1: Crime, Criminal Justice, and
Criminology
Learning Objectives
This section will broadly introduce crime, criminal justice, and criminology. This section is designed to be a
broad overview of what the subsequent chapters will cover in detail. It also demonstrates how the United States
create laws, policies enacted to enforce laws, and the role of the media. After reading this section, students will be
able to:
• Understand the differences between deviance, rule violations, and criminality
• Explain the differences between the interactionist, consensus, and conflict views in the creation of
laws
• Identify the three components of the criminal justice system
• Discuss the differences between crime control and due process model, and application examples to
each
• Describe the wedding cake model theory and application examples to each tier
• Briefly explain the role of the media and how media may spread myths in society
• Briefly understand the unique role of victims in the criminal justice process
Background Knowledge Probe: The goal here is to assess current knowledge about the criminal
justice system at the start of the course. Each of these topics is covered throughout the course, and they will
often be a controversial topic and topic for debate.
You will indicate whether you know each statement to be True or False, but there is no right or wrong
answer since it is just to assess your background knowledge.
1. Blacks commit more crime than any other racial group.
9
2. The United States has the lowest recidivism rates in the world (return to prison).
3. The death penalty is cheaper than life imprisonment.
4. Politicians shape our thoughts on crime, even if they are inaccurate.
5. Children are most likely to be killed by a stranger.
6. A stranger is most likely to physically harm you.
7. White-collar crime costs our country more every year than street-crime.
8. Juveniles are more violent today than ever before.
9. Immigrants commit more crime than native-born people.
10. Violent crime has risen in the United States over the last 20 years.
ALISON S. BURKE, DAVID CARTER, BRIAN FEDOREK, TIFFANY MOREY, LORE RUTZ-BURRI, AND SHANELL
SANCHEZ
10
1.1. Crime and the Criminal Justice System
SHANELL SANCHEZ
Theft as a Child
The first lesson in crime and criminality I remember was when I was in second grade and stole something from
a local drug store. I thought that the bracelet was shiny and perfect. At first, I remember wanting to try it on, but
then I did not want to take it off. I had more questions than my Nana may have been ready to answer about why I
did it and why I could not keep it. I had to take the bracelet back, which hurt because I loved it. Because of guilt or
shame, I told my grandma what I did.
Think about a time in your life that you may have done something similar. Was this first lesson in crime and
criminality from the person you were raised by such as a parent(s) or grandparent(s)? Did they teach you that what
you did was a crime and, hopefully, how to correct this wrong at a young age?
You were probably punished, and they may have consisted of helping out with more chores or losing your
allowance to pay back what you stole.
Imagine all the questions you may have for your parents at the moment: Why was it wrong? What would happen
to me if I did not tell you? What is a crime? Who decides what makes a crime? What happens to me if I commit a
crime and get caught? What is my punishment? Why was it wrong when there were so many polishes there?
Further, I had to help out around the house for the weekend. In exchange for all this, she did not tell my dad
because she knew her punishment was sufficient and to tell him may be excessive. She took a balanced approach to
punishment and I think this is why it was so effective. It was not too strict, it was hard to complete, and I had to
think about what I did.
Most criminologists define crime as the violation of the laws of a society by a person or a group of
people who are subject to the laws of that society (citizens). Thus, crime as defined by the State or Federal
government. Essentially, crime is what the law states and a violation of the law, stated in the statue, would
make actions criminal.
1
1. Lynch, M., Stretesky, P., Long, M. (2015). Defining crime: A critique of the concept and its implication. Palgrave Macmillan: US.
11
For example, if someone murdered another individual in the process of stealing their automobile most
people would see this as a criminal and a straight-forward example of crime. We often see murder and
robbery as wrong and harms society, as well as social . However, there are times crime is not as straight-
forward though and people may hesitate to call it criminal. The community I live in, and many others
throughout the area, post signs that it is illegal to give food and other items to homeless individuals in need.
If one were to violate this law and give food to a homeless person it would not involve harm to individuals,
but the social .
