his father

will find him wrecked at last!”

They all roared approval, urged him on,

rose at once and retired to Odysseus’ palace.

760But not for long was Penelope unaware

of the grim plots her suitors planned in secret.

762The herald Medon told her. He’d overheard their schemes,

listening in outside the court while they wove on within.

He rushed the news through the halls to tell the queen

who greeted him as he crossed her chamber’s threshold:

“Herald, why have the young blades sent you now?

To order King Odysseus’ serving-women

to stop their work and slave to fix their feast?

I hate their courting, their running riot here—

770would to god that this meal, here and now,

were their last meal on earth!

Day after day,

all of you swarming, draining our life’s blood,

my wary son’s estate. What, didn’t you listen

to your fathers—when you were children, years ago—

telling you how Odysseus treated them, your parents?

Never an unfair word, never an unfair action

among his people here, though that’s the way

of our god-appointed kings,

hating one man, loving the next, with luck.

780Not Odysseus. Never an outrage done to any man alive.

But you, you and your ugly outbursts, shameful acts,

they’re plain to see. Look at the thanks he gets

for all past acts of kindness!”

Medon replied,

sure of his own discretion, “Ah my queen,

if only that were the worst of all you face.

Now your suitors are plotting something worse,

harsher, crueler. God forbid they bring it off!

They’re poised to cut Telemachus down with bronze swords

on his way back home. He’s sailed off, you see…

790for news of his father—to sacred Pylos first,

then out to the sunny hills of Lacedaemon.”

Her knees gave way on the spot, her heart too.

She stood there speechless a while, struck dumb,

tears filling her eyes, her warm voice choked.

At last she found some words to make reply:

“Oh herald, why has my child gone and left me?

No need in the world for him to board the ships,

those chariots of the sea that sweep men on,

driving across the ocean’s endless wastes…

800Does he want his very name wiped off the earth?”

Medon, the soul of thoughtfulness, responded,

“I don’t know if a god inspired your son

or the boy’s own impulse led him down to Pylos,

but he went to learn of his father’s journey home,

or whatever fate he’s met.”

Back through King Odysseus’ house he went

but a cloud of heartbreak overwhelmed the queen.

She could bear no longer sitting on a chair

though her room had chairs aplenty.

810Down she sank on her well-built chamber’s floor,

weeping, pitifully, as the women whimpered round her,

all the women, young and old, who served her house.

Penelope, sobbing uncontrollably, cried out to them,

“Hear me, dear ones! Zeus has given me torment—

me above all the others born and bred in my day.

My lionhearted husband, lost, long years ago,

who excelled the Argives all in every strength—

that great man whose fame resounds through Hellas

right to the depths of Argos!

But now my son,

820my darling boy—the whirlwinds have ripped him

out of the halls without a trace! I never heard

he’d gone—not even from you, you hard, heartless…

not one of you even thought to rouse me from my bed,

though well you knew when he boarded that black ship.

Oh if only I had learned he was planning such a journey,

he would have stayed, by god, keen as he was to sail—

or left me dead right here within our palace.

828Go, someone, quickly! Call old Dolius now,

the servant my father gave me when I came,

830the man who tends my orchard green with trees,

so he can run to Laertes, sit beside him,

tell him the whole story, point by point.

Perhaps—who knows?—he’ll weave some plan,

he’ll come out of hiding, plead with all these people

mad to destroy his line, his son’s line of kings!”

“Oh dear girl,” Eurycleia the fond old nurse replied,

“kill me then with a bronze knife—no mercy—or let me live,

here in the palace—I’ll hide nothing from you now!

I knew it all, I gave him all he asked for,

840bread and mellow wine, but he made me take

a binding oath that I, I wouldn’t tell you,

no, not till ten or a dozen days had passed

or you missed the lad yourself and learned he’d gone,

so tears would never mar your lovely face…

Come, bathe now, put on some fresh clothes,

climb to the upper rooms with all your women

and pray to Pallas, daughter of storming Zeus—

she may save Telemachus yet, even at death’s door.

Don’t worry an old man, worried enough by now.

850I can’t believe the blessed gods so hate

851the heirs of King Arcesius, through and through.

One will still live on—I know it—born to rule

this lofty house and the green fields far and wide.”

With that

she lulled Penelope’s grief and dried her eyes of tears.

And the queen bathed and put fresh clothing on,

climbed to the upper rooms with all her women

857and sifting barley into a basket, prayed to Pallas,

“Hear me, daughter of Zeus whose shield is thunder—

tireless one, Athena! If ever, here in his halls,

860resourceful King Odysseus

burned rich thighs of sheep or oxen in your honor,

oh remember it now for my sake, save my darling son,

defend him from these outrageous, overbearing suitors!”

She shrilled a high cry and the goddess heard her prayer

as the suitors burst into uproar through the shadowed halls

and one of the lusty young men began to brag, “Listen,

our long-courted queen’s preparing us all a marriage—

with no glimmer at all

how the murder of her son has been decreed.”

Boasting so,

870with no glimmer at all of what had been decreed.

But Antinous took the floor and issued orders:

“Stupid fools! Muzzle your bragging now—

before someone slips inside and reports us.

Up now, not a sound, drive home our plan—

it suits us well, we approved it one and all.”

With that he picked out twenty first-rate men

and down they went to the swift ship at the sea’s edge.

First they hauled the craft into deeper water,

stepped the mast amidships, canvas brailed,

880made oars fast in the leather oarlock straps

while zealous aides-in-arms brought weapons on.

They moored her well out in the channel, disembarked

and took their meal on shore, waiting for dusk to fall.

But there in her upper rooms she lay, Penelope

lost in thought, fasting, shunning food and drink,

brooding now… would her fine son escape his death

or go down at her overweening suitors’ hands?

Her mind in torment, wheeling

like some lion at bay, dreading gangs of hunters

890closing their cunning ring around him for the finish.

Harried so she was, when a deep kind sleep overcame her,

back she sank and slept, her limbs fell limp and still.

And again the bright-eyed goddess Pallas thought

of one more way to help. She made a phantom now,

895its build like a woman’s build, Iphthime’s, yes,

another daughter of generous Lord Icarius,

897Eumelus’ bride, who made her home in Pherae.

Athena sped her on to King Odysseus’ house

to spare Penelope, worn with pain and sobbing,

900further spells of grief and storms of tears.

The phantom entered her bedroom,

passing quickly in through the doorbolt slit

and hovering at her head she rose and spoke now:

“Sleeping, Penelope, your heart so wrung with sorrow?

No need, I tell you, no, the gods who live at ease

can’t bear to let you weep and rack your spirit.

Your son will still come home—it is decreed.

He’s never wronged the gods in any way.”

And Penelope murmured back, still cautious,

910drifting softly now at the gate of dreams,

“Why have you come, my sister?

Your visits all too rare in the past,

for you make your home so very far away.

You tell me to lay to rest the grief and tears

that overwhelm me now, torment me, heart and soul?

With my lionhearted husband lost long years ago,

who excelled the Argives all in every strength?

That great man whose fame resounds through Hellas

right to the depths of Argos…

And now my darling boy,

920he’s off and gone in a hollow ship! Just a youngster,

still untrained for war or stiff debate.

Him I mourn even more than I do my husband—

I quake in terror for all that he might suffer

either on open sea or shores he goes to visit.

Hordes of enemies scheme against him now,

keen to kill him off

before he can reach his native land again.”

“Courage!” the shadowy phantom reassured her.

“Don’t be overwhelmed by all your direst fears.

930He travels with such an escort, one that others

would pray to stand beside them. She has power—

Pallas Athena. She pities you in your tears.

She wings me here to tell you all these things.”

But the circumspect Penelope replied,

“If you are a god and have heard a god’s own voice,

come, tell me about that luckless man as well.

Is he still alive? does he see the light of day?

Or is he dead already, lost in the House of Death?”

“About that man,” the shadowy phantom answered,

940“I cannot tell you the story start to finish,

whether he’s dead or alive.

It’s wrong to lead you on with idle words.”

At that

she glided off by the doorpost past the bolt—

gone on a lifting breeze. Icarius’ daughter

started up from sleep, her spirit warmed now

that a dream so clear had come to her in darkest night.

But the suitors boarded now and sailed the sea-lanes,

plotting in their hearts Telemachus’ plunge to death.

Off in the middle channel lies a rocky island,

950just between Ithaca and Same’s rugged cliffs—

951Asteris—not large, but it has a cove,

a harbor with two mouths where ships can hide.

Here the Achaeans lurked in ambush for the prince.

BOOK FIVE

Odysseus—Nymph and Shipwreck

1

A
s Dawn rose up from bed by her lordly mate Tithonus,

bringing light to immortal gods and mortal men,

the gods sat down in council, circling Zeus

the thunder king whose power rules the world.

Athena began, recalling Odysseus to their thoughts,

the goddess deeply moved by the man’s long ordeal,

held captive still in the nymph Calypso’s house:

“Father Zeus—you other happy gods who never die—

never let any sceptered king be kind and gentle now,

10not with all his heart, or set his mind on justice—

no, let him be cruel and always practice outrage.

Think: not one of the people whom he ruled

remembers Odysseus now, that godlike man,

and kindly as a father to his children.

Now

he’s left to pine on an island, racked with grief

in the nymph Calypso’s house—she holds him there by force.

He has no way to voyage home to his own native land,

no trim ships in reach, no crew to ply the oars

and send him scudding over the sea’s broad back.

20And now his dear son… they plot to kill the boy

on his way back home. Yes, he has sailed off

for news of his father, to holy Pylos first,

then out to the sunny hills of Lacedaemon.”

“My child,” Zeus who marshals the thunderheads replied,

“what nonsense you let slip through your teeth. Come now,

wasn’t the plan your own? You conceived it yourself:

Odysseus shall return and pay the traitors back.

Telemachus? Sail him home with all your skill—

the power is yours, no doubt—

30home to his native country all unharmed

while the suitors limp to port, defeated, baffled men.”

With those words, Zeus turned to his own son Hermes.

“You are our messenger, Hermes, sent on all our missions.

Announce to the nymph with lovely braids our fixed decree:

Odysseus journeys home—the exile must return.

But not in the convoy of the gods or mortal men.

No, on a lashed, makeshift raft and wrung with pains,

38on the twentieth day he will make his landfall, fertile Scheria,

39the land of Phaeacians, close kin to the gods themselves,

40who with all their hearts will prize him like a god

and send him off in a ship to his own beloved land,

giving him bronze and hoards of gold and robes—

more plunder than he could ever have won from Troy

if Odysseus had returned intact with his fair share.

So his destiny ordains. He shall see his loved ones,

reach his high-roofed house, his native land at last.”

So Zeus decreed and the giant-killing guide obeyed at once.

Quickly under his feet he fastened the supple sandals,

ever-glowing gold, that wing him over the waves

50and boundless earth with the rush of gusting winds.

He seized the wand that enchants the eyes of men

whenever Hermes wants, or wakes us up from sleep.

That wand in his grip, the powerful giant-killer,

54swooping down from Pieria, down the high clear air,

plunged to the sea and skimmed the waves like a tern

that down the deadly gulfs of the barren salt swells

glides and dives for fish,

dipping its beating wings in bursts of spray—

so Hermes skimmed the crests on endless crests.

60But once he gained that island worlds apart,

up from the deep-blue sea he climbed to dry land

and strode on till he reached the spacious cave

where the nymph with lovely braids had made her home,

and he found her there inside…

A great fire

blazed on the hearth and the smell of cedar

cleanly split and sweetwood burning bright

wafted a cloud of fragrance down the island.

Deep inside she sang, the goddess Calypso, lifting

her breathtaking voice as she glided back and forth

70before her loom, her golden shuttle weaving.

Thick, luxuriant woods grew round the cave,

alders and black poplars, pungent cypress too,

and there birds roosted, folding their long wings,

owls and hawks and the spread-beaked ravens of the sea,

black skimmers who make their living off the waves.

And round the mouth of the cavern trailed a vine

laden with clusters, bursting with ripe grapes.

Four springs in a row, bubbling clear and cold,

running side-by-side, took channels left and right.

80Soft meadows spreading round were starred with violets,

81lush with beds of parsley. Why, even a deathless god

who came upon that place would gaze in wonder,

heart entranced with pleasure. Hermes the guide,

84the mighty giant-killer, stood there, spellbound…

But once he’d had his fill of marveling at it all

he briskly entered the deep vaulted cavern.

Calypso, lustrous goddess, knew him at once,

as soon as she saw his features face-to-face.

Immortals are never strangers to each other,

90no matter how distant one may make her home.

But as for great Odysseus—

Hermes could not find him within the cave.

Off he sat on a headland, weeping there as always,

wrenching his heart with sobs and groans and anguish,

gazing out over the barren sea through blinding tears.

But Calypso, lustrous goddess, questioned Hermes,

seating him on a glistening, polished chair.

“God of the golden wand, why have you come?

A beloved, honored friend,

100but it’s been so long, your visits much too rare.

Tell me what’s on your mind. I’m eager to do it,

whatever I can do… whatever can be done.”

And the goddess drew a table up beside him,

heaped with ambrosia, mixed him deep-red nectar.

Hermes the guide and giant-killer ate and drank.

Once he had dined and fortified himself with food

he launched right in, replying to her questions:

“As one god to another, you ask me why I’ve come.

I’ll tell you the whole story, mince no words—

110your wish is my command.

It was Zeus who made me come, no choice of mine.

Who would willingly roam across a salty waste so vast,

so endless? Think: no city of men in sight, and not a soul

to offer the gods a sacrifice and burn the fattest victims.

But there is no way, you know, for another god to thwart

the will of storming Zeus and make it come to nothing.

Zeus claims you keep beside you a most unlucky man,

most harried of all who fought for Priam’s Troy

nine years, sacking the city in the tenth,

120and then set sail for home.

But voyaging back they outraged Queen Athena

who loosed the gales and pounding seas against them.

There all the rest of his loyal shipmates died

but the wind drove him on, the current bore him here.

Now Zeus commands you to send him off with all good speed:

it is not his fate to die here, far from his own people.

Destiny still ordains that he shall see his loved ones,

reach his high-roofed house, his native land at last.”

But lustrous Calypso shuddered at those words

130and burst into a flight of indignation. “Hard-hearted

you are, you gods! You unrivaled lords of jealousy—

scandalized when goddesses sleep with mortals,

openly, even when one has made the man her husband.

134So when Dawn with her rose-red fingers took Orion,

you gods in your everlasting ease were horrified

till chaste Artemis throned in gold attacked him,

out on Delos, shot him to death with gentle shafts.

138And so when Demeter the graceful one with lovely braids

139gave way to her passion and made love with Iasion,

140bedding down in a furrow plowed three times—

Zeus got wind of it soon enough, I’d say,

and blasted the man to death with flashing bolts.

So now at last, you gods, you train your spite on me

for keeping a mortal man beside me. The man I saved,

riding astride his keel-board, all alone, when Zeus

with one hurl of a white-hot bolt had crushed

his racing warship down the wine-dark sea.

There all the rest of his loyal shipmates died

but the wind drove him on, the current bore him here.

150And I welcomed him warmly, cherished him, even vowed

151to make the man immortal, ageless, all his days…

But since there is no way for another god to thwart

the will of storming Zeus and make it come to nothing,

let the man go—if the Almighty insists, commands—

and destroy himself on the barren salt sea!

I’ll send him off, but not with any escort.

I have no ships in reach, no crew to ply the oars

and send him scudding over the sea’s broad back.

But I will gladly advise him—I’ll hide nothing—

160so he can reach his native country all unharmed.”

161And the guide and giant-killer reinforced her words:

“Release him at once, just so. Steer clear of the rage of Zeus!

Or down the years he’ll fume and make your life a hell.”

With that the powerful giant-killer sped away.

The queenly nymph sought out the great Odysseus—

the commands of Zeus still ringing in her ears—

and found him there on the headland, sitting, still,

weeping, his eyes never dry, his sweet life flowing away

with the tears he wept for his foiled journey home,

170since the nymph no longer pleased. In the nights, true,

he’d sleep with her in the arching cave—he had no choice—

172unwilling lover alongside lover all too willing…

But all his days he’d sit on the rocks and beaches,

wrenching his heart with sobs and groans and anguish,

gazing out over the barren sea through blinding tears.

So coming up to him now, the lustrous goddess ventured,

“No need, my unlucky one, to grieve here any longer,

no, don’t waste your life away. Now I am willing,

heart and soul, to send you off at last. Come,

180take bronze tools, cut your lengthy timbers,

make them into a broad-beamed raft

and top it off with a half-deck high enough

to sweep you free and clear on the misty seas.

And I myself will stock her with food and water,

ruddy wine to your taste—all to stave off hunger—

give you clothing, send you a stiff following wind

so you can reach your native country all unharmed.

If only the gods are willing. They rule the vaulting skies.

They’re stronger than I to plan and drive things home.”

190Long-enduring Odysseus shuddered at that

and broke out in a sharp flight of protest.

“Passage home? Never. Surely you’re plotting

something else, goddess, urging me—in a raft—

to cross the ocean’s mighty gulfs. So vast, so full

of danger not even deep-sea ships can make it through,

swift as they are and buoyed up by the winds of Zeus himself.

I won’t set foot on a raft until you show good faith,

until you consent to swear, goddess, a binding oath

you’ll never plot some new intrigue to harm me!”

200He was so intense the lustrous goddess smiled,

stroked him with her hand, savored his name and chided,

“Ah what a wicked man you are, and never at a loss.

What a thing to imagine, what a thing to say!

Earth be my witness now, the vaulting Sky above

205and the dark cascading waters of the Styx—I swear

by the greatest, grimmest oath that binds the happy gods:

I will never plot some new intrigue to harm you.

Never. All I have in mind and devise for you

are the very plans I’d fashion for myself

210if I were in your straits. My every impulse

bends to what is right. Not iron, trust me,

the heart within my breast. I am all compassion.”

And lustrous Calypso quickly led the way

as he followed in the footsteps of the goddess.

They reached the arching cavern, man and god as one,

and Odysseus took the seat that Hermes just left,

while the nymph set out before him every kind

of food and drink that mortal men will take.

Calypso sat down face-to-face with the king

220and the women served her nectar and ambrosia.

They reached out for the good things that lay at hand

and when they’d had their fill of food and drink

the lustrous one took up a new approach. “So then,

royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, man of exploits,

still eager to leave at once and hurry back

to your own home, your beloved native land?

Good luck to you, even so. Farewell!

228But if you only knew, down deep, what pains

are fated to fill your cup before you reach that shore,

230you’d stay right here, preside in our house with me

and be immortal. Much as you long to see your wife,

the one you pine for all your days… and yet

I just might claim to be nothing less than she,

neither in face nor figure. Hardly right, is it,

for mortal woman to rival immortal goddess?

How, in build? in beauty?”

“Ah great goddess,”

worldly Odysseus answered, “don’t be angry with me,

please. All that you say is true, how well I know.

Look at my wise Penelope. She falls far short of you,

240your beauty, stature. She is mortal after all

and you, you never age or die…

Nevertheless I long—I pine, all my days—

to travel home and see the dawn of my return.

And if a god will wreck me yet again on the wine-dark sea,

I can bear that too, with a spirit tempered to endure.

244Much have I suffered, labored long and hard by now

in the waves and wars. Add this to the total—

bring the trial on!”

Even as he spoke

the sun set and the darkness swept the earth.

250And now, withdrawing into the cavern’s deep recesses,

long in each other’s arms they lost themselves in love.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

Odysseus quickly dressed himself in cloak and shirt

while the nymph slipped on a loose, glistening robe,

filmy, a joy to the eye, and round her waist

she ran a brocaded golden belt

and over her head a scarf to shield her brow,

then turned to plan the great man’s voyage home.

She gave him a heavy bronze ax that fit his grip,

260both blades well-honed, with a fine olive haft

lashed firm to its head. She gave him a polished

smoothing-adze as well and then she led the way

to the island’s outer edge where trees grew tall,

alders, black poplars and firs that shot sky-high,

seasoned, drying for years, ideal for easy floating.

Once she’d shown her guest where the tall timber stood,

Calypso the lustrous goddess headed home again.

He set to cutting trunks—the work was done in no time.

Twenty in all he felled, he trimmed them clean with his ax

270and split them deftly, trued them straight to the line.

Meanwhile the radiant goddess brought him drills—

he bored through all his planks and wedged them snugly,

knocking them home together, locked with pegs and joints.

Broad in the beam and bottom flat as a merchantman

when a master shipwright turns out her hull,

so broad the craft Odysseus made himself.

Working away at speed

he put up half-decks pinned to close-set ribs

and a sweep of gunwales rounded off the sides.

280He fashioned the mast next and sank its yard in deep

and added a steering-oar to hold her right on course,

then he fenced her stem to stern with twigs and wicker,

bulwark against the sea-surge, floored with heaps of brush.

And lustrous Calypso came again, now with bolts of cloth

to make the sail, and he finished that off too, expertly.

Braces, sheets and brails—he rigged all fast on board,

then eased her down with levers into the sunlit sea.

That was the fourth day and all his work was done.

On the fifth, the lovely goddess launched him from her island,

290once she had bathed and decked him out in fragrant clothes.

And Calypso stowed two skins aboard—dark wine in one,

the larger one held water—added a sack of rations,

filled with her choicest meats to build his strength,

and summoned a wind to bear him onward, fair and warm.

The wind lifting his spirits high, royal Odysseus

spread sail—gripping the tiller, seated astern—

and now the master mariner steered his craft,

sleep never closing his eyes, forever scanning

299the stars, the Pleiades and the Plowman late to set

300and the Great Bear that mankind also calls the Wagon:

301she wheels on her axis always fixed, watching the Hunter,

and she alone is denied a plunge in the Ocean’s baths.

Hers were the stars the lustrous goddess told him

to keep hard to port as he cut across the sea.

And seventeen days he sailed, making headway well;

on the eighteenth, shadowy mountains slowly loomed…

the Phaeacians’ island reaching toward him now,

over the misty breakers, rising like a shield.

But now Poseidon, god of the earthquake, saw him—

310just returning home from his Ethiopian friends,

311from miles away on the Solymi mountain-range

he spied Odysseus sailing down the sea

and it made his fury boil even more.

He shook his head and rumbled to himself,

315“Outrageous! Look how the gods have changed their minds

about Odysseus—while I was off with my Ethiopians.

317Just look at him there, nearing Phaeacia’s shores

318where he’s fated to escape his noose of pain

that’s held him until now. Still my hopes ride high—

320I’ll give that man his swamping fill of trouble!”

With that he rammed the clouds together—both hands

clutching his trident—churned the waves into chaos, whipping

all the gales from every quarter, shrouding over in thunderheads

the earth and sea at once—and night swept down from the sky—

East and South Winds clashed and the raging West and North,

sprung from the heavens, roiled heaving breakers up—

and Odysseus’ knees quaked, his spirit too;

numb with fear he spoke to his own great heart:

“Wretched man—what becomes of me now, at last?

330I fear the nymph foretold it all too well—

on the high seas, she said, before I can reach

my native land I’ll fill my cup of pain! And now,

look, it all comes to pass. What monstrous clouds—

King Zeus crowning the whole wide heaven black—

churning the seas in chaos, gales blasting,

raging around my head from every quarter—

my death-plunge in a flash, it’s certain now!

Three, four times blessed, my friends-in-arms

who died on the plains of Troy those years ago,

340serving the sons of Atreus to the end. Would to god

I’d died there too and met my fate that day the Trojans,

swarms of them, hurled at me with bronze spears,

fighting over the corpse of proud Achilles!

A hero’s funeral then, my glory spread by comrades—

now what a wretched death I’m doomed to die!”

At that a massive wave came crashing down on his head,

a terrific onslaught spinning his craft round and round—

he was thrown clear of the decks—

the steering-oar wrenched

from his grasp—

and in one lightning attack the brawling

350galewinds struck full-force, snapping the mast mid-shaft

and hurling the sail and sailyard far across the sea.

He went under a good long while, no fast way out,

no struggling up from under the giant wave’s assault,

his clothing dragged him down—divine Calypso’s gifts—

but at last he fought his way to the surface spewing

bitter brine, streams of it pouring down his head.

But half-drowned as he was, he’d not forget his craft—

he lunged after her through the breakers, laying hold

and huddling amidships, fled the stroke of death.

360Pell-mell the rollers tossed her along down-current,

wild as the North Wind tossing thistle along the fields

at high harvest—dry stalks clutching each other tightly—

so the galewinds tumbled her down the sea, this way, that way,

now the South Wind flinging her over to North to sport with,

now the East Wind giving her up to West to harry on and on.

366But someone saw him—Cadmus’ daughter with lovely ankles,

367Ino, a mortal woman once with human voice and called

368Leucothea now she lives in the sea’s salt depths,

esteemed by all the gods as she deserves.

370She pitied Odysseus, tossed, tormented so—

she broke from the waves like a shearwater on the wing,

lit on the wreck and asked him kindly, “Ah poor man,

373why is the god of earthquakes so dead set against you?

Strewing your way with such a crop of troubles!

But he can’t destroy you, not for all his anger.

Just do as I say. You seem no fool to me.

Strip off those clothes and leave your craft

for the winds to hurl, and swim for it now, you must,

strike out with your arms for landfall there,

380Phaeacian land where destined safety waits.

Here, take this scarf,

tie it around your waist—it is immortal.

Nothing to fear now, neither pain nor death.

But once you grasp the mainland with your hands

untie it quickly, throw it into the wine-dark sea,

far from the shore, but you, you turn your head away!”

With that the goddess handed him the scarf

and slipped back in the heavy breaking seas

like a shearwater once again

390and a dark heaving billow closed above her.

But battle-weary Odysseus weighed two courses,

deeply torn, probing his fighting spirit: “Oh no—

I fear another immortal weaves a snare to trap me,

urging me to abandon ship! I won’t. Not yet.

That shore’s too far away—

I glimpsed it myself—where she says refuge waits.

No, here’s what I’ll do, it’s what seems best to me.

As long as the timbers cling and joints stand fast,

I’ll hold out aboard her and take a whipping—

400once the breakers smash my craft to pieces,

then I’ll swim—no better plan for now.”

But just as great Odysseus thrashed things out,

Poseidon god of the earthquake launched a colossal wave,

terrible, murderous, arching over him, pounding down on him,

hard as a windstorm blasting piles of dry parched chaff,

scattering flying husks—so the long planks of his boat

were scattered far and wide. But Odysseus leapt aboard

one timber and riding it like a plunging racehorse

stripped away his clothes, divine Calypso’s gifts,

410and quickly tying the scarf around his waist

he dove headfirst in the sea,

stretched his arms and stroked for life itself.

But again the mighty god of earthquakes spied him,

shook his head and grumbled deep in his spirit, “Go, go,

after all you’ve suffered—rove your miles of sea—

till you fall in the arms of people loved by Zeus.

Even so I can hardly think you’ll find

your punishments too light!”

With that threat

he lashed his team with their long flowing manes,

420gaining Aegae port where his famous palace stands.

But Zeus’s daughter Athena countered him at once.

The rest of the winds she stopped right in their tracks,

commanding them all to hush now, go to sleep.

All but the boisterous North—she whipped him up

and the goddess beat the breakers flat before Odysseus,

dear to Zeus, so he could reach the Phaeacians,

mingle with men who love their long oars

and escape his death at last.

Yes, but now,

adrift on the heaving swells two nights, two days—

430quite lost—again and again the man foresaw his death.

Then when Dawn with her lovely locks brought on

the third day, the wind fell in an instant,

all glazed to a dead calm, and Odysseus,

scanning sharply, raised high by a groundswell,

looked up and saw it—landfall, just ahead.

Joy… warm as the joy that children feel

when they see their father’s life dawn again,

one who’s lain on a sickbed racked with torment,

wasting away, slowly, under some angry power’s onslaught—

440then what joy when the gods deliver him from his pains!

So warm, Odysseus’ joy when he saw that shore, those trees,

as he swam on, anxious to plant his feet on solid ground again.

But just offshore, as far as a man’s shout can carry,

he caught the boom of a heavy surf on jagged reefs—

roaring breakers crashing down on an ironbound coast,

exploding in fury—

the whole sea shrouded—

sheets of spray—

no harbors to hold ships, no roadstead where they’d ride,

nothing but jutting headlands, riptooth reefs, cliffs.

Odysseus’ knees quaked and the heart inside him sank;

450he spoke to his fighting spirit, desperate: “Worse and worse!

Now that Zeus has granted a glimpse of land beyond my hopes,

now I’ve crossed this waste of water, the end in sight,

there’s no way out of the boiling surf—I see no way!

Rugged reefs offshore, around them breakers roaring,

above them a smooth rock face, rising steeply, look,

and the surge too deep inshore, no spot to stand

on my own two legs and battle free of death.

If I clamber out, some big comber will hoist me,

dash me against that cliff—my struggles all a waste!

460If I keep on swimming down the coast, trying to find

a seabeach shelving against the waves, a sheltered cove—

I dread it—another gale will snatch me up and haul me

back to the fish-infested sea, retching in despair.

Or a dark power will loose some monster at me,

rearing out of the waves—one of the thousands

Amphitrite’s breakers teem with. Well I know

467the famous god of earthquakes hates my very name!”

Just as that fear went churning through his mind

a tremendous roller swept him toward the rocky coast

470where he’d have been flayed alive, his bones crushed

if the bright-eyed goddess Pallas had not inspired him now.

He lunged for a reef, he seized it with both hands and clung

for dear life, groaning until the giant wave surged past

and so he escaped its force, but the breaker’s backwash

charged into him full fury and hurled him out to sea.

Like pebbles stuck in the suckers of some octopus

dragged from its lair—so strips of skin torn

from his clawing hands stuck to the rock face.

A heavy sea covered him over, then and there

480unlucky Odysseus would have met his death—

against the will of Fate—

but the bright-eyed one inspired him yet again.

Fighting out from the breakers pounding toward the coast,

out of danger he swam on, scanning the land, trying to find

a seabeach shelving against the waves, a sheltered cove,

and stroking hard he came abreast of a river’s mouth,

running calmly, the perfect spot, he thought…

free of rocks, with a windbreak from the gales.

As the current flowed he felt the river’s god and

490prayed to him in spirit: “Hear me, lord, whoever you are,

I’ve come to you, the answer to all my prayers—

rescue me from the sea, the Sea-lord’s curse!

Even immortal gods will show a man respect,

whatever wanderer seeks their help—like me—

I throw myself on your mercy, on your current now—

I have suffered greatly. Pity me, lord,

your suppliant cries for help!”

So the man prayed

and the god stemmed his current, held his surge at once

and smoothing out the swells before Odysseus now,

500drew him safe to shore at the river’s mouth.

His knees buckled, massive arms fell limp,

the sea had beaten down his striving heart.

His whole body swollen, brine aplenty gushing

out of his mouth and nostrils—breathless, speechless,

there he lay, with only a little strength left in him,

deathly waves of exhaustion overwhelmed him now…

But once he regained his breath and rallied back to life,

at last he loosed the goddess’ scarf from his body,

dropped it into the river flowing out to sea

510and a swift current bore it far downstream

and suddenly Ino caught it in her hands.

Struggling up from the banks, he flung himself

in the deep reeds, he kissed the good green earth

and addressed his fighting spirit, desperate still:

“Man of misery, what next? Is this the end?

If I wait out a long tense night by the banks,

I fear the sharp frost and the soaking dew together

will do me in—I’m bone-weary, about to breathe my last,

and a cold wind blows from a river on toward morning.

520But what if I climb that slope, go for the dark woods

and bed down in the thick brush? What if I’m spared

the chill, fatigue, and a sweet sleep comes my way?

I fear wild beasts will drag me off as quarry.”

But this was the better course, it struck him now.

He set out for the woods and not far from the water

found a grove with a clearing all around and crawled

beneath two bushy olives sprung from the same root,

one olive wild, the other well-bred stock.

No sodden gusty winds could ever pierce them,

530nor could the sun’s sharp rays invade their depths,

nor could a downpour drench them through and through,

so dense they grew together, tangling side-by-side.

Odysseus crept beneath them, scraping up at once

a good wide bed for himself with both hands.

A fine litter of dead leaves had drifted in,

enough to cover two men over, even three,

in the wildest kind of winter known to man.

Long-enduring great Odysseus, overjoyed at the sight,

bedded down in the midst and heaped the leaves around him.

540As a man will bury his glowing brand in black ashes,

off on a lonely farmstead, no neighbors near,

to keep a spark alive—no need to kindle fire

from somewhere else—so great Odysseus buried

himself in leaves and Athena showered sleep

upon his eyes… sleep in a swift wave

delivering him from all his pains and labors,

blessed sleep that sealed his eyes at last.

BOOK SIX

The Princess and the Stranger

S
o there he lay at rest, the storm-tossed great Odysseus,

borne down by his hard labors first and now deep sleep

as Athena traveled through the countryside

and reached the Phaeacians’ city. Years ago

they lived in a land of spacious dancing-circles,

6Hyperia, all too close to the overbearing Cyclops,

stronger, violent brutes who harried them without end.

8So their godlike king, Nausithous, led the people off

in a vast migration, settled them in Scheria,

10far from the men who toil on this earth—

he flung up walls around the city, built the houses,

raised the gods’ temples and shared the land for plowing.

But his fate had long since forced him down to Death

14and now Alcinous ruled, and the gods made him wise.

Straight to his house the clear-eyed Pallas went,

full of plans for great Odysseus’ journey home.

She made her way to the gaily painted room

where a young girl lay asleep…

a match for the deathless gods in build and beauty,

20Nausicaa, the daughter of generous King Alcinous.

21Two handmaids fair as the Graces slept beside her,

flanking the two posts, with the gleaming doors closed.

But the goddess drifted through like a breath of fresh air,

rushed to the girl’s bed and hovering close she spoke,

25in face and form like the shipman Dymas’ daughter,

a girl the princess’ age, and dearest to her heart.

Disguised, the bright-eyed goddess chided, “Nausicaa,

how could your mother bear a careless girl like you?

Look at your fine clothes, lying here neglected—

30with your marriage not far off,

the day you should be decked in all your glory

and offer elegant dress to those who form your escort.

That’s how a bride’s good name goes out across the world

and it brings her father and queenly mother joy. Come,

let’s go wash these clothes at the break of day—

I’ll help you, lend a hand, and the work will fly!

You won’t stay unwed long. The noblest men

in the country court you now, all Phaeacians

just like you, Phaeacia-born and raised. So come,

40the first thing in the morning press your kingly father

to harness the mules and wagon for you, all to carry

your sashes, dresses, glossy spreads for your bed.

It’s so much nicer for you to ride than go on foot.

The washing-pools are just too far from town.”

With that

the bright-eyed goddess sped away to Olympus, where,

46they say, the gods’ eternal mansion stands unmoved,

never rocked by galewinds, never drenched by rains,

nor do the drifting snows assail it, no, the clear air

stretches away without a cloud, and a great radiance

50plays across that world where the blithe gods

live all their days in bliss. There Athena went,

once the bright-eyed one had urged the princess on.

Dawn soon rose on her splendid throne and woke

Nausicaa finely gowned. Still beguiled by her dream,

down she went through the house to tell her parents now,

her beloved father and mother. She found them both inside.

Her mother sat at the hearth with several waiting-women,

spinning yarn on a spindle, lustrous sea-blue wool.

Her father she met as he left to join the lords

60at a council island nobles asked him to attend.

She stepped up close to him, confiding, “Daddy dear,

I wonder, won’t you have them harness a wagon for me,

the tall one with the good smooth wheels… so I

can take our clothes to the river for a washing?

Lovely things, but lying before me all soiled.

And you yourself, sitting among the princes,

debating points at your council,

you really should be wearing spotless linen.

Then you have five sons, full-grown in the palace,

70two of them married, but three are lusty bachelors

always demanding crisp shirts fresh from the wash

when they go out to dance. Look at my duties—

that all rests on me.”

So she coaxed, too shy

to touch on her hopes for marriage, young warm hopes,

in her father’s presence. But he saw through it all

and answered quickly, “I won’t deny you the mules,

my darling girl… I won’t deny you anything.

Off you go, and the men will harness a wagon,

the tall one with the good smooth wheels,

fitted out with a cradle on the top.”

80With that

he called to the stablemen and they complied.

They trundled the wagon out now, rolling smoothly,

backed the mule-team into the traces, hitched them up,

84while the princess brought her finery from the room

and piled it into the wagon’s polished cradle.

Her mother packed a hamper—treats of all kinds,

favorite things to refresh her daughter’s spirits—

poured wine in a skin, and as Nausicaa climbed aboard,

the queen gave her a golden flask of suppling olive oil

90for her and her maids to smooth on after bathing.

Then, taking the whip in hand and glistening reins,

she touched the mules to a start and out they clattered,

trotting on at a clip, bearing the princess and her clothes

and not alone: her maids went with her, stepping briskly too.

Once they reached the banks of the river flowing strong

where the pools would never fail, with plenty of water

cool and clear, bubbling up and rushing through

to scour the darkest stains—they loosed the mules,

out from under the wagon yoke, and chased them down

100the river’s rippling banks to graze on luscious clover.

Down from the cradle they lifted clothes by the armload,

plunged them into the dark pools and stamped them down

in the hollows, one girl racing the next to finish first

until they’d scoured and rinsed off all the grime,

then they spread them out in a line along the beach

where the surf had washed a pebbly scree ashore.

And once they’d bathed and smoothed their skin with oil,

they took their picnic, sitting along the river’s banks

and waiting for all the clothes to dry in the hot noon sun.

110Now fed to their hearts’ content, the princess and her retinue

threw their veils to the wind, struck up a game of ball.

White-armed Nausicaa led their singing, dancing beat…

as lithe as Artemis with her arrows striding down

114from a high peak—Taygetus’ towering ridge or Erymanthus—

thrilled to race with the wild boar or bounding deer,

and nymphs of the hills race with her,

daughters of Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder,

118ranging the hills in sport, and Leto’s heart exults

as head and shoulders over the rest her daughter rises,

120unmistakable—she outshines them all, though all are lovely.

So Nausicaa shone among her maids, a virgin, still unwed.

But now, as she was about to fold her clothes

and yoke the mules and turn for home again,

now clear-eyed Pallas thought of what came next,

to make Odysseus wake and see this young beauty

and she would lead him to the Phaeacians’ town.

The ball—

the princess suddenly tossed it to a maid

but it missed the girl, it splashed in a deep swirling pool

and they all shouted out—

and that woke great Odysseus.

130He sat up with a start, puzzling, his heart pounding:

“Man of misery, whose land have I lit on now?

What are they here—violent, savage, lawless?

or friendly to strangers, god-fearing men?

Listen: shouting, echoing round me—women, girls—

or the nymphs who haunt the rugged mountaintops

and the river springs and meadows lush with grass!

Or am I really close to people who speak my language?

Up with you, see how the land lies, see for yourself now…”

Muttering so, great Odysseus crept out of the bushes,

140stripping off with his massive hand a leafy branch

from the tangled olive growth to shield his body,

hide his private parts. And out he stalked

as a mountain lion exultant in his power

strides through wind and rain and his eyes blaze

and he charges sheep or oxen or chases wild deer

but his hunger drives him on to go for flocks,

even to raid the best-defended homestead.

So Odysseus moved out…

about to mingle with all those lovely girls,

150naked now as he was, for the need drove him on,

a terrible sight, all crusted, caked with brine—

they scattered in panic down the jutting beaches.

Only Alcinous’ daughter held fast, for Athena planted

courage within her heart, dissolved the trembling in her limbs,

and she firmly stood her ground and faced Odysseus, torn now—

156Should he fling his arms around her knees, the young beauty,

plead for help, or stand back, plead with a winning word,

beg her to lead him to the town and lend him clothing?

This was the better way, he thought. Plead now

160with a subtle, winning word and stand well back,

don’t clasp her knees, the girl might bridle, yes.

He launched in at once, endearing, sly and suave:

“Here I am at your mercy, princess—

are you a goddess or a mortal? If one of the gods

who rule the skies up there, you’re Artemis to the life,

the daughter of mighty Zeus—I see her now—just look

at your build, your bearing, your lithe flowing grace…

But if you’re one of the mortals living here on earth,

three times blest are your father, your queenly mother,

170three times over your brothers too. How often their hearts

must warm with joy to see you striding into the dances—

such a bloom of beauty. True, but he is the one

more blest than all other men alive, that man

who sways you with gifts and leads you home, his bride!

I have never laid eyes on anyone like you,

neither man nor woman…

I look at you and a sense of wonder takes me.

Wait,

178once I saw the like—in Delos, beside Apollo’s altar—

the young slip of a palm-tree springing into the light.

180There I’d sailed, you see, with a great army in my wake,

out on the long campaign that doomed my life to hardship.

That vision! Just as I stood there gazing, rapt, for hours…

no shaft like that had ever risen up from the earth—

so now I marvel at you, my lady: rapt, enthralled,

too struck with awe to grasp you by the knees

though pain has ground me down.

Only yesterday,

the twentieth day, did I escape the wine-dark sea.

Till then the waves and the rushing gales had swept me on

from the island of Ogygia. Now some power has tossed me here,

190doubtless to suffer still more torments on your shores.

I can’t believe they’ll stop. Long before that

the gods will give me more, still more.

Compassion—

princess, please! You, after all that I have suffered,

you are the first I’ve come to. I know no one else,

none in your city, no one in your land.

Show me the way to town, give me a rag for cover,

just some cloth, some wrapper you carried with you here.

And may the good gods give you all your heart desires:

husband, and house, and lasting harmony too.

200No finer, greater gift in the world than that…

when man and woman possess their home, two minds,

two hearts that work as one. Despair to their enemies,

a joy to all their friends. Their own best claim to glory.”

“Stranger,” the white-armed princess answered staunchly,

“friend, you’re hardly a wicked man, and no fool, I’d say—

it’s Olympian Zeus himself who hands our fortunes out,

to each of us in turn, to the good and bad,

however Zeus prefers…

He gave you pain, it seems. You simply have to bear it.

210But now, seeing you’ve reached our city and our land,

you’ll never lack for clothing or any other gift,

the right of worn-out suppliants come our way.

I’ll show you our town, tell you our people’s name.

Phaeacians we are, who hold this city and this land,

and I am the daughter of generous King Alcinous.

All our people’s power stems from him.”

She called out to her girls with lovely braids:

“Stop, my friends! Why run when you see a man?

Surely you don’t think him an enemy, do you?

220There’s no one alive, there never will be one,

who’d reach Phaeacian soil and lay it waste.

The immortals love us far too much for that.

We live too far apart, out in the surging sea,

off at the world’s end—

no other mortals come to mingle with us.

But here’s an unlucky wanderer strayed our way

and we must tend him well. Every stranger and beggar

comes from Zeus, and whatever scrap we give him

he’ll be glad to get. So, quick, my girls,

230give our newfound friend some food and drink

and bathe the man in the river,

wherever you find some shelter from the wind.”

At that

they came to a halt and teased each other on

and led Odysseus down to a sheltered spot

where he could find a seat,

just as great Alcinous’ daughter told them.

They laid out cloak and shirt for him to wear,

they gave him the golden flask of suppling olive oil

and pressed him to bathe himself in the river’s stream.

240Then thoughtful Odysseus reassured the handmaids,

“Stand where you are, dear girls, a good way off,

so I can rinse the brine from my shoulders now

and rub myself with oil…

how long it’s been since oil touched my skin!

245But I won’t bathe in front of you. I would be embarrassed—

stark naked before young girls with lovely braids.”

The handmaids scurried off to tell their mistress.

Great Odysseus bathed in the river, scrubbed his body

clean of brine that clung to his back and broad shoulders,

250scoured away the brackish scurf that caked his head.

And then, once he had bathed all over, rubbed in oil

and donned the clothes the virgin princess gave him,

Zeus’s daughter Athena made him taller to all eyes,

his build more massive now, and down from his brow

she ran his curls like thick hyacinth clusters

full of blooms. As a master craftsman washes

gold over beaten silver—a man the god of fire

and Queen Athena trained in every fine technique—

and finishes off his latest effort, handsome work,

260so she lavished splendor over his head and shoulders now.

And down to the beach he walked and sat apart,

glistening in his glory, breathtaking, yes,

and the princess gazed in wonder…

then turned to her maids with lovely braided hair:

“Listen, my white-armed girls, to what I tell you.

The gods of Olympus can’t be all against this man

who’s come to mingle among our noble people.

At first he seemed appalling, I must say—

now he seems like a god who rules the skies up there!

270Ah, if only a man like that were called my husband,

lived right here, pleased to stay forever…

Enough.

Give the stranger food and drink, my girls.”

They hung on her words and did her will at once,

set before Odysseus food and drink, and he ate and drank,

the great Odysseus, long deprived, so ravenous now—

it seemed like years since he had tasted food.

The white-armed princess thought of one last thing.

Folding the clothes, she packed them into her painted wagon,

hitched the sharp-hoofed mules, and climbing up herself,

280Nausicaa urged Odysseus, warmly urged her guest,

“Up with you now, my friend, and off to town we go.

I’ll see you into my wise father’s palace where,

I promise you, you’ll meet all the best Phaeacians.

Wait, let’s do it this way. You seem no fool to me.

While we’re passing along the fields and plowlands,

you follow the mules and wagon, stepping briskly

with all my maids. I’ll lead the way myself.

But once we reach our city, ringed by walls

and strong high towers too, with a fine harbor either side…

290and the causeway in is narrow; along the road the rolling ships

are all hauled up, with a slipway cleared for every vessel.

There’s our assembly, round Poseidon’s royal precinct,

built of quarried slabs planted deep in the earth.

Here the sailors tend their black ships’ tackle,

cables and sails, and plane their oarblades down.

Phaeacians, you see, care nothing for bow or quiver,

only for masts and oars and good trim ships themselves—

we glory in our ships, crossing the foaming seas!

But I shrink from all our sea-dogs’ nasty gossip.

300Some old salt might mock us behind our backs—

we have our share of insolent types in town

and one of the coarser sort, spying us, might say,

‘Now who’s that tall, handsome stranger Nausicaa has in tow?

Where’d she light on him? Her husband-to-be, just wait!

But who—some shipwrecked stray she’s taken up with,

some alien from abroad? Since nobody lives nearby.

Unless it’s really a god come down from the blue

to answer all her prayers, and to have her all his days.

Good riddance! Let the girl go roving to find herself

310a man from foreign parts. She only spurns her own—

countless Phaeacians round about who court her,

nothing but our best.’

So they’ll scoff…

just think of the scandal that would face me then.

I’d find fault with a girl who carried on that way,

flouting her parents’ wishes—father, mother, still alive—

consorting with men before she’d tied the knot in public.

No, stranger, listen closely to what I say, the sooner

to win your swift voyage home at my father’s hands.

Now, you’ll find a splendid grove along the road—

320poplars, sacred to Pallas—

a bubbling spring’s inside and meadows run around it.

There lies my father’s estate, his blossoming orchard too,

as far from town as a man’s strong shout can carry.

Take a seat there, wait a while, and give us time

to make it into town and reach my father’s house.

Then, when you think we’re home, walk on yourself

to the city, ask the way to my father’s palace,

generous King Alcinous. You cannot miss it,

even an innocent child could guide you there.

330No other Phaeacian’s house is built like that:

so grand, the palace of Alcinous, our great hero.

Once the mansion and courtyard have enclosed you, go,

quickly, across the hall until you reach my mother.

Beside the hearth she sits in the fire’s glare,

spinning yarn on a spindle, sea-blue wool—

a stirring sight, you’ll see…

she leans against a pillar, her ladies sit behind.

And my father’s throne is drawn up close beside her;

there he sits and takes his wine, a mortal like a god.

340Go past him, grasp my mother’s knees—if you want

to see the day of your return, rejoicing, soon,

even if your home’s a world away.

If only the queen will take you to her heart,

then there’s hope that you will see your loved ones,

reach your own grand house, your native land at last.”

At that she touched the mules with her shining whip

and they quickly left the running stream behind.

The team trotted on, their hoofs wove in and out.

She drove them back with care so all the rest,

350maids and Odysseus, could keep the pace on foot,

and she used the whip discreetly.

The sun sank as they reached the hallowed grove,

sacred to Athena, where Odysseus stopped and sat

and said a prayer at once to mighty Zeus’s daughter:

“Hear me, daughter of Zeus whose shield is thunder—

tireless one, Athena! Now hear my prayer at last,

for you never heard me then, when I was shattered,

when the famous god of earthquakes wrecked my craft.

Grant that here among the Phaeacian people

360I may find some mercy and some love!”

So he prayed and Athena heard his prayer

but would not yet appear to him undisguised.

She stood in awe of her Father’s brother, lord of the sea

who still seethed on, still churning with rage against

the great Odysseus till he reached his native land.

BOOK SEVEN

Phaeacia’s Halls and Gardens

N
ow as Odysseus, long an exile, prayed in Athena’s grove,

the hardy mule-team drew the princess toward the city.

Reaching her father’s splendid halls, she reined in,

just at the gates—her brothers clustering round her,

men like gods, released the mules from the yoke

and brought the clothes indoors

as Nausicaa made her way toward her bedroom.

There her chambermaid lit a fire for her—

9Eurymedusa, the old woman who’d come from Apiraea

10years ago, when the rolling ships had sailed her in

and the country picked her out as King Alcinous’ prize,

for he ruled all the Phaeacians, they obeyed him like a god.

Once, she had nursed the white-armed princess in the palace.

Now she lit a fire and made her supper in the room.

At the same time, Odysseus set off toward the city.

Pallas Athena, harboring kindness for the hero,

drifted a heavy mist around him, shielding him

from any swaggering islander who’d cross his path,

provoke him with taunts and search out who he was.

20Instead, as he was about to enter the welcome city,

the bright-eyed goddess herself came up to greet him there,

for all the world like a young girl, holding a pitcher,

standing face-to-face with the visitor, who asked,

“Little girl, now wouldn’t you be my guide

to the palace of the one they call Alcinous?

The king who rules the people of these parts.

I am a stranger, you see, weighed down with troubles,

come this way from a distant, far-off shore.

So I know no one here, none at all

in your city and the farmlands round about.”

30“Oh yes, sir,

good old stranger,” the bright-eyed goddess said,

“I’ll show you the very palace that you’re after—

the king lives right beside my noble father.

Come, quietly too, and I will lead the way.

Now not a glance at anyone, not a question.

The men here never suffer strangers gladly,

have no love for hosting a man from foreign lands.

All they really trust are their fast, flying ships

that cross the mighty ocean. Gifts of Poseidon,

40ah what ships they are—

quick as a bird, quick as a darting thought!”

And Pallas Athena sped away in the lead

as he followed in her footsteps, man and goddess.

But the famed Phaeacian sailors never saw him,

right in their midst, striding down their streets.

Athena the one with lovely braids would not permit it,

the awesome goddess poured an enchanted mist around him,

harboring kindness for Odysseus in her heart.

And he marveled now at the balanced ships and havens,

50the meeting grounds of the great lords and the long ramparts

looming, coped and crowned with palisades of stakes—

an amazing sight to see…

And once they reached the king’s resplendent halls

the bright-eyed goddess cried out, “Good old stranger,

here, here is the very palace that you’re after—

I’ve guided you all the way. Here you’ll find

our princes dear to the gods, busy feasting.

You go on inside. Be bold, nothing to fear.

In every venture the bold man comes off best,

60even the wanderer, bound from distant shores.

The queen is the first you’ll light on in the halls.

62Arete, she is called, and earns the name:

she answers all our prayers. She comes, in fact,

64from the same stock that bred our King Alcinous.

First came Nausithous, son of the earthquake god

66Poseidon and Periboea, the lovely, matchless beauty,

67the youngest daughter of iron-willed Eurymedon,

king of the overweening Giants years ago.

He led that reckless clan to its own ruin,

70killed himself in the bargain, but the Sea-lord

lay in love with Periboea and she produced a son,

Nausithous, that lionheart who ruled Phaeacia well.

73Now, Nausithous had two sons, Rhexenor and Alcinous,

but the lord of the silver bow, Apollo, shot Rhexenor down—

married, true, yet still without a son in the halls,

he left one child behind, a daughter named Arete.

Alcinous made the girl his wife and honors her

as no woman is honored on this earth, of all the wives

now keeping households under their husbands’ sway.

80Such is her pride of place, and always will be so:

dear to her loving children, to Alcinous himself

and all our people. They gaze on her as a god,

saluting her warmly on her walks through town.

She lacks nothing in good sense and judgment—

she can dissolve quarrels, even among men,

whoever wins her sympathies.

If only our queen will take you to her heart,

then there’s hope that you will see your loved ones,

reach your high-roofed house, your native land at last.”

90And with that vow the bright-eyed goddess sped away,

over the barren sea, leaving welcome Scheria far behind,

92and reaching Marathon and the spacious streets of Athens,

93entered Erechtheus’ sturdy halls, Athena’s stronghold.

Now as Odysseus approached Alcinous’ famous house

a rush of feelings stirred within his heart,

bringing him to a standstill,

even before he crossed the bronze threshold…

A radiance strong as the moon or rising sun came flooding

through the high-roofed halls of generous King Alcinous.

100Walls plated in bronze, crowned with a circling frieze

glazed as blue as lapis, ran to left and right

from outer gates to the deepest court recess,

and solid golden doors enclosed the palace.

Up from the bronze threshold silver doorposts rose

with silver lintel above, and golden handle hooks.

And dogs of gold and silver were stationed either side,

forged by the god of fire with all his cunning craft

to keep watch on generous King Alcinous’ palace,

his immortal guard-dogs, ageless, all their days.

110Inside to left and right, in a long unbroken row

from farthest outer gate to the inmost chamber,

thrones stood backed against the wall, each draped

with a finely spun brocade, women’s handsome work.

Here the Phaeacian lords would sit enthroned,

dining, drinking—the feast flowed on forever.

And young boys, molded of gold, set on pedestals

standing firm, were lifting torches high in their hands

to flare through the nights and light the feasters down the hall.

And Alcinous has some fifty serving-women in his house:

120some, turning the handmill, grind the apple-yellow grain,

some weave at their webs or sit and spin their yarn,

fingers flickering quick as aspen leaves in the wind

and the densely woven woolens dripping oil droplets.

Just as Phaeacian men excel the world at sailing,

driving their swift ships on the open seas,

so the women excel at all the arts of weaving.

That is Athena’s gift to them beyond all others—

a genius for lovely work, and a fine mind too.

Outside the courtyard, fronting the high gates,

130a magnificent orchard stretches four acres deep

with a strong fence running round it side-to-side.

Here luxuriant trees are always in their prime,

pomegranates and pears, and apples glowing red,

succulent figs and olives swelling sleek and dark.

And the yield of all these trees will never flag or die,

neither in winter nor in summer, a harvest all year round

for the West Wind always breathing through will bring

some fruits to the bud and others warm to ripeness—

pear mellowing ripe on pear, apple on apple,

140cluster of grapes on cluster, fig crowding fig.

And here is a teeming vineyard planted for the kings,

beyond it an open level bank where the vintage grapes

lie baking to raisins in the sun while pickers gather others;

some they trample down in vats, and here in the front rows

bunches of unripe grapes have hardly shed their blooms

while others under the sunlight slowly darken purple.

And there by the last rows are beds of greens,

bordered and plotted, greens of every kind,

glistening fresh, year in, year out. And last,

150there are two springs, one rippling in channels

over the whole orchard—the other, flanking it,

rushes under the palace gates

to bubble up in front of the lofty roofs

where the city people come and draw their water.

Such

were the gifts, the glories showered down by the gods

on King Alcinous’ realm.

And there Odysseus stood,

gazing at all this bounty, a man who’d borne so much…

Once he’d had his fill of marveling at it all,

he crossed the threshold quickly,

160strode inside the palace. Here he found

the Phaeacian lords and captains tipping out

libations now to the guide and giant-killer Hermes,

the god to whom they would always pour the final cup

before they sought their beds. Odysseus went on

striding down the hall, the man of many struggles

shrouded still in the mist Athena drifted round him,

till he reached Arete and Alcinous the king. And then,

the moment he flung his arms around Arete’s knees,

the godsent mist rolled back to reveal the great man.

170And silence seized the feasters all along the hall—

seeing him right before their eyes, they marveled,

gazing on him now as Odysseus pleaded, “Queen,

Arete, daughter of godlike King Rhexenor!

Here after many trials I come to beg for mercy,

your husband’s, yours, and all these feasters’ here.

May the gods endow them with fortune all their lives,

may each hand down to his sons the riches in his house

and the pride of place the realm has granted him.

But as for myself, grant me a rapid convoy home

180to my own native land. How far away I’ve been

from all my loved ones—how long I have suffered!”

Pleading so, the man sank down in the ashes,

just at the hearth beside the blazing fire,

while all the rest stayed hushed, stock-still.

185At last the old revered Echeneus broke the spell,

the eldest lord in Phaeacia, finest speaker too,

a past master at all the island’s ancient ways.

Impelled by kindness now, he rose and said,

“This is no way, Alcinous. How indecent, look,

190our guest on the ground, in the ashes by the fire!

Your people are holding back, waiting for your signal.

Come, raise him up and seat the stranger now,

in a silver-studded chair,

and tell the heralds to mix more wine for all

so we can pour out cups to Zeus who loves the lightning,

champion of suppliants—suppliants’ rights are sacred.

And let the housekeeper give our guest his supper,

unstinting with her stores.”

Hearing that,

Alcinous, poised in all his majesty, took the hand

200of the seasoned, worldly-wise Odysseus, raised him up

from the hearth and sat him down in a burnished chair,

202displacing his own son, the courtly Lord Laodamas

who had sat beside him, the son he loved the most.

A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

and over a silver basin tipped it out

so the guest might rinse his hands,

then pulled a gleaming table to his side.

A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve him,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

210As long-suffering great Odysseus ate and drank,

the hallowed King Alcinous called his herald:

212“Come, Pontonous! Mix the wine in the bowl,

pour rounds to all our banqueters in the house

so we can pour out cups to Zeus who loves the lightning,

champion of suppliants—suppliants’ rights are sacred.”

At that Pontonous mixed the heady, honeyed wine

and tipped first drops for the god in every cup,

then poured full rounds for all. And once they’d poured

libations out and drunk to their hearts’ content,

220Alcinous rose and addressed his island people:

“Hear me, lords and captains of Phaeacia,

hear what the heart inside me has to say.

Now, our feast finished, home you go to sleep.

But at dawn we call the elders in to full assembly,

host our guest in the palace, sacrifice to the gods

and then we turn our minds to his passage home,

so under our convoy our new friend can travel back

to his own land—no toil, no troubles—soon,

rejoicing, even if his home’s a world away.

230And on the way no pain or hardship suffered,

not till he sets foot on native ground again.

There in the future he must suffer all that Fate

233and the overbearing Spinners spun out on his life line

the very day his mother gave him birth… But if

he’s one of the deathless powers, out of the blue,

the gods are working now in strange, new ways.

Always, up to now, they came to us face-to-face

whenever we’d give them grand, glorious sacrifices—

they always sat beside us here and shared our feasts.

240Even when some lonely traveler meets them on the roads,

they never disguise themselves. We’re too close kin for that,

close as the wild Giants are, the Cyclops too.”

“Alcinous!”

wary Odysseus countered, “cross that thought from your mind.

I’m nothing like the immortal gods who rule the skies,

either in build or breeding. I’m just a mortal man.

Whom do you know most saddled down with sorrow?

They are the ones I’d equal, grief for grief.

And I could tell a tale of still more hardship,

all I’ve suffered, thanks to the gods’ will.

250But despite my misery, let me finish dinner.

The belly’s a shameless dog, there’s nothing worse.

Always insisting, pressing, it never lets us forget—

destroyed as I am, my heart racked with sadness,

sick with anguish, still it keeps demanding,

‘Eat, drink!’ It blots out all the memory

of my pain, commanding, ‘Fill me up!’

But you,

at the first light of day, hurry, please,

to set your unlucky guest on his own home soil.

How much I have suffered… Oh just let me see

260my lands, my serving-men and the grand high-roofed house—

then I can die in peace.”

All burst into applause,

urging passage home for their newfound friend,

his pleading rang so true. And once they’d poured

libations out and drunk to their hearts’ content,

each one made his way to rest in his own house.

But King Odysseus still remained at hall,

seated beside the royal Alcinous and Arete

as servants cleared the cups and plates away.

The white-armed Queen Arete took the lead;

270she’d spotted the cape and shirt Odysseus wore,

fine clothes she’d made herself with all her women,

so now her words flew brusquely, sharply: “Stranger,

I’ll be the first to question you—myself.

Who are you? Where are you from?

Who gave you the clothes you’re wearing now?

Didn’t you say you reached us roving on the sea?”

“What hard labor, queen,” the man of craft replied,

“to tell you the story of my troubles start to finish.

The gods on high have given me my share.

280Still, this much I will tell you…

seeing you probe and press me so intently.

There is an island, Ogygia, lying far at sea,

where the daughter of Atlas, Calypso, has her home,

the seductive nymph with lovely braids—a danger too,

and no one, god or mortal, dares approach her there. But I,

cursed as I am, some power brought me to her hearth,

alone, when Zeus with a white-hot bolt had crushed

my racing warship down the wine-dark sea.

There all the rest of my loyal shipmates died

290but I, locking my arms around my good ship’s keel,

drifted along nine days. On the tenth, at dead of night,

the gods cast me up on Ogygia, Calypso’s island,

home of the dangerous nymph with glossy braids,

and the goddess took me in in all her kindness,

welcomed me warmly, cherished me, even vowed

to make me immortal, ageless, all my days—

but she never won the heart inside me, never.

Seven endless years I remained there, always drenching

with my tears the immortal clothes Calypso gave me.

300Then, at last, when the eighth came wheeling round,

she insisted that I sail—inspired by warnings sent

from Zeus, perhaps, or her own mind had changed.

She saw me on my way in a solid craft,

tight and trim, and gave me full provisions,

food and mellow wine, immortal clothes to wear

and summoned a wind to bear me onward, fair and warm.

And seventeen days I sailed, making headway well;

on the eighteenth, shadowy mountains slowly loomed…

your land! My heart leapt up, unlucky as I am,

310doomed to be comrade still to many hardships.

Many pains the god of earthquakes piled upon me,

loosing the winds against me, blocking passage through,

heaving up a terrific sea, beyond belief—nor did the whitecaps

let me cling to my craft, for all my desperate groaning.

No, the squalls shattered her stem to stern, but I,

I swam hard, I plowed my way through those dark gulfs

till at last the wind and current bore me to your shores.

But here, had I tried to land, the breakers would have hurled me,

smashed me against the jagged cliffs of that grim coast,

320so I pulled away, swam back till I reached a river,

the perfect spot at last, or so it struck me,

free of rocks, with a windbreak from the gales.

So, fighting for life, I flung myself ashore

and the godsent, bracing night came on at once.

Clambering up from the river, big with Zeus’s rains,

I bedded down in the brush, my body heaped with leaves,

and a god poured down a boundless sleep upon me, yes,

and there in the leaves, exhausted, sick at heart,

I slept the whole night through

330and on to the break of day and on into high noon

and the sun was wheeling down when sweet sleep set me free.

And I looked up, and there were your daughter’s maids

at play on the beach, and she, she moved among them

like a deathless goddess! I begged her for help

and not once did her sense of tact desert her;

she behaved as you’d never hope to find

in one so young, not in a random meeting—

time and again the youngsters prove so flighty.

Not she. She gave me food aplenty and shining wine,

340a bath in the river too, and gave me all this clothing.

That’s my whole story. Wrenching to tell, but true.”

“Ah, but in one regard, my friend,” the king replied,

“her good sense missed the mark, this daughter of mine.

She never escorted you to our house with all her maids

but she was the first you asked for care and shelter.”

“Your majesty,” diplomatic Odysseus answered,

“don’t find fault with a flawless daughter now,

not for my sake, please.

She urged me herself to follow with her maids.

350I chose not to, fearing embarrassment in fact—

what if you took offense, seeing us both together?

Suspicious we are, we men who walk the earth.”

“Oh no, my friend,” Alcinous stated flatly,

“I’m hardly a man for reckless, idle anger.

Balance is best in all things.

356Father Zeus, Athena and lord Apollo! if only—

seeing the man you are, seeing we think as one—

you could wed my daughter and be my son-in-law

and stay right here with us. I’d give you a house

360and great wealth—if you chose to stay, that is.

No Phaeacian would hold you back by force.

The curse of Father Zeus on such a thing!

And about your convoy home, you rest assured:

I have chosen the day and I decree it is tomorrow.

And all that voyage long you’ll lie in a deep sleep

while my people sail you on through calm and gentle tides

till you reach your land and house, or any place you please.

368True, even if landfall lies more distant than Euboea,

off at the edge of the world…

370So say our crews, at least, who saw it once,

371that time they carried the gold-haired Rhadamanthys

372out to visit Tityus, son of Mother Earth. Imagine,

there they sailed and back they came in the same day,

they finished the homeward run with no strain at all.

You’ll see for yourself how far they top the best—

my ships and their young shipmates

tossing up the whitecaps with their oars!”

So he vowed

and the long-enduring great Odysseus glowed with joy

and raised a prayer and called the god by name:

“Father Zeus on high—

380may the king fulfill his promises one and all!

Then his fame would ring through the fertile earth

and never die—and I should reach my native land at last!”

And now as the two men exchanged their hopes,

the white-armed queen instructed her palace maids

to make a bed in the porch’s shelter, lay down

some heavy purple throws for the bed itself,

and over it spread some blankets, thick woolly robes,

a warm covering laid on top. Torches in hand,

they left the hall and fell to work at once,

390briskly prepared a good snug resting-place

and then returned to Odysseus, urged the guest,

“Up, friend, time for sleep. Your bed is made.”

How welcome the thought of sleep to that man now…

So there after many trials Odysseus lay at rest

on a corded bed inside the echoing colonnade.

Alcinous slept in chambers deep in his lofty house

where the queen his wife arranged and shared their bed.

BOOK EIGHT

A Day for Songs and Contests

W
hen young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

royal Alcinous, hallowed island king, rose from bed

and great Odysseus, raider of cities, rose too.

Poised in his majesty, Alcinous led the way

to Phaeacia’s meeting grounds, built for all

beside the harbored ships. Both men sat down

on the polished stone benches side-by-side

as Athena started roaming up and down the town,

in build and voice the wise Alcinous’ herald,

10furthering plans for Odysseus’ journey home,

and stopped beside each citizen, urged them all,

“Come this way, you lords and captains of Phaeacia,

come to the meeting grounds and learn about the stranger!

A new arrival! Here at our wise king’s palace now,

he’s here from roving the ocean, driven far off course—

he looks like a deathless god!”

Rousing their zeal,

their curiosity, each and every man, and soon enough

the assembly seats were filled with people thronging,

gazing in wonder at the seasoned man of war…

20Over Odysseus’ head and shoulders now

Athena lavished a marvelous splendor, yes,

making him taller, more massive to all eyes,

so Phaeacians might regard the man with kindness,

awe and respect as well, and he might win through

the many trials they’d pose to test the hero’s strength.

Once they’d grouped, crowding the meeting grounds,

Alcinous rose and addressed his island people:

“Hear me, lords and captains of Phaeacia,

hear what the heart inside me has to say.

30This stranger here, our guest—

I don’t know who he is, or whether he comes

from sunrise lands or the western lands of evening,

but he has come in his wanderings to my palace;

he pleads for passage, he begs we guarantee it.

So now, as in years gone by, let us press on

and grant him escort. No one, I tell you, no one

who comes to my house will languish long here,

heartsick for convoy home.

Come, my people!

Haul a black ship down to the bright sea,

40rigged for her maiden voyage—

41enlist a crew of fifty-two young sailors,

42the best in town, who’ve proved their strength before.

Let all hands lash their oars to the thwarts then disembark,

come to my house and fall in for a banquet, quickly.

I’ll lay on a princely feast for all. So then,

these are the orders I issue to our crews.

For the rest, you sceptered princes here,

you come to my royal halls so we can give

this stranger a hero’s welcome in our palace—

50no one here refuse. Call in the inspired bard

51Demodocus. God has given the man the gift of song,

to him beyond all others, the power to please,

however the spirit stirs him on to sing.”

With those commands Alcinous led the way

and a file of sceptered princes took his lead

while the herald went to find the gifted bard.

And the fifty-two young sailors, duly chosen,

briskly following orders,

went down to the shore of the barren salt sea.

60And once they reached the ship at the surf’s edge,

first they hauled the craft into deeper water,

stepped the mast amidships, canvas brailed,

they made oars fast in the leather oarlock straps,

moored her riding high on the swell, then disembarked

and made their way to wise Alcinous’ high-roofed halls.

There colonnades and courts and rooms were overflowing

with crowds, a mounting host of people young and old.

The king slaughtered a dozen sheep to feed his guests,

eight boars with shining tusks and a pair of shambling oxen.

70These they skinned and dressed, and then laid out a feast

to fill the heart with savor.

In came the herald now,

leading along the faithful bard the Muse adored

above all others, true, but her gifts were mixed

with good and evil both: she stripped him of sight

but gave the man the power of stirring, rapturous song.

Pontonous brought the bard a silver-studded chair,

right amid the feasters, leaning it up against

a central column—hung his high clear lyre

on a peg above his head and showed him how

80to reach up with his hands and lift it down.

And the herald placed a table by his side

with a basket full of bread and cup of wine

for him to sip when his spirit craved refreshment.

