ACC621 Task 2, ATMC Semester 2, 2020 Substantive audit procedures
You are part of the audit team assigned to the audit of Maidenhair Enterprises for the year ended 30 June 2020. This is the third year that your firm has been engaged for the audit of Maidenhair. Notes from last year’s audit file indicated that internal controls around revenue and current assets are strong, while controls around other accounts are generally weak. Tests of controls confirmed this is also the case for the current year. The preliminary assessment of materiality has been set at $5,000. The unaudited trial balance for the client is shown below.
Cash at bank 37,525 | 36,271 | ||
Accounts receivable 36,365 | 34,642 | ||
Inventory 175,295 | 173,034 | ||
Machinery 141,000 | 140,900 | ||
Accumulated depreciation | 30,750 | 23,250 | |
Furniture 11,000 | 11,000 | ||
Accumulated depreciation | 2,623 | 2,050 | |
Accounts payable | 12,450 | 13,450 | |
Bank Loan | 240,000 | 240,000 | |
Sales | 241,470 | 230,520 | |
Cost of sales 130,250 | 135,501 | ||
Consulting revenue | 53,645 | 37,890 | |
Interest income | 56 | 32 | |
Other income | 1,434 | 5,075 | |
Bank charges 515 | 350 | ||
Depreciation 8,073 | 7,944 | ||
Interest expense 12,343 | 10,092 | ||
Printing 501 | 896 | ||
Wages 55,260 | 54,005 | ||
Superannuation 5,349 | 5,095 |
The senior auditor in your team has asked each team member to substantively test a different account. Refer to the following to identify the account that has been allocated to you.
Your task is to prepare a working paper/s to be included in the audit file, for your allocated account. The working paper/s must address the six points below.
⇛ Ensure that your working paper clearly identifies the account being tested, a relevant audit objective, relevant assertions, and the procedure/s to be used. It is recommended that you prepare your audit working paper using either Microsoft Excel or Microsoft Word and use the feature to add additional notes/justification for your choices. The comments feature should also be used to record your references to information sources.
⇛ You may like to address points 4 to 6 on a separate working paper, or include this on your existing working paper. You do not have the documents required to complete the audit testing for this account. As such, your working paper/s will be incomplete. There should be a section at the bottom which says “Conclusion:” but this will remain blank. It would likely be completed during a site visit to the client.
Criteria
Your assignment will be graded based on the criteria below. Please pay due regard to these criteria.
Criteria | High Distinction | Distinction | Credit | Pass | Fail |
Knowledge of audit risks and assertions. (9 marks) | Sophisticated: Sophisticated and insightful application of knowledge of
analytical processes, audit risks and assertions. |
Scholarly:
Highly effective application of knowledge of analytical processes, audit risks, and assertions. |
Advancing:
Demonstrates good knowledge of analytical processes, audit risks, and assertions, evidenced through application to audit case. |
Developing:
Evidences adequate knowledge of analytical processes, audit risks, and assertions. |
Undeveloped: Demonstrates little or no comprehension of analytical processes, audit risks and assertions. |
Identification of appropriate audit procedure.
(4 marks) |
Sophisticated:
Sophisticated and insightful application of knowledge of audit procedures. |
Scholarly:
Highly effective application of knowledge of audit procedures. |
Advancing:
Demonstrates good knowledge of audit procedures evidenced through application to audit case. |
Developing: Evidences adequate knowledge of audit procedures. | Undeveloped: Demonstrates little or no comprehension of audit procedures. |
Knowledge and application of audit sampling processes. (4 marks) | Sophisticated:
Sophisticated and insightful application of knowledge of audit sampling. |
Scholarly:
Highly effective application of knowledge of audit sampling. |
Advancing:
Demonstrates good knowledge of audit sampling evidenced through application to audit case. |
Developing:
Evidences adequate knowledge of audit sampling. |
Undeveloped: Demonstrates little or no comprehension of audit sampling processes and considerations. |
Demonstration of critical thinking to evaluate vouching approach requested by audit senior.
(6 marks) |
Exemplary:
Evidences a sophisticated capacity for critical thinking. Rigorously identifies, prioritises, and justifies highly pertinent issues. Uses advanced and relevant discipline- based theory, frameworks and principles to critically and insightfully evaluate these issues. |
Accomplished: Demonstrates an advanced capacity for critical thinking.
Insightfully identifies, prioritises, and justifies pertinent issues in the business context. Uses relevant discipline-based theory, frameworks and principles to critically evaluate these issues. |
Advancing:
Demonstrates good capacity for critical thinking. Systematically identifies and prioritises pertinent issues in the business context. Critically analyses and evaluates these issues through application of discipline-based theories, frameworks and principles. |
Developing:
Demonstrates developing capacity for critical thinking. Identifies and demonstrates developing capacity to critically analyse pertinent issues in the business context using relevant theories and frameworks. |
Undeveloped: Demonstrates limited of no capacity for critical thinking. Demonstrates inadequate capacity to identify and
critically analyse issues in the business context. |
Communication using digital tools/channels (i.e. Microsoft Word or Microsoft Excel)
(4 marks) |
Sophisticated:
Demonstrates sophisticated use of digital tools/channels to communicate in a highly effective manner. Language choice and tone is highly professional, appropriate and impactful. |
Confident:
Confidently uses digital tools/channels to communicate accurately and professionally. Language choice and tone is professional, appropriate and effective. |
Competent:
Competently and accurately communicates using digital tools/channels. Language choice and tone is effective and appropriate. E |
Adequate:
Uses digital tools/channels to communicate appropriately. Language choice and tone is appropriate. |
Undeveloped:
Demonstrates little or no ability to use digital communication tools/channels to communicate appropriately in a business context. |
Access and use of information ethically and legally
(3 marks) |
Ethically, legally and professionally accesses and uses information gathered via digital tools/channels. | Evidences strong understanding of the ethical and legal use of information gathered via digital tools/channels. | Demonstrates good understanding of the ethical and legal use of information gathered from digital tools/channels. | Demonstrates developing understanding of the ethical and legal use of information gathered from digital tools/channels. | Demonstrates little or no understanding of the ethical and legal use of information gathered from digital tools/channels. |
Delivering a high-quality product at a reasonable price is not enough anymore.
That’s why we have developed 5 beneficial guarantees that will make your experience with our service enjoyable, easy, and safe.
You have to be 100% sure of the quality of your product to give a money-back guarantee. This describes us perfectly. Make sure that this guarantee is totally transparent.
Read moreEach paper is composed from scratch, according to your instructions. It is then checked by our plagiarism-detection software. There is no gap where plagiarism could squeeze in.
Read moreThanks to our free revisions, there is no way for you to be unsatisfied. We will work on your paper until you are completely happy with the result.
Read moreYour email is safe, as we store it according to international data protection rules. Your bank details are secure, as we use only reliable payment systems.
Read moreBy sending us your money, you buy the service we provide. Check out our terms and conditions if you prefer business talks to be laid out in official language.
Read more