Adele MacLean joined others in an Atlanta park to feed the hungry the Sunday before Thanksgiving and
was given a citation and a summons to appear in court. Ultimately, MacLean’s case was dropped when she
showed up in court, but she and her lawyers argued the citation for serving food without a permit was
improper and demonstrates callousness toward the homeless. The city and some advocates say feeding people
on the streets can hinder long-term solutions and raises sanitation concerns.
2
Approximately 40 cities across
the nation have active laws to restrict food sharing, and a few dozen more had attempted such restrictions,
according to the National Coalition for the Homeless.
3
We will talk later about how we may create laws based on what can cause harm. Harm can be to the social ,
physical, economic, social, emotional, environmental, and more. In to ensure that people receive justice in
today’s society, we use the criminal justice system to administer punishment or reward, and those crimes are often
punished based on morals and norms.
The criminal justice system is a major social institution that is tasked with controlling crime in various ways.
Police are often tasked with detecting crime and detaining individuals, courts often adjudicate and hand down
punishments, and the correction system implements punishments and/or rehabilitative efforts for people who have
been found guilty of breaking the law.
Criminal Justice Process
When the law is broken, the criminal justice system must respond in an attempt to make society whole
again. The criminal justice system is made up of various agencies at different levels of government that
can work independently and together, but each attempting to deal with crime. Challenges may arise
when agencies do not work together or attempt to work together inefficiently. The notorious serial killer
Ted Bundy was an example of U.S. law enforcement agencies not working together because of lack of
technological advancement to freely exchange information and resources about killings in their area. Bundy
exploited gaps in the traditional law enforcement, investigative processes throughout different jurisdictions,
and ultimately was able to avoid arrest and detection. If various agencies at the Federal, State, and Local law
enforcement level had worked together they could have potentially stopped Ted Bundy sooner. Following
Ted Bundy, a Multi-agency Investigative Team manual, also known as the MAIT Taskforce, was created
through the National Institute of Justice to develop information about the crime, it causes and how to control
it https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/Digitization/110826NCJRS.pdf. One of the values of the United States is
that local agencies will control their local community, but at times this may create unexpected complications.
Working Together?
2. Brumback, K. (2017). Cities, volunteers clash over feeding homeless in public. Associated Press. https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-
world/cities-volunteers-clash-over-feeding-homeless-in-public/
3. National Coalition for the Homeless. (2018).
ALISON S. BURKE, DAVID CARTER, BRIAN FEDOREK, TIFFANY MOREY, LORE RUTZ-BURRI, AND SHANELL
SANCHEZ
12
You are to create an argument for or against law enforcement agencies working together. Some countries have
national police forces, whereas we do not. Be prepared to defend your position in the class.
Although agencies may operate differently, the way cases move through the criminal justice system is
consistent. The first step after getting caught stealing something from a store is involvement with police
when law enforcement is called. The next step in the process is to proceed through the court system to
determine guilt or innocence. If you are found guilty then you will receive a sentence that will be carried
out in the next step. After conviction, you move to the correctional system for formal punishment and/or
treatments as determined by the courts. An individual may not go through the entire process and criminal
justice officials decide whether the case should continue on to the next stage. Perhaps the officer decides not
to cite you and your contact ends there. However, it may be the district attorney (DA) that decides to drop
your case before it even goes to trial. Regardless, the process is typically cops, courts, and then corrections.
We will explore each of these in greater detail later on.
News Box: In 2016, more people were arrested for marijuana possession than for all crimes the FBI
classifies as violent.
4
Overall in 2016, roughly 1.5 million people were arrested for drug-related offenses, up
slightly year-over-year
5
Marijuana enforcement and criminalization goes to the heart of some of the most
pressing issues facing the criminal justice system, policymakers, citizens, and the world. Is criminalizing
drug use effective, especially for marijuana? Is spending money on enforcing drug laws, prosecuting drug
crimes, and punishing drug offenders effective? The United States has taken a get-tough approach towards
the War on Drugs, created mandatory minimum sentences, and punished people in large numbers but is it
effective?
4. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2016/crime-in-the-u.s.-2016/topic-pages/tables/table-18
5. Ingraham, C. (2017). More people were arrested last year over pot than for murder, rape, aggravated assault, and robbery —
combined. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/09/26/more-people-were-arrested-last-year-
over-pot-than-for-murder-rape-aggravated-assault-and-robbery-combined/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.62735d3474ea
Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System
13
1.2. Deviance, Rule Violations, and Criminality
SHANELL SANCHEZ
Nude Ultimate Frisbee
Imagine you recently moved to Oregon for work from Georgia after graduating college and hope to make new
friends. Georgia has been your home forever, so Oregon is entirely new. Then one day at the dog park you run
into a guy that seems like someone you would like to hang out with and he tells you to come out and play ultimate
frisbee this weekend. You decide to take the leap and meet new people, play a new sport, and have some fun.
You arrive on the field, but notice something that stands out as different to you and wonders ‘is this allowed
in Oregon?’ Some women and men are naked, some fully and some just certain parts exposed, but no one seems
uncomfortable. You look around at the topless players, all adults, and wonder if this is the wrong place. Other
people in costume walk around like Unicorns, Mario, Rainbow Brite, among others. Suddenly, thoughts start
racing through your mind: “Why are people dressed strangely? Is it legal to be nude in public in the state of
Oregon? Why does no one seem to mind? Can I keep my clothes on? What will my family in Georgia think?
Should I just go back to my apartment now?”
Suddenly, the guy from the dog park runs up and tells you to come on over so he can introduce you to the
team. Situations like this are often examples we use in the college classroom to demonstrate the difference between
deviance, rule violations, and criminal violations. Sometimes there are times that behaviors that appear to be deviant
are not illegal, but other times behaviors that are illegal are not deviant.
Just about everyone in society has done something that someone else would disagree with and see as deviant.
For example, I recently wore clothes to the gym that were out of style but how did I know they were out of
style? Well, easy! The reaction of others to my lack of style in the gym was clear that it is no longer cool to
wear knee-high socks with athletic shorts to the gym.
Another time I was at Thanksgiving dinner with my family and I expressed open support for a politician
that no one else in the family supported. Their reactions to my support of him made it evident that I
was the deviant one that was not going along with the typical political views expected in my reasonably
conservative, Republican family.
Alternatively, perhaps I am deviant when I tell you my favorite show on television is, and always will
14
“Facial Tattoos and Piercings”
be, the Golden Girls, which seems odd for someone in their early thirties. Perhaps someone thinks it is
utter nonsense and ‘crazy’ wasting my time watching such shows. These are just a few examples where my
behavior, thoughts, actions, or beliefs may be different from those around me.
From a sociological perspective, social norms are all around us and are accepted norms and behaviors
that defined within a specific group. The group you are in can change, which would mean the norms and
behaviors that are acceptable at any given time may change.
1
Deviance is behavior that departs from the social norm. Goode argues
that four things must happen in for something deviant to take place
or exist:
1) a rule or norm must be established; 2) someone has to violate that
rule or norm; 3) there must be an audience or someone, that witnesses
the act and judges it to be wrong; 4) and there is likely going to be a
negative reaction from that audience that can come in many forms (i.e.,
criticism, disapproval, punishment, and more).
To commit an act of deviance one does not need to violate a
dangerous norm, and not all acts that are deviant are criminal. Not all
criminal acts are deviant either. Deviance falls on a spectrum that can
range from really deviant to not so deviant but remember it is dependent
on the audience. Think back to the previous comment about the show
Golden Girls. My grandma would not find that as deviant as my husband
does because we grew up watching it together. We spent many hours on
the couch laughing away at the silliness of it all, so we would both agree
it is a beautiful show.
2
Applying Knowledge
Assignment: Apply Goode’s definition of what needs to happen in for something to be considered deviant
in no less than 500 words and following the example below.