All reached out for the good things that lay at hand

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

the Muse inspired the bard

to sing the famous deeds of fighting heroes—

the song whose fame had reached the skies those days:

89The Strife Between Odysseus and Achilles, Peleus’ Son…

90how once at the gods’ lavish feast the captains clashed

in a savage war of words, while Agamemnon, lord of armies,

rejoiced at heart that Achaea’s bravest men were battling so.

For this was the victory sign that Apollo prophesied

94at his shrine in Pytho when Agamemnon strode across

the rocky threshold, asking the oracle for advice—

the start of the tidal waves of ruin tumbling down

on Troy’s and Achaea’s forces, both at once,

thanks to the will of Zeus who rules the world.

That was the song the famous harper sang

100but Odysseus, clutching his flaring sea-blue cape

in both powerful hands, drew it over his head

and buried his handsome face,

ashamed his hosts might see him shedding tears.

Whenever the rapt bard would pause in the song,

he’d lift the cape from his head, wipe off his tears

and hoisting his double-handled cup, pour it out to the gods.

But soon as the bard would start again, impelled to sing

by Phaeacia’s lords, who reveled in his tale,

again Odysseus hid his face and wept.

110His weeping went unmarked by all the others;

only Alcinous, sitting close beside him,

noticed his guest’s tears,

heard the groan in the man’s labored breathing

and said at once to the master mariners around him,

“Hear me, my lords and captains of Phaeacia!

By now we’ve had our fill of food well-shared

and the lyre too, our loyal friend at banquets.

Now out we go again and test ourselves in contests,

games of every kind—so our guest can tell his friends,

120when he reaches home, how far we excel the world

at boxing, wrestling, jumping, speed of foot.”

He forged ahead and the rest fell in behind.

The herald hung the ringing lyre back on its peg

and taking Demodocus by the hand, led him from the palace,

guiding him down the same path the island lords

had just pursued, keen to watch the contests.

They reached the meeting grounds

with throngs of people streaming in their trail

129as a press of young champions rose for competition.

130Topsail and Riptide rose, the helmsman Rowhard too

and Seaman and Sternman, Surf-at-the-Beach and Stroke-Oar,

Breaker and Bowsprit, Racing-the-Wind and Swing-Aboard

and Seagirt the son of Greatfleet, Shipwrightson

and the son of Launcher, Broadsea, rose up too,

135a match for murderous Ares, death to men—

in looks and build the best of all Phaeacians

after gallant Laodamas, the Captain of the People.

Laodamas rose with two more sons of great Alcinous,

139Halius bred to the sea and Clytoneus famed for ships.

140And now the games began, the first event a footrace…

They toed the line—

and broke flat out from the start

with a fast pack flying down the field in a whirl of dust

and Clytoneus the prince outstripped them all by far,

144flashing ahead the length two mules will plow a furrow

before he turned for home, leaving the pack behind

and raced to reach the crowds.

Next the wrestling,

grueling sport. They grappled, locked, and Broadsea,

pinning the strongest champions, won the bouts.

Next, in the jumping, Seagirt leapt and beat the field.

150In the discus Rowhard up and outhurled them all by far.

And the king’s good son Laodamas boxed them to their knees.

When all had enjoyed the games to their hearts’ content

Alcinous’ son Laodamas spurred them: “Come, my friends,

let’s ask our guest if he knows the ropes of any sport.

He’s no mean man, not with a build like that…

Look at his thighs, his legs, and what a pair of arms—

his massive neck, his big, rippling strength!

Nor is he past his prime,

just beaten down by one too many blows.

160Nothing worse than the sea, I always say,

to crush a man, the strongest man alive.”

And Broadsea put in quickly,

“Well said, Laodamas, right to the point.

Go up to the fellow, challenge him yourself.”

On that cue, the noble prince strode up

before Odysseus, front and center, asking,

“Come, stranger, sir, won’t you try your hand

at our contests now? If you have skill in any.

It’s fit and proper for you to know your sports.

170What greater glory attends a man, while he’s alive,

than what he wins with his racing feet and striving hands?

Come and compete then, throw your cares to the wind!

It won’t be long, your journey’s not far off—

your ship’s already hauled down to the sea,

your crew is set to sail.”

“Laodamas,”

quick to the mark Odysseus countered sharply,

“why do you taunt me so with such a challenge?

Pains weigh on my spirit now, not your sports—

I’ve suffered much already, struggled hard.

180But here I sit amid your assembly still,

starved for passage home, begging your king,

begging all your people.”

“Oh I knew it!”

Broadsea broke in, mocking him to his face.

“I never took you for someone skilled in games,

the kind that real men play throughout the world.

186Not a chance. You’re some skipper of profiteers,

roving the high seas in his scudding craft,

reckoning up his freight with a keen eye out

for home-cargo, grabbing the gold he can!

You’re no athlete. I see that.”

190With a dark glance

wily Odysseus shot back, “Indecent talk, my friend.

You, you’re a reckless fool—I see that. So,

the gods don’t hand out all their gifts at once,

not build and brains and flowing speech to all.

One man may fail to impress us with his looks

but a god can crown his words with beauty, charm,

and men look on with delight when he speaks out.

Never faltering, filled with winning self-control,

he shines forth at assembly grounds and people gaze

200at him like a god when he walks through the streets.

Another man may look like a deathless one on high

but there’s not a bit of grace to crown his words.

Just like you, my fine, handsome friend. Not even

a god could improve those lovely looks of yours

but the mind inside is worthless.

Your slander fans the anger in my heart!

I’m no stranger to sports—for all your taunts—

I’ve held my place in the front ranks, I tell you,

long as I could trust to my youth and striving hands.

210But now I’m wrestled down by pain and hardship, look,

I’ve borne my share of struggles, cleaving my way

through wars of men and pounding waves at sea.

Nevertheless, despite so many blows,

I’ll compete in your games, just watch. Your insults

cut to the quick—you rouse my fighting blood!”

Up he sprang, cloak and all, and seized a discus,

huge and heavy, more weighty by far than those

the Phaeacians used to hurl and test each other.

Wheeling round, he let loose with his great hand

220and the stone whirred on—and down to ground they went,

those lords of the long oars and master mariners cringing

under the rock’s onrush, soaring lightly out of his grip,

flying away past all the other marks, and Queen Athena,

built like a man, staked out the spot and cried

with a voice of triumph, “Even a blind man,

friend, could find your mark by groping round—

it’s not mixed up in the crowd, it’s far in front!

There’s nothing to fear in this event—

229no one can touch you, much less beat your distance!”

230At that the heart of the long-suffering hero laughed,

so glad to find a ready friend in the crowd that,

lighter in mood, he challenged all Phaeacia’s best:

“Now go match that, you young pups, and straightaway

I’ll hurl you another just as far, I swear, or even farther!

All the rest of you, anyone with the spine and spirit,

step right up and try me—you’ve incensed me so—

at boxing, wrestling, racing; nothing daunts me.

Any Phaeacian here except Laodamas himself.

The man’s my host. Who would fight his friend?

240He’d have to be good-for-nothing, senseless, yes,

to challenge his host and come to grips in games,

in a far-off land at that. He’d cut his own legs short.

But there are no others I’d deny or think beneath me—

I’ll take on all contenders, gladly, test them head-to-head!

I’m no disgrace in the world of games where men compete.

246Well I know how to handle a fine polished bow,

the first to hit my man in a mass of enemies,

even with rows of comrades pressing near me,

taking aim with our shafts to hit our targets.

250Philoctetes alone outshot me there at Troy

when ranks of Achaean archers bent their bows.

Of the rest I’d say that I outclass them all—

men still alive, who eat their bread on earth.

But I’d never vie with the men of days gone by,

255not Heracles, not Eurytus of Oechalia—archers

who rivaled immortal powers with their bows.

That’s why noble Eurytus died a sudden death:

no old age, creeping upon him in his halls…

Apollo shot him down, enraged that the man

had challenged him, the Archer God.

260As for spears,

I can fling a spear as far as the next man wings an arrow!

Only at sprinting I fear you’d leave me in the dust.

I’ve taken a shameful beating out on heavy seas,

no conditioning there on shipboard day by day.

My legs have lost their spring.”

He finished. All stood quiet, hushed.

Only Alcinous found a way to answer. “Stranger,

friend—nothing you say among us seems ungracious.

You simply want to display the gifts you’re born with,

270stung that a youngster marched up to you in the games,

mocking, ridiculing your prowess as no one would

who had some sense of fit and proper speech.

But come now, hear me out,

so you can tell our story to other lords

as you sit and feast in your own halls someday,

your own wife and your children by your side,

remembering there our island prowess here:

what skills great Zeus has given us as well,

down all the years from our fathers’ days till now.

280We’re hardly world-class boxers or wrestlers, I admit,

but we can race like the wind, we’re champion sailors too,

and always dear to our hearts, the feast, the lyre and dance

and changes of fresh clothes, our warm baths and beds.

So come—all you Phaeacian masters of the dance—

now dance away! So our guest can tell his friends,

when he reaches home, how far we excel the world

in sailing, nimble footwork, dance and song.

Go, someone,

quickly, fetch Demodocus now his ringing lyre.

It must be hanging somewhere in the palace.”

290At the king’s word the herald sprang to his feet

and ran to fetch the vibrant lyre from the house.

And stewards rose, nine in all, picked from the realm

to set the stage for contests: masters-at-arms who

leveled the dancing-floor to make a fine broad ring.

The herald returned and placed the ringing lyre now

in Demodocus’ hands, and the bard moved toward the center,

flanked by boys in the flush of youth, skilled dancers

who stamped the ground with marvelous pulsing steps

as Odysseus gazed at their flying, flashing feet,

his heart aglow with wonder.

300A rippling prelude—

now the bard struck up an irresistible song:

302The Love of Ares and Aphrodite Crowned with Flowers…

how the two had first made love in Hephaestus’ mansion,

all in secret. Ares had showered her with gifts

and showered Hephaestus’ marriage bed with shame

but a messenger ran to tell the god of fire—

307Helios, lord of the sun, who’d spied the couple

lost in each other’s arms and making love.

Hephaestus, hearing the heart-wounding story,

310bustled toward his forge, brooding on his revenge—

planted the huge anvil on its block and beat out chains,

not to be slipped or broken, all to pin the lovers on the spot.

This snare the Firegod forged, ablaze with his rage at War,

then limped to the room where the bed of love stood firm

and round the posts he poured the chains in a sweeping net

with streams of others flowing down from the roofbeam,

gossamer-fine as spider webs no man could see,

not even a blissful god—

the Smith had forged a masterwork of guile.

320Once he’d spun that cunning trap around his bed

321he feigned a trip to the well-built town of Lemnos,

dearest to him by far of all the towns on earth.

But the god of battle kept no blind man’s watch.

As soon as he saw the Master Craftsman leave

he plied his golden reins and arrived at once

and entered the famous god of fire’s mansion,

chafing with lust for Aphrodite crowned with flowers.

She’d just returned from her father’s palace, mighty Zeus,

and now she sat in her rooms as Ares strode right in

330and grasped her hand with a warm, seductive urging:

“Quick, my darling, come, let’s go to bed

and lose ourselves in love! Your husband’s away—

by now he must be off in the wilds of Lemnos,

334consorting with his raucous Sintian friends.”

So he pressed

and her heart raced with joy to sleep with War

and off they went to bed and down they lay—

and down around them came those cunning chains

of the crafty god of fire, showering down now

till the couple could not move a limb or lift a finger—

340then they knew at last: there was no way out, not now.

But now the glorious crippled Smith was drawing near…

he’d turned around, miles short of the Lemnos coast,

for the Sungod kept his watch and told Hephaestus all,

so back he rushed to his house, his heart consumed with anguish.

Halting there at the gates, seized with savage rage

he howled a terrible cry, imploring all the gods,

“Father Zeus, look here—

the rest of you happy gods who live forever—

349here is a sight to make you laugh, revolt you too!

350Just because I am crippled, Zeus’s daughter Aphrodite

will always spurn me and love that devastating Ares,

just because of his striking looks and racer’s legs

while I am a weakling, lame from birth, and who’s to blame?

Both my parents—who else? If only they’d never bred me!

Just look at the two lovers… crawled inside my bed,

locked in each other’s arms—the sight makes me burn!

But I doubt they’ll want to lie that way much longer,

not a moment more—mad as they are for each other.

No, they’ll soon tire of bedding down together,

360but then my cunning chains will bind them fast

361till our Father pays my bride-gifts back in full,

all I handed him for that shameless bitch his daughter,

irresistible beauty—all unbridled too!”

So Hephaestus wailed

as the gods came crowding up to his bronze-floored house.

Poseidon god of the earthquake came, and Hermes came,

the running god of luck, and the Archer, lord Apollo,

while modesty kept each goddess to her mansion.

The immortals, givers of all good things, stood at the gates,

369and uncontrollable laughter burst from the happy gods

370when they saw the god of fire’s subtle, cunning work.

One would glance at his neighbor, laughing out,

“A bad day for adultery! Slow outstrips the Swift.”

“Look how limping Hephaestus conquers War,

the quickest of all the gods who rule Olympus!”

“The cripple wins by craft.”

“The adulterer,

he will pay the price!”

So the gods would banter

among themselves but lord Apollo goaded Hermes on:

“Tell me, Quicksilver, giver of all good things—

even with those unwieldy shackles wrapped around you,

380how would you like to bed the golden Aphrodite?”

381“Oh Apollo, if only!” the giant-killer cried.

“Archer, bind me down with triple those endless chains!

Let all you gods look on, and all you goddesses too—

how I’d love to bed that golden Aphrodite!”

A peal of laughter broke from the deathless ones

but not Poseidon, not a smile from him; he kept on

begging the famous Smith to loose the god of war,

pleading, his words flying, “Let him go!

I guarantee you Ares will pay the price,

390whatever you ask, Hephaestus,

whatever’s right in the eyes of all the gods.”

But the famous crippled Smith appealed in turn,

“God of the earthquake, please don’t urge this on me.

A pledge for a worthless man is a worthless pledge indeed.

What if he slips out of his chains—his debts as well?

How could I shackle you while all the gods look on?”

But the god of earthquakes reassured the Smith,

“Look, Hephaestus, if Ares scuttles off and away,

squirming out of his debt, I’ll pay the fine myself.”

400And the famous crippled Smith complied at last:

“Now there’s an offer I really can’t refuse!”

With all his force the god of fire loosed the chains

and the two lovers, free of the bonds that overwhelmed them so,

404sprang up and away at once, and the Wargod sped to Thrace

405while Love with her telltale laughter sped to Paphos,

Cyprus Isle, where her grove and scented altar stand.

There the Graces bathed and anointed her with oil,

ambrosial oil, the bloom that clings to the gods

who never die, and swathed her round in gowns

410to stop the heart… an ecstasy—a vision.

That was the song the famous harper sang

and Odysseus relished every note as the islanders,

the lords of the long oars and master mariners rejoiced.

Next the king asked Halius and Laodamas to dance,

the two alone, since none could match that pair.

So taking in hand a gleaming sea-blue ball

417made by the craftsman Polybus—arching back,

one prince would hurl it toward the shadowy clouds

as the other leaping high into the air would catch it

420quickly, nimbly, before his feet hit ground again.

Once they’d vied at throwing the ball straight up,

they tossed it back and forth in a blur of hands

as they danced across the earth that feeds us all,

while boys around the ring stamped out the beat

and a splendid rhythmic drumming sound arose

and good Odysseus looked at his host, exclaiming,

“King Alcinous, shining among your island people,

you boasted Phaeacia’s dancers are the best—

they prove your point—I watch and I’m amazed!”

430His praises cheered the hallowed island king

who spoke at once to the master mariners around him:

“Hear me, my lords and captains of Phaeacia,

our guest is a man of real taste, I’d say. Come,

let’s give him the parting gifts a guest deserves.

435There are twelve peers of the realm who rule our land,

thirteen, counting myself. Let each of us contribute

a fresh cloak and shirt and a bar of precious gold.

Gather the gifts together, hurry, so our guest

can have them all in hand when he goes to dine,

440his spirit filled with joy.

As for Broadsea, let him make amends,

man-to-man, with his words as well as gifts.

His first remarks were hardly fit to hear.”

All assented and gave their own commands,

each noble sent a page to fetch his gifts.

And Broadsea volunteered in turn, obliging:

“Great Alcinous, shining among our island people,

of course I’ll make amends to our newfound friend

as you request. I’ll give the man this sword.

450It’s solid bronze and the hilt has silver studs,

the sheath around it ivory freshly carved.

Here’s a gift our guest will value highly.”

He placed the silver-studded sword in Odysseus’ hands

with a burst of warm words: “Farewell, stranger, sir—

if any remark of mine gave you offense,

may stormwinds snatch it up and sweep it off!

May the gods grant you safe passage home to see your wife—

you’ve been so far from loved ones, suffered so!”

Tactful Odysseus answered him in kind:

460“And a warm farewell to you, too, my friend.

May the gods grant you good fortune—

may you never miss this sword, this gift you give

with such salutes. You’ve made amends in full.”

With that

he slung the silver-studded sword across his shoulder.

As the sun sank, his glittering gifts arrived

and proud heralds bore them into the hall

where sons of King Alcinous took them over,

spread them out before their noble mother’s feet—

a grand array of gifts. The king in all his majesty

470led the rest of his peers inside, following in a file

and down they sat on rows of high-backed chairs.

The king turned to the queen and urged her, “Come,

my dear, bring in an elegant chest, the best you have,

and lay inside it a fresh cloak and shirt, your own gifts.

Then heat a bronze cauldron over the fire, boil water,

so once our guest has bathed and reviewed his gifts—

all neatly stacked for sailing,

gifts our Phaeacian lords have brought him now—

he’ll feast in peace and hear the harper’s songs.

480And I will give him this gorgeous golden cup of mine,

so he’ll remember Alcinous all his days to come

when he pours libations out in his own house

to Father Zeus and the other gods on high.”

And at that Arete told her serving-women,

“Set a great three-legged cauldron over the fire—

do it right away!”

And hoisting over the blaze

a cauldron, filling it brimful with bathing water,

they piled fresh logs beneath and lit them quickly.

The fire lapped at the vessel’s belly, the water warmed.

490Meanwhile the queen had a polished chest brought forth

from an inner room and laid the priceless gifts inside,

the clothes and gold the Phaeacian lords had brought,

and added her own gifts, a cloak and a fine shirt,

and gave her guest instructions quick and clear:

“Now look to the lid yourself and bind it fast

with a good tight knot, so no one can rob you

on your voyage—drifting into a sweet sleep

as the black ship sails you home.”

Hearing that,

the storm-tossed man secured the lid straightway,

500he battened it fast with a swift, intricate knot

501the lady Circe had taught him long ago.

And the housekeeper invited him at once

to climb into a waiting tub and bathe—

a hot, steaming bath…

what a welcome sight to Odysseus’ eyes!

He’d been a stranger to comforts such as these

since he left the lovely-haired Calypso’s house,

yet all those years he enjoyed such comforts there,

never-ending, as if he were a god… And now,

510when maids had washed him, rubbed him down with oil

and drawn warm fleece and a shirt around his shoulders,

he stepped from the bath to join the nobles at their wine.

And there stood Nausicaa as he passed. Beside a column

that propped the sturdy roof she paused, endowed

by the gods with all her beauty, gazing at

Odysseus right before her eyes. Wonderstruck,

she hailed her guest with a winning flight of words:

518“Farewell, my friend! And when you are at home,

home in your own land, remember me at times.

520Mainly to me you owe the gift of life.”

Odysseus rose to the moment deftly, gently:

“Nausicaa, daughter of generous King Alcinous,

may Zeus the Thunderer, Hera’s husband, grant it so—

that I travel home and see the dawn of my return.

Even at home I’ll pray to you as a deathless goddess

all my days to come. You saved my life, dear girl.”

And he went and took his seat beside the king.

By now they were serving out the portions, mixing wine,

and the herald soon approached, leading the faithful bard

530Demodocus, prized by all the people—seated him in a chair

amid the feasters, leaning it against a central column.

At once alert Odysseus carved a strip of loin,

rich and crisp with fat, from the white-tusked boar

that still had much meat left, and called the herald over:

“Here, herald, take this choice cut to Demodocus

so he can eat his fill—with warm regards

from a man who knows what suffering is…

From all who walk the earth our bards deserve

esteem and awe, for the Muse herself has taught them

540paths of song. She loves the breed of harpers.”

The herald placed the gift in Demodocus’ hands

and the famous blind bard received it, overjoyed.

They reached for the good things that lay outspread

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Odysseus, master of many exploits, praised the singer:

“I respect you, Demodocus, more than any man alive—

surely the Muse has taught you, Zeus’s daughter,

or god Apollo himself. How true to life,

all too true… you sing the Achaeans’ fate,

550all they did and suffered, all they soldiered through,

as if you were there yourself or heard from one who was.

552But come now, shift your ground. Sing of the wooden horse

553Epeus built with Athena’s help, the cunning trap that

good Odysseus brought one day to the heights of Troy,

filled with fighting men who laid the city waste.

Sing that for me—true to life as it deserves—

and I will tell the world at once how freely

the Muse gave you the gods’ own gift of song.”

559Stirred now by the Muse, the bard launched out

560in a fine blaze of song, starting at just the point

where the main Achaean force, setting their camps afire,

had boarded the oarswept ships and sailed for home

but famed Odysseus’ men already crouched in hiding—

in the heart of Troy’s assembly—dark in that horse

the Trojans dragged themselves to the city heights.

Now it stood there, looming…

and round its bulk the Trojans sat debating,

clashing, days on end. Three plans split their ranks:

either to hack open the hollow vault with ruthless bronze

570or haul it up to the highest ridge and pitch it down the cliffs

or let it stand—a glorious offering made to pacify the gods—

and that, that final plan, was bound to win the day.

For Troy was fated to perish once the city lodged

inside her walls the monstrous wooden horse

where the prime of Argive power lay in wait

with death and slaughter bearing down on Troy.

And he sang how troops of Achaeans broke from cover,

streaming out of the horse’s hollow flanks to plunder Troy—

he sang how left and right they ravaged the steep city,

580sang how Odysseus marched right up to Deiphobus’ house

like the god of war on attack with diehard Menelaus.

There, he sang, Odysseus fought the grimmest fight

he had ever braved but he won through at last,

thanks to Athena’s superhuman power.

That was the song the famous harper sang

but great Odysseus melted into tears,

running down from his eyes to wet his cheeks…

as a woman weeps, her arms flung round her darling husband,

a man who fell in battle, fighting for town and townsmen,

590trying to beat the day of doom from home and children.

Seeing the man go down, dying, gasping for breath,

she clings for dear life, screams and shrills—

but the victors, just behind her,

digging spear-butts into her back and shoulders,

drag her off in bondage, yoked to hard labor, pain,

and the most heartbreaking torment wastes her cheeks.

So from Odysseus’ eyes ran tears of heartbreak now.

But his weeping went unmarked by all the others;

only Alcinous, sitting close beside him,

600noticed his guest’s tears,

heard the groan in the man’s labored breathing

and said at once to the master mariners around him,

“Hear me, my lords and captains of Phaeacia!

Let Demodocus rest his ringing lyre now—

this song he sings can hardly please us all.

Ever since our meal began and the stirring bard

launched his song, our guest has never paused

in his tears and throbbing sorrow.

Clearly grief has overpowered his heart.

Break off this song! Let us all enjoy ourselves,

the hosts and guest together. Much the warmer way.

All these things are performed for him, our honored guest,

the royal send-off here and gifts we give in love.

Treat your guest and suppliant like a brother:

anyone with a touch of sense knows that.

So don’t be crafty now, my friend, don’t hide

the truth I’m after. Fair is fair, speak out!

Come, tell us the name they call you there at home—

your mother, father, townsmen, neighbors round about.

620Surely no man in the world is nameless, all told.

Born high, born low, as soon as he sees the light

his parents always name him, once he’s born.

And tell me your land, your people, your city too,

so our ships can sail you home—their wits will speed them there.

For we have no steersmen here among Phaeacia’s crews

or steering-oars that guide your common craft.

Our ships know in a flash their mates’ intentions,

know all ports of call and all the rich green fields.

With wings of the wind they cross the sea’s huge gulfs,

630shrouded in mist and cloud—no fear in the world of foundering,

fatal shipwreck.

True, there’s an old tale I heard

my father telling once. Nausithous used to say

that lord Poseidon was vexed with us because

we escorted all mankind and never came to grief.

He said that one day, as a well-built ship of ours

sailed home on the misty sea from such a convoy,

the god would crush it, yes,

and pile a huge mountain round about our port.

So the old king foretold… And as for the god, well,

640he can do his worst or leave it quite undone,

whatever warms his heart.

But come, my friend,

tell us your own story now, and tell it truly.

Where have your rovings forced you?

What lands of men have you seen, what sturdy towns,

what men themselves? Who were wild, savage, lawless?

Who were friendly to strangers, god-fearing men? Tell me,

why do you weep and grieve so sorely when you hear

the fate of the Argives, hear the fall of Troy?

That is the gods’ work, spinning threads of death

650through the lives of mortal men,

and all to make a song for those to come…

Did one of your kinsmen die before the walls of Troy,

some brave man—a son by marriage? father by marriage?

Next to our own blood kin, our nearest, dearest ties.

Or a friend perhaps, someone close to your heart,

staunch and loyal? No less dear than a brother,

the brother-in-arms who shares our inmost thoughts.”

BOOK NINE

In the One-Eyed Giant’s Cave

O
dysseus, the great teller of tales, launched out on his story:

“Alcinous, majesty, shining among your island people,

what a fine thing it is to listen to such a bard

as we have here—the man sings like a god.

The crown of life, I’d say. There’s nothing better

than when deep joy holds sway throughout the realm

and banqueters up and down the palace sit in ranks,

enthralled to hear the bard, and before them all, the tables

heaped with bread and meats, and drawing wine from a mixing-bowl

10the steward makes his rounds and keeps the winecups flowing.

This, to my mind, is the best that life can offer.

But now

you’re set on probing the bitter pains I’ve borne,

so I’m to weep and grieve, it seems, still more.

Well then, what shall I go through first,

what shall I save for last?

What pains—the gods have given me my share.

Now let me begin by telling you my name…

so you may know it well and I in times to come,

if I can escape the fatal day, will be your host,

20your sworn friend, though my home is far from here.

21I am Odysseus, son of Laertes, known to the world

for every kind of craft—my fame has reached the skies.

Sunny Ithaca is my home. Atop her stands our seamark,

24Mount Neriton’s leafy ridges shimmering in the wind.

Around her a ring of islands circle side-by-side,

Dulichion, Same, wooded Zacynthus too, but mine

27lies low and away, the farthest out to sea,

rearing into the western dusk

while the others face the east and breaking day.

30Mine is a rugged land but good for raising sons—

and I myself, I know no sweeter sight on earth

than a man’s own native country.

True enough,

Calypso the lustrous goddess tried to hold me back,

deep in her arching caverns, craving me for a husband.

So did Circe, holding me just as warmly in her halls,

36the bewitching queen of Aeaea keen to have me too.

But they never won the heart inside me, never.

So nothing is as sweet as a man’s own country,

his own parents, even though he’s settled down

40in some luxurious house, off in a foreign land

and far from those who bore him.

No more. Come,

let me tell you about the voyage fraught with hardship

Zeus inflicted on me, homeward bound from Troy…

44The wind drove me out of Ilium on to Ismarus,

45the Cicones’ stronghold. There I sacked the city,

killed the men, but as for the wives and plunder,

that rich haul we dragged away from the place—

we shared it round so no one, not on my account,

would go deprived of his fair share of spoils.

50Then I urged them to cut and run, set sail,

but would they listen? Not those mutinous fools;

there was too much wine to swill, too many sheep to slaughter

down along the beach, and shambling longhorn cattle.

And all the while the Cicones sought out other Cicones,

called for help from their neighbors living inland:

a larger force, and stronger soldiers too,

skilled hands at fighting men from chariots,

skilled, when a crisis broke, to fight on foot.

Out of the morning mist they came against us—

60packed as the leaves and spears that flower forth in spring—

and Zeus presented us with disaster, me and my comrades

doomed to suffer blow on mortal blow. Lining up,

both armies battled it out against our swift ships,

both raked each other with hurtling bronze lances.

Long as morning rose and the blessed day grew stronger

we stood and fought them off, massed as they were, but then,

when the sun wheeled past the hour for unyoking oxen,

the Cicones broke our lines and beat us down at last.

Out of each ship, six men-at-arms were killed;

70the rest of us rowed away from certain doom.

From there we sailed on, glad to escape our death

yet sick at heart for the dear companions we had lost.

But I would not let our rolling ships set sail until the crews

74had raised the triple cry, saluting each poor comrade

cut down by the fierce Cicones on that plain.

Now Zeus who masses the stormclouds hit the fleet

with the North Wind—

a howling, demonic gale, shrouding over

in thunderheads the earth and sea at once—

and night swept down

from the sky and the ships went plunging headlong on,

80our sails slashed to rags by the hurricane’s blast!

We struck them—cringing at death we rowed our ships

to the nearest shoreline, pulled with all our power.

There, for two nights, two days, we lay by, no letup,

eating our hearts out, bent with pain and bone-tired.

When Dawn with her lovely locks brought on the third day,

then stepping the masts and hoisting white sails high,

we lounged at the oarlocks, letting wind and helmsmen

keep us true on course…

And now, at long last,

I might have reached my native land unscathed,

but just as I doubled Malea’s cape, a tide-rip

90and the North Wind drove me way off course

92careering past Cythera.

Nine whole days

I was borne along by rough, deadly winds

on the fish-infested sea. Then on the tenth

our squadron reached the land of the Lotus-eaters,

95people who eat the lotus, mellow fruit and flower.

We disembarked on the coast, drew water there

and crewmen snatched a meal by the swift ships.

Once we’d had our fill of food and drink I sent

100a detail ahead, two picked men and a third, a runner,

to scout out who might live there—men like us perhaps,

who live on bread? So off they went and soon enough

they mingled among the natives, Lotus-eaters, Lotus-eaters

104who had no notion of killing my companions, not at all,

they simply gave them the lotus to taste instead…

Any crewmen who ate the lotus, the honey-sweet fruit,

107lost all desire to send a message back, much less return,

their only wish to linger there with the Lotus-eaters,

grazing on lotus, all memory of the journey home

110dissolved forever. But I brought them back, back

to the hollow ships, and streaming tears—I forced them,

hauled them under the rowing benches, lashed them fast

and shouted out commands to my other, steady comrades:

‘Quick, no time to lose, embark in the racing ships!’—

so none could eat the lotus, forget the voyage home.

They swung aboard at once, they sat to the oars in ranks

and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

From there we sailed on, our spirits now at a low ebb,

and reached the land of the high and mighty Cyclops,

120lawless brutes, who trust so to the everlasting gods

they never plant with their own hands or plow the soil.

Unsown, unplowed, the earth teems with all they need,

wheat, barley and vines, swelled by the rains of Zeus

to yield a big full-bodied wine from clustered grapes.

They have no meeting place for council, no laws either,

no, up on the mountain peaks they live in arching caverns—

each a law to himself, ruling his wives and children,

not a care in the world for any neighbor.

Now,

a level island stretches flat across the harbor,

130not close inshore to the Cyclops’ coast, not too far out,

thick with woods where the wild goats breed by hundreds.

No trampling of men to start them from their lairs,

no hunters roughing it out on the woody ridges,

stalking quarry, ever raid their haven.

No flocks browse, no plowlands roll with wheat;

unplowed, unsown forever—empty of humankind—

the island just feeds droves of bleating goats.

138For the Cyclops have no ships with crimson prows,

no shipwrights there to build them good trim craft

140that could sail them out to foreign ports of call

as most men risk the seas to trade with other men.

Such artisans would have made this island too

a decent place to live in… No mean spot,

it could bear you any crop you like in season.

The water-meadows along the low foaming shore

run soft and moist, and your vines would never flag.

The land’s clear for plowing. Harvest on harvest,

a man could reap a healthy stand of grain—

the subsoil’s dark and rich.

150There’s a snug deep-water harbor there, what’s more,

no need for mooring-gear, no anchor-stones to heave,

no cables to make fast. Just beach your keels, ride out

the days till your shipmates’ spirit stirs for open sea

and a fair wind blows. And last, at the harbor’s head

there’s a spring that rushes fresh from beneath a cave

and black poplars flourish round its mouth.

Well,

here we landed, and surely a god steered us in

through the pitch-black night.

Not that he ever showed himself, with thick fog

160swirling around the ships, the moon wrapped in clouds

and not a glimmer stealing through that gloom.

Not one of us glimpsed the island—scanning hard—

or the long combers rolling us slowly toward the coast,

not till our ships had run their keels ashore.

Beaching our vessels smoothly, striking sail,

the crews swung out on the low shelving sand

and there we fell asleep, awaiting Dawn’s first light.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

we all turned out, intrigued to tour the island.

170The local nymphs, the daughters of Zeus himself,

flushed mountain-goats so the crews could make their meal.

Quickly we fetched our curved bows and hunting spears

from the ships and, splitting up into three bands,

we started shooting, and soon enough some god

had sent us bags of game to warm our hearts.

A dozen vessels sailed in my command

and to each crew nine goats were shared out

and mine alone took ten. Then all day long

till the sun went down we sat and feasted well

180on sides of meat and rounds of heady wine.

The good red stock in our vessels’ holds

had not run out, there was still plenty left;

the men had carried off a generous store in jars

when we stormed and sacked the Cicones’ holy city.

Now we stared across at the Cyclops’ shore, so near

we could even see their smoke, hear their voices,

their bleating sheep and goats…

And then when the sun had set and night came on

we lay down and slept at the water’s shelving edge.

190When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

I called a muster briskly, commanding all the hands,

‘The rest of you stay here, my friends-in-arms.

I’ll go across with my own ship and crew

and probe the natives living over there.

What are they—violent, savage, lawless?

or friendly to strangers, god-fearing men?’

With that I boarded ship and told the crew

to embark at once and cast off cables quickly.

They swung aboard, they sat to the oars in ranks

200and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

But as soon as we reached the coast I mentioned—no long trip—

we spied a cavern just at the shore, gaping above the surf,

towering, overgrown with laurel. And here big flocks,

sheep and goats, were stalled to spend the nights,

and around its mouth a yard was walled up

with quarried boulders sunk deep in the earth

and enormous pines and oak-trees looming darkly…

Here was a giant’s lair, in fact, who always pastured

his sheepflocks far afield and never mixed with others.

210A grim loner, dead set in his own lawless ways.

Here was a piece of work, by god, a monster

built like no mortal who ever supped on bread,

no, like a shaggy peak, I’d say—a man-mountain

rearing head and shoulders over the world.

Now then,

I told most of my good trusty crew to wait,

to sit tight by the ship and guard her well

while I picked out my dozen finest fighters

and off I went. But I took a skin of wine along,

219the ruddy, irresistible wine that Maron gave me once,

220Euanthes’ son, a priest of Apollo, lord of Ismarus,

because we’d rescued him, his wife and children,

reverent as we were;

he lived, you see, in Apollo’s holy grove.

And so in return he gave me splendid gifts,

he handed me seven bars of well-wrought gold,

a mixing-bowl of solid silver, then this wine…

He drew it off in generous wine-jars, twelve in all,

all unmixed—and such a bouquet, a drink fit for the gods!

No maid or man of his household knew that secret store,

230only himself, his loving wife and a single servant.

Whenever they’d drink the deep-red mellow vintage,

232twenty cups of water he’d stir in one of wine

and what an aroma wafted from the bowl—

what magic, what a godsend—

no joy in holding back when that was poured!

Filling a great goatskin now, I took this wine,

provisions too in a leather sack. A sudden foreboding

told my fighting spirit I’d soon come up against

some giant clad in power like armor-plate—

240a savage deaf to justice, blind to law.

Our party quickly made its way to his cave

but we failed to find our host himself inside;

he was off in his pasture, ranging his sleek flocks.

So we explored his den, gazing wide-eyed at it all,

the large flat racks loaded with drying cheeses,

the folds crowded with young lambs and kids,

split into three groups—here the spring-born,

here mid-yearlings, here the fresh sucklings

off to the side—each sort was penned apart.

250And all his vessels, pails and hammered buckets

he used for milking, were brimming full with whey.

From the start my comrades pressed me, pleading hard,

‘Let’s make away with the cheeses, then come back—

hurry, drive the lambs and kids from the pens

to our swift ship, put out to sea at once!’

But I would not give way—

and how much better it would have been—

not till I saw him, saw what gifts he’d give.

But he proved no lovely sight to my companions.

260There we built a fire, set our hands on the cheeses,

offered some to the gods and ate the bulk ourselves

and settled down inside, awaiting his return…

And back he came from pasture, late in the day,

herding his flocks home, and lugging a huge load

of good dry logs to fuel his fire at supper.

He flung them down in the cave—a jolting crash—

we scuttled in panic into the deepest dark recess.

And next he drove his sleek flocks into the open vault,

all he’d milk at least, but he left the males outside,

270rams and billy goats out in the high-walled yard.

Then to close his door he hoisted overhead

a tremendous, massive slab—

no twenty-two wagons, rugged and four-wheeled,

could budge that boulder off the ground, I tell you,

such an immense stone the monster wedged to block his cave!

Then down he squatted to milk his sheep and bleating goats,

each in order, and put a suckling underneath each dam.

And half of the fresh white milk he curdled quickly,

set it aside in wicker racks to press for cheese,

280the other half let stand in pails and buckets,

ready at hand to wash his supper down.

As soon as he’d briskly finished all his chores

he lit his fire and spied us in the blaze and

‘Strangers!’ he thundered out, ‘now who are you?

Where did you sail from, over the running sea-lanes?

286Out on a trading spree or roving the waves like pirates,

sea-wolves raiding at will, who risk their lives

to plunder other men?’

The hearts inside us shook,

terrified by his rumbling voice and monstrous hulk.

290Nevertheless I found the nerve to answer, firmly,

‘Men of Achaea we are and bound now from Troy!

Driven far off course by the warring winds,

over the vast gulf of the sea—battling home

on a strange tack, a route that’s off the map,

and so we’ve come to you…

so it must please King Zeus’s plotting heart.

We’re glad to say we’re men of Atrides Agamemnon,

whose fame is the proudest thing on earth these days,

so great a city he sacked, such multitudes he killed!

300But since we’ve chanced on you, we’re at your knees

in hopes of a warm welcome, even a guest-gift,

the sort that hosts give strangers. That’s the custom.

Respect the gods, my friend. We’re suppliants—at your mercy!

304Zeus of the Strangers guards all guests and suppliants:

strangers are sacred—Zeus will avenge their rights!’

‘Stranger,’ he grumbled back from his brutal heart,

‘you must be a fool, stranger, or come from nowhere,

telling me to fear the gods or avoid their wrath!

309We Cyclops never blink at Zeus and Zeus’s shield

310of storm and thunder, or any other blessed god—

we’ve got more force by far.

I’d never spare you in fear of Zeus’s hatred,

you or your comrades here, unless I had the urge.

But tell me, where did you moor your sturdy ship

when you arrived? Up the coast or close in?

I’d just like to know.’

So he laid his trap

but he never caught me, no, wise to the world

I shot back in my crafty way, ‘My ship?

Poseidon god of the earthquake smashed my ship,

320he drove it against the rocks at your island’s far cape,

he dashed it against a cliff as the winds rode us in.

I and the men you see escaped a sudden death.’

Not a word in reply to that, the ruthless brute.

Lurching up, he lunged out with his hands toward my men

and snatching two at once, rapping them on the ground

he knocked them dead like pups—

their brains gushed out all over, soaked the floor—

and ripping them limb from limb to fix his meal

he bolted them down like a mountain-lion, left no scrap,

330devoured entrails, flesh and bones, marrow and all!

We flung our arms to Zeus, we wept and cried aloud,

looking on at his grisly work—paralyzed, appalled.

But once the Cyclops had stuffed his enormous gut

with human flesh, washing it down with raw milk,

he slept in his cave, stretched out along his flocks.

And I with my fighting heart, I thought at first

to steal up to him, draw the sharp sword at my hip

and stab his chest where the midriff packs the liver—

I groped for the fatal spot but a fresh thought held me back.

340There at a stroke we’d finish off ourselves as well—

how could we with our bare hands heave back

that slab he set to block his cavern’s gaping maw?

So we lay there groaning, waiting Dawn’s first light.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

the monster relit his fire and milked his handsome ewes,

each in order, putting a suckling underneath each dam,

and as soon as he’d briskly finished all his chores

he snatched up two more men and fixed his meal.

Well-fed, he drove his fat sheep from the cave,

350lightly lifting the huge doorslab up and away,

then slipped it back in place

as a hunter flips the lid of his quiver shut.

Piercing whistles—turning his flocks to the hills

he left me there, the heart inside me brooding on revenge:

how could I pay him back? would Athena give me glory?

Here was the plan that struck my mind as best…

the Cyclops’ great club: there it lay by the pens,

olivewood, full of sap. He’d lopped it off to brandish

once it dried. Looking it over, we judged it big enough

360to be the mast of a pitch-black ship with her twenty oars,

a freighter broad in the beam that plows through miles of sea—

so long, so thick it bulked before our eyes. Well,

flanking it now, I chopped off a fathom’s length,

rolled it to comrades, told them to plane it down,

and they made the club smooth as I bent and shaved

the tip to a stabbing point. I turned it over

the blazing fire to char it good and hard,

then hid it well, buried deep under the dung

that littered the cavern’s floor in thick wet clumps.

370And now I ordered my shipmates all to cast lots—

who’d brave it out with me

to hoist our stake and grind it into his eye

when sleep had overcome him? Luck of the draw:

I got the very ones I would have picked myself,

four good men, and I in the lead made five…

Nightfall brought him back, herding his woolly sheep

and he quickly drove the sleek flock into the vaulted cavern,

rams and all—none left outside in the walled yard—

his own idea, perhaps, or a god led him on.

380Then he hoisted the huge slab to block the door

and squatted to milk his sheep and bleating goats,

each in order, putting a suckling underneath each dam,

and as soon as he’d briskly finished all his chores

he snatched up two more men and fixed his meal.

But this time I lifted a carved wooden bowl,

brimful of my ruddy wine,

and went right up to the Cyclops, enticing,

‘Here, Cyclops, try this wine—to top off

the banquet of human flesh you’ve bolted down!

390Judge for yourself what stock our ship had stored.

I brought it here to make you a fine libation,

hoping you would pity me, Cyclops, send me home,

but your rages are insufferable. You barbarian—

how can any man on earth come visit you after this?

What you’ve done outrages all that’s right!’

At that he seized the bowl and tossed it off

and the heady wine pleased him immensely—‘More’—

he demanded a second bowl—‘a hearty helping!

And tell me your name now, quickly,

400so I can hand my guest a gift to warm his heart.

Our soil yields the Cyclops powerful, full-bodied wine

and the rains from Zeus build its strength. But this,

this is nectar, ambrosia—this flows from heaven!’

So he declared. I poured him another fiery bowl—

three bowls I brimmed and three he drank to the last drop,

the fool, and then, when the wine was swirling round his brain,

I approached my host with a cordial, winning word:

‘So, you ask me the name I’m known by, Cyclops?

I will tell you. But you must give me a guest-gift

410as you’ve promised. Nobody—that’s my name. Nobody—

so my mother and father call me, all my friends.’

But he boomed back at me from his ruthless heart,

‘Nobody? I’ll eat Nobody last of all his friends—

I’ll eat the others first! That’s my gift to you!’

With that

he toppled over, sprawled full-length, flat on his back

and lay there, his massive neck slumping to one side,

and sleep that conquers all overwhelmed him now

as wine came spurting, flooding up from his gullet

with chunks of human flesh—he vomited, blind drunk.

420Now, at last, I thrust our stake in a bed of embers

to get it red-hot and rallied all my comrades:

‘Courage—no panic, no one hang back now!’

And green as it was, just as the olive stake

was about to catch fire—the glow terrific, yes—

I dragged it from the flames, my men clustering round

as some god breathed enormous courage through us all.

Hoisting high that olive stake with its stabbing point,

straight into the monster’s eye they rammed it hard—

I drove my weight on it from above and bored it home

430as a shipwright bores his beam with a shipwright’s drill

that men below, whipping the strap back and forth, whirl

and the drill keeps twisting faster, never stopping—

So we seized our stake with its fiery tip

and bored it round and round in the giant’s eye

till blood came boiling up around that smoking shaft

and the hot blast singed his brow and eyelids round the core

and the broiling eyeball burst—

its crackling roots blazed

and hissed—

as a blacksmith plunges a glowing ax or adze

in an ice-cold bath and the metal screeches steam

440and its temper hardens—that’s the iron’s strength—

so the eye of the Cyclops sizzled round that stake!

He loosed a hideous roar, the rock walls echoed round

and we scuttled back in terror. The monster wrenched the spike

from his eye and out it came with a red geyser of blood—

he flung it aside with frantic hands, and mad with pain

he bellowed out for help from his neighbor Cyclops

living round about in caves on windswept crags.

Hearing his cries, they lumbered up from every side

and hulking round his cavern, asked what ailed him:

450‘What, Polyphemus, what in the world’s the trouble?

Roaring out in the godsent night to rob us of our sleep.

452Surely no one’s rustling your flocks against your will—

surely no one’s trying to kill you now by fraud or force!’

‘Nobody, friends’—Polyphemus bellowed back from his cave—

‘Nobody’s killing me now by fraud and not by force!’

‘If you’re alone,’ his friends boomed back at once,

‘and nobody’s trying to overpower you now—look,

it must be a plague sent here by mighty Zeus

and there’s no escape from that.

460You’d better pray to your father, Lord Poseidon.’

They lumbered off, but laughter filled my heart

to think how nobody’s name—my great cunning stroke—

had duped them one and all. But the Cyclops there,

still groaning, racked with agony, groped around

for the huge slab, and heaving it from the doorway,

down he sat in the cave’s mouth, his arms spread wide,

hoping to catch a comrade stealing out with sheep—

such a blithering fool he took me for!

But I was already plotting…

470what was the best way out? how could I find

escape from death for my crew, myself as well?

My wits kept weaving, weaving cunning schemes—

life at stake, monstrous death staring us in the face—

till this plan struck my mind as best. That flock,

those well-fed rams with their splendid thick fleece,

sturdy, handsome beasts sporting their dark weight of wool:

I lashed them abreast, quietly, twisting the willow-twigs

the Cyclops slept on—giant, lawless brute—I took them

three by three; each ram in the middle bore a man

480while the two rams either side would shield him well.

So three beasts to bear each man, but as for myself?

There was one bellwether ram, the prize of all the flock,

and clutching him by his back, tucked up under

his shaggy belly, there I hung, face upward,

both hands locked in his marvelous deep fleece,

clinging for dear life, my spirit steeled, enduring…

So we held on, desperate, waiting Dawn’s first light.

As soon

as young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

the rams went rumbling out of the cave toward pasture,

490the ewes kept bleating round the pens, unmilked,

their udders about to burst. Their master now,

heaving in torment, felt the back of each animal

halting before him here, but the idiot never sensed

my men were trussed up under their thick fleecy ribs.

And last of them all came my great ram now, striding out,

weighed down with his dense wool and my deep plots.

Stroking him gently, powerful Polyphemus murmured,

‘Dear old ram, why last of the flock to quit the cave?

In the good old days you’d never lag behind the rest—

500you with your long marching strides, first by far

of the flock to graze the fresh young grasses,

first by far to reach the rippling streams,

first to turn back home, keen for your fold

when night comes on—but now you’re last of all.

And why? Sick at heart for your master’s eye

that coward gouged out with his wicked crew?—

only after he’d stunned my wits with wine—

508that, that Nobody…

who’s not escaped his death, I swear, not yet.

510Oh if only you thought like me, had words like me

to tell me where that scoundrel is cringing from my rage!

I’d smash him against the ground, I’d spill his brains—

flooding across my cave—and that would ease my heart

of the pains that good-for-nothing Nobody made me suffer!’

And with that threat he let my ram go free outside.

But soon as we’d got one foot past cave and courtyard,

first I loosed myself from the ram, then loosed my men,

then quickly, glancing back again and again we drove

our flock, good plump beasts with their long shanks,

520straight to the ship, and a welcome sight we were

to loyal comrades—we who’d escaped our deaths—

but for all the rest they broke down and wailed.

I cut it short, I stopped each shipmate’s cries,

my head tossing, brows frowning, silent signals

to hurry, tumble our fleecy herd on board,

launch out on the open sea!

They swung aboard, they sat to the oars in ranks

and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

But once offshore as far as a man’s shout can carry,

530I called back to the Cyclops, stinging taunts:

‘So, Cyclops, no weak coward it was whose crew

you bent to devour there in your vaulted cave—

you with your brute force! Your filthy crimes

came down on your own head, you shameless cannibal,

daring to eat your guests in your own house—

so Zeus and the other gods have paid you back!’

That made the rage of the monster boil over.

Ripping off the peak of a towering crag, he heaved it

so hard the boulder landed just in front of our dark prow

540and a huge swell reared up as the rock went plunging under—

a tidal wave from the open sea. The sudden backwash

drove us landward again, forcing us close inshore

but grabbing a long pole, I thrust us off and away,

tossing my head for dear life, signaling crews

to put their backs in the oars, escape grim death.

They threw themselves in the labor, rowed on fast

but once we’d plowed the breakers twice as far,

again I began to taunt the Cyclops—men around me

trying to check me, calm me, left and right:

550‘So headstrong—why? Why rile the beast again?’

‘That rock he flung in the sea just now, hurling our ship

to shore once more—we thought we’d die on the spot!’

‘If he’d caught a sound from one of us, just a moan,

he would have crushed our heads and ship timbers

with one heave of another flashing, jagged rock!’

‘Good god, the brute can throw!’

So they begged

but they could not bring my fighting spirit round.

I called back with another burst of anger, ‘Cyclops—

if any man on the face of the earth should ask you

560who blinded you, shamed you so—say Odysseus,

raider of cities, he gouged out your eye,

Laertes’ son who makes his home in Ithaca!’

So I vaunted and he groaned back in answer,

‘Oh no, no—that prophecy years ago…

it all comes home to me with a vengeance now!

We once had a prophet here, a great tall man,

567Telemus, Eurymus’ son, a master at reading signs,

who grew old in his trade among his fellow-Cyclops.

All this, he warned me, would come to pass someday—

570that I’d be blinded here at the hands of one Odysseus.

But I always looked for a handsome giant man to cross my path,

some fighter clad in power like armor-plate, but now,

573look what a dwarf, a spineless good-for-nothing,

stuns me with wine, then gouges out my eye!

Come here, Odysseus, let me give you a guest-gift

and urge Poseidon the earthquake god to speed you home.

I am his son and he claims to be my father, true,

and he himself will heal me if he pleases—

no other blessed god, no man can do the work!’

‘Heal you!’—

580here was my parting shot—‘Would to god I could strip you

of life and breath and ship you down to the House of Death

as surely as no one will ever heal your eye,

not even your earthquake god himself!’

But at that he bellowed out to lord Poseidon,

thrusting his arms to the starry skies, and prayed, ‘Hear me—

Poseidon, god of the sea-blue mane who rocks the earth!

If I really am your son and you claim to be my father—

come, grant that Odysseus, raider of cities,

Laertes’ son who makes his home in Ithaca,

590never reaches home. Or if he’s fated to see

his people once again and reach his well-built house

592and his own native country, let him come home late

and come a broken man—all shipmates lost,

alone in a stranger’s ship—

and let him find a world of pain at home!’

So he prayed

and the god of the sea-blue mane, Poseidon, heard his prayer.

The monster suddenly hoisted a boulder—far larger—

wheeled and heaved it, putting his weight behind it,

massive strength, and the boulder crashed close,

600landing just in the wake of our dark stern,

just failing to graze the rudder’s bladed edge.

A huge swell reared up as the rock went plunging under,

yes, and the tidal breaker drove us out to our island’s

far shore where all my well-decked ships lay moored,

clustered, waiting, and huddled round them, crewmen

sat in anguish, waiting, chafing for our return.

We beached our vessel hard ashore on the sand,

we swung out in the frothing surf ourselves,

and herding Cyclops’ sheep from our deep holds

610we shared them round so no one, not on my account,

would go deprived of his fair share of spoils.

But the splendid ram—as we meted out the flocks

my friends-in-arms made him my prize of honor,

mine alone, and I slaughtered him on the beach

and burnt his thighs to Cronus’ mighty son,

Zeus of the thundercloud who rules the world.

But my sacrifices failed to move the god:

Zeus was still obsessed with plans to destroy

my entire oarswept fleet and loyal crew of comrades.

620Now all day long till the sun went down we sat

and feasted on sides of meat and heady wine.

Then when the sun had set and night came on

we lay down and slept at the water’s shelving edge.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

I roused the men straightway, ordering all crews

to man the ships and cast off cables quickly.

They swung aboard at once, they sat to the oars in ranks

and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

And from there we sailed on, glad to escape our death

630yet sick at heart for the comrades we had lost.”

BOOK TEN

The Bewitching Queen of Aeaea

1

“W
e reached the Aeolian island next, the home of Aeolus,

2Hippotas’ son, beloved by the gods who never die—

a great floating island it was, and round it all

huge ramparts rise of indestructible bronze

and sheer rock cliffs shoot up from sea to sky.

The king had sired twelve children within his halls,

six daughters and six sons in the lusty prime of youth,

so he gave his daughters as wives to his six sons.

Seated beside their dear father and doting mother,

10with delicacies aplenty spread before them,

they feast on forever… All day long

the halls breathe the savor of roasted meats

and echo round to the low moan of blowing pipes,

and all night long, each one by his faithful mate,

they sleep under soft-piled rugs on corded bedsteads.

To this city of theirs we came, their splendid palace,

and Aeolus hosted me one entire month, he pressed me for news

of Troy and the Argive ships and how we sailed for home,

and I told him the whole long story, first to last.

20And then, when I begged him to send me on my way,

he denied me nothing, he went about my passage.

He gave me a sack, the skin of a full-grown ox,

binding inside the winds that howl from every quarter,

for Zeus had made that king the master of all the winds,

with power to calm them down or rouse them as he pleased.

Aeolus stowed the sack inside my holds, lashed so fast

with a burnished silver cord

not even a slight puff could slip past that knot.

Yet he set the West Wind free to blow us on our way

30and waft our squadron home. But his plan was bound to fail,

yes, our own reckless folly swept us on to ruin…

Nine whole days we sailed, nine nights, nonstop.

On the tenth our own land hove into sight at last—

34we were so close we could see men tending fires.

But now an enticing sleep came on me, bone-weary

from working the vessel’s sheet myself, no letup,

never trusting the ropes to any other mate,

the faster to journey back to native land.

But the crews began to mutter among themselves,

40sure I was hauling troves of gold and silver home,

the gifts of open-hearted Aeolus, Hippotas’ son.

‘The old story!’ One man glanced at another, grumbling.

‘Look at our captain’s luck—so loved by the world,

so prized at every landfall, every port of call.’

‘Heaps of lovely plunder he hauls home from Troy,

while we who went through slogging just as hard,

we go home empty-handed.’

‘Now this Aeolus loads him

down with treasure. Favoritism, friend to friend!’

‘Hurry, let’s see what loot is in that sack,

50how much gold and silver. Break it open—now!’

A fatal plan, but it won my shipmates over.

They loosed the sack and all the winds burst out

and a sudden squall struck and swept us back to sea,

wailing, in tears, far from our own native land.

And I woke up with a start, my spirit churning—

56should I leap over the side and drown at once or

grit my teeth and bear it, stay among the living?

I bore it all, held firm, hiding my face,

clinging tight to the decks

60while heavy squalls blasted our squadron back

again to Aeolus’ island, shipmates groaning hard.

We disembarked on the coast, drew water there

and crewmen snatched a meal by the swift ships.

Once we’d had our fill of food and drink

I took a shipmate along with me, a herald too,

and approached King Aeolus’ famous halls and here

we found him feasting beside his wife and many children.

Reaching the doorposts at the threshold, down we sat

but our hosts, amazed to see us, only shouted questions:

70‘Back again, Odysseus—why? Some blustering god attacked you?

Surely we launched you well, we sped you on your way

to your own land and house, or any place you pleased.’

So they taunted, and I replied in deep despair,

‘A mutinous crew undid me—that and a cruel sleep.

Set it to rights, my friends. You have the power!’

So I pleaded—gentle, humble appeals—

but our hosts turned silent, hushed…

and the father broke forth with an ultimatum:

‘Away from my island—fast—most cursed man alive!

80It’s a crime to host a man or speed him on his way

when the blessed deathless gods despise him so.

Crawling back like this—

it proves the immortals hate you! Out—get out!’

Groan as I did, his curses drove me from his halls

and from there we pulled away with heavy hearts,

with the crews’ spirit broken under the oars’ labor,

thanks to our own folly… no favoring wind in sight.

Six whole days we rowed, six nights, nonstop.

On the seventh day we raised the Laestrygonian land,

90Telepylus heights where the craggy fort of Lamus rises.

Where shepherd calls to shepherd as one drives in his flocks

and the other drives his out and he calls back in answer,

where a man who never sleeps could rake in double wages,

one for herding cattle, one for pasturing fleecy sheep,

the nightfall and the sunrise march so close together.

We entered a fine harbor there, all walled around

by a great unbroken sweep of sky-scraping cliff

and two steep headlands, fronting each other, close

around the mouth so the passage in is cramped.

100Here the rest of my rolling squadron steered,

right into the gaping cove and moored tightly,

prow by prow. Never a swell there, big or small;

a milk-white calm spreads all around the place.

But I alone anchored my black ship outside,

well clear of the harbor’s jaws

I tied her fast to a cliffside with a cable.

I scaled its rock face to a lookout on its crest

but glimpsed no trace of the work of man or beast from there;

all I spied was a plume of smoke, drifting off the land.

110So I sent some crew ahead to learn who lived there—

men like us perhaps, who live on bread?

Two good mates I chose and a third to run the news.

They disembarked and set out on a beaten trail

the wagons used for hauling timber down to town

from the mountain heights above…

and before the walls they met a girl, drawing water,

117Antiphates’ strapping daughter—king of the Laestrygonians.

118She’d come down to a clear running spring, Artacia,

where the local people came to fill their pails.

120My shipmates clustered round her, asking questions:

who was king of the realm? who ruled the natives here?

She waved at once to her father’s high-roofed halls.

They entered the sumptuous palace, found his wife inside—

124a woman huge as a mountain crag who filled them all with horror.

Straightaway she summoned royal Antiphates from assembly,

her husband, who prepared my crew a barbarous welcome.

Snatching one of my men, he tore him up for dinner—

the other two sprang free and reached the ships.

But the king let loose a howling through the town

130that brought tremendous Laestrygonians swarming up

from every side—hundreds, not like men, like Giants!

Down from the cliffs they flung great rocks a man could hardly hoist

and a ghastly shattering din rose up from all the ships—

men in their death-cries, hulls smashed to splinters—

They speared the crews like fish

and whisked them home to make their grisly meal.

But while they killed them off in the harbor depths

I pulled the sword from beside my hip and hacked away

at the ropes that moored my blue-prowed ship of war

140and shouted rapid orders at my shipmates:

‘Put your backs in the oars—now row or die!’

In terror of death they ripped the swells—all as one—

and what a joy as we darted out toward open sea,

clear of those beetling cliffs… my ship alone.

But the rest went down en masse. Our squadron sank.

From there we sailed on, glad to escape our death

yet sick at heart for the dear companions we had lost.

We reached the Aeaean island next, the home of Circe

the nymph with lovely braids, an awesome power too

150who can speak with human voice,

151the true sister of murderous-minded Aeetes.

Both were bred by the Sun who lights our lives;

153their mother was Perse, a child the Ocean bore.

We brought our ship to port without a sound

as a god eased her into a harbor safe and snug,

and for two days and two nights we lay by there,

eating our hearts out, bent with pain and bone-tired.

When Dawn with her lovely locks brought on the third day,

at last I took my spear and my sharp sword again,

160rushed up from the ship to find a lookout point,

hoping to glimpse some sign of human labor,

catch some human voices…

I scaled a commanding crag and, scanning hard,

I could just make out some smoke from Circe’s halls,

drifting up from the broad terrain through brush and woods.

Mulling it over, I thought I’d scout the ground—

that fire aglow in the smoke, I saw it, true,

but soon enough this seemed the better plan:

I’d go back to shore and the swift ship first,

170feed the men, then send them out for scouting.

I was well on my way down, nearing our ship

when a god took pity on me, wandering all alone;

he sent me a big stag with high branching antlers,

right across my path—the sun’s heat forced him down

from his forest range to drink at a river’s banks—

just bounding out of the timber when I hit him

square in the backbone, halfway down the spine

and my bronze spear went punching clean through—

he dropped in the dust, groaning, gasping out his breath.

180Treading on him, I wrenched my bronze spear from the wound,

left it there on the ground, and snapping off some twigs

and creepers, twisted a rope about a fathom long,

I braided it tight, hand over hand, then lashed

the four hocks of that magnificent beast.

Loaded round my neck I lugged him toward the ship,

trudging, propped on my spear—no way to sling him

over a shoulder, steadying him with one free arm—

the kill was so immense!

I flung him down by the hull and roused the men,

190going up to them all with a word to lift their spirits:

‘Listen to me, my comrades, brothers in hardship—

we won’t go down to the House of Death, not yet,

not till our day arrives. Up with you, look,

there’s still some meat and drink in our good ship.

Put our minds on food—why die of hunger here?’

My hardy urging brought them round at once.

Heads came up from cloaks and there by the barren sea

they gazed at the stag, their eyes wide—my noble trophy.

But once they’d looked their fill and warmed their hearts,

200they washed their hands and prepared a splendid meal.

Now all day long till the sun went down we sat

and feasted on sides of meat and seasoned wine.

Then when the sun had set and night came on

we lay down and slept at the water’s shelving edge.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

I called a muster quickly, informing all the crew,

‘Listen to me, my comrades, brothers in hardship,

we can’t tell east from west, the dawn from the dusk,

nor where the sun that lights our lives goes under earth

210nor where it rises. We must think of a plan at once,

some cunning stroke. I doubt there’s one still left.

I scaled a commanding crag and from that height

surveyed an entire island

ringed like a crown by endless wastes of sea.

But the land itself lies low, and I did see smoke

drifting up from its heart through thick brush and woods.’

My message broke their spirit as they recalled

the gruesome work of the Laestrygonian king Antiphates

and the hearty cannibal Cyclops thirsting for our blood.

220They burst into cries, wailing, streaming live tears

that gained us nothing—what good can come of grief?

And so, numbering off my band of men-at-arms

into two platoons, I assigned them each a leader:

224I took one and lord Eurylochus the other.

We quickly shook lots in a bronze helmet—

the lot of brave Eurylochus leapt out first.

So he moved off with his two and twenty comrades,

weeping, leaving us behind in tears as well…

Deep in the wooded glens they came on Circe’s palace

230built of dressed stone on a cleared rise of land.

Mountain wolves and lions were roaming round the grounds—

she’d bewitched them herself, she gave them magic drugs.

But they wouldn’t attack my men; they just came pawing

up around them, fawning, swishing their long tails—

eager as hounds that fawn around their master,

coming home from a feast,

who always brings back scraps to calm them down.

So they came nuzzling round my men—lions, wolves

with big powerful claws—and the men cringed in fear

240at the sight of those strange, ferocious beasts… But still

they paused at her doors, the nymph with lovely braids,

Circe—and deep inside they heard her singing, lifting

her spellbinding voice as she glided back and forth

at her great immortal loom, her enchanting web

a shimmering glory only goddesses can weave.

246Polites, captain of armies, took command,

the closest, most devoted man I had: ‘Friends,

there’s someone inside, plying a great loom,

and how she sings—enthralling!

250The whole house is echoing to her song.

Goddess or woman—let’s call out to her now!’

So he urged and the men called out and hailed her.

She opened her gleaming doors at once and stepped forth,

inviting them all in, and in they went, all innocence.

Only Eurylochus stayed behind—he sensed a trap…

She ushered them in to sit on high-backed chairs,

then she mixed them a potion—cheese, barley

258and pale honey mulled in Pramnian wine—

but into the brew she stirred her wicked drugs

260to wipe from their memories any thought of home.

Once they’d drained the bowls she filled, suddenly

she struck with her wand, drove them into her pigsties,

all of them bristling into swine—with grunts,

snouts—even their bodies, yes, and only

the men’s minds stayed steadfast as before.

So off they went to their pens, sobbing, squealing

as Circe flung them acorns, cornel nuts and mast,

common fodder for hogs that root and roll in mud.

Back Eurylochus ran to our swift black ship

270to tell the disaster our poor friends had faced.

But try as he might, he couldn’t get a word out.

Numbing sorrow had stunned the man to silence—

tears welled in his eyes, his heart possessed by grief.

We assailed him with questions—all at our wits’ end—

till at last he could recount the fate our friends had met:

‘Off we went through the brush, captain, as you commanded.

Deep in the wooded glens we came on Circe’s palace

built of dressed stone on a cleared rise of land.

Someone inside was plying a great loom,

280and how she sang—in a high clear voice!

Goddess or woman—we called out and hailed her…

She opened her gleaming doors at once and stepped forth,

inviting us all in, and in we went, all innocence.

But I stayed behind—I sensed a trap. Suddenly

all vanished—blotted out—not one face showed again,

though I sat there keeping watch a good long time.’

At that report I slung the hefty bronze blade

of my silver-studded sword around my shoulder,

slung my bow on too and told our comrade,

290‘Lead me back by the same way that you came.’

But he flung both arms around my knees and pleaded,

begging me with his tears and winging words:

‘Don’t force me back there, captain, king—

leave me here on the spot.

You will never return yourself, I swear,

you’ll never bring back a single man alive.

Quick, cut and run with the rest of us here—

we can still escape the fatal day!’

299But I shot back, ‘Eurylochus, stay right here,

300eating, drinking, safe by the black ship.

I must be off. Necessity drives me on.’

Leaving the ship and shore, I headed inland,

clambering up through hushed, entrancing glades until,

as I was nearing the halls of Circe skilled in spells,

approaching her palace—Hermes god of the golden wand

crossed my path, and he looked for all the world

like a young man sporting his first beard,

just in the prime and warm pride of youth,

and grasped me by the hand and asked me kindly,

310‘Where are you going now, my unlucky friend—

trekking over the hills alone in unfamiliar country?

And your men are all in there, in Circe’s palace,

cooped like swine, hock by jowl in the sties.

Have you come to set them free?

Well, I warn you, you won’t get home yourself,

you’ll stay right there, trapped with all the rest.

But wait, I can save you, free you from that great danger.

Look, here is a potent drug. Take it to Circe’s halls—

its power alone will shield you from the fatal day.

320Let me tell you of all the witch’s subtle craft…

She’ll mix you a potion, lace the brew with drugs

but she’ll be powerless to bewitch you, even so—

this magic herb I give will fight her spells.

Now here’s your plan of action, step by step.

The moment Circe strikes with her long thin wand,

you draw your sharp sword sheathed at your hip

and rush her fast as if to run her through!

She’ll cower in fear and coax you to her bed—

but don’t refuse the goddess’ bed, not then, not if

330she’s to release your friends and treat you well yourself.

But have her swear the binding oath of the blessed gods

she’ll never plot some new intrigue to harm you,

once you lie there naked—

never unman you, strip away your courage!’

With that

the giant-killer handed over the magic herb,

pulling it from the earth,

and Hermes showed me all its name and nature.

Its root is black and its flower white as milk

and the gods call it moly. Dangerous for a mortal man

340to pluck from the soil but not for deathless gods.

All lies within their power.

Now Hermes went his way

to the steep heights of Olympus, over the island’s woods

while I, just approaching the halls of Circe,

my heart a heaving storm at every step,

paused at her doors, the nymph with lovely braids—

I stood and shouted to her there. She heard my voice,

she opened her gleaming doors at once and stepped forth,

inviting me in, and in I went, all anguish now…

She led me in to sit on a silver-studded chair,

350ornately carved, with a stool to rest my feet.

In a golden bowl she mixed a potion for me to drink,

stirring her poison in, her heart aswirl with evil.

And then she passed it on, I drank it down

but it never worked its spell—

she struck with her wand and ‘Now,’ she cried,

‘off to your sty, you swine, and wallow with your friends!’

But I, I drew my sharp sword sheathed at my hip

and rushed her fast as if to run her through—

359She screamed, slid under my blade, hugged my knees

360with a flood of warm tears and a burst of winging words:

‘Who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?

I’m wonderstruck—you drank my drugs, you’re not bewitched!

Never has any other man withstood my potion, never,

once it’s past his lips and he has drunk it down.

You have a mind in you no magic can enchant!

You must be Odysseus, man of twists and turns—

Hermes the giant-killer, god of the golden wand,

he always said you’d come,

homeward bound from Troy in your swift black ship.

370Come, sheathe your sword, let’s go to bed together,

mount my bed and mix in the magic work of love—

we’ll breed deep trust between us.’

So she enticed

but I fought back, still wary. ‘Circe, Circe,

how dare you tell me to treat you with any warmth?

You who turned my men to swine in your own house and now

you hold me here as well—teeming with treachery

you lure me to your room to mount your bed,

so once I lie there naked

you’ll unman me, strip away my courage!

380Mount your bed? Not for all the world. Not

until you consent to swear, goddess, a binding oath

you’ll never plot some new intrigue to harm me!’

Straightaway

she began to swear the oath that I required—never,

she’d never do me harm—and when she’d finished,

then, at last, I mounted Circe’s gorgeous bed…

At the same time her handmaids bustled through the halls,

four in all who perform the goddess’ household tasks:

nymphs, daughters born of the springs and groves

and the sacred rivers running down to open sea.

390One draped the chairs with fine crimson covers

over the seats she’d spread with linen cloths below.

A second drew up silver tables before the chairs

and laid out golden trays to hold the bread.

A third mulled heady, heart-warming wine

in a silver bowl and set out golden cups.

A fourth brought water and lit a blazing fire

beneath a massive cauldron. The water heated soon,

and once it reached the boil in the glowing bronze

she eased me into a tub and bathed me from the cauldron,

400mixing the hot and cold to suit my taste, showering

head and shoulders down until she’d washed away

the spirit-numbing exhaustion from my body.

The bathing finished, rubbing me sleek with oil,

throwing warm fleece and a shirt around my shoulders,

she led me in to sit on a silver-studded chair,

ornately carved, with a stool to rest my feet.

A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

and over a silver basin tipped it out

so I might rinse my hands,

410then pulled a gleaming table to my side.

A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve me,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

She pressed me to eat. I had no taste for food.

I just sat there, mind wandering, far away…

lost in grim forebodings.

As soon as Circe saw me,

huddled, not touching my food, immersed in sorrow,

she sidled near with a coaxing, winged word:

‘Odysseus, why just sit there, struck dumb,

eating your heart out, not touching food or drink?

420Suspect me of still more treachery? Nothing to fear.

Haven’t I just sworn my solemn, binding oath?’

So she asked, but I protested, ‘Circe—

how could any man in his right mind endure

the taste of food and drink before he’d freed

his comrades-in-arms and looked them in the eyes?

If you, you really want me to eat and drink,

set them free, all my beloved comrades—

let me feast my eyes.’

So I demanded.

Circe strode on through the halls and out,

430her wand held high in hand and, flinging open the pens,

drove forth my men, who looked like full-grown swine.

Facing her, there they stood as she went along the ranks,

anointing them one by one with some new magic oil—

and look, the bristles grown by the first wicked drug

that Circe gave them slipped away from their limbs

and they turned men again: younger than ever,

taller by far, more handsome to the eye, and yes,

they knew me at once and each man grasped my hands

and a painful longing for tears overcame us all,

440a terrible sobbing echoed through the house…

The goddess herself was moved and, standing by me,

warmly urged me on—a lustrous goddess now:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, tried and true,

go at once to your ship at the water’s edge,

haul her straight up on the shore first

and stow your cargo and running gear in caves,

then back you come and bring your trusty crew.’

Her urging won my stubborn spirit over.

Down I went to the swift ship at the water’s edge,

450and there on the decks I found my loyal crew

consumed with grief and weeping live warm tears.

But now, as calves in stalls when cows come home,

droves of them herded back from field to farmyard

once they’ve grazed their fill—as all their young calves

come frisking out to meet them, bucking out of their pens,

lowing nonstop, jostling, rushing round their mothers—

so my shipmates there at the sight of my return

came pressing round me now, streaming tears,

so deeply moved in their hearts they felt as if

460they’d made it back to their own land, their city,

Ithaca’s rocky soil where they were bred and reared.

And through their tears their words went winging home:

‘You’re back again, my king! How thrilled we are—

as if we’d reached our country, Ithaca, at last!

But come, tell us about the fate our comrades met.’

Still I replied with a timely word of comfort:

‘Let’s haul our ship straight up on the shore first

and stow our cargo and running gear in caves.

Then hurry, all of you, come along with me

470to see our friends in the magic halls of Circe,

eating and drinking—the feast flows on forever.’

So I said and they jumped to do my bidding.

Only Eurylochus tried to hold my shipmates back,

his mutinous outburst aimed at one and all:

‘Poor fools, where are we running now?

Why are we tempting fate?—

why stumble blindly down to Circe’s halls?

She’ll turn us all into pigs or wolves or lions

made to guard that palace of hers—by force, I tell you—

480just as the Cyclops trapped our comrades in his lair

with hotheaded Odysseus right beside them all—

thanks to this man’s rashness they died too!’

So he declared and I had half a mind

to draw the sharp sword from beside my hip

and slice his head off, tumbling down in the dust,

close kin that he was. But comrades checked me,

each man trying to calm me, left and right:

‘Captain, we’ll leave him here if you command,

just where he is, to sit and guard the ship.

Lead us on to the magic halls of Circe.’

490With that,

up from the ship and shore they headed inland.

Nor did Eurylochus malinger by the hull;

he straggled behind the rest,

dreading the sharp blast of my rebuke.

All the while

Circe had bathed my other comrades in her palace,

caring and kindly, rubbed them sleek with oil

and decked them out in fleecy cloaks and shirts.

We found them all together, feasting in her halls.

Once we had recognized each other, gazing face-to-face,

500we all broke down and wept—and the house resounded now

and Circe the lustrous one came toward me, pleading,

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, man of action,

no more tears now, calm these tides of sorrow.

Well I know what pains you bore on the swarming sea,

what punishment you endured from hostile men on land.

But come now, eat your food and drink your wine

till the same courage fills your chests, now as then,

when you first set sail from native land, from rocky Ithaca!

Now you are burnt-out husks, your spirits haggard, sere,

510always brooding over your wanderings long and hard,

your hearts never lifting with any joy—

you’ve suffered far too much.’

So she enticed

and won our battle-hardened spirits over.

And there we sat at ease,

day in, day out, till a year had run its course,

feasting on sides of meat and drafts of heady wine…

But then, when the year was gone and the seasons wheeled by

and the months waned and the long days came round again,

my loyal comrades took me aside and prodded,

520‘Captain, this is madness!

High time you thought of your own home at last,

if it really is your fate to make it back alive

and reach your well-built house and native land.’

Their urging brought my stubborn spirit round.

So all that day till the sun went down we sat

and feasted on sides of meat and heady wine.

Then when the sun had set and night came on

the men lay down to sleep in the shadowed halls

but I went up to that luxurious bed of Circe’s,

530hugged her by the knees

and the goddess heard my winging supplication:

‘Circe, now make good a promise you gave me once—

it’s time to help me home. My heart longs to be home,

my comrades’ hearts as well. They wear me down,

pleading with me whenever you’re away.’

So I pressed

and the lustrous goddess answered me in turn:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, old campaigner,

stay on no more in my house against your will.

But first another journey calls. You must travel down

540to the House of Death and the awesome one, Persephone,

541there to consult the ghost of Tiresias, seer of Thebes,

the great blind prophet whose mind remains unshaken.

Even in death—Persephone has given him wisdom,

everlasting vision to him and him alone…

the rest of the dead are empty, flitting shades.’

So she said and crushed the heart inside me.

I knelt in her bed and wept. I’d no desire

to go on living and see the rising light of day.

But once I’d had my fill of tears and writhing there,

550at last I found the words to venture, ‘Circe, Circe,

who can pilot us on that journey? Who has ever

reached the House of Death in a black ship?’

The lustrous goddess answered, never pausing,

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, born for exploits,

let no lack of a pilot at the helm concern you, no,

just step your mast and spread your white sail wide—

sit back and the North Wind will speed you on your way.

But once your vessel has cut across the Ocean River

you will raise a desolate coast and Persephone’s Grove,

560her tall black poplars, willows whose fruit dies young.

Beach your vessel hard by the Ocean’s churning shore

and make your own way down to the moldering House of Death.

563And there into Acheron, the Flood of Grief, two rivers flow,

the torrent River of Fire, the wailing River of Tears

that branches off from Styx, the Stream of Hate,

and a stark crag looms

where the two rivers thunder down and meet.

Once there, go forward, hero. Do as I say now.

Dig a trench of about a forearm’s depth and length

570and around it pour libations out to all the dead—

first with milk and honey, and then with mellow wine,

then water third and last, and sprinkle glistening barley

over it all, and vow again and again to all the dead,

to the drifting, listless spirits of their ghosts,

that once you return to Ithaca you will slaughter

a barren heifer in your halls, the best you have,

and load a pyre with treasures—and to Tiresias,

alone, apart, you will offer a sleek black ram,

the pride of all your herds. And once your prayers

580have invoked the nations of the dead in their dim glory,

slaughter a ram and a black ewe, turning both their heads

582toward Erebus, but turn your head away, looking toward

the Ocean River. Suddenly then the countless shades

of the dead and gone will surge around you there.

But order your men at once to flay the sheep

that lie before you, killed by your ruthless blade,

and burn them both, and then say prayers to the gods,

to the almighty god of death and dread Persephone.

But you—draw your sharp sword from beside your hip,

590sit down on alert there, and never let the ghosts

of the shambling, shiftless dead come near that blood

till you have questioned Tiresias yourself. Soon, soon

the great seer will appear before you, captain of armies:

he will tell you the way to go, the stages of your voyage,

how you can cross the swarming sea and reach home at last.’

And with those words Dawn rose on her golden throne

and Circe dressed me quickly in sea-cloak and shirt

while the queen slipped on a loose, glistening robe,

filmy, a joy to the eye, and round her waist

600she ran a brocaded golden belt

and over her head a scarf to shield her brow.

And I strode on through the halls to stir my men,

hovering over each with a winning word: ‘Up now!

No more lazing away in sleep, we must set sail—

Queen Circe has shown the way.’

I brought them round,

my hardy friends-in-arms, but not even from there

could I get them safely off without a loss…

608There was a man, Elpenor, the youngest in our ranks,

none too brave in battle, none too sound in mind.

610He’d strayed from his mates in Circe’s magic halls

and keen for the cool night air,

sodden with wine he’d bedded down on her roofs.

But roused by the shouts and tread of marching men,

he leapt up with a start at dawn but still so dazed

he forgot to climb back down again by the long ladder—

headfirst from the roof he plunged, his neck snapped

from the backbone, his soul flew down to Death.

Once on our way, I gave the men their orders:

‘You think we are headed home, our own dear land?

620Well, Circe sets us a rather different course…

down to the House of Death and the awesome one, Persephone,

there to consult the ghost of Tiresias, seer of Thebes.’

So I said, and it broke my shipmates’ hearts.

They sank down on the ground, moaning, tore their hair.

But it gained us nothing—what good can come of grief?

Back to the swift ship at the water’s edge we went,

our spirits deep in anguish, faces wet with tears.

But Circe got to the dark hull before us,

tethered a ram and black ewe close by—

630slipping past unseen. Who can glimpse a god

who wants to be invisible gliding here and there?”

BOOK ELEVEN

The Kingdom of the Dead

“N
ow down we came to the ship at the water’s edge,

we hauled and launched her into the sunlit breakers first,

stepped the mast in the black craft and set our sail

and loaded the sheep aboard, the ram and ewe,

then we ourselves embarked, streaming tears,

our hearts weighed down with anguish…

But Circe, the awesome nymph with lovely braids

who speaks with human voice, sent us a hardy shipmate,

yes, a fresh following wind ruffling up in our wake,

10bellying out our sail to drive our blue prow on as we,

securing the running gear from stem to stern, sat back

while the wind and helmsman kept her true on course.

The sail stretched taut as she cut the sea all day

and the sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark.

And she made the outer limits, the Ocean River’s bounds

16where Cimmerian people have their homes—their realm and city

shrouded in mist and cloud. The eye of the Sun can never

flash his rays through the dark and bring them light,

not when he climbs the starry skies or when he wheels

20back down from the heights to touch the earth once more—

an endless, deadly night overhangs those wretched men.

There, gaining that point, we beached our craft

and herding out the sheep, we picked our way

by the Ocean’s banks until we gained the place

that Circe made our goal.

Here at the spot

26Perimedes and Eurylochus held the victims fast,

and I, drawing my sharp sword from beside my hip,

dug a trench of about a forearm’s depth and length

and around it poured libations out to all the dead,

30first with milk and honey, and then with mellow wine,

then water third and last, and sprinkled glistening barley

over it all, and time and again I vowed to all the dead,

to the drifting, listless spirits of their ghosts,

that once I returned to Ithaca I would slaughter

a barren heifer in my halls, the best I had,

and load a pyre with treasures—and to Tiresias,

alone, apart, I would offer a sleek black ram,

the pride of all my herds. And once my vows

and prayers had invoked the nations of the dead,

40I took the victims, over the trench I cut their throats

and the dark blood flowed in—and up out of Erebus they came,

flocking toward me now, the ghosts of the dead and gone…

Brides and unwed youths and old men who had suffered much

and girls with their tender hearts freshly scarred by sorrow

and great armies of battle dead, stabbed by bronze spears,

men of war still wrapped in bloody armor—thousands

swarming around the trench from every side—

unearthly cries—blanching terror gripped me!

I ordered the men at once to flay the sheep

50that lay before us, killed by my ruthless blade,

and burn them both, and then say prayers to the gods,

to the almighty god of death and dread Persephone.

But I, the sharp sword drawn from beside my hip,

sat down on alert there and never let the ghosts

of the shambling, shiftless dead come near that blood

till I had questioned Tiresias myself.

But first

the ghost of Elpenor, my companion, came toward me.

He’d not been buried under the wide ways of earth,

not yet, we’d left his body in Circe’s house,

60unwept, unburied—this other labor pressed us.

But I wept to see him now, pity touched my heart

and I called out a winged word to him there: ‘Elpenor,

how did you travel down to the world of darkness?

Faster on foot, I see, than I in my black ship.’

My comrade groaned as he offered me an answer:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, old campaigner,

the doom of an angry god, and god knows how much wine—

they were my ruin, captain… I’d bedded down

on the roof of Circe’s house but never thought

70to climb back down again by the long ladder—

headfirst from the roof I plunged, my neck snapped

from the backbone, my soul flew down to Death. Now,

I beg you by those you left behind, so far from here,

your wife, your father who bred and reared you as a boy,

and Telemachus, left at home in your halls, your only son.

Well I know when you leave this lodging of the dead

that you and your ship will put ashore again

at the island of Aeaea—then and there,

my lord, remember me, I beg you! Don’t sail off

80and desert me, left behind unwept, unburied, don’t,

or my curse may draw god’s fury on your head.

No, burn me in full armor, all my harness,

heap my mound by the churning gray surf—

a man whose luck ran out—

so even men to come will learn my story.

Perform my rites, and plant on my tomb that oar

I swung with mates when I rowed among the living.’

‘All this, my unlucky friend,’ I reassured him,

‘I will do for you. I won’t forget a thing.’

So we sat

90and faced each other, trading our bleak parting words,

I on my side, holding my sword above the blood,

he across from me there, my comrade’s phantom

dragging out his story.

But look, the ghost

of my mother came! My mother, dead and gone now…

95Anticleia—daughter of that great heart Autolycus—

whom I had left alive when I sailed for sacred Troy.

I broke into tears to see her here, but filled with pity,

even throbbing with grief, I would not let her ghost

approach the blood till I had questioned Tiresias myself.

100At last he came. The shade of the famous Theban prophet,

holding a golden scepter, knew me at once and hailed me:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, master of exploits,

man of pain, what now, what brings you here,

forsaking the light of day

to see this joyless kingdom of the dead?

Stand back from the trench—put up your sharp sword

so I can drink the blood and tell you all the truth.’

Moving back, I thrust my silver-studded sword

deep in its sheath, and once he had drunk the dark blood

110the words came ringing from the prophet in his power:

‘A sweet smooth journey home, renowned Odysseus,

that is what you seek

but a god will make it hard for you—I know—

you will never escape the one who shakes the earth,

quaking with anger at you still, still enraged

because you blinded the Cyclops, his dear son.

Even so, you and your crew may still reach home,

suffering all the way, if you only have the power

to curb their wild desire and curb your own, what’s more,

120from the day your good trim vessel first puts in

121at Thrinacia Island, flees the cruel blue sea.

There you will find them grazing,

herds and fat flocks, the cattle of Helios,

god of the sun who sees all, hears all things.

125Leave the beasts unharmed, your mind set on home,

and you all may still reach Ithaca—bent with hardship,

true—but harm them in any way, and I can see it now:

your ship destroyed, your men destroyed as well.

And even if you escape, you’ll come home late

130and come a broken man—all shipmates lost,

alone in a stranger’s ship—

and you will find a world of pain at home,

crude, arrogant men devouring all your goods,

courting your noble wife, offering gifts to win her.

No doubt you will pay them back in blood when you come home!

But once you have killed those suitors in your halls—

by stealth or in open fight with slashing bronze—

go forth once more, you must…

carry your well-planed oar until you come

140to a race of people who know nothing of the sea,

whose food is never seasoned with salt, strangers all

to ships with their crimson prows and long slim oars,

wings that make ships fly. And here is your sign—

unmistakable, clear, so clear you cannot miss it:

When another traveler falls in with you and calls

146that weight across your shoulder a fan to winnow grain,

then plant your bladed, balanced oar in the earth

and sacrifice fine beasts to the lord god of the sea,

Poseidon—a ram, a bull and a ramping wild boar—

150then journey home and render noble offerings up

to the deathless gods who rule the vaulting skies,

to all the gods in order.

153And at last your own death will steal upon you…

154a gentle, painless death, far from the sea it comes

to take you down, borne down with the years in ripe old age

with all your people there in blessed peace around you.

All that I have told you will come true.’

‘Oh Tiresias,’

I replied as the prophet finished, ‘surely the gods

have spun this out as fate, the gods themselves.

160But tell me one thing more, and tell me clearly.

I see the ghost of my long-lost mother here before me.

Dead, crouching close to the blood in silence,

she cannot bear to look me in the eyes—

her own son—or speak a word to me. How,

lord, can I make her know me for the man I am?’

‘One rule there is,’ the famous seer explained,

‘and simple for me to say and you to learn.

Any one of the ghosts you let approach the blood

will speak the truth to you. Anyone you refuse

will turn and fade away.’

170And with those words,

now that his prophecies had closed, the awesome shade

of lord Tiresias strode back to the House of Death.

But I kept watch there, steadfast till my mother

approached and drank the dark, clouding blood.

175She knew me at once and wailed out in grief

and her words came winging toward me, flying home:

‘Oh my son—what brings you down to the world

of death and darkness? You are still alive!

It’s hard for the living to catch a glimpse of this…

180Great rivers flow between us, terrible waters,

the Ocean first of all—no one could ever ford

that stream on foot, only aboard some sturdy craft.

Have you just come from Troy, wandering long years

with your men and ship? Not yet returned to Ithaca?

You’ve still not seen your wife inside your halls?’

‘Mother,’

I replied, ‘I had to venture down to the House of Death,

to consult the shade of Tiresias, seer of Thebes.

Never yet have I neared Achaea, never once

set foot on native ground,

190always wandering—endless hardship from that day

I first set sail with King Agamemnon bound for Troy,

the stallion-land, to fight the Trojans there.

But tell me about yourself and spare me nothing.

What form of death overcame you, what laid you low,

some long slow illness? Or did Artemis showering arrows

come with her painless shafts and bring you down?

Tell me of father, tell of the son I left behind:

do my royal rights still lie in their safekeeping?

Or does some stranger hold the throne by now

200because men think that I’ll come home no more?

Please, tell me about my wife, her turn of mind,

her thoughts… still standing fast beside our son,

still guarding our great estates, secure as ever now?

Or has she wed some other countryman at last,

the finest prince among them?’

‘Surely, surely,’

my noble mother answered quickly, ‘she’s still waiting

there in your halls, poor woman, suffering so,

her life an endless hardship like your own…

wasting away the nights, weeping away the days.

210No one has taken over your royal rights, not yet.

Telemachus still holds your great estates in peace,

he attends the public banquets shared with all,

the feasts a man of justice should enjoy,

for every lord invites him. As for your father,

he keeps to his own farm—he never goes to town—

with no bed for him there, no blankets, glossy throws;

all winter long he sleeps in the lodge with servants,

in the ashes by the fire, his body wrapped in rags.

But when summer comes and the bumper crops of harvest,

220any spot on the rising ground of his vineyard rows

he makes his bed, heaped high with fallen leaves,

and there he lies in anguish…

with his old age bearing hard upon him, too,

and his grief grows as he longs for your return.

And I with the same grief, I died and met my fate.

No sharp-eyed Huntress showering arrows through the halls

approached and brought me down with painless shafts,

nor did some hateful illness strike me, that so often

devastates the body, drains our limbs of power.

230No, it was my longing for you, my shining Odysseus—

you and your quickness, you and your gentle ways—

that tore away my life that had been sweet.’

And I, my mind in turmoil, how I longed

to embrace my mother’s spirit, dead as she was!

Three times I rushed toward her, desperate to hold her,

three times she fluttered through my fingers, sifting away

like a shadow, dissolving like a dream, and each time

the grief cut to the heart, sharper, yes, and I,

I cried out to her, words winging into the darkness:

240‘Mother—why not wait for me? How I long to hold you!—

so even here, in the House of Death, we can fling

our loving arms around each other, take some joy

in the tears that numb the heart. Or is this just

some wraith that great Persephone sends my way

to make me ache with sorrow all the more?’

My noble mother answered me at once:

‘My son, my son, the unluckiest man alive!

This is no deception sent by Queen Persephone,

this is just the way of mortals when we die.

250Sinews no longer bind the flesh and bones together—

the fire in all its fury burns the body down to ashes

once life slips from the white bones, and the spirit,

rustling, flitters away… flown like a dream.

But you must long for the daylight. Go, quickly.

Remember all these things

so one day you can tell them to your wife.’

And so we both confided, trading parting words,

and there slowly came a grand array of women,

all sent before me now by august Persephone,

260and all were wives and daughters once of princes.

They swarmed in a flock around the dark blood

while I searched for a way to question each alone,

and the more I thought, the more this seemed the best:

Drawing forth the long sharp sword from beside my hip,

I would not let them drink the dark blood, all in a rush,

and so they waited, coming forward one after another.

Each declared her lineage, and I explored them all.

268And the first I saw there? Tyro, born of kings,

269who said her father was that great lord Salmoneus,

270said that she was the wife of Cretheus, Aeolus’ son.

271And once she fell in love with the river god, Enipeus,

far the clearest river flowing across the earth,

and so she’d haunt Enipeus’ glinting streams,

till taking his shape one day

the god who girds the earth and makes it tremble

bedded her where the swirling river rushes out to sea,

and a surging wave reared up, high as a mountain, dark,

arching over to hide the god and mortal girl together.

Loosing her virgin belt, he lapped her round in sleep

280and when the god had consummated his work of love

he took her by the hand and hailed her warmly:

‘Rejoice in our love, my lady! And when this year

has run its course you will give birth to glorious children—

bedding down with the gods is never barren, futile—

and you must tend them, breed and rear them well.

Now home you go, and restrain yourself, I say,

never breathe your lover’s name but know—

I am Poseidon, god who rocks the earth!’

With that he dove back in the heaving waves

290and she conceived for the god and bore him Pelias, Neleus,

and both grew up to be stalwart aides of Zeus almighty,

292both men alike. Pelias lived on the plains of Iolcos,

rich in sheepflocks, Neleus lived in sandy Pylos.

And the noble queen bore sons to Cretheus too:

295Aeson, Pheres and Amythaon, exultant charioteer.

296And after Tyro I saw Asopus’ daughter Antiope,

proud she’d spent a night in the arms of Zeus himself

298and borne the god twin sons, Amphion and Zethus,

the first to build the footings of seven-gated Thebes,

300her bastions too, for lacking ramparts none could live

in a place so vast, so open—strong as both men were.

302And I saw Alcmena next, Amphitryon’s wife,

who slept in the clasp of Zeus and merged in love

and brought forth Heracles, rugged will and lion heart.

305And I saw Megara too, magnanimous Creon’s daughter

wed to the stalwart Heracles, the hero never daunted.

307And I saw the mother of Oedipus, beautiful Epicaste.

What a monstrous thing she did, in all innocence—

she married her own son…

310who’d killed his father, then he married her!

But the gods soon made it known to all mankind.

So he in growing pain ruled on in beloved Thebes,

lording Cadmus’ people—thanks to the gods’ brutal plan—

while she went down to Death who guards the massive gates.

Lashing a noose to a steep rafter, there she hanged aloft,

strangling in all her anguish, leaving her son to bear

317the world of horror a mother’s Furies bring to life.

318And I saw magnificent Chloris, the one whom Neleus

wooed and won with a hoard of splendid gifts,

320so dazzled by her beauty years ago…

321the youngest daughter of Iasus’ son Amphion,

322the great Minyan king who ruled Orchomenos once.

She was his queen in Pylos, she bore him shining sons,

324Nestor and Chromius, Periclymenus too, good prince.

325And after her sons she bore a daughter, majestic Pero,

the marvel of her time, courted by all the young lords

round about. But Neleus would not give her to any suitor,

none but the man who might drive home the herds

329that powerful Iphiclus had stolen. Lurching,

330broad in the brow, those longhorned beasts,

331and no small task to round them up from Phylace.

332Only the valiant seer Melampus volunteered—

he would drive them home—

but a god’s iron sentence bound him fast:

barbarous herdsmen dragged him off in chains.

Yet when the months and days had run their course

and the year wheeled round and the seasons came again,

then mighty Iphiclus loosed the prophet’s shackles,

once he had told him all the gods’ decrees.

340And so the will of Zeus was done at last.

341And I saw Leda next, Tyndareus’ wife,

who’d borne the king two sons, intrepid twins,

343Castor, breaker of horses, and the hardy boxer Polydeuces,

both buried now in the life-giving earth though still alive.

Even under the earth Zeus grants them that distinction:

one day alive, the next day dead, each twin by turns,

they both hold honors equal to the gods’.

348And I saw Iphimedeia next, Aloeus’ wife,

who claimed she lay in the Sea-lord’s loving waves

350and gave the god two sons, but they did not live long,

351Otus staunch as a god and far-famed Ephialtes.

They were the tallest men the fertile earth has borne,

the handsomest too, by far, aside from renowned Orion.

Nine yards across they measured, even at nine years old,

nine fathoms tall they towered. They even threatened

the deathless gods they’d storm Olympus’ heights

with the pounding rush and grinding shock of battle.

358They were wild to pile Ossa upon Olympus, then on Ossa

359Pelion dense with timber—their toeholds up the heavens.

360And they’d have won the day if they had reached peak strength

but Apollo the son of Zeus, whom sleek-haired Leto bore,

laid both giants low before their beards had sprouted,

covering cheek and chin with a fresh crop of down.

364Phaedra and Procris too I saw, and lovely Ariadne,

365daughter of Minos, that harsh king. One day Theseus tried

366to spirit her off from Crete to Athens’ sacred heights

but he got no joy from her. Artemis killed her first

368on wave-washed Dia’s shores, accused by Dionysus.

369And I saw Clymene, Maera and loathsome Eriphyle—

370bribed with a golden necklace

to lure her lawful husband to his death…

But the whole cortege I could never tally, never name,

not all the daughters and wives of great men I saw there.

Long before that, the godsent night would ebb away.

But the time has come for sleep, either with friends

aboard your swift ship or here in your own house.

My passage home will rest with the gods and you.”

Odysseus paused… They all fell silent, hushed,

his story holding them spellbound down the shadowed halls

380till the white-armed queen Arete suddenly burst out,

“Phaeacians! How does this man impress you now,

his looks, his build, the balanced mind inside him?

The stranger is my guest

but each of you princes shares the honor here.

So let’s not be too hasty to send him on his way,

and don’t scrimp on his gifts. His need is great,

great as the riches piled up in your houses,

thanks to the gods’ good will.”

Following her,

the old revered Echeneus added his support,

390the eldest lord on the island of Phaeacia:

“Friends, the words of our considerate queen—

they never miss the mark or fail our expectations.

So do as Arete says, though on Alcinous here

depend all words and action.”

“And so it will be”—

Alcinous stepped in grandly—“sure as I am alive

and rule our island men who love their oars!

Our guest, much as he longs for passage home,

must stay and wait it out here till tomorrow,

till I can collect his whole array of parting gifts.

400His send-off rests with every noble here

but with me most of all:

I hold the reins of power in the realm.”

Odysseus, deft and tactful, echoed back,

“Alcinous, majesty, shining among your island people,

if you would urge me now to stay here one whole year

then speed me home weighed down with lordly gifts,

I’d gladly have it so. Better by far, that way.

The fuller my arms on landing there at home,

the more respected, well received I’d be

410by all who saw me sailing back to Ithaca.”

“Ah Odysseus,” Alcinous replied, “one look at you

and we know that you are no one who would cheat us—

no fraud, such as the dark soil breeds and spreads

across the face of the earth these days. Crowds of vagabonds

frame their lies so tightly none can test them. But you,

416what grace you give your words, and what good sense within!

You have told your story with all a singer’s skill,

the miseries you endured, your great Achaeans too.

But come now, tell me truly: your godlike comrades—

420did you see any heroes down in the House of Death,

any who sailed with you and met their doom at Troy?

The night’s still young, I’d say the night is endless.

For us in the palace now, it’s hardly time for sleep.

Keep telling us your adventures—they are wonderful.

I could hold out here till Dawn’s first light

if only you could bear, here in our halls,

to tell the tale of all the pains you suffered.”

So the man of countless exploits carried on:

“Alcinous, majesty, shining among your island people,

430there is a time for many words, a time for sleep as well.

But if you insist on hearing more, I’d never stint

on telling my own tale and those more painful still,

the griefs of my comrades, dead in the war’s wake,

who escaped the battle-cries of Trojan armies

only to die in blood at journey’s end—

thanks to a vicious woman’s will.

Now then,

no sooner had Queen Persephone driven off

the ghosts of lovely women, scattering left and right,

than forward marched the shade of Atreus’ son Agamemnon,

440fraught with grief and flanked by all his comrades,

troops of his men-at-arms who died beside him,

who met their fate in lord Aegisthus’ halls.

He knew me at once, as soon as he drank the blood,

and wailed out, shrilly; tears sprang to his eyes,

he thrust his arms toward me, keen to embrace me there—

no use—the great force was gone, the strength lost forever,

now, that filled his rippling limbs in the old days.

I wept at the sight, my heart went out to the man,

my words too, in a winging flight of pity:

450‘Famous Atrides, lord of men Agamemnon!

What fatal stroke of destiny brought you down?

Wrecked in the ships when lord Poseidon roused

some punishing blast of stormwinds, gust on gust?

Or did ranks of enemies mow you down on land

as you tried to raid and cut off herds and flocks

or fought to win their city, take their women?’

457The field marshal’s ghost replied at once:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, mastermind of war,

I was not wrecked in the ships when lord Poseidon

460roused some punishing blast of stormwinds, gust on gust,

nor did ranks of enemies mow me down on land—

Aegisthus hatched my doom and my destruction,

he killed me, he with my own accursed wife…

he invited me to his palace, sat me down to feast

then cut me down as a man cuts down some ox at the trough!

So I died—a wretched, ignominious death—and round me

all my comrades killed, no mercy, one after another,

just like white-tusked boars

butchered in some rich lord of power’s halls

470for a wedding, banquet or groaning public feast.

You in your day have witnessed hundreds slaughtered,

killed in single combat or killed in pitched battle, true,

but if you’d laid eyes on this it would have wrenched your heart—

how we sprawled by the mixing-bowl and loaded tables there,

throughout the palace, the whole floor awash with blood.

476But the death-cry of Cassandra, Priam’s daughter—

the most pitiful thing I heard! My treacherous queen,

Clytemnestra, killed her over my body, yes, and I,

lifting my fists, beat them down on the ground,

480dying, dying, writhing around the sword.

But she, that whore, she turned her back on me,

well on my way to Death—she even lacked the heart

to seal my eyes with her hand or close my jaws.

So,

there’s nothing more deadly, bestial than a woman

set on works like these—what a monstrous thing

she plotted, slaughtered her own lawful husband!

Why, I expected, at least, some welcome home

from all my children, all my household slaves

when I came sailing back again… But she—

490the queen hell-bent on outrage—bathes in shame

not only herself but the whole breed of womankind,

even the honest ones to come, forever down the years!’

So he declared and I cried out, ‘How terrible!

Zeus from the very start, the thunder king

has hated the race of Atreus with a vengeance—

his trustiest weapon women’s twisted wiles.

What armies of us died for the sake of Helen…

Clytemnestra schemed your death while you were worlds away!’

‘True, true,’ Agamemnon’s ghost kept pressing on,

500‘so even your own wife—never indulge her too far.

Never reveal the whole truth, whatever you may know;

just tell her a part of it, be sure to hide the rest.

Not that you, Odysseus, will be murdered by your wife.

She’s much too steady, her feelings run too deep,

Icarius’ daughter Penelope, that wise woman.

She was a young bride, I well remember…

we left her behind when we went off to war,

with an infant boy she nestled at her breast.

That boy must sit and be counted with the men now—

510happy man! His beloved father will come sailing home

and see his son, and he will embrace his father,

that is only right. But my wife—she never

even let me feast my eyes on my own son;

she killed me first, his father!

I tell you this—bear it in mind, you must—

when you reach your homeland steer your ship

into port in secret, never out in the open…

the time for trusting women’s gone forever!

Enough. Come, tell me this, and be precise.

520Have you heard news of my son? Where’s he living now?

Perhaps in Orchomenos, perhaps in sandy Pylos

or off in the Spartan plains with Menelaus?

He’s not dead yet, my Prince Orestes, no,

he’s somewhere on the earth.’

So he probed

but I cut it short: ‘Atrides, why ask me that?

I know nothing, whether he’s dead or alive.

It’s wrong to lead you on with idle words.’

So we stood there, trading heartsick stories,

deep in grief, as the tears streamed down our faces.

530But now there came the ghosts of Peleus’ son Achilles,

Patroclus, fearless Antilochus—and Great Ajax too,

the first in stature, first in build and bearing

of all the Argives after Peleus’ matchless son.

The ghost of the splendid runner knew me at once

and hailed me with a flight of mournful questions:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, man of tactics,

reckless friend, what next?

What greater feat can that cunning head contrive?

What daring brought you down to the House of Death?—

540where the senseless, burnt-out wraiths of mortals make their home.’

The voice of his spirit paused, and I was quick to answer:

‘Achilles, son of Peleus, greatest of the Achaeans,

I had to consult Tiresias, driven here by hopes

he would help me journey home to rocky Ithaca.

Never yet have I neared Achaea, never once

set foot on native ground…

547my life is endless trouble.

But you, Achilles,

there’s not a man in the world more blest than you—

there never has been, never will be one.

550Time was, when you were alive, we Argives

honored you as a god, and now down here, I see,

you lord it over the dead in all your power.

So grieve no more at dying, great Achilles.’

I reassured the ghost, but he broke out, protesting,

555‘No winning words about death to me, shining Odysseus!

556By god, I’d rather slave on earth for another man—

some dirt-poor tenant farmer who scrapes to keep alive—

than rule down here over all the breathless dead.

But come, tell me the news about my gallant son.

560Did he make his way to the wars,

did the boy become a champion—yes or no?

Tell me of noble Peleus, any word you’ve heard—

still holding pride of place among his Myrmidon hordes,

564or do they despise the man in Hellas and in Phthia

because old age has lamed his arms and legs?

For I no longer stand in the light of day—

the man I was—comrade-in-arms to help my father

as once I helped our armies, killing the best fighters

Troy could field in the wide world up there…

570Oh to arrive at father’s house—the man I was,

for one brief day—I’d make my fury and my hands,

invincible hands, a thing of terror to all those men

who abuse the king with force and wrest away his honor!’

So he grieved but I tried to lend him heart:

‘About noble Peleus I can tell you nothing,

576but about your own dear son, Neoptolemus,

I can report the whole story, as you wish.

I myself, in my trim ship, I brought him

579out of Scyros to join the Argives under arms.

580And dug in around Troy, debating battle-tactics,

he always spoke up first, and always on the mark—

godlike Nestor and I alone excelled the boy. Yes,

583and when our armies fought on the plain of Troy

he’d never hang back with the main force of men—

he’d always charge ahead,

giving ground to no one in his fury,

587and scores of men he killed in bloody combat.

How could I list them all, name them all, now,

the fighting ranks he leveled, battling for the Argives?

590But what a soldier he laid low with a bronze sword:

591the hero Eurypylus, Telephus’ son, and round him

592troops of his own Cetean comrades slaughtered,

lured to war by the bribe his mother took.

The only man I saw to put Eurypylus

in the shade was Memnon, son of the Morning.

Again, when our champions climbed inside the horse

that Epeus built with labor, and I held full command

to spring our packed ambush open or keep it sealed,

all our lords and captains were wiping off their tears,

600knees shaking beneath each man—but not your son.

Never once did I see his glowing skin go pale;

he never flicked a tear from his cheeks, no,

he kept on begging me there to let him burst

from the horse, kept gripping his hilted sword,

his heavy bronze-tipped javelin, keen to loose

his fighting fury against the Trojans. Then,

once we’d sacked King Priam’s craggy city,

laden with his fair share and princely prize

he boarded his own ship, his body all unscarred.

610Not a wound from a flying spear or a sharp sword,

cut-and-thrust close up—the common marks of war.

Random, raging Ares plays no favorites.’

So I said and

613off he went, the ghost of the great runner, Aeacus’ grandson

614loping with long strides across the fields of asphodel,

triumphant in all I had told him of his son,

his gallant, glorious son.

Now the rest of the ghosts, the dead and gone

came swarming up around me—deep in sorrow there,

each asking about the grief that touched him most.

620Only the ghost of Great Ajax, son of Telamon,

kept his distance, blazing with anger at me still

for the victory I had won by the ships that time

I pressed my claim for the arms of Prince Achilles.

His queenly mother had set them up as prizes,

625Pallas and captive Trojans served as judges.

Would to god I’d never won such trophies!

All for them the earth closed over Ajax,

that proud hero Ajax…

greatest in build, greatest in works of war

630of all the Argives after Peleus’ matchless son.

I cried out to him now, I tried to win him over:

‘Ajax, son of noble Telamon, still determined,

even in death, not once to forget that rage

you train on me for those accursed arms?

The gods set up that prize to plague the Achaeans—

so great a tower of strength we lost when you went down!

For your death we grieved as we did for Achilles’ death—

we grieved incessantly, true, and none’s to blame

but Zeus, who hated Achaea’s fighting spearmen

640so intensely, Zeus sealed your doom.

Come closer, king, and listen to my story.

Conquer your rage, your blazing, headstrong pride!’

So I cried out but Ajax answered not a word.

He stalked off toward Erebus, into the dark

to join the other lost, departed dead.

Yet now, despite his anger,

he might have spoken to me, or I to him,

but the heart inside me stirred with some desire

to see the ghosts of others dead and gone.

650And I saw Minos there, illustrious son of Zeus,

firmly enthroned, holding his golden scepter,

judging all the dead…

Some on their feet, some seated, all clustering

round the king of justice, pleading for his verdicts

reached in the House of Death with its all-embracing gates.

I next caught sight of Orion, that huge hunter,

rounding up on the fields of asphodel those wild beasts

the man in life cut down on the lonely mountain-slopes,

brandishing in his hands the bronze-studded club

that time can never shatter.

660I saw Tityus too,

son of the mighty goddess Earth—sprawling there

on the ground, spread over nine acres—two vultures

hunched on either side of him, digging into his liver,

beaking deep in the blood-sac, and he with his frantic hands

could never beat them off, for he had once dragged off

the famous consort of Zeus in all her glory,

Leto, threading her way toward Pytho’s ridge,

668over the lovely dancing-rings of Panopeus.

669And I saw Tantalus too, bearing endless torture.

670He stood erect in a pool as the water lapped his chin—

parched, he tried to drink, but he could not reach the surface,

no, time and again the old man stooped, craving a sip,

time and again the water vanished, swallowed down,

laying bare the caked black earth at his feet—

some spirit drank it dry. And over his head

leafy trees dangled their fruit from high aloft,

pomegranates and pears, and apples glowing red,

succulent figs and olives swelling sleek and dark,

but as soon as the old man would strain to clutch them fast

680a gust would toss them up to the lowering dark clouds.

681And I saw Sisyphus too, bound to his own torture,

grappling his monstrous boulder with both arms working,

heaving, hands struggling, legs driving, he kept on

thrusting the rock uphill toward the brink, but just

as it teetered, set to topple over—

time and again

the immense weight of the thing would wheel it back and

the ruthless boulder would bound and tumble down to the plain again—

so once again he would heave, would struggle to thrust it up,

sweat drenching his body, dust swirling above his head.

690And next I caught a glimpse of powerful Heracles—

his ghost, I mean: the man himself delights

in the grand feasts of the deathless gods on high,

693wed to Hebe, famed for her lithe, alluring ankles,

the daughter of mighty Zeus and Hera shod in gold.

Around him cries of the dead rang out like cries of birds,

scattering left and right in horror as on he came like night,

naked bow in his grip, an arrow grooved on the bowstring,

glaring round him fiercely, forever poised to shoot.

A terror too, that sword-belt sweeping across his chest,

700a baldric of solid gold emblazoned with awesome work…

bears and ramping boars and lions with wild, fiery eyes,

and wars, routs and battles, massacres, butchered men.

May the craftsman who forged that masterpiece—

whose skills could conjure up a belt like that—

never forge another!

Heracles knew me at once, at first glance,

and hailed me with a winging burst of pity:

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus famed for exploits,

luckless man, you too? Braving out a fate as harsh

710as the fate I bore, alive in the light of day?

Son of Zeus that I was, my torments never ended,

forced to slave for a man not half the man I was:

he saddled me with the worst heartbreaking labors.

Why, he sent me down here once, to retrieve the hound

that guards the dead—no harder task for me, he thought—

but I dragged the great beast up from the underworld to earth

and Hermes and gleaming-eyed Athena blazed the way!’

With that he turned and back he went to the House of Death

but I held fast in place, hoping that others might still come,

720shades of famous heroes, men who died in the old days

and ghosts of an even older age I longed to see,

Theseus and Pirithous, the gods’ own radiant sons.

723But before I could, the dead came surging round me,

hordes of them, thousands raising unearthly cries,

and blanching terror gripped me—panicked now

that Queen Persephone might send up from Death

726some monstrous head, some Gorgon’s staring face!

I rushed back to my ship, commanded all hands

to take to the decks and cast off cables quickly.

They swung aboard at once, they sat to the oars in ranks

730and a strong tide of the Ocean River swept her on downstream,

sped by our rowing first, then by a fresh fair wind.”

BOOK TWELVE

The Cattle of the Sun

“N
ow when our ship had left the Ocean River rolling in her wake

and launched out into open sea with its long swells to reach

the island of Aeaea—east where the Dawn forever young

has home and dancing-rings and the Sun his risings—

heading in we beached our craft on the sands,

the crews swung out on the low sloping shore

and there we fell asleep, awaiting Dawn’s first light.

As soon as Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone again

I dispatched some men to Circe’s halls to bring

10the dead Elpenor’s body. We cut logs in haste

and out on the island’s sharpest jutting headland

held his funeral rites in sorrow, streaming tears.

Once we’d burned the dead man and the dead man’s armor,

heaping his grave-mound, hauling a stone that coped it well,

we planted his balanced oar aloft to crown his tomb.

And so we saw to his rites, each step in turn.

Nor did our coming back from Death escape Circe—

she hurried toward us, decked in rich regalia,

handmaids following close with trays of bread

20and meats galore and glinting ruddy wine.

And the lustrous goddess, standing in our midst,

hailed us warmly: ‘Ah my daring, reckless friends!

You who ventured down to the House of Death alive,

doomed to die twice over—others die just once.

Come, take some food and drink some wine,

rest here the livelong day

and then, tomorrow at daybreak, you must sail.

28But I will set you a course and chart each seamark,

so neither on sea nor land will some new trap

30ensnare you in trouble, make you suffer more.’

Her foresight won our fighting spirits over.

So all that day till the sun went down we sat

and feasted on sides of meat and heady wine,

and then when the sun had set and night came on

the men lay down to sleep by the ship’s stern-cables.

But Circe, taking me by the hand, drew me away

from all my shipmates there and sat me down

and lying beside me probed me for details.

I told her the whole story, start to finish,

40then the queenly goddess laid my course:

‘Your descent to the dead is over, true,

but listen closely to what I tell you now

and god himself will bring it back to mind.

44First you will raise the island of the Sirens,

those creatures who spellbind any man alive,

whoever comes their way. Whoever draws too close,

off guard, and catches the Sirens’ voices in the air—

no sailing home for him, no wife rising to meet him,

no happy children beaming up at their father’s face.

50The high, thrilling song of the Sirens will transfix him,

lolling there in their meadow, round them heaps of corpses

rotting away, rags of skin shriveling on their bones…

Race straight past that coast! Soften some beeswax

and stop your shipmates’ ears so none can hear,

none of the crew, but if you are bent on hearing,

have them tie you hand and foot in the swift ship,

erect at the mast-block, lashed by ropes to the mast

so you can hear the Sirens’ song to your heart’s content.

But if you plead, commanding your men to set you free,

60then they must lash you faster, rope on rope.

But once your crew has rowed you past the Sirens

a choice of routes is yours. I cannot advise you

which to take, or lead you through it all—

you must decide for yourself—

but I can tell you the ways of either course.

On one side beetling cliffs shoot up, and against them

pound the huge roaring breakers of blue-eyed Amphitrite—

68the Clashing Rocks they’re called by all the blissful gods.

Not even birds can escape them, no, not even the doves

70that veer and fly ambrosia home to Father Zeus:

even of those the sheer Rocks always pick off one

and Father wings one more to keep the number up.

No ship of men has ever approached and slipped past—

always some disaster—big timbers and sailors’ corpses

whirled away by the waves and lethal blasts of fire.

76One ship alone, one deep-sea craft sailed clear,

77the Argo, sung by the world, when heading home

from Aeetes’ shores. And she would have crashed

against those giant rocks and sunk at once if Hera,

80for love of Jason, had not sped her through.

On the other side loom two enormous crags…

One thrusts into the vaulting sky its jagged peak,

hooded round with a dark cloud that never leaves—

no clear bright air can ever bathe its crown,

not even in summer’s heat or harvest-time.

No man on earth could scale it, mount its crest,

not even with twenty hands and twenty feet for climbing,

the rock’s so smooth, like dressed and burnished stone.

And halfway up that cliffside stands a fog-bound cavern

90gaping west toward Erebus, realm of death and darkness—

past it, great Odysseus, you should steer your ship.

No rugged young archer could hit that yawning cave

with a winged arrow shot from off the decks.

94Scylla lurks inside it—the yelping horror,

yelping, no louder than any suckling pup

but she’s a grisly monster, I assure you.

No one could look on her with any joy,

not even a god who meets her face-to-face…

She has twelve legs, all writhing, dangling down

100and six long swaying necks, a hideous head on each,

each head barbed with a triple row of fangs, thickset,

packed tight—and armed to the hilt with black death!

Holed up in the cavern’s bowels from her waist down

she shoots out her heads, out of that terrifying pit,

angling right from her nest, wildly sweeping the reefs

for dolphins, dogfish or any bigger quarry she can drag

from the thousands Amphitrite spawns in groaning seas.

No mariners yet can boast they’ve raced their ship

past Scylla’s lair without some mortal blow—

110with each of her six heads she snatches up

a man from the dark-prowed craft and whisks him off.

The other crag is lower—you will see, Odysseus—

though both lie side-by-side, an arrow-shot apart.

Atop it a great fig-tree rises, shaggy with leaves,

115beneath it awesome Charybdis gulps the dark water down.

Three times a day she vomits it up, three times she gulps it down,

that terror! Don’t be there when the whirlpool swallows down—

not even the earthquake god could save you from disaster.

No, hug Scylla’s crag—sail on past her—top speed!

120Better by far to lose six men and keep your ship

than lose your entire crew.’

‘Yes, yes,

but tell me the truth now, goddess,’ I protested.

‘Deadly Charybdis—can’t I possibly cut and run from her

and still fight Scylla off when Scylla strikes my men?’

‘So stubborn!’ the lovely goddess countered.

‘Hell-bent yet again on battle and feats of arms?

Can’t you bow to the deathless gods themselves?

Scylla’s no mortal, she’s an immortal devastation,

terrible, savage, wild, no fighting her, no defense—

130just flee the creature, that’s the only way.

Waste any time, arming for battle beside her rock,

I fear she’ll lunge out again with all of her six heads

and seize as many men. No, row for your lives,

invoke Brute Force, I tell you, Scylla’s mother—

she spawned her to scourge mankind,

she can stop the monster’s next attack!

Then you will make the island of Thrinacia…

where herds of the Sungod’s cattle graze, and fat sheep

and seven herds of oxen, as many sheepflocks, rich and woolly,

140fifty head in each. No breeding swells their number,

nor do they ever die. And goddesses herd them on,

142nymphs with glinting hair, Phaëthousa, Lampetie,

143born to the Sungod Helios by radiant Neaera.

Their queenly mother bred and reared them both

then settled them on the island of Thrinacia—

their homeland seas away—

to guard their father’s sheep and longhorn cattle.

148Leave the beasts unharmed, your mind set on home,

and you all may still reach Ithaca—bent with hardship,

150true—but harm them in any way, and I can see it now:

your ship destroyed, your men destroyed as well!

And even if you escape, you’ll come home late,

all shipmates lost, and come a broken man.’

At those words Dawn rose on her golden throne

and lustrous Circe made her way back up the island.

I went straight to my ship, commanding all hands

to take to the decks and cast off cables quickly.

They swung aboard at once, they sat to the oars in ranks

and in rhythm churned the water white with stroke on stroke.

160And Circe the nymph with glossy braids, the awesome one

who speaks with human voice, sent us a hardy shipmate,

yes, a fresh following wind ruffling up in our wake,

bellying out our sail to drive our blue prow on as we,

securing the running gear from stem to stern, sat back

while the wind and helmsman kept her true on course.

At last, and sore at heart, I told my shipmates,

‘Friends… it’s wrong for only one or two

to know the revelations that lovely Circe

made to me alone. I’ll tell you all,

170so we can die with our eyes wide open now

or escape our fate and certain death together.

First, she warns, we must steer clear of the Sirens,

their enchanting song, their meadow starred with flowers.

I alone was to hear their voices, so she said,

but you must bind me with tight chafing ropes

so I cannot move a muscle, bound to the spot,

erect at the mast-block, lashed by ropes to the mast.

And if I plead, commanding you to set me free,

then lash me faster, rope on pressing rope.’

180So I informed my shipmates point by point,

all the while our trim ship was speeding toward

the Sirens’ island, driven on by the brisk wind.

But then—the wind fell in an instant,

all glazed to a dead calm…

a mysterious power hushed the heaving swells.

The oarsmen leapt to their feet, struck the sail,

stowed it deep in the hold and sat to the oarlocks,

thrashing with polished oars, frothing the water white.

Now with a sharp sword I sliced an ample wheel of beeswax

190down into pieces, kneaded them in my two strong hands

and the wax soon grew soft, worked by my strength

and Helios’ burning rays, the sun at high noon,

and I stopped the ears of my comrades one by one.

They bound me hand and foot in the tight ship—

erect at the mast-block, lashed by ropes to the mast—

and rowed and churned the whitecaps stroke on stroke.

We were just offshore as far as a man’s shout can carry,

scudding close, when the Sirens sensed at once a ship

was racing past and burst into their high, thrilling song:

200‘Come closer, famous Odysseus—Achaea’s pride and glory—

moor your ship on our coast so you can hear our song!

Never has any sailor passed our shores in his black craft

until he has heard the honeyed voices pouring from our lips,

and once he hears to his heart’s content sails on, a wiser man.

We know all the pains that the Greeks and Trojans once endured

on the spreading plain of Troy when the gods willed it so—

all that comes to pass on the fertile earth, we know it all!’

So they sent their ravishing voices out across the air

and the heart inside me throbbed to listen longer.

210I signaled the crew with frowns to set me free—

they flung themselves at the oars and rowed on harder,

Perimedes and Eurylochus springing up at once

to bind me faster with rope on chafing rope.

But once we’d left the Sirens fading in our wake,

once we could hear their song no more, their urgent call—

my steadfast crew was quick to remove the wax I’d used

to seal their ears and loosed the bonds that lashed me.

We’d scarcely put that island astern when suddenly

I saw smoke and heavy breakers, heard their booming thunder.

220The men were terrified—oarblades flew from their grip,

clattering down to splash in the vessel’s wash.

She lay there, dead in the water…

no hands to tug the blades that drove her on.

But I strode down the decks to rouse my crewmen,

halting beside each one with a bracing, winning word:

‘Friends, we’re hardly strangers at meeting danger—

and this danger is no worse than what we faced

when Cyclops penned us up in his vaulted cave

with crushing force! But even from there my courage,

230my presence of mind and tactics saved us all,

and we will live to remember this someday,

I have no doubt. Up now, follow my orders,

all of us work as one! You men at the thwarts—

lay on with your oars and strike the heaving swells,

trusting that Zeus will pull us through these straits alive.

You, helmsman, here’s your order—burn it in your mind—

the steering-oar of our rolling ship is in your hands.

Keep her clear of that smoke and surging breakers,

head for those crags or she’ll catch you off guard,

240she’ll yaw over there—you’ll plunge us all in ruin!’

So I shouted. They snapped to each command.

No mention of Scylla—how to fight that nightmare?—

for fear the men would panic, desert their oars

and huddle down and stow themselves away.

But now I cleared my mind of Circe’s orders—

cramping my style, urging me not to arm at all.

I donned my heroic armor, seized long spears

in both my hands and marched out on the half-deck,

forward, hoping from there to catch the first glimpse

250of Scylla, ghoul of the cliffs, swooping to kill my men.

But nowhere could I make her out—and my eyes ached,

scanning that mist-bound rock face top to bottom.

Now wailing in fear, we rowed on up those straits,

Scylla to starboard, dreaded Charybdis off to port,

her horrible whirlpool gulping the sea-surge down, down

but when she spewed it up—like a cauldron over a raging fire—

all her churning depths would seethe and heave—exploding spray

showering down to splatter the peaks of both crags at once!

But when she swallowed the sea-surge down her gaping maw

260the whole abyss lay bare and the rocks around her roared,

terrible, deafening—

bedrock showed down deep, boiling

black with sand—

and ashen terror gripped the men.

But now, fearing death, all eyes fixed on Charybdis—

now Scylla snatched six men from our hollow ship,

the toughest, strongest hands I had, and glancing

backward over the decks, searching for my crew

I could see their hands and feet already hoisted,

flailing, high, higher, over my head, look—

wailing down at me, comrades riven in agony,

270shrieking out my name for one last time!

Just as an angler poised on a jutting rock

flings his treacherous bait in the offshore swell,

whips his long rod—hook sheathed in an oxhorn lure—

and whisks up little fish he flips on the beach-break,

writhing, gasping out their lives… so now they writhed,

gasping as Scylla swung them up her cliff and there

at her cavern’s mouth she bolted them down raw—

screaming out, flinging their arms toward me,

lost in that mortal struggle…

280Of all the pitiful things I’ve had to witness,

suffering, searching out the pathways of the sea,

this wrenched my heart the most.

But now, at last,

putting the Rocks, Scylla and dread Charybdis far astern,

we quickly reached the good green island of the Sun

285where Helios, lord Hyperion, keeps his fine cattle,

broad in the brow, and flocks of purebred sheep.

Still aboard my black ship in the open sea

I could hear the lowing cattle driven home,

the bleating sheep. And I was struck once more

290by the words of the blind Theban prophet, Tiresias,

and Aeaean Circe too: time and again they told me

to shun this island of the Sun, the joy of man.

So I warned my shipmates gravely, sick at heart,

‘Listen to me, my comrades, brothers in hardship,

let me tell you the dire prophecies of Tiresias

and Aeaean Circe too: time and again they told me

to shun this island of the Sun, the joy of man.

Here, they warned, the worst disaster awaits us.

Row straight past these shores—race our black ship on!’

300So I said, and the warnings broke their hearts.

But Eurylochus waded in at once—with mutiny on his mind:

‘You’re a hard man, Odysseus. Your fighting spirit’s

stronger than ours, your stamina never fails.

You must be made of iron head to foot. Look,

your crew’s half-dead with labor, starved for sleep,

and you forbid us to set foot on land, this island here,

washed by the waves, where we might catch a decent meal again.

Drained as we are, night falling fast, you’d have us desert

this haven and blunder off, into the mist-bound seas?

310Out of the night come winds that shatter vessels—

how can a man escape his headlong death

if suddenly, out of nowhere, a cyclone hits,

bred by the South or stormy West Wind? They’re the gales

that tear a ship to splinters—the gods, our masters,

willing or not, it seems. No, let’s give way

to the dark night, set out our supper here.

Sit tight by our swift ship and then at daybreak

board and launch her, make for open sea!’

So Eurylochus urged, and shipmates cheered.

320Then I knew some power was brewing trouble for us,

so I let fly with an anxious plea: ‘Eurylochus,

I’m one against all—the upper hand is yours.

But swear me a binding oath, all here, that if

we come on a herd of cattle or fine flock of sheep,

not one man among us—blind in his reckless ways—

will slaughter an ox or ram. Just eat in peace,

content with the food immortal Circe gave us.’

They quickly swore the oath that I required

and once they had vowed they’d never harm the herds,

330they moored our sturdy ship in the deep narrow harbor,

close to a fresh spring, and all hands disembarked

and adeptly set about the evening meal.

Once they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

they recalled our dear companions, wept for the men

that Scylla plucked from the hollow ship and ate alive,

and a welcome sleep came on them in their tears.

But then,

337at the night’s third watch, the stars just wheeling down,

Zeus who marshals the stormclouds loosed a ripping wind,

a howling, demonic gale, shrouding over in thunderheads

340the earth and sea at once—and night swept down from the sky.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

we hauled our craft ashore, securing her in a vaulted cave

where nymphs have lovely dancing-rings and hold their sessions.

There I called a muster, warning my shipmates yet again,

‘Friends, we’ve food and drink aplenty aboard the ship—

keep your hands off all these herds or we will pay the price!

The cattle, the sleek flocks, belong to an awesome master,

Helios, god of the sun who sees all, hears all things.’

So I warned, and my headstrong men complied.

350But for one whole month the South Wind blew nonstop,

no other wind came up, none but the South, Southeast.

As long as our food and ruddy wine held out, the crew,

eager to save their lives, kept hands off the herds.

But then, when supplies aboard had all run dry,

when the men turned to hunting, forced to range

for quarry with twisted hooks: for fish, birds,

anything they could lay their hands on—

hunger racked their bellies—I struck inland,

up the island, there to pray to the gods.

360If only one might show me some way home!

Crossing into the heartland, clear of the crew,

I rinsed my hands in a sheltered spot, a windbreak,

but soon as I’d prayed to all the gods who rule Olympus,

down on my eyes they poured a sweet, sound sleep…

as Eurylochus opened up his fatal plan to friends:

‘Listen to me, my comrades, brothers in hardship.

All ways of dying are hateful to us poor mortals,

true, but to die of hunger, starve to death—

that’s the worst of all. So up with you now,

370let’s drive off the pick of Helios’ sleek herds,

slaughter them to the gods who rule the skies up there.

If we ever make it home to Ithaca, native ground,

erect at once a glorious temple to the Sungod,

line the walls with hoards of dazzling gifts!

But if the Sun, inflamed for his longhorn cattle,

means to wreck our ship and the other gods pitch in—

I’d rather die at sea, with one deep gulp of death,

than die by inches on this desolate island here!’

So he urged, and shipmates cheered again.

380At once they drove off the Sungod’s finest cattle—

close at hand, not far from the blue-prowed ship they grazed,

those splendid beasts with their broad brows and curving horns.

Surrounding them in a ring, they lifted prayers to the gods,

384plucking fresh green leaves from a tall oak for the rite,

since white strewing-barley was long gone in the ship.

Once they’d prayed, slaughtered and skinned the cattle,

they cut the thighbones out, they wrapped them round in fat,

a double fold sliced clean and topped with strips of flesh.

And since they had no wine to anoint the glowing victims,

390they made libations with water, broiling all the innards,

and once they’d burned the bones and tasted the organs—

hacked the rest into pieces, piercing them with spits.

That moment soothing slumber fell from my eyes

and down I went to our ship at the water’s edge

but on my way, nearing the long beaked craft,

the smoky savor of roasts came floating up around me…

I groaned in anguish, crying out to the deathless gods:

‘Father Zeus! the rest of you blissful gods who never die—

you with your fatal sleep, you lulled me into disaster.

400Left on their own, look what a monstrous thing

my crew concocted!’

Quick as a flash

with her flaring robes Lampetie sped the news

to the Sun on high that we had killed his herds

and Helios burst out in rage to all the immortals:

‘Father Zeus! the rest of you blissful gods who never die—

punish them all, that crew of Laertes’ son Odysseus—

what an outrage! They, they killed my cattle,

the great joy of my heart… day in, day out,

when I climbed the starry skies and when I wheeled

410back down from the heights to touch the earth once more.

Unless they pay me back in blood for the butchery of my herds,

down I go to the House of Death and blaze among the dead!’

But Zeus who marshals the thunderheads insisted,

‘Sun, you keep on shining among the deathless gods

and mortal men across the good green earth.

And as for the guilty ones, why, soon enough

on the wine-dark sea I’ll hit their racing ship

with a white-hot bolt, I’ll tear it into splinters.’

—Or so I heard from the lovely nymph Calypso,

420who heard it herself, she said, from Hermes, god of guides.

As soon as I reached our ship at the water’s edge

I took the men to task, upbraiding each in turn,

but how to set things right? We couldn’t find a way.

The cattle were dead already…

and the gods soon showed us all some fateful signs—

the hides began to crawl, the meat, both raw and roasted,

bellowed out on the spits, and we heard a noise

like the moan of lowing oxen.

Yet six more days

my eager companions feasted on the cattle of the Sun,

430the pick of the herds they’d driven off, but then,

when Cronian Zeus brought on the seventh day,

the wind in its ceaseless raging dropped at last,

and stepping the mast at once, hoisting the white sail

we boarded ship and launched her, made for open sea.

But once we’d left that island in our wake—

no land at all in sight, nothing but sea and sky—

then Zeus the son of Cronus mounted a thunderhead

above our hollow ship and the deep went black beneath it.

Nor did the craft scud on much longer. All of a sudden

440killer-squalls attacked us, screaming out of the west,

a murderous blast shearing the two forestays off

so the mast toppled backward, its running tackle spilling

into the bilge. The mast itself went crashing into the stern,

it struck the helmsman’s head and crushed his skull to pulp

and down from his deck the man flipped like a diver—

his hardy life spirit left his bones behind.

Then, then in the same breath Zeus hit the craft

with a lightning-bolt and thunder. Round she spun,

reeling under the impact, filled with reeking brimstone,

450shipmates pitching out of her, bobbing round like seahawks

swept along by the whitecaps past the trim black hull—

and the god cut short their journey home forever.

But I went lurching along our battered hulk

till the sea-surge ripped the plankings from the keel

and the waves swirled it away, stripped bare, and snapped

the mast from the decks—but a backstay made of bull’s-hide

still held fast, and with this I lashed the mast and keel

together, made them one, riding my makeshift raft

as the wretched galewinds bore me on and on.

460At last the West Wind quit its wild rage

but the South came on at once to hound me even more,

making me double back my route toward cruel Charybdis.

All night long I was rushed back and then at break of day

I reached the crag of Scylla and dire Charybdis’ vortex

right when the dreadful whirlpool gulped the salt sea down.

But heaving myself aloft to clutch at the fig-tree’s height,

like a bat I clung to its trunk for dear life—not a chance

for a good firm foothold there, no clambering up it either,

the roots too far to reach, the boughs too high overhead,

470huge swaying branches that overshadowed Charybdis.

But I held on, dead set… waiting for her

to vomit my mast and keel back up again—

Oh how I ached for both! and back they came,

late but at last, at just the hour a judge at court,

who’s settled the countless suits of brash young claimants,

rises, the day’s work done, and turns home for supper—

that’s when the timbers reared back up from Charybdis.

I let go—I plunged with my hands and feet flailing,

crashing into the waves beside those great beams

480and scrambling aboard them fast

I rowed hard with my hands right through the straits…

And the father of men and gods did not let Scylla see me,

else I’d have died on the spot—no escape from death.

I drifted along nine days. On the tenth, at night,

the gods cast me up on Ogygia, Calypso’s island,

home of the dangerous nymph with glossy braids

who speaks with human voice, and she took me in,

she loved me… Why cover the same ground again?

Just yesterday, here at hall, I told you all the rest,

490you and your gracious wife. It goes against my grain

to repeat a tale told once, and told so clearly.”

BOOK THIRTEEN

Ithaca at Last

H
is tale was over now. The Phaeacians all fell silent, hushed,

2his story holding them spellbound down the shadowed halls

until Alcinous found the poise to say, “Odysseus,

now that you have come to my bronze-floored house,

my vaulted roofs, I know you won’t be driven

off your course, nothing can hold you back—

however much you’ve suffered, you’ll sail home.

Here, friends, here’s a command for one and all,

you who frequent my palace day and night and drink

10the shining wine of kings and enjoy the harper’s songs.

The robes and hammered gold and a haul of other gifts

you lords of our island council brought our guest—

all lie packed in his polished sea-chest now. Come,

each of us add a sumptuous tripod, add a cauldron!

Then recover our costs with levies on the people:

it’s hard to afford such bounty man by man.”

The king’s instructions met with warm applause

and home they went to sleep, each in his own house.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

20they hurried down to the ship with handsome bronze gifts,

and striding along the decks, the ardent King Alcinous

stowed them under the benches, shipshape, so nothing

could foul the crewmen tugging at their oars.

Then back the party went to Alcinous’ house

and shared a royal feast.

The majestic king

slaughtered an ox for them to Cronus’ mighty son,

Zeus of the thundercloud, whose power rules the world.

They burned the thighs and fell to the lordly banquet,

reveling there, while in their midst the inspired bard

30struck up a song, Demodocus, prized by all the people.

True, but time and again Odysseus turned his face

toward the radiant sun, anxious for it to set,

yearning now to be gone and home once more…

As a man aches for his evening meal when all day long

his brace of wine-dark oxen have dragged the bolted plowshare

down a fallow field—how welcome the setting sun to him,

the going home to supper, yes, though his knees buckle,

struggling home at last. So welcome now to Odysseus

the setting light of day, and he lost no time

40as he pressed Phaeacia’s men who love their oars,

addressing his host, Alcinous, first and foremost:

“Alcinous, majesty, shining among your island people,

make your libations, launch me safely on my way—

to one and all, farewell!

All is now made good, my heart’s desire,

your convoy home, your precious, loving gifts,

and may the gods of Olympus bless them for me!

May I find an unswerving wife when I reach home,

and loved ones hale, unharmed! And you, my friends

50remaining here in your kingdom now, may you delight

in your loyal wives and children! May the gods

rain down all kinds of fortune on your lives,

misfortune never harbor in your homeland!”

All burst into applause, urging passage home

for their parting guest, his farewell rang so true.

Hallowed King Alcinous briskly called his herald:

“Come, Pontonous! Mix the wine in the bowl,

pour rounds to all our banqueters in the house,

so we, with a prayer to mighty Zeus the Father,

60can sail our new friend home to native land.”

Pontonous mixed the heady, honeyed wine

and hovering closely, poured full rounds for all.

And from where they sat they tipped libations out

to the happy gods who rule the vaulting skies.

Then King Odysseus rose up from his seat

and placing his two-eared cup in Arete’s hands,

addressed the queen with parting wishes on the wing:

“Your health, my queen, through all your days to come—

until old age and death, that visit all mankind,

70pay you a visit too. Now I am on my way

but you, may you take joy in this house of yours,

in your children, your people, in Alcinous the king!”

With that the great Odysseus strode across the threshold.

And King Alcinous sent the herald off with the guest

to lead him down to the swift ship and foaming surf.

And Arete sent her serving-women, one to carry

a sea-cloak, washed and fresh, a shirt as well,

another assigned to bear the sturdy chest

and a third to take the bread and ruddy wine.

80When they reached the ship at the water’s edge

the royal escorts took charge of the gifts at once

and stores of food and wine, stowed them deep in the holds,

and then for their guest they spread out rug and sheets

on the half-deck, clear astern on the ship’s hull

so he might sleep there soundly, undisturbed.

And last, Odysseus climbed aboard himself

and down he lay, all quiet

as crewmen sat to the oarlocks, each in line.

They slipped the cable free of the drilled stone post

90and soon as they swung back and the blades tossed up the spray

an irresistible sleep fell deeply on his eyes, the sweetest,

soundest oblivion, still as the sleep of death itself…

And the ship like a four-horse team careering down the plain,

all breaking as one with the whiplash cracking smartly,

leaping with hoofs high to run the course in no time—

so the stern hove high and plunged with the seething rollers

crashing dark in her wake as on she surged unwavering,

never flagging, no, not even a darting hawk,

the quickest thing on wings, could keep her pace

100as on she ran, cutting the swells at top speed,

bearing a man endowed with the gods’ own wisdom,

one who had suffered twenty years of torment, sick at heart,

cleaving his way through wars of men and pounding waves at sea

but now he slept in peace, the memory of his struggles

laid to rest.

And then, that hour the star rose up,

the clearest, brightest star, that always heralds

the newborn light of day, the deep-sea-going ship

made landfall on the island… Ithaca, at last.

There on the coast a haven lies, named for Phorcys,

110the old god of the deep—with two jutting headlands,

sheared off at the seaward side but shelving toward the bay,

that break the great waves whipped by the gales outside

so within the harbor ships can ride unmoored

whenever they come in mooring range of shore.

At the harbor’s head a branching olive stands

with a welcome cave nearby it, dank with sea-mist,

117sacred to nymphs of the springs we call the Naiads.

There are mixing-bowls inside and double-handled jars,

crafted of stone, and bees store up their honey in the hollows.