Example: The awkward outfit to the gym: knee socks, athletic shorts, and an oversized Broncos t-shirt
mentioned above could be deviant. Based on Goode’s definition of deviance, this attire departed from the social
norm at the gym in 2018. Whether we realize it or not some specific rules or norms established in the gym (1);
sometimes we have a dress code, but other times, you have to keep up with current ‘hip trends’ such as yoga pants
for women in 2018. Next, I violated that norm by my attire (2); since it was a busy Monday night lots of people
saw my attire, my audience, that was able to witness my act and then judge it (3). Lastly, they cannot kick me out
for not dressing cool, but the awkward smirks, stares, and giggles were all I needed to know that my clothes were
deviant and not cool (4). This could certainly have not been true in 1950, 1980, or even early 2000s. If I think back
to when I started lifting over a decade ago, yoga pants were unheard of and no one wore anything ‘tight’ to the
gym. Today yoga pants are regular and in some parts of the country for women and men.
1. By Tuerto – [1], CC by-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=26526042
2. Goode, E. (2015). Deviant Behavior, (10th ed.). New York: Pearson, Education.
Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System
15
1.3. Social Norms: Folkways, Mores, Taboo, and Laws
SHANELL SANCHEZ
Social Control Exercise
Assignment: We rely on informal social control to influence people’s behavior, such as giving the stink eye, cold
shoulder, or correcting someone’s behavior in to ensure people conform. Think about a time when a parent,
guardian, coach, employer, or teacher (agents of social control) used informal social control to respond to your
behavior. What did the agent of informal social control do? Provide an example when informal social control was
applied to another person. What were they doing and how was their behavior controlled through informal social
control?
Example: Talking on the phone with a work-related matter and kids start bickering over slime. I am unable to
put the phone down, so I relied on hand motions to show them it was unacceptable. There was no need to hang up
or say anything at all. The eye actions indicated they were acting inappropriate and their behavior changed.
Norms can be internalized, which would make an individual conform without external rewards or
punishments. There are four types of social norms that can help inform people about behavior that is
considered acceptable: folkways, mores, taboos, and law. Further, social norms can vary across time, cultures,
place, and even sub-group.
1
Think back to your first experiences in school and surely you can identify some folkways and mores
learned. Folkways are behaviors that are learned and shared by a social group that we often refer to as
“customs” in a group that are not morally significant, but they can be important for social acceptance.
2
Each
group can develop different customs, but there can be customs that embraced at a larger, societal level.
1. Goode, E. (2015). Deviant Behavior, (10th ed.). New York: Pearson, Education.
2. Augustyn, A., Bauer, P., Duignan, B., Eldridge, A., Gregersen, E., Luebbering, J.E., etc…, (N.D.). Folkway, Encyclopedia Britannica.
16
Folkway Example
Imagine sitting in the college classroom with sixty other people around. As a professor who teaches early morning
classes, it is always encouraged to eat if hungry. However, everyone must be considerate of those around them.
You should not chew loudly. That would be considered rude, and it is against class ‘customs’ to do so. To make it
worse, imagine burping without saying ‘excuse me.’ These would be folkway violations. Remember, this may not
be disrespectful in all cultures, and it is very subjective.
Perhaps stricter than folkways are more because they can lead to a violation of what we view as moral
and ethical behavior. Mores are norms of morality, or right and wrong, and if you break one it is often
considered offensive to most people of a culture.
3
Sometimes a more violation can also be illegal, but other
times it can just be offensive. If a more is not written down in legislation, it cannot get sanctioned by the
criminal justice system. Other times it can be both illegal and morally wrong.
More Example
If one attended a funeral for a family member, no one would expect to see someone in bright pink clothes or
a bikini. Most people are encouraged to wear black clothing out of respect. Although there may not be specific
rules or laws that state expected attire to wear to a funeral, it would be against what most of American society
views as right and wrong to attend a funeral in a bikini or be in hot pink leotards. It would be disrespectful to the
individual people are mourning. Both mores and folkways are taught through socialization with various sources:
family, friends, peers, schools, and more.
A taboo goes a step farther and is a very negative norm that should not get violated because people will be
upset. Additionally, one may get excluded from the group or society. The nature and the degree of the taboo
are in the mores.