120There are long stone looms as well, where the nymphs weave out

their webs from clouds of sea-blue wool—a marvelous sight—

and a wellspring flows forever. The cave has two ways in,

one facing the North Wind, a pathway down for mortals;

the other, facing the South, belongs to the gods,

no man may go that way…

it is the path for all the deathless powers.

Here at this bay the Phaeacian crew put in—

they’d known it long before—driving the ship so hard

she ran up onto the beach for a good half her length,

130such way the oarsmen’s brawny arms had made.

Up from the benches, swinging down to land,

first they lifted Odysseus off the decks—

linen and lustrous carpet too—and laid him

down on the sand asleep, still dead to the world,

then hoisted out the treasures proud Phaeacians,

urged by open-hearted Pallas, had lavished on him,

setting out for home. They heaped them all

by the olive’s trunk, in a neat pile, clear

of the road for fear some passerby might spot

140and steal Odysseus’ hoard before he could awaken.

Then pushing off, they pulled for home themselves.

But now Poseidon, god of the earthquake, never once

forgetting the first threats he leveled at the hero,

probed almighty Zeus to learn his plans in full:

“Zeus, Father, I will lose all my honor now

145among the immortals, now there are mortal men

who show me no respect—Phaeacians, too,

born of my own loins! I said myself

that Odysseus would suffer long and hard

150before he made it home, but I never dreamed

of blocking his return, not absolutely at least,

once you had pledged your word and bowed your head.

But now they’ve swept him across the sea in their swift ship,

they’ve set him down in Ithaca, sound asleep, and loaded the man

with boundless gifts—bronze and hoards of gold and robes—

aye, more plunder than he could ever have won from Troy

if Odysseus had returned intact with his fair share!”

“Incredible,” Zeus who marshals the thunderheads replied.

“Earth-shaker, you with your massive power, why moaning so?

160The gods don’t disrespect you. What a stir there’d be

if they flung abuse at the oldest, noblest of them all.

162Those mortals? If any man, so lost in his strength

and prowess, pays you no respect—just pay him back.

The power is always yours.

Do what you like. Whatever warms your heart.”

“King of the dark cloud,” the earthquake god agreed,

“I’d like to avenge myself at once, as you advise,

but I’ve always feared your wrath and shied away.

But now I’ll crush that fine Phaeacian cutter

170out on the misty sea, now on her homeward run

171from the latest convoy. They will learn at last

to cease and desist from escorting every man alive—

I’ll pile a huge mountain round about their port!”

“Wait, dear brother,” Zeus who collects the clouds

had second thoughts. “Here’s what seems best to me.

As the people all lean down from the city heights

to watch her speeding home, strike her into a rock

that looks like a racing vessel, just offshore—

amaze all men with a marvel for the ages.

180Then pile your huge mountain round about their port.”

Hearing that from Zeus, the god of the earthquake

sped to Scheria now, the Phaeacians’ island home,

and waited there till the ship came sweeping in,

scudding lightly along—and surging close abreast,

the earthquake god with one flat stroke of his hand

struck her to stone, rooted her to the ocean floor

and made for open sea.

The Phaeacians, aghast,

those lords of the long oars, the master mariners

traded startled glances, sudden outcries:

190“Look—who’s pinned our swift ship to the sea?”

“Just racing for home!”

“Just hove into plain view!”

They might well wonder, blind to what had happened,

till Alcinous rose and made things all too clear:

“Oh no—my father’s prophecy years ago…

it all comes home to me with a vengeance now!

He used to say Poseidon was vexed with us because

we escorted all mankind and never came to grief.

He said that one day, as a well-built ship of ours

sailed home on the misty sea from such a convoy,

200the god would crush it, yes,

and pile a huge mountain round about our port.

So the old king foretold. Now, look, it all comes true!

Hurry, friends, do as I say, let us all comply:

stop our convoys home for every castaway

chancing on our city! As for Poseidon,

sacrifice twelve bulls to the god at once—

the pick of the herds. Perhaps he’ll pity us,

pile no looming mountain ridge around our port.”

The people, terrified, prepared the bulls at once.

210So all of Phaeacia’s island lords and captains,

milling round the altar, lifted prayers

to Poseidon, master of the sea…

That very moment

great Odysseus woke from sleep on native ground at last—

he’d been away for years—but failed to know the land

for the goddess Pallas Athena, Zeus’s daughter,

showered mist over all, so under cover

she might change his appearance head to foot

as she told him every peril he’d meet at home—

keep him from being known by wife, townsmen, friends,

220till the suitors paid the price for all their outrage.

And so to the king himself all Ithaca looked strange…

the winding beaten paths, the coves where ships can ride,

the steep rock face of the cliffs and the tall leafy trees.

He sprang to his feet and, scanning his own native country,

groaned, slapped his thighs with his flat palms

and Odysseus cried in anguish:

227“Man of misery, whose land have I lit on now?

What are they here—violent, savage, lawless?

or friendly to strangers, god-fearing men?

230Where can I take this heap of treasure now

and where in the world do I wander off myself?

If only the trove had stayed among the Phaeacians there

and I had made my way to some other mighty king

who would have hosted me well and sent me home!

But now I don’t know where to stow all this,

and I can’t leave it here, inviting any bandit

to rob me blind.

So damn those lords and captains,

those Phaeacians! Not entirely honest or upright, were they?

Sweeping me off to this, this no-man’s-land, and they,

240they swore they’d sail me home to sunny Ithaca—well,

241they never kept their word. Zeus of the Suppliants

pay them back—he keeps an eye on the world of men

and punishes all transgressors!

Come, quickly,

I’ll inspect my treasure and count it up myself.

Did they make off with anything in their ship?”

With that he counted up the gorgeous tripods,

cauldrons, bars of gold and the lovely woven robes.

Not a stitch was missing from the lot. But still

he wept for his native country, trailing down the shore

250where the wash of sea on shingle ebbs and flows,

his homesick heart in turmoil.

But now Athena appeared and came toward him.

She looked like a young man… a shepherd boy

yet elegant too, with all the gifts that grace the sons of kings,

with a well-cut cloak falling in folds across her shoulders,

sandals under her shining feet, a hunting spear in hand.

Odysseus, overjoyed at the sight, went up to meet her,

joining her now with salutations on the wing:

“Greetings, friend! Since you are the first

260I’ve come on in this harbor, treat me kindly—

no cruelty, please. Save these treasures,

save me too. I pray to you like a god,

I fall before your knees and ask your mercy!

And tell me this for a fact—I need to know—

where on earth am I? what land? who lives here?

Is it one of the sunny islands or some jutting shore

of the good green mainland slanting down to sea?”

Athena answered, her eyes brightening now,

“You must be a fool, stranger, or come from nowhere,

270if you really have to ask what land this is.

Trust me, it’s not so nameless after all.

It’s known the world around,

to all who live to the east and rising sun

and to all who face the western mists and darkness.

It’s a rugged land, too cramped for driving horses,

but though it’s far from broad, it’s hardly poor.

There’s plenty of grain for bread, grapes for wine,

the rains never fail and the dewfall’s healthy.

Good country for goats, good for cattle too—

280there’s stand on stand of timber

and water runs in streambeds through the year.

So,

stranger, the name of Ithaca’s reached as far as Troy,

and Troy, they say, is a long hard sail from Greece.”

Ithaca… Heart racing, Odysseus that great exile

filled with joy to hear Athena, daughter of storming Zeus,

pronounce that name. He stood on native ground at last

and he replied with a winging word to Pallas,

not with a word of truth—he choked it back,

always invoking the cunning in his heart:

290“Ithaca… yes, I seem to have heard of Ithaca,

even on Crete’s broad island far across the sea,

and now I’ve reached it myself, with all this loot,

but I left behind an equal measure for my children.

294I’m a fugitive now, you see. I killed Idomeneus’ son,

295Orsilochus, lightning on his legs, a man who beat

all runners alive on that long island—what a racer!

He tried to rob me of all the spoil I’d won at Troy,

the plunder I went to hell and back to capture, true,

cleaving my way through wars of men and waves at sea—

300and just because I refused to please his father,

serve under him at Troy. I led my own command.

So now with a friend I lay in wait by the road,

I killed him just loping in from the fields—

with one quick stroke of my bronze spear

in the dead of night, the heavens pitch-black…

no one could see us, spot me tearing out his life

with a weapon honed for action. Once I’d cut him down

308I made for a ship and begged the Phoenician crew for mercy,

paying those decent hands a hearty share of plunder—

310asked them to take me on and land me down in Pylos,

311there or lovely Elis, where Epeans rule in power.

But a heavy galewind blew them way off course,

much against their will—

they’d no desire to cheat me. Driven afar,

we reached this island here at the midnight hour,

rowing for dear life, we made it into your harbor—

not a thought of supper, much as we all craved food,

we dropped from the decks and lay down, just like that!

A welcome sleep came over my weary bones at once,

320while the crew hoisted up my loot from the holds

and set it down on the sand near where I slept.

322They reembarked, now homeward bound for Sidon,

their own noble city, leaving me here behind,

homesick in my heart…”

As his story ended,

goddess Athena, gray eyes gleaming, broke into a smile

and stroked him with her hand, and now she appeared a woman,

beautiful, tall and skilled at weaving lovely things.

Her words went flying straight toward Odysseus:

“Any man—any god who met you—would have to be

330some champion lying cheat to get past you

for all-round craft and guile! You terrible man,

foxy, ingenious, never tired of twists and tricks—

so, not even here, on native soil, would you give up

those wily tales that warm the cockles of your heart!

Come, enough of this now. We’re both old hands

at the arts of intrigue. Here among mortal men

you’re far the best at tactics, spinning yarns,

and I am famous among the gods for wisdom,

cunning wiles, too.

340Ah, but you never recognized me, did you?

Pallas Athena, daughter of Zeus—who always

stands beside you, shields you in every exploit:

thanks to me the Phaeacians all embraced you warmly.

And now I am here once more, to weave a scheme with you

and to hide the treasure-trove Phaeacia’s nobles

lavished on you then—I willed it, planned it so

when you set out for home—and to tell you all

the trials you must suffer in your palace…

Endure them all. You must. You have no choice.

350And to no one—no man, no woman, not a soul—

reveal that you are the wanderer home at last.

No, in silence you must bear a world of pain,

subject yourself to the cruel abuse of men.”

“Ah goddess,” the cool tactician countered,

“you’re so hard for a mortal man to know on sight,

however shrewd he is—the shapes you take are endless!

But I do know this: you were kind to me in the war years,

so long as we men of Achaea soldiered on at Troy.

But once we’d sacked King Priam’s craggy city,

360boarded ship, and a god dispersed the fleet,

361from then on, daughter of Zeus, I never saw you,

never glimpsed you striding along my decks

to ward off some disaster. No, I wandered on,

my heart forever torn to pieces inside my chest

till the gods released me from my miseries at last,

that day in the fertile kingdom of Phaeacia when

you cheered me with words, in person, led me to their city.

But now I beg you by your almighty Father’s name…

for I can’t believe I’ve reached my sunny Ithaca,

370I must be roaming around one more exotic land—

you’re mocking me, I know it, telling me tales

to make me lose my way. Tell me the truth now,

have I really reached the land I love?”

“Always the same, your wary turn of mind,”

Athena exclaimed, her glances flashing warmly.

“That’s why I can’t forsake you in your troubles—

you are so winning, so worldly-wise, so self-possessed!

Anyone else, come back from wandering long and hard,

would have hurried home at once, delighted to see

380his children and his wife. Oh, but not you,

it’s not your pleasure to probe for news of them—

you must put your wife to the proof yourself!

But she, she waits in your halls, as always,

her life an endless hardship…

wasting away the nights, weeping away the days.

I never had doubts myself, no, I knew down deep

that you would return at last, with all your shipmates lost.

388But I could not bring myself to fight my Father’s brother,

Poseidon, quaking with anger at you, still enraged

390because you blinded the Cyclops, his dear son.

But come, let me show you Ithaca’s setting,

I’ll convince you. This haven—look around—

it’s named for Phorcys, the old god of the deep,

and here at the harbor’s head the branching olive stands

with the welcome cave nearby it, dank with sea-mist,

sacred to nymphs of the springs we call the Naiads.

Here, under its arching vault, time and again

you’d offer the nymphs a generous sacrifice

to bring success! And the slopes above you, look,

Mount Neriton decked in forests!”

400At those words

the goddess scattered the mist and the country stood out clear

and the great man who had borne so much rejoiced at last,

thrilled to see his Ithaca—he kissed the good green earth

and raised his hands to the nymphs and prayed at once,

“Nymphs of the springs, Naiads, daughters of Zeus,

I never dreamed I would see you yet again…

Now rejoice in my loving prayers—and later,

just like the old days, I will give you gifts

if Athena, Zeus’s daughter, Queen of Armies

410comes to my rescue, grants this fighter life

and brings my son to manhood!”

“Courage!”—

goddess Athena answered, eyes afire—

“Free your mind of all that anguish now.

Come, quick, let’s bury your treasures here

in some recess of this haunted hallowed cave

where they’ll be safe and sound,

then we’ll make plans so we can win the day.”

With that

the goddess swept into the cavern’s shadowed vault,

searching for hiding-places far inside its depths

420while Odysseus hauled his treasures closer up,

the gold, durable bronze and finespun robes,

the Phaeacians’ parting gifts.

Once he’d stowed them well away, the goddess,

Pallas Athena, daughter of storming Zeus,

sealed the mouth of the cavern with a stone.

Then down they sat by the sacred olive’s trunk

to plot the death of the high and mighty suitors.

The bright-eyed goddess Athena led the way:

“Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, old campaigner,

430think how to lay your hands on all those brazen suitors,

lording it over your house now, three whole years,

courting your noble wife, offering gifts to win her.

But she, forever broken-hearted for your return,

builds up each man’s hopes—

dangling promises, dropping hints to each—

but all the while with something else in mind.”

“God help me!” the man of intrigue broke out:

“Clearly I might have died the same ignoble death

as Agamemnon, bled white in my own house too,

440if you had never revealed this to me now,

goddess, point by point.

Come, weave us a scheme so I can pay them back!

Stand beside me, Athena, fire me with daring, fierce

as the day we ripped Troy’s glittering crown of towers down.

Stand by me—furious now as then, my bright-eyed one—

and I would fight three hundred men, great goddess,

with you to brace me, comrade-in-arms in battle!”

Gray eyes ablaze, the goddess urged him on:

“Surely I’ll stand beside you, not forget you,

450not when the day arrives for us to do our work.

Those men who court your wife and waste your goods?

I have a feeling some will splatter your ample floors

with all their blood and brains. Up now, quickly.

First I will transform you—no one must know you.

I will shrivel the supple skin on your lithe limbs,

strip the russet curls from your head and deck you out

in rags you’d hate to see some other mortal wear;

I’ll dim the fire in your eyes, so shining once—

until you seem appalling to all those suitors,

460even your wife and son you left behind at home.

But you, you make your way to the swineherd first,

in charge of your pigs, and true to you as always,

loyal friend to your son, to Penelope, so self-possessed.

You’ll find him posted beside his swine, grubbing round

465by Raven’s Rock and the spring called Arethusa,

rooting for feed that makes pigs sleek and fat,

the nuts they love, the dark pools they drink.

Wait there, sit with him, ask him all he knows.

I’m off to Sparta, where the women are a wonder,

470to call Telemachus home, your own dear son, Odysseus.

He’s journeyed to Lacedaemon’s rolling hills

to see Menelaus, searching for news of you,

hoping to learn if you are still alive.”

Shrewd Odysseus answered her at once:

“Why not tell him the truth? You know it all.

Or is he too—like father, like son—condemned

to hardship, roving over the barren salt sea

while strangers devour our livelihood right here?”

But the bright-eyed goddess reassured him firmly:

480“No need for anguish, trust me, not for him—

I escorted your son myself

so he might make his name by sailing there.

Nor is he saddled down with any troubles now.

He sits at ease in the halls of Menelaus,

bathed in endless bounty… True enough,

some young lords in a black cutter lurk in ambush,

poised to kill the prince before he reaches home,

but I have my doubts they will. Sooner the earth

will swallow down a few of those young gallants

490who eat you out of house and home these days!”

No more words, not now—

Athena stroked Odysseus with her wand.

She shriveled the supple skin on his lithe limbs,

stripped the russet curls from his head, covered his body

top to toe with the wrinkled hide of an old man

and dimmed the fire in his eyes, so shining once.

She turned his shirt and cloak into squalid rags,

ripped and filthy, smeared with grime and soot.

She flung over this the long pelt of a bounding deer,

500rubbed bare, and gave him a staff and beggar’s sack,

torn and tattered, slung from a fraying rope.

All plans made,

they went their separate ways—Athena setting off

to bring Telemachus home from hallowed Lacedaemon.

BOOK FOURTEEN

The Loyal Swineherd

S
o up from the haven now Odysseus climbed a rugged path

through timber along high ground—Athena had shown the way—

to reach the swineherd’s place, that fine loyal man

who of all the household hands Odysseus ever had

cared the most for his master’s worldly goods.

Sitting at the door of his lodge he found him,

there in his farmstead, high-walled, broad and large,

with its long view on its cleared rise of ground…

The swineherd made those walls with his own hands

10to enclose the pigs of his master gone for years.

Alone, apart from his queen or old Laertes,

he’d built them up of quarried blocks of stone

and coped them well with a fence of wild pear.

Outside he’d driven stakes in a long-line stockade,

a ring of thickset palings split from an oak’s dark heart.

Within the yard he’d built twelve sties, side-by-side,

to bed his pigs, and in each one fifty brood-sows

slept aground, penned and kept for breeding.

The boars slept outside, but far fewer of them,

20thanks to the lordly suitors’ feasts that kept on

thinning the herd and kept the swineherd stepping,

sending to town each day the best fat hog in sight.

By now they were down to three hundred and sixty head.

But guarding them all the time were dogs like savage beasts,

a pack of four, reared by the swineherd, foreman of men.

The man himself was fitting sandals to his feet,

carving away at an oxhide, dark and supple.

As for his men, three were off with their pigs,

herding them here or there. Under orders he’d sent

30a fourth to town, with hog in tow for the gorging suitors

to slaughter off and glut themselves with pork.

Suddenly—those snarling dogs spotted Odysseus,

charged him fast—a shatter of barks—but Odysseus

sank to the ground at once, he knew the trick:

the staff dropped from his hand but here and now,

on his own farm, he might have taken a shameful mauling.

Yes, but the swineherd, quick to move, dashed for the gate,

flinging his oxhide down, rushed the dogs with curses,

scattered them left and right with flying rocks

40and warned his master, “Lucky to be alive, old man—

a moment more, my pack would have torn you limb from limb!

Then you’d have covered me with shame. As if the gods

had never given me blows and groans aplenty…

Here I sit, my heart aching, broken for him,

my master, my great king—fattening up

his own hogs for other men to eat, while he,

starving for food, I wager, wanders the earth,

a beggar adrift in strangers’ cities, foreign-speaking lands,

if he’s still alive, that is, still sees the rising sun.

50Come, follow me into my place, old man, so you,

at least, can eat your fill of bread and wine.

Then you can tell me where you’re from

and all the pains you’ve weathered.”

On that note

the loyal swineherd led the way to his shelter,

55showed his guest inside and sat Odysseus down

on brush and twigs he piled up for the visitor,

flinging over these the skin of a shaggy wild goat,

broad and soft, the swineherd’s own good bedding.

The king, delighted to be so well received,

60thanked the man at once: “My host—may Zeus

and the other gods give you your heart’s desire

for the royal welcome you have shown me here!”

63And you replied, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“It’s wrong, my friend, to send any stranger packing—

even one who arrives in worse shape than you.

Every stranger and beggar comes from Zeus

and whatever scrap they get from the likes of us,

they’ll find it welcome. That’s the best we can do,

we servants, always cowed by our high and mighty masters,

70especially our young lords… But my old king?

The gods, they must have blocked his journey home.

He’d have treated me well, he would, with a house,

a plot of land and a wife you’d gladly prize.

Goods that a kind lord will give a household hand

who labors for him, hard, whose work the gods have sped,

just as they speed the work I labor at all day.

My master, I tell you, would have repaid me well

if he’d grown old right here. But now he’s dead…

If only Helen and all her kind had died out too,

80brought to her knees, just as she cut the legs

from under troops of men! My king among them,

he went off to the stallion-land of Troy

to fight the Trojans, save Agamemnon’s honor!”

Enough—

he brusquely cinched his belt around his shirt,

strode out to the pens, crammed with droves of pigs,

picked out two, bundled them in and slaughtered both,

singed them, sliced them down, skewered them through

and roasting all to a turn, set them before Odysseus,

sizzling hot on the spits.

90Then coating the meat with white barley groats

and mixing honeyed wine in a carved wooden bowl,

he sat down across from his guest, inviting warmly,

“Eat up now, my friend. It’s all we slaves have got,

scrawny pork, while the suitors eat the fatted hogs—

no fear of the gods in their hard hearts, no mercy!

Trust me, the blessed gods have no love for crime.

They honor justice, honor the decent acts of men.

Even cutthroat bandits who raid foreign parts—

and Zeus grants them a healthy share of plunder,

100ships filled to the brim, and back they head for home—

even their dark hearts are stalked by the dread of vengeance.

But the suitors know, they’ve caught some godsent rumor

of master’s grisly death! That’s why they have no mind

to do their courting fairly or go back home in peace.

No, at their royal ease they devour all his goods,

those brazen rascals never spare a scrap!

Not a day or a night goes by, sent down by Zeus,

but they butcher victims, never stopping at one or two,

and drain his wine as if there’s no tomorrow—

110swilling the last drop…

Believe me, my master’s wealth was vast!

No other prince on earth could match his riches,

not on the loamy mainland or here at home in Ithaca—

no twenty men in the world could equal his great treasures!

Let me count them off for you. A dozen herds of cattle

back on the mainland, just as many head of sheep,

as many droves of pigs and goatflocks ranging free;

hired hands or his own herdsmen keep them grazing there.

Here in Ithaca, goatflocks, eleven in all, scatter

120to graze the island, out at the wild end,

and trusty goatherds watch their every move.

And each herdsman, day after day, it never ends,

drives in a beast for the suitors—best in sight,

a sheep or well-fed goat. While I tend to these pigs,

I guard them, pick the best for those carousers

and send it to the slaughter!”

His voice rose

while the stranger ate his meat and drank his wine,

ravenous, bolting it all down in silence…

brooding on ways to serve the suitors right.

130But once he’d supped and refreshed himself with food,

he filled the wooden bowl he’d been drinking from,

brimmed it with wine and passed it to his host

who received the offer gladly, spirit cheered

as the stranger probed him now with winging words:

“Friend, who was the man who bought you with his goods,

the master of such vast riches, powerful as you say?

You tell me he died defending Agamemnon’s honor?

What’s his name? I just might know such a man…

Zeus would know, and the other deathless gods,

140if I ever saw him, if I bring you any news.

I’ve roamed the whole earth over.”

And the good swineherd answered, foreman of men,

“Old friend, no wanderer landing here with news of him

is likely to win his wife and dear son over.

Random drifters, hungry for bed and board,

lie through their teeth and swallow back the truth.

Why, any tramp washed up on Ithaca’s shores

scurries right to my mistress, babbling lies,

and she ushers him in, kindly, pressing for details,

150and the warm tears of grief come trickling down her cheeks,

the loyal wife’s way when her husband’s died abroad.

Even you, old codger, could rig up some fine tale—

and soon enough, I’d say,

if they gave you shirt and clothing for your pains.

My master? Well, no doubt the dogs and wheeling birds

have ripped the skin from his ribs by now, his life is through—

or fish have picked him clean at sea, and the man’s bones

lie piled up on the mainland, buried deep in sand…

he’s dead and gone. Aye, leaving a broken heart

160for loved ones left behind, for me most of all.

Never another master kind as he!

I’ll never find one—no matter where I go,

not even if I went back to mother and father,

the house where I was born and my parents reared me once.

Ah, but much as I grieve for them, much as I long

to lay my eyes on them, set foot on the old soil,

it’s longing for him, him that wrings my heart—

Odysseus, lost and gone!

That man, old friend, far away as he is…

170I can scarcely bear to say his name aloud,

so deeply he loved me, cared for me, so deeply.

Worlds away as he is, I call him Master, Brother!”

“My friend,” the great Odysseus, long in exile, answered,

“since you are dead certain, since you still insist

he’s never coming back, still the soul of denial,

I won’t simply say it—on my oath I swear

Odysseus is on his way!

Reward for such good news? Let me have it

the moment he sets foot in his own house,

180dress me in shirt and cloak, in handsome clothes.

Before then, poor as I am, I wouldn’t take a thing.

182I hate that man like the very Gates of Death who,

ground down by poverty, stoops to peddling lies.

I swear by Zeus, the first of all the gods,

by this table of hospitality here, my host,

by Odysseus’ hearth where I have come for help:

all will come to pass, I swear, exactly as I say.

True, this very month—just as the old moon dies

and the new moon rises into life—Odysseus will return!

190He will come home and take revenge on any man

who offends his wedded wife and princely son!”

“Good news,” you replied, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“but I will never pay a reward for that, old friend—

Odysseus, he’ll never come home again. Never…

Drink your wine, sit back, let’s talk of other things.

Don’t remind me of all this. The heart inside me

breaks when anyone mentions my dear master.

That oath of yours, we’ll let it pass—

Odysseus,

oh come back!—

just as I wish, I and Penelope,

200old Laertes too, Telemachus too, the godlike boy.

How I grieve for him now, I can’t stop—Odysseus’ son,

Telemachus. The gods reared him up like a fine young tree

and I often said, ‘In the ranks of men he’ll match his father,

his own dear father—amazing in build and looks, that boy!’

But all of a sudden a god wrecks his sense of balance—

god or man, no matter—off he’s gone to catch

some news of his father, down to holy Pylos.

And now those gallant suitors lie in wait for him,

sailing home, to tear the royal line of Arcesius

210out of Ithaca, root and branch, good name and all!

Enough. Let him pass too—whether he’s trapped

or the hand of Zeus will pull him through alive.

Come,

old soldier, tell me the story of your troubles,

tell me truly, too, I’d like to know it well…

Who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?

What sort of vessel brought you? Why did the sailors

land you here in Ithaca? Who did they say they are?

I hardly think you came this way on foot.”

The great teller of tales returned at length,

220“My story—the whole truth—I’m glad to tell it all.

If only the two of us had food and mellow wine

to last us long, here in your shelter now,

for us to sup on, undisturbed,

while others take the work of the world in hand,

I could easily spend all year and never reach the end

of my endless story, all the heartbreaking trials

I struggled through. The gods willed it so…

I hail from Crete’s broad land, I’m proud to say,

and I am a rich man’s son. And many other sons

230he brought up in his palace, born in wedlock,

sprung of his lawful wife. Unlike my mother.

She was a slave, a concubine he’d purchased, yes,

but he treated me on a par with all his true-born sons—

234Castor, Hylax’ son. I’m proud to boast his blood, that man

revered like a god throughout all Crete those days,

for wealth, power and all his glorious offspring.

But the deadly spirits soon swept him down

to the House of Death, and his high and mighty sons

carved up his lands and then cast lots for the parts

240and gave me just a pittance, a paltry house as well.

But I won myself a wife from wealthy, landed people,

thanks to my own strong points. I was no fool

and never shirked a fight.

But now my heyday’s gone—

I’ve had my share of blows. Yet look hard at the husk

and you’ll still see, I think, the grain that gave it life.

By heaven, Ares gave me courage, Athena too, to break

the ranks of men wide open, once, in the old days,

whenever I picked my troops and formed an ambush,

plotting attacks to spring against our foes—

250no hint of death could daunt my fighting spirit!

Far out of the front I’d charge and spear my man,

I’d cut down any enemy soldier backing off.

Such was I in battle, true, but I had no love

for working the land, the chores of households either,

the labor that raises crops of shining children. No,

it was always oarswept ships that thrilled my heart,

and wars, and the long polished spears and arrows,

dreadful gear that makes the next man cringe.

I loved them all—god planted that love inside me.

260Each man delights in the work that suits him best.

Why, long before we Achaeans ever camped at Troy,

nine commands I led in our deep-sea-going ships,

raiding foreign men, and a fine haul reached my hands.

I helped myself to the lion’s share and still more spoils

came by lot. And my house grew by leaps and bounds,

266I walked among the Cretans, honored, feared as well.

But then, when thundering Zeus contrived that expedition—

that disaster that brought so many fighters to their knees—

269and men kept pressing me and renowned Idomeneus

270to head a fleet to Troy,

there was no way out, no denying them then,

the voice of the people bore down much too hard.

So nine whole years we Achaeans soldiered on at Troy,

in the tenth we sacked King Priam’s city, then embarked

for home in the long ships, and a god dispersed the fleet.

Unlucky me. Shrewd old Zeus was plotting still more pain.

No more than a month I stayed at home, taking joy

in my children, loyal wife and lovely plunder.

But a spirit in me urged, ‘Set sail for Egypt—

280fit out ships, take crews of seasoned heroes!’

Nine I fitted out, the men joined up at once

and then six days my shipmates feasted well,

while I provided a flock of sheep to offer up

to the gods and keep the feasters’ table groaning.

On the seventh we launched out from the plains of Crete

with a stiff North Wind fair astern—smooth sailing,

aye, like coasting on downstream…

And not one craft in our squadron foundered;

all shipshape, and all hands sound, we sat back

290while the wind and helmsmen kept us true on course.

Five days out and we raised the great river Nile

and there in the Nile delta moored our ships of war.

God knows I ordered my trusty crews to stand by,

just where they were, and guard the anchored fleet

and I sent a patrol to scout things out from higher ground.

But swept away by their own reckless fury, the crew went berserk—

they promptly began to plunder the lush Egyptian farms,

dragged off the women and children, killed the men.

Outcries reached the city in no time—stirred by shouts

300the entire town came streaming down at the break of day,

filling the river plain with chariots, ranks of infantry

and the gleam of bronze. Zeus who loves the lightning

flung down murderous panic on all my men-at-arms—

no one dared to stand his ground and fight,

disaster ringed us round from every quarter.

Droves of my men they hacked down with swords,

led off the rest alive, to labor for them as slaves.

And I? Zeus flashed an inspiration through my mind,

though I wish I’d died a soldier down in Egypt then!

310A world of pain, you see, still lay in wait for me…

Quickly I wrenched the skullcap helmet off my head,

I tore the shield from my back and dropped my spear

and ran right into the path of the king’s chariot,

hugged and kissed his knees. He pitied me, spared me,

hoisted me onto his war-car, took me home in tears.

Troops of his men came rushing after, shaking javelins,

mad to kill me—their fighting blood at the boil—

but their master drove them off.

He feared the wrath of Zeus, the god of guests,

the first of the gods to pay back acts of outrage.

320So,

there I lingered for seven years, amassing a fortune

from all the Egyptian people loading me with gifts.

Then, at last, when the eighth had come full turn,

along comes this Phoenician one fine day…

a scoundrel, swindler, an old hand at lies

who’d already done the world a lot of damage.

Well, he smoothly talked me round and off we sailed,

Phoenicia-bound, where his house and holdings lay.

There in his care I stayed till the year was out.

330Then, when the months and days had run their course

and the year wheeled round and the seasons came again,

he conned me aboard his freighter bound for Libya,

pretending I’d help him ship a cargo there for sale

but in fact he’d sell me there and make a killing!

I suspected as much, of course, but had no choice,

so I boarded with him, yes, and the ship ran on

with a good strong North Wind gusting—

fast on the middle passage clear of Crete—

but Zeus was brewing mischief for that crew…

340Once we’d left the island in our wake—

no land at all in sight, nothing but sea and sky—

then Zeus the son of Cronus mounted a thunderhead

above our hollow ship and the deep went black beneath it.

Then, then in the same breath Zeus hit the craft

with a lightning-bolt and thunder. Round she spun,

reeling under the impact, filled with reeking brimstone,

shipmates pitching out of her, bobbing round like seahawks

swept along by the breakers past the trim black hull—

and the god cut short their journey home forever.

Not mine.

350Zeus himself—when I was just at the final gasp—

thrust the huge mast of my dark-prowed vessel

right into my arms so I might flee disaster

one more time. Wrapping myself around it,

I was borne along by the wretched galewinds,

rushed along nine days—on the tenth, at dead of night,

356a shouldering breaker rolled me up along Thesprotia’s beaches.

357There the king of Thesprotia, Phidon, my salvation,

treated me kindly, asked for no reward at all.

His own good son had found me, half-dead

360from exhaustion and the cold. He raised me up

by the hand and led me home to his father’s house

and dressed me in cloak and shirt and decent clothes.

That’s where I first got wind of him—Odysseus…

The king told me he’d hosted the man in style,

befriended him on his way home to native land,

and showed me all the treasure Odysseus had amassed.

Bronze and gold and plenty of hard wrought iron,

enough to last a man and ten generations of his heirs—

so great the wealth stored up for him in the king’s vaults!

370But Odysseus, he made clear, was off at Dodona then

to hear the will of Zeus that rustles forth

from the god’s tall leafy oak: how should he return,

after all the years away, to his own green land of Ithaca—

openly or in secret? Phidon swore to me, what’s more,

as the princely man poured out libations in his house,

‘The ship’s hauled down and the crew set to sail,

to take Odysseus home to native land.’

But I…

he shipped me off before. A Thesprotian cutter

chanced to be heading for Dulichion rich in wheat,

380so he told the crew to take me to the king, Acastus,

treat me kindly, too, but it pleased them more

to scheme foul play against me,

sink me into the very depths of pain. As soon

as the ship was far off land, scudding in mid-sea,

they sprang their trap—my day of slavery then and there!

They stripped from my back the shirt and cloak I wore,

decked me out in a new suit of clothes, all rags,

ripped and filthy—the rags you see right now.

But then, once they’d gained the fields of Ithaca,

390still clear in the evening light, they lashed me fast

to the rowing-benches, twisting a cable round me;

all hands went ashore

and rushed to catch their supper on the beach.

But the gods themselves unhitched my knots at once

with the gods’ own ease. I wrapped my head in rags,

slid down the gangplank polished smooth, slipped my body

into the water, not a splash, chest-high, then quick,

launched out with both my arms and swam away—

out of the surf in no time, clear of the crew.

400I clambered upland, into a flowery, fragrant brush

and crouched there, huddling low. They raised a hue and cry,

wildly beat the bushes, but when it seemed no use

to pursue the hunt, back they trudged again and

boarded their empty ship.

The gods hid me themselves—

it’s light work for them—and brought me here,

the homestead of a man who knows the world.

So it seems to be my lot that I’ll live on.”

And you replied, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“So much misery, friend! You’ve moved my heart,

410deeply, with your long tale… such blows, such roving.

But one part’s off the mark, I know—you’ll never persuade me—

what you say about Odysseus. A man in your condition,

who are you, I ask you, to lie for no good reason?

Well I know the truth of my good lord’s return,

how the gods detested him, with a vengeance—

never letting him go under, fighting Trojans,

or die in the arms of loved ones,

once he’d wound down the long coil of war.

Then all united Achaea would have raised his tomb

420and he’d have won his son great fame for years to come.

But now the whirlwinds have ripped him away—no fame for him!

And I live here, cut off from the world, with all my pigs.

I never go into town unless, perhaps, wise Penelope

calls me back, when news drops in from nowhere.

There they crowd the messenger, cross-examine him,

heartsick for their long-lost lord or all too glad

to eat him out of house and home, scot-free.

But I’ve no love for all that probing, prying,

429not since some Aetolian fooled me with his yarn.

430He’d killed a man, wandered over the face of the earth,

stumbled onto my hut, and I received him warmly.

He told me he’d seen Odysseus

lodged with King Idomeneus down in Crete—

refitting his ships, hard-hit by the gales,

but he’d be home, he said, by summer or harvest-time,

his hulls freighted with treasure, manned by fighting crews.

So you, old misery, seeing a god has led you here to me,

don’t try to charm me now, don’t spellbind me with lies!

Never for that will I respect you, treat you kindly;

440no, it’s my fear of Zeus, the god of guests,

and because I pity you…”

“Good god,” the crafty man pressed on,

“what a dark, suspicious heart you have inside you!

Not even my oath can win you over, make you see the light.

Come, strike a bargain—all the gods of Olympus

witness now our pact!

If your master returns, here to your house,

dress me in shirt and cloak and send me off

to Dulichion at once, the place I long to be.

450But if your master doesn’t return as I predict,

set your men on me—fling me off some rocky crag

so the next beggar here may just think twice

before he peddles lies.”

“Surely, friend!”—

the swineherd shook his head—“and just think

of the praise and fame I’d win among mankind,

now and for all time to come, if first I took you

under my roof, I treated you kindly as my guest

then cut you down and robbed you of your life—

how keen I’d be to say my prayers to Zeus!

460But it’s high time for a meal.

I hope the men will be home at any moment

so we can fix a tasty supper in the lodge.”

As host and guest confided back and forth

the herdsmen came in, driving their hogs up close,

penning sows in their proper sties for the night,

squealing for all they’re worth, shut inside their yard,

and the good swineherd shouted to his men,

“Bring in your fattest hog!

I’ll slaughter it for our guest from far abroad.

470We’ll savor it ourselves. All too long we’ve sweated

over these white-tusked boars—our wretched labor—

while others wolf our work down free of charge!”

Calling out

as he split up kindling now with a good sharp ax

and his men hauled in a tusker five years old,

rippling fat, and stood him steady by the hearth.

The swineherd, soul of virtue, did not forget the gods.

He began the rite by plucking tufts from the porker’s head,

threw them into the fire and prayed to all the powers,

“Bring him home, our wise Odysseus, home at last!”

480Then raising himself full-length, with an oak log

he’d left unsplit he clubbed and stunned the beast

and it gasped out its life…

The men slashed its throat, singed the carcass,

quickly quartered it all, and then the swineherd,

cutting first strips for the gods from every limb,

spread them across the thighs, wrapped in sleek fat,

and sprinkling barley over them, flung them on the fire.

They sliced the rest into pieces, pierced them with skewers,

broiled them all to a turn and, pulling them off the spits,

490piled the platters high. The swineherd, standing up

to share the meat—his sense of fairness perfect—

carved it all out into seven equal portions.

One he set aside, lifting up a prayer

494to the forest nymphs and Hermes, Maia’s son,

and the rest he handed on to each man in turn.

But to Odysseus he presented the boar’s long loin

and the cut of honor cheered his master’s heart.

The man for all occasions thanked his host:

“I pray, Eumaeus, you’ll be as dear to Father Zeus

500as you are to me—a man in my condition—

you honor me by giving me your best.”

You replied in kind, Eumaeus, swineherd:

“Eat, my strange new friend… enjoy it now,

it’s all we have to offer. As for Father Zeus,

one thing he will give and another he’ll hold back,

whatever his pleasure. All things are in his power.”

He burned choice parts for the gods who never die

and pouring glistening wine in a full libation,

placed the cup in his guest’s hands—Odysseus,

510raider of cities—and down he sat to his own share.

511Mesaulius served them bread, a man the swineherd

purchased for himself in his master’s absence—

alone, apart from his queen or old Laertes—

bought him from Taphians, bartered his own goods.

They reached out for the spread that lay at hand

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Mesaulius cleared the things away. And now, content

with bread and meat, they made for bed at once.

A foul night came on—the dark of the moon—and Zeus

520rained from dusk to dawn and a sodden West Wind raged.

Odysseus spoke up now, keen to test the swineherd.

Would he take his cloak off, hand it to his guest

or at least tell one of his men to do the same?

He cared for the stranger so, who ventured now,

“Listen, Eumaeus, and all you comrades here,

allow me to sing my praises for a moment.

Say it’s the wine that leads me on, the wild wine

that sets the wisest man to sing at the top of his lungs,

laugh like a fool—it drives the man to dancing… it even

530tempts him to blurt out stories better never told.

But now that I’m sounding off, I can’t hold back.

Oh make me young again, and the strength inside me

steady as a rock! Just as I was that day

we sprang a sudden ambush against the Trojans.

Odysseus led the raid with Atreus’ son Menelaus.

I was third in command—they’d chosen me themselves.

Once we’d edged up under the city’s steep ramparts,

crowding the walls but sinking into the thick brake,

the reeds and marshy flats, huddling under our armor

540there we lay, and a foul night came on, the North Wind struck,

freezing cold, and down from the skies the snow fell like frost,

packed hard—the rims of our shields armored round with ice.

There all the rest of the men wore shirts and cloaks and,

hunching shields over their shoulders, slept at ease.

Not I. I’d left my cloak at camp when I set out—

idiot—never thinking it might turn cold,

so I joined in with just the shield on my back

and a shining waist-guard… But then at last,

the night’s third watch, the stars just wheeling down—

550I muttered into his ear, Odysseus, right beside me,

nudging him with an elbow—he perked up at once—

‘Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, full of tactics,

I’m not long for the living. The cold will do me in.

See, I’ve got no cloak. Some spirit’s fooled me—

I came out half-dressed. Now there’s no escape!’

I hadn’t finished—a thought flashed in his mind;

no one could touch the man at plots or battles.

‘Shhh!’ he hissed back—Odysseus had a plan—

‘One of our fighters over there might hear you.’

560Then he propped his head on his forearm, calling out,

‘Friends, wake up. I slept and a god sent down a dream.

It warned that we’re too far from the ships, exposed.

Go, someone, tell Agamemnon, our field marshal—

he might rush reinforcements from the beach.’

565Thoas, son of Andraemon, sprang up at once,

flung off his purple cloak and ran to the ships

while I, bundling into his wrap, was glad at heart

till Dawn rose on her golden throne once more.

Oh make me young again

570and the strength inside me steady as a rock!

One of the swineherds here would lend a wrap

for love of a good soldier, respect as well.

Now they spurn me, dressed in filthy rags.”

And you replied, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“Now that was a fine yarn you told, old-timer,

not without point, not without profit either.

You won’t want for clothes or whatever else

is due a worn-out traveler come for help—

not for tonight at least. Tomorrow morning

580you’ll have to flap around in rags again.

Here we’ve got no store of shirts and cloaks,

no changes. Just one wrap per man, that’s all.

But just you wait till Odysseus’ dear son comes back—

that boy will deck you out in a cloak and shirt

and send you off, wherever your heart desires!”

With that

he rose to his feet and laid out a bed by the fire,

throwing over it skins of sheep and goats and

down Odysseus lay. Eumaeus flung on his guest

the heavy flaring cloak he kept in reserve

to wear when winter brought some wild storm.

590So here

Odysseus slept and the young hands slept beside him.

Not the swineherd. Not his style to bed indoors,

apart from his pigs. He geared up to go outside

and it warmed Odysseus’ heart,

Eumaeus cared so much for his absent master’s goods.

First, over his broad shoulders he slung a whetted sword,

wrapped himself in a cloak stitched tight to block the wind,

and adding a cape, the pelt of a shaggy well-fed goat,

he took a good sharp lance to fight off men and dogs.

600Then out he went to sleep where his white-tusked boars

had settled down for the night… just under

a jutting crag that broke the North Wind’s blast.

BOOK FIFTEEN

The Prince Sets Sail for Home

N
ow south through the spacious dancing-rings of Lacedaemon

Athena went to remind the hero’s princely son

of his journey home and spur him on his way.

She found him there with Nestor’s gallant son,

bedded down in the porch of illustrious Menelaus—

Pisistratus, at least, overcome with deep sound sleep,

but not Telemachus. Welcome sleep could not hold him.

All through the godsent night he lay awake…

9tossing with anxious thoughts about his father.

10Hovering over him, eyes ablaze, Athena said,

“It’s wrong, Telemachus, wrong to rove so far,

so long from home, leaving your own holdings

unprotected—crowds in your palace so brazen

they’ll carve up all your wealth, devour it all,

and then your journey here will come to nothing.

Quickly, press Menelaus, lord of the warcry,

to speed you home at once, if you want to find

your irreproachable mother still inside your house.

Even now her father and brothers urge Penelope

20to marry Eurymachus, who excels all other suitors

21at giving gifts and drives the bride-price higher.

She must not carry anything off against your will!

23You know how the heart of a woman always works:

she likes to build the wealth of her new groom—

of the sons she bore, of her dear, departed husband,

not a memory of the dead, no questions asked.

So sail for home, I say!

With your own hands turn over all your goods

to the one serving-woman you can trust the most,

30till the gods bring to light your own noble bride.

And another thing. Take it to heart, I tell you.

Picked men of the suitors lie in ambush, grim-set

in the straits between Ithaca and rocky Same,

poised to kill you before you can reach home,

but I have my doubts they will. Sooner the earth

will swallow down a few of those young gallants

who eat you out of house and home these days!

Just give the channel islands a wide berth,

push on in your trim ship, sail night and day,

40and the deathless god who guards and pulls you through

will send you a fresh fair wind from hard astern.

At your first landfall, Ithaca’s outer banks,

speed ship and shipmates round to the city side.

But you—you make your way to the swineherd first,

in charge of your pigs, and true to you as always.

Sleep the night there, send him to town at once

to tell the news to your mother, wise Penelope—

you’ve made it back from Pylos safe and sound.”

Mission accomplished, back she went to Olympus’ heights

50as Telemachus woke Nestor’s son from his sweet sleep;

he dug a heel in his ribs and roused him briskly:

“Up, Pisistratus. Hitch the team to the chariot—

let’s head for home at once!”

“No, Telemachus,”

Nestor’s son objected, “much as we long to go,

we cannot drive a team in the dead of night.

Morning will soon be here. So wait, I say,

wait till he loads our chariot down with gifts—

the hero Atrides, Menelaus, the great spearman—

and gives us warm salutes and sees us off like princes.

60That’s the man a guest will remember all his days:

the lavish host who showers him with kindness.”

At those words Dawn rose on her golden throne

and Menelaus, lord of the warcry, rising up from bed

by the side of Helen with her loose and lovely hair,

walked toward his guests. As soon as he saw him,

Telemachus rushed to pull a shimmering tunic on,

over his broad shoulders threw his flaring cape

and the young prince, son of King Odysseus,

strode out to meet his host: “Menelaus,

70royal son of Atreus, captain of armies,

let me go back to my own country now.

The heart inside me longs for home at last.”

The lord of the warcry reassured the prince,

74“I’d never detain you here too long, Telemachus,

not if your heart is set on going home.

I’d find fault with another host, I’m sure,

too warm to his guests, too pressing or too cold.

Balance is best in all things. It’s bad either way,

spurring the stranger home who wants to linger,

80holding the one who longs to leave—you know,

‘Welcome the coming, speed the parting guest!’

But wait till I load your chariot down with gifts—

fine ones, too, you’ll see with your own eyes—

and tell the maids to serve a meal at hall.

We have god’s plenty here.

It’s honor and glory to us, a help to you as well

if you dine in style first, then leave to see the world.

And if you’re keen for the grand tour of all Hellas,

right to the depths of Argos, I’ll escort you myself,

90harness the horses, guide you through the towns.

And no host will turn us away with empty hands,

each will give us at least one gift to prize—

a handsome tripod, cauldron forged in bronze,

a brace of mules or a solid golden cup.”

Firmly resolved, Telemachus replied,

“Menelaus, royal Atrides, captain of armies,

I must go back to my own home at once.

When I started out I left no one behind

to guard my own possessions. God forbid,

100searching for my great father, I lose my life

or lose some priceless treasure from my house!”

As soon as the lord of the warcry heard that,

he told his wife and serving-women to lay out a meal

in the hall at once. They’d stores aplenty there.

Eteoneus, son of Boëthous, came to join them—

fresh from bed, he lived close by the palace.

The warlord Menelaus told him to build a fire

and broil some meat. He quickly did his bidding.

Down Atrides walked to a storeroom filled with scent,

110and not alone: Helen and Megapenthes went along.

Reaching the spot where all the heirlooms lay,

Menelaus chose a generous two-handled cup;

he told his son Megapenthes to take a mixing-bowl,

solid silver, while Helen lingered beside the chests,

and there they were, brocaded, beautiful robes

her own hands had woven. Queenly Helen,

radiance of women, lifted one from the lot,

the largest, loveliest robe, and richly worked

and like a star it glistened, deep beneath the others.

120Then all three went up and on through the halls until

they found Telemachus. The red-haired king spoke out:

“Oh my boy, may Zeus the Thunderer, Hera’s lord,

grant you the journey home your heart desires!

Of all the treasures lying heaped in my palace

you shall have the finest, most esteemed. Look,

I’ll give you this mixing-bowl, forged to perfection—

it’s solid silver finished off with a lip of gold.

Hephaestus made it himself. And a royal friend,

Phaedimus, king of Sidon, lavished it on me

130when his palace welcomed me on passage home.

How pleased I’d be if you took it as a gift!”

And the warlord placed the two-eared cup

in his hands while stalwart Megapenthes carried in

the glittering silver bowl and set it down before him.

Helen, her cheeks flushed with beauty, moved beside him,

holding the robe in her arms, and offered, warmly,

“Here, dear boy, I too have a gift to give you,

a keepsake of Helen—I wove it with my hands—

for your own bride to wear

140when the blissful day of marriage dawns…

Until then, let it rest in your mother’s room.

And may you return in joy—my parting wish—

to your own grand house, your native land at last.”

With that

she laid the robe in his arms, and he received it gladly.

Prince Pisistratus, taking the gifts, stowed them deep

in the chariot cradle, viewed them all with wonder.

The red-haired warlord led them back to his house

and the guests took seats on low and high-backed chairs.

A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

150and over a silver basin tipped it out

so they might rinse their hands,

then pulled a gleaming table to their side.

A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve them,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

Ready Eteoneus carved and passed the meat,

the son of illustrious Menelaus poured their wine.

They reached out for the good things that lay at hand

and once they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Prince Telemachus and the gallant son of Nestor

160yoked their team, mounted the blazoned car

and drove through the gates and echoing colonnade.

The red-haired King Menelaus followed both boys out,

his right hand holding a golden cup of honeyed wine

so the two might pour libations forth at parting.

Just in front of the straining team he strode,

lifting his cup and pledging both his guests:

“Farewell, my princes! Give my warm greetings

to Nestor, the great commander,

always kind to me as a father, long ago

170when we young men of Achaea fought at Troy.”

And tactful Telemachus replied at once,

“Surely, my royal host, we’ll tell him all,

as soon as we reach old Nestor—all you say.

I wish I were just as sure I’d find Odysseus

waiting there at home when I reach Ithaca.

I’d tell him I come from you,

treated with so much kindness at your hands,

loaded down with all these priceless gifts!”

179At his last words a bird flew past on the right,

180an eagle clutching a huge white goose in its talons,

plucked from the household yards. And all rushed after,

shouting, men and women, and swooping toward the chariot now

the bird veered off to the right again before the horses.

All looked up, overjoyed—people’s spirits lifted.

Nestor’s son Pisistratus spoke out first:

“Look there! King Menelaus, captain of armies,

what, did the god send down that sign for you

or the two of us?”

The warlord fell to thinking—

how to read the omen rightly, how to reply?…

190But long-robed Helen stepped in well before him:

“Listen to me and I will be your prophet,

sure as the gods have flashed it in my mind

and it will come to pass, I know it will.

Just as the eagle swooped down from the crags

where it was born and bred, just as it snatched

that goose fattened up for the kill inside the house,

just so, after many trials and roving long and hard,

Odysseus will descend on his house and take revenge—

unless he’s home already, sowing seeds of ruin

for that whole crowd of suitors!”

200“Oh if only,”

pensive Telemachus burst out in thanks to Helen,

“Zeus the thundering lord of Hera makes it so—

even at home I’ll pray to you as a deathless goddess!”

He cracked the lash and the horses broke quickly,

careering through the city out into open country,

shaking the yoke across their shoulders all day long.

The sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark

as they reached Phera, pulling up to Diocles’ halls,

the son of Ortilochus, son of the Alpheus River.

210He gave them a royal welcome; there they slept the night.

When young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

they yoked their pair again, mounted the blazoned car

and out through the gates and echoing colonnade

they whipped the team to a run and on they flew,

holding nothing back, approaching Pylos soon,

the craggy citadel. That was when Telemachus

turned to Pisistratus, saying, “Son of Nestor,

won’t you do as I ask you, see it through?

We’re friends for all our days now, so we claim,

220thanks to our fathers’ friendship. We’re the same age as well

and this tour of ours has made us more like brothers.

Prince, don’t drive me past my vessel, drop me there.

223Your father’s old, in love with his hospitality;

I fear he’ll hold me, chafing in his palace—

I must hurry home!”

The son of Nestor pondered…

how to do it properly, see it through?

Pausing a moment, then this way seemed best.

Swerving his team, he drove down to the ship

tied up on shore and loaded into her stern

230the splendid gifts, the robes and gold Menelaus gave,

and sped his friend with a flight of winging words:

“Climb aboard now—fast! Muster all your men

before I get home and break the news to father.

With that man’s overbearing spirit—I know it,

know it all too well—he’ll never let you go,

he’ll come down here and summon you himself.

He won’t return without you, believe me—

in any case he’ll fly into a rage.”

With that warning he whipped his sleek horses

240back to Pylos city and reached his house in no time.

Telemachus shouted out commands to all his shipmates:

“Stow our gear, my comrades, deep in the holds

and board at once—we must be on our way!”

His shipmates snapped to orders,

swung aboard and sat to the oars in ranks.

But just as Telemachus prepared to launch,

praying, sacrificing to Pallas by the stern,

a man from a far-off country came toward him now,

a fugitive out of Argos: he had killed a man…

250He was a prophet, sprung of Melampus’ line of seers,

Melampus who lived in Pylos, mother of flocks, some years ago,

rich among his Pylians, at home in his great high house.

But then he was made to go abroad to foreign parts,

fleeing his native land and hot-blooded Neleus—

most imperious man alive—who’d commandeered

his vast estate and held it down by force

for one entire year. That year Melampus,

258bound by cruel chains in the halls of Phylacus,

suffered agonies—all for Neleus’ daughter Pero,

260that and the mad spell a Fury, murderous spirit,

cast upon his mind. But the seer worked free of death

and drove the lusty, bellowing cattle out of Phylace,

back to Pylos. There he avenged himself on Neleus

for the shameful thing the king had done to him,

and escorted Pero home as his brother’s bride.

But he himself went off to a distant country,

Argos, land of stallions—his destined home

where he would live and rule the Argive nation.

Here he married a wife and built a high-roofed house

270and sired Antiphates and Mantius, two staunch sons.

271Antiphates fathered Oicles, gallant heart,

272Oicles fathered Amphiaraus, driver of armies,

whom storming Zeus and Apollo loved intensely,

showering him with every form of kindness.

But he never reached the threshold of old age,

276he died at Thebes—undone by a bribe his wife accepted—

277leaving behind his two sons, Alcmaeon and Amphilochus.

278On his side Mantius sired Polyphides and Clitus both

but Dawn of the golden throne whisked Clitus away,

280overwhelmed by his beauty,

so the boy would live among the deathless gods.

Yet Apollo made magnanimous Polyphides a prophet—

after Amphiaraus’ death—the greatest seer on earth.

284But a feud with his father drove him off to Hyperesia

where he made his home and prophesied to the world…

286This prophet’s son it was—Theoclymenus his name—

who approached Telemachus now and found him pouring

wine to a god and saying prayers beside his ship.

“Friend,” he said in a winging supplication,

290“since I find you burning offerings here,

I beg you by these rites and the god you pray to,

then by your own life and the lives of all the men

who travel with you—tell me truly, don’t hold back,

who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?”

“Of course, stranger,” the forthright prince responded,

“I will tell you everything, clearly as I can.

Ithaca is my country. Odysseus is my father—

there was a man, or was he all a dream?…

but he’s surely died a wretched death by now.

300Yet here I’ve come with my crew and black ship,

out for news of my father, lost and gone so long.”

And the godlike seer Theoclymenus replied,

“Just like you, I too have left my land—

I because I killed a man of my own tribe.

But he has many brothers and kin in Argos,

stallion-land, who rule the plains in force.

Fleeing death at their hands, a dismal fate,

I am a fugitive now,

doomed to wander across this mortal world.

310So take me aboard, hear a fugitive’s prayer:

don’t let them kill me—they’re after me, well I know!”

“So desperate!” thoughtful Telemachus exclaimed.

“How could I drive you from my ship? Come sail with us,

we’ll tend you at home, with all we can provide.”

And he took the prophet’s honed bronze spear,

laid it down full-length on the rolling deck,

swung aboard the deep-sea craft himself,

assuming the pilot’s seat reserved astern

and put the seer beside him. Cables cast off,

320Telemachus shouted out commands to all his shipmates:

“All lay hands to tackle!” They sprang to orders,

hoisting the pinewood mast, they stepped it firm

in its block amidships, lashed it fast with stays

and with braided rawhide halyards hauled the white sail high.

Now bright-eyed Athena sent them a stiff following wind

blustering out of a clear sky, gusting on so the ship

might run its course through the salt sea at top speed—

328and past the Springs she raced and the Chalcis’ rushing stream

as the sun sank and the roads of the world grew dark and

330on she pressed for Pheae, driven on by a wind from Zeus

and flew past lovely Elis, where Epeans rule in power,

332and then Telemachus veered for the Jagged Islands,

wondering all the way—

would he sweep clear of death or be cut down?

The king and loyal swineherd, just that night,

were supping with other fieldhands in the lodge.

And once they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

Odysseus spoke up, eager to test the swineherd,

see if he’d stretch out his warm welcome now,

340invite him to stay on in the farmstead here

or send him off to town. “Listen, Eumaeus,

all you comrades here—at the crack of dawn

I mean to go to town and do my begging,

not be a drain on you and all your men.

But advise me well, give me a trusty guide

to see me there. And then I’m on my own

to roam the streets—I must, I have no choice—

hoping to find a handout, just a crust or cupful.

I’d really like to go to the house of King Odysseus

350and give my news to his cautious queen, Penelope.

Why, I’d even mix with those overweening suitors—

would they spare me a plateful? Look at all they have!

I’d do good work for them, promptly, anything they want.

Let me tell you, listen closely, catch my drift…

Thanks to Hermes the guide, who gives all work

of our hands the grace and fame that it deserves,

no one alive can match me at household chores:

building a good fire, splitting kindling neatly,

carving, roasting meat and pouring rounds of wine…

360anything menials do to serve their noble masters.”

“God’s sake, my friend!” you broke in now,

Eumaeus, loyal swineherd, deeply troubled.

“What’s got into your head, what crazy plan?

You must be hell-bent on destruction, on the spot,

if you’re keen to mingle with that mob of suitors—

their pride and violence hit the iron skies!

They’re a far cry from you,

the men who do their bidding. Young bucks,

all rigged out in their fine robes and shirts,

370hair sleeked down with oil, faces always beaming,

the ones who slave for them! The tables polished,

sagging under the bread and meat and wine.

No, stay here. No one finds you a burden,

surely not I, nor any comrade here.

You wait till Odysseus’ dear son comes back—

that boy will deck you out in a cloak and shirt

and send you off, wherever your heart desires!”

“If only, Eumaeus,” the wayworn exile said,

“you were as dear to Father Zeus as you are to me!

380You who stopped my pain, my endless, homesick roving.

Tramping about the world—there’s nothing worse for a man.

But the fact is that men put up with misery

to stuff their cursed bellies.

But seeing you hold me here, urging me now

to wait for him, the prince who’s on his way,

tell me about the mother of King Odysseus, please,

the father he left as well—on the threshold of old age—

when he sailed off to war. Are they still alive,

perhaps, still looking into the light of day?

Or dead by now, and down in Death’s long house?”

390“Friend,”

the swineherd, foreman of men, assured his guest,

“I’ll tell you the whole story, point by point.

Laertes is still alive, but night and day

he prays to Zeus, waiting there in his house,

for the life breath to slip away and leave his body.

His heart’s so racked for his son, lost and gone these years,

for his wife so fine, so wise—her death is the worst blow

he’s had to suffer—it made him old before his time.

She died of grief for her boy, her glorious boy,

400it wore her down, a wretched way to go.

I pray that no one I love dies such a death,

no island neighbor of mine who treats me kindly!

While she was still alive, heartsick as she was,

it always moved me to ask about her, learn the news.

She’d reared me herself, and right beside her daughter,

406Ctimene, graceful girl with her long light gown,

the youngest one she’d borne…

Just the two of us, growing up together,

the woman tending me almost like her child,

410till we both reached the lovely flush of youth

and then her parents gave her away in marriage, yes,

to a Samian man, and a haul of gifts they got.

But her mother decked me out in cloak and shirt,

good clothing she wrapped about me—gave me sandals,

sent me here, this farm. She loved me from the heart.

Oh how I miss her kindness now! The happy gods

speed the work that I labor at, that gives me

food and drink to spare for the ones I value.

But from Queen Penelope I never get a thing,

420never a winning word, no friendly gesture,

not since this, this plague has hit the house—

these high and mighty suitors. Servants miss it,

terribly, gossiping back and forth with the mistress,

gathering scraps of news, a snack and a cup or two,

then taking home to the fields some little gift.

It never fails to cheer a servant’s heart.”

“Imagine that,” his canny master said,

“you must have been just a little fellow, Eumaeus,

when you were swept so far from home and parents.

430Come, tell me the whole story, truly too.

Was your city sacked?—

some city filled with people and wide streets

where your father and your mother made their home?

Or were you all alone, herding your sheep and cattle,

when pirates kidnapped, shipped and sold you off

to this man’s house, who paid a healthy price?”

“My friend,” the swineherd answered, foreman of men,

“you really want my story? So many questions—well,

listen in quiet, then, and take your ease, sit back

440and drink your wine. The nights are endless now.

We’ve plenty of time to sleep or savor a long tale.

No need, you know, to turn in before the hour.

Even too much sleep can be a bore.

But anyone else who feels the urge

can go to bed and then, at the crack of dawn,

break bread, turn out and tend our master’s pigs.

We two will keep to the shelter here, eat and drink

and take some joy in each other’s heartbreaking sorrows,

sharing each other’s memories. Over the years, you know,

450a man finds solace even in old sorrows, true, a man

who’s weathered many blows and wandered many miles.

My own story? This will answer all your questions…

453There’s an island, Syrie—you may have heard of it—

454off above Ortygia, out where the sun wheels around.

Not so packed with people, still a good place, though,

fine for sheep and cattle, rich in wine and wheat.

Hunger never attacks the land, no sickness either,

that always stalks the lives of us poor men.

No, as each generation grows old on the island,

460down Apollo comes with his silver bow, with Artemis,

and they shoot them all to death with gentle arrows.

Two cities there are, that split the land in half,

and over them both my father ruled in force—

464Ormenus’ son Ctesius, a man like a deathless god.

One day

a band of Phoenicians landed there. The famous sea-dogs,

sharp bargainers too, the holds of their black ship

brimful with a hoard of flashy baubles. Now,

my father kept a Phoenician woman in his house,

beautiful, tall and skilled at weaving lovely things,

470and her rascal countrymen lusted to seduce her, yes,

and lost no time—she was washing clothes when one of them

waylaid her beside their ship, in a long deep embrace

that can break a woman’s will, even the best alive.

And then he asked her questions…

her name, who was she, where did she come from?

She waved at once to my father’s high-roofed house—

‘But I’m proud to hail from Sidon paved in bronze,’ she said,

478‘and Arybas was my father, a man who rolled in wealth.

I was heading home from the fields when Taphian pirates

480snatched me away, and they shipped and sold me here

to this man’s house. He paid a good stiff price!’

The sailor, her secret lover, lured her on:

‘Well then, why don’t you sail back home with us?—

see your own high house, your father and mother there.

They’re still alive, and people say they’re rich!’

‘Now there’s a tempting offer,’ she said in haste,

‘if only you sailors here would swear an oath

you’ll land me safe at home without a scratch.’

Those were her terms, and once they vowed to keep them,

490swore their oaths they’d never do her harm,

the woman hatched a plan: ‘Now not a word!

Let none of your shipmates say a thing to me,

meeting me on the street or at the springs.

Someone might go running off to the house

and tell the old king—he’d think the worst,

clap me in cruel chains and find a way to kill you.

So keep it a secret, down deep, get on with buying

your home cargo, quickly. But once your holds

are loaded up with goods, then fast as you can

500you send the word to me over there at the palace.

I’ll bring you all the gold I can lay my hands on

and something else I’ll give you in the bargain,

fare for passage home…

I’m nurse to my master’s son in the palace now—

such a precious toddler, scampering round outside,

always at my heels. I’ll bring him aboard as well.

Wherever you sell him off, whatever foreign parts,

he’ll fetch you quite a price!’

Bargain struck,

back the woman went to our lofty halls

510and the rovers stayed on with us one whole year,

bartering, piling up big hoards in their hollow ship,

and once their holds were loaded full for sailing

they sent a messenger, fast, to alert the woman.

This crafty bandit came to my father’s house,

dangling a golden choker linked with amber beads,

and while the maids at hall and my noble mother

kept on fondling it—dazzled, feasting their eyes

and making bids—he gave a quiet nod to my nurse,

he gave her the nod and slunk back to his ship.

520Grabbing my hand, she swept me through the house

and there in the porch she came on cups and tables

left by the latest feasters, father’s men of council

just gone off to the meeting grounds for full debate—

and quick as a flash she snatched up three goblets,

tucked them into her bosom, whisked them off

and I tagged along, lost in all my innocence!

The sun sank, the roads of the world grew dark

and both on the run, we reached the bay at once

where the swift Phoenician ship lay set to sail.

530Handing us up on board, the crewmen launched out

on the foaming lanes and Zeus sent wind astern.

Six whole days we sailed, six nights, nonstop

and then, when the god brought on the seventh day,

Artemis showering arrows came and shot the woman—

headfirst into the bilge she splashed like a diving tern

and the crewmen heaved her body over, a nice treat

for the seals and fish, but left me all alone,

cowering, sick at heart…

Until, at last,

the wind and current bore us on to Ithaca,

540here where Laertes bought me with his wealth.

And so I first laid eyes on this good land.”

And royal King Odysseus answered warmly,

“Eumaeus, so much misery! You’ve moved my heart,

deeply, with your long tale—such pain, such sorrow.

True, but look at the good fortune Zeus sends you,

hand-in-hand with the bad. After all your toil

you reached the house of a decent, kindly man

who gives you all you need in meat and drink—

he’s seen to that, I’d say—

550it’s a fine life you lead! Better than mine…

I’ve been drifting through cities up and down the earth

and now I’ve landed here.”

So guest and host

confided through the night until they slept,

a little at least, not long.

Dawn soon rose and took her golden throne.

That hour

Telemachus and his shipmates raised the coasts of home,

they struck sail and lowered the mast, smartly,

rowed her into a mooring under oars.

Out went the bow-stones, cables fast astern,

560the crew themselves swung out in the breaking surf,

they got a meal together and mixed some ruddy wine.

And once they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

clear-headed Telemachus gave the men commands:

“Pull our black ship round to the city now—

I’m off to my herdsmen and my farms. By nightfall,

once I’ve seen to my holdings, I’ll be down in town.

In the morning I’ll give you wages for the voyage,

a handsome feast of meat and hearty wine.”

The seer Theoclymenus broke in quickly,

570“Where shall I go, dear boy? Of all the lords

in rocky Ithaca, whose house shall I head for now?

Or do I go straight to your mother’s house and yours?”

“Surely in better times,” discreet Telemachus replied,

“I would invite you home. Our hospitality never fails

but now, I fear, it could only serve you poorly.

I’ll be away, and mother would never see you.

She rarely appears these days,

what with those suitors milling in the hall;

she keeps to her upper story, weaving at her loom.

580But I’ll mention someone else you might just visit:

Eurymachus, wise Polybus’ fine, upstanding son.

He’s the man of the hour! Our island people

look on him like a god—the prince of suitors,

hottest to wed my mother, seize my father’s powers.

But god knows—Zeus up there in his bright Olympus—

whether or not before that wedding day arrives

he’ll bring the day of death on all their heads!”

588At his last words a bird flew past on the right,

a hawk, Apollo’s wind-swift herald—tight in his claws

590a struggling dove, and he ripped its feathers out

and they drifted down to earth between the ship

and the young prince himself…

The prophet called him aside, clear of his men,

and grasped his hand, exclaiming, “Look, Telemachus,

the will of god just winged that bird on your right!

Why, the moment I saw it, here before my eyes,

I knew it was a sign. No line more kingly than yours

in all of Ithaca—yours will reign forever!”

“If only, friend,”

alert Telemachus answered, “all you say comes true!

600You’d soon know my affection, know my gifts.

Any man you meet would call you blest.”

602He turned to a trusted friend and said, “Piraeus,

603son of Clytius, you are the one who’s done my bidding,

more than all other friends who sailed with me to Pylos.

Please, take this guest of mine to your own house,

treat him kindly, host him with all good will

till I can come myself.”

“Of course, Telemachus,”

Piraeus the gallant spearman offered warmly:

“Stay up-country just as long as you like.

610I’ll tend the man, he’ll never lack a lodging.”

Piraeus boarded ship and told the crew

to embark at once and cast off cables quickly—

they swung aboard and sat to the oars in ranks.

Telemachus fastened rawhide sandals on his feet

and took from the decks his rugged bronze-tipped spear.

The men cast off, pushed out and pulled for town

as Telemachus ordered, King Odysseus’ son.

The prince strode out briskly,

legs speeding him on till he reached the farm

620where his great droves of pigs crowded their pens

and the loyal swineherd often slept beside them,

always the man to serve his masters well.

BOOK SIXTEEN

Father and Son

A
s dawn came into the lodge, the king and loyal swineherd

set out breakfast, once they had raked the fire up

and got the herdsmen off with droves of pigs.

And now Telemachus…

the howling dogs went nuzzling up around him,

not a growl as he approached. From inside

Odysseus noticed the pack’s quiet welcome,

noticed the light tread of footsteps too

and turned to Eumaeus quickly, winged a word:

10“Eumaeus, here comes a friend of yours, I’d say.

Someone you know, at least. The pack’s not barking,

must be fawning around him. I can hear his footfall.”

The words were still on his lips when his own son

stood in the doorway, there. The swineherd started up,

amazed, he dropped the bowls with a clatter—he’d been busy

mixing ruddy wine. Straight to the prince he rushed

and kissed his face and kissed his shining eyes,

both hands, as the tears rolled down his cheeks.

As a father, brimming with love, welcomes home

20his darling only son in a warm embrace—

what pain he’s borne for him and him alone!—

home now, in the tenth year from far abroad,

so the loyal swineherd hugged the beaming prince,

he clung for dear life, covering him with kisses, yes,

like one escaped from death. Eumaeus wept and sobbed,

his words flew from the heart: “You’re home, Telemachus,

sweet light of my eyes! I never thought I’d see you again,

once you’d shipped to Pylos! Quick, dear boy, come in,

let me look at you, look to my heart’s content—

30under my own roof, the rover home at last.

You rarely visit the farm and men these days,

always keeping to town, as if it cheered you

to see them there, that infernal crowd of suitors!”

“Have it your way,” thoughtful Telemachus replied.

“Dear old man, it’s all for you that I’ve come,

36to see you for myself and learn the news—

whether mother still holds out in the halls

or some other man has married her at last,

and Odysseus’ bed, I suppose, is lying empty,

blanketed now with filthy cobwebs.”

40“Surely,”

the foreman of men responded, “she’s still waiting

there in your halls, poor woman, suffering so,

her life an endless hardship…

wasting away the nights, weeping away the days.”

With that

he took the bronze spear from the boy, and Telemachus,

crossing the stone doorsill, went inside the lodge.

As he approached, his father, Odysseus, rose

to yield his seat, but the son on his part

waved him back: “Stay where you are, stranger.

50I know we can find another seat somewhere,

here on our farm, and here’s the man to fetch it.”

So Odysseus, moving back, sat down once more,

and now for the prince the swineherd strewed a bundle

of fresh green brushwood, topped it off with sheepskin

and there the true son of Odysseus took his place.

Eumaeus set before them platters of roast meat

left from the meal he’d had the day before;

he promptly served them bread, heaped in baskets,

mixed their hearty wine in a wooden bowl

60and then sat down himself to face the king.

They reached for the good things that lay at hand,

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink

Telemachus asked his loyal serving-man at last,

“Old friend, where does this stranger come from?

Why did the sailors land him here in Ithaca?

Who did they say they are?

I hardly think he came this way on foot.”

You answered him, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“Here, my boy, I’ll tell you the whole true story.

70He hails from Crete’s broad land, he’s proud to say,

but he claims he’s drifted round through countless towns of men,

roaming the earth… and so a god’s spun out his fate.

He just now broke away from some Thesprotian ship

and came to my farm. I’ll put him in your hands,

you tend to him as you like.

He counts on you, he says, for care and shelter.”

“Shelter? Oh Eumaeus,” Telemachus replied,

“that word of yours, it cuts me to the quick!

How can I lend the stranger refuge in my house?

80I’m young myself. I can hardly trust my hands

to fight off any man who rises up against me.

Then my mother’s wavering, always torn two ways:

whether to stay with me and care for the household,

true to her husband’s bed, the people’s voice as well,

85or leave at long last with the best man in Achaea

who courts her in the halls, who offers her the most.

But our new guest, since he’s arrived at your house,

I’ll give him a shirt and cloak to wear, good clothing,

give him a two-edged sword and sandals for his feet

90and send him off, wherever his heart desires.

Or if you’d rather, keep him here at the farmstead,

tend to him here, and I’ll send up the clothes

and full rations to keep the man in food;

he’ll be no drain on you and all your men.

But I can’t let him go down and join the suitors.

They’re far too abusive, reckless, know no limits:

they’ll make a mockery of him—that would break my heart.

It’s hard for a man to win his way against a mob,

even a man of iron. They are much too strong.”

100“Friend”—the long-enduring Odysseus stepped in—

“surely it’s right for me to say a word at this point.

My heart, by god, is torn to pieces hearing this,

both of you telling how these reckless suitors,

there in your own house, against your will,

plot your ruin—a fine young prince like you.

Tell me, though, do you let yourself be so abused

or do people round about, stirred up by the prompting

of some god, despise you? Or are your brothers at fault?

Brothers a man can trust to fight beside him, true,

110no matter what deadly blood-feud rages on.

Would I were young as you, to match my spirit now,

or I were the son of great Odysseus, or the king himself

returned from all his roving—there’s still room for hope!

Then let some foreigner lop my head off if I failed

to march right into Odysseus’ royal halls

and kill them all. And what if I went down,

crushed by their numbers—I, fighting alone?

I’d rather die, cut down in my own house

than have to look on at their outrage day by day.

120Guests treated to blows, men dragging the serving-women

through the noble house, exploiting them all, no shame,

and the gushing wine swilled, the food squandered—

gorging for gorging’s sake—

and the courting game goes on, no end in sight!”

“You’re right, my friend,” sober Telemachus agreed.

“Now let me tell you the whole story, first to last.

It’s not that all our people have turned against me,

keen for a showdown. Nor have I any brothers at fault,

brothers a man can trust to fight beside him, true,

130no matter what deadly blood-feud rages on…

131Zeus made our line a line of only sons.

Arcesius had only one son, Laertes,

and Laertes had only one son, Odysseus,

and I am Odysseus’ only son. He fathered me,

he left me behind at home, and from me he got no joy.

So now our house is plagued by swarms of enemies.

All the nobles who rule the islands round about,

Dulichion, and Same, and wooded Zacynthus too,

and all who lord it in rocky Ithaca as well—

140down to the last man they court my mother,

they lay waste my house! And mother…

she neither rejects a marriage she despises

nor can she bear to bring the courting to an end—

while they continue to bleed my household white.

Soon—you wait—they’ll grind me down as well!

But all lies in the lap of the great gods.

Eumaeus,

good old friend, go, quickly, to wise Penelope.

Tell her I’m home from Pylos safe and sound.

I’ll stay on right here. But you come back

150as soon as you’ve told the news to her alone.

No other Achaean must hear—

all too many plot to take my life.”

“I know,”

you assured your prince, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd.

“I see your point—there’s sense in this old head.

One thing more, and make your orders clear.

On the same trip do I go and give the news

to King Laertes too? For many years, poor man,

heartsick for his son, he’d always keep an eye

on the farm and take his meals with the hired hands

160whenever he felt the urge to. Now, from the day

you sailed away to Pylos, not a sip or a bite

he’s touched, they say, not as he did before,

and his eyes are shut to all the farmyard labors.

Huddled over, groaning in grief and tears,

he wastes away—the man’s all skin and bones.”

“So much the worse,” Telemachus answered firmly.

“Leave him alone; though it hurts us now, we must.

If men could have all they want, free for the taking,

I’d take first my father’s journey home. So,

170you go and give the message, then come back,

no roaming over the fields to find Laertes.

Tell my mother to send her housekeeper,

fast as she can, in secret—

she can give the poor old man the news.”

That roused Eumaeus. The swineherd grasped his sandals,

strapped them onto his feet and made for town.

His exit did not escape Athena’s notice…

Approaching, closer, now she appeared a woman,

beautiful, tall and skilled at weaving lovely things.

180Just at the shelter’s door she stopped, visible to Odysseus

but Telemachus could not see her, sense her there—

the gods don’t show themselves to every man alive.

Odysseus saw her, so did the dogs; no barking now,

they whimpered, cringing away in terror through the yard.

She gave a sign with her brows, Odysseus caught it,

out of the lodge he went and past the high stockade

and stood before the goddess. Athena urged him on:

“Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, old campaigner,

now is the time, now tell your son the truth.

190Hold nothing back, so the two of you can plot

the suitors’ doom and then set out for town.

I myself won’t lag behind you long—

I’m blazing for a battle!”

Athena stroked him with her golden wand.

First she made the cloak and shirt on his body

fresh and clean, then made him taller, supple, young,

his ruddy tan came back, the cut of his jawline firmed

and the dark beard clustered black around his chin.

Her work complete, she went her way once more

200and Odysseus returned to the lodge. His own son

gazed at him, wonderstruck, terrified too, turning

his eyes away, suddenly—

this must be some god—

and he let fly with a burst of exclamations:

“Friend, you’re a new man—not what I saw before!

Your clothes, they’ve changed, even your skin has changed—

surely you are some god who rules the vaulting skies!

Oh be kind, and we will give you offerings,

gifts of hammered gold to warm your heart—

spare us, please, I beg you!”

“No, I am not a god,”

210the long-enduring, great Odysseus returned.

“Why confuse me with one who never dies?

No, I am your father—

the Odysseus you wept for all your days,

you bore a world of pain, the cruel abuse of men.”

And with those words Odysseus kissed his son

and the tears streamed down his cheeks and wet the ground,

though before he’d always reined his emotions back.

But still not convinced that it was his father,

Telemachus broke out, wild with disbelief,

220“No, you’re not Odysseus! Not my father!

Just some spirit spellbinding me now—

to make me ache with sorrow all the more.

Impossible for a mortal to work such marvels,

not with his own devices, not unless some god

comes down in person, eager to make that mortal

young or old—like that! Why, just now

you were old, and wrapped in rags, but now, look,

you seem like a god who rules the skies up there!”

“Telemachus,” Odysseus, man of exploits, urged his son,

230“it’s wrong to marvel, carried away in wonder so

to see your father here before your eyes.

No other Odysseus will ever return to you.

That man and I are one, the man you see…

here after many hardships,

endless wanderings, after twenty years

I have come home to native ground at last.

My changing so? Athena’s work, the Fighter’s Queen—

she has that power, she makes me look as she likes,

now like a beggar, the next moment a young man,

240decked out in handsome clothes about my body.

It’s light work for the gods who rule the skies

to exalt a mortal man or bring him low.”

At that

Odysseus sat down again, and Telemachus threw his arms

around his great father, sobbing uncontrollably

as the deep desire for tears welled up in both.

They cried out, shrilling cries, pulsing sharper

than birds of prey—eagles, vultures with hooked claws—

when farmers plunder their nest of young too young to fly.

Both men so filled with compassion, eyes streaming tears,

250that now the sunlight would have set upon their cries

if Telemachus had not asked his father, all at once,

“What sort of ship, dear father, brought you here?—

Ithaca, at last. Who did the sailors say they are?

I hardly think you came back home on foot!”

So long an exile, great Odysseus replied,

“Surely, my son, I’ll tell you the whole story now.

Phaeacians brought me here, the famous sailors

who ferry home all men who reach their shores.

They sailed me across the sea in their swift ship,

260they set me down in Ithaca, sound asleep, and gave me

glittering gifts—bronze and hoards of gold and robes.

All lie stowed in a cave, thanks to the gods’ help,

and Athena’s inspiration spurred me here, now,

so we could plan the slaughter of our foes.

Come, give me the full tally of these suitors—

I must know their numbers, gauge their strength.

Then I’ll deploy this old tactician’s wits,

decide if the two of us can take them on,

alone, without allies,

or we should hunt reserves to back us up.”

270“Father,”

clear-headed Telemachus countered quickly,

“all my life I’ve heard of your great fame—

a brave man in war and a deep mind in counsel—

but what you say dumbfounds me, staggers imagination!

How on earth could two men fight so many and so strong?

These suitors are not just ten or twenty, they’re far more—

you count them up for yourself now, take a moment…

From Dulichion, fifty-two of them, picked young men,

six servants in their troop; from Same, twenty-four,

280from Zacynthus, twenty Achaeans, nobles all,

and the twelve best lords from Ithaca itself.

Medon the herald’s with them, a gifted bard,

and two henchmen, skilled to carve their meat.

If we pit ourselves against all these in the house,

I fear the revenge you come back home to take

will recoil on our heads—a bitter, deadly blow.

Think: can you come up with a friend-in-arms?

Some man to fight beside us, some brave heart?”

“Let me tell you,” the old soldier said,

290“bear it in mind now, listen to me closely.

Think: will Athena flanked by Father Zeus

do for the two of us?

Or shall I rack my brains for another champion?”

Telemachus answered shrewdly, full of poise,

“Two great champions, those you name, it’s true.

Off in the clouds they sit

and they lord it over gods and mortal men.”

“Trust me,” his seasoned father reassured him,

“they won’t hold off long from the cries and clash of battle,

300not when we and the suitors put our fighting strength

to proof in my own halls! But now, with daybreak,

home you go and mix with that overbearing crowd.

The swineherd will lead me into the city later,

looking old and broken, a beggar once again.

If they abuse me in the palace, steel yourself,

no matter what outrage I must suffer, even

if they drag me through our house by the heels

and throw me out or pelt me with things they hurl—

you just look on, endure it. Prompt them to quit

310their wild reckless ways, try to win them over

with friendly words. Those men will never listen,

now the day of doom is hovering at their heads.

One more thing. Take it to heart, I urge you.

When Athena, Queen of Tactics, tells me it is time,

I’ll give you a nod, and when you catch that signal

round up all the deadly weapons kept in the hall,

stow them away upstairs in a storeroom’s deep recess—

all the arms and armor—and when the suitors miss them

and ask you questions, put them off with a winning story:

320‘I stowed them away, clear of the smoke. A far cry

from the arms Odysseus left when he went to Troy,

fire-damaged equipment, black with reeking fumes.

And a god reminded me of something darker too.

When you’re in your cups a quarrel might break out,

you’d wound each other, shame your feasting here

and cast a pall on your courting.

327Iron has powers to draw a man to ruin.’

Just you leave

a pair of swords for the two of us, a pair of spears

and a pair of oxhide bucklers right at hand so we

330can break for the weapons, seize them! Then Athena,

Zeus in his wisdom—they will daze the suitors’ wits.

Now one last thing. Bear it in mind. You must.

If you are my own true son, born of my blood,

let no one hear that Odysseus has come home.

Don’t let Laertes know, not Eumaeus either,

none in the household, not Penelope herself.

You and I alone will assess the women’s mood

and we might test a few of the serving-men as well:

where are the ones who still respect us both,

340who hold us in awe? And who shirk their duties?—

slighting you because you are so young.”

“Soon enough, father,” his gallant son replied,

“you’ll sense the courage inside me, that I know—

I’m hardly a flighty, weak-willed boy these days.

But I think your last plan would gain us nothing.

Reconsider, I urge you.

You’ll waste time, roaming around our holdings,

probing the fieldhands man by man, while the suitors

sit at ease in our house, devouring all our goods—

350those brazen rascals never spare a scrap!

But I do advise you to sound the women out:

who are disloyal to you, who are guiltless?

The men—I say no to testing them farm by farm.

That’s work for later, if you have really seen

a sign from Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder.”

Now as father and son conspired, shaping plans,

the ship that brought the prince and shipmates back

from Pylos was just approaching Ithaca, home port.

As soon as they put in to the harbor’s deep bay

360they hauled the black vessel up onto dry land

and eager deckhands bore away their gear

and rushed the priceless gifts to Clytius’ house.

But they sent a herald on to Odysseus’ halls at once

to give the news to thoughtful, cautious Penelope

that Telemachus was home—just up-country now

but he’d told his mates to sail across to port—

so the noble queen would not be seized with fright

and break down in tears. And now those two men met,

herald and swineherd, both out on the same errand,

370to give the queen the news. But once they reached

the house of the royal king the herald strode up,

into the serving-women’s midst, and burst out,

“Your beloved son, my queen, is home at last!”

Eumaeus though, bending close to Penelope,

whispered every word that her dear son

entrusted him to say. Message told in full,

he left the halls and precincts, heading for his pigs.

But the news shook the suitors, dashed their spirits.

Out of the halls they crowded, past the high-walled court

380and there before the gates they sat in council.

Polybus’ son Eurymachus opened up among them:

“Friends, what a fine piece of work he’s carried off!

Telemachus—what insolence—and we thought his little jaunt

would come to grief! Up now, launch a black ship,

the best we can find—muster a crew of oarsmen,

row the news to our friends in ambush, fast,

bring them back at once.”

And just then—

388he’d not quite finished when Amphinomus,

wheeling round in his seat,

390saw their vessel moored in the deep harbor,

their comrades striking sail and hoisting oars.

He broke into heady laughter, called his friends:

“No need for a message now. They’re home, look there!

Some god gave them the news, or they saw the prince’s ship

go sailing past and failed to overtake her.”

Rising, all trooped down to the water’s edge

as the crew hauled the vessel up onto dry land

and the hot-blooded hands bore off their gear.

Then in a pack they went to the meeting grounds,

400suffering no one else, young or old, to sit among them.

Eupithes’ son Antinous rose and harangued them all:

“What a blow! See how the gods have saved this boy

from bloody death? And our lookouts all day long,

stationed atop the windy heights, kept watch,

shift on shift; and once the sun went down

we’d never sleep the night ashore, never,

always aboard our swift ship, cruising till dawn,

patrolling to catch Telemachus, kill him on the spot,

and all the while some spirit whisked him home!

410So here at home we’ll plot his certain death:

he must never slip through our hands again,

that boy—while he still lives,

I swear we’ll never bring our venture off.

The clever little schemer, he does have his skills,

and the crowds no longer show us favor, not at all.

So act! before he can gather his people in assembly.

He’ll never give in an inch, I know, he’ll rise

and rage away, shouting out to them all how we,

we schemed his sudden death but never caught him.

420Hearing of our foul play, they’ll hardly sing our praises.

Why, they might do us damage, run us off our lands,

drive us abroad to hunt for strangers’ shores.

Strike first, I say, and kill him!—

clear of town, in the fields or on the road.

Then we’ll seize his estates and worldly goods,

carve them up between us, share and share alike.

But as for his palace, let his mother keep it,

she and the man she weds.

There’s my plan.

If you find it offensive, if you want him

430living on—in full command of his patrimony—

gather here no more then, living the life of kings,

consuming all his wealth. Each from his own house

must try to win her, showering her with gifts.

Then she can marry the one who offers most,

the man marked out by fate to be her husband.”

That brought them all to a hushed, stunned silence

till Amphinomus rose to have his say among them—

438the noted son of Nisus, King Aretias’ grandson,

the chief who led the suitors from Dulichion,

440land of grass and grains,

441and the man who pleased Penelope the most,

thanks to his timely words and good clear sense.

Concerned for their welfare now, he stood and argued:

“Friends, I’ve no desire to kill Telemachus, not I—

it’s a terrible thing to shed the blood of kings.

Wait, sound out the will of the gods—that first.

If the decrees of mighty Zeus commend the work,

I’ll kill the prince myself and spur on all the rest.

If the gods are against it, then I say hold back!”

450So Amphinomus urged, and won them over.

They rose at once, returned to Odysseus’ palace,

entered and took their seats on burnished chairs.

But now an inspiration took the discreet Penelope

to face her suitors, brutal, reckless men.

The queen had heard it all…

how they plotted inside the house to kill her son.

The herald Medon told her—he’d overheard their schemes.

And so, flanked by her ladies, she descended to the hall.

That luster of women, once she reached her suitors,

460drawing her glistening veil across her cheeks,

paused now where a column propped the sturdy roof

and rounding on Antinous, cried out against him:

“You, Antinous! Violent, vicious, scheming—

you, they say, are the best man your age in Ithaca,

best for eloquence, counsel. You’re nothing of the sort!

Madman, why do you weave destruction for Telemachus?—

show no pity to those who need it?—those over whom

almighty Zeus stands guard. It’s wrong, unholy, yes,

weaving death for those who deserve your mercy!

470Don’t you know how your father fled here once?

A fugitive, terrified of the people, up in arms

against him because he’d joined some Taphian pirates

473out to attack Thesprotians, sworn allies of ours.

The mobs were set to destroy him, rip his life out,

devour his vast wealth to their heart’s content,

but Odysseus held them back, he kept their fury down.

And this is the man whose house you waste, scot-free,

whose wife you court, whose son you mean to kill—

you make my life an agony! Stop, I tell you,

480stop all this, and make the rest stop too!”

But Polybus’ son Eurymachus tried to calm her:

“Wise Penelope, daughter of Icarius, courage!

Disabuse yourself of all these worries now.

That man is not alive—

he never will be, he never can be born—

who’ll lift a hand against Telemachus, your son,

not while I walk the land and I can see the light.

I tell you this—so help me, it will all come true—

in an instant that man’s blood will spurt around my spear!

490My spear, since time and again Odysseus dandled me

on his knees, the great raider of cities fed me

roasted meat and held the red wine to my lips.

So to me your son is the dearest man alive,

and I urge the boy to have no fear of death,

not from the suitors at least.

What comes from the gods—there’s no escaping that.”

Encouraging, all the way, but all the while

plotting the prince’s murder in his mind…

The queen, going up to her lofty well-lit room,

500fell to weeping for Odysseus, her beloved husband,

till watchful Athena sealed her eyes with welcome sleep.

Returning just at dusk to Odysseus and his son,

the loyal swineherd found they’d killed a yearling pig

and standing over it now were busy cooking supper.

But Athena had approached Laertes’ son Odysseus,

tapped him with her wand and made him old again.

She dressed him in filthy rags too, for fear Eumaeus,

recognizing his master face-to-face, might hurry

back to shrewd Penelope, blurting out the news

510and never hide the secret in his heart.

Telemachus was the first to greet the swineherd:

“Welcome home, my friend! What’s the talk in town?

Are the swaggering suitors back from ambush yet—

or still waiting to catch me coming home?”

You answered the prince, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“I had no time to go roaming all through town,

digging round for that. My heart raced me on

to get my message told and rush back here.

But I met up with a fast runner there,

520sent by your crew, a herald,

first to tell your mother all the news.

And this I know, I saw with my own eyes—

I was just above the city, heading home,

clambering over Hermes’ Ridge, when I caught sight

of a trim ship pulling into the harbor, loaded down

with a crowd aboard her, shields and two-edged spears.

I think they’re the men you’re after—I’m not sure.”

At that the young prince Telemachus smiled,

glancing toward his father, avoiding Eumaeus’ eyes.

And now,

530with the roasting done, the meal set out, they ate well

and no one’s hunger lacked a proper share of supper.

When they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

they remembered bed and took the gift of sleep.

BOOK SEVENTEEN

Stranger at the Gates

W
hen young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

Telemachus strapped his rawhide sandals to his feet

and the young prince, the son of King Odysseus,

picked up the rugged spear that fit his grip

and striking out for the city, told his swineherd,

“I’m off to town, old friend, to present myself to mother.

She’ll never stop her bitter tears and mourning,

well I know, till she sees me face-to-face.

And for you I have some orders—

10take this luckless stranger to town, so he can beg

his supper there, and whoever wants can give the man

some crumbs and a cup to drink. How can I put up with

every passerby? My mind’s weighed down with troubles.

If the stranger resents it, all the worse for him.

I like to tell the truth and tell it plainly.”

“My friend,

subtle Odysseus broke in, “I’ve no desire, myself,

to linger here. Better that beggars cadge their meals

in town than in the fields. Some willing soul

will see to my needs. I’m hardly fit, at my age,

20to keep to a farm and jump to a foreman’s every order.

Go on then. This man will take me, as you’ve told him,

once I’m warm from the fire and the sun’s good and strong.

Look at the clothing on my back—all rags and tatters.

I’m afraid the frost at dawn could do me in,

and town, you say, is a long hard way from here.”

At that Telemachus strode down through the farm

in quick, firm strides, brooding death for the suitors.

And once he reached his well-constructed palace,

propping his spear against a sturdy pillar

30and crossing the stone threshold, in he went.

His old nurse was the first to see him, Eurycleia,

just spreading fleeces over the carved, inlaid chairs.

Tears sprang to her eyes, she rushed straight to the prince

as the other maids of great Odysseus flocked around him,

hugged him warmly, kissed his head and shoulders.

Now down from her chamber came discreet Penelope,

looking for all the world like Artemis or golden Aphrodite—

bursting into tears as she flung her arms around her darling son

and kissed his face and kissed his shining eyes and sobbed,

40“You’re home, Telemachus!”—words flew from her heart—

“sweet light of my eyes! I never thought I’d see you again,

once you shipped to Pylos—against my will, so secret,

out for news of your dear father. Quick tell me,

did you catch sight of the man—meet him—what?”

“Please, mother,” steady Telemachus replied,

“don’t move me to tears, don’t stir the heart inside me.

I’ve just escaped from death. Sudden death.

No. Bathe now, put on some fresh clothes,

go up to your own room with your serving-women,

50pray, and promise the gods a generous sacrifice

to bring success, if Zeus will ever grant us

the hour of our revenge. I myself am off

to the meeting grounds to summon up a guest

who came with me from abroad when I sailed home.

I sent him on ahead with my trusted crew.

I told Piraeus to take him to his house,

treat him well, host him with all good will

till I could come myself.”

Words to the mark

that left his mother silent…

60She bathed now, put on some fresh clothes,

prayed, and promised the gods a generous sacrifice

to bring success, if Zeus would ever grant

the hour of their revenge.

Spear in hand,

Telemachus strode on through the hall and out,

and a pair of sleek hounds went trotting at his heels.

And Athena lavished a marvelous splendor on the prince

so the people all gazed in wonder as he came forward.

The swaggering suitors clustered, milling round him,

welcome words on their lips, and murder in their hearts.

70But he gave them a wide berth as they came crowding in

71and there where Mentor sat, Antiphus, Halitherses too—

his father’s loyal friends from days gone by—

he took his seat as they pressed him with their questions.

And just then Piraeus the gallant spearman approached,

leading the stranger through the town and out onto

the meeting grounds. Telemachus, not hanging back,

went right up to greet Theoclymenus, his guest,

but Piraeus spoke out first: “Quickly now,

Telemachus, send some women to my house

80to retrieve the gifts that Menelaus gave you.”

“Wait, Piraeus,” wary Telemachus cautioned,

“we’ve no idea how all of this will go.

If the brazen suitors cut me down in the palace—

off guard—and carve apart my father’s whole estate,

I’d rather you yourself, or one of his friends here,

keep those gifts and get some pleasure from them.

But if I can bring down slaughter on that crew,

you send the gifts to my house—we’ll share the joy.”

Their plans made, he led the wayworn stranger home

90and once they reached the well-constructed palace,

spreading out their cloaks on a chair or bench,

into the burnished tubs they climbed and bathed.

When women had washed them, rubbed them down with oil

and drawn warm fleece and shirts around their shoulders,

out of the baths they stepped and sat on high-backed chairs.

A maid brought water soon in a graceful golden pitcher

and over a silver basin tipped it out

so they might rinse their hands,

then pulled a gleaming table to their side.

100A staid housekeeper brought on bread to serve them,

appetizers aplenty too, lavish with her bounty.

Penelope sat across from her son, beside a pillar,

leaning back on a low chair and winding finespun yarn.

They reached out for the good things that lay at hand

and when they’d put aside desire for food and drink,

the queen, for all her composure, said at last,

“Telemachus, I’m going back to my room upstairs

and lie down on my bed…

that bed of pain my tears have streaked, year in,

110year out, from the day Odysseus sailed away to Troy

with Atreus’ two sons.

But you, you never had the heart—

before those insolent suitors crowd back to the house—

to tell me clearly about your father’s journey home,

if you’ve heard any news.”

“Of course, mother,”

thoughtful Telemachus reassured her quickly,

“I will tell you the whole true story now.

We sailed to Pylos, to Nestor, the great king,

and he received me there in his lofty palace,

treated me well and warmly, yes, as a father treats

120a long-lost son just home from voyaging, years abroad:

such care he showered on me, he and his noble sons.

But of strong, enduring Odysseus, dead or alive,

he’s heard no news, he said, from any man on earth.

He sent me on to the famous spearman Atrides Menelaus,

on with a team of horses drawing a bolted chariot.

And there I saw her, Helen of Argos—all for her

Achaeans and Trojans suffered so much hardship,

thanks to the gods’ decree…

The lord of the warcry, Menelaus, asked at once

130what pressing need had brought me to lovely Lacedaemon,

and when I told him the whole story, first to last,

the king burst out, ‘How shameful! That’s the bed

of a brave man of war they’d like to crawl inside,

those spineless, craven cowards!

Weak as the doe that beds down her fawns

in a mighty lion’s den—her newborn sucklings—

then trails off to the mountain spurs and grassy bends

to graze her fill, but back the lion comes to his own lair

and the master deals both fawns a ghastly bloody death,

140just what Odysseus will deal that mob—ghastly death.

Ah if only—Father Zeus, Athena and lord Apollo—

that man who years ago in the games at Lesbos

rose to Philomelides’ challenge, wrestled him,

pinned him down with one tremendous throw

and the Argives roared with joy…

if only that Odysseus sported with those suitors,

a blood wedding, a quick death would take the lot!

But about the things you’ve asked me, so intently,

I’ll skew and sidestep nothing, not deceive you, ever.

150Of all he told me—the Old Man of the Sea who never lies—

I’ll hide or hold back nothing, not a single word.

He said he’d seen Odysseus on an island,

ground down in misery, off in a goddess’ house,

the nymph Calypso, who holds him there by force.

He has no way to voyage home to his own native land,

no trim ships in reach, no crew to ply the oars

and send him scudding over the sea’s broad back.’

So Menelaus, the famous spearman, told me.

My mission accomplished, back I came at once,

160and the gods sent me a stiff following wind

that sped me home to the native land I love.”

His reassurance stirred the queen to her depths

and the godlike seer Theoclymenus added firmly,

“Noble lady, wife of Laertes’ son, Odysseus,

Menelaus can have no perfect revelations;

mark my words—I will make you a prophecy,

quite precise, and I’ll hold nothing back.

I swear by Zeus, the first of all the gods,

by this table of hospitality here, my host,

170by Odysseus’ hearth where I have come for help—

I swear Odysseus is on native soil, here and now!

Poised or on the prowl, learning of these rank crimes

he’s sowing seeds of ruin for all your suitors.

So clear, so true, that bird-sign I saw

175as I sat on the benched ship

and sounded out the future to the prince!”

“If only, my friend,” reserved Penelope exclaimed,

“everything you say would come to pass!

You’d soon know my affection, know my gifts.

180Any man you meet would call you blest.”

And so the three confided in the halls

while all the suitors, before Odysseus’ palace,

amused themselves with discus and long throwing spears,

out on the leveled grounds, free and easy as always,

full of swagger. When the dinner-hour approached

and sheep came home from pastures near and far,

driven in by familiar drovers,

Medon called them all, their favorite herald,

always present at their meals: “My young lords,

190now you’ve played your games to your hearts’ content,

come back to the halls so we can fix your supper.

Nothing’s better than dining well on time!”

They came at his summons, rising from the games

and now, bustling into the well-constructed palace,

flinging down their cloaks on a chair or bench,

they butchered hulking sheep and fatted goats,

full-grown hogs and a young cow from the herd,

preparing for their feast.

At the same time

the king and his loyal swineherd geared to leave

200the country for the town. Eumaeus, foreman of men,

set things in motion: “Friend, I know you’re keen

on going down to town today, just as my master bid,

though I’d rather you stay here to guard the farm.

But I prize the boy, I fear he’ll blame me later—

a dressing-down from your master’s hard to bear.

So off we go now. The shank of the day is past.

You’ll find it colder with nightfall coming on.”

“I know, I see your point,” the crafty man replied.

“There’s sense in this old head. So let’s be off.

210And from now on, you lead me all the way.

Just give me a stick to lean on,

if you have one ready-cut. You say the road

is treacherous, full of slips and slides.”

With that

he flung his beggar’s sack across his shoulders—

torn and tattered, slung from a fraying rope.

Eumaeus gave him a staff that met his needs.

Then the two moved out, leaving behind them

dogs and herdsmen to stay and guard the farm.

And so the servant led his master toward the city,

220looking for all the world like an old and broken beggar

hunched on a stick, his body wrapped in shameful rags…

Down over the rugged road they went till hard by town

they reached the stone-rimmed fountain running clear

where the city people came and drew their water.

225Ithacus built it once, with Neritus and Polyctor.

Round it a stand of poplar thrived on the dank soil,

all in a nestling ring, and down from a rock-ledge overhead

the cold water splashed, and crowning the fountain

rose an altar-stone erected to the nymphs,

230where every traveler paused and left an offering.

231Here Dolius’ son, Melanthius, crossed their path,

herding his goats with a pair of drovers’ help,

the pick of his flocks to make the suitors’ meal.

As soon as he saw them there he broke into a flood

of brutal, foul abuse that made Odysseus’ blood boil.

“Look!”—he sneered—“one scum nosing another scum along,

dirt finds dirt by the will of god—it never fails!

Wretched pig-boy, where do you take your filthy swine,

this sickening beggar who licks the pots at feasts?

240Hanging round the doorposts, rubbing his back,

scavenging after scraps,

no hero’s swords and cauldrons, not for him.

Hand him over to me—I’ll teach him to work a farm,

muck out my stalls, pitch feed to the young goats;

whey to drink will put some muscle on his hams!

Oh no, he’s learned his lazy ways too well,

he’s got no itch to stick to good hard work,

he’d rather go scrounging round the countryside,

begging for crusts to stuff his greedy gut!

250Let me tell you—so help me it’s the truth—

if he sets foot in King Odysseus’ royal palace,

salvos of footstools flung at his head by all the lords

will crack his ribs as he runs the line of fire through the house!”

Wild, reckless taunts—and just as he passed Odysseus

the idiot lurched out with a heel and kicked his hip

but he couldn’t knock the beggar off the path,

he stood his ground so staunchly. Odysseus was torn…

should he wheel with his staff and beat the scoundrel senseless?—

or hoist him by the midriff, split his skull on the rocks?

260He steeled himself instead, his mind in full control.

But Eumaeus glared at the goatherd, cursed him to his face,

then lifted up his hands and prayed his heart out:

“O nymphs of the fountain, daughters of Zeus—

if Odysseus ever burned you the long thighs

of lambs or kids, covered with rich fat,

now bring my prayer to pass!

Let that man come back—some god guide him now!

He’d toss to the winds the flashy show you make,

Melanthius, so cocksure—always strutting round the town

270while worthless fieldhands leave your flocks a shambles!”

“Listen to him!” the goatherd shouted back.

“All bark and no bite from the vicious mutt!

One fine day I’ll ship him out in a black lugger,

miles from Ithaca—sell him off for a good stiff price!

Just let Apollo shoot Telemachus down with his silver bow,

today in the halls, or the suitors snuff his life out—

as sure as I know the day of the king’s return

is blotted out, the king is worlds away!”

With his parting shot he left them trudging on

280and went and reached the royal house in no time.

Slipping in, he took his seat among the suitors,

facing Eurymachus, who favored him the most.

The carvers set before him his plate of meat,

a staid housekeeper brought the man his bread.

And now at last the king and loyal swineherd,

drawing near the palace, halted just outside

as the lyre’s rippling music drifted round them—

Phemius, striking up a song for assembled guests—

and the master seized his servant’s hand, exclaiming,

290“Friend, what a noble house! Odysseus’ house, it must be!

No mistaking it—you could tell it among a townful, look.

One building linked to the next, and the courtyard wall

is finished off with a fine coping, the double doors

are battle-proof—no man could break them down!

I can tell a crowd is feasting there in force—

smell the savor of roasts… the ringing lyre, listen,

the lyre that god has made the friend of feasts.”

“An easy guess,” you said, Eumaeus, swineherd,

“for a man as keen as you at every turn.

300Put heads together. What do we do next?

Either you’re the first one into the palace—

mix with the suitors, leave me where I am.

Or if you like, stay put, and I’ll go first myself.

Don’t linger long. Someone might spot you here outside,

knock you down or pelt you. Mark my words. Take care.”

The man who’d borne long years abroad replied,

“Well I know. Remember? There’s sense in this old head.

You go in, you first, while I stay here behind.

Stones and blows and I are hardly strangers.

310My heart is steeled by now,

I’ve had my share of pain in the waves and wars.

Add this to the total. Bring the trial on.

But there’s no way to hide the belly’s hungers—

what a curse, what mischief it brews in all our lives!

Just for hunger we rig and ride our long benched ships

on the barren salt sea, speeding death to enemies.”

Now, as they talked on, a dog that lay there

lifted up his muzzle, pricked his ears…

319It was Argos, long-enduring Odysseus’ dog

320he trained as a puppy once, but little joy he got

since all too soon he shipped to sacred Troy.

In the old days young hunters loved to set him

coursing after the wild goats and deer and hares.

But now with his master gone he lay there, castaway,

on piles of dung from mules and cattle, heaps collecting

out before the gates till Odysseus’ serving-men

could cart it off to manure the king’s estates.

Infested with ticks, half-dead from neglect,

here lay the hound, old Argos.

330But the moment he sensed Odysseus standing by

he thumped his tail, nuzzling low, and his ears dropped,

though he had no strength to drag himself an inch

toward his master. Odysseus glanced to the side

and flicked away a tear, hiding it from Eumaeus,

diverting his friend in a hasty, offhand way:

“Strange, Eumaeus, look, a dog like this,

lying here on a dung-hill…

what handsome lines! But I can’t say for sure

if he had the running speed to match his looks

340or he was only the sort that gentry spoil at table,

show-dogs masters pamper for their points.”

You told the stranger, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“Here—it’s all too true—here’s the dog of a man

who died in foreign parts. But if he had now

the form and flair he had in his glory days—

as Odysseus left him, sailing off to Troy—

you’d be amazed to see such speed, such strength.

No quarry he chased in the deepest, darkest woods

could ever slip this hound. A champion tracker too!

350Ah, but he’s run out of luck now, poor fellow…

his master’s dead and gone, so far from home,

and the heartless women tend him not at all. Slaves,

with their lords no longer there to crack the whip,

lose all zest to perform their duties well. Zeus,

the Old Thunderer, robs a man of half his virtue

the day the yoke clamps down around his neck.”

With that he entered the well-constructed palace,

strode through the halls and joined the proud suitors.

But the dark shadow of death closed down on Argos’ eyes

360the instant he saw Odysseus, twenty years away.

Now Prince Telemachus, first by far to note

the swineherd coming down the hall, nodded briskly,

called and waved him on. Eumaeus, glancing about,

picked up a handy stool where the carver always sat,

slicing meat for the suitors feasting through the house.

He took and put it beside the prince’s table, facing him,

straddled it himself as a steward set a plate of meat

before the man and served him bread from trays.

Right behind him came Odysseus, into his own house,

370looking for all the world like an old and broken beggar

hunched on a stick, his body wrapped in shameful rags.

Just in the doorway, just at the ashwood threshold,

there he settled down…

leaning against the cypress post a master joiner

planed smooth and hung with a plumb line years ago.

Telemachus motioned the swineherd over now,

and choosing a whole loaf from a fine wicker tray

and as much meat as his outstretched hands could hold,

he said, “Now take these to the stranger, tell him too

380to make the rounds of the suitors, beg from one and all.

Bashfulness, for a man in need, is no great friend.”

And Eumaeus did his bidding, went straight up

to the guest and winged a greeting: “Here, stranger,

Prince Telemachus sends you these, and tells you too

to make the rounds of the suitors, beg from one and all.

Bashfulness for a beggar, he says, is no great friend.”

“Powerful Zeus!” the crafty king responded,

“grant that your prince be blest among mankind—

and all his heart’s desires come to pass!”

390Taking the food in both hands, setting it down,

spread out on his filthy sack before his feet,

the beggar fell to his meal

as the singer raised a song throughout the house.

Once he’d supped and the stirring bard had closed,

the suitors broke into uproar down along the hall.

And now Athena came to the side of Laertes’ royal son

and urged him, “Go now, gather crusts from all the suitors,

test them, so we can tell the innocent from the guilty.”

But not even so would Athena save one man from death.

400Still, off he went, begging from each in turn,

circling left to right, reaching out his hand

like a beggar from the day that he was born.

They pitied him, gave him scraps, were puzzled too,

asking each other, “Who is this?” “Where’s he from?”

Till the goatherd Melanthius shouted out in their midst,

“Listen to me, you lords who court our noble queen—

I’ll tell you about the stranger. I’ve seen him before.

I know for a fact the swineherd led him in,

though I have no idea who the fellow is

or where he thinks he comes from.”

410At that

Antinous wheeled on Eumaeus, lashing out at him:

“Your highness, swineherd—why drag this to town?

Haven’t we got our share of vagabonds to deal with,

disgusting beggars who lick the feasters’ plates?

Isn’t it quite enough, these swarming crowds

consuming your master’s bounty—

must you invite this rascal in the bargain?”

“Antinous,

highborn as you are,” you told the man, Eumaeus,

“that was a mean low speech!

420Now who’d go out, who on his own hook—

not I—and ask a stranger in from nowhere

unless he had some skills to serve the house?

A prophet, a healer who cures disease, a worker in wood

or even a god-inspired bard whose singing warms the heart—

they’re the ones asked in around the world. A beggar?

Who’d invite a beggar to bleed his household white?

You, you of all the suitors are always roughest

on the servants of our king, on me most of all.

Not that I care, no, so long as his queen,

430his wise queen, is still alive in the palace,

Prince Telemachus too.”

“Stop, Eumaeus,”

poised Telemachus broke in quickly now,

“don’t waste so much breath on Antinous here.

It’s just his habit to bait a man with abuse

and spur the rest as well.”

He wheeled on the suitor,

letting loose: “How kind you are to me, Antinous,

kind as a father to his son! Encouraging me

to send this stranger packing from my house

with a harsh command! I’d never do it. God forbid.

440Take and give to the beggar. I don’t grudge it—

I’d even urge you on. No scruples now,

never fear your gifts will upset my mother

or any servant in King Odysseus’ royal house.

But no such qualm could enter that head of yours,

bent on feeding your own face, not feeding strangers!”

Antinous countered the young prince in kind:

“So high and mighty, Telemachus—such unbridled rage!

If all the suitors gave him the sort of gift I’ll give,

the house would be rid of him for three whole months!”

450With that, from under his table he seized the stool

that propped his smooth feet as he reveled on—

just lifting it into view…

But as for the rest,

all gave to the beggar, filled his sack with handouts,

bread and meat. And Odysseus seemed at the point

of getting back to his doorsill,

done with testing suitors, home free himself

when he stopped beside Antinous, begging face-to-face:

“Give me a morsel, friend. You’re hardly the worst

Achaean here, it seems. The noblest one, in fact.

460You look like a king to me!

So you should give a bigger crust than the rest

and I will sing your praises all across the earth.

I too once lived in a lofty house that men admired;

rolling in wealth, I’d often give to a vagabond like myself,

whoever he was, whatever need had brought him to my door.

And crowds of servants I had, and lots of all it takes

to live the life of ease, to make men call you rich.

But Zeus ruined it all—god’s will, no doubt—

when he shipped me off with a roving band of pirates

470bound for Egypt, a long hard sail, to wreck my life.

There in the Nile delta I moored our ships of war.

God knows I ordered my trusty crews to stand by,

just where they were, and guard the anchored fleet

and I sent a patrol to scout things out from higher ground.

But swept away by their own reckless fury, the crew went berserk—

they promptly began to plunder the lush Egyptian farms,

dragged off the women and children, killed the men.

Outcries reached the city in no time—stirred by shouts

the entire town came streaming down at the break of day,

480filling the river plain with chariots, ranks of infantry

and the gleam of bronze. Zeus who loves the lightning

flung down murderous panic on all my men-at-arms—

no one dared to stand his ground and fight,

disaster ringed us round from every quarter.

Droves of my men they hacked down with swords,

led off the rest alive, to labor for them as slaves.

Myself? They passed me on to a stranger come their way,

488to ship me to Cyprus—Iasus’ son Dmetor it was,

who ruled Cyprus then with an iron fist.

490And from there I sailed to Ithaca,

just as you see me now, ground down by pain and sorrow—”

“Good god almighty!” Antinous cut the beggar short.

“What spirit brought this pest to plague our feast?

Back off! Into the open, clear of my table, or you,

you’ll soon land in an Egypt, Cyprus, to break your heart!

What a brazen, shameless beggar! Scrounging food

from each man in turn, and look at their handouts,

reckless, never a qualm, no holding back, not

when making free with the next man’s goods—

each one’s got plenty here.”

500“Pity, pity,”

the wry Odysseus countered, drawing away.

“No sense in your head to match your handsome looks.

You’d grudge your servant a pinch of salt from your own larder,

you who lounge at the next man’s board but lack the heart

to tear a crust of bread and hand it on to me,

though there’s god’s plenty here.”

Boiling over

Antinous gave him a scathing look and let fly,

“Now you won’t get out of the hall unscarred, I swear,

not after such a filthy string of insults!”

With that

he seized the stool and hurled it—

510Square in the back

it struck Odysseus, just under the right shoulder

but he stood up against it—steady as a rock,

unstaggered by Antinous’ blow—just shook his head,

silent, his mind churning with thoughts of bloody work.

Back he went to the doorsill, crouched, and setting down

his sack about to burst, he faced the suitors, saying,

“Hear me out, you lords who court the noble queen,

I must say what the heart inside me urges.

There’s nothing to groan about, no hurt, when a man

520takes a blow as he fights to save his own possessions,

cattle or shining flocks. But Antinous struck me

all because of my good-for-nothing belly—that,

that curse that makes such pain for us poor men.

But if beggars have their gods and Furies too,

let Antinous meet his death before he meets his bride!”

“Enough, stranger!” Antinous volleyed back.

“Sit there and eat in peace—or go get lost! Or else,

for the way you talk, these young men will hale you

up and down the halls by your hands or feet

until you’re skinned alive!”

530Naked threats—

but the rest were outraged, even those brash suitors.

One would say to another, “Look, Antinous,

that was a crime, to strike the luckless beggar!”

“Your fate is sealed if he’s some god from the blue.”

“And the gods do take on the look of strangers

dropping in from abroad—”

“Disguised in every way

as they roam and haunt our cities, watching over us—”

“All our foul play, all our fair play too!”

So they warned, but Antinous paid no heed.

540And the anguish welled up in Telemachus’ breast

for the blow his father took, yet he let no tears

go rolling down his face—he just shook his head,

silent, his mind churning with thoughts of bloody work.

But then, when cautious Queen Penelope heard

how Antinous struck the stranger, there in the halls,

she cried out, with her serving-women round her,

“May Apollo the Archer strike you just as hard!”

548And her housekeeper Eurynome added quickly,

“If only our prayers were granted—

550then not one of the lot would live to see

Dawn climb her throne tomorrow!”

“Dear old woman,”

alert Penelope replied, “they’re all hateful,

plotting their vicious plots. But Antinous

is the worst of all—he’s black death itself.

Here’s this luckless stranger, wandering down

the halls and begging scraps—hard-pressed by need—

and the rest all give the man his fill of food

but that one gives him a footstool

hurled at his right shoulder, hits his back!”

560While she exclaimed among her household women,

sitting there in her room, Odysseus bent to supper.

Penelope called the swineherd in and gave instructions:

“Go, good Eumaeus, tell the stranger to come at once.

I’d like to give him a warm welcome, ask the man

if he’s heard some news about my gallant husband

or seen him in the flesh…

He seems like one who’s roved around the world.”

“My queen,” you answered, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“if only the lords would hold their peace a moment!

570Such stories he tells—he’d charm you to your depths.

Three nights, three days I kept him in my shelter;

I was the first the fellow stumbled onto,

fleeing from some ship. But not even so

could he bring his tale of troubles to an end.

You know how you can stare at a bard in wonder—

trained by the gods to sing and hold men spellbound—

how you can long to sit there, listening, all your life

when the man begins to sing. So he charmed my heart,

I tell you, huddling there beside me at my fire.

580He and Odysseus’ father go way back, he says,

sworn friends, and the stranger hails from Crete

where the stock of old King Minos still lives on,

and from Crete he made his way, racked by hardship,

tumbling on like a rolling stone until he turned up here.

He swears he’s heard of Odysseus—just in reach,

in rich Thesprotian country—still alive,

laden with treasure, heading home at last!”

“Go,”

the cautious queen responded, “call him here

so he can tell me his own tale face-to-face.

590Our friends can sit at the gates or down the halls

and play their games, debauched to their hearts’ content.

Why not? Their own stores, their bread and seasoned wine,

lie intact at home; food for their serving-men alone.

But they, they infest our palace day and night,

they butcher our cattle, our sheep, our fat goats,

feasting themselves sick, swilling our glowing wine

as if there’s no tomorrow—all of it, squandered.

No, there is no man like Odysseus in command

to drive this curse from the house. Dear god,

600if only Odysseus came back home to native soil now,

he and his son would avenge the outrage of these men—like that!”

602At her last words Telemachus shook with a lusty sneeze

like a thunderclap resounding up and down the halls.

The queen was seized with laughter, calling out

to Eumaeus winged words: “Quickly, go!

Bring me this stranger now, face-to-face!

You hear how my son sealed all I said with a sneeze?

So let death come down with grim finality on these suitors—

one and all—not a single man escape his sudden doom!

610And another thing. Mark my words, I tell you.

If I’m convinced that all he says is true,

I’ll dress him in shirt and cloak, in handsome clothes.”

Off the swineherd went, following her instructions,

made his way to the stranger’s side and winged a word:

“Old friend—our queen, wise Penelope, summons you,

the prince’s mother! The spirit moves her now,

heartsick as she is,

to ask a question or two about her husband.

And if she’s convinced that all you say is true,

620she’ll dress you in shirt and cloak. That’s what you need,

that most of all now. Bread you can always beg

around the country, fill your belly well—

they’ll give you food, whoever has a mind to.”

“Gladly, Eumaeus,” the patient man replied,

“I’ll tell her the whole truth and nothing but,

Icarius’ daughter, your wise queen Penelope.

I know all about that man…

it’s been my lot to suffer what he’s suffered.

But I fear the mob’s abuse, those rough young bucks,

630their pride and violence hit the iron skies!

Just now that scoundrel—as I went down the halls,

harming no one—up and dealt me a jolting blow,

and who would raise a hand to save me? Telemachus?

Anyone else? No one. So tell Penelope now,

anxious as she may be, to wait in the halls

until the sun goes down. Then she can ask me

all she likes about her husband’s journey home.

But let her give me a seat close by the fire.

The clothes on my back are tatters. Well you know—

640you are the first I begged for care and shelter.”

Back the swineherd went, following his instructions.

Penelope, just as he crossed her threshold, broke out,

“Didn’t you bring him? What’s in the vagrant’s mind?

Fear of someone? Embarrassed by something else,

here in the house? Is the fellow bashful?

A bashful man will make a sorry beggar.”

You answered your queen, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd,

“He talks to the point—he thinks as the next man would

who wants to dodge their blows, that brutal crew.

650He tells you to wait here till the sun goes down.

It’s better for you, my queen. Then you can talk

with the man in private, hear the stranger’s news.”

“Nobody’s fool, that stranger,” wise Penelope said,

“he sees how things could go. Surely no men on earth

can match that gang for reckless, deadly schemes.”

So she agreed, and now, mission accomplished,

back the loyal swineherd went to mix with the suitors.

Moving next to the prince, he whispered a parting word,

their heads close together so no one else could hear.

660“Dear boy, I must be off, to see to the pigs

and the whole farm—your living, mine as well.

You’re the one to tend to all things here.

Look out for your own skin first,

do take care, you mustn’t come to grief.

Crowds of your own countrymen plot your death—

let Zeus wipe out the lot before they kill us all!”

“Right you are, old friend,” the canny prince replied.

“Now off you go, once you’ve had your supper.

But come back bright and early,

670bring some good sound boars for slaughter. Yes,

I’ll tend to all things here, I and the deathless gods.”

And the swineherd sat down again on his polished stool

and once he’d supped and drunk to his heart’s content,

back he went to his pigs, leaving the royal precincts

still filled with feasters, all indulging now

in the joys of dance and song.

The day was over. Dusk was falling fast.

BOOK EIGHTEEN

The Beggar-King of Ithaca

N
ow along came this tramp, this public nuisance

who used to scrounge a living round the streets of Ithaca—

notorious for his belly, a ravenous, bottomless pit

for food and drink, but he had no pith, no brawn,

despite the looming hulk that met your eyes.

6Arnaeus was his name,

so his worthy mother called him at birth,

8but all the young men called him Irus for short

because he’d hustle messages at any beck and call.

10Well he came by to rout the king from his own house

and met Odysseus now with a rough, abusive burst:

“Get off the porch, you old goat, before I haul you

off by the leg! Can’t you see them give me the wink,

all of them here, to drag you out—and so I would

but I’ve got some pangs of conscience. Up with you, man,

or before you know it, we’ll be trading blows!”

A killing look,

and the wily old soldier countered, “Out of your mind?

What damage have I done you? What have I said?

I don’t grudge you anything,

20not if the next man up and gives you plenty.

This doorsill is big enough for the both of us—

you’ve got no call to grudge me what’s not yours.

You’re another vagrant, just like me, I’d say,

and it lies with the gods to make us rich or poor. So,

keep your fists to yourself, don’t press your luck, don’t rile me,

or old as I am, I’ll bloody your lip, splatter your chest

and buy myself some peace and quiet for tomorrow.

I doubt you’ll ever come lumbering back again

to the halls of Laertes’ royal son Odysseus.”

30“Look who’s talking!” the beggar rumbled in anger.

“How this pot-bellied pig runs off at the mouth—

like an old crone at her oven!

Well I’ve got a knock-out blow in store for him—

I’ll batter the tramp with both fists, crack every tooth

from his jaws, I’ll litter the ground with teeth

like a rogue sow’s, punished for rooting corn!

Belt up—so the lords can see us fight it out.

How can you beat a champion half your age?”

Tongue-lashing each other, tempers flaring,

40there on the polished sill before the lofty doors.

And Antinous, that grand prince, hearing them wrangle,

broke into gloating laughter, calling out to the suitors,

“Friends, nothing like this has come our way before—

what sport some god has brought the palace now!

The stranger and Irus, look,

they’d battle it out together, fists flying.

Come, let’s pit them against each other—fast!”

All leapt from their seats with whoops of laughter,

clustering round the pair of ragged beggars there

50as Eupithes’ son Antinous planned the contest.

“Quiet, my fine friends. Here’s what I propose.

These goat sausages sizzling here in the fire—

we packed them with fat and blood to have for supper.

Now, whoever wins this bout and proves the stronger,

let that man step up and take his pick of the lot!

What’s more, from this day on he feasts among us—

no other beggar will we allow inside

to cadge his meals from us!”

They all cheered

but Odysseus, foxy veteran, plotted on…

60“Friends, how can an old man, worn down with pain,

stand up to a young buck? It’s just this belly of mine,

this trouble-maker, tempts me to take a licking.

So first, all of you swear me a binding oath:

come, not one of you steps in for Irus here,

strikes me a foul blow to pull him through

and lays me in the dust.”

And at that

they all mouthed the oath that he required,

and once they vowed they’d never interfere,

Prince Telemachus drove the matter home:

70“Stranger, if your spine and fighting pride

prompt you to go against this fellow now,

have no fear of any suitor in the pack—

whoever fouls you will have to face a crowd.

Count on me, your host. And two lords back me up,

Antinous and Eurymachus—both are men of sense.”

They all shouted approval of the prince

as Odysseus belted up, roping his rags around his loins,

baring his big rippling thighs—his boxer’s broad shoulders,

his massive chest and burly arms on full display

80as Athena stood beside him,

fleshing out the limbs of the great commander…

Despite their swagger, the suitors were amazed,

gaping at one another, trading forecasts:

“Irus will soon be ironed out for good!”

“He’s in for the beating he begged for all along.”

“Look at the hams on that old-timer—”

“Just under his rags!”

Each outcry jolted Irus to the core—too late.

The servants trussed his clothes up, dragged him on,

the flesh on his body quaking now with terror.

90Antinous rounded on him, flinging insults:

“You, you clumsy ox, you’re better off dead

or never born at all, if you cringe at him,

paralyzed with fear of an old, broken hulk,

ground down by the pains that hound his steps.

Mark my word—so help me I’ll make it good—

if that old relic whips you and wins the day,

I’ll toss you into a black ship and sail you off

98to Echetus, the mainland king who wrecks all men alive!

He’ll lop your nose and ears with his ruthless blade,

100he’ll rip your privates out by the roots, he will,

and serve them up to his dogs to bolt down raw!”

That threat shook his knees with a stronger fit

but they hauled him into the ring. Both men put up their fists—

with the seasoned fighter Odysseus deeply torn now…

should he knock him senseless, leave him dead where he dropped

or just stretch him out on the ground with a light jab?

As he mulled things over, that way seemed the best:

a glancing blow, the suitors would not detect him.

The two men squared off—

and Irus hurled a fist

110at Odysseus’ right shoulder as he came through

with a hook below the ear, pounding Irus’ neck,

smashing the bones inside—

suddenly red blood

came spurting out of his mouth, and headlong down

he pitched in the dust, howling, teeth locked in a grin,

feet beating the ground—

and the princely suitors,

flinging their hands in the air, died laughing.

Grabbing him by the leg, Odysseus hauled him

through the porch, across the yard to the outer gate,

heaped him against the courtyard wall, sitting slumped,

120stuck his stick in his hand and gave him a parting shot:

“Now hold your post—play the scarecrow to all the pigs and dogs!

But no more lording it over strangers, no more playing

the beggar-king for you, you loathsome fool,

or you’ll bring down something worse around your neck!”

He threw his beggar’s sack across his shoulders—

torn and tattered, slung from a fraying rope—

then back he went to the sill and took his seat.

The suitors ambled back as well, laughing jauntily,

toasting the beggar warmly now, those proud young blades,

130one man egging the other on: “Stranger, friend, may Zeus

and the other deathless gods fill up your sack with blessings!”

“All your heart desires!”

“You’ve knocked him out of action,

that insatiable tramp—”

“That parasite on the land!”

“Ship him off to Echetus, fast—the mainland king

who wrecks all men alive!”

Welcome words

and a lucky omen too—Odysseus’ heart leapt up.

Antinous laid before him a generous goat sausage,

bubbling fat and blood. Amphinomus took two loaves

from the wicker tray and set them down beside him,

140drank his health in a golden cup and said,

141“Cheers, old friend, old father,

saddled now as you are with so much trouble—

here’s to your luck, great days from this day on!”

And the one who knew the world replied at length,

“Amphinomus, you seem like a man of good sense to me.

145Just like your father—at least I’ve heard his praises,

Nisus of Dulichion, a righteous man, and rich.

You’re his son, they say, you seem well-spoken, too.

So I will tell you something. Listen. Listen closely.

150Of all that breathes and crawls across the earth,

our mother earth breeds nothing feebler than a man.

So long as the gods grant him power, spring in his knees,

he thinks he will never suffer affliction down the years.

But then, when the happy gods bring on the long hard times,

bear them he must, against his will, and steel his heart.

Our lives, our mood and mind as we pass across the earth,

turn as the days turn…

as the father of men and gods makes each day dawn.

I too seemed destined to be a man of fortune once

160and a wild wicked swath I cut, indulged my lust for violence,

staking all on my father and my brothers.

Look at me now.

And so, I say, let no man ever be lawless all his life,

just take in peace what gifts the gods will send.

True,

but here I see you suitors plotting your reckless work,

carving away at the wealth, affronting the loyal wife

of a man who won’t be gone from kin and country long.

167I say he’s right at hand—and may some power save you,

spirit you home before you meet him face-to-face

the moment he returns to native ground!

170Once under his own roof, he and your friends,

believe you me, won’t part till blood has flowed.”

With that

he poured out honeyed wine to the gods and drank deeply,

then restored the cup to the young prince’s hands.

Amphinomus made his way back through the hall,

his heart sick with anguish, shaking his head,

fraught with grave forebodings…

but not even so could he escape his fate.

178Even then Athena had bound him fast to death

at the hands of Prince Telemachus and his spear.

180Now back he went to the seat that he’d left empty.

But now the goddess Athena with her glinting eyes

inspired Penelope, Icarius’ daughter, wary, poised,

183to display herself to her suitors, fan their hearts,

inflame them more, and make her even more esteemed

by her husband and her son than she had been before.

Forcing a laugh, she called her maid: “Eurynome,

my spirit longs—though it never did till now—

to appear before my suitors, loathe them as I do.

I’d say a word to my son too, for his own good,

190not to mix so much with that pernicious crowd,

so glib with their friendly talk

but plotting wicked plots they’ll hatch tomorrow.”

“Well said, my child,” the old woman answered,

“all to the point. Go to the boy and warn him now,

hold nothing back. But first you should bathe yourself,

give a gloss to your face. Don’t go down like that—

your eyes dimmed, your cheeks streaked with tears.

It makes things worse, this grieving on and on.

Your son’s now come of age—your fondest prayer

200to the deathless gods, to see him wear a beard.”

“Eurynome,” discreet Penelope objected,

“don’t try to coax me, care for me as you do,

to bathe myself, refresh my face with oils.

Whatever glow I had died long ago…

the gods of Olympus snuffed it out that day

my husband sailed away in the hollow ships.

207But please, have Autonoë and Hippodamia come

and support me in the hall. I’ll never brave

those men alone. I’d be too embarrassed.”

210Now as the old nurse bustled through the house

to give the women orders, call them to the queen,

the bright-eyed goddess thought of one more thing.

She drifted a sound slumber over Icarius’ daughter,

back she sank and slept, her limbs fell limp and still,

reclining there on her couch, all the while Athena,

luminous goddess, lavished immortal gifts on her

to make her suitors lose themselves in wonder…

The divine unguent first. She cleansed her cheeks,

her brow and fine eyes with ambrosia smooth as the oils

220the goddess Love applies, donning her crown of flowers

whenever she joins the Graces’ captivating dances.

She made her taller, fuller in form to all men’s eyes,

her skin whiter than ivory freshly carved, and now,

Athena’s mission accomplished, off the bright one went

as bare-armed maids came in from their own quarters,

chattering all the way, and sleep released the queen.

She woke, touched her cheek with a hand, and mused,

“Ah, what a marvelous gentle sleep, enfolding me

in the midst of all my anguish! Now if only

230blessed Artemis sent me a death as gentle, now,

this instant—no more wasting away my life,

my heart broken in longing for my husband…

He had every strength,

rising over his countrymen, head and shoulders.”

Then, leaving her well-lit chamber, she descended,

not alone: two of her women followed close behind.

That radiant woman, once she reached her suitors,

drawing her glistening veil across her cheeks,

paused now where a column propped the sturdy roof,

240with one of her loyal handmaids stationed either side.

The suitors’ knees went slack, their hearts dissolved in lust—

all of them lifted prayers to lie beside her, share her bed.

243But turning toward her son, she warned, “Telemachus,

your sense of balance is not what it used to be.

When you were a boy you had much better judgment.

Now that you’ve grown and reached your young prime

and any stranger, seeing how tall and handsome you are,

would think you the son of some great man of wealth—

now your sense of fairness seems to fail you.

250Consider the dreadful thing just done in our halls—

how you let the stranger be so abused! Why,

suppose our guest, sitting here at peace,

here in our own house,

were hauled and badly hurt by such cruel treatment?

You’d be shamed, disgraced in all men’s eyes!”

“Mother…” Telemachus paused, then answered.

“I cannot fault your anger at all this.

My heart takes note of everything, feels it, too,

both the good and the bad—the boy you knew is gone.

260But how can I plan my world in a sane, thoughtful way?

These men drive me mad, hedging me round, right and left,

plotting their lethal plots, and no one takes my side.

Still, this battle between the stranger and Irus

hardly went as the suitors might have hoped:

the stranger beat him down!

If only—Father Zeus, Athena and lord Apollo—

these gallants, now, this moment, here in our house,

were battered senseless, heads lolling, knees unstrung,

some sprawled in the courtyard, some sprawled outside!

270Slumped like Irus down at the front gates now,

whipped, and his head rolling like some drunk.

He can’t stand up on his feet and stagger home,

whatever home he’s got—the man’s demolished.”

So Penelope and her son exchanged their hopes

as Eurymachus stepped in to praise the queen.

“Ah, daughter of Icarius, wise Penelope,

277if all the princes in Ionian Argos saw you now!

What a troop of suitors would banquet in your halls

tomorrow at sunrise! You surpass all women

280in build and beauty, refined and steady mind.”

“Oh no, Eurymachus,” wise Penelope demurred,

“whatever form and feature I had, what praise I’d won,

the deathless gods destroyed that day the Achaeans

sailed away to Troy, my husband in their ships,

Odysseus—if he could return to tend my life

the renown I had would only grow in glory.

Now my life is torment…

look at the griefs some god has loosed against me!

I’ll never forget the day he left this land of ours;

290he caught my right hand by the wrist and said, gently,

‘Dear woman, I doubt that every Achaean under arms

will make it home from Troy, all safe and sound.

The Trojans, they say, are fine soldiers too,

hurling javelins, shooting flights of arrows,

charioteers who can turn the tide—like that!—

when the great leveler, War, brings on some deadlock.

So I cannot tell if the gods will sail me home again

or I’ll go down out there, on the fields of Troy,

but all things here must rest in your control.

300Watch over my father and mother in the palace,

just as now, or perhaps a little more,

when I am far from home.

303But once you see the beard on the boy’s cheek,

you wed the man you like, and leave your house behind.’

So my husband advised me then. Now it all comes true…

a night will come when a hateful marriage falls my lot—

this cursed life of mine! Zeus has torn away my joy.

But there’s something else that mortifies me now.

Your way is a far cry from the time-honored way

310of suitors locked in rivalry, striving to win

some noble woman, a wealthy man’s daughter.

They bring in their own calves and lambs

to feast the friends of the bride-to-be, yes,

and shower her with gleaming gifts as well.

They don’t devour the woman’s goods scot-free.”

Staunch Odysseus glowed with joy to hear all this—

his wife’s trickery luring gifts from her suitors now,

enchanting their hearts with suave seductive words

but all the while with something else in mind.

“Gifts?”

320Eupithes’ son Antinous took her point at once.

“Daughter of Icarius, sensible Penelope,

whatever gifts your suitors would like to bring,

accept them. How ungracious to turn those gifts away!

We won’t go back to our own estates, or anywhere else,

till you have wed the man you find the best.”

So he proposed, and all the rest agreed.

Each suitor sent a page to go and get a gift.

Antinous’ man brought in a grand, resplendent robe,

stiff with embroidery, clasped with twelve gold brooches,

330long pins that clipped into sheathing loops with ease.

Eurymachus’ man brought in a necklace richly wrought,

gilded, strung with amber and glowing like the sun.

333Eurydamas’ two men came with a pair of earrings,

mulberry clusters dangling in triple drops

with a glint to catch the heart.

336From the halls of lord Pisander, Polyctor’s son,

a servant brought a choker, a fine, gleaming treasure.

And so each suitor in turn laid on a handsome gift.

Then the noble queen withdrew to her upper room,

340her file of waiting ladies close behind her,

bearing the gorgeous presents in their arms.

Now the suitors turned to dance and song,

to the lovely beat and sway,

waiting for dusk to come upon them there…

and the dark night came upon them, lost in pleasure.

They rushed to set up three braziers along the walls

to give them light, piled them high with kindling,

sere, well-seasoned, just split with an ax,

and mixed in chips to keep the torches flaring.

350The maids of Odysseus, steady man, took turns

to keep the fires up, but the king himself,

dear to the gods and cunning to the core,

gave them orders brusquely: “Maids of Odysseus,

your master gone so long—quick now, off you go

to the room where your queen and mistress waits.

Sit with her there and try to lift her spirits,

combing wool in your hands or spinning yarn.

But I will trim the torches for all her suitors,

even if they would like to revel on till Morning

360mounts her throne. They’ll never wear me down.

I have a name for lasting out the worst.”

At that

the women burst into laughter, glancing back and forth.

363Flushed with beauty, Melantho mocked him shamelessly—

Dolius was her father but Penelope brought her up;

she treated her like her own child and gave her toys

to cheer her heart. But despite that, her heart

felt nothing for all her mistress’ anguish now.

She was Eurymachus’ lover, always slept with him.

She was the one who mocked her king and taunted,

370“Cock of the walk, did someone beat your brains out?

Why not go bed down at the blacksmith’s cozy forge?

Or a public place where tramps collect? Why here—

blithering on, nonstop,

bold as brass in the face of all these lords?

No fear in your heart? Wine’s got to your wits?—

or do you always play the fool and babble nonsense?

Lost your head, have you, because you drubbed that hobo Irus?

You wait—a better man than Irus will take you on,

he’ll box both sides of your skull with heavy fists

and cart you from the palace gushing blood!”

380“You wait,

you bitch”—the hardened veteran flashed a killing look.

“I’ll go straight to the prince with your foul talk.

The prince will chop you to pieces here and now!”

His fury sent the women fluttering off, scattering

down the hall with panic shaking every limb—

they knew he spoke the truth.

But he took up his post by the flaring braziers,

tending the fires closely, looking after them all,

though the heart inside him stirred with other things,

390ranging ahead, now, to all that must be done…

But Athena had no mind to let the brazen suitors

hold back now from their heart-rending insults—

she meant to make the anguish cut still deeper

into the core of Laertes’ son Odysseus.

Polybus’ son Eurymachus launched in first,

baiting the king to give his friends a laugh:

“Listen to me, you lords who court our noble queen!

I simply have to say what’s on my mind. Look,

surely the gods have fetched this beggar here

400to Odysseus’ house. At least our torchlight seems

to come from the sheen of the man’s own head—

there’s not a hair on his bald pate, not a wisp!”