4
Taboo Example
A student once gave the example of a man in their neighborhood in Colorado that had multiple wives and
also had ten different children from the women. In most of American culture, it is seen as unacceptable to have
more than one spouse/partner. However, there are instances where having children with multiple people would
not be seen as taboo. Specifically, if a man or woman remarries and then has another child with their new partner.
However, again, this is more acceptable today than in the past because of the greater societal acceptance of divorce
and remarriage.
3. Sumner, W. (1906). Folkways.
4. Sumner, W. (1906). Folkways.
Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System
17
If one is religious think of something taboo in that specific religion? How about a sports team in college? Band?
Any ideas?
Lastly, and most important to the study of crime and criminal justice, our laws. Remember, a social norm is
an obligation to society that can lead to sanctions if one violates them. Therefore, laws are social norms that
have become formally inscribed at the state or federal level and can laws can result in formal punishment for
violations, such as fines, incarceration, or even death. Laws are a form of social control that outlines rules,
habits, and customs a society uses to enforce conformity to its norms.
Law Example
Let us go back to our example of having multiple wives for a moment. It is illegal, a violation of law, to have
multiple wives in American culture. It has not always been this way, and it is not true in every country, but in the
United States, it was viewed as so taboo, morally and ethically wrong, that there are laws that can punish people
for marrying more than one person at a time. However, there may be some people that do not think it is wrong or
some groups, but regardless, it is still illegal.
The following link is for Oregon statue ORS 163.515 Bigamy https://www.oregonlaws.org/ors/163.515
Remember our previous discussion on being the new person to Oregon and trying to figure out if it is
allowed to be nude at an ultimate frisbee practice, but they do not feel morally or ethically wrong. The first
thing one may do is go home and look up some rules and see if they are violating ultimate frisbee rules.
Next, one may check out Oregon laws governing clothing to see if they are violating laws by being nude.
In the end, one finds out that it is not ‘illegal,’ so you cannot call the cops, but you certainly did find a case
in Eugene, Oregon that determined not wearing clothes can be a violation of rules on the college campus.
https://www.oregonlive.com/news/index.ssf/2009/04/uo_board_says_no_clothes_no_ul.html
However, this is a recreational league, and it does not appear to have any formal rules established. Now one
has to make a decision that is hard: Does one want to be part of a subculture that endorses nudity? Does this
go against one’s morals and ethics? Alternatively, is one willing to be part of the team and encourage
acceptance of a new norm? The criminal justice system cannot act for merely violating norms, but at times,
what feels like a norm can lead to criminal justice involvement. For example, walk a town or city, and
many may be found jaywalking because it may be safer, faster, or more accessible. A person can get a ticket
for it in most communities because it is technically violating a law. That is the thing with the line between
deviance, rule violations, and criminality—it does not allow mean we agree. There are many examples of
laws that are not deviant and things that are deviant some subcultures may wish to be illegal. Most, but not
all crimes are deviant, and not all deviant acts are criminal. The question then becomes: well, how then do
we as a society decide who does and does not have the opportunity to make law?
ALISON S. BURKE, DAVID CARTER, BRIAN FEDOREK, TIFFANY MOREY, LORE RUTZ-BURRI, AND SHANELL
SANCHEZ
18
Jaywalking
Adam Ruins Everything: Why Jaywalking is a Crime? https://www.trutv.com/shows/adam-ruins-
everything/videos/why-jaywalking-is-a-crime.html
Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System
19
1.4. Interactionist View
SHANELL SANCHEZ
Tattoos at Work
An article by Forbes in 2015, encourages employers to revisit their dress code expectations, with a specific
suggestion on lifting the ‘tattoo taboo.’ The article argues “allowing employees to maintain their style or grooming
allows your company to project how genuine you are as a brand to employees and to the customers they support.”
So, instead of suggesting tattoos are taboo in the workforce to employees, according to the article, one can
encourage people to ‘project who they are’ by accepting tattoos and ultimately, improve your business. This
example demonstrates how societal changes in how deviance can change through time and space.
Read the Forbes article to learn more about this discussion:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/micahsolomon/2015/01/12/how-rethinking-employee-dress-codes-tattoos-and-
piercings-improves-customer-service-and-the-customer-experience/#7b923ad54312
Typically, in our society, a deviant act becomes a criminal act that can be prohibited and punished under
criminal law when a crime is deemed socially harmful or dangerous to society.