Then he wheeled on Odysseus, raider of cities:

“Stranger, how would you like to work for me

if I took you on—I’d give you decent wages—

picking the stones to lay a tight dry wall

or planting tall trees on the edge of my estate?

I’d give you rations to last you year-round,

clothes for your body, sandals for your feet.

410Oh no, you’ve learned your lazy ways too well,

you’ve got no itch to stick to good hard work,

you’d rather go scrounging round the countryside,

begging for crusts to stuff your greedy gut!”

“Ah, Eurymachus,” Odysseus, master of many exploits,

answered firmly, “if only the two of us could go

man-to-man in the labors of the field…

In the late spring, when the long days come round,

out in the meadow, I swinging a well-curved scythe

and you swinging yours—we’d test our strength for work,

420fasting right till dusk with lots of hay to mow.

Or give us a team of oxen to drive, purebreds,

hulking, ruddy beasts, both lusty with fodder,

paired for age and pulling-power that never flags—

with four acres to work, the loam churning under the plow—

you’d see what a straight unbroken furrow I could cut you then.

Or if Zeus would bring some battle on—out of the blue,

this very day—and give me a shield and two spears

and a bronze helmet to fit this soldier’s temples,

then you’d see me fight where front ranks clash—

430no more mocking this belly of mine, not then.

Enough. You’re sick with pride, you brutal fool.

No doubt you count yourself a great, powerful man

because you sport with a puny crowd, ill-bred to boot.

If only Odysseus came back home and stood right here,

in a flash you’d find those doors—broad as they are—

too cramped for your race to safety through the porch!”

That made Eurymachus’ fury seethe and burst—

he gave the beggar a dark look and let fly, “You,

you odious—I’ll make you pay for your ugly rant!

440Bold as brass in the face of all these lords?

No fear in your heart? Wine’s got to your wits?—

or do you always play the fool and babble nonsense?

Lost your head, have you, because you drubbed that hobo Irus?”

As he shouted out he seized a stool, but Odysseus,

fearing the blow, crouched at Amphinomus’ knees

as Eurymachus hurled and hit the wine-steward,

clipping his right hand—

his cup dropped, clattered along the floor

and flat on his back he went, groaning in the dust.

450The suitors broke into uproar through the shadowed halls,

glancing at one another, trading angry outcries:

“Would to god this drifter had dropped dead—”

“Anywhere else before he landed here!”

“Then he’d never have loosed such pandemonium.”

“Now we’re squabbling over beggars!”

“No more joy

in the sumptuous feast…”

“Now riot rules the day!”

But now Prince Telemachus dressed them down:

“Fools, you’re out of your minds! No hiding it,

food and wine have gone to your heads. Some god

460has got your blood up. Come, now you’ve eaten well

go home to bed—when the spirit moves, that is.

I, for one, I’ll drive no guest away.”

So he declared. And they all bit their lips,

amazed the prince could speak with so much daring.

At last Amphinomus rose to take the floor,

the noted son of Nisus, King Aretias’ grandson.

“Fair enough, my friends; when a man speaks well

we have no grounds for wrangling, no cause for abuse.

Hands off the stranger! And any other servant

470in King Odysseus’ palace. Come, steward,

pour first drops for the god in every cup;

let’s make libations, then go home to bed.

The stranger? Leave him here in Odysseus’ halls

and have his host, Telemachus, tend him well—

it’s the prince’s royal house the man has reached.”

So he said. His proposal pleased them all.

477And gallant Mulius, a herald of Dulichion,

a friend-in-arms of lord Amphinomus too,

mixed the men a bowl and, hovering closely,

480poured full rounds for all. They tipped cups

to the blissful gods and then, libations made,

they drank the heady wine to their hearts’ content

and went their ways to bed, each suitor to his house.

BOOK NINETEEN

Penelope and Her Guest

T
hat left the great Odysseus waiting in his hall

as Athena helped him plot the slaughter of the suitors.

He turned at once to Telemachus, brisk with orders:

“Now we must stow the weapons out of reach, my boy,

all the arms and armor—and when the suitors miss them

and ask you questions, put them off with a winning story:

‘I stowed them away, clear of the smoke. A far cry

from the arms Odysseus left when he went to Troy,

fire-damaged equipment, black with reeking fumes.

10And a god reminded me of something darker too.

When you’re in your cups a quarrel might break out,

you’d wound each other, shame your feasting here

and cast a pall on your courting.

14Iron has powers to draw a man to ruin.’”

Telemachus did his father’s will at once,

calling out to his old nurse Eurycleia: “Quick,

dear one, close the women up in their own quarters,

till I can stow my father’s weapons in the storeroom.

Splendid gear, lying about, neglected, black with soot

20since father sailed away. I was only a boy then.

Now I must safeguard them from the smoke.”

“High time, child,” the loving nurse replied.

“If only you’d bother to tend your whole house

and safeguard all your treasures. Tell me,

who’s to fetch and carry the torch for you?

You won’t let out the maids who’d light your way.”

“Our friend here will,” Telemachus answered coolly.

“I won’t put up with a man who shirks his work,

not if he takes his ration from my stores,

30even if he’s miles away from home.”

That silenced the old nurse.

She barred the doors that led from the long hall—

and up they sprang, Odysseus and his princely son,

and began to carry off the helmets, studded shields

and pointed spears, and Pallas Athena strode before them,

lifting a golden lamp that cast a dazzling radiance round about.

“Father,” Telemachus suddenly burst out to Odysseus,

“oh what a marvel fills my eyes! Look, look there—

all the sides of the hall, the handsome crossbeams,

40pinewood rafters, the tall columns towering—

all glow in my eyes like flaming fire!

Surely a god is here—

one of those who rule the vaulting skies!”

“Quiet,” his father, the old soldier, warned him.

“Get a grip on yourself. No more questions now.

It’s just the way of the gods who rule Olympus.

Off you go to bed. I’ll stay here behind

to test the women, test your mother too.

She in her grief will ask me everything I know.”

50Under the flaring torchlight, through the hall

Telemachus made his way to his own bedroom now,

where he always went when welcome sleep came on him.

There he lay tonight as well, till Dawn’s first light.

That left the great king still waiting in his hall

as Athena helped him plot the slaughter of the suitors…

Now down from her chamber came reserved Penelope,

looking for all the world like Artemis or golden Aphrodite.

Close to the fire her women drew her favorite chair

with its whorls of silver and ivory, inlaid rings.

60The craftsman who made it years ago, Icmalius,

added a footrest under the seat itself,

mortised into the frame,

and over it all was draped a heavy fleece.

Here Penelope took her place, discreet, observant.

The women, arms bared, pressing in from their quarters,

cleared away the tables, the heaped remains of the feast

and the cups from which the raucous lords had drunk.

Raking embers from the braziers onto the ground,

they piled them high again with seasoned wood,

providing light and warmth.

70And yet again

Melantho lashed out at Odysseus: “You still here?—

you pest, slinking around the house all night,

leering up at the women?

Get out, you tramp—be glad of the food you got—

or we’ll sling a torch at you, rout you out at once!”

A killing glance, and the old trooper countered,

“What’s possessed you, woman? Why lay into me? Such abuse!

Just because I’m filthy, because I wear such rags,

roving round the country, living hand-to-mouth.

80But it’s fate that drives me on:

that’s the lot of beggars, homeless drifters.

I too once lived in a lofty house that men admired;

rolling in wealth, I’d often give to a vagabond like myself,

whoever he was, whatever need had brought him to my door.

And crowds of servants I had, and lots of all it takes

to live the life of ease, to make men call you rich.

But Zeus ruined it all—god’s will, no doubt.

So beware, woman, or one day you may lose it all,

all your glitter that puts your work-mates in the shade.

90Or your mistress may just fly in a rage and dress you down

or Odysseus may return—there’s still room for hope!

Or if he’s dead as you think and never coming home,

well there’s his son, Telemachus…

94like father, like son—thanks to god Apollo.

No women’s wildness here in the house escapes

the prince’s eye. He’s come of age at last.”

So he warned, and alert Penelope heard him,

wheeled on the maid and tongue-lashed her smartly:

“Make no mistake, you brazen, shameless bitch,

100none of your ugly work escapes me either—

you will pay for it with your life, you will!

How well you knew—you heard from my own lips—

that I meant to probe this stranger in our house

and ask about my husband… my heart breaks for him.”

She turned to her housekeeper Eurynome and said,

“Now bring us a chair and spread it soft with fleece,

so our guest can sit and tell me his whole story

and hear me out as well.

I’d like to ask him questions, point by point.”

110Eurynome bustled off to fetch a polished chair

and set it down and spread it soft with fleece.

Here Odysseus sat, the man of many trials,

as cautious Penelope began the conversation:

“Stranger, let me start our questioning myself…

Who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?”

“My good woman,” Odysseus, master of craft, replied,

“no man on the face of the earth could find fault with you.

Your fame, believe me, has reached the vaulting skies.

Fame like a flawless king’s who dreads the gods,

120who governs a kingdom vast, proud and strong—

who upholds justice, true, and the black earth

bears wheat and barley, trees bow down with fruit

and the sheep drop lambs and never fail and the sea

teems with fish—thanks to his decent, upright rule,

and under his sovereign sway the people flourish.

So then, here in your house, ask me anything else

but don’t, please, search out my birth, my land,

or you’ll fill my heart to overflowing even more

as I bring back the past…

130I am a man who’s had his share of sorrows.

It’s wrong for me, in someone else’s house,

to sit here moaning and groaning, sobbing so—

it makes things worse, this grieving on and on.

One of your maids, or you yourself, might scold me,

think it’s just the wine that had doused my wits

and made me drown in tears.”

“No, no, stranger,” wise Penelope demurred,

“whatever form and feature I had, what praise I’d won,

the deathless gods destroyed that day the Achaeans

140sailed away to Troy, my husband in their ships,

Odysseus—if he could return to tend my life

the renown I had would only grow in glory.

Now my life is torment…

look at the griefs some god has loosed against me!

All the nobles who rule the islands round about,

Dulichion, Same, and wooded Zacynthus too,

and all who lord it in sunny Ithaca itself—

they court me against my will, they lay waste my house.

So I pay no heed to strangers, suppliants at my door,

150not even heralds out on their public errands here—

I yearn for Odysseus, always, my heart pines away.

They rush the marriage on, and I spin out my wiles.

A god from the blue it was inspired me first

to set up a great loom in our royal halls

and I began to weave, and the weaving finespun,

the yarns endless, and I would lead them on: ‘Young men,

my suitors, now that King Odysseus is no more,

go slowly, keen as you are to marry me, until

I can finish off this web…

160so my weaving won’t all fray and come to nothing.

This is a shroud for old lord Laertes, for that day

when the deadly fate that lays us out at last will take him down.

I dread the shame my countrywomen would heap upon me,

yes, if a man of such wealth should lie in state

without a shroud for cover.’

My very words,

and despite their pride and passion they believed me.

So by day I’d weave at my great and growing web—

by night, by the light of torches set beside me,

I would unravel all I’d done. Three whole years

170I deceived them blind, seduced them with this scheme.

Then, when the wheeling seasons brought the fourth year on

and the months waned and the long days came round once more,

then, thanks to my maids—the shameless, reckless creatures—

the suitors caught me in the act, denounced me harshly.

So I finished it off. Against my will. They forced me.

And now I cannot escape a marriage, nor can I contrive

177a deft way out. My parents urge me to tie the knot

and my son is galled as they squander his estate—

he sees it all. He’s a grown man by now, equipped

180to tend to his own royal house and tend it well:

Zeus grants my son that honor…

But for all that—now tell me who you are.

Where do you come from? You’ve hardly sprung

from a rock or oak like some old man of legend.”

The master improviser answered, slowly,

“My lady… wife of Laertes’ son, Odysseus,

will your questions about my family never end?

All right then. Here’s my story. Even though

it plunges me into deeper grief than I feel now.

190But that’s the way of the world, when one has been

so far from home, so long away as I, roving over

many cities of men, enduring many hardships.

Still,

my story will tell you all you need to know.

There is a land called Crete…

ringed by the wine-dark sea with rolling whitecaps—

handsome country, fertile, thronged with people

well past counting—boasting ninety cities,

language mixing with language side-by-side.

First come the Achaeans, then the native Cretans,

200hardy, gallant in action, then Cydonian clansmen,

201Dorians living in three tribes, and proud Pelasgians last.

202Central to all their cities is magnificent Cnossos,

203the site where Minos ruled and each ninth year

conferred with almighty Zeus himself. Minos,

205father of my father, Deucalion, that bold heart.

Besides myself Deucalion sired Prince Idomeneus,

who set sail for Troy in his beaked ships of war,

208escorting Atreus’ sons. My own name is Aethon.

I am the younger-born;

210my older brother’s a better man than I am.

Now, it was there in Cnossos that I saw him…

Odysseus—and we traded gifts of friendship.

A heavy gale had landed him on our coast,

driven him way off course, rounding Malea’s cape

215when he was bound for Troy. He anchored in Amnisus,

hard by the goddess’ cave of childbirth and labor,

that rough harbor—barely riding out the storm.

218He came into town at once, asking for Idomeneus,

claiming to be my brother’s close, respected friend.

220Too late. Ten or eleven days had already passed

since he set sail for Troy in his beaked ships.

So I took Odysseus back to my own house,

gave him a hero’s welcome, treated him in style—

stores in our palace made for princely entertainment.

As for his comrades, all who’d shipped with him,

I dipped into public stock to give them barley,

ruddy wine and fine cattle for slaughter,

beef to their hearts’ content. A dozen days

they stayed with me there, those brave Achaeans,

230penned up by a North Wind so stiff that a man,

even on dry land, could never keep his feet—

some angry spirit raised that blast, I’d say.

Then on the thirteenth day the wind died down

and they set sail for Troy.”

Falsehoods all,

but he gave his falsehoods all the ring of truth.

As she listened on, her tears flowed and soaked her cheeks

as the heavy snow melts down from the high mountain ridges,

snow the West Wind piles there and the warm East Wind thaws

and the snow, melting, swells the rivers to overflow their banks—

240so she dissolved in tears, streaming down her lovely cheeks,

weeping for him, her husband, sitting there beside her.

Odysseus’ heart went out to his grief-stricken wife

but under his lids his eyes remained stock-still—

they might have been horn or iron—

his guile fought back his tears. And she,

once she’d had her fill of grief and weeping,

turned again to her guest with this reply:

“Now, stranger, I think I’ll test you, just to see

if there in your house, with all his friends-in-arms,

250you actually entertained my husband as you say.

Come, tell me what sort of clothing he wore,

what cut of man was he?

What of the men who followed in his train?”

“Ah good woman,”

Odysseus, the great master of subtlety, returned,

“how hard it is to speak, after so much time

apart… why, some twenty years have passed

since he left my house and put my land behind him.

Even so, imagine the man as I portray him—

I can see him now.

King Odysseus…

260he was wearing a heavy woolen cape, sea-purple

in double folds, with a golden brooch to clasp it,

twin sheaths for the pins, on the face a work of art:

a hound clenching a dappled fawn in its front paws,

slashing it as it writhed. All marveled to see it,

solid gold as it was, the hound slashing, throttling

the fawn in its death-throes, hoofs flailing to break free.

I noticed his glossy tunic too, clinging to his skin

like the thin glistening skin of a dried onion,

silky, soft, the glint of the sun itself.

270Women galore would gaze on it with relish.

And this too. Bear it in mind, won’t you?

I’ve no idea if Odysseus wore these things at home

or a comrade gave him them as he boarded ship,

or a host perhaps—the man was loved by many.

There were few Achaeans to equal him… and I?

I gave him a bronze sword myself, a lined cloak,

elegant, deep red, and a fringed shirt as well,

and I saw him off in his long benched ship of war

in lordly style.

Something else. He kept a herald

280beside him, a man a little older than himself.

I’ll try to describe him to you, best I can.

Round-shouldered he was, swarthy, curly-haired.

283His name? Eurybates. And Odysseus prized him

most of all his men. Their minds worked as one.”

His words renewed her deep desire to weep,

recognizing the strong clear signs Odysseus offered.

But as soon as she’d had her fill of tears and grief,

Penelope turned again to her guest and said,

“Now, stranger, much as I pitied you before,

290now in my house you’ll be my special friend,

my honored guest. I am the one, myself,

who gave him the very clothes that you describe.

I brought them up from the storeroom, folded them neatly,

fastened the golden brooch to adorn my husband,

Odysseus—never again will I embrace him,

striding home to his own native land.

A black day it was

when he took ship to see that cursed city…

299
Destroy, I call it—I hate to say its name!”

300“Ah my queen,” the man of craft assured her,

“noble wife of Laertes’ son, Odysseus,

ravage no more your lovely face with tears

or consume your heart with grieving for your husband.

Not that I’d blame you, ever. Any woman will mourn

the bridegroom she has lost, lain with in love

and borne his children too. Even though he

was no Odysseus—a man like a god, they say.

But dry your tears and take my words to heart.

I will tell you the whole truth and hide nothing:

310I have heard that Odysseus now, at last, is on his way,

he’s just in reach, in rich Thesprotian country—

the man is still alive

and he’s bringing home a royal hoard of treasure,

gifts he won from the people of those parts.

His crew? He’s lost his crew and hollow ship

on the wine-dark waters off Thrinacia Island.

317Zeus and Helios raged, dead set against Odysseus

for his men-at-arms had killed the cattle of the Sun,

so down to the last hand they drowned in crashing seas.

320But not Odysseus, clinging tight to his ship’s keel—

the breakers flung him out onto dry land, on Scheria,

the land of Phaeacians, close kin to the gods themselves,

and with all their hearts they prized him like a god,

showered the man with gifts, and they’d have gladly

sailed him home unscathed. In fact Odysseus

would have been here beside you long ago

but he thought it the better, shrewder course

to recoup his fortunes roving through the world.

At sly profit-turning there’s not a man alive

330to touch Odysseus. He’s got no rival there.

So I learned from Phidon, king of Thesprotia,

who swore to me as he poured libations in his house,

‘The ship’s hauled down and the shipmates set to sail,

to take Odysseus home to native land.’

But I…

he shipped me off before. A Thesprotian cutter

chanced to be heading for Dulichion rich in wheat.

But he showed me all the treasure Odysseus had amassed,

enough to last a man and ten generations of his heirs—

so great the wealth stored up for him in the king’s vaults!

340But Odysseus, he made clear, was off at Dodona then

to hear the will of Zeus that rustles forth

from the god’s tall leafy oak: how should he return,

after all the years away, to his own beloved Ithaca,

openly or in secret?

And so the man is safe,

as you can see, and he’s coming home, soon,

he’s close, close at hand—

he won’t be severed long from kin and country,

no, not now. I give you my solemn, binding oath.

I swear by Zeus, the first, the greatest god—

350by Odysseus’ hearth, where I have come for help:

all will come to pass, I swear, exactly as I say.

True, this very month—just as the old moon dies

and the new moon rises into life—Odysseus will return!”

“If only, my friend,” reserved Penelope exclaimed,

“everything you say would come to pass!

You’d soon know my affection, know my gifts.

Any man you meet would call you blest.

But my heart can sense the way it all will go.

Odysseus, I tell you, is never coming back,

360nor will you ever gain your passage home,

for we have no masters in our house like him

at welcoming in or sending off an honored guest.

Odysseus. There was a man, or was he all a dream?

But come, women, wash the stranger and make his bed,

with bedding, blankets and lustrous spreads to keep him warm

till Dawn comes up and takes her golden throne.

Then, tomorrow at daybreak, bathe him well

and rub him down with oil, so he can sit beside

Telemachus in the hall, enjoy his breakfast there.

370And anyone who offends our guest beyond endurance—

he defeats himself; he’s doomed to failure here,

no matter how raucously he raves and blusters on.

For how can you know, my friend, if I surpass

all women in thoughtfulness and shrewd good sense,

if I’d allow you to take your meals at hall

so weatherbeaten, clad in rags and tatters?

Our lives are much too brief…

If a man is cruel by nature, cruel in action,

the mortal world will call down curses on his head

380while he is alive, and all will mock his memory after death.

But then if a man is kind by nature, kind in action,

his guests will carry his fame across the earth

and people all will praise him from the heart.”

“Wait, my queen,” the crafty man objected,

“noble wife of Laertes’ son, Odysseus—

blankets and glossy spreads? They’re not my style.

Not from the day I launched out in my long-oared ship

and the snowy peaks of Crete went fading far astern.

I’ll lie as I’ve done through sleepless nights before.

390Many a night I’ve spent on rugged beds afield,

waiting for Dawn to mount her lovely throne.

Nor do I pine for any footbaths either.

Of all the women who serve your household here,

not one will touch my feet. Unless, perhaps,

there is some old retainer, the soul of trust,

someone who’s borne as much as I have borne…

I wouldn’t mind if she would touch my feet.”

“Dear friend,”

the discreet Penelope replied, “never has any man

so thoughtful—of all the guests in my palace

400come from foreign parts—been as welcome as you…

so sensible, so apt, is every word you say.

I have just such an old woman, seasoned, wise,

who carefully tended my unlucky husband, reared him,

took him into her arms the day his mother bore him—

frail as the woman is, she’ll wash your feet.

Up with you now, my good old Eurycleia,

407come and wash your master’s… equal in years.

Odysseus must have feet and hands like his by now—

hardship can age a person overnight.”

At that name

410the old retainer buried her face in both hands,

burst into warm tears and wailed out in grief,

“Oh my child, how helpless I am to help you now!

How Zeus despised you, more than all other men,

god-fearing man that you were…

Never did any mortal burn the Old Thunderer

such rich thighbones—offerings charred and choice—

never as many as you did, praying always to reach

a ripe old age and raise a son to glory. Now,

you alone he’s robbed of your home-coming day!

420Just so, the women must have mocked my king,

far away, when he’d stopped at some fine house—

just as all these bitches, stranger, mock you here.

And because you shrink from their taunts, their wicked barbs,

you will not let them wash you. The work is mine—

Icarius’ daughter, wise Penelope, bids me now

and I am all too glad. I will wash your feet,

both for my own dear queen and for yourself—

your sorrows wring my heart… and why?

Listen to me closely, mark my words.

430Many a wayworn guest has landed here

but never, I swear, has one so struck my eyes—

your build, your voice, your feet—you’re like Odysseus…

to the life!”

“Old woman,” wily Odysseus countered,

“that’s what they all say who’ve seen us both.

We bear a striking resemblance to each other,

as you have had the wit to say yourself.”

The old woman took up a burnished basin

she used for washing feet and poured in bowls

of fresh cold water before she stirred in hot.

440Odysseus, sitting full in the firelight, suddenly

swerved round to the dark, gripped by a quick misgiving—

soon as she touched him she might spot the scar!

The truth would all come out.

Bending closer

she started to bathe her master… then,

in a flash, she knew the scar—

that old wound

made years ago by a boar’s white tusk when Odysseus

447went to Parnassus, out to see Autolycus and his sons.

The man was his mother’s noble father, one who excelled

the world at thievery, that and subtle, shifty oaths.

450Hermes gave him the gift, overjoyed by the thighs

of lambs and kids he burned in the god’s honor—

Hermes the ready partner in his crimes. Now,

Autolycus once visited Ithaca’s fertile land,

to find his daughter’s son had just been born.

Eurycleia set him down on the old man’s knees

as he finished dinner, urging him, “Autolycus,

you must find a name for your daughter’s darling son.

The baby comes as the answer to her prayers.”

“You,

my daughter, and you, my son-in-law,” Autolycus replied,

460“give the boy the name I tell you now. Just as I

have come from afar, creating pain for many—

men and women across the good green earth—

463so let his name be Odysseus…

the Son of Pain, a name he’ll earn in full.

And when he has come of age and pays his visit

to Parnassus—the great estate of his mother’s line

where all my treasures lie—I will give him enough

to cheer his heart, then speed him home to you.”

And so,

in time, Odysseus went to collect the splendid gifts.

470Autolycus and the sons of Autolycus warmed him in

with eager handclasps, hearty words of welcome.

472His mother’s mother, Amphithea, hugged the boy

and kissed his face and kissed his shining eyes.

Autolycus told his well-bred sons to prepare

a princely feast. They followed orders gladly,

herded an ox inside at once, five years old,

skinned it and split the carcass into quarters,

deftly cut it in pieces, skewered these on spits,

roasted all to a turn and served the portions out.

480So all day long till the sun went down they feasted,

consuming equal shares to their hearts’ content.

Then when the sun had set and night came on

they turned to bed and took the gift of sleep.

As soon

as young Dawn with her rose-red fingers shone once more

they all moved out for the hunt, hounds in the lead,

Autolycus’ sons and Prince Odysseus in their ranks.

Climbing Parnassus’ ridges, thick with timber,

they quickly reached the mountain’s windy folds

and just as the sun began to strike the plowlands,

490rising out of the deep calm flow of the Ocean River,

the beaters came to a wooded glen, the hounds broke,

hot on a trail, and right behind the pack they came,

Autolycus’ sons—Odysseus out in front now,

pressing the dogs, brandishing high his spear

with its long shadow waving. Then and there

a great boar lay in wait, in a thicket lair so dense

that the sodden gusty winds could never pierce it,

nor could the sun’s sharp rays invade its depths

nor a downpour drench it through and through,

500so dense, so dark, and piled with fallen leaves.

Here, as the hunters closed in for the kill,

crowding the hounds, the tramp of men and dogs

came drumming round the boar—he crashed from his lair,

his razor back bristling, his eyes flashing fire

and charging up to the hunt he stopped, at bay—

and Odysseus rushed him first,

shaking his long spear in a sturdy hand,

wild to strike but the boar struck faster,

lunging in on the slant, a tusk thrusting up

510over the boy’s knee, gouging a deep strip of flesh

but it never hit the bone—

Odysseus thrust and struck,

stabbing the beast’s right shoulder—

a glint of bronze—

the point ripped clean through and down in the dust he dropped,

grunting out his breath as his life winged away.

The sons of Autolycus, working over Odysseus,

skillfully binding up his open wound—

the gallant, godlike prince—

chanted an old spell that stanched the blood

and quickly bore him home to their father’s palace.

520There, in no time, Autolycus and the sons of Autolycus

healed him well and, showering him with splendid gifts,

sped Odysseus back to his native land, to Ithaca,

a young man filled with joy. His happy parents,

his father and noble mother, welcomed him home

and asked him of all his exploits, blow-by-blow:

how did he get that wound? He told his tale with style,

how the white tusk of a wild boar had gashed his leg,

hunting on Parnassus with Autolycus and his sons…

That scar—

as the old nurse cradled his leg and her hands passed down

530she felt it, knew it, suddenly let his foot fall—

down it dropped in the basin—the bronze clanged,

tipping over, spilling water across the floor.

Joy and torment gripped her heart at once,

tears rushed to her eyes—voice choked in her throat

she reached for Odysseus’ chin and whispered quickly,

“Yes, yes! you are Odysseus—oh dear boy—

I couldn’t know you before…

not till I touched the body of my king!”

She glanced at Penelope, keen to signal her

540that here was her own dear husband, here and now,

but she could not catch the glance, she took no heed,

Athena turned her attention elsewhere. But Odysseus—

his right hand shot out, clutching the nurse’s throat,

with his left he hugged her to himself and muttered,

“Nurse, you want to kill me? You suckled me yourself

at your own breast—and now I’m home, at last,

after bearing twenty years of brutal hardship,

home, on native ground. But now you know,

now that a god has flashed it in your mind,

550quiet! not a word to anyone in the house.

Or else, I warn you—and I mean business too—

if a god beats down these brazen suitors at my hands,

I will not spare you—my old nurse that you are—

when I kill the other women in my house.”

“Child,” shrewd old Eurycleia protested,

“what nonsense you let slip through your teeth!

You know me—I’m stubborn, never give an inch—

I’ll keep still as solid rock or iron.

One more thing. Take it to heart, I tell you.

560If a god beats down these brazen suitors at your hands,

I’ll report in full on the women in your house:

who are disloyal to you, who are guiltless.”

“Nurse,” the cool tactician Odysseus said,

“why bother to count them off? A waste of breath.

I’ll observe them, judge each one myself.

Just be quiet. Keep your tales to yourself.

Leave the rest to the gods.”

Hushed so,

the old nurse went padding along the halls

to fetch more water—her basin had all spilled—

570and once she’d bathed and rubbed him down with oil,

Odysseus drew his chair up near the fire again,

trying to keep warm,

but he hid his scar beneath his beggar’s rags

as cautious Penelope resumed their conversation:

“My friend, I have only one more question for you,

something slight, now the hour draws on for welcome sleep—

for those who can yield to sweet repose, that is,

heartsick as they are. As for myself, though,

some god has sent me pain that knows no bounds.

580All day long I indulge myself in sighs and tears

as I see to my tasks, direct the household women.

When night falls and the world lies lost in sleep,

I take to my bed, my heart throbbing, about to break,

anxieties swarming, piercing—I may go mad with grief.

585Like Pandareus’ daughter, the nightingale in the green woods

lifting her lovely song at the first warm rush of spring,

perched in the treetops’ rustling leaves and pouring forth

her music shifting, trilling and sinking, rippling high to burst

589in grief for Itylus, her beloved boy, King Zethus’ son

590whom she in innocence once cut down with bronze…

so my wavering heart goes shuttling, back and forth:

Do I stay beside my son and keep all things secure—

my lands, my serving-women, the grand high-roofed house—

true to my husband’s bed, the people’s voice as well?

Or do I follow, at last, the best man who courts me

here in the halls, who gives the greatest gifts?

My son—when he was a boy and lighthearted—

urged me not to marry and leave my husband’s house.

But now he has grown and reached his young prime,

600he begs me to leave our palace, travel home.

Telemachus, so obsessed with his own estate,

the wealth my princely suitors bleed away.

But please,

read this dream for me, won’t you? Listen closely…

I keep twenty geese in the house, from the water trough

they come and peck their wheat—I love to watch them all.

But down from a mountain swooped this great hook-beaked eagle,

yes, and he snapped their necks and killed them one and all

and they lay in heaps throughout the halls while he,

back to the clear blue sky he soared at once.

610But I wept and wailed—only a dream, of course—

and our well-groomed ladies came and clustered round me,

sobbing, stricken: the eagle killed my geese. But down

he swooped again and settling onto a jutting rafter

called out in a human voice that dried my tears,

‘Courage, daughter of famous King Icarius!

This is no dream but a happy waking vision,

real as day, that will come true for you.

The geese were your suitors—I was once the eagle

but now I am your husband, back again at last,

620about to launch a terrible fate against them all!’

So he vowed, and the soothing sleep released me.

I peered around and saw my geese in the house,

pecking at their wheat, at the same trough

where they always took their meal.”

“Dear woman,”

quick Odysseus answered, “twist it however you like,

your dream can only mean one thing. Odysseus

told you himself—he’ll make it come to pass.

Destruction is clear for each and every suitor;

not a soul escapes his death and doom.”

630“Ah my friend,” seasoned Penelope dissented,

“dreams are hard to unravel, wayward, drifting things—

not all we glimpse in them will come to pass…

633Two gates there are for our evanescent dreams,

one is made of ivory, the other made of horn.

Those that pass through the ivory cleanly carved

are will-o’-the-wisps, their message bears no fruit.

The dreams that pass through the gates of polished horn

are fraught with truth, for the dreamer who can see them.

But I can’t believe my strange dream has come that way,

640much as my son and I would love to have it so.

One more thing I’ll tell you—weigh it well.

The day that dawns today, this cursed day,

will cut me off from Odysseus’ house. Now,

644I mean to announce a contest with those axes,

the ones he would often line up here inside the hall,

twelve in a straight unbroken row like blocks to shore a keel,

then stand well back and whip an arrow through the lot.

Now I will bring them on as a trial for my suitors.

The hand that can string the bow with greatest ease,

650that shoots an arrow clean through all twelve axes—

he’s the man I follow, yes, forsaking this house

where I was once a bride, this gracious house

so filled with the best that life can offer—

I shall always remember it, that I know…

even in my dreams.”

“Oh my queen,”

Odysseus, man of exploits, urged her on,

“royal wife of Laertes’ son, Odysseus, now,

don’t put off this test in the halls a moment.

Before that crew can handle the polished bow,

660string it taut and shoot through all those axes—

Odysseus, man of exploits, will be home with you!”

“If only, my friend,” the wise Penelope replied,

“you were willing to sit beside me in the house,

indulging me in the comfort of your presence,

sleep would never drift across my eyes.

But one can’t go without one’s sleep forever.

The immortals give each thing its proper place

in our mortal lives throughout the good green earth.

So now I’m going back to my room upstairs

670and lie down on my bed,

that bed of pain my tears have streaked, year in,

year out, from the day Odysseus sailed away to see…

673
Destroy, I call it—I hate to say its name!

There I’ll rest, while you lie here in the hall,

spreading your blankets somewhere on the floor,

or the women will prepare a decent bed.”

With that

the queen went up to her lofty well-lit room

and not alone: her women followed close behind.

Penelope, once they reached the upper story,

680fell to weeping for Odysseus, her beloved husband,

till watchful Athena sealed her eyes with welcome sleep.

BOOK TWENTY

Portents Gather

O
ff in the entrance-hall the great king made his bed,

spreading out on the ground the raw hide of an ox,

heaping over it fleece from sheep the suitors

butchered day and night, then Eurynome threw

a blanket over him, once he’d nestled down.

And there Odysseus lay…

plotting within himself the suitors’ death—

awake, alert, as the women slipped from the house,

the maids who whored in the suitors’ beds each night,

10tittering, linking arms and frisking as before.

The master’s anger rose inside his chest,

torn in thought, debating, head and heart—

should he up and rush them, kill them one and all

or let them rut with their lovers one last time?

The heart inside him growled low with rage,

as a bitch mounting over her weak, defenseless puppies

growls, facing a stranger, bristling for a showdown—

so he growled from his depths, hackles rising at their outrage.

But he struck his chest and curbed his fighting heart:

20“Bear up, old heart! You’ve borne worse, far worse,

that day when the Cyclops, man-mountain, bolted

your hardy comrades down. But you held fast—

23Nobody but your cunning pulled you through

the monster’s cave you thought would be your death.”

So he forced his spirit into submission,

the rage in his breast reined back—unswerving,

all endurance. But he himself kept tossing, turning,

intent as a cook before some white-hot blazing fire

who rolls his sizzling sausage back and forth,

30packed with fat and blood—keen to broil it quickly,

tossing, turning it, this way, that way—so he cast about:

how could he get these shameless suitors in his clutches,

one man facing a mob?… when close to his side she came,

Athena sweeping down from the sky in a woman’s build

and hovering at his head, the goddess spoke:

“Why still awake? The unluckiest man alive!

Here is your house, your wife at home, your son,

as fine a boy as one could hope to have.”

“True,”

the wily fighter replied, “how right you are, goddess,

40but still this worry haunts me, heart and soul—

how can I get these shameless suitors in my clutches?

Single-handed, braving an army always camped inside.

43There’s another worry, that haunts me even more.

What if I kill them—thanks to you and Zeus—

how do I run from under their avengers?

Show me the way, I ask you.”

“Impossible man!”

Athena bantered, the goddess’ eyes ablaze.

“Others are quick to trust a weaker comrade,

some poor mortal, far less cunning than I.

50But I am a goddess, look, the very one who

guards you in all your trials to the last.

I tell you this straight out:

even if fifty bands of mortal fighters

closed around us, hot to kill us off in battle,

still you could drive away their herds and sleek flocks!

So, surrender to sleep at last. What a misery,

keeping watch through the night, wide awake—

you’ll soon come up from under all your troubles.”

With that she showered sleep across his eyes

60and back to Olympus went the lustrous goddess.

As soon as sleep came on him, loosing his limbs,

slipping the toils of anguish from his mind,

his devoted wife awoke and,

sitting up in her soft bed, returned to tears.

When the queen had wept to her heart’s content

she prayed to the Huntress, Artemis, first of all:

“Artemis—goddess, noble daughter of Zeus, if only

you’d whip an arrow through my breast and tear my life out,

now, at once! Or let some whirlwind pluck me up

70and sweep me away along those murky paths and

fling me down where the Ocean River running

round the world rolls back upon itself!

Quick

73as the whirlwinds swept away Pandareus’ daughters—

years ago, when the gods destroyed their parents,

leaving the young girls orphans in their house.

But radiant Aphrodite nursed them well

on cheese and luscious honey and heady wine,

and Hera gave them beauty and sound good sense,

more than all other women—virgin Artemis made them tall

80and Athena honed their skills to fashion lovely work.

But then, when Aphrodite approached Olympus’ peaks

to ask for the girls their crowning day as brides

from Zeus who loves the lightning—Zeus who knows all,

all that’s fated, all not fated, for mortal man—

then the storm spirits snatched them away

and passed them on to the hateful Furies,

yes, for all their loving care.

Just so

may the gods who rule Olympus blot me out!

Artemis with your glossy braids, come shoot me dead—

90so I can plunge beneath this loathsome earth

with the image of Odysseus vivid in my mind.

92Never let me warm the heart of a weaker man!

Even grief is bearable, true, when someone weeps

through the days, sobbing, heart convulsed with pain

yet embraced by sleep all night—sweet oblivion, sleep

dissolving all, the good and the bad, once it seals our eyes—

but even my dreams torment me, sent by wicked spirits.

Again—just this night—someone lay beside me…

like Odysseus to the life, when he embarked

100with his men-at-arms. My heart raced with joy.

No dream, I thought, the waking truth at last!”

At those words

Dawn rose on her golden throne in a sudden gleam of light.

And great Odysseus caught the sound of his wife’s cry

and began to daydream—deep in his heart it seemed

she stood beside him, knew him, now, at last…

Gathering up the fleece and blankets where he’d slept,

he laid them on a chair in the hall, he took the oxhide out

and spread it down, lifted his hands and prayed to Zeus:

“Father Zeus, if you really willed it so—to bring me

110home over land and sea-lanes, home to native ground

after all the pain you brought me—show me a sign,

a good omen voiced by someone awake indoors,

another sign, outside, from Zeus himself!”

And Zeus in all his wisdom heard that prayer.

He thundered at once, out of his clear blue heavens

high above the clouds, and Odysseus’ spirit lifted.

Then from within the halls a woman grinding grain

let fly a lucky word. Close at hand she was,

where the good commander set the handmills once

120and now twelve women in all performed their tasks,

grinding the wheat and barley, marrow of men’s bones.

The rest were abed by now—they’d milled their stint—

this one alone, the frailest of all, kept working on.

Stopping her mill, she spoke an omen for her master:

“Zeus, Father! King of gods and men, now there

was a crack of thunder out of the starry sky—

and not a cloud in sight!

Sure it’s a sign you’re showing someone now.

So, poor as I am, grant me my prayer as well:

130let this day be the last, the last these suitors

bolt their groaning feasts in King Odysseus’ house!

These brutes who break my knees—heart-wrenching labor,

grinding their grain—now let them eat their last!”

A lucky omen, linked with Zeus’s thunder.

Odysseus’ heart leapt up, the man convinced

he’d grind the scoundrels’ lives out in revenge.

By now

the other maids were gathering in Odysseus’ royal palace,

raking up on the hearth the fire still going strong.

Telemachus climbed from bed and dressed at once,

140brisk as a young god—

over his shoulder he slung his well-honed sword,

he fastened rawhide sandals under his smooth feet,

he seized his tough spear tipped with a bronze point

and took his stand at the threshold, calling Eurycleia:

145“Dear nurse, how did you treat the stranger in our house?

With bed and board? Or leave him to lie untended?

That would be mother’s way—sensible as she is—

all impulse, doting over some worthless stranger,

turning a good man out to face the worst.”

150“Please, child,” his calm old nurse replied,

“don’t blame her—your mother’s blameless this time.

He sat and drank his wine till he’d had his fill.

Food? He’d lost his hunger. But she asked him.

And when it was time to think of turning in,

she told the maids to spread a decent bed, but he—

so down-and-out, poor soul, so dogged by fate—

said no to snuggling into a bed, between covers.

No sir, the man lay down in the entrance-hall,

on the raw hide of an ox and sheep’s fleece,

and we threw a blanket over him, so we did.”

160Hearing that,

Telemachus strode out through the palace, spear in hand,

and a pair of sleek hounds went trotting at his heels.

He made for the meeting grounds to join the island lords

while Eurycleia the daughter of Ops, Pisenor’s son,

that best of women, gave the maids their orders:

“Quick now, look alive, sweep out the house,

wet down the floors!

You, those purple coverlets,

fling them over the fancy chairs!

All those tables,

sponge them down—scour the winebowls, burnished cups!

170The rest—now off you go to the spring and fetch some water,

fast as your legs can run!

Our young gallants won’t be long from the palace,

they’ll be bright and early—today’s a public feast.”

They hung on her words and ran to do her bidding.

Full twenty scurried off to the spring’s dark water,

others bent to the housework, all good hands.

Then in they trooped, the strutting serving-men,

who split the firewood cleanly now as the women

bustled in from the spring, the swineherd at their heels,

180driving three fat porkers, the best of all his herds.

And leaving them to root in the broad courtyard,

up he went to Odysseus, hailed him warmly:

“Friend, do the suitors show you more respect

or treat you like the dregs of the earth as always?”

“Good Eumaeus,” the crafty man replied,

“if only the gods would pay back their outrage!

Wild and reckless young cubs, conniving here

in another’s house. They’ve got no sense of shame.”

And now as the two confided in each other,

190the goatherd Melanthius sauntered toward them,

herding his goats with a pair of drovers’ help,

the pick of his flocks to make the suitors’ meal.

Under the echoing porch he tethered these, then turned

on Odysseus once again with cutting insults: “Still alive?

Still hounding your betters, begging round the house?

Why don’t you cart yourself away? Get out!

We’ll never part, I swear,

till we taste each other’s fists. Riffraff,

you and your begging make us sick! Get out—

200we’re hardly the only banquet on the island.”

No reply. The wily one just shook his head,

silent, his mind churning with thoughts of bloody work…

203Third to arrive was Philoetius, that good cowherd,

prodding in for the crowd a heifer and fat goats.

Boatmen had brought them over from the mainland,

crews who ferry across all travelers too,

whoever comes for passage.

Under the echoing porch he tethered all heads well

and then approached the swineherd, full of questions:

210“Who’s this stranger, Eumaeus, just come to the house?

What roots does the man claim—who are his people?

Where are his blood kin? his father’s fields?

Poor beggar. But what a build—a royal king’s!

Ah, once the gods weave trouble into our lives

they drive us across the earth, they drown us all in pain,

even kings of the realm.”

And with that thought

he walked up to Odysseus, gave him his right hand

and winged a greeting: “Cheers, old friend, old father,

here’s to your luck, great days from this day on—

220saddled now as you are with so much trouble.

Father Zeus, no god’s more deadly than you!

No mercy for men, you give them life yourself

then plunge them into misery, brutal hardship.

I broke into sweat, my friend, when I first saw you—

see, my eyes still brim with tears, remembering him,

Odysseus… He must wear such rags, I know it,

knocking about, drifting through the world

if he’s still alive and sees the light of day.

If he’s dead already, lost in the House of Death,

230my heart aches for Odysseus, my great lord and master.

231He set me in charge of his herds, in Cephallenian country,

when I was just a youngster. How they’ve grown by now,

past counting! No mortal on earth could breed

a finer stock of oxen—broad in the brow,

they thrive like ears of corn. But just look,

these interlopers tell me to drive them in

for their own private feasts. Not a thought

for the young prince in the house, they never flinch—

no regard for the gods’ wrath—in their mad rush

240to carve up his goods, my master gone so long!

I’m tossed from horn to horn in my own mind…

What a traitor I’d be, with the prince still alive,

if I’d run off to some other country, herds and all,

to a new set of strangers. Ah, but isn’t it worse

to hold out here, tending the herds for upstarts,

not their owners—suffering all the pains of hell?

I could have fled, ages ago, to some great king

who’d give me shelter. It’s unbearable here.

True, but I still dream of my old master,

250unlucky man—if only he’d drop in from the blue

and drive these suitors all in a rout throughout the halls!”

“Cowherd,” the cool tactician Odysseus answered,

“you’re no coward, and nobody’s fool, I’d say.

Even I can see there’s sense in that old head.

So I tell you this on my solemn, binding oath:

I swear by Zeus, the first of all the gods—

by the table of hospitality waiting for us,

by Odysseus’ hearth where I have come for help,

Odysseus will come home while you’re still here.

260You’ll see with your own eyes, if you have the heart,

these suitors who lord it here cut down in blood.”

“Stranger, if only,” the cowherd cried aloud,

“if only Zeus would make that oath come true—

you’d see my power, my fighting arms in action!”

Eumaeus echoed his prayer to all the gods

that their wise king would soon come home again.

Now as they spoke and urged each other on,

and once more the suitors were plotting certain doom

269for the young prince—suddenly, banking high on the left

270an omen flew past, an eagle clutching a trembling dove.

And Amphinomus rose in haste to warn them all,

“My friends, we’ll never carry off this plot

to kill the prince. Let’s concentrate on feasting.”

His timely invitation pleased them all.

The suitors ambled into Odysseus’ royal house

and flinging down their cloaks on a chair or bench,

they butchered hulking sheep and fatted goats,

full-grown hogs and a young cow from the herd.

They roasted all the innards, served them round

280and filled the bowls with wine and mixed it well.

Eumaeus passed out cups; Philoetius, trusty herdsman,

brought on loaves of bread in ample wicker trays;

Melanthius poured the wine. The whole company

reached out for the good things that lay at hand.

Telemachus, maneuvering shrewdly, sat his father down

on the stone threshold, just inside the timbered hall,

and set a rickety stool and cramped table there.

He gave him a share of innards, poured his wine

in a golden cup and added a bracing invitation:

290“Now sit right there. Drink your wine with the crowd.

I’ll defend you from all their taunts and blows,

these young bucks. This is no public place,

this is Odysseus’ house—

my father won it for me, so it’s mine.

You suitors, control yourselves. No insults now,

no brawling, no, or it’s war between us all.”

So he declared. And they all bit their lips,

amazed the prince could speak with so much daring.

Only Eupithes’ son Antinous ventured,

300“Fighting words, but do let’s knuckle under—

to our prince. Such abuse, such naked threats!

But clearly Zeus has foiled us. Or long before

we would have shut his mouth for him in the halls,

fluent and flowing as he is.”

So he mocked.

Telemachus paid no heed.

And now through the streets

the heralds passed, leading the beasts marked out

307for sacrifice on Apollo’s grand festal day,

and the islanders with their long hair were filing

into the god’s shady grove—the distant deadly Archer.

310Those in the palace, once they’d roasted the prime cuts,

pulled them off the spits and, sharing out the portions,

fell to the royal feast…

The men who served them gave Odysseus his share,

as fair as the helping they received themselves.

So Telemachus ordered, the king’s own son.

But Athena had no mind to let the brazen suitors

hold back now from their heart-rending insults—

she meant to make the anguish cut still deeper

into the core of Laertes’ son Odysseus.

320There was one among them, a lawless boor—

321Ctesippus was his name, he made his home in Same,

a fellow so impressed with his own astounding wealth

he courted the wife of Odysseus, gone for years.

Now the man harangued his swaggering comrades:

“Listen to me, my fine friends, here’s what I say!

From the start our guest has had his fair share—

it’s only right, you know.

How impolite it would be, how wrong to scant

whatever guest Telemachus welcomes to his house.

330Look here, I’ll give him a proper guest-gift too,

a prize he can hand the crone who bathes his feet

or a tip for another slave who haunts the halls

of our great king Odysseus!”

On that note,

grabbing an oxhoof out of a basket where it lay,

with a brawny hand he flung it straight at the king—

but Odysseus ducked his head a little, dodging the blow,

and seething just as the oxhoof hit the solid wall

he clenched his teeth in a wry sardonic grin.

Telemachus dressed Ctesippus down at once:

340“Ctesippus, you can thank your lucky stars

you missed our guest—he ducked your blow, by god!

Else I would have planted my sharp spear in your bowels—

your father would have been busy with your funeral,

not your wedding here. Enough.

Don’t let me see more offenses in my house,

not from anyone! I’m alive to it all, now,

the good and the bad—the boy you knew is gone.

But I still must bear with this, this lovely sight…

sheepflocks butchered, wine swilled, food squandered—

350how can a man fight off so many single-handed?

But no more of your crimes against me, please!

Unless you’re bent on cutting me down, now,

and I’d rather die, yes, better that by far

than have to look on at your outrage day by day:

guests treated to blows, men dragging the serving-women

through our noble house, exploiting them all, no shame!”

Dead quiet. The suitors all fell silent, hushed.

358At last Damastor’s son Agelaus rose and said,

“Fair enough, my friends; when a man speaks well

360we have no grounds for wrangling, no cause for abuse.

Hands off this stranger! Or any other servant

in King Odysseus’ palace. But now a word

of friendly advice for Telemachus and his mother—

here’s hoping it proves congenial to them both.

So long as your hearts still kept a spark alive

that Odysseus would return—that great, deep man—

who could blame you, playing the waiting game at home

and holding off the suitors? The better course, it’s true.

What if Odysseus had returned, had made it home at last?

370But now it’s clear as day—the man will come no more.

So go, Telemachus, sit with your mother, coax her

to wed the best man here, the one who offers most,

so you can have and hold your father’s estate,

eating and drinking here, your mind at peace

while mother plays the wife in another’s house.”

The young prince, keeping his poise, replied,

“I swear by Zeus, Agelaus, by all my father suffered—

dead, no doubt, or wandering far from Ithaca these days—

I don’t delay my mother’s marriage, not a moment,

380I press her to wed the man who takes her heart.

I’ll shower her myself with boundless gifts.

But I shrink from driving mother from our house,

issuing harsh commands against her will.

God forbid it ever comes to that!”

So he vowed

and Athena set off uncontrollable laughter in the suitors,

crazed them out of their minds—mad, hysterical laughter

seemed to break from the jaws of strangers, not their own,

and the meat they were eating oozed red with blood—

tears flooded their eyes, hearts possessed by grief.

390The inspired seer Theoclymenus wailed out in their midst,

“Poor men, what terror is this that overwhelms you so?

Night shrouds your heads, your faces, down to your knees—

cries of mourning are bursting into fire—cheeks rivering tears—

the walls and the handsome crossbeams dripping dank with blood!

395Ghosts, look, thronging the entrance, thronging the court,

go trooping down to the world of death and darkness!

The sun is blotted out of the sky—look there—

a lethal mist spreads all across the earth!”

At that

they all broke into peals of laughter aimed at the seer—

400Polybus’ son Eurymachus braying first and foremost,

“Our guest just in from abroad, the man is raving!

Quick, my boys, hustle him out of the house,

into the meeting grounds, the light of day—

everything here he thinks is dark as night!”

“Eurymachus,” the inspired prophet countered,

“when I want your escort, I’ll ask for it myself.

I have eyes and ears, and both my feet, still,

and a head that’s fairly sound,

nothing to be ashamed of. These will do

to take me past those doors…

410Oh I can see it now—

the disaster closing on you all! There’s no escaping it,

no way out—not for a single one of you suitors,

wild reckless fools, plotting outrage here,

the halls of Odysseus, great and strong as a god!”

With that he marched out of the sturdy house

and went home to Piraeus, the host who warmed him in.

Now all the suitors, trading their snide glances, started

heckling Telemachus, made a mockery of his guests.

One or another brash young gallant scoffed,

420“Telemachus, no one’s more unlucky with his guests!”

“Look what your man dragged in—this mangy tramp

scraping for bread and wine!”

“Not fit for good hard work,

the bag of bones—”

“A useless dead weight on the land!”

“And then this charlatan up and apes the prophet.”

“Take it from me—you’ll be better off by far—

toss your friends in a slave-ship—”

“Pack them off

427to Sicily, fast—they’ll fetch you one sweet price!”

So they jeered, but the prince paid no attention…

silent, eyes riveted on his father, always waiting

430the moment he’d lay hands on that outrageous mob.

And all the while Icarius’ daughter, wise Penelope,

had placed her carved chair within earshot, at the door,

so she could catch each word they uttered in the hall.

Laughing rowdily, men prepared their noonday meal,

succulent, rich—they’d butchered quite a herd.

But as for supper, what could be less enticing

than what a goddess and a powerful man

would spread before them soon? A groaning feast—

for they’d been first to plot their vicious crimes.

BOOK TWENTY-ONE

Odysseus Strings His Bow

T
he time had come. The goddess Athena with her blazing eyes

inspired Penelope, Icarius’ daughter, wary, poised,

to set the bow and the gleaming iron axes out

before her suitors waiting in Odysseus’ hall—

to test their skill and bring their slaughter on.

Up the steep stairs to her room she climbed

and grasped in a steady hand the curved key—

fine bronze, with ivory haft attached—

and then with her chamber-women made her way

10to a hidden storeroom, far in the palace depths,

and there they lay, the royal master’s treasures:

bronze, gold and a wealth of hard wrought iron

and there it lay as well… his backsprung bow

with its quiver bristling arrows, shafts of pain.

Gifts from the old days, from a friend he’d met

16in Lacedaemon—Iphitus, Eurytus’ gallant son.

17Once in Messene the two struck up together,

in sly Ortilochus’ house, that time Odysseus

went to collect a debt the whole realm owed him,

20for Messenian raiders had lifted flocks from Ithaca,

three hundred head in their oarswept ships, the herdsmen too.

So his father and island elders sent Odysseus off,

a young boy on a mission,

a distant embassy made to right that wrong.

Iphitus went there hunting the stock that he had lost,

a dozen mares still nursing their hardy suckling mules.

The same mares that would prove his certain death

when he reached the son of Zeus, that iron heart,

Heracles—the past master of monstrous works—

30who killed the man, a guest in his own house.

Brutal. Not a care for the wrathful eyes of god

or rites of hospitality he had spread before him,

no, he dined him, then he murdered him, commandeered

those hard-hoofed mares for the hero’s own grange.

Still on the trail of these when he met Odysseus,

Iphitus gave him the bow his father, mighty Eurytus,

used to wield as a young man, but when he died

in his lofty house he left it to his son.

In turn, Odysseus gave his friend a sharp sword

40and a rugged spear to mark the start of friendship,

treasured ties that bind. But before they got to know

the warmth of each other’s board, the son of Zeus

had murdered Iphitus, Eurytus’ magnificent son

who gave the prince the bow.

That great weapon—

King Odysseus never took it abroad with him

when he sailed off to war in his long black ships.

He kept it stored away in his stately house,

guarding the memory of a cherished friend,

and only took that bow on hunts at home.

Now,

50the lustrous queen soon reached the hidden vault

and stopped at the oaken doorsill, work an expert

sanded smooth and trued to the line some years ago,

planting the doorjambs snugly, hanging shining doors.

At once she loosed the thong from around its hook,

55inserted the key and aiming straight and true,

shot back the bolts—and the rasping doors groaned

as loud as a bull will bellow, champing grass at pasture.

So as the key went home those handsome double doors

rang out now and sprang wide before her.

60She stepped onto a plank where chests stood tall,

brimming with clothing scented sweet with cedar.

Reaching, tiptoe, lifting the bow down off its peg,

still secure in the burnished case that held it,

down she sank, laying the case across her knees,

and dissolved in tears with a high thin wail

as she drew her husband’s weapon from its sheath…

Then, having wept and sobbed to her heart’s content,

off she went to the hall to meet her proud admirers,

cradling her husband’s backsprung bow in her arms,

70its quiver bristling arrows, shafts of pain.

Her women followed, bringing a chest that held

the bronze and the iron axes, trophies won by the master.

That radiant woman, once she reached her suitors,

drawing her glistening veil across her cheeks,

paused now where a column propped the sturdy roof,

with one of her loyal handmaids stationed either side,

and delivered an ultimatum to her suitors:

“Listen to me, my overbearing friends!

You who plague this palace night and day,

80drinking, eating us out of house and home

with the lord and master absent, gone so long—

the only excuse that you can offer is your zest

to win me as your bride. So, to arms, my gallants!

Here is the prize at issue, right before you, look—

I set before you the great bow of King Odysseus now!

The hand that can string this bow with greatest ease,

that shoots an arrow clean through all twelve axes—

he is the man I follow, yes, forsaking this house

where I was once a bride, this gracious house

90so filled with the best that life can offer—

I shall always remember it, that I know…

even in my dreams.”

She turned to Eumaeus,

ordered the good swineherd now to set the bow

and the gleaming iron axes out before the suitors.

He broke into tears as he received them, laid them down.

The cowherd wept too, when he saw his master’s bow.

But Antinous wheeled on both and let them have it:

“Yokels, fools—you can’t tell night from day!

You mawkish idiots, why are you sniveling here?

100You’re stirring up your mistress! Isn’t she drowned

in grief already? She’s lost her darling husband.

Sit down. Eat in peace, or take your snuffling

out of doors! But leave that bow right here—

our crucial test that makes or breaks us all.

105No easy game, I wager, to string his polished bow.

Not a soul in the crowd can match Odysseus—

what a man he was…

I saw him once, remember him to this day,

though I was young and foolish way back then.”

Smooth talk,

110but deep in the suitor’s heart his hopes were bent

on stringing the bow and shooting through the axes.

Antinous—fated to be the first man to taste

an arrow whipped from great Odysseus’ hands,

the king he mocked, at ease in the king’s house,

egging comrades on to mock him too.

“Amazing!”

Prince Telemachus waded in with a laugh:

“Zeus up there has robbed me of my wits.

My own dear mother, sensible as she is,

says she’ll marry again, forsake our house,

120and look at me—laughing for all I’m worth,

giggling like some fool. Step up, my friends!

Here is the prize at issue, right before you, look—

a woman who has no equal now in all Achaean country,

neither in holy Pylos, nor in Argos or Mycenae,

not even Ithaca itself or the loamy mainland.

You know it well. Why sing my mother’s praises?

Come, let the games begin! No dodges, no delays,

no turning back from the stringing of the bow—

we’ll see who wins, we will.

130I’d even take a crack at the bow myself…

If I string it and shoot through all the axes,

I’d worry less if my noble mother left our house

with another man and left me here behind—man enough

at last to win my father’s splendid prizes!”

With that

he leapt to his feet and dropped his bright-red cloak,

slipping the sword and sword-belt off his shoulders.

137First he planted the axes, digging a long trench,

one for all, and trued them all to a line

then tamped the earth to bed them. Wonder took

140the revelers looking on: his work so firm, precise,

though he’d never seen the axes ranged before.

He stood at the threshold, poised to try the bow…

Three times he made it shudder, straining to bend it,

three times his power flagged—but his hopes ran high

he’d string his father’s bow and shoot through every iron

and now, struggling with all his might for the fourth time,

he would have strung the bow, but Odysseus shook his head

and stopped him short despite his tensing zeal.

“God help me,” the inspired prince cried out,

150“must I be a weakling, a failure all my life?

Unless I’m just too young to trust my hands

to fight off any man who rises up against me.

Come, my betters, so much stronger than I am—

try the bow and finish off the contest.”

He propped his father’s weapon on the ground,

tilting it up against the polished well-hung doors

and resting a shaft aslant the bow’s fine horn,

then back he went to the seat that he had left.

“Up, friends!” Antinous called, taking over.

160“One man after another, left to right,

starting from where the steward pours the wine.”

So Antinous urged and all agreed.

163The first man up was Leodes, Oenops’ son,

a seer who could see their futures in the smoke,

who always sat by the glowing winebowl, well back,

the one man in the group who loathed their reckless ways,

appalled by all their outrage. His turn first…

Picking up the weapon now and the swift arrow,

he stood at the threshold, poised to try the bow

170but failed to bend it. As soon as he tugged the string

his hands went slack, his soft, uncallused hands,

and he called back to the suitors, “Friends,

I can’t bend it. Take it, someone—try.

Here is a bow to rob our best of life and breath,

all our best contenders! Still, better be dead

than live on here, never winning the prize

that tempts us all—forever in pursuit,

burning with expectation every day.

If there’s still a suitor here who hopes,

180who aches to marry Penelope, Odysseus’ wife,

just let him try the bow; he’ll see the truth!

He’ll soon lay siege to another Argive woman

trailing her long robes, and shower her with gifts—

and then our queen can marry the one who offers most,

the man marked out by fate to be her husband.”

With those words he thrust the bow aside,

tilting it up against the polished well-hung doors

and resting a shaft aslant the bow’s fine horn,

then back he went to the seat that he had left.

190But Antinous turned on the seer, abuses flying:

“Leodes! what are you saying? what’s got past your lips?

What awful, grisly nonsense—it shocks me to hear it—

‘here is a bow to rob our best of life and breath!’

Just because you can’t string it, you’re so weak?

Clearly your genteel mother never bred her boy

for the work of bending bows and shooting arrows.

We have champions in our ranks to string it quickly.

Hop to it, Melanthius!”—he barked at the goatherd—

“Rake the fire in the hall, pull up a big stool,

200heap it with fleece and fetch that hefty ball

of lard from the stores inside. So we young lords

can heat and limber the bow and rub it down with grease

before we try again and finish off the contest!”

The goatherd bustled about to rake the fire

still going strong. He pulled up a big stool,

heaped it with fleece and fetched the hefty ball

of lard from the stores inside. And the young men

limbered the bow, rubbing it down with hot grease,

then struggled to bend it back but failed. No use—

210they fell far short of the strength the bow required.

Antinous still held off, dashing Eurymachus too,

the ringleaders of all the suitors,

head and shoulders the strongest of the lot.

But now

the king’s two men, the cowherd and the swineherd,

had slipped out of the palace side-by-side

and great Odysseus left the house to join them.

Once they were past the courtyard and the gates

he probed them deftly, surely: “Cowherd, swineherd,

what, shall I blurt this out or keep it to myself?

220No, speak out. The heart inside me says so.

How far would you go to fight beside Odysseus?

Say he dropped like that from a clear blue sky

and a god brought him back—

would you fight for the suitors or your king?

Tell me how you feel inside your hearts.”

“Father Zeus,” the trusty cowherd shouted,

“bring my prayer to pass! Let the master come—

some god guide him now! You’d see my power,

my fighting arms in action!”

230Eumaeus echoed his prayer to all the gods

that their wise king would soon come home again.

Certain at least these two were loyal to the death,

Odysseus reassured them quickly: “I’m right here,

here in the flesh—myself—and home at last,

after bearing twenty years of brutal hardship.

Now I know that of all my men you two alone

longed for my return. From the rest I’ve heard

not one real prayer that I come back again.

So now I’ll tell you what’s in store for you.

240If a god beats down the lofty suitors at my hands,

I’ll find you wives, both of you, grant you property,

sturdy houses beside my own, and in my eyes you’ll be

comrades to Prince Telemachus, brothers from then on.

Come, I’ll show you something—living proof—

know me for certain, put your minds at rest.

This scar,

look, where a boar’s white tusk gored me, years ago,

hunting on Parnassus, Autolycus’ sons and I.”

With that,

pushing back his rags, he revealed the great scar…

And the men gazed at it, scanned it, knew it well,

250broke into tears and threw their arms around their master—

lost in affection, kissing his head and shoulders,

and so Odysseus kissed their heads and hands.

Now the sun would have set upon their tears

if Odysseus had not called a halt himself.

“No more weeping. Coming out of the house

a man might see us, tell the men inside.

Let’s slip back in—singly, not in a pack.

I’ll go first. You’re next. Here’s our signal.

When all the rest in there, our lordly friends,

260are dead against my having the bow and quiver,

good Eumaeus, carry the weapon down the hall

and put it in my hands. Then tell the serving-women

to lock the snugly fitted doors to their own rooms.

If anyone hears from there the jolting blows

and groans of men, caught in our huge net,

not one of them show her face—

sit tight, keep to her weaving, not a sound.

You, my good Philoetius, here are your orders.

Shoot the bolt of the courtyard’s outer gate,

lock it, lash it fast.”

270With that command

the master entered his well-constructed house

and back he went to the stool that he had left.

The king’s two men, in turn, slipped in as well.

Just now Eurymachus held the bow in his hands,

turning it over, tip to tip, before the blazing fire

to heat the weapon. But he failed to bend it even so

and the suitor’s high heart groaned to bursting.

“A black day,” he exclaimed in wounded pride,

“a blow to myself, a blow to each man here!

280It’s less the marriage that mortifies me now—

that’s galling too, but lots of women are left,

some in seagirt Ithaca, some in other cities.

What breaks my heart is the fact we fall so short

of great Odysseus’ strength we cannot string his bow.

285A disgrace to ring in the ears of men to come.”

“Eurymachus,” Eupithes’ son Antinous countered,

“it will never come to that, as you well know.

Today is a feast-day up and down the island

in honor of the Archer God. Who flexes bows today?

290Set it aside. Rest easy now. And all the axes,

let’s just leave them planted where they are.

Trust me, no one’s about to crash the gates

of Laertes’ son and carry off these trophies.

Steward, pour some drops for the god in every cup,

we’ll tip the wine, then put the bow to bed.

And first thing in the morning have Melanthius

bring the pick of his goats from all his herds

so we can burn the thighs to Apollo, god of archers—

then try the bow and finish off the contest.”

300Welcome advice. And again they all agreed.

Heralds sprinkled water over their hands for rinsing,

the young men brimmed the mixing bowls with wine,

they tipped first drops for the god in every cup,

then poured full rounds for all. And now, once

they’d tipped libations out and drunk their fill,

the king of craft, Odysseus, said with all his cunning,

“Listen to me, you lords who court the noble queen.

I have to say what the heart inside me urges.

I appeal especially to Eurymachus, and you,

310brilliant Antinous, who spoke so shrewdly now.

Give the bow a rest for today, leave it to the gods—

at dawn the Archer God will grant a victory

to the man he favors most.

For the moment,

give me the polished bow now, won’t you? So,

to amuse you all, I can try my hand, my strength…

is the old force still alive inside these gnarled limbs?

Or has a life of roaming, years of rough neglect,

destroyed it long ago?”

Modest words

that sent them all into hot, indignant rage,

320fearing he just might string the polished bow.

So Antinous rounded on him, dressed him down:

“Not a shred of sense in your head, you filthy drifter!

Not content to feast at your ease with us, the island’s pride?

Never denied your full share of the banquet, never,

you can listen in on our secrets. No one else

can eavesdrop on our talk, no tramp, no beggar.

The wine has overpowered you, heady wine—

the ruin of many another man, whoever

gulps it down and drinks beyond his limit.

330Wine—it drove the Centaur, famous Eurytion,

331mad in the halls of lionhearted Pirithous.

332There to visit the Lapiths, crazed with wine

the headlong Centaur bent to his ugly work

in the prince’s own house! His hosts sprang up,

seized with fury, dragged him across the forecourt,

flung him out of doors, hacking his nose and ears off

with their knives, no mercy. The creature reeled away,

still blind with drink, his heart like a wild storm,

loaded with all the frenzy in his mind!

And so

340the feud between mortal men and Centaurs had its start.

But the drunk was first to bring disaster on himself

by drowning in his cups. You too, I promise you

no end of trouble if you should string that bow.

You’ll meet no kindness in our part of the world—

we’ll sail you off in a black ship to Echetus,

the mainland king who wrecks all men alive.

Nothing can save you from his royal grip!

So drink, but hold your peace,

don’t take on the younger, stronger men.”

350“Antinous,” watchful Penelope stepped in,

“how impolite it would be, how wrong, to scant

whatever guest Telemachus welcomes to his house.

You really think—if the stranger trusts so to his hands

and strength that he strings Odysseus’ great bow—

he’ll take me home and claim me as his bride?

He never dreamed of such a thing, I’m sure.

Don’t let that ruin the feast for any reveler here.

Unthinkable—nothing, nothing could be worse.”

Polybus’ son Eurymachus had an answer:

360“Wise Penelope, daughter of Icarius, do we really

expect the man to wed you? Unthinkable, I know.

But we do recoil at the talk of men and women.

One of the island’s meaner sort will mutter,

‘Look at the riffraff courting a king’s wife.

Weaklings, look, they can’t even string his bow.

But along came this beggar, drifting out of the blue—

strung his bow with ease and shot through all the axes!’

Gossip will fly. We’ll hang our heads in shame.”

“Shame?” alert Penelope protested—

370“How can you hope for any public fame at all?

You who disgrace, devour a great man’s house and home!

Why hang your heads in shame over next to nothing?

Our friend here is a strapping, well-built man

and claims to be the son of a noble father.

Come, hand him the bow now, let’s just see…

I tell you this—and I’ll make good my word—

if he strings the bow and Apollo grants him glory,

I’ll dress him in shirt and cloak, in handsome clothes,

I’ll give him a good sharp lance to fight off men and dogs,

380give him a two-edged sword and sandals for his feet

and send him off, wherever his heart desires.”

“Mother,”

poised Telemachus broke in now, “my father’s bow—

no Achaean on earth has more right than I

to give it or withhold it, as I please.

Of all the lords in Ithaca’s rocky heights

or the islands facing Elis grazed by horses,

not a single one will force or thwart my will,

even if I decide to give our guest this bow—

a gift outright—to carry off himself.

So, mother,

390go back to your quarters. Tend to your own tasks,

the distaff and the loom, and keep the women

working hard as well. As for the bow now,

men will see to that, but I most of all:

I hold the reins of power in this house.”

Astonished,

she withdrew to her own room. She took to heart

the clear good sense in what her son had said.

Climbing up to the lofty chamber with her women,

she fell to weeping for Odysseus, her beloved husband,

till watchful Athena sealed her eyes with welcome sleep.

400And now the loyal swineherd had lifted up the bow,

was taking it toward the king, when all the suitors

burst out in an ugly uproar through the palace—

brash young bullies, this or that one heckling,

“Where on earth are you going with that bow?”

“You, you grubby swineherd, are you crazy?”

“The speedy dogs you reared will eat your corpse—”

“Out there with your pigs, out in the cold, alone!”

“If only Apollo and all the gods shine down on us!”

Eumaeus froze in his tracks, put down the bow,

410panicked by every outcry in the hall.

Telemachus shouted too, from the other side,

and full of threats: “Carry on with the bow, old boy!

If you serve too many masters, you’ll soon suffer.

Look sharp, or I’ll pelt you back to your farm

with flying rocks. I may be younger than you

but I’m much stronger. If only I had that edge

in fists and brawn over all this courting crowd,

I’d soon dispatch them—licking their wounds at last—

clear of our palace where they plot their vicious plots!”

420His outburst sent them all into gales of laughter,

blithe and oblivious, that dissolved their pique

against the prince. The swineherd took the bow,

carried it down the hall to his ready, waiting king

and standing by him, placed it in his hands,

then he called the nurse aside and whispered,

“Good Eurycleia—Telemachus commands you now

to lock the snugly fitted doors to your own rooms.

If anyone hears from there the jolting blows

and groans of men, caught in our huge net,

430not one of you show your face—

sit tight, keep to your weaving, not a sound.”

That silenced the old nurse—

she barred the doors that led from the long hall.

The cowherd quietly bounded out of the house

to lock the gates of the high-stockaded court.

Under the portico lay a cable, ship’s tough gear:

he lashed the gates with this, then slipped back in

and ran and sat on the stool that he’d just left,

eyes riveted on Odysseus.

Now he held the bow

440in his own hands, turning it over, tip to tip,

testing it, this way, that way… fearing worms

had bored through the weapon’s horn with the master gone abroad.

A suitor would glance at his neighbor, jeering, taunting,

“Look at our connoisseur of bows!”

“Sly old fox—

maybe he’s got bows like it, stored in his house.”

“That or he’s bent on making one himself.”

“Look how he twists and turns it in his hands!”

“The clever tramp means trouble—”

“I wish him luck,” some cocksure lord chimed in,

450“as good as his luck in bending back that weapon!”

So they mocked, but Odysseus, mastermind in action,

once he’d handled the great bow and scanned every inch,

then, like an expert singer skilled at lyre and song—

who strains a string to a new peg with ease,

making the pliant sheep-gut fast at either end—

so with his virtuoso ease Odysseus strung his mighty bow.

Quickly his right hand plucked the string to test its pitch

and under his touch it sang out clear and sharp as a swallow’s cry.

Horror swept through the suitors, faces blanching white,

460and Zeus cracked the sky with a bolt, his blazing sign,

and the great man who had borne so much rejoiced at last

that the son of cunning Cronus flung that omen down for him.

He snatched a winged arrow lying bare on the board—

the rest still bristled deep inside the quiver,

soon to be tasted by all the feasters there.

Setting shaft on the handgrip, drawing the notch

467and bowstring back, back… right from his stool,

just as he sat but aiming straight and true, he let fly—

and never missing an ax from the first ax-handle

470clean on through to the last and out

the shaft with its weighted brazen head shot free!

“Telemachus,”

Odysseus looked to his son and said, “your guest,

sitting here in your house, has not disgraced you.

No missing the mark, look, and no long labor spent

to string the bow. My strength’s not broken yet,

not quite so frail as the mocking suitors thought.

But the hour has come to serve our masters right—

supper in broad daylight—then to other revels,

song and dancing, all that crowns a feast.”

480He paused with a warning nod, and at that sign

Prince Telemachus, son of King Odysseus,

girding his sharp sword on, clamping hand to spear,

took his stand by a chair that flanked his father—

his bronze spearpoint glinting now like fire…

BOOK TWENTY-TWO

Slaughter in the Hall

N
ow stripping back his rags Odysseus master of craft and battle

vaulted onto the great threshold, gripping his bow and quiver

bristling arrows, and poured his flashing shafts before him,

loose at his feet, and thundered out to all the suitors:

“Look—your crucial test is finished, now, at last!

But another target’s left that no one’s hit before—

we’ll see if I can hit it—Apollo give me glory!”

With that he trained a stabbing arrow on Antinous…

just lifting a gorgeous golden loving-cup in his hands,

10just tilting the two-handled goblet back to his lips,

about to drain the wine—and slaughter the last thing

on the suitor’s mind: who could dream that one foe

in that crowd of feasters, however great his power,

would bring down death on himself, and black doom?

But Odysseus aimed and shot Antinous square in the throat

and the point went stabbing clean through the soft neck and out—

and off to the side he pitched, the cup dropped from his grasp

as the shaft sank home, and the man’s life-blood came spurting

from his nostrils—

thick red jets—

a sudden thrust of his foot—

he kicked away the table—

20food showered across the floor,

the bread and meats soaked in a swirl of bloody filth.

The suitors burst into uproar all throughout the house

when they saw their leader down. They leapt from their seats,

milling about, desperate, scanning the stone walls—

not a shield in sight, no rugged spear to seize.

They wheeled on Odysseus, lashing out in fury:

“Stranger, shooting at men will cost your life!”

“Your game is over—you, you’ve shot your last!”

“You’ll never escape your own headlong death!”

30“You killed the best in Ithaca—our fine prince!”

“Vultures will eat your corpse!”

Groping, frantic—

each one persuading himself the guest had killed

the man by chance. Poor fools, blind to the fact

that all their necks were in the noose, their doom sealed.

With a dark look, the wily fighter Odysseus shouted back,

36“You dogs! you never imagined I’d return from Troy—

so cocksure that you bled my house to death,

ravished my serving-women—wooed my wife

behind my back while I was still alive!

40No fear of the gods who rule the skies up there,

no fear that men’s revenge might arrive someday—

now all your necks are in the noose—your doom is sealed!”

Terror gripped them all, blanched their faces white,

each man glancing wildly—how to escape his instant death?

Only Eurymachus had the breath to venture, “If you,

you’re truly Odysseus of Ithaca, home at last,

you’re right to accuse these men of what they’ve done—

so much reckless outrage here in your palace,

so much on your lands. But here he lies,

50quite dead, and he incited it all—Antinous—

look, the man who drove us all to crime!

Not that he needed marriage, craved it so;

he’d bigger game in mind—though Zeus barred his way—

he’d lord it over Ithaca’s handsome country, king himself,

once he’d lain in wait for your son and cut him down!

But now he’s received the death that he deserved.

So spare your own people! Later we’ll recoup

your costs with a tax laid down upon the land,

covering all we ate and drank inside your halls,

60and each of us here will pay full measure too—

twenty oxen in value, bronze and gold we’ll give

until we melt your heart. Before we’ve settled,

who on earth could blame you for your rage?”

But the battle-master kept on glaring, seething.

65“No, Eurymachus! Not if you paid me all your father’s wealth—

all you possess now, and all that could pour in from the world’s end—

no, not even then would I stay my hands from slaughter

till all you suitors had paid for all your crimes!

Now life or death—your choice—fight me or flee

70if you hope to escape your sudden bloody doom!

I doubt one man in the lot will save his skin!”

His menace shook their knees, their hearts too

but Eurymachus spoke again, now to the suitors: “Friends!

This man will never restrain his hands, invincible hands—

now that he’s seized that polished bow and quiver, look,

he’ll shoot from the sill until he’s killed us all!

So fight—call up the joy of battle! Swords out!

Tables lifted—block his arrows winging death!

Charge him, charge in a pack—

80try to rout the man from the sill, the doors,

race through town and sound an alarm at once—

our friend would soon see he’s shot his bolt!”

Brave talk—

he drew his two-edged sword, bronze, honed for the kill

and hurled himself at the king with a raw savage cry

in the same breath that Odysseus loosed an arrow

ripping his breast beside the nipple so hard

it lodged in the man’s liver—

out of his grasp the sword dropped to the ground—

over his table, head over heels he tumbled, doubled up,

90flinging his food and his two-handled cup across the floor—

he smashed the ground with his forehead, writhing in pain,

both feet flailing out, and his high seat tottered—

the mist of death came swirling down his eyes.

Amphinomus rushed the king in all his glory,

charging him face-to-face, a slashing sword drawn—

if only he could force him clear of the doorway, now,

but Telemachus—too quick—stabbed the man from behind,

plunging his bronze spear between the suitor’s shoulders

and straight on through his chest the point came jutting out—

100down he went with a thud, his forehead slammed the ground.

Telemachus swerved aside, leaving his long spearshaft

lodged in Amphinomus—fearing some suitor just might

lunge in from behind as he tugged the shaft,

impale him with a sword or hack him down,

crouching over the corpse.

He went on the run, reached his father at once

and halting right beside him, let fly, “Father—

now I’ll get you a shield and a pair of spears,

a helmet of solid bronze to fit your temples!

110I’ll arm myself on the way back and hand out

arms to the swineherd, arm the cowherd too—

we’d better fight equipped!”

“Run, fetch them,”

the wily captain urged, “while I’ve got arrows left

to defend me—or they’ll force me from the doors

while I fight on alone!”

Telemachus moved to his father’s orders smartly.

Off he ran to the room where the famous arms lay stored,

took up four shields, eight spears, four bronze helmets

ridged with horsehair crests and, loaded with these,

120ran back to reach his father’s side in no time.

The prince was first to case himself in bronze

and his servants followed suit—both harnessed up

and all three flanked Odysseus, mastermind of war,

and he, as long as he’d arrows left to defend himself,

kept picking suitors off in the palace, one by one

and down they went, corpse on corpse in droves.

Then, when the royal archer’s shafts ran out,

he leaned his bow on a post of the massive doors—

where walls of the hallway catch the light—and armed:

130across his shoulder he slung a buckler four plies thick,

over his powerful head he set a well-forged helmet,

the horsehair crest atop it tossing, bristling terror,

and grasped two rugged lances tipped with fiery bronze.

134Now a side-door was fitted into the main wall—

right at the edge of the great hall’s stone sill—

and led to a passage always shut by good tight boards.

But Odysseus gave the swineherd strict commands

to stand hard by the side-door, guard it well—

the only way the suitors might break out.

140Agelaus called to his comrades with a plan:

“Friends, can’t someone climb through the hatch?—

tell men outside to sound the alarm, be quick—

our guest would soon see he’d shot his last!”

The goatherd Melanthius answered, “Not a chance,

my lord—the door to the courtyard’s much too near,

dangerous too, the mouth of the passage cramped.

One strong man could block us, one and all!

No, I’ll fetch you some armor to harness on,

out of the storeroom—there, nowhere else, I’m sure,

150the king and his gallant son have stowed their arms!”

With that the goatherd clambered up through smoke-ducts

high on the wall and scurried into Odysseus’ storeroom,

bundled a dozen shields, as many spears and helmets

ridged with horsehair crests and, loaded with these,

rushed back down to the suitors, quickly issued arms.

Odysseus’ knees shook, his heart too, when he saw them

buckling on their armor, brandishing long spears—

here was a battle looming, well he knew.

He turned at once to Telemachus, warnings flying:

160“A bad break in the fight, my boy! One of the women’s

tipped the odds against us—or could it be the goatherd?”

“My fault, father,” the cool clear prince replied,

“the blame’s all mine. That snug door to the vault,

I left it ajar—they’ve kept a better watch than I.

Go, Eumaeus, shut the door to the storeroom,

check and see if it’s one of the women’s tricks

or Dolius’ son Melanthius. He’s our man, I’d say.”

And even as they conspired, back the goatherd

climbed to the room to fetch more burnished arms,

170but Eumaeus spotted him, quickly told his king

who stood close by: “Odysseus, wily captain,

there he goes again, the infernal nuisance—

just as we suspected—back to the storeroom.

Give me a clear command!

Do I kill the man—if I can take him down—

or drag him back to you, here, to pay in full

for the vicious work he’s plotted in your house?”

Odysseus, master of tactics, answered briskly,

“I and the prince will keep these brazen suitors

180crammed in the hall, for all their battle-fury.

You two wrench Melanthius’ arms and legs behind him,

fling him down in the storeroom—lash his back to a plank

and strap a twisted cable fast to the scoundrel’s body,

hoist him up a column until he hits the rafters—

let him dangle in agony, still alive,

for a good long time!”

They hung on his orders, keen to do his will.

Off they ran to the storeroom, unseen by him inside—

Melanthius, rummaging after arms, deep in a dark recess

190as the two men took their stand, either side of the doorposts,

poised till the goatherd tried to cross the doorsill…

one hand clutching a crested helmet, the other

an ample old buckler blotched with mildew,

the shield Laertes bore as a young soldier once

but there it lay for ages, seams on the handstraps split—

Quick, they rushed him, seized him, haled him back by the hair,

flung him down on the floor, writhing with terror, bound him

hand and foot with a chafing cord, wrenched his limbs

back, back till the joints locked tight—

200just as Laertes’ cunning son commanded—

they strapped a twisted cable round his body,

hoisted him up a column until he hit the rafters,

then you mocked him, Eumaeus, my good swineherd:

“Now stand guard through the whole night, Melanthius—

stretched out on a soft bed fit for you, your highness!

You’re bound to see the Morning rising up from the Ocean,

mounting her golden throne—at just the hour you always

drive in goats to feast the suitors in the hall!”

So they left him, trussed in his agonizing sling;

210they clapped on armor again, shut the gleaming doors

and ran to rejoin Odysseus, mastermind of war.

And now as the ranks squared off, breathing fury—

four at the sill confronting a larger, stronger force

arrayed inside the hall—now Zeus’s daughter Athena,

taking the build and voice of Mentor, swept in

and Odysseus, thrilled to see her, cried out,

“Rescue us, Mentor, now it’s life or death!

Remember your old comrade—all the service

I offered you! We were boys together!”

So he cried

220yet knew in his bones it was Athena, Driver of Armies.

But across the hall the suitors brayed against her,

Agelaus first, his outburst full of threats:

“Mentor, never let Odysseus trick you into

siding with him to fight against the suitors.

Here’s our plan of action, and we will see it through!

Once we’ve killed them both, the father and the son,

we’ll kill you too, for all you’re bent on doing

here in the halls—you’ll pay with your own head!

And once our swords have stopped your violence cold—

230all your property, all in your house, your fields,

we’ll lump it all with Odysseus’ rich estate

and never let your sons live on in your halls

or free your wife and daughters to walk through town!”

Naked threats—and Athena hit new heights of rage,

she lashed out at Odysseus now with blazing accusations:

236“Where’s it gone, Odysseus—your power, your fighting heart?

The great soldier who fought for famous white-armed Helen,

battling Trojans nine long years—nonstop, no mercy,

mowing their armies down in grueling battle—

240you who seized the broad streets of Troy

241with your fine strategic stroke! How can you—

now you’ve returned to your own house, your own wealth—

bewail the loss of your combat strength in a war with suitors?

Come, old friend, stand by me! You’ll see action now,

245see how Mentor the son of Alcimus, that brave fighter,

kills your enemies, pays you back for service!”

Rousing words—

but she gave no all-out turning of the tide, not yet,

she kept on testing Odysseus and his gallant son,

putting their force and fighting heart to proof.

250For all the world like a swallow in their sight

she flew on high to perch

on the great hall’s central roofbeam black with smoke.

But the suitors closed ranks, commanded now by Damastor’s son

254Agelaus, flanked by Eurynomus, Demoptolemus and Amphimedon,

255Pisander, Polyctor’s son, and Polybus ready, waiting—

head and shoulders the best and bravest of the lot

still left to fight for their lives,

now that the pelting shafts had killed the rest.

Agelaus spurred his comrades on with battle-plans:

260“Friends, at last the man’s invincible hands are useless!

Mentor has mouthed some empty boasts and flitted off—

just four are left to fight at the front doors. So now,

no wasting your long spears—all at a single hurl,

just six of us launch out in the first wave!

If Zeus is willing, we may hit Odysseus,

carry off the glory! The rest are nothing

once the captain’s down!”

At his command,

concentrating their shots, all six hurled as one

but Athena sent the whole salvo wide of the mark—

270one of them hit the jamb of the great hall’s doors,

another the massive door itself, and the heavy bronze point

of a third ashen javelin crashed against the wall.

Seeing his men untouched by the suitors’ flurry,

steady Odysseus leapt to take command:

“Friends! now it’s for us to hurl at them, I say,

into this ruck of suitors! Topping all their crimes

they’re mad to strip the armor off our bodies!”

Taking aim at the ranks, all four let fly as one

and the lances struck home—Odysseus killed Demoptolemus,

280Telemachus killed Euryades—the swineherd, Elatus—

and the cowherd cut Pisander down in blood.

They bit the dust of the broad floor, all as one.

Back to the great hall’s far recess the others shrank

as the four rushed in and plucked up spears from corpses.

And again the suitors hurled their whetted shafts

but Athena sent the better part of the salvo wide—

one of them hit the jamb of the great hall’s doors,

another the massive door itself, and the heavy bronze point

of a third ashen javelin crashed against the wall.

290True, Amphimedon nicked Telemachus on the wrist—

the glancing blade just barely broke his skin.

Ctesippus sent a long spear sailing over

Eumaeus’ buckler, grazing his shoulder blade

but the weapon skittered off and hit the ground.

And again those led by the brilliant battle-master

hurled their razor spears at the suitors’ ranks—

and now Odysseus raider of cities hit Eurydamas,

Telemachus hit Amphimedon—Eumaeus, Polybus—

and the cowherd stabbed Ctesippus

300right in the man’s chest and triumphed over his body:

301“Love your mockery, do you? Son of that blowhard Polytherses!

No more shooting off your mouth, you idiot, such big talk—

leave the last word to the gods—they’re much stronger!

Take this spear, this guest-gift, for the cow’s hoof

you once gave King Odysseus begging in his house!”

So the master of longhorn cattle had his say—

as Odysseus, fighting at close quarters, ran Agelaus

through with a long lance—Telemachus speared Leocritus

so deep in the groin the bronze came punching out his back

310and the man crashed headfirst, slamming the ground full-face.

And now Athena, looming out of the rafters high above them,

brandished her man-destroying shield of thunder, terrifying

the suitors out of their minds, and down the hall they panicked—

wild, like herds stampeding, driven mad as the darting gadfly

strikes in the late spring when the long days come round.

The attackers struck like eagles, crook-clawed, hook-beaked,

swooping down from a mountain ridge to harry smaller birds

that skim across the flatland, cringing under the clouds

but the eagles plunge in fury, rip their lives out—hopeless,

320never a chance of flight or rescue—and people love the sport—

so the attackers routed suitors headlong down the hall,

wheeling into the slaughter, slashing left and right

and grisly screams broke from skulls cracked open—

the whole floor awash with blood.

Leodes now—

he flung himself at Odysseus, clutched his knees,

crying out to the king with a sudden, winging prayer:

“I hug your knees, Odysseus—mercy! spare my life!

Never, I swear, did I harass any woman in your house—

never a word, a gesture—nothing, no, I tried

330to restrain the suitors, whoever did such things.

They wouldn’t listen, keep their hands to themselves—

so reckless, so they earn their shameful fate.

But I was just their prophet—

my hands are clean—and I’m to die their death!

Look at the thanks I get for years of service!”

A killing look, and the wry soldier answered,

“Only a priest, a prophet for this mob, you say?

How hard you must have prayed in my own house

that the heady day of my return would never dawn—

340my dear wife would be yours, would bear your children!

For that there’s no escape from grueling death—you die!”

And snatching up in one powerful hand a sword

left on the ground—Agelaus dropped it when he fell—

Odysseus hacked the prophet square across the neck

and the praying head went tumbling in the dust.

Now one was left,

346trying still to escape black death. Phemius, Terpis’ son,

the bard who always performed among the suitors—

they forced the man to sing…

There he stood, backing into the side-door,

350still clutching his ringing lyre in his hands,

his mind in turmoil, torn—what should he do?

Steal from the hall and crouch at the altar-stone

of Zeus who Guards the Court, where time and again

Odysseus and Laertes burned the long thighs of oxen?

Or throw himself on the master’s mercy, clasp his knees?

That was the better way—or so it struck him, yes,

grasp the knees of Laertes’ royal son. And so,

cradling his hollow lyre, he laid it on the ground

between the mixing-bowl and the silver-studded throne,

360then rushed up to Odysseus, yes, and clutched his knees,

singing out to his king with a stirring, winged prayer:

“I hug your knees, Odysseus—mercy! spare my life!

What a grief it will be to you for all the years to come

if you kill the singer now, who sings for gods and men.

I taught myself the craft, but a god has planted

deep in my spirit all the paths of song—

songs I’m fit to sing for you as for a god.

Calm your bloodlust now—don’t take my head!

He’d bear me out, your own dear son Telemachus—

370never of my own will, never for any gain did I

perform in your house, singing after the suitors

had their feasts. They were too strong, too many—

they forced me to come and sing—I had no choice!”

The inspired Prince Telemachus heard his pleas

and quickly said to his father close beside him,

“Stop, don’t cut him down! This one’s innocent.

So is the herald Medon—the one who always

tended me in the house when I was little—

spare him too. Unless he’s dead by now,

380killed by Philoetius or Eumaeus here—

or ran into you rampaging through the halls.”

The herald pricked up his anxious ears at that…

cautious soul, he cowered, trembling, under a chair—

wrapped in an oxhide freshly stripped—to dodge black death.

He jumped in a flash from there, threw off the smelly hide

and scuttling up to Telemachus, clutching his knees,

the herald begged for life in words that fluttered:

“Here I am, dear boy—spare me! Tell your father,

flushed with victory, not to kill me with his sword—

390enraged as he is with these young lords who bled

his palace white and showed you no respect,

the reckless fools!”

Breaking into a smile

the canny Odysseus reassured him, “Courage!

The prince has pulled you through, he’s saved you now

so you can take it to heart and tell the next man too:

clearly doing good puts doing bad to shame.

Now leave the palace, go and sit outside—

out in the courtyard, clear of the slaughter—

you and the bard with all his many songs.

400Wait till I’ve done some household chores

that call for my attention.”

The two men scurried out of the house at once

and crouched at the altar-stone of mighty Zeus—

glancing left and right,

fearing death would strike at any moment.

Odysseus scanned his house to see if any man

still skulked alive, still hoped to avoid black death.

But he found them one and all in blood and dust…

great hauls of them down and out like fish that fishermen

410drag from the churning gray surf in looped and coiling nets

and fling ashore on a sweeping hook of beach—some noble catch

heaped on the sand, twitching, lusting for fresh salt sea

but the Sungod hammers down and burns their lives out…

so the suitors lay in heaps, corpse covering corpse.

At last the seasoned fighter turned to his son:

“Telemachus, go, call the old nurse here—

I must tell her all that’s on my mind.”

Telemachus ran to do his father’s bidding,

shook the women’s doors, calling Eurycleia:

420“Come out now! Up with you, good old woman!

You who watch over all the household hands—

quick, my father wants you, needs to have a word!”

Crisp command that left the old nurse hushed—

she spread the doors to the well-constructed hall,

slipped out in haste, and the prince led her on…

She found Odysseus in the thick of slaughtered corpses,

splattered with bloody filth like a lion that’s devoured

some ox of the field and lopes home, covered with blood,

his chest streaked, both jaws glistening, dripping red—

430a sight to strike terror. So Odysseus looked now,

splattered with gore, his thighs, his fighting hands,

and she, when she saw the corpses, all the pooling blood,

was about to lift a cry of triumph—here was a great exploit,

look—but the soldier held her back and checked her zeal

with warnings winging home: “Rejoice in your heart,

old woman—peace! No cries of triumph now.

It’s unholy to glory over the bodies of the dead.

These men the doom of the gods has brought low,

and their own indecent acts. They’d no regard

440for any man on earth—good or bad—

who chanced to come their way. And so, thanks

to their reckless work, they met this shameful fate.

Quick, report in full on the women in my halls—

who are disloyal to me, who are guiltless?”

“Surely, child,”

his fond old nurse replied, “now here’s the truth.

Fifty women you have inside your house,

women we’ve trained to do their duties well,

to card the wool and bear the yoke of service.

Some dozen in all went tramping to their shame,

450thumbing their noses at me, at the queen herself!

And Telemachus, just now come of age—his mother

would never let the boy take charge of the maids.

But let me climb to her well-lit room upstairs

and tell your wife the news—

some god has put the woman fast asleep.”

“Don’t wake her yet,” the crafty man returned,

“you tell those women to hurry here at once—

just the ones who’ve shamed us all along.”

Away the old nurse bustled through the house

460to give the women orders, rush them to the king.

Odysseus called Telemachus over, both herdsmen too,

with strict commands: “Start clearing away the bodies.

Make the women pitch in too. Chairs and tables—

scrub them down with sponges, rinse them clean.

And once you’ve put the entire house in order,

march the women out of the great hall—between

the roundhouse and the courtyard’s strong stockade—

and hack them with your swords, slash out all their lives—

blot out of their minds the joys of love they relished

470under the suitors’ bodies, rutting on the sly!”

The women crowded in, huddling all together…

wailing convulsively, streaming live warm tears.

First they carried out the bodies of the dead

and propped them under the courtyard colonnade,

standing them one against another. Odysseus

shouted commands himself, moving things along

and they kept bearing out the bodies—they were forced.

Next they scrubbed down the elegant chairs and tables,

washed them with sopping sponges, rinsed them clean.

480Then Telemachus and the herdsmen scraped smooth

the packed earth floor of the royal house with spades

as the women gathered up the filth and piled it outside.

And then, at last, once the entire house was put in order,

they marched the women out of the great hall—between

the roundhouse and the courtyard’s strong stockade—

crammed them into a dead end, no way out from there,

and stern Telemachus gave the men their orders:

488“No clean death for the likes of them, by god!

Not from me—they showered abuse on my head,

my mother’s too!

490You sluts—the suitors’ whores!”

With that, taking a cable used on a dark-prowed ship

he coiled it over the roundhouse, lashed it fast to a tall column,

hoisting it up so high no toes could touch the ground.

Then, as doves or thrushes beating their spread wings

against some snare rigged up in thickets—flying in

for a cozy nest but a grisly bed receives them—

so the women’s heads were trapped in a line,

nooses yanking their necks up, one by one

so all might die a pitiful, ghastly death…

they kicked up heels for a little—not for long.

500Melanthius?

They hauled him out through the doorway, into the court,

lopped his nose and ears with a ruthless knife,

tore his genitals out for the dogs to eat raw

and in manic fury hacked off hands and feet.

Then,

once they’d washed their own hands and feet,

they went inside again to join Odysseus.

Their work was done with now.

But the king turned to devoted Eurycleia, saying,

“Bring sulfur, nurse, to scour all this pollution—

510bring me fire too, so I can fumigate the house.

And call Penelope here with all her women—

tell all the maids to come back in at once.”

“Well said, my boy,” his old nurse replied,

“right to the point. But wait,

let me fetch you a shirt and cloak to wrap you.

No more dawdling round the palace, nothing but rags

to cover those broad shoulders—it’s a scandal!”

“Fire first,” the good soldier answered.

“Light me a fire to purify this house.”

520The devoted nurse snapped to his command,

brought her master fire and brimstone. Odysseus

purged his palace, halls and court, with cleansing fumes.

Then back through the royal house the old nurse went

to tell the women the news and bring them in at once.

They came crowding out of their quarters, torch in hand,

flung their arms around Odysseus, hugged him, home at last,

and kissed his head and shoulders, seized his hands, and he,

overcome by a lovely longing, broke down and wept…

deep in his heart he knew them one and all.

BOOK TWENTY-THREE

The Great Rooted Bed

U
p to the rooms the old nurse clambered, chuckling all the way,

to tell the queen her husband was here now, home at last.

Her knees bustling, feet shuffling over each other,

till hovering at her mistress’ head she spoke:

“Penelope—child—wake up and see for yourself,

with your own eyes, all you dreamed of, all your days!

He’s here—Odysseus—he’s come home, at long last!

He’s killed the suitors, swaggering young brutes

who plagued his house, wolfed his cattle down,

10rode roughshod over his son!”

“Dear old nurse,” wary Penelope replied,

“the gods have made you mad. They have that power,

putting lunacy into the clearest head around

or setting a half-wit on the path to sense.

They’ve unhinged you, and you were once so sane.

Why do you mock me?—haven’t I wept enough?—

telling such wild stories, interrupting my sleep,

sweet sleep that held me, sealed my eyes just now.

Not once have I slept so soundly since the day

20Odysseus sailed away to see that cursed city…

21
Destroy, I call it—I hate to say its name!

Now down you go. Back to your own quarters.

If any other woman of mine had come to me,

rousing me out of sleep with such a tale,

I’d have her bundled back to her room in pain.

It’s only your old gray head that spares you that!”

“Never”—the fond old nurse kept pressing on—

“dear child, I’d never mock you! No, it’s all true,

he’s here—Odysseus—he’s come home, just as I tell you!

30He’s the stranger they all manhandled in the hall.

Telemachus knew he was here, for days and days,

but he knew enough to hide his father’s plans

so he could pay those vipers back in kind!”

Penelope’s heart burst in joy, she leapt from bed,

her eyes streaming tears, she hugged the old nurse

and cried out with an eager, winging word,

“Please, dear one, give me the whole story.

If he’s really home again, just as you tell me,

how did he get those shameless suitors in his clutches?—

40single-handed, braving an army always camped inside.”

“I have no idea,” the devoted nurse replied.

“I didn’t see it, I didn’t ask—all I heard

was the choking groans of men cut down in blood.

We crouched in terror—a dark nook of our quarters—

all of us locked tight behind those snug doors

till your boy Telemachus came and called me out—

his father rushed him there to do just that. And then

I found Odysseus in the thick of slaughtered corpses;

there he stood and all around him, over the beaten floor,

50the bodies sprawled in heaps, lying one on another…

How it would have thrilled your heart to see him—

splattered with bloody filth, a lion with his kill!

And now they’re all stacked at the courtyard gates—

he’s lit a roaring fire,

he’s purifying the house with cleansing fumes

and he’s sent me here to bring you back to him.

Follow me down! So now, after all the years of grief,

you two can embark, loving hearts, along the road to joy.

Look, your dreams, put off so long, come true at last—

60he’s back alive, home at his hearth, and found you,

found his son still here. And all those suitors

who did him wrong, he’s paid them back, he has,

right in his own house!”

“Hush, dear woman,”

guarded Penelope cautioned her at once.

“Don’t laugh, don’t cry in triumph—not yet.

You know how welcome the sight of him would be

to all in the house, and to me most of all

and the son we bore together.

69But the story can’t be true, not as you tell it,

70no, it must be a god who’s killed our brazen friends—

up in arms at their outrage, heartbreaking crimes.

They’d no regard for any man on earth—

good or bad—who chanced to come their way. So,

thanks to their reckless work they die their deaths.

Odysseus? Far from Achaea now, he’s lost all hope

of coming home… he’s lost and gone himself.”

“Child,” the devoted old nurse protested,

“what nonsense you let slip through your teeth.

Here’s your husband, warming his hands at his own hearth,

80here—and you, you say he’ll never come home again,

always the soul of trust! All right, this too—

I’ll give you a sign, a proof that’s plain as day.

That scar, made years ago by a boar’s white tusk—

I spotted the scar myself, when I washed his feet,

and I tried to tell you, ah, but he, the crafty rascal,

clamped his hand on my mouth—I couldn’t say a word.

Follow me down now. I’ll stake my life on it:

if I am lying to you—

kill me with a thousand knives of pain!”

90“Dear old nurse,” composed Penelope responded,

“deep as you are, my friend, you’ll find it hard

to plumb the plans of the everlasting gods.

All the same, let’s go and join my son

so I can see the suitors lying dead

and see… the one who killed them.”

With that thought

Penelope started down from her lofty room, her heart

in turmoil, torn… should she keep her distance,

probe her husband? Or rush up to the man at once

and kiss his head and cling to both his hands?

100As soon as she stepped across the stone threshold,

slipping in, she took a seat at the closest wall

and radiant in the firelight, faced Odysseus now.

There he sat, leaning against the great central column,

eyes fixed on the ground, waiting, poised for whatever words

his hardy wife might say when she caught sight of him.

A long while she sat in silence… numbing wonder

filled her heart as her eyes explored his face.

One moment he seemed… Odysseus, to the life—

the next, no, he was not the man she knew,

110a huddled mass of rags was all she saw.

“Oh mother,” Telemachus reproached her,

111“cruel mother, you with your hard heart!

Why do you spurn my father so—why don’t you

sit beside him, engage him, ask him questions?

What other wife could have a spirit so unbending?

Holding back from her husband, home at last for her

after bearing twenty years of brutal struggle—

your heart was always harder than a rock!”

“My child,”

Penelope, well-aware, explained, “I’m stunned with wonder,

120powerless. Cannot speak to him, ask him questions,

121look him in the eyes… But if he is truly

Odysseus, home at last, make no mistake:

we two will know each other, even better—

124we two have secret signs,

known to us both but hidden from the world.”

Odysseus, long-enduring, broke into a smile

and turned to his son with pointed, winging words:

“Leave your mother here in the hall to test me

as she will. She soon will know me better.

130Now because I am filthy, wear such grimy rags,

she spurns me—your mother still can’t bring herself

to believe I am her husband.

But you and I,

put heads together. What’s our best defense?

When someone kills a lone man in the realm

who leaves behind him no great band of avengers,

still the killer flees, goodbye to kin and country.

But we brought down the best of the island’s princes,

the pillars of Ithaca. Weigh it well, I urge you.”

“Look to it all yourself now, father,” his son

140deferred at once. “You are the best on earth,

they say, when it comes to mapping tactics.

142No one, no mortal man, can touch you there.

But we’re behind you, hearts intent on battle,

nor do I think you’ll find us short on courage,

long as our strength will last.”

“Then here’s our plan,”

the master of tactics said. “I think it’s best.

First go and wash, and pull fresh tunics on

and tell the maids in the hall to dress well too.

And let the inspired bard take up his ringing lyre

150and lead off for us all a dance so full of heart

that whoever hears the strains outside the gates—

a passerby on the road, a neighbor round about—

will think it’s a wedding-feast that’s under way.

No news of the suitors’ death must spread through town

till we have slipped away to our own estates,

our orchard green with trees. There we’ll see

what winning strategy Zeus will hand us then.”

They hung on his words and moved to orders smartly.

First they washed and pulled fresh tunics on,

160the women arrayed themselves—the inspired bard

struck up his resounding lyre and stirred in all

a desire for dance and song, the lovely lilting beat,

till the great house echoed round to the measured tread

of dancing men in motion, women sashed and lithe.

And whoever heard the strains outside would say,

“A miracle—someone’s married the queen at last!”

“One of her hundred suitors.”

“That callous woman,

too faithless to keep her lord and master’s house

to the bitter end—”

“Till he came sailing home.”

170So they’d say, blind to what had happened:

the great-hearted Odysseus was home again at last.

The maid Eurynome bathed him, rubbed him down with oil

and drew around him a royal cape and choice tunic too.

And Athena crowned the man with beauty, head to foot,

made him taller to all eyes, his build more massive,

yes, and down from his brow the great goddess

ran his curls like thick hyacinth clusters

full of blooms. As a master craftsman washes

gold over beaten silver—a man the god of fire

180and Queen Athena trained in every fine technique—

and finishes off his latest effort, handsome work…

so she lavished splendor over his head and shoulders now.

He stepped from his bath, glistening like a god,

and back he went to the seat that he had left

and facing his wife, declared,

“Strange woman! So hard—the gods of Olympus

made you harder than any other woman in the world!

What other wife could have a spirit so unbending?

Holding back from her husband, home at last for her

190after bearing twenty years of brutal struggle.

Come, nurse, make me a bed, I’ll sleep alone.

192She has a heart of iron in her breast.”

“Strange man,”

wary Penelope said. “I’m not so proud, so scornful,

nor am I overwhelmed by your quick change…

195You look—how well I know—the way he looked,

setting sail from Ithaca years ago

aboard the long-oared ship.

Come, Eurycleia,

move the sturdy bedstead out of our bridal chamber—

that room the master built with his own hands.

200Take it out now, sturdy bed that it is,

and spread it deep with fleece,

blankets and lustrous throws to keep him warm.”

Putting her husband to the proof—but Odysseus

blazed up in fury, lashing out at his loyal wife:

205“Woman—your words, they cut me to the core!

Who could move my bed? Impossible task,

even for some skilled craftsman—unless a god

came down in person, quick to lend a hand,

lifted it out with ease and moved it elsewhere.

210Not a man on earth, not even at peak strength,

would find it easy to prise it up and shift it, no,

a great sign, a hallmark lies in its construction.

I know, I built it myself—no one else…

There was a branching olive-tree inside our court,

grown to its full prime, the bole like a column, thickset.

Around it I built my bedroom, finished off the walls

with good tight stonework, roofed it over soundly

and added doors, hung well and snugly wedged.

Then I lopped the leafy crown of the olive,

220clean-cutting the stump bare from roots up,

planing it round with a bronze smoothing-adze—

I had the skill—I shaped it plumb to the line to make

my bedpost, bored the holes it needed with an auger.

Working from there I built my bed, start to finish,

I gave it ivory inlays, gold and silver fittings,

wove the straps across it, oxhide gleaming red.

There’s our secret sign, I tell you, our life story!

228Does the bed, my lady, still stand planted firm?—

I don’t know—or has someone chopped away

that olive-trunk and hauled our bedstead off?”

230Living proof—

Penelope felt her knees go slack, her heart surrender,

recognizing the strong clear signs Odysseus offered.

She dissolved in tears, rushed to Odysseus, flung her arms

around his neck and kissed his head and cried out,

“Odysseus—don’t flare up at me now, not you,

always the most understanding man alive!

The gods, it was the gods who sent us sorrow—

they grudged us both a life in each other’s arms

from the heady zest of youth to the stoop of old age.

240But don’t fault me, angry with me now because I failed,

at the first glimpse, to greet you, hold you, so…

242In my heart of hearts I always cringed with fear

some fraud might come, beguile me with his talk;

the world is full of the sort,

cunning ones who plot their own dark ends.

Remember Helen of Argos, Zeus’s daughter—

would she have sported so in a stranger’s bed

if she had dreamed that Achaea’s sons were doomed

to fight and die to bring her home again?

250Some god spurred her to do her shameless work.

Not till then did her mind conceive that madness,

blinding madness that caused her anguish, ours as well.

But now, since you have revealed such overwhelming proof—

the secret sign of our bed, which no one’s ever seen

255but you and I and a single handmaid, Actoris,

the servant my father gave me when I came,

who kept the doors of our room you built so well…

you’ve conquered my heart, my hard heart, at last!”

The more she spoke, the more a deep desire for tears

260welled up inside his breast—he wept as he held the wife

he loved, the soul of loyalty, in his arms at last.

Joy, warm as the joy that shipwrecked sailors feel

when they catch sight of land—Poseidon has struck

their well-rigged ship on the open sea with gale winds

and crushing walls of waves, and only a few escape, swimming,

struggling out of the frothing surf to reach the shore,

their bodies crusted with salt but buoyed up with joy

as they plant their feet on solid ground again,

spared a deadly fate. So joyous now to her

270the sight of her husband, vivid in her gaze,

that her white arms, embracing his neck

would never for a moment let him go…

Dawn with her rose-red fingers might have shone

upon their tears, if with her glinting eyes

Athena had not thought of one more thing.

She held back the night, and night lingered long

at the western edge of the earth, while in the east

she reined in Dawn of the golden throne at Ocean’s banks,

commanding her not to yoke the windswift team that brings men light,

280Blaze and Aurora, the young colts that race the Morning on.

Yet now Odysseus, seasoned veteran, said to his wife,

“Dear woman… we have still not reached the end

of all our trials. One more labor lies in store—

boundless, laden with danger, great and long,

and I must brave it out from start to finish.

So the ghost of Tiresias prophesied to me,

the day that I went down to the House of Death

to learn our best route home, my comrades’ and my own.

But come, let’s go to bed, dear woman—at long last

290delight in sleep, delight in each other, come!”

“If it’s bed you want,” reserved Penelope replied,

“it’s bed you’ll have, whenever the spirit moves you,

now that the gods have brought you home again

to native land, your grand and gracious house.

But since you’ve alluded to it,

since a god has put it in your mind,

please, tell me about this trial still to come.

I’m bound to learn of it later, I am sure—

what’s the harm if I hear of it tonight?”

“Still so strange,”

300Odysseus, the old master of stories, answered.

“Why again, why force me to tell you all?

Well, tell I shall. I’ll hide nothing now.

But little joy it will bring you, I’m afraid,

as little joy for me.

The prophet said

that I must rove through towns on towns of men,

that I must carry a well-planed oar until

I come to a people who know nothing of the sea,

whose food is never seasoned with salt, strangers all

to ships with their crimson prows and long slim oars,

310wings that make ships fly. And here is my sign,

he told me, clear, so clear I cannot miss it,

and I will share it with you now…

When another traveler falls in with me and calls

that weight across my shoulder a fan to winnow grain,

then, he told me, I must plant my oar in the earth

and sacrifice fine beasts to the lord god of the sea,

Poseidon—a ram, a bull and a ramping wild boar—

then journey home and render noble offerings up

to the deathless gods who rule the vaulting skies,

320to all the gods in order.

And at last my own death will steal upon me…

a gentle, painless death, far from the sea it comes

to take me down, borne down with the years in ripe old age

with all my people here in blessed peace around me.

All this, the prophet said, will come to pass.”

“And so,” Penelope said, in her great wisdom,

“if the gods will really grant a happier old age,

there’s hope that we’ll escape our trials at last.”

So husband and wife confided in each other,

330while nurse and Eurynome, under the flaring brands,

were making up the bed with coverings deep and soft.

And working briskly, soon as they’d made it snug,

back to her room the old nurse went to sleep

as Eurynome, their attendant, torch in hand,

lighted the royal couple’s way to bed and,

leading them to their chamber, slipped away.

Rejoicing in each other, they returned to their bed,

the old familiar place they loved so well.

Now Telemachus, the cowherd and the swineherd

340rested their dancing feet and had the women do the same,

and across the shadowed hall the men lay down to sleep.

But the royal couple, once they’d reveled in all

the longed-for joys of love, reveled in each other’s stories,

the radiant woman telling of all she’d borne at home,

watching them there, the infernal crowd of suitors

slaughtering herds of cattle and good fat sheep—

while keen to win her hand—

draining the broached vats dry of vintage wine.

349And great Odysseus told his wife of all the pains

350he had dealt out to other men and all the hardships

he’d endured himself—his story first to last—

and she listened on, enchanted…

Sleep never sealed her eyes till all was told.

He launched in with how he fought the Cicones down,

then how he came to the Lotus-eaters’ lush green land.

Then all the crimes of the Cyclops and how he paid him back

for the gallant men the monster ate without a qualm—

then how he visited Aeolus, who gave him a hero’s welcome

then he sent him off, but the homeward run was not his fate,

360not yet—some sudden squalls snatched him away once more

and drove him over the swarming sea, groaning in despair.

Then how he moored at Telepylus, where Laestrygonians

wrecked his fleet and killed his men-at-arms.

He told her of Circe’s cunning magic wiles

and how he voyaged down in his long benched ship

to the moldering House of Death, to consult Tiresias,

ghostly seer of Thebes, and he saw old comrades there

and he saw his mother, who bore and reared him as a child.

He told how he caught the Sirens’ voices throbbing in the wind

and how he had scudded past the Clashing Rocks, past grim Charybdis,

past Scylla—whom no rover had ever coasted by, home free—

and how his shipmates slaughtered the cattle of the Sun

and Zeus the king of thunder split his racing ship

with a reeking bolt and killed his hardy comrades,

all his fighting men at a stroke, but he alone

escaped their death at sea. He told how he reached

Ogygia’s shores and the nymph Calypso held him back,

deep in her arching caverns, craving him for a husband—

cherished him, vowed to make him immortal, ageless, all his days,

380yes, but she never won the heart inside him, never…

then how he reached the Phaeacians—heavy sailing there—

who with all their hearts had prized him like a god

and sent him off in a ship to his own beloved land,

giving him bronze and hoards of gold and robes…

and that was the last he told her, just as sleep

overcame him… sleep loosing his limbs,

slipping the toils of anguish from his mind.

Athena, her eyes afire, had fresh plans.

Once she thought he’d had his heart’s content

390of love and sleep at his wife’s side, straightaway

she roused young Dawn from Ocean’s banks to her golden throne

to bring men light and roused Odysseus too, who rose

from his soft bed and advised his wife in parting,

“Dear woman, we both have had our fill of trials.

You in our house, weeping over my journey home,

fraught with storms and torment, true, and I,

pinned down in pain by Zeus and other gods,

for all my desire, blocked from reaching home.

But now that we’ve arrived at our bed together—

400the reunion that we yearned for all those years—

look after the things still left me in our house.

But as for the flocks those brazen suitors plundered,

much I’ll recoup myself, making many raids;

404the rest our fellow-Ithacans will supply

till all my folds are full of sheep again.

But now I must be off to the upland farm,

our orchard green with trees, to see my father,

good old man weighed down with so much grief for me.

And you, dear woman, sensible as you are,

410I would advise you, still…

quick as the rising sun the news will spread

of the suitors that I killed inside the house.

So climb to your lofty chamber with your women.

Sit tight there. See no one. Question no one.”

He strapped his burnished armor round his shoulders,

roused Telemachus, the cowherd and the swineherd,

and told them to take up weapons honed for battle.

They snapped to commands, harnessed up in bronze,

opened the doors and strode out, Odysseus in the lead.

420By now the daylight covered the land, but Pallas,

shrouding them all in darkness,

quickly led the four men out of town.

BOOK TWENTY-FOUR

Peace

1

N
ow Cyllenian Hermes called away the suitors’ ghosts,

holding firm in his hand the wand of fine pure gold

that enchants the eyes of men whenever Hermes wants

or wakes us up from sleep.

With a wave of this he stirred and led them on

6and the ghosts trailed after with high thin cries

as bats cry in the depths of a dark haunted cavern,

shrilling, flittering, wild when one drops from the chain—

slipped from the rock face, while the rest cling tight…

10So with their high thin cries the ghosts flocked now

and Hermes the Healer led them on, and down the dank

moldering paths and past the Ocean’s streams they went

and past the White Rock and the Sun’s Western Gates and past

the Land of Dreams, and they soon reached the fields of asphodel

where the dead, the burnt-out wraiths of mortals, make their home.

There they found the ghosts of Peleus’ son Achilles,

Patroclus, fearless Antilochus—and Great Ajax too,

the first in stature, first in build and bearing

of all the Argives after Peleus’ matchless son.

20They had grouped around Achilles’ ghost, and now

the shade of Atreus’ son Agamemnon marched toward them—

fraught with grief and flanked by all his comrades,

troops of his men-at-arms who died beside him,

who met their fate in lord Aegisthus’ halls.

Achilles’ ghost was first to greet him: “Agamemnon,

you were the one, we thought, of all our fighting princes

Zeus who loves the lightning favored most, all your days,

because you commanded such a powerful host of men

on the fields of Troy where we Achaeans suffered.

30But you were doomed to encounter fate so early,

you too, yet no one born escapes its deadly force.

If only you had died your death in the full flush

of the glory you had mastered—died on Trojan soil!

Then all united Achaea would have raised your tomb

and you’d have won your son great fame for years to come.

Not so. You were fated to die a wretched death.”

And the ghost of Atrides Agamemnon answered,

“Son of Peleus, great godlike Achilles! Happy man,

you died on the fields of Troy, a world away from home,

40and the best of Trojan and Argive champions died around you,

fighting for your corpse. And you… there you lay

in the whirling dust, overpowered in all your power

and wiped from memory all your horseman’s skills.

That whole day we fought, we’d never have stopped

if Zeus had not stopped us with sudden gales.

Then we bore you out of the fighting, onto the ships,

we laid you down on a litter, cleansed your handsome flesh

with warm water and soothing oils, and round your body

49troops of Danaans wept hot tears and cut their locks.

50Hearing the news, your mother, Thetis, rose from the sea,

immortal sea-nymphs in her wake, and a strange unearthly cry

came throbbing over the ocean. Terror gripped Achaea’s armies,

they would have leapt in panic, boarded the long hollow ships

if one man, deep in his age-old wisdom, had not checked them:

Nestor—from the first his counsel always seemed the best,

and now, concerned for the ranks, he rose and shouted,

‘Hold fast, Argives! Sons of Achaea, don’t run now!

This is Achilles’ mother rising from the sea

with all her immortal sea-nymphs—

60she longs to join her son who died in battle!’

That stopped our panicked forces in their tracks

as the Old Man of the Sea’s daughters gathered round you—

wailing, heartsick—dressed you in ambrosial, deathless robes

and the Muses, nine in all, voice-to-voice in choirs,

their vibrant music rising, raised your dirge.

Not one soldier would you have seen dry-eyed,

the Muses’ song so pierced us to the heart.

For seventeen days unbroken, days and nights

we mourned you—immortal gods and mortal men.

70At the eighteenth dawn we gave you to the flames

and slaughtered around your body droves of fat sheep

and shambling longhorn cattle, and you were burned

in the garments of the gods and laved with soothing oils

and honey running sweet, and a long cortege of Argive heroes

paraded in review, in battle armor round your blazing pyre,

men in chariots, men on foot—a resounding roar went up.

And once the god of fire had burned your corpse to ash,

at first light we gathered your white bones, Achilles,

cured them in strong neat wine and seasoned oils.

80Your mother gave us a gold two-handled urn,

a gift from Dionysus, she said,

a masterwork of the famous Smith, the god of fire.

Your white bones rest in that, my brilliant Achilles,

84mixed with the bones of dead Patroclus, Menoetius’ son,

apart from those of Antilochus, whom you treasured

more than all other comrades once Patroclus died.

Over your bones we reared a grand, noble tomb—

devoted veterans all, Achaea’s combat forces—

89high on its jutting headland over the Hellespont’s

90broad reach, a landmark glimpsed from far out at sea

by men of our own day and men of days to come.

And then

your mother, begging the gods for priceless trophies,

set them out in the ring for all our champions.

You in your day have witnessed funeral games

for many heroes, games to honor the death of kings,

when young men cinch their belts, tense to win some prize—

but if you’d laid eyes on these it would have thrilled your heart,

magnificent trophies the goddess, glistening-footed Thetis,

held out in your honor. You were dear to the gods,

100so even in death your name will never die…

Great glory is yours, Achilles,

for all time, in the eyes of all mankind!

But I?

What joy for me when the coil of war had wound down?

For my return Zeus hatched a pitiful death

at the hands of Aegisthus—and my accursed wife.”

As they exchanged the stories of their fates,

Hermes the guide and giant-killer drew up close to both,

leading down the ghosts of the suitors King Odysseus killed.

Struck by the sight, the two went up to them right away

110and the ghost of Atreus’ son Agamemnon recognized

111the noted prince Amphimedon, Melaneus’ dear son

who received him once in Ithaca, at his home,

and Atrides’ ghost called out to his old friend now,

“Amphimedon, what disaster brings you down to the dark world?

All of you, good picked men, and all in your prime—

no captain out to recruit the best in any city

could have chosen better. What laid you low?

Wrecked in the ships when lord Poseidon roused

some punishing blast of gales and heavy breakers?

120Or did ranks of enemies mow you down on land

as you tried to raid and cut off herds and flocks

or fought to win their city, take their women?

Answer me, tell me. I was once your guest.

Don’t you recall the day I came to visit

your house in Ithaca—King Menelaus came too—

126to urge Odysseus to sail with us in the ships

on our campaign to Troy? And the long slow voyage,

crossing wastes of ocean, cost us one whole month.

That’s how hard it was to bring him round,

Odysseus, raider of cities.”

130“Famous Atrides!”

Amphimedon’s ghost called back. “Lord of men, Agamemnon,

I remember it all, your majesty, as you say,

and I will tell you, start to finish now,

the story of our death,

the brutal end contrived to take us off.

We were courting the wife of Odysseus, gone so long.

She neither spurned nor embraced a marriage she despised,

no, she simply planned our death, our black doom!

This was her latest masterpiece of guile:

140she set up a great loom in the royal halls

and she began to weave, and the weaving finespun,

the yarns endless, and she would lead us on: ‘Young men,

my suitors, now that King Odysseus is no more,

go slowly, keen as you are to marry me, until

I can finish off this web…

so my weaving won’t all fray and come to nothing.

This is a shroud for old lord Laertes, for that day

when the deadly fate that lays us out at last will take him down.

I dread the shame my countrywomen would heap upon me,

150yes, if a man of such wealth should lie in state

without a shroud for cover.’

Her very words,

and despite our pride and passion we believed her.

So by day she’d weave at her great and growing web—

by night, by the light of torches set beside her,

she would unravel all she’d done. Three whole years

she deceived us blind, seduced us with this scheme…

Then, when the wheeling seasons brought the fourth year on

and the months waned and the long days came round once more,

one of her women, in on the queen’s secret, told the truth

160and we caught her in the act—unweaving her gorgeous web.

So she finished it off. Against her will. We forced her.

But just as she bound off that great shroud and washed it,

spread it out—glistening like the sunlight or the moon—

just then some wicked spirit brought Odysseus back,

from god knows where, to the edge of his estate

where the swineherd kept his pigs. And back too,

to the same place, came Odysseus’ own dear son,

scudding home in his black ship from sandy Pylos.

The pair of them schemed our doom, our deathtrap,

170then lit out for town—

Telemachus first in fact, Odysseus followed,

later, led by the swineherd, and clad in tatters,

looking for all the world like an old and broken beggar

hunched on a stick, his body wrapped in shameful rags.

Disguised so none of us, not even the older ones,

could spot that tramp for the man he really was,

bursting in on us there, out of the blue. No,

we attacked him, blows and insults flying fast,

and he took it all for a time, in his own house,

180all the taunts and blows—he had a heart of iron.

But once the will of thundering Zeus had roused his blood,

he and Telemachus bore the burnished weapons off

and stowed them deep in a storeroom, shot the bolts

184and he—the soul of cunning—told his wife to set

the great bow and the gleaming iron axes out

before the suitors—all of us doomed now—

to test our skill and bring our slaughter on…

Not one of us had the strength to string that powerful weapon,

all of us fell far short of what it took. But then,

190when the bow was coming round to Odysseus’ hands,

we raised a hue and cry—he must not have it,

no matter how he begged! Only Telemachus

urged him to take it up, and once he got it

in his clutches, long-suffering great Odysseus

strung his bow with ease and shot through all the axes,

then, vaulting onto the threshold, stood there poised, and pouring

his flashing arrows out before him, glaring for the kill,

he cut Antinous down, then shot his painful arrows

into the rest of us, aiming straight and true,

200and down we went, corpse on corpse in droves.

Clearly a god was driving him and all his henchmen,

routing us headlong in their fury down the hall,

wheeling into the slaughter, slashing left and right

and grisly screams broke from skulls cracked open—

the whole floor awash with blood.

So we died,

Agamemnon… our bodies lie untended even now,

strewn in Odysseus’ palace. They know nothing yet,

the kin in our houses who might wash our wounds

of clotted gore and lay us out and mourn us.

These are the solemn honors owed the dead.”

210“Happy Odysseus!”

Agamemnon’s ghost cried out. “Son of old Laertes—

mastermind—what a fine, faithful wife you won!

What good sense resided in your Penelope—

how well Icarius’ daughter remembered you,

Odysseus, the man she married once!

The fame of her great virtue will never die.

The immortal gods will lift a song for all mankind,

a glorious song in praise of self-possessed Penelope.

A far cry from the daughter of Tyndareus, Clytemnestra—

220what outrage she committed, killing the man she married once!—

yes, and the song men sing of her will ring with loathing.

She brands with a foul name the breed of womankind,

even the honest ones to come!”

So they traded stories,

the two ghosts standing there in the House of Death,

far in the hidden depths below the earth.

Odysseus and his men had stridden down from town

and quickly reached Laertes’ large, well-tended farm

that the old king himself had wrested from the wilds,

years ago, laboring long and hard. His lodge was here

230and around it stretched a row of sheds where fieldhands,

bondsmen who did his bidding, sat and ate and slept.

And an old Sicilian woman was in charge,

who faithfully looked after her aged master

out on his good estate remote from town.

Odysseus told his servants and his son,

“Into the timbered lodge now, go, quickly,

kill us the fattest porker, fix our meal.

And I will put my father to the test,

see if the old man knows me now, on sight,

240or fails to, after twenty years apart.”

With that he passed his armor to his men

and in they went at once, his son as well. Odysseus

wandered off, approaching the thriving vineyard, searching,

picking his way down to the great orchard, searching,

but found neither Dolius nor his sons nor any hand.

They’d just gone off, old Dolius in the lead,

to gather stones for a dry retaining wall

to shore the vineyard up. But he did find

his father, alone, on that well-worked plot,

250spading round a sapling—clad in filthy rags,

in a patched, unseemly shirt, and round his shins

he had some oxhide leggings strapped, patched too,

to keep from getting scraped, and gloves on his hands

to fight against the thorns, and on his head

he wore a goatskin skullcap

to cultivate his misery that much more…

Long-enduring Odysseus, catching sight of him now—

258a man worn down with years, his heart racked with sorrow—

259halted under a branching pear-tree, paused and wept.

260Debating, head and heart, what should he do now?

Kiss and embrace his father, pour out the long tale—

how he had made the journey home to native land—

or probe him first and test him every way?

Torn, mulling it over, this seemed better:

test the old man first,

reproach him with words that cut him to the core.

Convinced, Odysseus went right up to his father.

Laertes was digging round the sapling, head bent low

as his famous offspring hovered over him and began,

270“You want no skill, old man, at tending a garden.

All’s well-kept here; not one thing in the plot,

no plant, no fig, no pear, no olive, no vine,

not a vegetable, lacks your tender, loving care.

But I must say—and don’t be offended now—

your plants are doing better than yourself.

Enough to be stooped with age

but look how squalid you are, those shabby rags.

Surely it’s not for sloth your master lets you go to seed.

There’s nothing of slave about your build or bearing.

280I have eyes: you look like a king to me. The sort

entitled to bathe, sup well, then sleep in a soft bed.

That’s the right and pride of you old-timers.

Come now, tell me—in no uncertain terms—

284whose slave are you? whose orchard are you tending?

And tell me this—I must be absolutely sure—

this place I’ve reached, is it truly Ithaca?

Just as that fellow told me, just now…

I fell in with him on the road here. Clumsy,

none too friendly, couldn’t trouble himself

290to hear me out or give me a decent answer

when I asked about a long-lost friend of mine,

whether he’s still alive, somewhere in Ithaca,

or dead and gone already, lost in the House of Death.

Do you want to hear his story? Listen. Catch my drift.

I once played host to a man in my own country;

he’d come to my door, the most welcome guest

from foreign parts I ever entertained.

He claimed he came of good Ithacan stock,

said his father was Arcesius’ son, Laertes.

300So I took the new arrival under my own roof,

I gave him a hero’s welcome, treated him in style—

stores in our palace made for princely entertainment.

And I gave my friend some gifts to fit his station,

handed him seven bars of well-wrought gold,

a mixing-bowl of solid silver, etched with flowers,

a dozen cloaks, unlined and light, a dozen rugs

and as many full-cut capes and shirts as well,

and to top it off, four women, perfect beauties

skilled in crafts—he could pick them out himself.”

310“Stranger,” his father answered, weeping softly,

“the land you’ve reached is the very one you’re after,

true, but it’s in the grip of reckless, lawless men.

And as for the gifts you showered on your guest,

you gave them all for nothing.

315But if you’d found him alive, here in Ithaca,

he would have replied in kind, with gift for gift,

and entertained you warmly before he sent you off.

That’s the old custom, when one has led the way.

But tell me, please—in no uncertain terms—

320how many years ago did you host the man,

that unfortunate guest of yours, my son…

there was a son, or was he all a dream?

That most unlucky man, whom now, I fear,

far from his own soil and those he loves,

the fish have swallowed down on the high seas

or birds and beasts on land have made their meal.

Nor could the ones who bore him—mother, father—

wrap his corpse in a shroud and mourn him deeply.

Nor could his warm, generous wife, so self-possessed,

330Penelope, ever keen for her husband on his deathbed,

the fit and proper way, or close his eyes at last.

These are the solemn honors owed the dead.

But tell me your own story—that I’d like to know:

Who are you? where are you from? your city? your parents?

Where does the ship lie moored that brought you here,

your hardy shipmates too? Or did you arrive

as a passenger aboard some stranger’s craft

and men who put you ashore have pulled away?”

“The whole tale,”

his crafty son replied, “I’ll tell you start to finish.

340I come from Roamer-Town, my home’s a famous place,

341my father’s Unsparing, son of old King Pain,

and my name’s Man of Strife…

343I sailed from Sicily, aye, but some ill wind

blew me here, off course—much against my will—

and my ship lies moored off farmlands far from town.

As for Odysseus, well, five years have passed

since he left my house and put my land behind him,

348luckless man! But the birds were good as he launched out,

all on the right, and I rejoiced as I sent him off

350and he rejoiced in sailing. We had high hopes

we’d meet again as guests, as old friends,

and trade some shining gifts.”

At those words

a black cloud of grief came shrouding over Laertes.

Both hands clawing the ground for dirt and grime,

he poured it over his grizzled head, sobbing, in spasms.

Odysseus’ heart shuddered, a sudden twinge went shooting up

through his nostrils, watching his dear father struggle…

He sprang toward him, kissed him, hugged him, crying,

“Father—I am your son—myself, the man you’re seeking,

360home after twenty years, on native ground at last!

Hold back your tears, your grief.

Let me tell you the news, but we must hurry—

I’ve cut the suitors down in our own house,

I’ve paid them back their outrage, vicious crimes!”

“Odysseus…”

Laertes, catching his breath, found words to answer.

“You—you’re truly my son, Odysseus, home at last?

Give me a sign, some proof—I must be sure.”

“This scar first,”

quick to the mark, his son said, “look at this—

the wound I took from the boar’s white tusk

370on Mount Parnassus. There you’d sent me, you

and mother, to see her fond old father, Autolycus,

and collect the gifts he vowed to give me, once,

when he came to see us here.

Or these, these trees—

let me tell you the trees you gave me years ago,

here on this well-worked plot…

I begged you for everything I saw, a little boy

trailing you through the orchard, picking our way

among these trees, and you named them one by one.

379You gave me thirteen pear, ten apple trees

380and forty figs—and promised to give me, look,

fifty vinerows, bearing hard on each other’s heels,

clusters of grapes year-round at every grade of ripeness,

mellowed as Zeus’s seasons weigh them down.”

Living proof—

and Laertes’ knees went slack, his heart surrendered,

recognizing the strong clear signs Odysseus offered.

He threw his arms around his own dear son, fainting

as hardy great Odysseus hugged him to his heart

until he regained his breath, came back to life

and cried out, “Father Zeus—

390you gods of Olympus, you still rule on high

if those suitors have truly paid in blood

for all their reckless outrage! Oh, but now

my heart quakes with fear that all the Ithacans

will come down on us in a pack, at any time,

and rush the alarm through every island town!”

“There’s nothing to fear,” his canny son replied,

“put it from your mind. Let’s make for your lodge

beside the orchard here. I sent Telemachus on ahead,

the cowherd, swineherd too, to fix a hasty meal.”

400So the two went home, confiding all the way

and arriving at the ample, timbered lodge,

they found Telemachus with the two herdsmen

carving sides of meat and mixing ruddy wine.

Before they ate, the Sicilian serving-woman

bathed her master, Laertes—his spirits high

in his own room—and rubbed him down with oil

and round his shoulders drew a fresh new cloak.

And Athena stood beside him, fleshing out the limbs

of the old commander, made him taller to all eyes,

410his build more massive, stepping from his bath,

so his own son gazed at him, wonderstruck—

face-to-face he seemed a deathless god…

“Father”—Odysseus’ words had wings—“surely

one of the everlasting gods has made you

taller, stronger, shining in my eyes!”

Facing his son, the wise old man returned,

“If only—Father Zeus, Athena and lord Apollo—

I were the man I was, king of the Cephallenians

419when I sacked the city of Nericus, sturdy fortress

420out on its jutting cape! If I’d been young in arms

last night in our house with harness on my back,

standing beside you, fighting off the suitors,

how many I would have cut the knees from under—

the heart inside you would have leapt for joy!”

So father and son confirmed each other’s spirits.

And then, with the roasting done, the meal set out,

the others took their seats on chairs and stools,

were just putting their hands to bread and meat

when old Dolius trudged in with his sons,

430worn out from the fieldwork.

The old Sicilian had gone and fetched them home,

the mother who reared the boys and tended Dolius well,

now that the years had ground the old man down…

When they saw Odysseus—knew him in their bones—

they stopped in their tracks, staring, struck dumb,

but the king waved them on with a warm and easy air:

“Sit down to your food, old friend. Snap out of your wonder.

We’ve been cooling our heels here long enough,

eager to get our hands on all this pork,

440hoping you’d all troop in at any moment.”

Spreading his arms, Dolius rushed up to him,

clutched Odysseus by the wrist and kissed his hand,

greeting his king now with a burst of winging words:

“Dear master, you’re back—the answer to our prayers!

We’d lost all hope but the gods have brought you home!

Welcome—health! The skies rain blessings on you!

But tell me the truth now—this I’d like to know—

shrewd Penelope, has she heard you’re home?

Or should we send a messenger?”

“She knows by now,

450old man,” his wily master answered brusquely.

“Why busy yourself with that?”

So Dolius went back to his sanded stool.

His sons too, pressing around the famous king,

greeted Odysseus warmly, grasped him by the hand

then took their seats in order by their father.

But now, as they fell to supper in the lodge,

457Rumor the herald sped like wildfire through the city,

crying out the news of the suitors’ bloody death and doom,

and massing from every quarter as they listened, kinsmen milled

460with wails and moans of grief before Odysseus’ palace.

And then they carried out the bodies, every family

buried their own, and the dead from other towns

they loaded onto the rapid ships for crews

to ferry back again, each to his own home…

Then in a long, mourning file they moved to assembly

where, once they’d grouped, crowding the meeting grounds,

old lord Eupithes rose in their midst to speak out.

Unforgettable sorrow wrung his heart for his son,

Antinous, the first that great Odysseus killed.

470In tears for the one he lost, he stood and cried,

“My friends, what a mortal blow this man has dealt

to all our island people! Those fighters, many and brave,

he led away in his curved ships—he lost the ships

and he lost the men and back he comes again

to kill the best of our Cephallenian princes.

Quick, after him! Before he flees to Pylos

or holy Elis, where Epeans rule in power—

up, attack! Or we’ll hang our heads forever,

all disgraced, even by generations down the years,

480if we don’t punish the murderers of our brothers and our sons!

Why, life would lose its relish—for me, at least—

I’d rather die at once and go among the dead.

Attack!—before the assassins cross the sea

and leave us in their wake.”

He closed in tears

and compassion ran through every Achaean there.

Suddenly Medon and the inspired bard approached them,

fresh from Odysseus’ house, where they had just awakened.

They strode into the crowds; amazement took each man

but the herald Medon spoke in all his wisdom:

490“Hear me, men of Ithaca. Not without the hand

of the deathless gods did Odysseus do these things!

Myself, I saw an immortal fighting at his side—

like Mentor to the life. I saw the same god,

now in front of Odysseus, spurring him on,

now stampeding the suitors through the hall,

crazed with fear, and down they went in droves!”

Terror gripped them all, their faces ashen white.

At last the old warrior Halitherses, Mastor’s son—

who alone could see the days behind and days ahead—

500rose up and spoke, distraught for each man there:

“Hear me, men of Ithaca. Hear what I have to say.

Thanks to your own craven hearts these things were done!

You never listened to me or the good commander Mentor,

you never put a stop to your sons’ senseless folly.

What fine work they did, so blind, so reckless,

carving away the wealth, affronting the wife

of a great and famous man, telling themselves

that he’d return no more! So let things rest now.

Listen to me for once—I say don’t attack!

Else some will draw the lightning on their necks.”

510So he urged

and some held fast to their seats, but more than half

sprang up with warcries now. They had no taste

for the prophet’s sane plan—winning Eupithes

quickly won them over. They ran for armor

and once they’d harnessed up in burnished bronze

they grouped in ranks before the terraced city.

Eupithes led them on in their foolish, mad campaign,

certain he would avenge the slaughter of his son

but the father was not destined to return—

520he’d meet his death in battle then and there.

Athena at this point made appeals to Zeus:

“Father, son of Cronus, our high and mighty king,

now let me ask you a question…

tell me the secrets hidden in your mind.

Will you prolong the pain, the cruel fighting here

or hand down pacts of peace between both sides?”

“My child,” Zeus who marshals the thunderheads replied,

“why do you pry and probe me so intently? Come now,

wasn’t the plan your own? You conceived it yourself:

530Odysseus should return and pay the traitors back.

Do as your heart desires—

but let me tell you how it should be done.

Now that royal Odysseus has taken his revenge,

let both sides seal their pacts that he shall reign for life,

and let us purge their memories of the bloody slaughter

of their brothers and their sons. Let them be friends,

devoted as in the old days. Let peace and wealth

come cresting through the land.”

So Zeus decreed

and launched Athena already poised for action—

540down she swept from Olympus’ craggy peaks.

By then Odysseus’ men had had their fill

of hearty fare, and the seasoned captain said,

“One of you go outside—see if they’re closing in.”

A son of Dolius snapped to his command,

ran to the door and saw them all too close

and shouted back to Odysseus,

“They’re on top of us! To arms—and fast!”

Up they sprang and strapped themselves in armor,

the three men with Odysseus, Dolius’ six sons

550and Dolius and Laertes clapped on armor too,

gray as they were, but they would fight if forced.