1
In criminology, we often cover a wide array of harms that can include economic, physical, emotional,
social, and environmental. The critical thing to note is that we do not want to create laws against everything
in society, so we must draw a line between what we consider deviant and unusual verse dangerous and
criminal. For example, some people do not support tattoos and would argue they are deviant, but it would be
challenging to suggest they are dangerous to individuals and society. However, thirty years ago, it may have
been acceptable to put into dress code, rules guiding our physical conduct in the workspace, that people may
not have visible tattoos and people may not be as vocal as they would today. Today, tattoos may be seen as
more normalized and acceptable, which could lead to a lot of upset employees saying those are unfair rules
in their work of employment if they are against the dress code.
Now that we have a basis for understanding differences between deviance, rule violations, and criminal
law violations, we can now discuss who determines if a law becomes criminalized or decriminalized in the
1. Goode, E. (2016). Deviant Behavior. Routledge: New York.
20
United States. A criminalized act is when a deviant act becomes criminal and law is written, with defined
sanctions, that can be enforced by the criminal justice system.
2
Jaywalking
In the 1920s, auto groups aggressively fought to redefine who owned the city street. As cars began to spread to
the streets of America, the number of pedestrians killed by cars skyrocketed. At this time, the public was outraged
that elderly and children were dying in what was viewed as ‘pleasure cars’ because, at this time, our society was
structured very differently and did not rely on vehicles. Judges often ruled that the car was to blame in most
pedestrian deaths and drivers were charged with manslaughter, regardless of the circumstances. In 1923, 42,000
Cincinnati residents signed a petition for a ballot initiative that would require all cars to have a governor limiting
them to 25 miles per hour, which upset auto dealers and sprang them into action to send letters out to vote against
the measure.
Vote No
It was at this point that automakers, dealers, and others worked to redefine the street so that pedestrians, not
cars, would be restricted. Today, these law changes can be seen in our expectations for pedestrians to only cross at
crosswalks.
2. Farmer, L. (2016). Making the modern criminal law: Criminalization and civil . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System
21
Don’t Jaywalk
The Vox Article below has an excellent summary of what we discussed:
https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history
The creation of jaywalking laws would be an example of the interactionist view in lawmaking. The
interactionist view states that the definition of crime reflects the preferences and opinions of people who
hold social power in a particular legal jurisdiction, such as the auto industry. The auto industry used their
power and influence to impose what they felt was to be right and wrong and became moral entrepreneurs.
3
A moral entrepreneur was a phrase coined by sociologist Howard Becker. Becker referred to individuals
who use the strength of their positions to encourage others to follow their moral stances. Moral
entrepreneurs create rules and argue their causes will better society, and they have a vested interest in that
cause that maintains their political power or position.
4 5
The auto industry used aggressive tactics to garner support for the new laws: using news media to shift
3. Vuolo, M., Kadowaki, J., & Kelly, B. (2017). Marijuana’s Moral Entrepreneurs, Then and Now. https://contexts.org/articles/marijuanas-
moral-entrepreneurs/
4. Becker, H. (1963). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of …
Delivering a high-quality product at a reasonable price is not enough anymore.
That’s why we have developed 5 beneficial guarantees that will make your experience with our service enjoyable, easy, and safe.
You have to be 100% sure of the quality of your product to give a money-back guarantee. This describes us perfectly. Make sure that this guarantee is totally transparent.
Read moreEach paper is composed from scratch, according to your instructions. It is then checked by our plagiarism-detection software. There is no gap where plagiarism could squeeze in.
Read moreThanks to our free revisions, there is no way for you to be unsatisfied. We will work on your paper until you are completely happy with the result.
Read moreYour email is safe, as we store it according to international data protection rules. Your bank details are secure, as we use only reliable payment systems.
Read moreBy sending us your money, you buy the service we provide. Check out our terms and conditions if you prefer business talks to be laid out in official language.
Read more