Once they had all harnessed up in burnished bronze

they opened the doors and strode out, Odysseus in the lead.

And now, taking the build and voice of Mentor,

Zeus’s daughter Athena marched right in.

The good soldier Odysseus thrilled to see her,

turned to his son and said in haste, “Telemachus,

you’ll learn soon enough—as you move up to fight

where champions strive to prove themselves the best—

560not to disgrace your father’s line a moment.

In battle prowess we’ve excelled for ages

all across the world.”

Telemachus reassured him,

“Now you’ll see, if you care to watch, father,

now I’m fired up. Disgrace, you say?

I won’t disgrace your line!”

Laertes called out in deep delight,

567“What a day for me, dear gods! What joy—

my son and my grandson vying over courage!”

“Laertes!”

Goddess Athena rushed beside him, eyes ablaze:

570“Son of Arcesius, dearest of all my comrades,

say a prayer to the bright-eyed girl and Father Zeus,

then brandish your long spear and wing it fast!”

Athena breathed enormous strength in the old man.

He lifted a prayer to mighty Zeus’s daughter,

brandished his spear a moment, winged it fast

and hit Eupithes, pierced his bronze-sided helmet

that failed to block the bronze point tearing through—

down Eupithes crashed, his armor clanging against his chest.

Odysseus and his gallant son charged straight at the front lines,

580slashing away with swords, with two-edged spears and now

581they would have killed them all, cut them off from home

if Athena, daughter of storming Zeus, had not cried out

in a piercing voice that stopped all fighters cold,

“Hold back, you men of Ithaca, back from brutal war!

Break off—shed no more blood—make peace at once!”

So Athena commanded. Terror blanched their faces,

they went limp with fear, weapons slipped from their hands

and strewed the ground at the goddess’ ringing voice.

They spun in flight to the city, wild to save their lives,

590but loosing a savage cry, the long-enduring great Odysseus,

gathering all his force, swooped like a soaring eagle—

just as the son of Cronus hurled a reeking bolt

that fell at her feet, the mighty Father’s daughter,

and blazing-eyed Athena wheeled on Odysseus, crying,

“Royal son of Laertes, Odysseus, master of exploits,

hold back now! Call a halt to the great leveler, War—

don’t court the rage of Zeus who rules the world!”

So she commanded. He obeyed her, glad at heart.

And Athena handed down her pacts of peace

600between both sides for all the years to come—

the daughter of Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder,

yes, but the goddess still kept Mentor’s build and voice.

NOTES

TRANSLATOR’S POSTSCRIPT

“Homer makes us Hearers,” Pope has said, “and Virgil leaves us Readers.” So the great translator of Homer, no doubt unknowingly, set at odds the claims of an oral tradition and those of a literary one, as we would call the two traditions now. Homer’s work is a performance, even in part a musical event. Perhaps that is the source of his speed, directness and simplicity, that Matthew Arnold praised—and his nobility too, elusive yet undeniable, that Arnold pursued but never really caught. Surely it is a major source of Homer’s energy, the loft and carry of his imagination that sweeps along the listener together with the performer. For there is a power in Homer’s song, and whether it is “that unequal’d Fire and Rapture” that Pope found in the Iliad or the glow of the setting sun that Longinus found in the Odyssey, it brings to light the Homeric Question facing all translators: how to convey the force of his performance in the quieter medium of writing? “Homer makes us Hearers, and Virgil leaves us Readers.”

Yet the contrast may be too extreme. Virgil the writer was certainly no stranger to recitation. Homer the performer, as Bernard Knox conjectures in his Introduction, may have known a rudimentary form of writing. And writing may have lent his work some qualities we associate with written works in general—idiosyncrasies at times, and pungency and wit—and with the Iliad and the Odyssey in particular, their architectonics, their magnificent scale, and the figures of Achilles and Hector, Odysseus and Penelope. But even if Homer never used an alphabet himself, he now seems less the creature of an oral tradition whom Milman Parry discovered, and more and more its master, as envisioned by Adam, Parry’s son, and as others have agreed. A brilliant improviser, Homer deployed the stock, inherited features of this tradition with all the individual talent he could muster. Never more so, in fact, than in his use of the fixed and formulaic, frequently repeated phrase. Not only is Homer often less formulaic than might appear, but the formulas themselves are often more resonant, more apt and telling in their contexts, than the “hard Parryites” argued for at first. So the original form of Homer’s work, though a far cry from a work of literature as we know it now, is not exactly a song, pure and simple, either. It may be more the record of a song, building, perhaps, over the poet’s entire lifetime—not spontaneity outright but what Marianne Moore would call “a simulacrum of spontaneity.”

Writing at a far remove from Homer, my approach in this translation has been the one I took in a version of the Iliad. With the Odyssey, however, I have tried to vary my voice in even more ways, modulating it to fit the postwar world, the more domestic, more intimate world of the later poem; yet raising it when an occasion calls—when Homer returns to heroic action or a fabulous encounter or an emotional crescendo—as a reminder that a related voice runs through both poems. That, taken as a sequel to the Iliad, the Odyssey would celebrate, in Wallace Stevens’ phrase, “war’s miracle begetting that of peace.” And both of my translations share a related impulse, too. Again I have tried to find a middle ground (and not a no-man’s-land, if I can help it) between the features of Homer’s performance and the expectations of a contemporary reader. Not a line-by-line translation, my version of the Odyssey is, I hope, neither so literal in rendering Homer’s language as to cramp and distort my own—though I want to convey as much of what he says as possible—nor so literary as to brake his energy, his forward drive, though I want my work to be literate and clear. For the more literal approach would seem to be too little English, and the more literary seems too little Greek. What I have tried to find is a cross between the two, a modern English Homer.

Of course, it is a risky business, stating what one had tried to do or, worse, the principles one has used (petards that will probably hoist the writer later). But a few words of explanation seem in order, and the first of them refer to the more fixed and formulaic parts of Homer. Again I have treated them in a flexible, discretionary way, not incompatible with Homer’s way, I like to think—especially when his formulas are functional as well as fixed—yet also answering to the ways we read today. It is a matter of “riding easy in the harness,” as Robert Frost once said of democracy, and my practice ranges from the pliant to the fairly strict.

With one of the most frequently repeated phrases, for example—the line that introduces many individual speeches—I have been the freest, trying to hint at the speaker’s nuance of the moment while retaining, at least, the habit of an introductory line for every speech. When Homer begins a speech of “winged words,” however, I rarely omit the well-known phrase, yet I like the flight of the words to vary, with a sudden burst at times and a longer drift at others, depending on the words a character has to say. And so with the epithets that cling to the leading figures as closely as their names. According to what perifrôn Penelope is doing at the time, the sense of the epithet may go from the heroine’s guardedness, her circumspection, to her self-possession, to her gift for great good wisdom, and her willingness to give that wisdom voice. With pepnumenos Telemachus, many qualities, from his wariness, to his growing poise, to his level-headed sense in action as well as speech, may be involved. And with polumêtis Odysseus, the epithet may extend from the hero’s craft and cunning (murderous cunning when required), to his skill of hand or expertise at quick disguise and spinning yarns, to his zest for exploit and adventure. Odysseus, the virtuoso of sometimes doubtful virtue, is short on “character” in the sense of habitual goodness but long on “character” as John Crowe Ransom has described “the Shakespearean, modern, passionately cherished, almost religious sense of the total individuality of a person who is rich in vivid yet contingent traits, even physical traits, that are not ethical at all.” And as Ransom concludes, “this kind of character engages an auditor’s love, and that is more than his ethical approval.” Fullness of personality would seem to be essential, particularly for the “polytropic” hero, “the man of twists and turns”—the beggar-king who moves at will from self-effacement to self-assertion, from mê tis to mêtis, from Nobody to Odysseus, the wily raider of cities. (See notes 9.410 and 19.463–64.) In sum, as each Homeric epithet recurs, within its family of meanings I try to find a kindred English word that suits the character and the context.

Yet with longer repetitions in the Odyssey I like to repeat my English version closely, especially if the context shifts the function of the passage, and the opportunities for irony may be ample. For instance, the rituals prior to dining—rinsing the hands, serving the appetizers and the bread, and drawing a table toward a guest—recur, hospitably, in Ithaca and Sparta and Phaeacia, but in Circe’s house they are part of her seductions, all of which Odysseus resists until the witch, who turned his shipmates into pigs, turns them back again to men. With one of the longest recurrent passages in the poem, Penelope’s deception of her suitors, the translation, like Homer’s original, repeats almost verbatim the weaving and unweaving of her web. First Antinous describes it in Book 2.101–22, indicting Penelope before the Ithacan assembly while, as the Introduction observes, paying “reluctant tribute to the subtlety of her delaying tactics.” Then when she describes her weaving in Book 19.153–75— adding her own words of indignation in 173–74—she defends herself, her fidelity and her finesse before the nameless stranger, though some suggest she is also secretly appealing to the man she senses is Odysseus. And finally in Book 24.139–61, a leading suitor, Amphimedon—killed by Odysseus and new to the world of the dead—cries out against Penelope’s duplicity to the ghost of Agamemnon, who had been murdered by Clytemnestra, his duplicitous wife. The suitor may trust that the warlord will be outraged when he hears of another wife’s deceptions, but of course the wife of Odysseus, deliberately or not, sped the work of her avenging husband. That’s what impresses Agamemnon, and so he calls for “a glorious song in praise of self-possessed Penelope” (24.218, see note 1.34–55)—the song that Homer has provided in the Odyssey. All in all, then, I have tried for repetition with a difference when variation seems of use, yet for virtual repetition in the longer passages, particularly when the weave of right and wrong, the Homeric moral fabric, is at issue.

Turning briefly to Homer’s metrics, I would also like to hold a middle ground, here between his spacious hexameter line—his “ear, ear for the sea-surge,” as Pound once heard it—and a tighter line more native to English verse. If, as Knox suggests, the strongest weapon in Homer’s poetic arsenal is variety within a metrical norm, the translation opts for a freer give-and-take between the two, and one that offers more variety than uniformity in the end. Working from a five- or six-beat line while leaning more to six, I expand at times to seven beats—to convey the reach of a simile or the vehemence of a storm at sea or a long-drawn-out conclusion to a story—or I contract at times to three, to give a point in speech or action sharper stress. Free as it is, such interplay between variety and norm results, I suppose, from a kind of tug-of-war peculiar to translation: in this case, trying to capture the meaning of the Greek on the one hand, trying to find a cadence for one’s English on the other, yet joining hands, if possible, to make a line of verse. I hope, at any rate, not only to give my own language a slight stretching now and then, but also to lend Homer the sort of range in rhythm, pace and tone that may make an Odyssey engaging to the reader.

And I would like to suggest, again at a far remove, another tension in Homer’s metrics, his blend of mass and movement both—his lines have so much body or ongkos yet so much grace and speed. And so I have tried to make my own lines as momentarily end-stopped, and yet as steadily ongoing too, as English syntax and the breathing marks of punctuation will allow. My hope has been that each turn in the verse might mark a fresh beginning, moving toward a fresh conclusion, turning and returning, like a version in minuscule of a familiar Odyssean rhythm. In other words, I have tried to keep the master’s voice in mind and to offer, if nothing more, a partial, distant echo of it in the reader’s ear. But Homer’s line is the line beyond compare, and I would only remind the reader of the Introduction’s fine description: “The long line, which no matter how it varies in the opening and middle always ends in the same way, builds up its hypnotic effect in book after book, imposing on things and men and gods the same pattern, presenting in a rhythmic microcosm the wandering course to a fixed end which is the pattern of the rage of Achilles and the travels of Odysseus, of all natural phenomena and all human destinies.”

In aiming for these and other objectives in a version of the Odyssey, I have had many kinds of help. The greatest has come from my collaborator, Bernard Knox, whom I would rather call a comrade. As we worked together on Sophocles and the Iliad, so we have done on the Odyssey as well. Not only has he written the Introduction and Notes on the Translation, but he has commented on my drafts for many years. And when I leaf through the pages now, his commentary seems to ring my typescript so completely that I might be looking at a worse-for-wear, dog-eared manuscript encircled by a scholiast’s remarks. Yet Knox’s gifts are larger, for he has offered me what Yeats would call Platonic tolerance and Doric discipline, and something even more basic to the Iliad and the Odyssey. Athena, disguised as Mentor, encourages Telemachus to live up to Odysseus, “a man… in words and action both” (2.305). My good fortune has been to work with such a man.

Several modern scholars and critics, cited among the further readings, have helped as well, and so have several modern translators of the Odyssey. Each has introduced me to a new aspect of the poem, another potential for the present. “For if it is true,” as Maynard Mack proposes, “that what we translate from a given work is what, wearing the spectacles of our time, we see in it, it is also true that we see in it what we have the power to translate.” So the help I have derived from others is considerable, and I would like to say my thanks to them, dividing them for convenience into groups. First the ones who have translated the Odyssey into prose: from Samuel Butler, A. T. Murray, revised by George E. Dimock, and George Herbert Palmer, to W. H. D. Rouse and R. D. Dawe, and in particular to Walter Shewring and to D. C. H. Rieu who, in consultation with Peter V. Jones, has revised the earlier work of his father, E. V. Rieu. Each presents an example of accuracy as well as grace, and the stronger that example, the more instructive each has been in bringing me somewhat closer to the Greek. And next the translators who have turned the Odyssey into verse: from Albert Cook to Ennis Rees to Richmond Lattimore, Allen Mandelbaum, Oliver Taplin and Robert Fitzgerald. Each presents a kind of aspiration, and I have learned from each, probably most from Fitzgerald, since he would persuade us that Homer is, as he described him, “a living presence bringing into life his great company of imagined persons.” And finally there are the unapproachables, who either are too remote (and so to me, at least, examples not to follow), like certain Victorians, and Cowper, and Chapman—pace Keats—or are impossible to equal, like T. E. Lawrence at his best or Pope in the dozen books of the Odyssey that he produced himself.

Only a few of the recent translators have I known in person, yet we all may know each other in a way, having trekked across the same territory, perhaps having experienced the same nightmare that harried Pope throughout his Homeric efforts. “He was engaged in a long journey,” as Joseph Spence reports Pope’s dream, “puzzled which way to take, and full of fears” that it would never end. And if you reach the end, the fears may start in earnest. Your best hope, I suppose, and a distant one at that, is the one held out by Walter Benjamin in his essay “The Task of the Translator,” where he writes, “even the greatest translation is destined to become part of the growth of its own language and eventually to be absorbed by its renewal.”

Many friends have come to my side, some by reading, some by listening to me read, the work-in-progress, and responding with criticism or encouragement or a healthy blend of both. Most encouraging of all, none has asked me, “Why another Odyssey?” Each has understood, it seems, that if Homer was a performer, his translator might aim to be one as well; and no two performances of the same work—surely not of musical composition, so probably not of a work of language either—will ever be the same. The timbre and tempo of each will be distinct, let alone its deeper resonance, build and thrust. My thanks, then, to André Aciman, Clarence Brown, Andrew Ford, Rachel Hadas, Robert Hollander, David Lenson, Earl Miner, Sarah Nelson, Joyce Carol Oates, Jacqueline Savini, Ben Sonnenberg and Theodore Weiss. And I also thank the ones who invited me to try the work in public, and improve it in the bargain: Peter Bien at Dartmouth College, Ward Briggs III at the University of South Carolina, Larry Carver and Paul Woodruff at the University of Texas in Austin, and Karl Kirchwey at the Unterberg Poetry Center of the 92nd Street Y. And philhellenic thanks should go to Edmund Keeley, the English voice of the great modern Greek poets, for he accompanied me on Homer’s nostos, reacting line by line and knowing well, with his Cavafy, that only Ithaca can give you “the marvelous journey” in the first place.

Several classicists have offered information and advice: Marilyn Arthur Katz, John Keaney, Richard Martin, Georgia Nugent, John Peradotto, Pietro Pucci and Froma Zeitlin. Together with the lexicons, Homeric and ancient Greek in general, the commentaries of other scholars have been my vade mecums: those on other English translations of the Odyssey—Ralph Hexter’s on Robert Fitzgerald’s and Peter Jones’s on Richmond Lattimore’s—and those on Homer’s text itself: A. F. Garvie’s on Books 6 through 8 and R. B. Rutherford’s on 19 and 20; the complete three-volume Oxford commentary compiled by M. Fernández-Galiano, J. B. Hainsworth, A. Heubeck, A. Hoekstra, J. Russo and S. West; and W. B. Stanford’s edition of the Odyssey with his commentary on the poem. The first incentive for translating Homer came from the late Stanford, who, one afternoon in County Wicklow many years ago, sketched out a route for returning to the source. And in pursuit of it, I have often consulted the familiar spirits of Anne and Adam Parry.

The roofs of some great houses have extended welcome shelter to the translator and his work. Mary and Theodore Cross have turned Nantucket into Ithaca West with their Homeric hospitality. Princeton University gave me generous leaves of absence in the spring of 1992 and, adding a McCosh Faculty Fellowship for good measure, throughout the spring and fall semesters three years later. More important, the University has enabled me to study Homer with students who have been an education to me. The Program in Hellenic Studies appointed me to a Stanley J. Seeger Fellowship, which took me to the Ionian islands in the summer of 1994 (and persuaded me that unless Cephallenia—lying “low and away, the farthest out to sea” [9.27]—was actually Ithaca, Odysseus may never have got home at all). The Rockefeller Foundation provided Bernard Knox with a resident fellowship at the Villa Serbelloni in April 1991, when he began to write the Introduction. And the staff of Comparative Literature at Princeton, Carol Szymanski and Cass Garner, have been invaluable to us both as we prepared the work for publication.

To produce the book at hand, my editor, Kathryn Court, assisted by Laurie Walsh, has treated the writing and the writer, too, with insight, affection and address. As my manuscript editor, Beena Kamlani’s efforts to tame and train a fairly unruly piece of work have been heroic. The good people at Viking Penguin—Barbara Grossman, Cathy Hemming, Paul Slovak, Leigh Butler—all have been loyal allies in New York, where Peter Mayer—like Peter Carson and Paul Keegan in London—has been a gracious host to the latest Homer in the house. Ann Gold with all her artistry, in coordination with Junie Lee, has designed a volume to companion the Iliad that came before it, and Maggie Payette and Neil Stuart have created its handsome jacket. Roni Axelrod and Cynthia Achar oversaw the production of the book, and Marjorie Horvitz’s sharp eye was helpful to the text. Dan Lundy, Mary Sunden and Maria Barbieri have labored long and hard with Joe Marcey and Peter Smith to find this version of the Odyssey some readers. Mark Stafford, Susan Mosakowski and Mary Kohl have done the same to find some listeners, too, producing the Penguin Audiobook, read by Ian McKellen, who performs the translation as if he were personifying Homer. My former editor Alan Williams, who saw me through the straits of Aeschylus and Sophocles, gave my plans a timely push toward Troy, then home again to Greece with the old dog Argos as our guide. And through it all, without the unfailing stay and strategies of my friend and agent Georges Borchardt, assisted by Cindy Klein for several years, this translation might not have seen the light.

The Odyssey, the perennial poem of adventure, stops but never really ends. Seen in one way, Odysseus is forever outward bound, off to another country to appease Poseidon in the future, and changing through the centuries as he goes, “the man of twists and turns,” of many incarnations, with as many destinations. Among them are Virgil’s Aeneas, who makes his way toward Rome, and Dante’s Ulysses moving toward “the world where no one lives,” and Milton’s Adam toward “a paradise within thee, happier far,” and Tennyson’s restless mariner toward “the baths / of all the western stars,” and Joyce’s Bloom toward the New Bloomusalem, until he settles for dear dirty Dublin and the moly that is Molly. For as Joyce makes clear, an equal adventure lies within the bounds of Homer’s poem itself. There, after twenty years of warfaring and wayfaring, Odysseus circles back toward Penelope, and the two together reach their resting place and share a kingdom with their offspring, as if to say, with great good spirit, that life continues here and now at home. If the translation offers any sense of this, the translator thanks his daughters, Katya and Nina, and first and last the Muse he calls on in the dedication, Lynne.

R. F.

Princeton, N.J.

June 17, 1996

A N
OTE ON THIS
P
RINTING
:

This printing contains minor revisions of the text.

R.F.

May 17, 1997

THE GENEALOGY OF THE ROYAL HOUSE OF ODYSSEUS

THE GENEALOGY OF THE ROYAL HOUSE OF PHAEACIA

THE GENEALOGY OF THEOCLYMENUS

THE GENEALOGY OF TYRO

TEXTUAL VARIANTS FROM THE OXFORD CLASSICAL TEXT

2.11, duô

2.191, Omitted

3.131, Omitted

4.399, xeine

4.465, ereeineis

4.783, Omitted

5.91, Omitted

9.199, paisi

9.483, Omitted

13.400, anthrôpon

15.345, Omitted

18.402, metheêke

23.320, Omitted

NOTES ON THE TRANSLATION

(Here and throughout the Pronouncing Glossary that follows, line numbers refer to the translation, where the line numbers of the Greek text will be found at the top of every page.)

1.20.
that year spun out by the gods when he should reach his home: The tenth year since the sack of Troy, the twentieth year since Odysseus left Ithaca.

1.34.
Aegisthus, / the man Agamemnon’s son, renowned Orestes, killed: Throughout the Odyssey, the events in the House of Atreus will provide a continuous background to Homer’s narrative. Taken in sequence, these events begin with the successful vengeance of Orestes—which is chosen by Zeus as an example of justice (ref)—then are used by Athena to rouse the courage of Telemachus (ref), and then by Nestor (ref) not only to encourage the prince but also to caution him with the additional stories of Clytemnestra’s infidelity and the wanderings of Menelaus, absent from Argos when Agamemnon was assassinated. Next Menelaus tells Telemachus how Proteus informed him of Agamemnon’s murder by Aegisthus (ref); and the crime is dramatized when, in the underworld, Odysseus learns from the ghost of Agamemnon how both he and Cassandra were murdered by his wife together with her lover (ref). However optimistic the climax of Orestes’ vengeance, in other words, each version of Agamemnon’s death presents a greater darkness, and so a starker foil for the luminous reunion of Odysseus and Penelope; until at the end of the Odyssey (ref) Agamemnon’s ghost calls for a song to immortalize the virtue of Penelope and another to condemn the perfidy of Clytemnestra. As W. B. Stanford observes (his note 24.196–98), Homer has provided the first, and Aeschylus, in the Oresteia, the second. See note ref.

1.62.
Atlas, wicked Titan: In other accounts, Atlas is a giant who holds up the sky “with his hard and unwearying hands” (Hesiod, Theogony 519). Here he apparently stands in the sea and supports pillars that perform the same function. His location in the sea rather than on land (as in Hesiod) may be due to influence from Near Eastern myths. Why he is called “wicked” we do not know.

1.375.
The Achaeans’ Journey Home from Troy: Phemius’ song is one of those poems (now lost) that the Greeks called Nostoi—Returns Home. During the capture and sack of Troy, Ajax, son of Oileus (not the Great Ajax, son of Telamon, who had killed himself before Troy fell: see ref and note ref), attempted to rape Cassandra, King Priam’s daughter, in the temple of Athena, where she had taken refuge. The Achaeans failed to punish him for this offense, and Athena retaliated by arranging for storm winds to blow most of them off course on their way home. Ajax was killed by Poseidon when he had almost reached home (see ref), Menelaus wandered for seven years, Odysseus for ten.

1.443.
king of Ithaca: The Greek word translated as “king,” basileus, does not carry the connotation of hereditary monarchical rule inherent in the English word. In the kingdom of Phaeacia, Alcinous announces: “There are twelve peers of the realm who rule our land, / thirteen, counting myself” (ref). The word he uses is basilêes. They are all kings, but he is, so to speak, top king. That is why Telemachus can say: “I’d be happy to take the crown if Zeus presents it” (ref). It is a position won by acclaim and superior wealth and achievement, and clearly Antinous, as the leader of the suitors, thinks himself in line for the position once he marries Penelope.

2.172.
they swooped away on the right: The lucky side for omens, lucky at least for Telemachus in this case. The idea that signs on the right are lucky and on the left unlucky is common in many cultures and languages: our word “sinister,” for example, is the Latin word for “left.” See ref, 588, ref, ref.

2.371.
splitting up his goods: In the event of Telemachus’ death, the palace and all its property would revert to Penelope and whichever of the suitors she chose to marry. The suitor here seems to be suggesting a division of Telemachus’ property as a consolation prize for those who do not win Penelope’s hand. The speech emphasizes once again the reckless illegality of the suitors’ proceedings. See Introduction, pp. ref, ref.

3.46.
daughter of Zeus whose shield is storm and thunder: The shield is the aegis (literally “goatskin”). It is sometimes displayed by Zeus himself, and by Apollo, as well as by Athena. Its shape is not easily determined from the text: at times it seems to be a shield, for the figure of the Gorgon’s head and other forms of terror appear on it. Its effect seems to be to stiffen morale among those it is raised to protect and inspire terror in those who face it.

3.81.
roving the waves like pirates: See Introduction, pp. ref.

3.121.
There Ajax lies… Achilles… Patroclus… Antilochus: Ajax, son of Telamon, the greatest of the Achaean warriors after Achilles, killed himself when the arms and armor of the dead Achilles, offered by his mother, Thetis, as a prize to the bravest champion, were given to Odysseus (see ref and note ref). Achilles was killed by an arrow shot by Paris, son of Priam; Patroclus, his closest friend, was killed by Euphorbus, Hector and Apollo. Antilochus, who had come to the aid of his father, Nestor, was killed by the Ethiopian prince Memnon, an ally of the Trojans.

3.150.
[Athena’s] rage: See note ref.

3.213.
the shining son / of lionhearted Achilles: Neoptolemus (whose name means “new war”) came to Troy after Achilles’ death and, together with Philoctetes, who wielded the unerring bow of Heracles, led the fight against the Trojans (see ref). Idomeneus, a Cretan king, is often mentioned later in Odysseus’ false travel tales (see ref, ref, ref).

3.215.
Philoctetes: His safe return concludes a well-known story about the final phase of the Trojan War. The Achaeans, unable to take Troy, learned of a prophecy that they would be able to do so only with the aid of Philoctetes and his bow, a famous weapon that he had inherited from Heracles. They had to send an embassy to Lemnos to persuade him to come and help them. This embassy is the subject of Sophocles’ tragedy Philoctetes.

3.346.
Orestes / home from Athens: In Athenian tragedy, he always comes home from Phocis, in central Greece. This may be due to the fact that Aeschylus, in the last play of the Oresteia (458
B.C.
), brings him to Athens to stand trial for his mother’s murder—a coup de théâtre that would have been spoiled if he had come from there in the first place.

3.373.
cut out the victims’ tongues: The tongues of the sacrificed animals, like the thighbones, are reserved for the gods. In this case they were cut out when the bulls were sacrificed in the morning (ref) but put aside as a late evening offering. The first drops of wine are for the libation: the wine poured on the fire for the gods.

3.423.
Zeus’s daughter… his third born: This is a literal rendering of Athena’s title Tritogeneia, but the meaning of the word is disputed. Some ancient sources connect it with Lake Tritonis in Libya, where Zeus sent Athena to be reared, or with the river Triton in Boeotia. A modern explanation compares the Athenian Tritopateres, i.e., genuine ancestors: this would give the meaning “genuine daughter of Zeus.”

3.485.
Athena came… / to attend her sacred rites: What happens in the following passage is a sacrifice to the gods that is also a feast for the human worshipers (this was the way meat was eaten in the ancient world). The animal is placed at the altar, and the sacrificers wash their hands to establish purity for the ritual. They scatter barley on the victim, then stun the animal with a blow on the head, pull back its head and cut its throat over the altar. The animal’s skin is taken off and a portion of the meat prepared for the gods. This is a choice portion, the meat of the thighbones: it is wrapped in a double fold of fat and the outside covered with small pieces of meat from different parts of the animal. This portion is burned over the fire—the smoke and savor go up to the gods above. Wine is poured over it, a libation. The sacrificers at last begin their meal—with the entrails, which they have roasted on forks over the fire. They then carve the carcass and roast portions of meat on spits and set them out for the feast.

4.6.
the son of great Achilles: Neoptolemus, who married Hermione, the daughter of Helen and Menelaus. See refff. and note ref.

4.96.
Three times in the circling year the ewes give birth: A typical traveler’s yarn about a far-off region—it is an impossibility for ewes to bear three cycles of lambs in every year, since the gestation period for sheep is about 150 days.

4.106.
I lost this handsome palace built for the ages: Presumably because he did not see it for seventeen years; but also because Paris and Helen, when they left, stripped it of all its treasures. In the Iliad the terms of the duel between Menelaus and Paris in Book 3 are that if Paris wins he will keep “Helen and all her wealth”; if not, the Trojans will surrender Helen and “those treasures” (3.86–88).

4.144.
tripods: Large metal pots or cauldrons standing on three legs so they can straddle a fire. Often highly ornamented for presentation as a gift or prize, they were unusually valuable and rare.

4.165.
Odysseus’ feet were like the boy’s: Since ancient Greeks went barefoot or wore sandals most of the time, familiarity with the shape of someone else’s foot was nothing strange. In Aeschylus’ tragedy The Libation Bearers Electra recognizes the footprints left on the ground by her brother Orestes.

4.304.
What a piece of work the hero dared: Odysseus’ most famous exploit, celebrated in song at the court of Alcinous (ref) and invoked by Athena disguised as Mentor to spur him on in the fight against the suitors (ref), was to plan and participate in the stratagem that brought about the fall of Troy—the wooden horse in which he and a band of Achaean heroes were concealed while the Trojans brought it into the city as an offering to Athena.

4.454.
his lovely ocean-lady: The wife of Proteus, who is either Thetis or Amphitrite.

4.560.
Ajax… went down: Little Ajax, son of Oileus. See note ref.

4.574.
Agamemnon got away / in his beaked ships: This passage shows Homer’s uncertain grasp of the geography of the western side of the Aegean Sea. Agamemnon’s home is Argos; he would have no reason to sail as far south as Cape Malea on his way home. Furthermore, the prevailing wind at the cape is NE; it is the wind that blows Odysseus’ ship SW into the unknown world. It is also far from clear exactly where Aegisthus’ home is. It must be close to Agamemnon’s if Aegisthus is able to prepare an ambush in his palace, then go out to meet the king as soon as his spy reports his arrival, yet at 581–83 it sounds as if it were far away. The confusion here may stem from the amalgamation of two different accounts of Agamemnon’s return home. See Introduction, p. ref.

4.590.
One whole year he’d watched: Presumably Aegisthus posted the watchman during the tenth year of the Trojan War, the year that Calchas has prophesied would see the city’s fall. A simple hireling of Aegisthus in the Odyssey, the watchman becomes a loyal servant of Agamemnon in Aeschylus’ Oresteia, where he unwittingly ensures the king’s death by rushing the news of his arrival to Clytemnestra, his queen.

4.632.
it’s not for you to die: This special dispensation for Menelaus has nothing to do with merit: he qualifies for Elysium simply because he is the husband of Helen, who will later be worshiped as a goddess at Sparta and elsewhere in Greece.

4.663.
three stallions and a chariot: Two under the yoke and a third to serve as a trace horse.

4.738.
he boarded ship for Pylos days ago: Actually Athena did, disguised as Mentor, and the goddess set sail with Telemachus for Pylos four days before.

4.857.
sifting barley into a basket: Barley is scattered on the sacrificial animal before it is killed (see ref). We do not know what Penelope intends to do with it: pour it out as a sort of libation? offer it to the goddess?

5.60.
that island worlds apart: Ogygia, home of Calypso.

5.134.
Orion… Demeter… Iasion: Orion was a giant huntsman with whom Eos, the dawn goddess, fell in love; after his death he became a constellation. Demeter was the goddess of the crops and especially of wheat; the place where she made love with Iasion was a field ritually plowed with a triple furrow at the beginning of the plowing season.

5.161.
the guide and giant-killer: In the Greek, two regular epithets of Hermes. He is called the guide or escort (the meaning of the word is disputed) because he is often sent by Zeus to act in that role, as at the start of Book 24, when he escorts the dead souls of the suitors to the underworld. The other epithet refers to the fact that, at the request of Zeus, Hermes killed a monster of immense strength called Argos, who had eyes all over his body, so that he could keep some of them open when he slept. He was killed because Hera had sent him to guard Io, a woman Zeus was in love with, whom Hera had changed into a cow.

5.205.
the Styx: The main river of the underworld was the guarantor of oaths sworn by the gods. Any one of the gods, Hesiod tells us (Theogony 793–806), who pours a libation of the river’s water and swears falsely is paralyzed for one year and for nine years after that is excluded from the feasts and assemblies of the gods. See note ref.

5.299.
the stars… the Plowman… the Great Bear… the Hunter: “Plowman” is the English equivalent of the Greek name Boôtes, a constellation that sets in the late evening. “The Wagon” is the constellation also known as the Big Dipper and the Great Bear. As seen from the northern hemisphere, it never disappears below the horizon or, as Homer puts it, “plunge[s] in the Ocean’s baths.” The Great Bear is referred to as “she” (301) because she was originally the nymph Callisto, who ranged the woods as one of the virgin companions of the goddess Artemis. Zeus made her pregnant, and when this could no longer be concealed, Artemis changed her into a bear and killed her. Zeus in turn changed her into the constellation. The Hunter is Orion.

5.367.
Ino, a mortal woman once: Ino, daughter of Cadmus, jumped into the sea at Corinth with her infant son in her arms, in flight from her insane husband, Athamas. Her new name—Leucothea—means “white goddess.”

6.156.
fling his arms around her knees… / plead for help: What Odysseus declines to adopt is the position of the suppliant—kneeling, clasping the knees of the person supplicated, reaching up to his (or her) chin. It is a gesture that symbolizes the utter helplessness of the suppliant, his abject dependence, but at the same time applies a physical and moral constraint on the person so addressed. The Greeks believed that Zeus was the protector and champion of suppliants. See ref, ref.

6.245.
I would be embarrassed: He has of course been naked all along, but shielding his privates with the olive branch—“the first gentleman in Europe,” as Joyce described Odysseus in this scene. Since, however, men are regularly bathed by young women elsewhere in the poem (ref, ref), his modesty here seems strange. It may be due to the fact that, unlike Telemachus when he is bathed by Nestor’s youngest daughter and Odysseus himself when bathed by Circe’s handmaids, he is now “a terrible sight… all crusted, caked with brine.” From Homer’s point of view, of course, it is necessary to get him off by himself so that Athena can make him “taller to all eyes, / his build more massive now.”

7.62.
Arete, she is called, and earns the name: / she answers all our prayers: The name brings to mind the Greek verb araomai, “pray,” which suggests the meaning “prayed for” (by her parents) as well as “prayed to” (by suppliants like Odysseus).

7.64.
the same stock that bred our King Alcinous: See Genealogy (adapted from Garvie), p. ref.

7.233.
Spinners: The Fates. They were visualized as three women spinning thread, a normal household occupation for Greek women: the thread was a human life. After Homer they were given names: Clotho (“Spinner”), Lachesis (“Allotter”— she decided how long the thread should be), and Atropos (“one who cannot be turned back”), who cuts the thread.

7.368.
more distant than Euboea: A long, narrow island off the eastern coast of Greece; for the Phaeacians, who apparently live in the fabulous west, it is “off at the edge of the world” (369).

7.371.
Rhadamanthys… Tityus: Rhadamanthys was a legendary Cretan king who after his death went to Elysium (ref). Tityus was one of the great legendary sinners; for his attempt to rape the goddess Leto, the mother of Apollo and Artemis, he was eternally tortured in the lower world (ref). Why Rhadamanthys went to Euboea to visit him we do not know.

8.41.
a crew of fifty-two young sailors: The ship is apparently a penteconter, and so requires fifty oarsmen plus two officers.

8.89.
The Strife Between Odysseus and Achilles: Our sources do not explain the cause of the strife between the two. See Introduction, p. ref.

8.129.
young champions rose for competition: The translation attempts to gloss the Homeric names of the Phaeacian competitors in terms of their root meanings in Greek, all of them fittingly nautical for a seafaring people. In doing so, the translator has followed the lead of earlier translators of the Odyssey, W. H. D. Rowse (1937) and Robert Fitzgerald (1961), as well as his own practice in glossing the names of the Nereids in the Iliad (18.43–56). The translator uses the same strategy with other, though far from all, “significant names” in the Odyssey: with those of Odysseus’ forebears, for example, as Autolycus cites them in Book ref, and with Odysseus’ fictitious parents in Book ref. See notes ref, ref, ref, ref.

8.144.
the length two mules will plow a furrow: This length (ouron) is the customary length Greek plowmen went before turning; we have no accurate figure for it, and the usual guess is 30 to 40 meters.

8.302.
The Love of Ares and Aphrodite: Hephaestus, the smith god, is lame. This may be a reflection of the fact that in a community where agriculture and war are the predominant features in the life of its men, someone with weak legs and strong arms would probably become a blacksmith. He seems to have been lame from birth: in the Iliad (18.461–64) he says that his mother, Hera, threw him out of Olympus because of this defect.

8.321.
Lemnos: A center of the cult of Hephaestus, Lemnos was an island noted for its volcanic gas and inhabited by people whom Homer identifies as Sintians (see ref), who rescued Hephaestus after his fall from Mount Olympus.

8.361.
our Father: Zeus, the father of both Aphrodite and Hephaestus.

9.27.
[Ithaca] lies low and away, the farthest out to sea: For the vagueness of Homeric geography see Introduction, p. ref, and note ref.

9.74.
the triple cry: A funeral rite, presumably a farewell to the dead; three times presumably to make sure the dead hear the cry.

9.232.
twenty cups of water he’d stir in one of wine: A powerful wine indeed. Ancient Greeks drank their wine diluted with water (as do many modern Greeks), but the usual proportions of water to wine were 3:1 or 3:2.

9.410.
Nobody—that’s my name: The Greek word outis, the name Odysseus gives himself, is formed from the normal Greek locution for “nobody”—ou tis, “not anybody.” This enables Homer to make brilliant use of wordplay that cannot be adequately reproduced in English. When his fellow Cyclops ask Polyphemus why he is making such an uproar and he tells them “Nobody’s killing me now by fraud and not by force,” they naturally misunderstand it and reply, “If… nobody’s trying to overpower you…” (456–57). But in Greek their reply has a different form for “no one”: not ou tis but mê tis, the usual form for use after the word “if.” But mê tis, “not anyone,” sounds exactly the same as mêtis, a key word of the Odyssey, the main characteristic of its hero: craft, cunning. And Polyphemus is in fact being overpowered by the mêtis, the craft and cunning of Odysseus. See, for example, ref, ref, ref, 508, 573, ref, ref.

9.560.
Odysseus, / raider of cities… / Laertes’ son who makes his home in Ithaca: For the importance of Odysseus’ declaration of his name, see Introduction, pp. ref, ref.

9.590.
if he’s fated to see / his people once again… let him find a world of pain at home: Polyphemus’ curse will be repeated by Tiresias as prophecy in the underworld (ref) and by Circe as a solemn warning on the island of Aeaea (ref).

10.563.
there into Acheron… rivers flow: The names Acheron and Styx are glossed in the translation; the Greek name of the River of Fire is Pyriphlegethon and that of the River of Tears, Cocytus. Milton has made their names and etymologies resound in Paradise Lost:

… four infernal Rivers that disgorge

Into the burning Lake their baleful streams:

Abhorred Styx the flood of deadly hate,

Sad Acheron of sorrow, black and deep;

Cocytus, nam’d of lamentation loud

Heard on the rueful stream; fierce Phlegeton

Whose waves of torrent fire inflame with rage.

2.575–81

11.146.
a fan to winnow grain: Before the invention of a threshing machine in 1784, grain was beaten on a flat surface on a windy hill; it was then thrown up into the wind to blow away the chaff in a shallow basket fixed to the end of a long handle, a winnowing fan.

11.154.
a gentle, painless death, far from the sea: Aeschylus and Sophocles may have understood the words as “out of the sea,” for they both wrote tragedies based on a legend that Odysseus was killed by a fishbone, either through blood poisoning from a scratch or as the result of a wound inflicted by a spear tipped with fishbone, which Telegonus, his son by Circe, wielded. But the words “a gentle, painless death” tell against this interpretation.

11.268.
Tyro: Among her descendants are Nestor, Jason, the leader of the Argonauts, and Melampus, the grandfather of Theoclymenus. For Tyro’s line, see Introduction, p. ref, and Genealogies (adapted from Jones and Stanford), pp. ref, ref.

11.307.
Epicaste: She is called Iocaste (Jocasta) in Sophocles’ play Oedipus the King, in which Oedipus, when he learns the truth, blinds himself and leaves Thebes, in exile.

11.318.
Chloris: Daughter of Amphion of Orchomenos (not the Amphion who founded Thebes; see ref). She was married to Neleus, father of Nestor. Neleus would give the hand of their daughter Pero only to the man who could recover his stolen cattle from Iphiclus, who had driven the herd from Pylos to his home at Phylace in Thessaly. Melampus, captured in an attempt to recover the cattle, was imprisoned but released because of his prophetic skills. A different form of the story is given at ref. See note ad loc., and Genealogies, pp. ref, ref.

11.343.
Castor… Polydeuces: Twin sons of Leda, who are often referred to as the Dioscuri—“sons of Zeus.” The extraordinary privilege granted them—that they should come back to life on alternate days—was attributed to the fact that one was the son of Zeus and the other of Tyndareus, Leda’s human husband. (The usual English form of Polydeuces is Pollux.)

11.351.
Otus… Ephialtes: The best-known version of the story is that they piled Mount Pelion on Mount Ossa in Thessaly to reach Mount Olympus, the home of the gods; here the gods are imagined as living in the sky.

11.364.
Ariadne: She helped Theseus kill the Minotaur and left Crete with him but, according to the usual version of the story, was abandoned by him on the island of Dia off the northern shore of Crete (on the island of Naxos in other accounts), where Dionysus came to take her as his bride, and she “play[ed] the queen,” as Robert Graves has said, “to nobler company.” Why the god denounced her in Homer’s version we do not know.

11.369.
Eriphyle: She accepted from Polynices, leader of the Seven Against Thebes, a necklace as a bribe for persuading her husband, the prophet Amphiaraus, to join the expedition, in which he met his death.

11.591.
Eurypylus: Like Amphiaraus, he lost his life as the result of a bribe, this time one accepted from King Priam of Troy by his mother, who persuaded her son to fight on the Trojan side.

11.625.
Pallas and captive Trojans served as judges: The captured sons of the Trojans would obviously be competent judges of the fighting qualities of their opponents. Athena, however, who favored Odysseus in all things, was hardly an impartial judge. The unexpected decision was such a shock to Ajax that he went berserk and tried to kill Agamemnon, Menelaus and Odysseus but, thwarted, killed himself instead. His suicide is the subject of Sophocles’ tragedy Ajax. See note ref.

11.660.
Tityus: See note ref.

11.669.
Tantalus: Homer takes for granted the audience’s knowledge of Tantalus’ offense. Later accounts of it differ in detail, but food and drink play a part in most of them. One version has Tantalus, who was a confidant and often invited guest of the gods, invite them to his palace for a feast and serve up to them the cooked flesh of his son Pelops, as a test of their divine powers of perception. They all refused the meat, except Demeter, who gnawed on a shoulder. After Tantalus was dispatched to his everlasting punishment in Hades—doomed, fittingly enough, to eternal thirst and hunger—Pelops was put back together again and brought to life; the missing part of his shoulder was replaced by a marble prosthesis, which was on display centuries later at Olympia, the site of the games founded by Pelops.

11.681.
Sisyphus: A great trickster (in some accounts he is the real father of Odysseus), who tricked even the God of Death. On his deathbed he told his wife not to perform the funeral rituals for him. Once in Hades, he complained that his wife had left him unburied and asked permission to return and persuade her to do her duty. Permission was given, but once at home, he refused to return and lived on to a ripe old age.

11.690.
Heracles: The greatest of the Greek heroes, Heracles eventually, after his death, became an immortal god. He was the son of Zeus and a mortal woman, Alcmena. Zeus intended that he should lord it over all who dwell around him, but Zeus’s jealous wife, Hera, contrived to have that destiny conferred on Eurystheus, king of Argos, to whom Heracles was to be subject. At Eurystheus’ command, Heracles performed the famous twelve labors: among them was the capture of the three-headed dog, Cerberus, the guardian of the entrance to the underworld. Homer attributes Heracles’ death to Hera’s anger, but in other poets’ versions of his death Hera plays no part. See notes ref, ref.

12.68.
Clashing Rocks: The Greek word Homer uses means something like “Wandering Rocks” but clearly he is drawing on the story of the Symplegades (a word which does mean Clashing Rocks), between which even the doves bringing ambrosia to Zeus could get caught. They are a prominent feature of the story of Jason and the Argonauts, which is mentioned as a well-known theme for song at ref. See Introduction, p. ref.

12.285.
Hyperion: A name which, whatever its true etymology, suggests the meaning “the one who goes above,” and is another name of Helios, the sun.

12.337.
the night’s third watch: The night was divided into three parts, each approximately four hours long.

12.384.
fresh green leaves… for the rite: A substitute for the barley scattered over the sacrificial animal. Later, lacking wine, they made libations with water. It is appropriate that, since the slaughter of the cattle is an offense to the god, the ritual should fall far short of proper procedure.

13.180.
Then pile your huge mountain round about their port: For Zeus’s encouragement of Poseidon here, see Introduction, pp. ref.

14.63.
And you replied, Eumaeus, loyal swineherd: Homer is fond of introducing Eumaeus in the second person, as he often does Patroclus and Menelaus in the Iliad. In the Odyssey it may be the result of a metrical convenience or a vestige of older, bardic practice or, as Stanford (his note 14.55) and other commentators, following the lead of Eustathius, suggest, “a mark of the poet’s special affection for Eumaeus.”

14.494.
the forest nymphs and Hermes: One share of Eumaeus’ supper is set aside for a local cult of the wood nymphs, another share for Hermes, in his role as patron god of herdsmen.

15.21.
bride-price: See ref and Introduction, pp. ref, ref.

15.80.
you know, / ‘Welcome the coming, speed the parting guest!’: This is Pope’s translation of the line, adopted here but enclosed in quotation marks as if, by a spin of reverse English, it had become proverbial in our language, even though spoken by Menelaus centuries before. Pope in his Horatian Imitations (Satires II.ii.160), introducing it as “sage Homer’s rule,” later revised the line to read “welcome the coming, speed the going guest.” This translator prefers the Odyssean version. See Introduction, p. ref.

15.250.
Melampus’ line of seers: A different version of the story told at ref. Here Neleus drives Melampus out and confiscates his property. We do not know why Phylacus (Iphiclus in the other version) imprisoned Melampus, nor why he was persecuted by the Furies, nor how he avenged himself on Neleus. In this version he wins Neleus’ daughter Pero not for himself but for his brother. Homer does not mention it, but we learn from Hesiod that Melampus, who could understand the speech of birds and animals, was released from prison because he had heard worms in the palace roofbeams discussing how thoroughly they had undermined the structure, and so Melampus warned his captor that the building would soon collapse. See Genealogies, pp. ref, ref, and note ref.

15.276.
undone by a bribe his wife accepted: See note ref.

16.131.
Zeus made our line a line of only sons: See Genealogy, p. ref.

17.602.
Telemachus shook with a lusty sneeze: Ancient Greeks regarded a sneeze as an omen, since it is something a human being can neither produce at will nor control when it arrives. Hence it must be the work of a god.

18.6.
Arnaeus… Irus: Arnaeus is called Irus presumably because, like Iris the messenger of the gods, he runs errands for the suitors.

18.277.
Ionian Argos: The adjective usually designates Greek settlements on the Aegean islands and what is now the western coast of Turkey, whose inhabitants spoke a dialect known as Ionian. Argos is in the Peloponnese, but there is good evidence for an Ionian presence there in very early times.

19.94.
thanks to god Apollo: In his aspect of Apollo kourotrophos, the rearer of young men.

19.203.
Minos: The legendary king of Crete, whose name has been given to the civilization unearthed by archaeologists in the early years of our century. Minos ruled Crete either in nine-year cycles or, as Plato understood the Homeric line, went every ninth year to the cave of Zeus to confer with the god and bring back laws for his people. Together with another Cretan king, Rhadamanthys, he is sometimes mentioned as one of the judges in the world of the dead. See ref.

19.299.
Destroy, I call it—I hate to say its name: “desTroy” is T.E. Lawrence’s rendering of a remarkable turn of phrase in Penelope’s speech: she calls the city she does not wish to mention kakoilion, combining the Greek word for evil—kakos— with the name Ilion, an alternative name for Troy. See ref, ref.

19.407.
your master’s… equal in years: The pause indicated in the translation, allowing the reader to imagine for a second that Penelope has penetrated Odysseus’ disguise, attempts to reproduce a similar effect that Homer produced for the ears of his audience, but through Greek word order rather than a pause.

19.463.
Odysseus… / the Son of Pain, a name he’ll earn in full: The name “Odysseus” may be associated with the Greek verb odussomai—to feel anger toward, to rage or hate. The verb, however, appears to function in the middle voice, a cross between the active and the passive, implying that Odysseus is not only an agent of rage or hatred but its target too. Particularly to the point are the discussions by John Peradotto (pp. 129–34) and George Dimock (pp. 257–63), who suggest that Odysseus suffers for making others suffer, not as an end in itself but, insofar as odussomai brings to mind the verb ôdinô—to suffer pain, especially the pain of labor—as the rigors by which the hero brings his identity to life. Consequently Dimock proposes that we translate “Odysseus” as “man of pain”— active and passive, doing and done to, agent and victim both, inflicting and bearing pain yet somehow born himself in the process. That is the version which this translator adopts and adapts throughout his work. Yet when Homer intends a pun between the root of the hero’s name and the hostility he arouses in others, the translator tries to develop some wordplay, wherever possible, between “Odysseus” and those “dead set” against him. See ref, ref, ref; and, as variations on the theme, ref, ref, ref, ref, ref.

19.585.
Pandareus’ daughter, the nightingale: Her name was Aedon (which is the Greek word for nightingale). She had only one son, but her sister-in-law Niobe had many; in a fit of jealous rage, she tried to kill Niobe’s eldest son but by mistake killed her own son, Itylus. Zeus turned her into a nightingale, mourning her son in song forever. There is a different version of the story that is familiar to us from the Latin and our own poets, in which Procne, an Athenian princess, married Tereus, a Thracian king. Tereus raped Procne’s sister, Philomela, and then cut out her tongue to prevent her from denouncing him to her sister. But Philomela wove the story into a tapestry to show Procne, who then killed Itys, her son by Tereus, cooked the flesh and served it to her husband, who ate it. When told what he had eaten, Tereus tried to kill both sisters, but Zeus turned them all into birds: Procne became the nightingale, eternally mourning Itys, Philomela the swallow and Tereus the hoopoe.

19.633.
Two gates… for our evanescent dreams: Why the ivory gate should be the exit for false dreams and the gate of horn for true has never been satisfactorily explained.

19.644.
a contest with those axes: There has been much controversy about the axes and still no agreement. When in ref Telemachus sets them up for the contest, he digs a trench in the dirt floor of the hall, plants them in it in a straight line and stamps the earth down to hold them firm. Many editors have assumed that what he planted in the trench were the ax blades, with the holes for the helves lined up. But to shoot an arrow through such a lineup, the archer would have to be lying on the floor, an impossible position from which to draw the bow, not to mention making such a difficult shot. In any case, we are told (ref) that when Odysseus does shoot an arrow through the axes he is sitting on a stool. So the holes the arrow goes through must be at least two feet off the ground. The only possible solution seems to be that the axes all have a metal ring on the end of the helve, presumably so that the ax could be hung on a nail in the wall.

20.73.
the whirlwinds swept away Pandareus’ daughters: This story of the death of Pandareus’ daughters, none of them named, seems to have no connection with the tale of the nightingale. See ref and note ad loc.

20.307.
Apollo’s grand festal day: It is a significant coincidence that the archery contest, which will bring about the deaths of the suitors and Odysseus’ reinstatement in his own home, is to take place on the festival day of Apollo, the archer god. See ref and note ref.

20.395.
Ghosts, look: Presumably those of the suitors, glimpsed here in a visionary, prophetic way but clearly present, following their slaughter in Book 22, at the beginning of Book 24.

21.16.
Eurytus: One of the great archers Odysseus mentions when he claims mastery of the bow among the Phaeacians (ref). Eurytus had even challenged Apollo to a contest, an insult for which the god killed him. According to later sources, Apollo had given him a bow and trained him in its use; if so, the bow Iphitus gave Odysseus comes from the hand of the archer god himself, to be used against the suitors on Apollo’s feast day. See note ref.

21.55.
inserted the key and aiming straight and true, / shot back the bolts: The mechanism of Homeric doorlocks is so mysterious that Joyce’s parody in Ulysses may be the best commentary on this passage:

How did the centripetal remainer afford egress to the centrifugal departer?

By inserting the barrel of an arruginated male key in the hole of an unstable female lock, obtaining a purchase on the bow of the key and turning its wards from right to left, withdrawing a bolt from its staple, pulling inward spasmodically an obsolescent unhinged door and revealing an aperture for free egress and free ingress.

21.331.
Pirithous: A friend of Theseus and his companion on many of his exploits, he was king of the Lapiths, a tribe living in Thessaly, a country famous for its horses. He invited to his wedding with Hippodameia the Centaurs, who were later visualized as half man and half horse but whom Homer describes in the Iliad (1.312) as “wild brutes of the mountains.” Their leader, Eurytion, got drunk at the feast and tried to rape the bride (whose name, incidentally, means “tamer of horses”). The resultant battle was a favorite theme for temple sculpture (it is featured, for example, on the west pediment of the temple of Zeus at Olympia); it symbolized the fight between civilized Greeks and savage barbarians.

22.134.
a side-door was fitted into the main wall: Commentators have puzzled over the architectural details of the palace in vain. The confusion is probably the result of a combination of different bardic formulas over time, which became the standard version. In any case, the original audience, swept along by the performance, would not have worried too much about the details. See Introduction, p. ref.

22.241.
your fine strategic stroke: Odysseus’ stratagem of the Trojan Horse, which held the Achaean force that leveled Troy. See note ref.

24.126.
to urge Odysseus to sail: In a later epic poem, the Cypria, we are told that Odysseus, unwilling to leave his wife and baby son, feigned madness to escape the summons to the war against Troy. He drove his plow, harnessed to an ass and an ox, sowing salt in the furrows. Palamedes, the cleverest of the chiefs assembled for the expedition, put Odysseus’ baby son in the path of the plow; Odysseus reined it in, his deceit exposed. “But once at the war,” as Joyce reminded Frank Budgen, “the conscientious objector became a jusqu’ auboutist.”

24.341.
my father’s Unsparing, son of old King Pain, / and my name’s Man of Strife…: See note ref.

SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER READING

I. Texts and Commentaries

Homeri Opera. Ed. by T. W. Allen. 2d ed., Vols. III and IV. Oxford Classical Texts. London and New York, 1917.

The Odyssey. Ed. with Introduction, Commentary and Indexes by W. B. Stanford. 2d ed., 2 vols. London and New York, reprinted with alterations and additions, 1967.

A Commentary on Homer’s Odyssey. Vol. I: Books I–VIII, A. Heubeck, S. West, J. B. Hainsworth. Vol. II: Books IX–XVI, A. Heubeck, A. Hoekstra. Vol. III: Books XVII–XXIV, J. Russo, M. Fernández-Galiano, A. Heubeck. New York and Oxford, 1988–92.

Homer, Odyssey: Books XIX and XX. Ed. R. B. Rutherford. Cambridge Greek and Latin Classics. Cambridge, England, 1992.

Homer, Odyssey: Books VI–VIII. Ed. A. F. Garvie. Cambridge Greek and Latin Classics. Cambridge, England, 1994.

Homer, The Odyssey. Ed. with English translation by A. T. Murray, revised by George E. Dimock. 2 vols. The Loeb Classical Library. Cambridge, Mass., and London, 1995.

II. Critical Works

Ahl, Frederick, and Hanna M. Roisman. The Odyssey Re-Formed. Ithaca, 1996.

Arnold, Matthew. “On Translating Homer.” In On the Classical Tradition, ed. R. H. Super. Ann Arbor and London, 1960.

Atchity, Kenneth, ed. Critical Essays on Homer. Boston, 1987.

Auerbach, Erich. Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature. Trans. Willard Trask. Chapter 1, “Odysseus’ Scar.” Princeton, 1953.

Austin, Norman. Archery at the Dark of the Moon: Poetic Problems in Homer’s Odyssey. Berkeley, Los Angeles and London, 1975.

Bakker, Egbert, and Ahuvia Kahane, eds. Written Voices, Spoken Signs: Tradition, Performance, and the Epic Text. Cambridge, Mass., 2000.

Beissinger, Margaret, Jane Tylus, and Susanne Wofford, eds. Epic Traditions in the Contemporary World: The Poetics of Community. Berkeley, 1999.

Benardete, Seth. The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey. New York and London, 1997.

Beye, Charles R. The Iliad, the Odyssey, and the Epic Tradition. New York and London, 1966.

Bloom, Harold, ed. Homer’s Odyssey. New York, 1996.

Bremer, J. M., I. J. F. de Jong, and J. Kalff, eds. Homer: Beyond Oral Poetry. Recent Trends in Homeric Interpretation. Amsterdam, 1987.

Buitron, Diana, and Beth Cohen, eds. The Odyssey and Ancient Art: An Epic in Word and Image. The Edith C. Blum Art Institute, Bard College, Annandale-on-Hudson, New York, 1992.

Camps, W. A. An Introduction to Homer. Oxford, 1980.

Carpenter, Rhys. Folk Tale, Fiction, and Saga in the Homeric Epics. Berkeley, 1946.

Carter, Jane B., and Sarah P. Morris, eds. The Ages of Homer: A Tribute to Emily Townsend Vermeule. Austin, 1995.

Chadwick, John. The Mycenaean World. London and New York, 1976.

Clarke, Howard. Homer’s Readers: A Historical Introduction to the Iliad and the Odyssey. Newark, Del., 1981.

Clay, Jenny Strauss. The Wrath of Athena: Gods and Men in the Odyssey. Princeton, 1983.

Cohen, Beth, ed. The Distaff Side: Representing the Female in Homer’s Odyssey. New York and London, 1995.

Cook, Erwin F. The “Odyssey” in Athens: Myths of Cultural Origins. Ithaca and London, 1996.

Crotty, Kevin. The Poetics of Supplication: Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. Ithaca and London, 1994.

Dawe, R. D. The Odyssey: Translation and Analysis. Sussex, 1993.

Dimock, George E. The Unity of the Odyssey. Amherst, 1989.

Edwards, Mark W. Homer: Poet of the Iliad. Baltimore and London, 1987.

Felson-Rubin, Nancy. Regarding Penelope: From Character to Poetics. Princeton, 1994.

Fenik, Bernard. Studies in the Odyssey. Hermes Einzelschrift 30. Wiesbaden, 1974.

Ferrucci, Franco. The Poetics of Disguise: The Autobiography of the Work in Homer, Dante, and Shakespeare. Trans. A. Dunnigan. Ithaca, 1980.

Finley, John H., Jr. Homer’s Odyssey. Cambridge, Mass., and London, 1978.

Finley, Sir Moses. The World of Odysseus. 2d rev. ed. Harmondsworth, 1979.

Finnegan, Ruth. Oral Poetry: Its Nature, Significance, and Social Context. Cambridge, England, 1977.

Ford, Andrew. Homer: The Poetry of the Past. Ithaca and London, 1992.

Frame, Douglas. The Myth of Return in Early Greek Epic. New Haven, 1978.

Greene, Thomas M. The Descent from Heaven: A Study in Epic Continuity. Chapter 4, “Form and Craft in the Odyssey.” New Haven, 1963.

Griffin, Jasper. Homer on Life and Death. Oxford, 1980.

____. Homer: The Odyssey. Landmarks of World Literature. Cambridge, England, and New York, 1987.

Guthrie, W. K. C. The Greeks and Their Gods. London, 1949; repr. Boston, 1950.

Hexter, Ralph. A Guide to the Odyssey: A Commentary on the English Translation of Robert Fitzgerald. New York, 1993.

Jenkyns, Richard. Classical Epic: Homer and Virgil. Bristol Classical World series. London, 1992.

Jones, Peter V. Homer’s Odyssey: A Companion to the Translation of Richmond Lattimore. Carbondale and Bristol, 1988.

Katz, Marylin A. Penelope’s Renown: Meaning and Indeterminacy in the Odyssey. Princeton, 1991.

Kirk, G. S. The Songs of Homer. Cambridge, England, 1962.

Lamberton, Robert. Homer the Theologian: Neoplatonist Allegorical Reading and the Growth of the Epic Tradition. Berkeley, Los Angeles and London, 1986.

____, and J. J. Keaney, eds. Homer’s Ancient Readers: The Hermeneutics of Greek Epic’s Earliest Exegetes. Princeton, 1992.

Lloyd-Jones, Sir Hugh. The Justice of Zeus. 2d ed. Sather Classical Lectures, Vol. 41. Berkeley, Los Angeles and London, 1983.

Lord, Albert. The Singer of Tales. Cambridge, Mass., 1960.

Louden, Bruce. The Odyssey: Structure, Narration, and Meaning. Baltimore and London, 1999.

Martin, Richard. The Language of Heroes: Speech and Performance in the Iliad. Ithaca, 1989.

McAuslan, Ian, and Peter Walcot, eds. Homer. Oxford and New York, 1998.

Morris, Ian, and Barry Powell, eds. A New Companion to Homer. Leiden and New York, 1997.

Moulton, Carroll. Similes in the Homeric Poems. Göttingen, 1977.

Mueller, Martin, The Iliad. Unwin Critical Library, ed. Claude Rawson. London, 1984.

Murnaghan, Sheila. Disguise and Recognition in the Odyssey. Princeton, 1987.

Myrsiades, Kostas, ed. Approaches to Teaching Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. New York, 1987.

Nagy, Gregory. The Best of the Achaeans: Concepts of the Hero in Archaic Greek Poetry. Baltimore and London, 1979.

Olson, S. Douglas. Blood and Iron: Stories and Storytelling in Homer’s Odyssey. Leiden, New York, Köln, 1995.

Page, Sir Denys. Folktales in Homer’s Odyssey. Cambridge, Mass., 1973.

____. The Homeric Odyssey. Oxford, 1955.

Parry, Adam M. Foreword by Sir Hugh Lloyd-Jones. The Language of Achilles and Other Papers. Oxford, 1989.

Parry, Milman. The Making of Homeric Verse: The Collected Papers of Milman Parry. Ed. Adam Parry. Oxford, 1971.

Peradotto, John. Man in the Middle Voice: Name and Narration in the Odyssey. Martin Classical Lectures, New Series, Vol. 1. Princeton, 1990.

Pucci, Pietro. Odysseus Polutropos: Intertextual Readings in the Odyssey and the Iliad. 2d ed. Ithaca, 1995.

Rubens, Beaty, and Oliver Taplin. An Odyssey Round Odysseus: The Man and His Story Traced Through Time and Place. London, 1989.

Rubino, Carl A., and Cynthia W. Shelmerdine, eds. Approaches to Homer. Austin, 1983.

Schein, Seth L., ed. Reading the Odyssey: Selected Interpretive Essays. Princeton, 1995.

Scully, Stephen. Homer and the Sacred City. Ithaca and London, 1990.

Segal, Charles. Singers, Heroes, and Gods in the Odyssey. Ithaca, 1994.

Shive, David M. Naming Achilles. New York and Oxford, 1987.

Stanford, W. B. The Ulysses Theme: A Study in the Adaptability of a Traditional Hero. Oxford, 1983.

Steiner, George, and Robert Fagles, eds. Homer: A Collection of Critical Essays. Twentieth Century Views, ed. Maynard Mack. Englewood Cliffs, 1962.

____, ed., with Aminadov Dykman. Homer in English. Penguin Poets in Translation, ed. Christopher Ricks. Harmondsworth, 1996.

Suzuki, Mihoko. Metamorphoses of Helen: Authority, Difference, and the Epic. Chapter 2, “The Odyssey.” Ithaca and London, 1989.

Taylor, Charles H., Jr., ed. Essays on the Odyssey: Selected Modern Criticism. Indianapolis, 1963.

Thalmann, William G. The Odyssey: An Epic of Return. Twayne Publishers, New York, 1992.

____. The Swineherd and the Bow: Representations of Class in the Odyssey. Ithaca, N.Y., 1998.

Thornton, Agathe. People and Themes in Homer’s Odyssey. London, 1970.

Tracy, Stephen V. The Story of the Odyssey. Princeton, 1990.

____. Greece in the Bronze Age. Chicago and London, 1964.

Vermeule, Emily. Aspects of Death in Early Greek Art and Poetry. Sather Classical Lectures, Vol. 46. Berkeley, Los Angeles and London, 1979.

Vivante, Paolo. Homer. Hermes Books, ed. John Herington. New Haven and London, 1985.

Wace, Alan J. B., and Frank Stubbings. A Companion to Homer. London, 1962.

Wender, Dorothea. The Last Scenes of the Odyssey. Mnemosyne Supplement 52. Leiden, 1978.

Whitman, Cedric H. Homer and the Heroic Tradition. Chapter 12, “The Odyssey and Change.” Cambridge, Mass., and London, 1958.

Wood, Robert. An Essay on the Original Genius and Writings of Homer. London, 1769; rep. Philadelphia, 1976.

Woodhouse, W. J. The Composition of Homer’s Odyssey. Oxford, 1930.

PRONOUNCING GLOSSARY

The main purpose of this glossary is to indicate pronunciation. Identifications are brief, and only the first appearance of a name is listed.

Phonetic Equivalents:

a as in cat

ay as in day

aw as in raw

ai as in air

ah as in father

e as in pet

ee as in feet

i as in bit

eye as in bite

o as in pot

oh as in bone

oo as in boot

or as in bore

s as in hiss

th as in thin

u as in us

ur as in burst

Stress is indicated by an apostrophe after the stressed syllable (af’-ter).

ACASTUS

(a-kas’-tus): king of Dulichion, ref.

ACHAEA

(a-kee’-a): general, collective name for mainland Greece, ref.

ACHAEANS

(a-kee’-unz): collective name for all Greek people, including the citizens of Ithaca, ref.

ACHERON

(a’-ker-on): a river in the underworld, ref. See note ad loc.

ACHILLES

(a-kil’-eez): son of Peleus and Thetis, grandson of Aeacus, and commander of the Myrmidons, Achaean allies, at Troy, ref.

ACTORIS

(ak’-to-ris): maid of Penelope, ref.

ADRESTE

(a-drees’-tee): maid of Helen, ref.

AEACUS

(ee’-a-kus): son of Zeus, father of Peleus, grandfather of Achilles, ref.

AEAEA

(ee-ee’-a): island home of Circe, ref.

AEETES

(ee-ee’-teez): brother of Circe, ref.

AEGAE

(ee’-jee): Achaean city in the northern Peloponnese and sacred to Poseidon, ref.

AEGISTHUS

(ee-jis’-thus): son of Thyestes, seducer of Clytemnestra and murderer of Agamemnon, killed by Orestes, ref. See note ad loc.

AEGYPTIUS

(ee-jip’-shus): Ithacan elder, father of Eurynomus, ref.

AEOLIA

(ee-oh’-li-a): island ruled by Aeolus, ref.

AEOLUS

(ee’-oh-lus): (1) master of the winds, ref. (2) Father of Cretheus, ref.

AESON

(ee’-son): son of Tyro and Cretheus, father of Jason, ref.

AETHON

(ee’-thon): name assumed by Odysseus, disguised as a beggar, ref.

AETOLIA

(ee-toh’-li-a): region in west-central Greece, ref.

AGAMEMNON

(a-ga-mem’-non): king of Mycenae, son of Atreus, husband of Clytemnestra, murdered by her and Aegisthus; brother of Menelaus, supreme commander of all Achaea’s armies and leader of the largest contingent at Troy, ref. See note ref.

AGELAUS

(a-je-lay’-us): suitor, son of Damastor, killed by Odysseus, ref.

AJAX

(ay’-jax): (1) Achaean, son of Telamon, Telamonian or Great Ajax, defeated by Odysseus in the contest for Achilles’ armor, ref. See notes ad loc. and ref. (2) Achaean, son of Oileus, Oilean or Little Ajax, ref. See notes ref, ref.

ALCANDRE

(al-kan’-dree): lady of Egyptian Thebes, wife of Polybus, ref.

ALCIMUS

(al’-si-mus): father of Mentor, ref.

ALCINOUS

(al-si’-no-us): king of the Phaeacians, husband of Arete, father of Nausicaa, ref.

ALCIPPE

(al-si’-pee): maid of Helen, ref.

ALCMAEON

(alk-mee’-on): son of Amphiaraus, ref.

ALCMENA

(alk-mee’-na): mother of Heracles by Zeus, ref. See note ref.

ALECTOR

(a-lek’-tor): Spartan, whose daughter married Megapenthes, ref.

ALOEUS

(a-lee’-us): husband of Iphimedeia, supposed father of Otus and Ephialtes, ref.

ALPHEUS

(al-fee’-us): river in the western Peloponnese, ref.

AMNISUS

(am-ni’-sus): port city of Cnossos, on the northern coast of Crete, ref.

AMPHIARAUS

(am-fi-a-ray’-us): prophet and king of Argos, son of Oicles,